According to the Sue Fishkoff book " The Rebbe's Army" p.167, Bob Dylan is one of the biggest names associated with Chabad. In the early 1980s, Chabad " rescued" Dylan from a brief flirtation with Christianity, and for several years, Bylan studied with Minneapolis Rabbis Manis Friedman and Moshe Feller, whom he visited also for Shabbat dinners. Dylan made surprise albunm INFIDELS in 1983 with Jewish content. For Chabad he sang " Hava Negila" on the harmonica in 1988.
Khalid, in the end you to will confess that the God of Israel is God, no matter if the Jews are good or bad, God has chosen them, for His names sake, no man is good, not one who does what God wants, but He chooses who He wants and He has chosen Isaak over Ishmael as He chose Jakob over Esau.
it is funny how zionist always portray themselves as the victims because their flag gets burned while they forget that they kill innocent civilian, distroy houses, and took out a whole palestinian nation from their land, and still play the victim card.
@nelsonr32 Read the Bible: He is not on his enemies' land. On the contrary: His enemies are on HIS land. The LORD will sort it out before it is all over -- at the cost of much blood, both Jewish and Gentile.
No allies!, what nonsence..Look at the money,$3 billion a year, sometimes more, Israel gets off of America.. Or the german reparations ..
and also israel does change the course of rivers..
In the 1967 war Israel deliberately attacked a US ship, USS Liberty,so as to prevent America from knowing that syria wasnt provoking israel, they attacked syria and occupied the golan heights, with their precious water supplies..
205 of its crew were either killed or wounded in the attack..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
By the way, you know Germany was surrounded by a bunch of enemies too....interesting how being surrounded by countries that disagree with your injustices has no impact on the fact they are STILL UNJUST.
I'm sure Nazi Germany had propaganda maps like that - OMG look at us were so small, look at all those horrible jewish infested countries surrounding us.
This video, and the Israeli DEFENSE Forces prove that this world will always have some form of injustice that goes ignored for far too long.
@camdanable you're complete fool - germany attacked all of the nations surrounding germany Israel has been and is continually attacked by the nations surrounding israel. On top of that, the mufti of Jerusalem (MUSLIM) went to Berlin in WW2 and organized muslims to fight FOR THE SS against the allies.
Whatever valid points you may have the fact that the Mufti of Jerusalem sided with Germany doesn't prove anything. Palestine was under British occupation as I'm sure you know, so it is only natural that the mufti would side with the enemies of his enemies. It doesn't make really mar the Palestinans. Again, you may have some good points, but that is not one of them. If Paua New Guniea had been waging on the British Empire perhaps the Mufti would have sided with them.
@platypusmessiah I don't think you know much about what you are saying here. The Mufti of Jerusalem didn't side with Hitler because of the British. He sided with Hitler because he was a raging anti-semite who believed in the "Final Solution" to the "Jewish Problem". I would recommend you consider reading "Icon of Evil: Hitler's Mufti and the Rise of Radical Islam" if you'd like some insights into that time period. It is much more relevant to the times today than you might realize.
The poles and French weren't calling for all the Germans to be killed. The Arab and Iranian Governments on the other hand have launched the biggest rounds of hate propoganda against the people of Israel since WWII.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Who'd have guessed lol....Bob Dylan made propoganda...isn't that something. No surprise this is from one of his worst selling albums.
There are so many blatant disregards for historical and political accuracy (never mind objectivity) in this song and video post that I'm not going to even bother refute it.
I hope you sheep enjoy sucking up your own cocks as you watch this - follow the herd you stupid, oh so stupid Jews.
This song should be called Bob Dylan and Israel's Mutual Masterbation.
1Keep not thou silence, O God: hold not thy peace, and be not still, O God. 2For, lo, thine enemies make a tumult: and they that hate thee have lifted up the head. 3They have taken crafty counsel against thy people, and consulted against thy hidden ones. 4They have said, Come, and let us cut them off from being a nation; that the name of Israel may be no more in remembrance.
jews took no land that wasnt theirs....100 years ago there was a turkish muslim prescence in jerusalem ....christians from many lands lived there and the majority was jewish in jerusalem....there were no arabs...arabs were bedouins who had no fixed place to live....palestinians were made up in 1967 and koshered by the europeans in 1980 after many many satanic killing sprees by the PLO...no palestinians...no illegal settlements...no traditional east jerusalem...never existed
so for 7565709, don't be defensive, please check the history long before this place become no man land. and see the prophecy and history in the bible. And there are many prophecy in the bible come to pass either you believe or not. Also there are many things that proof this place (once) as isrealy land. just check the history.
palestina was no man land, jewish,islam, & western was there. the people in palestina (islam) claim this land was theirs. But before that, israely was in this land. David established his kingdom in Jerusalem as his capital (as you can see the history proof his kindom presence was there).God worn israel if they didn't obey God & because their disobidient God allow Babilonia took most of israely to babilon&some israely still in there (the really poor one).but God promise to give them back.(1947).
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Please dont be defensive and hateful..i am only making a point. israelis took a land that isnt theirs. they massacred palestinians and treated them like animals. the worlds strongers superpower is their ally (US). i love bob dylan but what is this all about?? if you're strong enough to admit that this land is not yours and you are a jew then you deserve respect, but dont just support murderers because its the easier thing to do
for cple years ago this land was no man land, jewish, islam, kristen was there. but long time ago this land was israely land. David established his kingdom in Jerusalem as his capital. But God worn them if they didn't obey God. And one day God scattered Israel to all different nation, first babilonia took them to their land. on that moment israel was no more, islam,and westeren started to habitat their land. But God promises them to give them back. see this prophecy in the bible &in the history.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
While I'm sure that many who comment here condemn extreme atrocities such as the Holocaust, they are absolutely willing to use it as an "excuse" for the expulsion and massacre committed against the Palestinians by the Israeli government.
