Added: 2 years ago
From: lememberz
Views: 73,103
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (177)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • good but the pianoist should slow done cause then that messes up the other instrument

  • It's rlly nice but damn ppl there in HIGH SCHOOL!!!! It's not gonna be freakin perfect!

  • problem: pianist doesnt look at the conductor!!!

  • You need asians here.

  • Problem: not enough asians.

  • @Iceandjello @fierryhair  I see a ton of 'em!

  • amazing!

  • For a school orchestra they did a damn good job so shut up!!!

  • The Pianist should get solo !

  • No rubato?

  • when the orchestra plays.. the angels sing :)

  • *BOOM* THAT WAS THEM BLOWING MY MIND!!!!

  • The pianist is good, but the rest.... ;)

  • Mr. Anderson, why? Why do you persist?

  • some of them loss there rhythm through the song. =D =D

  • i wish my school would play awesome songs like this

  • wow they're pretty good. 

  • why do u people criticize these people like they are pros?!?! they are jus in high school i think! they are good, even though slightly out of tune, but i am pretty sure high notes are sharp or somthing on a violin...

  • omg people they are little school kids shut up if u were just learning i bet u wouldnt be able to do it no im in high school i can do a lot but that is something i will need a lot of work at the violin and stuff is hard so dont be rude

  • Are they a beginner group? If they are that's pretty good. I just assumed they were beginners because I didn't really hear much vibrato, nor did I hear the right dynamics but otherwise goodjob!

  • Beautifull...

  • Yeouch... My ears were killing me because of uneven tuning... I liked it but, needs tuning work

  • I wanna play this at my orchestra!!

  • great!!

  • yeah its not the best 

  • Don't play it just for the sake of playing it. This is way too fast and the piano should be the main not your fucking violin.

  • way way too fast

  • TOO FAST !

  • TOO FAST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I wish my school played this..

    A bit rushed and got out of sync with the piano here and there. A bit out of tune as well.

    Too bad the violins didnt play the high trill. :/

    Overall i liked it though/

  • Heu...que dire...what the fuck?

  • Is it meant to be out of tune?

  • BOOOOOOOOOOOO..............

  • Jesus christ guys. ITS a school orchestra not fkng bethoven

    

  • @Banished8712 Beethoven*

  • @Banished8712 *Beethoven. And I think Yiruma's music should be taken as seriously as Beethoven's.

  • @Banished8712 Did you just put Beethoven and Fucking in one sentence!? NO! That is not allowed! Some people love Beethoven, and you spelt his ...name...wrong! *Cries.* He inspired people! You do NOT write his name wrong and GET AWAY WITH IT!

  • @4775327 Calm down man he tried to spell it but, YOU DON'T HAVE TO OVEREACT SO MUCH

  • @yectorium ....................I'm a girl...

  • @4775327 he didnt, he said Bethoven not Beethoven

  • @abfun123 ...

  • this song sounds a little rushed

  • the people are all off with the conductor i mean look at the hand and listen to the beat the students were playing at urghhhh still good though

  • wow with the violins it's beautiful !

  • woooow some instruments are out of tune like hell

    and after 1.35 it becomes a mess

  • @teenhakker

    I've heard all versions of this, the orchestral one the most, and you are completely right... they're not even in the right key it sounds e.o

  • ca vous dit un basket ?

  • the tempo is off but they did well...for what it was

  • too fast...and very sharp at certain...*shiver*..ok again

  • I love this, even if its fast, its good for an orchestrated version, in my opinion. (I have no formal lessons on cello, sorry) I', probably going to learn this by ear, write it down for cello, transfer it to violin, and then to every other main string instrument. :D can't wait till next year to do it for my orchestra

  • ummm tempo is a bit fast... and tuning could do with a bit of work :D BUT AWESOME ARRANGEMENT XD

  • Did the violins have mutes on or what?

  • Beautifullllll <3 <3 <3

  • it gets faster n faster~slower will makes better!

    the strings sound weird...erm... abit strange...

  • uummmm....a little slower plz!

  • Beautiful *•.¸✿

  • Sin Palabras me quedado :O

  • ah i would of LOVED orchestra at my school....i cannot wait to start my journey in composition as a major :)

  • it sounds a bit disharmonic, weird, but the piano sounds very beautiful!

