The argument of libertarianism where it promotes to the extreme the right to liberty and the dismissal of the moral laws are wrong. If we as a society do not have rules and laws to live by, our world will be on a chaos. it is because of this rules, we have not have a chemical war and i hope that this continuo this way. because if we lead libertarianism to rule over us, who is to say what can or can not do in war.
In a global labor market, there is no question that coercion is at work to some extent. Third world markets are dictated by starvation, poverty, and inferior wage, safety, and environmental regulations. That is inherently problematic for any nation that prohibits involuntary servitude etc slavery aside. As well, profits are made possible through infrastructure, security, etc. that facilitate shipping, sale, and such. That stated, this series provides a very comprehensive view of libertarianism.
Try not to confuse rights with needs. A lot of people can not obtain there needs in this economy or economic model around the world.
Now the wants outweigh the needs of others because of compassion lacking in those that hoard money. Simple
The court made money free speech, poor people have no speech. While making money free speech they also inadvertently attached compassion to money. If compassion were free there would be no starving children. Why hoard compassion?
seriously... I would have slapped half of the idiots there. how can you say that it's okay to redistribute using force what I've earned with my hard work? Logic is not for women, sandwiches are!
Easter morning. 1 room. 20 hidden easter eggs. 5 kids. 2 are very competitive. parents say "go". the two competitive kids find 15 and 5 eggs. the 3 non-competitive kids get zero. there were enough for every one. the two competitive ones TOOK control of the event in the sense that they MADE it NECESSARY to compete 'AGAINST' the others to get any eggs. it doesn't seem right overall. the balance of the situation seems off. 'because they can' is the justification? regard for others?
the question of FULL DISCLOSURE comes ... in business dealings, in the free market, do people TRULY understand how some transactions might work against their future prosperity... & do corporations, & businesses, intend 2 silently expand holdings 2 such degree that can b said 2 harm those who do not want/need 2 feel compelled 2 conquest of holdings... in other words, just because i do not feel the need 2 constantly compete 2 buy more & more real-estate, should i eventually be deprived?
but what of the RIGHT of the 'lesser' to make their own CHOICES of their own FREE WILL so that they to may gain the experiences, good and bad, which would enable them to become refined beings -- to gain the enlightened state of the so-called 'greater' individuals? It is a theft of sorts to rob them of the experiences which might allow them to move towards 'enlightenment', and 'refinement of soul'. So it seems hypocritical, for the 'enlightened' to want to enforce 'enlightened behaviour'
The whole discussion is crocked from the very beginning. Not because of the starting assumption - people's fundamental liberty - and not because of the points following this assumption:
Nozick: What makes income distribution just? (12'47)
1. Justice in acquisition (first holdings)
2. Justice in Transfert (free market)
3. [take from the rich for the poor is unjust] (can't find the right moment with the slide shown)
Well the arguments of the "libertarians" in the video have been nuked 170 years ago in a piece of work by Pierre-Joseph Proudhon "What Is Property?" (see Wikipedia).
Proudhon agrees to all 3 points, but he states that if the first was taken seriously, there whould be no extraordinary rich people.
Everything that an individual builds by himself, alone in the complete processing, truly belongs to him.
Whenever the processing implies the help of somebody else (and nowadays it is true for nearly everythin), then the result no longer is only property but that the result is a poccession of the coworkers in with every one of them has a share part.
Thus the reward earned selling it has to be fairely shared among the coworkers.
In the end you could not have some individual making a huge fortune by selling expensive sport gears maked in Asia for extreme low costs, because the acqisition of the gears is not fair to the people building them for almost nothing.
The price paid, should be fairely shared between all people living for the creation of this products from owner of the company to the worker.
Because the owner without the workers never could sustain alone his company, therefore he is no longer the true owner.
The ownership has become diluted in all people involved in the company.
This is only a quick scratch of the resoning and there are objections to this view, and they are the same today as they were for 170 years, for those interested they are all met in the book...
