Added: 3 months ago
From: xfactorfanxxx
Views: 59,917
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (126)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • your singing gives me chills.. you have such a great voice. hope you win ;)

  • I truly love her she is such a great person and a future winner. She sang Micheal Jackson like no one else can and Linda would also be thankful for such a great and powerful singer.

  • I truly love her she is such a great person and a future winner.

  • sou seu fã linda ..vc canta muito ..amo sua voz ..beojo0s!!!

  • why are all the songs so shortened

  • @92024able to fit all the contestants into 2 hours

  • @92024able Because of live performance. They only have a certain time limit, notice in some weeks how the host is rushing along the judges choices, they have a time limit to go by and a deadline to make because it is live TV in America

  • melanie, u r a diva in the making. a dumb person can hear u sing...i billion votes for u, all d way frm Nigeria

  • i love her voice, face and confidence, im totally glued to her. 

  • your so beautiful... Your a perfect STar...

  • OK - So we have LISTEN (R&B Genre), WILL YOU BE THERE (Pop style by M.J.), I AM NOTHING (Big DIVA Style), and finally DESPERADO (Country/Rock by the Eagles/Linda Ronstadt). Wonder what we will see this week. At any rate, Simon has had his wheels turning since he first heard her...More than just a "One Trick Pony". Seems like she is getting some pretty RARE pieces to perform to show off her chops to the world....Was she singing to Simon at the end?? "Let somebody Love You." Eye Twinkle??

  • SHE IS AMAZING ANYBODY WHO SAYS DIFFERENT U BUMPED YOUR HEADS I LOVE HER GOOD JOB GOD BLESS HER!!!!!!

  • She's really good and she has a beautiful voice. She has a career in music already I'm sure, but I preferred Josh's performance of "Jar of Hearts". They may be the last 2 standing.

  • I love her! She is amazing in live! She has a strong, wonderful voice! I`ll buy her album for sure! good job Melanie~ :)

  • I second that, for sure, prboi92. Melanie is amazing, one of the best vocal singers I have ever heard.

  • @richardpweiss POSITIVELY AGREE

  • Love this girl. The tone, the range, the clarity. And lovely personality to boot.

  • This is the X in x-factor! Beautifully done!

  • she has the best range and intonation of all the singers - and she's pretty. If she can ditch the telephone-ring vibrato I'll be sold. Otherwise she has a future as a really good singer who almost made it.

  • fuck sake, there is nothing i wouldnt do to marry her!

    america..if you do the right thing and make her win then the rest of the world might finally forgive you for voting bush!

  • between Melanie and josh, they have the most standout voices in my opinion and they definitely showed it in their performances that week back to back, drew just annoying, loved that song by Nelly and i didn't like what she did :(

  • Everyone*

  • Always a hater for everyonr huh? Sithu04. That person is probably drew >_>

  • what's the name of this song??

  • From Genuine gold to plastic...

    My God Melanie, what have they done to you...

    Watch the first audition and then what she has become...

    IMHO... Very disapointed...

  • I hope not.......

  • the BEST!!!

  • Is it just me, in simon's group....... melanie is the only one who seems to be concern about being elimated from the show?!

  • @Native0A0Thug ikr even though they play it like shes in danger when everyone knows shes not going anywhere anytime soon

  • DONT WORRY MELANIE GOT YOUR BACK!! :) 1 BILLION VOTES HERE :)

  • @8750348 She got another 1 billion from me too ;)

  • 1 billion vote for Melanie Amaro...The best!

  • @thejompi She did indeed nail that part. It really stood out.

  • Comment removed

  • LOVE HER!!! All of Simon's girls are the best in the show!!

  • @jaynjoy7282 ahahaha thats so true!

  • One Million vote for you Melanie :)

  • beautiful voice :)!

  • Amazing!!! Brilliant !!!

  • she got everything, looks, voice and etc..she knows how to deliver every kind of song ... OMG!!!!

  • first off...melanie is 19 years old...she has an amazing voice and the ability to go far in the music industry...for all you haters out there...sure didnt see you go try out for x factor...or maybe you did and got laughed off the stage!!! goooooo melanie...you got the x factor and then some!!!!!

  • I wish they would cut some of the video packages we've already seen and give them at least 2 minutes for the song. I would really love to hear her sing the whole song.

  • @ba4774 I agree.. l want to hear the full versions too.

  • 1:21

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Brilliant!!!

  • Melanie " AMAZING " Amaro!!!!!!!!

  • She sang it well, but there is no emotional connection to the song, now that said, they only have 1min and 30sec, and I was going to use Listen as an example; when she sang that, u could tell she was relating to that song, yes it was longer as well.

  • @shottut Well. I think she does communicate emotion in this song, because of the way she relates what she sings to real people. I am sure the end piece " You better let somebody love you " was directed towards Simon, IMO anyway...