Condemn terrorism unequivocally.
Thus, I'm forced to see that there is only marginal difference between the Israeli Defense Forces and Hamas or Al-Qaeda: different flags, different uniforms, different ways of killing humans -- but it's all the same.
You're straining at gnats and swallowing camels....
"Jew" is simply a contraction of the word "Judean", like "Roman" is someone from "Rome"? About a million Israel Jews came from other West Asian countries.
The non-Jewish inhabitants of Israel may have their birthright, but the Judeans also have a claim to Judea.
BTW, you aren't a US citizen of European extraction, are you? If so, please go kill yourself, or at least go read some history...
these are the same "palestinians "who wouldnt permit "jews to worship nor indeed in Jerusalem pre 1947 allow "jews" to walk on the same side of the street without having to give way,I am not Jewish but for a race of people that have been persecuted throughout history they are entitled to a homeland and the bible or koran is derived from the old testament where it calls the jews Israelites and shows it as there "promised land".
When he went to Wailing Wall he went in the '60s when people thought he was some kind of leader of a generation. That was the '60s I guess these lyrics are serious (1980s - just when he finished with his Christian albums).
Last 21 April Dylan was playing in Geneva Arena, just a few feet away from the UN, where the commemoration of the "Yom Hashoah" was taking place. Two hours earlier, at the same place, Iran's Ahmadinejad had once again demonized Israel. It's really a pity that Dylan didn't come to sing this song on the Place of nations, or even inside the UN !... It coulda been a moment of history !
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
no religion deserves special treatment, and a certain group certainly doesnt deserve an illegal nation all to themeselves. Fuck Israel! Fuck Zionists! Fuck Religion!
YEEEY COOL SONG IDF ROCKZZZZZZZZ JESUS LIVES DUDES ... inside of every christ and good jew , muslim hindu and so on!!!!!!!!!!! PEACEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
No idea why this comment was thumbed down, perhaps to much truth for the propaganda machine?
chbillgr (2 weeks ago) Show Hide -10
Marked as spam
Reply | Spam
I don't have JUST an OPINION about crimes against humanity. The United Nations, Amnesty International and all hunman rights organizations do. Israel is INDEED THE NEIGHBOURHOOD BULLY.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this one 2
chbillgr (2 weeks ago) Show Hide -7
Marked as spam
Reply | Spam
UN watch has nothing to do with the United Nations you moron. UN watch is is affiliated with the American Jewish Committee, is based in Geneva and combatting Anti-Semitism. I am not an Anti-Semit. You are saying nothing about the facts. And the fact is that Israel has been ignoring the United Nations since forever under the blessings of the US governments who just care to sell weapons. Remember Masters of War? Huh?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Bob Dylan has clearly lost his humanist edge. What happened to the objective sentiment in Hurricane and Times are a changin. Clearly his heritage blinds him in his old age.
Why can't Israel live in peace? They are a dynamic people, instead the oppression of Palestinians continue. To the point where even young Israeli soldiers are questioning the orders given to them to 'shoot at will' at innocent civilians.
More than anything we jews crave to live in peace, but the arabs won`t let us !
They vote for war when they vote for Hamas.....gazans being frustrated by Arafat corruption & misuse of his peoples trust is just a SMALL part of the picture !
You may be interested in this prophecy from Jesus recorded in Luke 21:24"They will fall by the sword(the Jews)and will be taken as prisoners to all nations.Jerusalem will be trampled on by the Gentiles until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled".The prophecy was fulfilled in 1948 when Israel became a nation again.They are now back in Israel exactly as the prophet Ezekiel said (Ez 37). The prophecy was completely fulfilled in 1973 when Jerusalem was regained. I hope this is encouraging to you
Since I`m jewish, the CHRISTIAN New Testament isn`t my primary source of spiritual and historical guidance..........-and besides, my experience tells me that when moslems(I assume you are one) read christian and jewish holy scriptures, they most often tend to interpret what they are reading in a way supporting their own preconcieved prejudices...
-What are YOU talking about, our jewish capital Yerushalayim, was 'regained' i e liberated in 1967, not 1973 !
Nickjw55, it was not my intension to offend you in any way,and i was surprised at the spirit of your reply.I am not a moslem. I was just talking about the the power of God in bringing His people back to THEIR land as was prophecied.I know about 1967,but what happend in 1973 brought the whole of Yerashalayim under Israeli control.I am glad that these words have been fulfilled .i wish Israel all the best.
No harm, no foul.....-possibly I am a bit oversensitive sometimes......
You wouldn`t believe -or perhaps You would, the degree of vitriol / hatred topped off with ignorance & indifferernce we very often encounter, both in real life as well as verbally / in writing on debate forums e.t.c. ? Makes for kneejerk reactions on occasion, sorry about that.
Bob Dylan is a realist.....if someone who`s stated their objective ; to annihilate the jewish state, is shooting at us, our homes and our families.....-we jews don`t turn the other cheek, we take action to try to stop our enemy from shooting at us !
-Just like what any democratic european & american people/nation would do, were they in the same situation as Israel !
