Although 9/10 comments mention Anneke (and I agree with them) we have to give credit to Silje for this song. I think we just have to realize that this will be a new era, not necessarily a bad era for Gathering. And you have to agree that the song is really good, and she has a nice, distinctive voice.
really good song, good album e good vocal, but Im imaging here Anneke singing this song. I really miss her in The Gathering. Someone knows about why she left the band?
Me gusta mucho su voz pero desearía más fuerza y potencia en su voz, aun así suena a The Gathering pero extrañaré mucho a Anneke, su sonrisa, carisma, su mirada de demente tierna y por supuesto, su poderosa voz...
son fan de esta banda desde hace 10 años ycom todos estamos acostumbrados a anneke pero esta mujer (silje) viene a proyectar a la banda a otros niveles tiene muy buena voz ademas es buena la rola y para los q le son fieles a anneke proximamente su primer material como solista habra que ver q tal le va
soy fan de the gathering desde hace 10 años y estoy acostumbrado a ver a esta banda con anneke pero para ser sincero creo q la nueva voz proyectara mas a esta legendaria banda holandesa y a los fans de anneke no desesperais ya viene su material solista muy buena rola
I'm with whoever said that, good as she is here, SIlje should be making more Octavia Sperati albums. Such a good band! That said, this is the first time I've cared about a new Gathering release in years, and I hope she helps draw the band back towards their heavy roots.
Surely this girl has some Asian in her bloodline. Her eyes are a dead give away, even with her eyes being blue and all. Pretty girl though, nice voice too
the band is still brilliant, the new songs are fantastic. when a band loses a singer so charismatic as Anneke, it's kind of hard to come back with a new one as good as the previous. The Gathering did it. Silje is a fantastic singer, great technique and very emotional too.
Imo I like the music the Gathering are making now more than Anneke's music, and while she is an amazing singer, it doesn't make any of the other singers less good. I love the vocal melody in this song at 2:24 - 2:35
People should stop comparing Silje to Anneke. This is useless. Let's face the truth - Anneke is not in The Gathering anymore. And now TG started new age in their career - Silje age. And I'm very happy with that because she's an amazing singer and her voice perfectly fits in the music. And I still love Anneke and I think she's best female singer ever. That's really great that she has got great successor.
What is the fucking problem, she is an EXCELLent singer, yes she is not Anneke, i love Anneke, but she is not anymore get over, at least she sing pretty good, she is not Anette (nightwish) or even worst Mariangela (tristania)
The problem is people can't accept change man. You're wasting your time trying to explain it, believe me, I've tried to. I love Anneke aswell, she was fantastic. I honestly thought no one could possibly replace her, but man the new vocalist is fantastic and people need to give credit where it's due! She did the unthinkable and replaced Anneke without ripping her off. She managed to make it her own, while still staying true to the classic Gathering formula. That deserves respect, in my opinion.
aaaa..c'mom u guys expect so much of the singer ¬¬...if u were any musical expert or understand something about vocals u would not act like that...unfortunatelly the gathering now is one "nightwish" when talking about vocalists ¬¬...patetic
As a vocalist, I find I prefer Silje. I just love her tone so much more than Anneke's. Anneke is talented, but with Silje in the band now, I listen to them more. In the end, I find them to both be good. Honestly though, I think Silje should have been making more Octavia Sperati records. They're an ace metal band.
the gatering the best , evanescence is shit , gringos hijos de putas
killernazis 4 months ago
Although 9/10 comments mention Anneke (and I agree with them) we have to give credit to Silje for this song. I think we just have to realize that this will be a new era, not necessarily a bad era for Gathering. And you have to agree that the song is really good, and she has a nice, distinctive voice.
TheAvento 9 months ago 5
Love this track.
lekorque 1 year ago 9
Very good singer, very good album, rekindled my interest in the group, they sound fresh with ideas.
spyretto 1 year ago 8
the gathering made a good choice, silje is a great singer and I´m proud of their new work.
Obviously I prefer anneke´s voice, I love her and I like what is she doin´now.
have a different opinion about nightwish´s choice, I think they made a terrible mistake with anette, but it´s done.. unfortunately
whatever
I like new Gathering and love anneke´s work :)
vitaliah 1 year ago 13
*wonders about the significance of t'haugen
xDivinitysCreaturex 1 year ago
Video ótimo, música ótima, adorei o novo som!!!
