Added: 3 years ago
From: moonpig7066
Views: 36,146
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (132)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • THATS LIKE SAYING NINJA GAIDEN IS AN RPG TOO RIGHT? RETARD!

  • RU FUCKIN HIGH? DEVIL MAY CRY IS NOTTTTTT AN RPG U CRACKHEAD!

  • The best RPGs are like Diablo 2, has a story, an atmosphere and and open ended feel to it..so things don't stop evolving after you finish the entire campaign.

  • Man...He dont Understand what is RPG gameplay...

  • Ever since the market went 'multiformat', there has been more and more confusion about what an cRPG is. This video proves it. I think it;s to do with so many games saying they have 'lite RPG elements' and games like Jade Empire and Mass Effect and Dragon Age calling themselves RPG's when they either don't have avatar stats/ attributes or they don't have an open world sandbox type gameworld, These surely are the three things that make a game a cRPG, avatar stats and a sandbox world. Like Witcher

  • @HardWarUK I don't see how a sandbox world is a factor of an RPG?

  • @peri2502 Exploration has always been in RPG's throughout history. Let me put it another way - if it's not open world, it must be linear, and since when have RPG's been linear? All the Elder Scrolls RPG's are open world, all the Wizardry RPG's are, all the Ultima RPG's are, all the Gothic's RPG's are, all the Fallout's RPG's are, etc. Only from 2005, when the 'multiformat' market has arrived have we started arguing that RPG's can be linear to support action-adventures like Mass Effect, etc!

  • @HardWarUK In my opinion RPG's have always been linear to a degree...which is required, if you want to tell a story. In games like Ultima, you just had the option to roam around as you wish until you pick the thread back up. And while I basically agree with your underlying criticism that modern RPG's don't offer much in terms of exploration anymore, I think that storytelling is a far more important factor in an RPG. For example, I think that the Mass Effect games are excellent RPG's...

  • @HardWarUK because they really sucked me into the world. Of course, it would have been nice to be able to explore the galaxy more, but there is always a trade off. If you look at a game like the Elder Scrolls series, you had a huge world to explore, but the main storyline really wasn't all that involving or gripping. Personally, I prefer a well told story to the ability to roam around freely.

  • @peri2502 Your so right, you can always tell a story better in a linear game than an open world game. Point and click adventures are the opitimy of this, with some of the best stories (The Longest Journey, Syberia, etc) and that is because the adventure genre was the most linear. So Mass Effect doesn have a great story, but that's because it's not an sandbox RPG, it is a fairly linear action adventure. You talk about story being most important, but EVERY game has a story, so it's a mute point.

  • @HardWarUK Every game has a story, but not every game tells it well. If you look at the archetypal pencil and paper RPG's you will see that they always were linear, although players had the option to deviate. But every roleplayer will emphasize that a good game session had a great and well told story, not that the DM left them to run around aimlessly. Making an RPG as a sandbox game is one way, but it is not the only way, and it certainly isn't the classical way.

  • looks like he only mmorpg game that you ever played is runescape

  • aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahaha­hahahahahhahahahahahahahahahha­ahhahahahahhahahahahahahahahah­ahahahahahahahahahahahahhaahha­hahahahhahahahahahahahahahahah­ahahahahahahahahahahhaahhahaha­hahhahahahahahahahahahahahahah­ahahahahahahahahhaahhahahahahh­ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah­ahahahahahahhaahhahahahahhahah­ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah­ahahahahhaahhahahahahhahahahah­ahahahahahahahahaahhahahahahha­hahahahahahahahahahaha.. runescape.. what a fucking tool..

  • runscape fuckin sucks its a disgrace to all mmo'S!!!

  • so true

  • Main characters in Devilmaycry 4 are emos ? :P

  • not rly but mabie

  • I wish everyone would get off of oblivion's dick

  • many of the games on this list were not RPGs.....

  • oblivion is fuking crazy carnt wait 4 the eldar scrolls v in 2010!!!

  • wow is for fags

  • bulll WoW is better then runescape

  • lol anything is better than runescape

  • did mass efect came out on 2008 or 2009? cause if it came out on 2008 you realy miss it, that is the best rpg ever!

  • Not a RPG, it's a FPS. FPS are RPG by definition, but there are so many FPS, and so many RPG that are not FPS, with huge differences in genre I.E. Multiplayer experience and single player experience, weapon choices, etc.

  • The original Oblivion came out in 2005.

  • Freelancer was a amazing game ^^ but i have to admit terran conflict is fucking amazing

  • some one know a game like frilancer and starlancer ?

  • X3: Terran Conflict is hard, great grafics space simulator.

  • Thanks

  • Oblivion is too easy

  • So stupid Assassins creed it's not an rpg!!!