The gazan people ought to be more careful with what they vote for & wish for....they just might get it, all over again !
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
"But just because somebody feels a certain way, you can't come around and stick some political-party slogan on it. If you listen closely, it really could be about other things. It's simple and easy to define it, so you got it pegged, and you can deal with it in that certain kinda way. However, I wouldn't do that. 'Cause I don't know what the politics of Israel is. I just don't know. "
Bob Dylan said that the song could be about other things, that it wasn´t jingoistic Israeli nonsense.
Well no offense intended to you. I understand that I have not stepped foot on Israeli soil. I can only imagine what it must be like for an Israeli soldier. I have not been to Iraq or many other places yet as a human being and in particular a U.S. citizen whose government is very much involved in the problems of the Middle East if feel it's relevant for me to attempt some understanding of the situation.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Israel is guilty of crimes against humanity and the cause of it's own trouble with the Palestinian people. Listen to what Jimmy Carter has to say on this.
Jimmy Carter was the worst president US ever had. He is now senile. And the first crime Israel has been committing was against itself, by authorizing so many Arabs to stay on a land where they had nothing to do.
Historians agree these presidents were worse than Carter.
Jimmy Carter simply expresses what the most people paying attention to the conflict believe throughout the world. If you believe Israel's only crime is it not being harsher towards the Palestinian people I have nothing further to say to you.
So, let's not talk. How many times have you been in Israel ? What allows you to judge ? Do you know how many billions of oil money are spent on pro-Palestinian propaganda with only one agenda, the destruction of the state of Israel ? I you were in Israel's situation, you would do 100 times worst. Those guys are saints. I know. I was in the Israeli army !
And also, by the way, their is not such a thing as "the Palestinian People"... Their were some Arabs, living in the Palestine region. Many more came when they saw what the Jews were able to do with the desert. Later on, they called themselves Palestinians. They are just Arabs. Nothing more.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Please don't think I'm against Israel. Even if I am naive what I'd like to see is freedom for all people there as much as this can be achieved and lasting peace. I don't believe Israel will secure peace through the policies it has implemented or through escalating aggression. Anyway, I'm afraid I've read too much Chomsky and Finkelstein. Too late for me to be reached.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The Greek toponym Palaistinê (Παλαιστίνη), with which the Arabic Filastin (فلسطين) is cognate, first occurs in the work of the Greek historian Herodotus, active in the middle of the 5th century BCE, where it denotes generally the coastal land from Phoenicia down to Egypt. Herodotus also employs the term as an ethnonym, as when he speaks of the 'Syrians of Palestine' .Don't try to make Palestinian people "dissappear" like the Germans tried to do with the Jewish people.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Well I guess you are older and wiser than Herodotus. Also more informed than Wikipedia. Blame them for twisting names. It's their article. Btw in greek, Palaistinê (Palestine) is pronounced Falastini since forever. Just to get some things straight.
Neither Dylan nor Israel should be destroyed. This is absolute nonsense. People must find a way to live together peacefully and Dylan is entitled to his own opinions. Destruction is no solution and what it only brings is more desctruction.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Probably with. But, he's not always clear who or what he's with or against. Certain things I've heard him say on Israel and his religious beliefs lead me to figure he's probably fairly biased like most people, especially American Jews.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Are you Bob's spokesman? Are you sure that everyone with a heart and brain is pro-Israel? I am not so sure myself considering Israel is guilty of crimes against humanity.
pro israel or not this song describes exactly israel, what could be more perfect :)
u can have an opinion about crimes,
but only when u live in both sides i would believe what u r claiming but sorry u have quiet life somewhere so mind ur own buisness please :) athens is on fire where are u? :P
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't have JUST an OPINION about crimes against humanity. The United Nations, Amnesty International and all hunman rights organizations do. Israel is INDEED THE NEIGHBOURHOOD BULLY.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
UN has nothing on Israel because the United States constantly veto every single UN resolution against Israel in the security council. And you know why? Because the United States are the biggest supplier of weapons to Israel and Israel is its best client by far. This is what I call shit.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
UN watch has nothing to do with the United Nations you moron. UN watch is is affiliated with the American Jewish Committee, is based in Geneva and combatting Anti-Semitism. I am not an Anti-Semit. You are saying nothing about the facts. And the fact is that Israel has been ignoring the United Nations since forever under the blessings of the US governments who just care to sell weapons. Remember Masters of War? Huh?
So, let the UN, that has about 50 Arab Nations, condem Israel that has about , let's see, 1 nation. So, do I really believe in the UN? Fuck you and your Amnesty International bullshitters.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i reposted your posts, these fucking ..
not gonna be anti-semtic even tou sometimes they really live up to the stereotype.
thumbing ur posts down because they state fact, thats nothing new here, they really have made quite a system for doing this on youtube.
Fact is to good for u isrelis?
Adjust to the rest of the world and stop feeling sorry for yourself, the holocaust was a time ago, uve milked that one into a country, but still u want more land?
YOU are a driven propagandist, seeing what you want to see and ignoring the rest....I suppose you`re familiar with the old proverb ; 'Jew, stay on your cross...as long as you remain there, we`ll continue loving you'...
-Newsflash, we jews left our cross in 1948 and we`re NEVER AGAIN going back there !!
By your last two words, you showed everybody what YOU`re made of !
Social fascists, islamo-fascists & old school european fascists jointly against Israel !
"No allies to speak of"?! Are you kidding? 'Israel, right or wrong' seems to be the United States' motto.