The morality of stealing a loaf of bread: It isn't about whether or not the act of stealing a load of bread is moral, immoral, or justified. The real question is... Do I have a right to defend my property when you try to steal my loaf of bread. And the answer to that is yes. How do you have any legitimate claim on something I have made entirely myself. Should I give you a load of bread? Yes. Should I be forced at gunpoint against my will to give it to you? No.
Rights are not something that can be awarded or revoked through a voting process or the consent of the majority.
He's accepting the mythical social contract as fact. If a a violent gang illegitimately gained jurisdiction over a specific territory, of which your house resided, and they began to extort you for money on a yearly basis. Surely the mere fact that you are allowed to sell your house and move to a different plot of land outside of their jurisdiction does not make this right.
@dslkflkdsfskldfj How can a person declare his own set of rights while living in a society among other people? Can I decide one day that I have the "right" to free bread and thus I'm now justfied to have free bread at all bakeries? Just as you may ridicule and disrespect my idea of the right to free bread, others may disrespect your own set of supposed rights. Therefore, rights that aren't approved by society are meaningless.
@JJFZ3000 A possible hole in your argument is that this would then mean that China could vote for laws within the United States - because the Chinese people outnumber the people in the United States. Similarly, the principle would also allow for the people in a town to claim the moral right to vote for laws contrary to the greater state. Establishing the number of people at which democracy is no longer ridiculous is essentially arbitrary. Troubling indeed.
@JJFZ3000 Rights are merely universally preferable acts that can be reached a priori. You have no right to x if it infringes upon the rights of others. Thus your right to free bread could not be universally preferable.
life's not fair, get used to it - Bill Gates. True, its simply the reality. These students study at Harvard while other youngsters are making snickers. Some have perfect vision, I have glassed, some are born blind. There's no equal opportunities. Life shows us that you can win games even if you were dealt a bad hand.
Without justice, no farmer will farm. To the extent men are exploited by threat or force, they will seek to hide their talent, skills and capital. Societies grow poor when governments grow rich.
the rich have to adapt to this phrase "with great wealth, comes great responsibility"(i know its a ripoff from spider man lol) but its true the more wealth you acquire the more you are responsible for the economy wether it be inflation, rise in taxes, job losses, etc. you hold more responsibility to give back to society.
Nice discussions but even if they bring a lot of good arguments, they don't have/take the time to go deeper. This makes the whole thing looks black & white (without the necessary playground of tones to support each group of opinion). Is it good to tax the rich? (but.. wait!.. what kind of rich person?? how much do you tax it??) I mean, basicaly it would not be good to tax 99.9% as taxing 0,01% would be too much infime to support the idea of taxation. A no end debate if we only explore surface..
well, it is always just the majority rule. the poor are majority so taxation is right, the day rich will become majority taxation will be wrong. the christian were thrown to tigers in Rome because Romans were majority and their pleasure, ecstasy was right. the cabin boy was minority (he didn't agree to lottery)was eaten. in democracy the government seek to fulfill majority (here poor people) desires.
I believe libertarians are full of shit wen it comes to welfear.(welfear works better outside the us).If we all agree on a free market than we should take responsability for the negative side of it,poverty,just like we should take responsability for pollution.You should not have the option of escaping responsability,other than that i agree with the libertarian ideology.Speaking of liberty,what about the land you took away from native americans?We can all agree on a loving society i think.
DON'T READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT ON AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS.NOW YOU HAVE STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP THIS IS SCARY. PUT THIS ON AT LEATS 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES. WHEN YOU ARE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR LOVE OF YOUR LIFES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO CAUSE IT WORKS
41:50 I hate to say this but the Koch Brothers and others in the top 1% have used the openness of our society to convince a large number of people that taxation, ANY taxation, is wrong. This is briefly touched on, but Libertarianism is fundamentally at odds with Democracy because the idea of individual liberty taken to the extreme leads to such a degree of selfishness and a lack of altruism that it ultimately threatens the survival of all. Too much oxygen will kill you, liberty is the same way.
