One of my favorite songs from PF, but i miss the touch and soul of them in this band. This music is not to dance but to feel and hear. I think the band is good except for the singer. I hope in the near future the technology can bring to life Pink Floyd for real on stage!
as a big Floyd fan i do like the way you brought this song :-) although i do miss the roughness of the original, you cqn heqr the modern technoly trough the entire song :-) this is not a bad comment even tho it might seems like it. i was afraid of the "talk box" solo, its a difficult effect to master and in those days only Peter Frampton and David Gilmour pulled it off nicely :-) but your guy did it excelent, a great addaption with his own pitch on it, the only thing i miss in that solo
Man, must be a bit easier to make it in a tribute band abroad than it is here in the U.S. I could never score a gig like that in the Doors tributes I was in! :)
I plainly don't understand the reverence to every note and posture of my all time favorite band. I love it when musicians make the music their own. In fact I think Waters and Gilmour themselves hew too closely to their recorded music. Earlier in their careers they were much more "in the moment". Most fans want to hear exactly what was put down on wax but I like to hear a LIVE performance.
@duffmoses I agree, this material (from 1977) was done with analog equipment. Only the Floyd can get away with using the digital stuff because they were evolving their sound with the times, but even the latest Gilmour tour, both him an Rick went back to using some of their original gear for the old Floyd numbers. I have yet to see one Floyd tribute band use an authentic Hammond Organ not a clone, yet I've seen non Floyd tributes cover Floyd with all analog and they sound better than this.
It's OK to jump around and have fun onstage! I'm sure I jump around and have fun in my living room when listening to Pink Floyd. And YOU get to PLAY the music.
The band is very good and the stage and lighting is incredible, but the lead singer is an embarrassment! I mean jumping around on stage like that? Honestly, has he ever seen a Pink Floyd show? His behavior on stage is ridiculous.
to make a little clearer why so much movement on stage, It was unfortunate that evening in poland 4 degrees celsius, so very cold. when it is warm at the next concert he will be determined quiet . Thanks for your positive Feedback, it was our first Concert and we also learn from comments.
@WWWFLOYDRELOADEDCOM pues ponte un sweter !!! pero quedate quieto! parece que estas animando una fiesta o evento politico !!!!! la verdad la banda esta genial y se ve muy profesional el escenario, solo el detalle del movimiento (ojala lo entiendan)
A pretty good performance but played way too fast.
kyla2112 1 week ago
nobody can do better than Floyd!!
AngelMTZ8A 1 week ago
what a fukin awsome remake/cover i like it...
imbueto 1 month ago
One of my favorite songs from PF, but i miss the touch and soul of them in this band. This music is not to dance but to feel and hear. I think the band is good except for the singer. I hope in the near future the technology can bring to life Pink Floyd for real on stage!
arqjmgarzon 3 months ago 5
I laughed from the talkboxes voice)))
By the way, very cool
BallbreakerRUS 4 months ago
lamento decir que la unica banda tributo que lo hace casi perfecto es THE AUSTRALIAN PINK FLOYD SHOW...
shaskas 6 months ago
as a big Floyd fan i do like the way you brought this song :-) although i do miss the roughness of the original, you cqn heqr the modern technoly trough the entire song :-) this is not a bad comment even tho it might seems like it. i was afraid of the "talk box" solo, its a difficult effect to master and in those days only Peter Frampton and David Gilmour pulled it off nicely :-) but your guy did it excelent, a great addaption with his own pitch on it, the only thing i miss in that solo
Tawnyn 6 months ago
Nothing wrong with backing singers that I can see !!! Floyd did use backing singers too !!! Very good cover band.....
jtlampsu 9 months ago
Man, must be a bit easier to make it in a tribute band abroad than it is here in the U.S. I could never score a gig like that in the Doors tributes I was in! :)
husq48 11 months ago
I plainly don't understand the reverence to every note and posture of my all time favorite band. I love it when musicians make the music their own. In fact I think Waters and Gilmour themselves hew too closely to their recorded music. Earlier in their careers they were much more "in the moment". Most fans want to hear exactly what was put down on wax but I like to hear a LIVE performance.
duffmoses 11 months ago
@duffmoses I agree, this material (from 1977) was done with analog equipment. Only the Floyd can get away with using the digital stuff because they were evolving their sound with the times, but even the latest Gilmour tour, both him an Rick went back to using some of their original gear for the old Floyd numbers. I have yet to see one Floyd tribute band use an authentic Hammond Organ not a clone, yet I've seen non Floyd tributes cover Floyd with all analog and they sound better than this.
Deltarogers 3 months ago
It's OK to jump around and have fun onstage! I'm sure I jump around and have fun in my living room when listening to Pink Floyd. And YOU get to PLAY the music.
195511SM 1 year ago
Why backvocals? That killed the song
thebenke 1 year ago
@thebenke you couldnt of said it better
bendirkss 1 year ago
Einfach nur geil! Echt hammer !!!
BadNauheimTV 1 year ago
Das ist der Oberhammer!! Astreines Talkbox-Solo von Phil!! WOW!!
63vegas 1 year ago
The band is very good and the stage and lighting is incredible, but the lead singer is an embarrassment! I mean jumping around on stage like that? Honestly, has he ever seen a Pink Floyd show? His behavior on stage is ridiculous.
gr8deadfan75 1 year ago 13
@gr8deadfan75
Hi from Germany,
to make a little clearer why so much movement on stage, It was unfortunate that evening in poland 4 degrees celsius, so very cold. when it is warm at the next concert he will be determined quiet . Thanks for your positive Feedback, it was our first Concert and we also learn from comments.
Thanks
Floyd Reloaded
WWWFLOYDRELOADEDCOM 1 year ago 3
@WWWFLOYDRELOADEDCOM well, honestly.....i don't picture Waters or Gilmour jumping around only 'cause they're cold
ktulu6 1 year ago
@WWWFLOYDRELOADEDCOM pues ponte un sweter !!! pero quedate quieto! parece que estas animando una fiesta o evento politico !!!!! la verdad la banda esta genial y se ve muy profesional el escenario, solo el detalle del movimiento (ojala lo entiendan)
shikaram123 4 months ago
@WWWFLOYDRELOADEDCOM I liked your interpretation. You made this song rock. Very well done. Guitar lead at ending was brilliant.
KennyRay86351 1 month ago