  • Jeez, why can't all schools have orchestras :(

  • i wish i had an orchestra at my school damnit

  • Wtf its so not tuned and way too fast. But quite good for a school orchestra tho

  • i had goosebumps. it's so good. :3

  • amazing. ^^

  • Uuuuuhm this is kinda bad. REALLY of pitch ALL the time. It hurts a bit...

  • @lOtakul i agree

  • u guy dont have a audiotariom? O .o

  • @anime1fanforeva Not everyone has the ability to have an auditorium like most people, my school doesn't have an auditorium but we are a really good band and choir. We don't have a orchestra though, but our school is also small and we also were in debt for a while. So not all schools are lucky enough for one, which is sad.

  • @AuroraSkies17 oh srr..

  • @anime1fanforeva No big deal it's not like you knew. =)

  • beautiful...a bit too fast for my liking its really a beautiful song with slow and fast speed at specific times to evoke emotions..but lovely still lovely..i would have gave a standing ovation..

  • IMPRESSIVE

  • 20 people have no music taste :)

  • its kinda fast...but still nice

  • foarte tare`.

  • uau`...e foarte taree :X. adorabila melodia`:-< .

  • this is way too fast

  • it would have been nicer if it had been alot slower, it sounds as though the whole orchestra was playing all the wrong notes.... :S oh well pretty good anyways!

  • its cool how the orchestra director allowed this to be played in his orchestra =]

    my old school's director would never play sumtin lyk this xD

  • I got goosebumps.:)

  • this is amazing:)

  • notes were somehow good, but waay to fast.

  • Wow im in orchesta im a, violist I love the viola. But this is awesme

  • omg is that fast..

    i think its a little bit too fast...

    but its a nice arrangment

  • clap, clap, clap...

  • wow its good but...its like they are ruching it y'know? it needs to kinda slow down and get that soothing sound =D

  • It was great! It was rushed just slightly though. And it's so not that hard to hold a freakin' camera dude! That's a lot of people.

  • It was great, but a bit too fast. Try playing it a little slower.

  • can i get the sheet for violin?

  • Anyone got violin notes for this song?

  • no offence dude but that sounded CR*P!!

  • goosebumps haha! wow.

  • Dude this sucks shit. No rubato, No dynamics, Wrong Tempo? YOU FUCKING SUCK SHIT SERIOUSLY. NO EMOTION YOU LIL FAGGOT. Jewish Cunt. Ruins all the fucking emotions out of all the songs.

  • Who the hell are you to critique like this? Get a life - you obviously don't know what it means to be a LEARNER. Everyone must go through stages of learning - it's never perfect from the beginning. Shut the fuck up asshole.

  • @xaznherox4life wow so much vulgarity...u are immaturity at its best.What purpose does ur vulgarity serve ?Dont like it dont listen..even though U CAN PLAY a musical instrument doesnt mean THAT WE will all agree that its nice and even if WE DONT agree, we wont find the immature need to curse..now please get a life

  • @xaznherox4life isnt that a bit offensive to jewish people? ._.

  • epic fail

  • this should be "river floods in you." not "flows in you."

  • i like it when they gave it a twist but i think te piano and the strings didn't synchronize in the middle part of the vid.

  • omgeeezz dis sounds soo beautiful dis song always makes me wanna cry.....omgosh oo dis is beautiful

  • could someone get me a link or a store or somehign for the score / sheet music so that y school could learn this aswell? thnx sooooooooooooo much

  • The Piano is too load

  • @LuluBananie

    You mean too loud?

    It isn't.

  • @94msueng that is how it's supposed to sound!!

    They did great! :] :]

  • this is horrible.

  • Is there the sheet music for the separate instruments?? I wealliee weallieee need it!! Pweaseeeeeeee

  • Comment removed

  • van un poco a destiempo los chicos de violin de hay en fuera suena bien

  • It's not too fast people, that's how Yiruma plays it. Go look it up.

  • the piano is too fast, this song is supposed to be soft and slow

  • @94msueng

    What're you talking about? It seams that you don't know how the original goes at all. Search it up.

  • its poor

  • i would say this was good if i had never heard the song b4

  • incredibly out of tune strings

  • that's due to recording, i'm sure there well-tuned ;)

  • my god it's SOOOO bad...

    they're not going at the same time...

    The pianist plays as if he were alone...and the violinists have made many mistakes

  • It is a pretty song, but the Orchestra was out of tune, no vabrato, and more dynamics.