@uscdave1124 yes. and many libertarians become ancap, as they see the state as not being democratic and is instead a corrupt coercive force. You can vote on who stays in power with your money through buying products!
That's pretty much where things are going. Best thing to do to make a decent living is get a skill. Tech school will make you a ton more money than college.
American... Money is the way of life. Its a little bit like in india where certain people have NO chance since their birth and its justified with the deeds they commited in a former life.
Having no money, being a"looser"is the worst case in USA.
But this society should determine itself how it treats a poor mayority
Id be interested if the prof knows Marx as good as Locke and J.S.Mill
Oh...wait, lady you can kill someone if you want...but you also know that there will be a price to pay for that. THAT is self possesion...you can do ANYTHING you want regarldless of where, when or how you live.
my best friend's mom makes $67 every hour on the laptop. She has been fired for 5 months but last month her paycheck was $9022 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Here's the site MakeCash4. c o m
Well.. Still Had To Review When Still Young (Kindergarden) Then Crucially When Being Teenager Then Strictly Wiser To Maturity. Heartbreaker. Patience.
Harvard again? I mean still, cuz again would mean it was on the main page 2 months ago, and now again, but its still cuz its been 2-3 months and its still Harvard... Well atleast its another episode
In my country, we also have a somewhat social security in place. The well off don't worry much about it because they can afford to have that portion of income taken away for savings. I'm not rich but I happen to agree with this policy. However, the poor, and even some of my own peers, absolutely dislike it. To them it's depravation of earned income. Basically, there's no way government can keep everyone happy on every policy they make. I may agree with this policy but disagree on the next.
I like the idea of Libertarianism, but I'm not saying it's the best way to run things. If the world as it is is anything to go by, I think the fusion of all these ideas becomes the final product. Also, each individual theory provides the necessary checks to prevent extremism. The objections are there for a reason and building / compromising on those issues will certainly provide the correct answer and best result.
I've just started following this series and I thinks it's really great that Harvard puts this kind of stuff up.
I come from an Asian country, and yes we are democratic, but more than that, we live in a highly meritocratic society. Which really explains why you find many Asians working very hard at education. It's very much the culture in this part of our world. Frankly, I thinks it stinks that I have to live my whole life running on the tips of my toes and I'd much rather be somewhere else.
The three libertarians are, in order from left to right: an entitled slob, a smarmy wee tick and a frankly terrifying psycho-girl. Hell no, let the family starve!
I don't think students at Universities like Harvard are an more intellegent than any average person. Their biggest talent is being able to concetrate for very long periods of very boring material. Their reading comprehention is really good. I think smarts is also shown in people who can solve problems, like a good mechanic, and computer people. Some of the smartest people are able to think outside the box to solve problems.
Αfter a couple of videos, I still cannot believe that there are Harvard students with so shallow thoughts and such an incapacity to construct pure logical arguments in avoiding basic reasoning mistakes... The basis of the social contract- not even democracy!- is to cede a part of your personnal liberty for the benefits of living together with others, and thus yes people, the collective partially owns us! If you don't like it, you have the right on the free choice not to live in society!
it's the most effective site in the world to connect with, date and marry successful, beautiful people.-Meanwhile, . It's worthy a try. You do not have to be rich or famous. !
Everyone assumed going to Harvard will solve hunger, unemployment, getting rich and high level of status. It is presumed a ceasar's class of learning. Can this professor analyze a simple street protest called "Wall Street take-over" the practical way?
@mrfishsticklover: absolutely a myth. First and second generation immigrants in Asian families just study much harder than other people. They understand education is a way for better life. Jewish understands that as well.
@mrfishsticklover Maybe, but maybe it's just that education is held in high esteem in their counties and therefore they work harder than their American counter parts, just like Indians. The sad thing is that this is a famous American university yet there are almost no Americans attending. They should only allow people from the US to attend. Other countries have their own uniersities. Let their people study there.
