Mariah Carey vs Christina Aguilera - Belts Notes after 2005

[filipeaa320]

Well... even though mariah's vocals are not the same as she used to deliver in the 90's, they are further healthier than aguilera's. Aguilera demages her vocal apparatus excessively; her upper chest is insanely bad!

[VasushAriel]

Christina. One and only Queen of all music.

[K3nny905]

Why take the clips from after 2005 and not from the start of their careers? Mariah totally slays Xtina in her prime

[TroyWannaBE101]

Christina. Is. Simply. The. Best. :).

[XtinoBart]

XTINA THE BEST

[daven688]

People who say christina can sing obviously cant hear that good...she strains even up 2 B4...WTF!! She sounds terrible and too make up for it with too many runs and rifts but she doesnt notice that she sounds like shit. Ok mariah doesnt sound the same, but shes performed everywhere and for over 20years she has a reason...chrisitna isnt as or will never be as big as mariah soo she'll never perform as much she did. But christina is too young too sound that terrible..but she never did sound good

[TroyWannaBE101]

@daven688 Christina is bigger than Mariah carey haha ... Smh, Her sound is just different, if it was strained she wouldnt be able to do it no more. And she clearly can.

[ILoveMcWhMj4ever]

Mariah Carey.. Forever and always... Wow who ever made this video didn't do so many spectacular peformances.. Angels cry, Merry Christmas 2 you.. Yea Chrsitina can sing But Not as Great as MARIAH CAREY!!!! Christina's just hollars she doesn't sing to me..

[TroyWannaBE101]

@ILoveMcWhMj4ever The point in this video is showing people that christina is better, mariah has nothing on her "now" People always wanna talk about how good mariah is, it isnt is .. Its (was) ...

[stardusth2o]

Mariah>>>Christina anytime, any year.

[TroyWannaBE101]

@stardusth2o Oh you meant Mariah<<<Christina all the time, Now and days forever and always ...

[296218047]

All Mariah Fans>>>stop saying Christina can't sing.

I love Christina, but mariah has much more controll about her voice, her belts are clearer. Christinas voice is definitely more powerful than mariahs today. but see mariahs if its over performances, that was as much power as christina have today. Plus the fact she has more control over her voice. Mariah loses power with the years and wins control, i don't thin the 1990 mariah could sing a song like flab or hate u. but u cant compare xtina&mimi

[TroyWannaBE101]

@296218047 Yeah you can, if we take it out of the 2000's christina could out sing mariah even then, and still can today ... And that doesnt make any since at all mariah have more control? shes the only artist ever to loose control of her voice live ... Christina just has a different sound thats why she sounds the way she does.

[imsofucingtired]

Omg whoever made this video is wiked. Those Mariah vocals are complete shit, she has way better than those. Ms. Aguilera wins here.

[TroyWannaBE101]

@imsofucingtired It's not that she has better, she does back in the day but since 2005 ....... aha she isnt the same, and thats due to over use of whistle register ...

[Raoulirshan]

Mariah all dayyyy!

[aapascrom96]

Christina´s voice is better with the years...

SHE ROCKS!!!!

[TroyWannaBE101]

@aapascrom96 HELL YEAH

[123buffylover]

this is biased, while christina's voice is getting better with time, she still has problems with slight straining, but mariah lost her voice, because of her belting, and 7th octave whistling, i love them both still

[TroyWannaBE101]

@123buffylover Not strained thats what belts sounds like, when mariah belts they sound similar. You cant here vibrato with belts thats how you tell the different. Christina just has a unique sound.

[musicguy713]

Mariah without even watching a second of the video. She may not have been very consistent during these years but she will always be better than christina.

[NewtonSalem]

emm, well I'm not a big fan of neither of those, but I prefer aChristina :) her voice causes a better bigger effect on me =/

[1flutedude]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA!!! FOR SURE

[DreamloverLambi]

Mariah

[reulior]

Christina >>>>>>>>> Mariah

[imafan123456]

Christina just shouts/screams. Her belt is horrible. Mariah is a lot better, especially since shes been pregnant. I think Xtina has a good voice just she destroys it when she shouts and oversings every other word.

[iSeeyouXD]

christina is soo much better

[chocolatechipcokies]

mariah FTW!!!

living legend <3

[horseracing2009]

@chocolatechipcokies Christina obviously has a better voice though.

[chocolatechipcokies]

@horseracing2009 says who? mariah has one of THE best voices out there! PERIOD.

i like christina, but too much screaming for me :/

[horseracing2009]

@chocolatechipcokies If she didn't 'scream' she would have a better voice. She beats her anyday.

[chocolatechipcokies]

@horseracing2009 yeah, i'm sure only the deaf agrees with you there.

[horseracing2009]

@chocolatechipcokies It's obvious, Christina has a full vocal range Mariah doesn't.

[Puilip]

@horseracing2009 U nid to go to the audiologist seriously =)

[ale5677]

It's not fair to compare Christina at her prime to Mariah Carey Vocals after two decades of singing. Let's compare this Christina to Mariah at her prime thean that would be a vocal battle. But Mariah still gives the fight when it comes to belting.

[mariahthebest1]

they both are good know let stop acting childish and go after the bad singers of today.

[Devotedlamb19]

I'm just gonna finish my assessment with this. Even with her diminished voice, Mariah kicks the shit out of Christina's harsh, screamy, throaty voice.

[wuddap2]

Christina does not sing better with time. She constantly screams and goes all over the place & she even cracked within her second clip & its starting to show that her voice is becoming damaged from all of her screaming

[Chimier]

Mariah. Even with her diminished voice, she doesn't sound as screamy, thin and horrid as The Noise. Mariah has 5x the better vocal production, skill and resonance.

[Devotedlamb19]

Mariah's C5 vs Christina's E5s: Mariah

Mariah's G#5 vs Christina's G5: Mariah

Mariah's Eb5 vs Christina's E5: Mariah

Mariah's D5 vs Christina's D5s: Christina

Mariah's E5s vs Christina's D5: Tie

[latinomada]

Mariah Carey!!!!!!

[latinomada]

!!!!!!!!!!!MARIAH CAREY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[heartburn17]

LOL @ 5:17 Godzilla is back! <3

[RaciouS91]

@heartburn17 ahahhaha

[TheAnkheart]

CHRISTINA SINGS and shout...

unlike of mariah...

[Litalici0us]

You took some of worst Mariah's vocals

[eelposho]

@Litalici0us this are after 2005 ! :D

[eelposho]

@Litalici0us this video is after the year 2005 , of this form sing mariah now :D

[imafan123456]

@eelposho But she has done much better perfromances than this. And your description box shows how biased this video is.

[TroyWannaBE101]

@Litalici0us No just mariah isnt as good as she use to be sorry.

[ThatsNonpossible]

yeah, Mariah was awesome in her time before she sold out with the abortions she created after her awesome Butterfly album. Christina is amazing. That's all I can say about that.

[lebb20]

all christina does is scream mariah is was and always will be the queen of music

[jochiluis]

mariah is by far better! shes 10 years older than christina! and her vocal abilities are amazing, it really depens on the hours she sleeps, and her vocal resting time!! i love christina too, but mariah takes the cake!