LeshaAnn 4 months ago
According to the Sue Fishkoff book " The Rebbe's Army" p.167, Bob Dylan is one of the biggest names associated with Chabad. In the early 1980s, Chabad " rescued" Dylan from a brief flirtation with Christianity, and for several years, Bylan studied with Minneapolis Rabbis Manis Friedman and Moshe Feller, whom he visited also for Shabbat dinners. Dylan made surprise albunm INFIDELS in 1983 with Jewish content. For Chabad he sang " Hava Negila" on the harmonica in 1988.
JerusalemRocks 4 months ago
Khalid, in the end you to will confess that the God of Israel is God, no matter if the Jews are good or bad, God has chosen them, for His names sake, no man is good, not one who does what God wants, but He chooses who He wants and He has chosen Isaak over Ishmael as He chose Jakob over Esau.
hartzion 1 year ago
it is funny how zionist always portray themselves as the victims because their flag gets burned while they forget that they kill innocent civilian, distroy houses, and took out a whole palestinian nation from their land, and still play the victim card.
Israel will be exterminated (Enshallah)
khalidglory 1 year ago
@khalidglory Fuck off and die, IslamoNazi filth.
JimboUSofA 4 months ago in playlist Save
What Makes Barack Hussein Obama Really Mad? (Hint: Starts with I and Ends with S-R-A-E-L)
nateruiz77 1 year ago
I love this song, but the message it gives is contradictory and inaccurate.
I mean, "His enemies say, he's on there land."...even Israels allies agree on that one!!
And "no allies to really speak of"; that's the reason they've been able to commit genocide for the last 33 years!
I do wonder what Dylans take on Israeli's occupation would be in 2010. No suprise he doesn't perform it...
nelsonr32 2 years ago
@nelsonr32 Actually they wouldn't agree with that at all.. What do you think is under the Dome of the Rock, Sir? It's the Temple Mount..
Mojoski 2 years ago
@nelsonr32 Read the Bible: He is not on his enemies' land. On the contrary: His enemies are on HIS land. The LORD will sort it out before it is all over -- at the cost of much blood, both Jewish and Gentile.
avgguy777 1 year ago
No allies!, what nonsence..Look at the money,$3 billion a year, sometimes more, Israel gets off of America.. Or the german reparations ..
and also israel does change the course of rivers..
In the 1967 war Israel deliberately attacked a US ship, USS Liberty,so as to prevent America from knowing that syria wasnt provoking israel, they attacked syria and occupied the golan heights, with their precious water supplies..
205 of its crew were either killed or wounded in the attack..
risteardsean 2 years ago
Only bob dylan can capture the essence of israel so beautifully and to the point.
maybe goldstone sould listen to this song
tamiravig 2 years ago 2
You'd have to pay me to watch it. Is there a site like that?
platypusmessiah 2 years ago
End the unjust Arab occupation of Jewish Land.
Dismantle Arab Imperialism.
There is no place for religious killing and Islam should be banned.
eliezer017 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
By the way, you know Germany was surrounded by a bunch of enemies too....interesting how being surrounded by countries that disagree with your injustices has no impact on the fact they are STILL UNJUST.
I'm sure Nazi Germany had propaganda maps like that - OMG look at us were so small, look at all those horrible jewish infested countries surrounding us.
This video, and the Israeli DEFENSE Forces prove that this world will always have some form of injustice that goes ignored for far too long.
camdanable 2 years ago
@camdanable you're complete fool - germany attacked all of the nations surrounding germany Israel has been and is continually attacked by the nations surrounding israel. On top of that, the mufti of Jerusalem (MUSLIM) went to Berlin in WW2 and organized muslims to fight FOR THE SS against the allies.
jpeditor 2 years ago 3
Whatever valid points you may have the fact that the Mufti of Jerusalem sided with Germany doesn't prove anything. Palestine was under British occupation as I'm sure you know, so it is only natural that the mufti would side with the enemies of his enemies. It doesn't make really mar the Palestinans. Again, you may have some good points, but that is not one of them. If Paua New Guniea had been waging on the British Empire perhaps the Mufti would have sided with them.
platypusmessiah 2 years ago
@platypusmessiah I don't think you know much about what you are saying here. The Mufti of Jerusalem didn't side with Hitler because of the British. He sided with Hitler because he was a raging anti-semite who believed in the "Final Solution" to the "Jewish Problem". I would recommend you consider reading "Icon of Evil: Hitler's Mufti and the Rise of Radical Islam" if you'd like some insights into that time period. It is much more relevant to the times today than you might realize.
Mojoski 2 years ago
@Mojoski Good post. Much can be found on this war criminal at the blog called "Atlas Shrugs," run by Ms Pamela Geller.
avgguy777 1 year ago
The poles and French weren't calling for all the Germans to be killed. The Arab and Iranian Governments on the other hand have launched the biggest rounds of hate propoganda against the people of Israel since WWII.
nbcable 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Who'd have guessed lol....Bob Dylan made propoganda...isn't that something. No surprise this is from one of his worst selling albums.
There are so many blatant disregards for historical and political accuracy (never mind objectivity) in this song and video post that I'm not going to even bother refute it.
I hope you sheep enjoy sucking up your own cocks as you watch this - follow the herd you stupid, oh so stupid Jews.