@mjpitche: your suggestion is exactly the same as putting a trade barrier between countries. That's not how the world works. No country can be completely isolated. If you don't want foreign students in US schools, don't allow any immigrant. As a result of that, the aging American will lose their retirement and social security. US just doesn't have enough new born to support the people exiting labor force.
Only the insane have strength enough to prosper. Only those who propser truly judge what is sane. The victorious decide what justice is, which means justice is a concept built on insanity.
No se trata principalmente de distribuir la riqueza, va más allá de ser solidario. Se trata, según creo, de evitar el absolutismo en cuanto a poder de coerción, acumulado en una persona o grupo económico.
@BeepimajeepBeep That's pretty much where things are going. Best thing to do to make a decent living is get a skill. Tech school will make you a ton more money than college.
Please visit my channel for the unpopular truth about homosexuality.
A person does not need hatred or any kind of phobia in order to acknowledge important differences between heterosexual attraction / behavior / marriage / adoption and homosexual attraction / behavior / marriage / adoption. Even non-religious people know this.
Homosexual activists, with support from the media, have successfuly framed themselves as noble victims; it's an effective way to push a social agenda.
@orjanst1 I hope it's so .. as he concluded that they have the right to do it if they didn't harm anyone it wasn't even a matter of discussion or opening perspectives .
Estou fazendo essa dieta indicada por uma amiga já estou na terceira semana e consegui perder 9kg. O site dessa dieta para quem quiser: editoratmb(.)com/emagrecer/
That's because we are not just individuals, we form groups. For the group to be happy,it can't just be one happy rich guy (who decide for the others, who has everything he wants) and the other are poor and unhappy.
Harvard is cool:-p
pickuptruck1212 2 days ago
heres a quote ... if u do not have iconomic rights u can not excersise ur other rights !!!
onxiaftw 2 days ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
Comment removed
onxiaftw 2 days ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
libertariabism = amercan constitution ... vote for RonPaul
onxiaftw 2 days ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
This has been flagged as spam show
The argument of libertarianism where it promotes to the extreme the right to liberty and the dismissal of the moral laws are wrong. If we as a society do not have rules and laws to live by, our world will be on a chaos. it is because of this rules, we have not have a chemical war and i hope that this continuo this way. because if we lead libertarianism to rule over us, who is to say what can or can not do in war.
snowboyperu 3 days ago
Comment removed
snowboyperu 3 days ago
Julie completely backed-out on her point. If you're going to be stupidly poignant and insensitive, at least be consistently stupid.
"Oh no, he mentioned Katrina! I have to fold immediately"
Tordah26 3 days ago
I imagine the students arguing for libertarianism got into Harvard almost completely because of luck...
guildmastersan 1 week ago
@guildmastersan How do you figure?
chauvinistpig42 5 days ago
@guildmastersan And a little help from mommy and daddy, ironically enough.
Tordah26 3 days ago
Comment removed
guildmastersan 1 week ago
lot of asianss :p
GameDoctor21 1 week ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
In a global labor market, there is no question that coercion is at work to some extent. Third world markets are dictated by starvation, poverty, and inferior wage, safety, and environmental regulations. That is inherently problematic for any nation that prohibits involuntary servitude etc slavery aside. As well, profits are made possible through infrastructure, security, etc. that facilitate shipping, sale, and such. That stated, this series provides a very comprehensive view of libertarianism.
BillofRightsBrutus 1 week ago
Comment removed
ChristopheCocq 2 weeks ago in playlist eDUCATION
wow he didnt use a telapromter
twocoats100 2 weeks ago
Try not to confuse rights with needs. A lot of people can not obtain there needs in this economy or economic model around the world.
Now the wants outweigh the needs of others because of compassion lacking in those that hoard money. Simple
The court made money free speech, poor people have no speech. While making money free speech they also inadvertently attached compassion to money. If compassion were free there would be no starving children. Why hoard compassion?
1purelight 2 weeks ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
It looks really boring there.
