I didn´t like it,i found it boring and lack of energy,it almost seemed as if they didn´t have anything to eat in weeks,really bad and poor performance.
Was anyone directing this or was this one of those spontaneous outpourings of song in public places we see so much of these days. How fortuitous that they were in costume when the urge to sing came upon them, too bad they couldn't really sing.
@olaftheodor , Ordinarily, this is sung in Italian, but in this version the language is English. Listen closely, and you can make out some of the words, though I must admit their diction is not very clear. Listen to the very beginning; in Italian the first words are 'va pensiero". This particular chorus is not singing those words.
@Loic1409 , Go back and look at the postings. I'm not the person who couldn't understand the language. Please don't get nasty with the persons who were the ones who couldn't understand the language. The anonymity of usernames on YouTube isn't a license to be rude. Also we on YouTube come from all over the world. Some people on YouTube can't understand English. This does not mean that they're stupid or uneducated.
@bassfanne45 :] sorry .. ok maybe you're right i think i heard a few english words there.. it is an english choir too. i've just listened to another version and it sounds different. i take it all back and sorry for being so rude too. thanks for not being as harsh with your reply as you had every right to be..
@olaftheodor That's okay. I had to listen a couple of times to actually decide it was in English....and the choir's diction is terrible. Also, we're all used to hearing it sung in Italian. In fact, this is the first time I've heard it in English.
While I prefer the sound of Italian opera "sunged" in Italian, Verdi himself felt that opera should be sung in the language of the country where it is being performed.
Yes, because of course the only people who've ever taken whites as slaves were...other whites.
Also, the only time slavery ever counted was when it was whites being slave-masters. That includes slavery which still exists up to this day, mostly in Africa and the Middle East.
But, like I said, it's unimportant because it can't be blamed on whites, and so is a rich part of someone's culture.
Anywho - beautiful music, this not being the best performance I've ever seen by any means.
I heard this song when it was cold winter in South Africa. I find it is very impressive, may be, because of its melody, so cold and lonely. Thanks to you to give me such a good memory of the living in that place.
this choir doesn't sound like an opera choir... very nice although. I don't like the tuba at the begining, sounds like a short fard... and I prefer the italian... nice dresses...
mfranck1-Your facts are quite screwed. When were the Protestants ever of the numbers or the powers to have done what you accuse them of having done.France is a Catholic country by a huge margin,and have been for hundreds or even thousands of years.Did this not occur in French Canada (Quebec) while it was under British rule. Did these people not go to live in the Maritime provinces of Canada as well as Louisiana and some of the New England Statesof the U,S.
@mom98312 Nebuchadnezzar was very particular about the cleanliness of his slaves! Why? Because they are sold if they are no longer needed in the palace!
I didn´t like it,i found it boring and lack of energy,it almost seemed as if they didn´t have anything to eat in weeks,really bad and poor performance.
arvedsin 2 months ago in playlist Nabucco Verdi va pensiero
Where's the 4? All good music must have a four!
DimensionsofChange 3 months ago
These female Hebrew Slaves look like Catholic nuns. But they are not virgins! I remember we used to sing that tune in the synagogue.
davidorbachmusic 9 months ago
11ibolyaszentannainak ajámlom!
papucs1000 11 months ago
I have heard it better. It lacks the extra which would really approve of the choir
rutakirea 1 year ago
Opera in English booooooooo
JeeRant 1 year ago
Really excellent! As good as any I have heard, quite touching, too.
Phil
vladtheoptician 1 year ago
Was anyone directing this or was this one of those spontaneous outpourings of song in public places we see so much of these days. How fortuitous that they were in costume when the urge to sing came upon them, too bad they couldn't really sing.
bdarci 1 year ago
Ibolya, azt meghiszem olyan szép, hogy a párját ritkítja! Szívből küldtem: Gábor
papucs1000 1 year ago
@papucs1000
Lélegzet elállítóan szép .Gyönyörű!!!!!!!
Köszönőm ,Kedvesem ,Gábor !
11ibolyaszentannai 1 year ago 2
Gyönyörű Előadás!
papucs1000 1 year ago 2
@papucs1000
Nagyon szép ,párját ritkitja.
Köszönöm Kedvesem ,Gábor !
11ibolyaszentannai 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
papucs1000 1 year ago
Vivat Israel!
levimoni 1 year ago
Muzica nemuritoare ! Multumesc pentru postare!
oblio66420 1 year ago
Well done Preston Opera.
jam1966ful 1 year ago
sing in italian or don't sing.. is very ilarious
is like a shakespeae trasnlation in italian..loose pathos
editorialize 1 year ago
I love this. Were they directed? Some lovely voices in there but no verve. A shame , it could e mistaken for a nativity . aka no action.
Wanch1e1ady 1 year ago
I think this is in English. The enunciation is too slurred to know for sure.
bassfanne45 1 year ago
@bassfanne45 dude it's italian. jesus.
olaftheodor 1 year ago
@olaftheodor , Ordinarily, this is sung in Italian, but in this version the language is English. Listen closely, and you can make out some of the words, though I must admit their diction is not very clear. Listen to the very beginning; in Italian the first words are 'va pensiero". This particular chorus is not singing those words.
bassfanne45 1 year ago
Comment removed
bassfanne45 1 year ago
@bassfanne45 this is english and a
i think you do not understand this language . will sing for you in creole next time
Loic1409 1 year ago
@Loic1409 There's no need for nastiness. I'm a native English speaker, and could hear that it's in English.
bassfanne45 1 year ago
@Loic1409 , Go back and look at the postings. I'm not the person who couldn't understand the language. Please don't get nasty with the persons who were the ones who couldn't understand the language. The anonymity of usernames on YouTube isn't a license to be rude. Also we on YouTube come from all over the world. Some people on YouTube can't understand English. This does not mean that they're stupid or uneducated.
bassfanne45 1 year ago
@bassfanne45
you get two points for your team... for being understanding of others weakiness ....