This song should be called Bob Dylan and Israel's Mutual Masterbation.
camdanable 2 years ago
This album isn't exactly from his glory years. Past or present. But he's Bob Dylan, let it slide.
platypusmessiah 2 years ago
fight those fucking antisemites on the street and on the campus, theres no time for talking !!!!!!!
Long Live Israel!!!!
Fuck Old Europe!!!
mrStalingrad1943 2 years ago 5
Am Yisrael chai!
aarfeld 2 years ago 3
G*D Bless the IDF!
thuriferthecenser 2 years ago 3
I love the fact that so many Jew-haters love this song because they are so dam stupid to realise what the song is about.
capitalsho 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahaa it's like Americans listening Born in the USAY
but back to the point
FUCK BOB DYLAN
simonistic 2 years ago
Great song by a great performer.
Psalm 83
1Keep not thou silence, O God: hold not thy peace, and be not still, O God. 2For, lo, thine enemies make a tumult: and they that hate thee have lifted up the head. 3They have taken crafty counsel against thy people, and consulted against thy hidden ones. 4They have said, Come, and let us cut them off from being a nation; that the name of Israel may be no more in remembrance.
avgguy777 2 years ago
jews took no land that wasnt theirs....100 years ago there was a turkish muslim prescence in jerusalem ....christians from many lands lived there and the majority was jewish in jerusalem....there were no arabs...arabs were bedouins who had no fixed place to live....palestinians were made up in 1967 and koshered by the europeans in 1980 after many many satanic killing sprees by the PLO...no palestinians...no illegal settlements...no traditional east jerusalem...never existed
SHMUJEW 2 years ago 5
Neat!
underzog 2 years ago
so for 7565709, don't be defensive, please check the history long before this place become no man land. and see the prophecy and history in the bible. And there are many prophecy in the bible come to pass either you believe or not. Also there are many things that proof this place (once) as isrealy land. just check the history.
molilovesi 2 years ago 2
palestina was no man land, jewish,islam, & western was there. the people in palestina (islam) claim this land was theirs. But before that, israely was in this land. David established his kingdom in Jerusalem as his capital (as you can see the history proof his kindom presence was there).God worn israel if they didn't obey God & because their disobidient God allow Babilonia took most of israely to babilon&some israely still in there (the really poor one).but God promise to give them back.(1947).
molilovesi 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Please dont be defensive and hateful..i am only making a point. israelis took a land that isnt theirs. they massacred palestinians and treated them like animals. the worlds strongers superpower is their ally (US). i love bob dylan but what is this all about?? if you're strong enough to admit that this land is not yours and you are a jew then you deserve respect, but dont just support murderers because its the easier thing to do
7565709 2 years ago
for cple years ago this land was no man land, jewish, islam, kristen was there. but long time ago this land was israely land. David established his kingdom in Jerusalem as his capital. But God worn them if they didn't obey God. And one day God scattered Israel to all different nation, first babilonia took them to their land. on that moment israel was no more, islam,and westeren started to habitat their land. But God promises them to give them back. see this prophecy in the bible &in the history.
molilovesi 2 years ago
Jerusalem is God's land,just put it on His hand;
pray for Jerusalem N His children all the best
Amen
959up1up 2 years ago 5
To Nickjw55 ,what i should have said was Israel regained the Golan heights in 1973, and the surrounding area. all the best.
telabib 2 years ago
in 67 it was
myfavmusicvidoes 2 years ago
Great peace of music!
xGoldfasanx 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You're only a pawn in their game, Bob.
MarxBakuninMe 2 years ago
When it comes to the world we live in we are all pawns, no matter who you are. No one human is able to accomplish what they hope.
nbcable 2 years ago
That's because maybe they hope too much. Don't hope. Just do.
MarxBakuninMe 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
While I'm sure that many who comment here condemn extreme atrocities such as the Holocaust, they are absolutely willing to use it as an "excuse" for the expulsion and massacre committed against the Palestinians by the Israeli government.
Condemn terrorism unequivocally.
Thus, I'm forced to see that there is only marginal difference between the Israeli Defense Forces and Hamas or Al-Qaeda: different flags, different uniforms, different ways of killing humans -- but it's all the same.
jackjohn6921 2 years ago
You're straining at gnats and swallowing camels....
"Jew" is simply a contraction of the word "Judean", like "Roman" is someone from "Rome"? About a million Israel Jews came from other West Asian countries.
The non-Jewish inhabitants of Israel may have their birthright, but the Judeans also have a claim to Judea.
BTW, you aren't a US citizen of European extraction, are you? If so, please go kill yourself, or at least go read some history...
59DaveBrown 2 years ago
these are the same "palestinians "who wouldnt permit "jews to worship nor indeed in Jerusalem pre 1947 allow "jews" to walk on the same side of the street without having to give way,I am not Jewish but for a race of people that have been persecuted throughout history they are entitled to a homeland and the bible or koran is derived from the old testament where it calls the jews Israelites and shows it as there "promised land".
Linfiled09 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He wrote these lyrics as a joke.
He also went to The Wailing Wall in a skull cap as a stunt.
He didn't like that people viewed him as a "prophet" so he did things to shatter that image.
He started purposely writing bad lyrics and making bad records.
He didn't believe in these lyrics or the superior image that the people had given him.
Quite pathetic of everyone here that claim to be a Dylan fan, even though they don't know shit.
starburstslut 2 years ago
where is your evidence ??? I would be interested to to know.....the lyrics don't sound sarcastic...
nkvd1000 2 years ago
When he went to Wailing Wall he went in the '60s when people thought he was some kind of leader of a generation. That was the '60s I guess these lyrics are serious (1980s - just when he finished with his Christian albums).