472Colin 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
facebook.com/Connecting.People.Worldwide
CkroegerTV 2 weeks ago
seriously... I would have slapped half of the idiots there. how can you say that it's okay to redistribute using force what I've earned with my hard work? Logic is not for women, sandwiches are!
MrDemonshalo 3 weeks ago
Easter morning. 1 room. 20 hidden easter eggs. 5 kids. 2 are very competitive. parents say "go". the two competitive kids find 15 and 5 eggs. the 3 non-competitive kids get zero. there were enough for every one. the two competitive ones TOOK control of the event in the sense that they MADE it NECESSARY to compete 'AGAINST' the others to get any eggs. it doesn't seem right overall. the balance of the situation seems off. 'because they can' is the justification? regard for others?
etyrnal 3 weeks ago
the question of FULL DISCLOSURE comes ... in business dealings, in the free market, do people TRULY understand how some transactions might work against their future prosperity... & do corporations, & businesses, intend 2 silently expand holdings 2 such degree that can b said 2 harm those who do not want/need 2 feel compelled 2 conquest of holdings... in other words, just because i do not feel the need 2 constantly compete 2 buy more & more real-estate, should i eventually be deprived?
etyrnal 3 weeks ago
realizing that we are all 'one' helps clarify a number of these ideas...
etyrnal 3 weeks ago
but what of the RIGHT of the 'lesser' to make their own CHOICES of their own FREE WILL so that they to may gain the experiences, good and bad, which would enable them to become refined beings -- to gain the enlightened state of the so-called 'greater' individuals? It is a theft of sorts to rob them of the experiences which might allow them to move towards 'enlightenment', and 'refinement of soul'. So it seems hypocritical, for the 'enlightened' to want to enforce 'enlightened behaviour'
etyrnal 3 weeks ago
Oh man does Julia suck at arguing... Please just let John "the Trailer-Voice" Libertarianson talk.
Airplay89 3 weeks ago
Julia is a moron. She's damaging the other 2 guys arguments every time she speaks.
GrittyMcCheese 3 weeks ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
sorry character limitation...
you have to read from the first post form the bottom (6 posts)
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
The whole discussion is crocked from the very beginning. Not because of the starting assumption - people's fundamental liberty - and not because of the points following this assumption:
Nozick: What makes income distribution just? (12'47)
1. Justice in acquisition (first holdings)
2. Justice in Transfert (free market)
3. [take from the rich for the poor is unjust] (can't find the right moment with the slide shown)
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
@luscusredbeard (fu.... character limitation)
The whole distorsion of the following discution about taxation is resulting from the poor defined first point "justice in acquisition".
A majority of people feels that somehow taking from the rich to help the poor is more moral than let them starve to death.
Somehow it is not right that a minority of people can gather extraordinery wealth while others dispair.
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
Well the arguments of the "libertarians" in the video have been nuked 170 years ago in a piece of work by Pierre-Joseph Proudhon "What Is Property?" (see Wikipedia).
Proudhon agrees to all 3 points, but he states that if the first was taken seriously, there whould be no extraordinary rich people.
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
Everything that an individual builds by himself, alone in the complete processing, truly belongs to him.
Whenever the processing implies the help of somebody else (and nowadays it is true for nearly everythin), then the result no longer is only property but that the result is a poccession of the coworkers in with every one of them has a share part.
Thus the reward earned selling it has to be fairely shared among the coworkers.
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
In the end you could not have some individual making a huge fortune by selling expensive sport gears maked in Asia for extreme low costs, because the acqisition of the gears is not fair to the people building them for almost nothing.
The price paid, should be fairely shared between all people living for the creation of this products from owner of the company to the worker.
Because the owner without the workers never could sustain alone his company, therefore he is no longer the true owner.
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
The ownership has become diluted in all people involved in the company.