  • OMG so I just listened to Linda Ronstadt singing this from 1977 (Simple Dreams - tour) I was blown away ! Love you Melanie ... you did a wonderful job.

  • Nice version, but this is a classic Linda Ronstadt song, the Eagles might have wrote it, but Linda brought it to life, and after all this time no one quite touches her !

  • Again .. Melanie show us what a great singer she is. On the other hand song choice was shit ... the arrangment could have been better, and the gospel touches in the song sucked. Linda Ronstadt owns this song !!! Melanie should have listen to her singing this.

  • OMG!!!!!! OMG!!!!!!!!!!! TEAM MELANIE!!!

  • Brilliant!!! You are a winner!!!

  • Melanie, you've never looked so beautiful...so stunning tonight. Such a great performance, clearly the best in the competition.

  • Awesome! I am desperate for more!! She is my choice. She looks drop dead gorgeous tonite....

  • she killllllllleeedddd it!!

  • i really touched by the airy voice she made at 0:55

    just spot right in my ears and my hearth

  • @oke00306 1.08 too

  • @oke00306 OMG.. i was thinking about the same.. her airy voice also touch me..it makes Melanie Amaro special, and no like other artist... she did the same at judges house if u realized when she sang 'Lay Your Head Lowly'.. just spot right my ears n my heart to0.. ^_^

  • i luv the raspiness on her voice when she hits the chorus very fierce!!! she's one of a kind... she's a winner!!!

  • wow, one of the top voices for sure in the competition or at least most powerful!

  • How old are THE Haters?  ANNOYING!!! Anyways Melanie Your Brilliant. Your my winner. Fantastic cover of the eagles. That's classy :)

  • no emotion in her voice. she just sing just to showcase her vocal. carrie underwood can teach her how to sing emotionally. This really is bad and her high notes are sharp and not good fr recording

  • @sithu04 She is pitch perfect on this song. I think the judges probably have a better feel for her recording ability.

  • @ba4774 has zero emotion and I did not connect to the song. I did not revisit her song to listen again like I did for drew and lakoda rayne

  • @sithu04 I love it how you;re saying the peoplle who were voted out of this competition... Thing is when did Lakoda rain ever sounded connected to their songs? IMO Lakoda Rain was struggling with their harmonies to begin with, let alone connection to EACH OTHER and the song

  • @sithu04 Clearly, you're tone deaf. This was by far her most perfect performance. She never went flat, sharp or had pitch issues. It was as clean and crisp as any established veteran could ever hope to duplicate. You should leave the music critiques to those who actually know something about music.

  • @SapphireBoy26 I can guarantee u she will be eliminated at top 8. take my words

  • @sithu04 BS!!

  • @sithu04 Right. Because only YOU will determine the way America votes. Just be expecting me to come back here in 4 weeks to shove your words down your throat. I hope you'll be hungry by then.

  • @SapphireBoy26 no prob. even if she wins the show, she won't make money. she is way too boring. she belongs to idol . x factor needs popstar like drew

  • @sithu04 Why don't you go to Drew's videos and say nice things about Drew. You're not likely to change any minds here.

  • @sithu04 You have absolutely no idea how her career is going to be if she wins this competition. Are you like psychic and can predict the future of people's careers? You don't know the type of music this girl will sing or whether or not she can dance her ass off. Simon is the one giving her these types of songs. She can very well dance like or close to Beyonce and you don't even know. SO before you go ahead and say that she won't make money because she's boring, you might want to keep watching.

  • @Prboi92 we had big voice winners over idol and they became nothing afterwards, leona lewis struggling now too. we need fresh singers like drew or astro. pia toscano fr idol sang better than melaine and she still flops. melaine has very very sharp notes which makes me lost interest in her

  • Comment removed

  • @sithu04 Sharp notes? So, she she's singing a little higher than the melody? WHAT?!?!?!!!!!! You do NOT know what you're talking about and that's obvious. Pia Toscano is not doing as well as she could, because she's not being "pushed" out there in the public. She's needs someone who can get her gigs and possibly get some opening act time for another big time concert performer. If she's going to be HUGE, she needs to work hard on her public relations BIGGGG TIME!!!!! You can't disappear.

  • @birdy808 listen to her version i have nothing and listen closely when she sang the word 'close'. this is when her sharp note revealed and it is painful

  • @sithu04 I did listen to her previous song with I have nothing and yeah, it's not 100% perfect, but, it was still one of the best renditions of that song, and I also went back to listen to Whitney Houston's live performances of that song and she wasn't perfect either. What does that song have to do with this Desperado song? This Desperado song is one of the best renditions I've heard of any song I've listened to since I was learning piano at 6 years old.

  • @birdy808 i can 100% assure u that melaine won't win.

