most pianists make the g minor theme to this piece sound like its in 4/4 when it's actually in cut time. the voicing in the middle b major section was beautiful, but again, the choice of pacing detracted from the 2/4 long-phrase feel that brahms intended. didn't think the transition section between b major and the original theme flowed well either... the accelerando was too abrupt- the transition from legato to the original "allegro energico" should still contain brahms' marked 2/4 feel
@TheFrenchiesRock For pity's sake, please no! Everyone and their dog plays it fast. That just takes away all the power and makes it sound like a techno song.
This is my favourite interpretation of this piece. It's much more passionate than other versions I've heard, with a little more rubato. The quiet section leaves me frustrated, though. Why does he slow down so much? Also the dynamics there are a little bit unexpressive. Still, great performance.
Brahms is about emotion in pure strength and speed i think, that's not the real thing, doesn't mean it's bad, Kissin is a lot better at playing Liszt than any other composers imo
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Slow tempo, any very very fluctuating. The tempo it`s Allegro Energico, what he`s playing it isn`t even Allegretto, more like Andante ... He`s a great performer, but ... The best interpretation of the Intermezzo op.118 that i`ve ever heard it`s with Radu Lupu. Take Care !
@1p8t7r Well ... i don`t know if you ever seen the score of the Intermezzo`s. Yes ... there are 6 pieces, but they are not called that. The name of the cycle it`s Intermezzo.
yes i've seen it, and played all of op.118, and they are called Pieces for piano. but ok, perhapse you've seen the edition where they are all called intermezzo's
Well, i understand both your opinions. It's difficult to choose, there's both very diffirent and i like them both very very much. It depends on my mood i think, great interpretations!!!
Kissin, this interpretation is near my idea about Brahms. He discovers structure, pathos, architectonic intelligence, vision, intensity, polyphony, contrast, in one word: the text, the writing. Brahms had already "dropped the unnecessary notes under the table" and wrote that necessary, do not need to fall so Pogorielic other with his hurry.
I love this piece! Beautifully played! Very inventive interpretation in a good way. Tempo here is just right. Some people go too fast or too slow. I have performed this piece myself several times.
Well, this is very well played. With a lot of expression and interpretation. And the tempo´s are good. Brahms did not give another tempo for the middle part!! Although Kissin plays with little rubato he respects this. The temposhift in Pogorellich´s version is almost karikatural. Furthermore it is played mechanical..
This is one of my favourite performance of Brahms' Ballade No. 3 op. 118. Yes, I also like the rubato. I must perform this piece for a piano exam and I wish I could play it this well!! :)
i am choosing this peice for my piano exam as well. When i heard this peice, i jst could'nt forget the melody. Even though there is only 2 months away until my exam, im still changing Brahms op 188 no2 into this peice, brahms op 188 no3.
I prefer the playing of Andreas Thiel in this piece. Listen to it and compare.
msmarmion 3 weeks ago
like this <3
marimari9594 4 weeks ago
most pianists make the g minor theme to this piece sound like its in 4/4 when it's actually in cut time. the voicing in the middle b major section was beautiful, but again, the choice of pacing detracted from the 2/4 long-phrase feel that brahms intended. didn't think the transition section between b major and the original theme flowed well either... the accelerando was too abrupt- the transition from legato to the original "allegro energico" should still contain brahms' marked 2/4 feel
livelovelisten100 3 months ago
Loved it
MatheusDinizsr 10 months ago
i think it should be played faster...
TheFrenchiesRock 1 year ago
@TheFrenchiesRock For pity's sake, please no! Everyone and their dog plays it fast. That just takes away all the power and makes it sound like a techno song.