1905compton 1 year ago
@olaftheodor , BTW, it's dudette. Jesus!
bassfanne45 1 year ago
@bassfanne45 :] sorry .. ok maybe you're right i think i heard a few english words there.. it is an english choir too. i've just listened to another version and it sounds different. i take it all back and sorry for being so rude too. thanks for not being as harsh with your reply as you had every right to be..
olaftheodor 1 year ago
@olaftheodor That's okay. I had to listen a couple of times to actually decide it was in English....and the choir's diction is terrible. Also, we're all used to hearing it sung in Italian. In fact, this is the first time I've heard it in English.
bassfanne45 1 year ago
A great and elouquent song., Very moving, It is very thoughtful of them to pay homage to the original black hebrews.
aclspython 2 years ago
what black? u stupid ignorant dud, they were jewish u dumdum
kfatzfatzy 1 year ago 2
Have loved this piece since British Airways used in one of their commercials
bakerloobadboy 2 years ago
This chorus does nost sing in harmony/unison at all. Several disparate voices are heard, some of them quite strident as well.
AliciaDupres 2 years ago
I agree - they should be shot for their disparency.
ClanMcTavish1 1 year ago
it´s one of my father's favourite songs
cadoixo 2 years ago
Nice version
EdmundTheMagnificent 2 years ago
krásne
pantla12 2 years ago
Comment removed
amam511 2 years ago
Just liste to the music and enjoy forget the politics
Malcolmt23 3 years ago 13
Yesssss
EdmundTheMagnificent 2 years ago
Amen!! to that bro!!
padrimino 2 years ago
i dont likeabsolutely nothing this "chorus".
And an italian opera must be sunged in italian
enchantedzoro12 3 years ago
While I prefer the sound of Italian opera "sunged" in Italian, Verdi himself felt that opera should be sung in the language of the country where it is being performed.
sherhino 3 years ago
wow u imposters are fake jews
blackonblack100 3 years ago
great music
hahabinga 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
slavery has gone look forward to a bright future
davetoone12 3 years ago
Yes, because of course the only people who've ever taken whites as slaves were...other whites.
Also, the only time slavery ever counted was when it was whites being slave-masters. That includes slavery which still exists up to this day, mostly in Africa and the Middle East.
But, like I said, it's unimportant because it can't be blamed on whites, and so is a rich part of someone's culture.
Anywho - beautiful music, this not being the best performance I've ever seen by any means.
Tomakak 3 years ago
beautiful music and singing
noball12 3 years ago 2
This is set in Babylon, not Egypt. Nabucco is Nebucadnezar (sp?).
Meak - Whites were enslaving other whites for thousands of years (NOT an exaggeration) before enslaving blacks in the Americas.
Warjacki 4 years ago
I heard this song when it was cold winter in South Africa. I find it is very impressive, may be, because of its melody, so cold and lonely. Thanks to you to give me such a good memory of the living in that place.
tamyk007 4 years ago
this choir doesn't sound like an opera choir... very nice although. I don't like the tuba at the begining, sounds like a short fard... and I prefer the italian... nice dresses...
141407078989 4 years ago
just curious how could white moses past for a black egyptian
beyo2233 4 years ago
It was the isreal in egypt or was it in babylon, this people is trying to look like
nonnene 4 years ago
White slaves lol.
meak911 4 years ago
what is so funny greeks romans used to have them
corado21 3 years ago
There have been LOTS of white slaves! My people are the French-Acadiens, sent intil exile and slavery by the Protestants of France, for instance.
mfranck1 2 years ago 3
mfranck1-Your facts are quite screwed. When were the Protestants ever of the numbers or the powers to have done what you accuse them of having done.France is a Catholic country by a huge margin,and have been for hundreds or even thousands of years.Did this not occur in French Canada (Quebec) while it was under British rule. Did these people not go to live in the Maritime provinces of Canada as well as Louisiana and some of the New England Statesof the U,S.
paulostroff99 2 years ago
A wonderful piece of music,beautifully sung
No wonder it is the National Anthem of Padania
noball12 4 years ago
Very good! Love it.
barnacogue 4 years ago 2
these are the cleanest Hebrew slaves I've ever seen.
mom98312 4 years ago 10
@mom98312 Nebuchadnezzar was very particular about the cleanliness of his slaves! Why? Because they are sold if they are no longer needed in the palace!
Nonie46 1 year ago
Beautiful piece of music - wonderfully performed - thank you
justsue1 4 years ago
AWESOME !!!
Dredead1 4 years ago
Arpa d'or dei fatidici vati,
perché muta dal salice pendi?
Le memorie nel petto raccendi,
ci favella del tempo che fu!
O simile di Solima ai fati
traggi un suono di crudo lamento,
o t'ispiri il Signore un concento
che ne infonda al patire virtù!
cultusstultus 4 years ago
Va, pensiero, sull'ali dorate;
va, ti posa sui clivi, sui colli
ove olezzano tepide e molli
l'aure dolci del suolo natal!
Del Giordano le rive saluta,
di Sionne le torri atterrate.
Oh, mia patria sì bella e perduta!
Oh, membranza sì cara e fatal!
cultusstultus 4 years ago