Parabéns The Gathering.
flvbr2 1 year ago
she remember me a litle tori amos
prigarciae 2 years ago 4
She have a voice sometimes like Aneeke, sometimes like Evanescence vocalist ;)
tatiana888 2 years ago
@tatiana888 the Gathering never gonna sound like evanescence... evanecence aleve is like shit
jorgeegb 1 year ago 15
@jorgeegb The Gathering is one of the First Dutch band with Goth sound, even before Within Temptation.
Evanecence came way after W.T.. ;)
transploft8 7 months ago 4
true
annberrie 1 year ago
Great video! Great Album!
See you in Barcelona! :)
josecp 2 years ago
really good song, good album e good vocal, but Im imaging here Anneke singing this song. I really miss her in The Gathering. Someone knows about why she left the band?
08ti07a83go 2 years ago
She left because she wanted to concentrate on her own band Aqua de Annique. Unfortunetely her own band is not half as good as The Gathering. D:
CelestialParshath 2 years ago 6
Sencillamente excelente!!! Silje tiene una voz hermosa!!
MrSirAlucard 2 years ago
Good song, good video, the only think that i dont like her close up shots effects, it make her look ugly, and she is a pretty woman.
melinaimhoff 2 years ago 8
Might be just me but... in the very first verses she sounds like Tori Amos.
artrasa 2 years ago 8
Wow! An unforgetable voice!
Harmony603 2 years ago 2
Wow, sounds like Anneke Never left.
I always loved Silje from Octavia Sperati. Glad she'll be getting more recognition now that she's with The Gathering.
ComaLies225 2 years ago 8
Me gusta mucho su voz pero desearía más fuerza y potencia en su voz, aun así suena a The Gathering pero extrañaré mucho a Anneke, su sonrisa, carisma, su mirada de demente tierna y por supuesto, su poderosa voz...
warpfaber 2 years ago 6
Wow I thought the gathering were doomed once Anneke left, but this is really impressive. Will definitely be pickin the new album up.
NateVoD 2 years ago 10
miss anneke :(
though, this is a good song...
baraba 2 years ago 27
son fan de esta banda desde hace 10 años ycom todos estamos acostumbrados a anneke pero esta mujer (silje) viene a proyectar a la banda a otros niveles tiene muy buena voz ademas es buena la rola y para los q le son fieles a anneke proximamente su primer material como solista habra que ver q tal le va
pollokingeud 2 years ago
I love the new album and the song! But the video is pretty random :p not that it really matters tho...
JegVilHaMelon 2 years ago 2
The Gathering an Elis are two bands with female vocals that found good replacements for their departed (or sadly deceased, for Elis) singers.
Unlike other bands we know (Nightwish, Tristania, etc)...
Silje really does not disappoint. She sings wonderfully. And she is only replacing one of the best female singers in the world...
kenparker 2 years ago 8
i think anette is a great replacement but i see you like copycats.
tangleduprecordings 2 years ago
soy fan de the gathering desde hace 10 años y estoy acostumbrado a ver a esta banda con anneke pero para ser sincero creo q la nueva voz proyectara mas a esta legendaria banda holandesa y a los fans de anneke no desesperais ya viene su material solista muy buena rola
pollokingeud 2 years ago
Amazing I love you Silje and The Gathering <3
moorebratz 2 years ago
When Nightwish kicked Tarja out, they replaced her with a hideous pop screamer: Crapnette
When Theatre Of Tragedy kicked Liv out, they replaced her with a mediocre copycat: Nell
When Vibeke leaved Tristania, they replaced her with a mistake of nature: Mariangela
When Anneke leaved, The Gathering replaced her with a wonderful singer. That's why I will always love The Gathering: they're not sell outs.
80XxbelialxX08 2 years ago 12
Een dijk van een nummer
jacco1234567 2 years ago
Me agrada, me agrada. A todos nos agrada ¿no?
LadyPudrete666 2 years ago
this band sounds good but anneke sounds better with within temptation id say
SoloDomoProductions 2 years ago
I love this song (it's the only one off the album I like though) and I love Silje.
Wish she'd still be with Octavia tbh.