MarxBakuninMe 2 years ago
Last 21 April Dylan was playing in Geneva Arena, just a few feet away from the UN, where the commemoration of the "Yom Hashoah" was taking place. Two hours earlier, at the same place, Iran's Ahmadinejad had once again demonized Israel. It's really a pity that Dylan didn't come to sing this song on the Place of nations, or even inside the UN !... It coulda been a moment of history !
zorbazig 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fucking propaganda ...
soundwave2403d 2 years ago
Well said Dylan!!
adi4466 2 years ago
how true is this!!!!!.... Go Bob note ever great singer is either Jewish or pro Jewish!!!
badazred 2 years ago
great song. he's the best
nutrishus 2 years ago 3
Shalom Israel
Shortlie2342 2 years ago 4
lol even if the palestinan of today are philistins , they have no right to own land of israel has they are invaders who came from the aegen sea.
ZionistOpressor 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no religion deserves special treatment, and a certain group certainly doesnt deserve an illegal nation all to themeselves. Fuck Israel! Fuck Zionists! Fuck Religion!
killedbycrows 2 years ago
thank you Mr. Dylan. Long Live Israel.
delpiero47 2 years ago
Hey fuck, you forgot a few names of your prophet:
al-lier
al-pedophile
al-muderer
al-rapist
al, ah fuck you islamo fuck facist.
ChiefOren 2 years ago 5
well done...great pics...and the song, well, duh, it's Dylan at his best...
sirjohn2u 2 years ago 3
YEEEY COOL SONG IDF ROCKZZZZZZZZ JESUS LIVES DUDES ... inside of every christ and good jew , muslim hindu and so on!!!!!!!!!!! PEACEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
MrJesusvonNazaret 2 years ago
zeyfullahhh = this muzzie gonna explode watch out lol
ChosenOneJew 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
chernobilski 2 years ago
tool
arievanravensway18 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Zionist Israel is evil 666. Zionist Israel planned and did 9/11 and 7/7
US-citizens are paying taxes for Israel's global war-crimes.
War on Terror is a war for Israel's SATANIC EMPIRE.
Zionist US-PsychoCryptoJews nuked Hiroshima & Nagasaki
STOP THE FIGHTING AND DYING FOR ISRAEL666's TERRORIST SATANIC EMPIRE
MUKAVAME 2 years ago
Hey, go back to your goat. Islamo facist/
ChiefOren 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol mankind sucks!
and even more does religion !
but the jews .........
mehditalib 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No idea why this comment was thumbed down, perhaps to much truth for the propaganda machine?
chbillgr (2 weeks ago) Show Hide -10
Marked as spam
Reply | Spam
I don't have JUST an OPINION about crimes against humanity. The United Nations, Amnesty International and all hunman rights organizations do. Israel is INDEED THE NEIGHBOURHOOD BULLY.
simonistic 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this one 2
chbillgr (2 weeks ago) Show Hide -7
Marked as spam
Reply | Spam
UN watch has nothing to do with the United Nations you moron. UN watch is is affiliated with the American Jewish Committee, is based in Geneva and combatting Anti-Semitism. I am not an Anti-Semit. You are saying nothing about the facts. And the fact is that Israel has been ignoring the United Nations since forever under the blessings of the US governments who just care to sell weapons. Remember Masters of War? Huh?
simonistic 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bob Dylan has clearly lost his humanist edge. What happened to the objective sentiment in Hurricane and Times are a changin. Clearly his heritage blinds him in his old age.
Why can't Israel live in peace? They are a dynamic people, instead the oppression of Palestinians continue. To the point where even young Israeli soldiers are questioning the orders given to them to 'shoot at will' at innocent civilians.
ElliottJM 2 years ago
More than anything we jews crave to live in peace, but the arabs won`t let us !
They vote for war when they vote for Hamas.....gazans being frustrated by Arafat corruption & misuse of his peoples trust is just a SMALL part of the picture !
NickJw55 2 years ago 10
You may be interested in this prophecy from Jesus recorded in Luke 21:24"They will fall by the sword(the Jews)and will be taken as prisoners to all nations.Jerusalem will be trampled on by the Gentiles until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled".The prophecy was fulfilled in 1948 when Israel became a nation again.They are now back in Israel exactly as the prophet Ezekiel said (Ez 37). The prophecy was completely fulfilled in 1973 when Jerusalem was regained. I hope this is encouraging to you
telabib 2 years ago
telabib,
Since I`m jewish, the CHRISTIAN New Testament isn`t my primary source of spiritual and historical guidance..........-and besides, my experience tells me that when moslems(I assume you are one) read christian and jewish holy scriptures, they most often tend to interpret what they are reading in a way supporting their own preconcieved prejudices...
-What are YOU talking about, our jewish capital Yerushalayim, was 'regained' i e liberated in 1967, not 1973 !
-Get your facts straight !
NickJw55 2 years ago
Nickjw55, it was not my intension to offend you in any way,and i was surprised at the spirit of your reply.I am not a moslem. I was just talking about the the power of God in bringing His people back to THEIR land as was prophecied.I know about 1967,but what happend in 1973 brought the whole of Yerashalayim under Israeli control.I am glad that these words have been fulfilled .i wish Israel all the best.
telabib 2 years ago
Telabib,
No harm, no foul.....-possibly I am a bit oversensitive sometimes......