    This guy who upped this vid has no idea what an rpg is

  • no it's not

  • ya it is

  • you must study ignorant it's not

  • it is so an rpg and its role you play it and its a game (rpg)

  • OmegaD has right your description is too generic

  • lawl.... yeahhh right.

  • Then every single game in the world is a RPG ;)

    Even Tetris, in which you play the role of an unknown entity that somehow manipulates blocks in falling into place.

  • No u have no idea what an rpg game is so u should stay the fuck away from a computer!!!

  • no you see thats where you fail. roll as in i roll the dice not as in i play the role of some guy then every game would be a RPG.

  • dmc4 is not an rpg

  • HOLY CRAP.! rune escape is the best rpg.,??!

    that doesnt seem right.,

  • Plus one for making RuneScape look less shitty, minus ten for actually putting RunesCape as "best" RPG (lol MMO) PC game.....

  • runescape LOOLOLOLLO. even with an epic song, you cant cover the fail

  • just another copy its not best graphics but can you create INTERNET game with good graphics ? like crysis ? :D

  • I think Runescape is a good game, use to play it alot before...Guess iam hated now...

  • runescape suckz balls

  • Runescape graphics = FAIL

  • DMC is an action game.

  • lol, Runescape, hahahahha!

  • Ahhhhh runescape....

    i remember those days....

    that was like almost 4 years ago XD

  • What?!Where's Hellgate:London?...And The Witcher?

  • Hellgate London? It was the most monotonous game that I ever played so far. It wasn't bad but it was pretty much the same all the time - go and kill something, come back, kill some more, go to another station and kill more... Fable is way better

  • is the witcher awesome? i wanna buy im thinking to buy it :)

    and does have to be have a high requiremnts i mean come on i dont wanna play with fucking lags

  • yes, one of the best rpg's i ever played

  • The witcher is a bit buggy on it's self but trust me. The witcher is AWESOME!!!!!

    Great gameplay,storyline and graphics you won't regret it!

  • i think devil may cry is more ACTION that RPG

  • Wait a second, when did Devil may cry come out on PC?

    Also A space sim is a space sim not an RPG,

    and runescape is a shit browser based game and is not a MMORPG, its just a ORPG

    and a joke at that. bad list.

  • Devil May Cry 4 came out for PC on July 8, 2008.

  • DMC is on PC long time ago

  • dmc 4 rpg "lol"

    and runescape ... wtf man

  • I can pretty much agree with the entire list, but one, Runescape? cmon! maybe its the best Free to Play MMO, but it is hardly the best MMO period.

  • if it's not japanese made it should just be filed under "good" not "best"

  • I really gotta check out Titan Quest, seen it alot but never tried it.

  • lets say If back then in 1990 when i was 7 i would have a computer+internet+runescape it would be pretty fuckin awesome but How,HOW? can u play this in the present??? :p Oblivions graphic of landscape and buildings pwned but the story sucked (there was a story? duh) skills sucked and there wasnt enough weapons,armor.

  • DMC 4 is not an rpg.

  • You fuking idiot cant you put the name of the games?..

  • he did...

  • oh GOD Freelancer was such a great game at the time...memories, good memories...there were so many thing you had to look out for during the space battles, that sometimes I called my friend, who was like a "Co-pilot", shooting the flares,using the nanobots, shooting the missiles...while I did the pilot's part...moved and shot.

  • Hell yeah!....

  • id commit to sucuide if ihad to play noobscape everrrrrr. and your wrong about WoW not being better. its defantly got its ups and downs but Wrath of the litch king expac was alot better than the second one....

  • THE LAST GAME SUCKED SO BADLY I WANNA PUNCH IT IN THE FACE, but I can't because it's a game....

  • lol

  • runescape doesnt deserve to be on the list

  • Normally if you say you're favorite something is one thing - that's what it is. If you think the best colour is blue it is the best colour for you. However, there is once exception to this rule. If you say you're favorite mmorpg is runescape - if you say runescape is the best mmorpg - techinally you are infact wrong.

  • BUT! Blue is the best.

  • i think they designed runescape in paint :))

  • Best mmo? runescape? are you kidding me lol. runescape sucks soooooooooooooooo bad.

  • thats his opinion.. it's all about taste dude..

  • If only it was possible to consider that "taste".

  • Well it got the basics but absolutely nothing more. Like eating a dry peice of bread... whit mold.

  • Oblivion is the best RPG ever Heehehehe runeescape lol love to hate ... or hate to love XD

  • oblivion dudes face are gay and there was something wrong when i played this game i could not put my finger on it so in my opinion oblivion dont even make the top 5 =D

  • yea oblivion was ok, i personally was blown away when i first got out of the prison. but the story aint shit. fallout 3 is awsome am playing it right now.