Seraph1na 2 years ago
She reminds me to a angela bovio, the stream of passion's singer.....but this new singer is different!! the gathring is amazing!!!
retinueofmoons 2 years ago
muy bueno!!!!! excelente.
aguadellave 2 years ago
Amazing video :)
xDivinitysCreaturex 2 years ago
Amazing video.
xDivinitysCreaturex 2 years ago
I really like to imagine how this would sound with Anneke´s angel voice, but there is no point.
great song, fantastic band, I love it, Silje is great .
Viva The Gathering!!!!
tchachinafan 2 years ago
I'm with whoever said that, good as she is here, SIlje should be making more Octavia Sperati albums. Such a good band! That said, this is the first time I've cared about a new Gathering release in years, and I hope she helps draw the band back towards their heavy roots.
Bmf10382 2 years ago
Great album! Great song! Great singer!
:)
cinthiavila 2 years ago 3
Great album! Great song! Great singer!
:)
cinthiavila 2 years ago 2
i'm not too fond of the video, but the song is great! just like the rest of the new album.
nyghtfall7 2 years ago
Great video
oliveband 2 years ago
Her eyes are peculiar looking..
Surely this girl has some Asian in her bloodline. Her eyes are a dead give away, even with her eyes being blue and all. Pretty girl though, nice voice too
yagu98 2 years ago
Lovely video :) Silje looks and sounds beautiful ^^
eatallpiepods 2 years ago 3
the band is still brilliant, the new songs are fantastic. when a band loses a singer so charismatic as Anneke, it's kind of hard to come back with a new one as good as the previous. The Gathering did it. Silje is a fantastic singer, great technique and very emotional too.
Kontramanel 2 years ago 2
Yeah, requiem for Leaves. Anyway, Silje is amazing, great and only heir of Anneke
LasgalenOsten 2 years ago
nice video!!
lulu5278 2 years ago
I LOOVE THIS SONG TOO...
dulcetrivalista 2 years ago
yeahhhhh THE GATHERING RECARGADO!!!!!!!!
dulcetrivalista 2 years ago
GREAT vocal melody at 2:24-2:35
mikem1234 2 years ago
nize! :) I cant wait to see TG live again in Mexico!
babalucaz 2 years ago
Hey, I have a brilliant idea. Judge the song and the band by how they sound, not by how Anneke might have sounded
lordnizbit 2 years ago 112
Imo I like the music the Gathering are making now more than Anneke's music, and while she is an amazing singer, it doesn't make any of the other singers less good. I love the vocal melody in this song at 2:24 - 2:35
mikem1234 2 years ago
I am TOTALLY agree with you.........
finally someone said something interesting and intelligent...
boo170807 2 years ago 2
Muy bien dicho!
tobilander 2 years ago
i loved the video
stormrider3 2 years ago
This song is good. It fits the singer's voice beautifully.
About the whole Anneke v.s. Silje talk: Le roi est mort,...vive le roi!
lekorque 2 years ago
People should stop comparing Silje to Anneke. This is useless. Let's face the truth - Anneke is not in The Gathering anymore. And now TG started new age in their career - Silje age. And I'm very happy with that because she's an amazing singer and her voice perfectly fits in the music. And I still love Anneke and I think she's best female singer ever. That's really great that she has got great successor.
Karolcia1993 2 years ago 2
I like so much... excellent "The Gathering"
ozkrgrunge 2 years ago
I like so much... excellent "The Gathering"
ozkrgrunge 2 years ago
What is the fucking problem, she is an EXCELLent singer, yes she is not Anneke, i love Anneke, but she is not anymore get over, at least she sing pretty good, she is not Anette (nightwish) or even worst Mariangela (tristania)
boo170807 2 years ago 10
The problem is people can't accept change man. You're wasting your time trying to explain it, believe me, I've tried to. I love Anneke aswell, she was fantastic. I honestly thought no one could possibly replace her, but man the new vocalist is fantastic and people need to give credit where it's due! She did the unthinkable and replaced Anneke without ripping her off. She managed to make it her own, while still staying true to the classic Gathering formula. That deserves respect, in my opinion.
ShowNoMercy502 2 years ago
I love song!