You wouldn`t believe -or perhaps You would, the degree of vitriol / hatred topped off with ignorance & indifferernce we very often encounter, both in real life as well as verbally / in writing on debate forums e.t.c. ? Makes for kneejerk reactions on occasion, sorry about that.
NickJw55 2 years ago
no problem, all the best.
telabib 2 years ago
why i need jesus prophciy if i got ezekiel?
jesus were prophets stealer?:S
shawnvicious 2 years ago
ElliotJM,
Bob Dylan is a realist.....if someone who`s stated their objective ; to annihilate the jewish state, is shooting at us, our homes and our families.....-we jews don`t turn the other cheek, we take action to try to stop our enemy from shooting at us !
-Just like what any democratic european & american people/nation would do, were they in the same situation as Israel !
The gazan people ought to be more careful with what they vote for & wish for....they just might get it, all over again !
NickJw55 2 years ago 21
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"But just because somebody feels a certain way, you can't come around and stick some political-party slogan on it. If you listen closely, it really could be about other things. It's simple and easy to define it, so you got it pegged, and you can deal with it in that certain kinda way. However, I wouldn't do that. 'Cause I don't know what the politics of Israel is. I just don't know. "
Bob Dylan said that the song could be about other things, that it wasn´t jingoistic Israeli nonsense.
Cefuroxx 2 years ago
GREAT FUCKING SONG
96028 2 years ago 7
please visit my channel and tell also others about it, so we can fight biased media and tell what is really going on in Israel. thanks
JusticeVSpropaganda 2 years ago
Awesome video. These profound lyrics say it all!!!
julia707 2 years ago 6
Can't we all just get along?
aj31313 3 years ago
Great video. It speaks volume to the situation in Israel, and the history of the Jewish people.
puresrtrash 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
some funny shit mate. poor israel
actually poor jews. someone need to rid the world from these anti sematic bastards lmao
Amjad756 3 years ago
5/5 great video well combined love it :)
its very true in my OPINION.
thanks for the great video!
ChosenOneJew 3 years ago 14
mann
im a palastinan i i just wanr peace
if there was only one state and the palastinen and israel goverment cut be one palastine and israel would be paradise
but no you just wont to kill the peace
yomalek 3 years ago
no we dont it is hamas who doesnt support the peace even as we speak since last cease fire kassam keeps flying.
so i mean common this is nothing new and in no way is a step for peace.
i am just like u i would love there to be peace like many others but its hard when u got hamas in control in gaza.
and only the innocent suffer both sides.
and i can only blame hamas for all that.
ChosenOneJew 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
but it was israel that fird a mislil on a "smugle underground" but the mislil kild 16 peuopel and that was when the cefire still was acctive
a mistake. but that dosent mean that hamas have to attack again, he was angry
yomalek 3 years ago
Well no offense intended to you. I understand that I have not stepped foot on Israeli soil. I can only imagine what it must be like for an Israeli soldier. I have not been to Iraq or many other places yet as a human being and in particular a U.S. citizen whose government is very much involved in the problems of the Middle East if feel it's relevant for me to attempt some understanding of the situation.
S2Cents 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Israel is guilty of crimes against humanity and the cause of it's own trouble with the Palestinian people. Listen to what Jimmy Carter has to say on this.
S2Cents 3 years ago
Jimmy Carter was the worst president US ever had. He is now senile. And the first crime Israel has been committing was against itself, by authorizing so many Arabs to stay on a land where they had nothing to do.
Eddanij 3 years ago
AndrewJohnson,Pierce,Buchanan,Harding,Tyler,Nixon,Fillmore,Grant,Harrison..
Historians agree these presidents were worse than Carter.
Jimmy Carter simply expresses what the most people paying attention to the conflict believe throughout the world. If you believe Israel's only crime is it not being harsher towards the Palestinian people I have nothing further to say to you.
S2Cents 3 years ago
So, let's not talk. How many times have you been in Israel ? What allows you to judge ? Do you know how many billions of oil money are spent on pro-Palestinian propaganda with only one agenda, the destruction of the state of Israel ? I you were in Israel's situation, you would do 100 times worst. Those guys are saints. I know. I was in the Israeli army !
Eddanij 3 years ago 5
And also, by the way, their is not such a thing as "the Palestinian People"... Their were some Arabs, living in the Palestine region. Many more came when they saw what the Jews were able to do with the desert. Later on, they called themselves Palestinians. They are just Arabs. Nothing more.
Eddanij 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Please don't think I'm against Israel. Even if I am naive what I'd like to see is freedom for all people there as much as this can be achieved and lasting peace. I don't believe Israel will secure peace through the policies it has implemented or through escalating aggression. Anyway, I'm afraid I've read too much Chomsky and Finkelstein. Too late for me to be reached.
S2Cents 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Greek toponym Palaistinê (Παλαιστίνη), with which the Arabic Filastin (فلسطين) is cognate, first occurs in the work of the Greek historian Herodotus, active in the middle of the 5th century BCE, where it denotes generally the coastal land from Phoenicia down to Egypt. Herodotus also employs the term as an ethnonym, as when he speaks of the 'Syrians of Palestine' .Don't try to make Palestinian people "dissappear" like the Germans tried to do with the Jewish people.
chbillgr 3 years ago
in arabic it's Falastin, Filistin are dead long time ago they are the sea ppl who invaded israel in the bible time stop twisting up names.