  • Oblivion is an awesome game, including all it's flaws. the rest either weren't rpgs ( I.E DMC4 wtf was up with that?) at all or just plain sucked ( runescape.... seriously.... and in 2007-2008... come on )

  • Dmc is an action adventure, just like prince of persia, onimusha, resident evil.

    rpgs are , final fantasy, earthbound, YsF, kingdome hearts no comparison to DMC, lol just had to put that out there

  • dmc is an rpg muhahahahh.....no complains.

  • Oblivion still rules! Could it have been better? Of course it could have, what game couldn't use improvement?! But considering how much it did right and on the scale that ir did it, it is the best RPG ever!!

  • Freelancer came out in 2001...so its preety stupid to put it on a list of games from 2007+2008...and its not even an RPG,Devil may cry isent an RPG!!! its a hack and slash action game,just because you can upgrade shit dosent make it an RPG! Oblivion isent all that great,I loved it when I started playing but after noticing all the flaws I just couldent play it anymore...Runescape is fucking L-A-M-E,it sucks balls,not just because its ugly as hell,the gameplay is just weak as shit.

  • What was that space game?

  • mass effect?

  • Wondering the same thing =-O

  • 1.Devil May Cry is not an RPG dickhead

    2.Runescape is lame as tibia... why do u call it best MMORPG???? your game taste suck bolls... go FuCK your selph...

  • Whats the name of the song on runescape (worst shit ever )

  • i love OBLIVION!!!!

  • oblivion was made for consoles specifically- its more suited to the younger action orientated rpg audience- thats the main reason its not as good as morrowind imo

  • what the game called at 3:20 and is it f2p

  • i think u mean freelancer.

    if i'm not mistaken it's not an mmo so of course it's f2p

  • oblivion isnt too new, and u said its first person, its 3rd and 1st, and its a good game btw.. i got it for xbox360 tho

  • Big deal

    lol

    But yea, the elder scrolls games are known for their 1st person thing though

    they incorporated 3rd person in Morrowind i believe.

  • why is devil may cry on the list? furthest thing from an rpg.

  • err... no, Devil May Cry IS an RPG... an rpg game is a game where the character evolves through gameplay via stats as well, not just eh player.

  • Devil may cry is an action/rpg game!!

  • AHAHAHAH Runescape....

  • does anyone know what version of freelancer that was , i thought they scraped it after the first freelancer which looked nothing like what you showed there

  • i like blivion because i found it's construction set easy to use , the scripting was a little tricky , but i am planing on making a sci fi total convertion of the game ,

  • OBLIVION definitly is not boring....

  • omg oblivion is not boring!!!

  • last song name ?

  • Man, oblivion is boring

  • I think the same.....GO TO OBLIVION, SEARCH THIS, DESTROY THE PORTAL, GO BACK and the over and over......the only good part of Oblivion is the world is Huge and you can go anywhere, but there is nothing in that game....if you change the characters it could be MATRIX: THE PATH OF NEO because: YOU ARE THE CHOSEN ONE, YOU GOT TO FIGHT THE ORCS AND SAVE THE KING SON......ALWAYS THE SAME STORY!!!

  • oblivion the best.. u just dont know how to play it rite dumfuck. did u even download the expansions? do all the quests? level up? there alot to do in that game

  • jajajajajaja you know...it´s like a rule when you play a game...if the story doesn´t excite you after 5 hours.....you have to leave that game....that happens to me with Oblivion...I did almost al the quest for the THIEF GUILD....but no emotion in that game

  • Just because there is alot, doesn't make it the best. All three previous Elder Scrolls games were better than oblivion.

  • I have to agree

    i LOVE Morrowind

    Oblivion is good too... but you need a powerful PC to enjoy the gfx of oblivion.

  • Can you suggest a roleplaying game that does not involve heavy combat? I can never be bothered with conbat! One of my fave games was (don't laugh) Betrayal of Antara, so anything like that which is conpatible with windows vista would be fantastic!

  • lol

  • Though they're not new, I'd recommend Fallout 1 and 2 or Planescape Torment.

    While they CAN be played combat heavy, these games are also well known for being playable as a diplomatic character where you can talk your way through the game and have to use next to no violence. I dunno about Planescape Torments Vista compatibility though.

  • I put the witcher in part 2

  • another one you guys should try is the witcher, supposed to be a really awesome rpg for the pc(released in oct 2007).. i haven't played it yet but i will soon

  • The Witcher is almost as good as oblivion

  • i don't rlly consider dmc4 to be an rpg.. its genre is listed as action and i'd agree w/ that.

    i'd put mass effect/jade empire on this list, released to pc in 2007/2008 respectively.. some of the best rpgs ever.

  • love the vid, realy helpfull now iv just gotta go out and buy em. Great use of video

  • dang i forgot to add hellgate London

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more