  • Wow....way off and too fast. I once played that fast on the piano. And my piano teacher told me it sounded like "War"

  • @dkfa LMFAO

  • to fast

  • No dynamics, :o

    And why are there so many OPEN STRINGS?? Especially for those long A's. -.-

    The strings screwed it up x)

    But, they're probably like in middle school or something so its understandable.

  • They're high schoolers thank you very much. I wasn't in that orchestra though, I'm in the chamber orchestra of that same school, this isn't the top orchestra their. Cut them some slack, they're probably just doing what Mr. Anderson (the conductor) told them, and he likes to take things too fast.

  • Comment removed

  • tuning and tempo... nuff said

  • it would sound nice if they werent so off . i think a better orchestra could play it better

  • wow pianist..what a wonderful way to ruin such a great song...it's called watch the director.

    I'm sure you probably know that now cause I'm sure he probably gave you what for after the concert.

  • he was fine, leave him the hell alone. it's NOT an easy piece.

  • wow! NiCE! but out of tempo

  • ...THEY RUINED IT LOL. why do they sound flat?

  • rushing rushing rushing. Slow it down a bit and get it in tune and it may have been pretty cool. 3/5

  • that was horrible :-/ only the piano were great, bahhh the strings, awfull sound, realy bad.!!!!

  • this is amazing

  • eh love the song when its played BY YIRUMA. This kinda killed it.....out of tune i think...

  • this girl in my orchestra keeps playing this

    its soo annoying

    and she thinks its the twilight song thing which makes it even worse

  • Lol. I hate it when people do that.

  • Comment removed

  • wow, creative !

    but i do agree, it should have been slower. but still, still beautiful :]

    was this a beginning or intermediate orchestra ensemble ?

  • O.O

    Please record this beautiful and put here in youtube! °_°

    I want to listen it in studio quality. This orchestra is awesome.

  • feels too fast.

    needs more emotion.

    other than that, it's nice

  • its too fast

    they gotta sincronize

    and the camera man is a shit head

  • alot of wrong notes are hit by the orchestra. sounds out of tune.

    too harsh sounding as well.

    would be good with quality instruments and a better arrangement

  • fast for my taste but i love the arrangement. thanks for sharing. =)

  • noooooo

  • great camrea man

  • it is grate video

  • beautiful

    I love it

    Perfect.

  • the piano is to fast.

    i don't like it, its way to fast

  • seems like their rushing it. too fast for my liking

  • wunderschön, ich bekomm gänsehaut :)

  • I wish I can understand your language xD

  • okay, i try to translate it :D

    ehm...

    it's so beautiful, i get gooseflesh ;D

  • Ohh Haha Okay xD

  • he said : beautiful, i'm getting goose bumps.

  • @lememberz google translator :D

  • @lememberz

    very nice, i get chills

    thats what he says.

  • @lememberz He or she means that was beautiful and really great

  • Comment removed

  • Nice you guys sound great

    Check my orchestra version out

    It's not really an orchestra cuz it was made on computer...but check it out anyways

  • oh wow :} nice lol ocrch dorks are awsome im in orch dorks are awsome i play the piano tho

  • Is this the freshman orchestra? xD

  • Hahah Hells yeah!

  • What?! This is the Clackamas A Orchestra playing River Flows In You. Not the B Orchestra playing, for you information.

  • This is the A orchestra O_O what are you talking about

  • If your trying to say this is A orchestra playing, then we're BOTH right. Because in the front of the video, it says " Preformed by the High School Orchestra (A group)" which mean it is. But when you said "What are you talking about," do you mean it is not the A orchestra playing?

  • why are you making a big deal out of this. Its A orchestra there we're both right

  • Yes, I know we are both right. And I am not trying to make a big deal out of this. I just don't want anyone one to be confused if it is the freshman orchestra, or not. Because it isn't the freshman orchestra playing...

  • Yeahh Thanks for clarifying xD

  • You're Welcome.

  • its beautiful! I play the viola by the way.

    one of the 8th graders (she also a viola) is always playing this on the piano!

    This sounds so pretty because string insturaments make everything sound beautiful....except jazz. I hate it when our orch dork teacher makes us play jazz music. We sound so corny! Except for the basses.

    ORCH DORKS RULE!

  • its a bit 2 fast

  • Haha I guess so Im not sure hahah

  • =D Waaaoooooh! Very Good! Congratulations. I love this music... and this version is excelent!

    Saludos desde Venezuela!! =)

  • Wow it sounds great as an orchestrated version! Great job guys!

  • cool!!! i could play that on the piano too!!! i wish i could play the violin again!! that's soo cool!!