ChosenOneJew 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Well I guess you are older and wiser than Herodotus. Also more informed than Wikipedia. Blame them for twisting names. It's their article. Btw in greek, Palaistinê (Palestine) is pronounced Falastini since forever. Just to get some things straight.
chbillgr 2 years ago
Falastini , Palastine any of them still is not the ancient Philistins so whats your point wise guy.
ChosenOneJew 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
My point is you should read some take some history lessons instead of being rude.
chbillgr 2 years ago
u the one who need history lessons telling me that current palistines are ancient Philistins.
telling me i'm rude? look at your comments.
ChosenOneJew 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I guess white phosphorus bombs are polite too then.
chbillgr 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
.
Dylan and Israel should be destroyed.
.
GaryNull 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Neither Dylan nor Israel should be destroyed. This is absolute nonsense. People must find a way to live together peacefully and Dylan is entitled to his own opinions. Destruction is no solution and what it only brings is more desctruction.
chbillgr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Seig Hiel!
tenfed1861 2 years ago
S2Cents - You are a jew hating piece of shit and so is peanut head Jimmy Carter .
LODGE4444 2 years ago
Internet Tough Guy, I take no offense to your hateful, ignorant post. It is below me.
(To anybody that reads this, I actually like a lot of Jews and despise anti-Semites and have no idea what this asshole is talking about. Peace)
S2Cents 2 years ago
Hey asshole - I'm talking about your comment from 7 months ago.
LODGE4444 2 years ago
Yeah asshole, like I said your post is wrong, plain and simple.
S2Cents 2 years ago
No asshole - you're still a jew hating son of a bitch - read what you wrote 7 months ago and you'll see why.
LODGE4444 2 years ago
Yeah like I said your wrong and that's all there is to it. Sorry, deal with it.
S2Cents 2 years ago
is bob whit or against israel
yomalek 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Probably with. But, he's not always clear who or what he's with or against. Certain things I've heard him say on Israel and his religious beliefs lead me to figure he's probably fairly biased like most people, especially American Jews.
S2Cents 3 years ago
WITH of course. Bob has a heart and a brain.
Eddanij 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Are you Bob's spokesman? Are you sure that everyone with a heart and brain is pro-Israel? I am not so sure myself considering Israel is guilty of crimes against humanity.
chbillgr 3 years ago
pro israel or not this song describes exactly israel, what could be more perfect :)
u can have an opinion about crimes,
but only when u live in both sides i would believe what u r claiming but sorry u have quiet life somewhere so mind ur own buisness please :) athens is on fire where are u? :P
ChosenOneJew 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't have JUST an OPINION about crimes against humanity. The United Nations, Amnesty International and all hunman rights organizations do. Israel is INDEED THE NEIGHBOURHOOD BULLY.
chbillgr 2 years ago
chbillgr -- u obviously have no life.
lol u replay me after months hoping i wont replay u....
anyways u heard of UN watch? they exactly putt an eye on the propaganda
country's who belive in the same shit u believe UN has nothing on israel.
no war crimes what so ever.
on the other hand every single thing ham ass did was a war crime. :)
go to the UN.
ChosenOneJew 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
UN has nothing on Israel because the United States constantly veto every single UN resolution against Israel in the security council. And you know why? Because the United States are the biggest supplier of weapons to Israel and Israel is its best client by far. This is what I call shit.
chbillgr 2 years ago
u probally dont know whats UN watch hehe whatever u say.
ChosenOneJew 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
UN watch has nothing to do with the United Nations you moron. UN watch is is affiliated with the American Jewish Committee, is based in Geneva and combatting Anti-Semitism. I am not an Anti-Semit. You are saying nothing about the facts. And the fact is that Israel has been ignoring the United Nations since forever under the blessings of the US governments who just care to sell weapons. Remember Masters of War? Huh?
chbillgr 2 years ago
So, let the UN, that has about 50 Arab Nations, condem Israel that has about , let's see, 1 nation. So, do I really believe in the UN? Fuck you and your Amnesty International bullshitters.
ChiefOren 2 years ago 19
Thank you I'll keep that in mind.
chbillgr 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL
garabage :)
xBiscuitPowerx 3 years ago
Great video. Thanks for posting.
roddissimo 3 years ago 5
not worry,israel have innumerable righteous people aegis, you are not alone the war!
TOOPLIN 3 years ago
i like this, i also made one for this song :)
shawry86 3 years ago 2
God is with Israel
ChristFollower71 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Give me a break will ya.
chbillgr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i reposted your posts, these fucking ..
not gonna be anti-semtic even tou sometimes they really live up to the stereotype.
thumbing ur posts down because they state fact, thats nothing new here, they really have made quite a system for doing this on youtube.
Fact is to good for u isrelis?
Adjust to the rest of the world and stop feeling sorry for yourself, the holocaust was a time ago, uve milked that one into a country, but still u want more land?
two words: Nazi = Israel
simonistic 2 years ago
simonistic,
-Facts are on our side !
YOU are a driven propagandist, seeing what you want to see and ignoring the rest....I suppose you`re familiar with the old proverb ; 'Jew, stay on your cross...as long as you remain there, we`ll continue loving you'...
-Newsflash, we jews left our cross in 1948 and we`re NEVER AGAIN going back there !!
By your last two words, you showed everybody what YOU`re made of !
Social fascists, islamo-fascists & old school european fascists jointly against Israel !
NickJw55 2 years ago 8
This should be Israel's 2nd national anthem
IzraelMan 3 years ago 6
words of truth.
MojoRising89 3 years ago 32