So beautiful *.*
Barbara1519 2 years ago
no pues la ardilla de annete olson es pesima no comparen a silje con ella no sean malos pfffffffffffffff
aloneriz 2 years ago
I love the song, I love the video... The Gathering you're still the best!!!!
lejouretnuit 2 years ago 7
esta chido el video.........bien
THE GATHERING
aguademario 2 years ago 2
aaaa..c'mom u guys expect so much of the singer ¬¬...if u were any musical expert or understand something about vocals u would not act like that...unfortunatelly the gathering now is one "nightwish" when talking about vocalists ¬¬...patetic
sirks19 2 years ago
As a vocalist, I find I prefer Silje. I just love her tone so much more than Anneke's. Anneke is talented, but with Silje in the band now, I listen to them more. In the end, I find them to both be good. Honestly though, I think Silje should have been making more Octavia Sperati records. They're an ace metal band.
FloraKorkis 2 years ago
terrible video.... bad.....bad......bad
bad singer...
Aneeke is the best
Karloscoldplayer 2 years ago
Considering you couldn't even spell her name right, your opinion suddenly means nothing. Oh look at that. It never did in the first place.
ShowNoMercy502 2 years ago 5
the video is terrible, the editing is really bad and the shooting even worse.
tangleduprecordings 2 years ago
good song, but video is awful...
too long shots , too slow motion
the same structure of script: "Leaves", but there are no such mistakes.
I rather watch "Leaves" one more time than "All you are"
dyingmay 2 years ago 3
Great video!
ravenharlow 2 years ago
excelente! THE GATHERING...No esperaba menos, son los mejores, muy buen video
excellent! THE GATHERING...I did not expect less, they are the best, very good video
gatheringforever 2 years ago
Fantastic video!
mecgo83 2 years ago
Finally, a "kinda" decent TG vid :P
Silje looks great and this song is good. Funny when Hans drops the drumstick :D
pilorin 2 years ago
great video;)
Karolcia1993 2 years ago
Great video! Love it!
heksolson 2 years ago
i like a lot the gathering
darksnow666 2 years ago
I love band-playing parts!
anneke4ever 2 years ago
Déi real. So nice. This is TG.
weloestedeminas 2 years ago
Don't get why the hell The Gathering don't put a HD version, in divx or mkv on the internet ?!?!
Flash videos sucks!!!!
onesolo 2 years ago
Looooooooove that voice and looks!!
(:
DutchAmPsycho 2 years ago 2
Lovely!
9egomurder 2 years ago
love it!!!!
great video
tochirock 2 years ago
I love that 00:30 part. :)
Zaidini 2 years ago
SILJE SE VE LINDA EN ESA PARTE
aloneriz 2 years ago
Sounds very much like The Gathering we still love. I love it and I love Silje
ComaLies225 2 years ago 3
brilhant!
susumolko 2 years ago
very interesting guys!
LefterisDelirium 2 years ago
cOOLness!!!!!!
Faridee 2 years ago
Yay! :D
amillionfaces 2 years ago
Awesome!!!
Saludos desde Argentina!
yerman81 2 years ago
AT LAST!!!!!!!
CARIÑOS DESDE CHILE!
CamilaStar 2 years ago 2
VERY, VERY GOOD!!!!
rednoctifer 2 years ago 3
awesome!
mutismus 2 years ago
Superb nice Video!!:... :)
ulvergod 2 years ago
yay for more spinning trees! I'm glad the band is actually in the video : )
MooWithMetubes 2 years ago
it's like Leaves. I love it :D
Grettings from Chile, we are wating for you!
thequietxone 2 years ago
nice, nice!!
aguadegathering 2 years ago
congratulationssssssssssssss
aeverything 2 years ago
Fantastic video and song!!!!!!!!!
nocturnalconcerto89 2 years ago
as I expected from the best band =D
augustoliquid 2 years ago
Good job!
tdreamer25 2 years ago
Me gusto el video =D
GothicDream11 2 years ago
good song
mirokic 2 years ago
really nice video!!
i love the song!!!! <3
AnnaValo1 2 years ago
Great video for a great song!
Super!
FransTraas 2 years ago
Fantastic video... I love it
raimonds85 2 years ago
SUPER WONDERFUL!!!!!! I love it.
drummist100 2 years ago
Very good song, very good video. Bravo!
pantelis79 2 years ago
Cool ! I do love this song !
SupaCoco 2 years ago