Timrath 7 months ago
@TheFrenchiesRock me to
MrMica147 3 months ago
help!! i performing this very soon for my diploma aahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
nightslayer 1 year ago
This is my favourite interpretation of this piece. It's much more passionate than other versions I've heard, with a little more rubato. The quiet section leaves me frustrated, though. Why does he slow down so much? Also the dynamics there are a little bit unexpressive. Still, great performance.
bertiethetoupee4 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Best version on youtube so far
Hammond100L 2 years ago
Brahms is about emotion in pure strength and speed i think, that's not the real thing, doesn't mean it's bad, Kissin is a lot better at playing Liszt than any other composers imo
mrmazmaz 2 years ago 2
i like the tempo and this version but the basses are too softly played... mabe it's because of the recording
Yaniss 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Slow tempo, any very very fluctuating. The tempo it`s Allegro Energico, what he`s playing it isn`t even Allegretto, more like Andante ... He`s a great performer, but ... The best interpretation of the Intermezzo op.118 that i`ve ever heard it`s with Radu Lupu. Take Care !
eda2k 2 years ago
this is not an intermezzo!!!
and as for this piece, it is fantastic, and kissin did a great interpretation!
1p8t7r 2 years ago
Well ... this "Ballade" it`s from the 6 Intermezzo op.118, actually the 3rd. Better inform next time !
eda2k 2 years ago
but still, isn't an Intermezzo.
those are "Six pieces for piano"
The six pieces are:
No. 1. Intermezzo in A minor. Allegro non assai, ma molto appassionato
No. 2. Intermezzo in A major. Andante teneramente
No. 3. Ballade in G minor. Allegro energico
No. 4. Intermezzo in F minor. Allegretto un poco agitato
No. 5. Romance in F major. Andante
No. 6. Intermezzo in E flat minor. Andante, largo e mesto
Better inform next time!
1p8t7r 2 years ago 10
@1p8t7r Well ... i don`t know if you ever seen the score of the Intermezzo`s. Yes ... there are 6 pieces, but they are not called that. The name of the cycle it`s Intermezzo.
eda2k 2 years ago
yes i've seen it, and played all of op.118, and they are called Pieces for piano. but ok, perhapse you've seen the edition where they are all called intermezzo's
1p8t7r 2 years ago
excellente interprétation la meilleur selon moi sur youtube !!! c'est magnifique !
TwoWoods13 2 years ago
Well, i understand both your opinions. It's difficult to choose, there's both very diffirent and i like them both very very much. It depends on my mood i think, great interpretations!!!
nekudo 2 years ago
das ist immer das gleiche ärgernis mit kissin - alles wirkt geballert
mandyschulz 2 years ago
Kissin, this interpretation is near my idea about Brahms. He discovers structure, pathos, architectonic intelligence, vision, intensity, polyphony, contrast, in one word: the text, the writing. Brahms had already "dropped the unnecessary notes under the table" and wrote that necessary, do not need to fall so Pogorielic other with his hurry.
astrolabiosat 2 years ago
I love this piece! Beautifully played! Very inventive interpretation in a good way. Tempo here is just right. Some people go too fast or too slow. I have performed this piece myself several times.
tatjanalu 2 years ago
Well, this is very well played. With a lot of expression and interpretation. And the tempo´s are good. Brahms did not give another tempo for the middle part!! Although Kissin plays with little rubato he respects this. The temposhift in Pogorellich´s version is almost karikatural. Furthermore it is played mechanical..
seabird22 2 years ago
Comment removed
HappyKljave 2 years ago
I'm not normally a Brahms fan, but this piece is great!
Lavalampoflava 3 years ago 2
¿Normally?
gpablito14 3 years ago
@Lavalampoflava Not a Brahms fan? I didn't know not being a fan of Brahms was an option
aabaker22 1 year ago 8
This is one of my favourite performance of Brahms' Ballade No. 3 op. 118. Yes, I also like the rubato. I must perform this piece for a piano exam and I wish I could play it this well!! :)
PercivalHoward 3 years ago 2
i am choosing this peice for my piano exam as well. When i heard this peice, i jst could'nt forget the melody. Even though there is only 2 months away until my exam, im still changing Brahms op 188 no2 into this peice, brahms op 188 no3.
This peice is fabulous :)
Bellywelly123 2 years ago
Yes, it is so beautiful. Best of luck in your piano exam. You will do all the better for choosing a piece you love!
PercivalHoward 2 years ago
i like the rubato. not many other pianists have it in this piece.
DualThunder 3 years ago 2