This is only a quick scratch of the resoning and there are objections to this view, and they are the same today as they were for 170 years, for those interested they are all met in the book...
luscusredbeard 3 weeks ago
..Mr. Burns?
rustman888 3 weeks ago
The girl at 20:50 is weird....
lDiRTyxlHouSe 1 month ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
The morality of stealing a loaf of bread: It isn't about whether or not the act of stealing a load of bread is moral, immoral, or justified. The real question is... Do I have a right to defend my property when you try to steal my loaf of bread. And the answer to that is yes. How do you have any legitimate claim on something I have made entirely myself. Should I give you a load of bread? Yes. Should I be forced at gunpoint against my will to give it to you? No.
dslkflkdsfskldfj 1 month ago
Rights are not something that can be awarded or revoked through a voting process or the consent of the majority.
He's accepting the mythical social contract as fact. If a a violent gang illegitimately gained jurisdiction over a specific territory, of which your house resided, and they began to extort you for money on a yearly basis. Surely the mere fact that you are allowed to sell your house and move to a different plot of land outside of their jurisdiction does not make this right.
dslkflkdsfskldfj 1 month ago
@dslkflkdsfskldfj How can a person declare his own set of rights while living in a society among other people? Can I decide one day that I have the "right" to free bread and thus I'm now justfied to have free bread at all bakeries? Just as you may ridicule and disrespect my idea of the right to free bread, others may disrespect your own set of supposed rights. Therefore, rights that aren't approved by society are meaningless.
JJFZ3000 2 weeks ago
@JJFZ3000 A possible hole in your argument is that this would then mean that China could vote for laws within the United States - because the Chinese people outnumber the people in the United States. Similarly, the principle would also allow for the people in a town to claim the moral right to vote for laws contrary to the greater state. Establishing the number of people at which democracy is no longer ridiculous is essentially arbitrary. Troubling indeed.
clemonsx90 1 week ago
@JJFZ3000 Rights are merely universally preferable acts that can be reached a priori. You have no right to x if it infringes upon the rights of others. Thus your right to free bread could not be universally preferable.
dslkflkdsfskldfj 1 week ago
life's not fair, get used to it - Bill Gates. True, its simply the reality. These students study at Harvard while other youngsters are making snickers. Some have perfect vision, I have glassed, some are born blind. There's no equal opportunities. Life shows us that you can win games even if you were dealt a bad hand.
negochristian1 1 month ago
i really dont like any of those "libertarian team" guys
cynicshminic 1 month ago
@cynicshminic Why? You like when Government tells you what to do? Gov "Suck mah dick". You : "YES"
Trifonsdude 1 month ago
carnivores are inherently injust to the libertarian philosophy I suppose lol
noobler9 1 month ago
need is one thing an dessert is another.
workforcetrust 1 month ago
Without justice, no farmer will farm. To the extent men are exploited by threat or force, they will seek to hide their talent, skills and capital. Societies grow poor when governments grow rich.
MindThief2012 1 month ago
Damn that girl in the orange Spooky shirt is preeeeeeetyyyyyyy!
Nexgcs 1 month ago
Man this is the place I belong, what am I doing at home???
HafizParacha 1 month ago
Pachulya is not song only, but is leaning.
reba290 1 month ago
the rich have to adapt to this phrase "with great wealth, comes great responsibility"(i know its a ripoff from spider man lol) but its true the more wealth you acquire the more you are responsible for the economy wether it be inflation, rise in taxes, job losses, etc. you hold more responsibility to give back to society.
MXNR16 1 month ago
Nice discussions but even if they bring a lot of good arguments, they don't have/take the time to go deeper. This makes the whole thing looks black & white (without the necessary playground of tones to support each group of opinion). Is it good to tax the rich? (but.. wait!.. what kind of rich person?? how much do you tax it??) I mean, basicaly it would not be good to tax 99.9% as taxing 0,01% would be too much infime to support the idea of taxation. A no end debate if we only explore surface..
ledemiurge 1 month ago
anyone have any good resources on theories of justice ? I have an exam on monday the 12/12/11 !!
mootski 1 month ago
I believe that democracy is the best form of government present, but it is quite bad form of government .
qaz010wsx 1 month ago
@qaz010wsx how do you think goverment should be structured?
