Added: 3 years ago
From: KEUDER
Views: 47,719
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (35)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I prefer the playing of Andreas Thiel in this piece. Listen to it and compare.

  • like this <3

  • most pianists make the g minor theme to this piece sound like its in 4/4 when it's actually in cut time. the voicing in the middle b major section was beautiful, but again, the choice of pacing detracted from the 2/4 long-phrase feel that brahms intended. didn't think the transition section between b major and the original theme flowed well either... the accelerando was too abrupt- the transition from legato to the original "allegro energico" should still contain brahms' marked 2/4 feel

  • Loved it

  • i think it should be played faster...

  • @TheFrenchiesRock For pity's sake, please no! Everyone and their dog plays it fast. That just takes away all the power and makes it sound like a techno song.

  • help!! i performing this very soon for my diploma aahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • This is my favourite interpretation of this piece. It's much more passionate than other versions I've heard, with a little more rubato. The quiet section leaves me frustrated, though. Why does he slow down so much? Also the dynamics there are a little bit unexpressive. Still, great performance.

  • Brahms is about emotion in pure strength and speed i think, that's not the real thing, doesn't mean it's bad, Kissin is a lot better at playing Liszt than any other composers imo

  • i like the tempo and this version but the basses are too softly played... mabe it's because of the recording

  • this is not an intermezzo!!!

    and as for this piece, it is fantastic, and kissin did a great interpretation!

  • Well ... this "Ballade" it`s from the 6 Intermezzo op.118, actually the 3rd. Better inform next time !

  • but still, isn't an Intermezzo.

    those are "Six pieces for piano"

    The six pieces are:

    No. 1. Intermezzo in A minor. Allegro non assai, ma molto appassionato

    No. 2. Intermezzo in A major. Andante teneramente

    No. 3. Ballade in G minor. Allegro energico

    No. 4. Intermezzo in F minor. Allegretto un poco agitato

    No. 5. Romance in F major. Andante

    No. 6. Intermezzo in E flat minor. Andante, largo e mesto

    Better inform next time!

  • @1p8t7r Well ... i don`t know if you ever seen the score of the Intermezzo`s. Yes ... there are 6 pieces, but they are not called that. The name of the cycle it`s Intermezzo.

  • yes i've seen it, and played all of op.118, and they are called Pieces for piano. but ok, perhapse you've seen the edition where they are all called intermezzo's

  • excellente interprétation la meilleur selon moi sur youtube !!! c'est magnifique !

  • Well, i understand both your opinions. It's difficult to choose, there's both very diffirent and i like them both very very much. It depends on my mood i think, great interpretations!!!

  • das ist immer das gleiche ärgernis mit kissin - alles wirkt geballert

  • Kissin, this interpretation is near my idea about Brahms. He discovers structure, pathos, architectonic intelligence, vision, intensity, polyphony, contrast, in one word: the text, the writing. Brahms had already "dropped the unnecessary notes under the table" and wrote that necessary, do not need to fall so Pogorielic other with his hurry.

  • I love this piece! Beautifully played! Very inventive interpretation in a good way. Tempo here is just right. Some people go too fast or too slow. I have performed this piece myself several times.

  • Well, this is very well played. With a lot of expression and interpretation. And the tempo´s are good. Brahms did not give another tempo for the middle part!! Although Kissin plays with little rubato he respects this. The temposhift in Pogorellich´s version is almost karikatural. Furthermore it is played mechanical..

  • Comment removed

  • I'm not normally a Brahms fan, but this piece is great!

  • ¿Normally?

  • @Lavalampoflava Not a Brahms fan? I didn't know not being a fan of Brahms was an option

  • This is one of my favourite performance of Brahms' Ballade No. 3 op. 118. Yes, I also like the rubato. I must perform this piece for a piano exam and I wish I could play it this well!! :)

  • i am choosing this peice for my piano exam as well. When i heard this peice, i jst could'nt forget the melody. Even though there is only 2 months away until my exam, im still changing Brahms op 188 no2 into this peice, brahms op 188 no3.

    This peice is fabulous :)

  • Yes, it is so beautiful. Best of luck in your piano exam. You will do all the better for choosing a piece you love!

  • i like the rubato. not many other pianists have it in this piece.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more