  • @sithu04 And you are a psychic? Get real.

  • @taralo16 listen closely when she sing the word ''close'' at i have nothing performance. that's when I know simon made correct choice about the girl with big mouth. she should have been entertaining. melaine has sharp notes and emotionless and robotic performance. she will never win

  • @sithu04 why and who do you think will win

  • @sithu04 and this from a Britney S. and Justin B. fan who must be in pain quite often. lol.

  • @sithu04 OMG ONE SHARP NOTE OUT OF THE WHOLE BLINKIN' LOT OF HER PERFORMANCES... Get a life. I am sorry to rage but people like you are the reason there is so much hate in the world. Go away if you;re gonna write that crap.

  • @sithu04 When is her voice (notes) sharp in this performance? Or in any performance, seeing as you;re such the expert I want you to list EVERY single one of these "flat notes" because otherwise you are just one of those very few haters out there who need to get a life, you clearly know nothing about what you are trying to talk about and criticize. And BTW Astro can only rap... and Drew can only "pop". Just look at Melanie's range.

  • @Prboi92 AMEN TO THAT!

  • @sithu04 drew cant sing or dance. shes very irrarting, she awkward, shell just be another one hit wonder, if she even gets signed. oh well cant really blame you cause your obviously def to real music.

  • @sithu04 LOL, I do agree that Drew is a pop star, but far to young and cannot connect to the songs aswell as Melanie can. I will admit the closest that she has ever been connected to the song was when she sang Dream by Nelly, but other than that falls short compared to Melanie

  • @sithu04 Fail.

  • @SapphireBoy26 AMEN TO THAT

  • @sithu04 " This really is bad and her high notes are sharp and not good fr recording" hello Beyonce only one of the best vocalists out there !!!

  • @sithu04 We get it that she is not your favorite and is stiff competition. 20 individuals to your 1 think Melanie is a star. Although Melanie is my favorite, I am not putting the other competitors down to elevate her. Her talent will speak for itself. I hope that all the competitors on the X Factor are very successful after this show as each has its own talents. They are all unique and special. If you don't like how she sings then don't view her videos. You must view as she is the one to beat!

  • @N243LLA  A - TO THE - MEN TO THAT

  • @sithu04 Not good for recording????? My mother-in-law has an extra hearing aid I can give you. Why would you put something like that when it obvious makes you sound dumb? No emotion? Wow, that's worse than your hearing problem!

  • @444myangels lol. "My mother-in-law has an extra..."

  • @TPAHOTI LOL, I know LOL - It's a little "off" for me to mention my mother-in-law but this person was just as "off". She can't hear a thing unless I yell and since I can't yell at this person, this was the best I can think of :)

  • @sithu04 Lawl, not good for recording. You;re nuts son, she's won. GG lol

  • @1romanticSoul She's actually 19

  • it was very short.. she still got 20second left.. WE WANT MORE!!!!!!

  • @trumpetzzz yeah, why do they keep messing with her? it's like they're trying to make it fair for the other contestants.

  • V.I Massive where you deh???

  • BEAUTIFUL VOICE.....GREAT JOB!!!! MELANIE " AMAZING " AMARO

  • Wow...

    The Best Performance of one of Our All time Favorite Eagles Songs by a Female singer since Linda Ronstadt's version...

    This was an incredible performance by Melanie....

    Tonight's performances leave us with 2 Favorites to Win it All...

    Drew & Melanie..

    Robby&Bob~Cole&Parker

    Laguna Beach, Ca.

  • Wow. American audiences suck! We have forgotten how to behave. We are clueless and in the dark.

  • her voice is lovely & pure.. simply amazing!!!

  • My favorite :D GO MELANIE

  • She looks like a star already, so beautiful and amazing!

  • HI NATSIRT

  • why was her performance shorter than the others?

    her voice mesmerizes me, but she looks a lot older than 16 and I'm afraid it's time for her to sing uptempo stuff (personally speaking) or she'll hit predictable/boring zone

  • @mydiaryentries Absolutely nothing boring about her voice.

  • @mydiaryentries ~ She looks older then 16 because she is ....She's 18 !

  • @mydiaryentries she is 19 and she belongs to nicole cat. i kinda not seeing her as a star. drew is my fav

  • @sithu04 Oh it's you again - the one with the dumb comment above! You must have flunked math because Nicole's category is above 30! Although I think Drew is good as well, it's people like you who makes me want to see her NOT WIN - It's better for you to post your nonsense comments on Drew's board, NOT HERE!!!

  • audience STFU! !!!

  • @bluecamuflase Seriously! they need to address this, it's incredibly irritating when I can't hear her sing!

  • i hate the crowd.. T_T

  • Melanie all the way

    

  • AWESOME! i am desperado for more!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more