FJstudios1000 1 month ago
well, it is always just the majority rule. the poor are majority so taxation is right, the day rich will become majority taxation will be wrong. the christian were thrown to tigers in Rome because Romans were majority and their pleasure, ecstasy was right. the cabin boy was minority (he didn't agree to lottery)was eaten. in democracy the government seek to fulfill majority (here poor people) desires.
qaz010wsx 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I believe libertarians are full of shit wen it comes to welfear.(welfear works better outside the us).If we all agree on a free market than we should take responsability for the negative side of it,poverty,just like we should take responsability for pollution.You should not have the option of escaping responsability,other than that i agree with the libertarian ideology.Speaking of liberty,what about the land you took away from native americans?We can all agree on a loving society i think.
affilinet 1 month ago
Co ja pacze ?
Viiano 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DON'T READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT ON AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS.NOW YOU HAVE STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP THIS IS SCARY. PUT THIS ON AT LEATS 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES. WHEN YOU ARE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR LOVE OF YOUR LIFES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO CAUSE IT WORKS
sjconker64 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
↓ Klick for some nice pics!
YourCyberEva 2 months ago
Michael Sandel has the voice of Bob Barker. and even looks like he could be on the price is right when he holds the mic to the students.
bobbydigital85 2 months ago 2
LOL GOLDMAN SACHS FOUNDATION, FRIEDMAN... ALL JEWS. HARVARD = JEWISH PIT
ThiefLeet 2 months ago
why are the old videos being brought back? wtf?
dielawnz 2 months ago
awesome argument is awesome
MrShuxin 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
how is freedom being placed over the needs of others?
MrOnkelseoserbe 2 months ago
41:50 I hate to say this but the Koch Brothers and others in the top 1% have used the openness of our society to convince a large number of people that taxation, ANY taxation, is wrong. This is briefly touched on, but Libertarianism is fundamentally at odds with Democracy because the idea of individual liberty taken to the extreme leads to such a degree of selfishness and a lack of altruism that it ultimately threatens the survival of all. Too much oxygen will kill you, liberty is the same way.
uscdave1124 2 months ago in playlist Justice: Whats The Right Thing To Do
@uscdave1124 yes. and many libertarians become ancap, as they see the state as not being democratic and is instead a corrupt coercive force. You can vote on who stays in power with your money through buying products!
Thentox 1 month ago
Comment removed
uscdave1124 2 months ago in playlist Justice: Whats The Right Thing To Do
I have seen this video therefore I can now write that I went to Harvard on my CV.
Mike39244 2 months ago 14
18:30 nice Pokemon t-shirt man! :D
indraoldskool 2 months ago
flip flop @49:30 :D
erizzaaaaa 2 months ago
after a long watch
Tax is not thievery, consider it as security money, ransom, tribute.
if there is no tax, there is no salary for govt,
if there is no govt it will be anarchy, and people like Bill Gates will never existed
MrRichiarditya 2 months ago
Robin Hood must be Libertarian's Nemesis.
MrRichiarditya 2 months ago
hm komme aus deutschland
KrisManybo539 2 months ago
Damn I tought it was a Justice music vid.
-.-"
rikicopini1 2 months ago 2
@rikicopini1 This is a higher pleasure ;)
FrankiePoker 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That's pretty much where things are going. Best thing to do to make a decent living is get a skill. Tech school will make you a ton more money than college.
rshanks32 2 months ago
naa ich hab was unanständiges entdeckt
CindaNadabe605 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello Guys ..........
Johny my name plz ..
search on youtube ..... Guys Amazing Filipino
this is what his tittle of the video she ::::::
(Filipino Amazing human beatbox)
thank u.. .>_____________<.
RayWilliamJohnson40 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello Guys ..........
Johny my name plz ..
search on youtube ..... Guys Amazing Filipino
this is what his tittle of the video she ::::::
(Filipino Amazing human beatbox)
thank u.. .>_____________<....
RayWilliamJohnson40 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello Guys ..........
Johny my name plz ..
search on youtube ..... Guys Amazing Filipino
this is what his tittle of the video she ::::::
(Filipino Amazing human beatbox)
thank u.. .>_____________<
RayWilliamJohnson40 2 months ago
no money,no friends
philippinesfans 2 months ago
American... Money is the way of life. Its a little bit like in india where certain people have NO chance since their birth and its justified with the deeds they commited in a former life.
Having no money, being a"looser"is the worst case in USA.
But this society should determine itself how it treats a poor mayority
Id be interested if the prof knows Marx as good as Locke and J.S.Mill
ruedigergeppert 2 months ago
@ruedigergeppert it's not quite like that in India :)
guitarsly111 2 months ago
Oh...wait, lady you can kill someone if you want...but you also know that there will be a price to pay for that. THAT is self possesion...you can do ANYTHING you want regarldless of where, when or how you live.
thehornypuppy 2 months ago
Welcome back to the front page HARVARD!!
47param 2 months ago
wow i hope this old cunt dies.
UrMumsVagina 2 months ago
@UrMumsVagina Why?
ThobyThomas 2 months ago
I think the Skateboard kid proved that you don't need brains but money to get into Harvard. He must of taking the same root as Dubya, lol.
Humanrightsforall1 2 months ago
lol stoning bitch at 17:14!
stephenlikespork 2 months ago
@stephenlikespork AHAHHAHAHA
UrMumsVagina 2 months ago
Comment removed
HolyShizzle 2 months ago
Comment removed
HolyShizzle 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pessoal dêem uma olhada nessa banda..... musica muito boa...
Equação Zero - Pássaro solitário
youtube.com/watch?v=4ZqZJksaSfU
Quem gostar da um joinha ai..... façam os seus comentários, adicionem em favoritos e nos ajudem a divulgar....
obrigado..........
geversonurbano 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my best friend's mom makes $67 every hour on the laptop. She has been fired for 5 months but last month her paycheck was $9022 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Here's the site MakeCash4. c o m
HolmesEdith90 2 months ago
mooie
erka473 2 months ago
not racist or anything... but all i see are asians
DanniDyr 2 months ago
@DanniDyr u buggin theres mad white people in that room
2hafstylezk 2 months ago
17/11/11/
assisacpel 2 months ago
This harvard stuff is run by Satan
dtbaz821 2 months ago
dammm this is where I belong... Awesome video
ThobyThomas 2 months ago 42
Well.. Still Had To Review When Still Young (Kindergarden) Then Crucially When Being Teenager Then Strictly Wiser To Maturity. Heartbreaker. Patience.
WeeWooYou 2 months ago
Harvard again? I mean still, cuz again would mean it was on the main page 2 months ago, and now again, but its still cuz its been 2-3 months and its still Harvard... Well atleast its another episode
DesertStateNevada 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
destino
youtube.com/watch?v=clUv8_947LY
jonatas80802 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pessoal dêem uma olhada nessa banda..... musica muito boa...
Equação Zero - Pássaro solitário
/watch?v=4ZqZJksaSfU
Quem gostar da um joinha ai..... façam os seus comentários, adicionem em favoritos e nos ajudem a divulgar....
obrigado..........
geversonurbano 2 months ago
Am I the only one that thinks the students look a bit derpy?
SirLotalawlingenMacT 2 months ago
professor is speaking on and on so he gets tired i can say he should take rest after this.
04thekumar 2 months ago
In my country, we also have a somewhat social security in place. The well off don't worry much about it because they can afford to have that portion of income taken away for savings. I'm not rich but I happen to agree with this policy. However, the poor, and even some of my own peers, absolutely dislike it. To them it's depravation of earned income. Basically, there's no way government can keep everyone happy on every policy they make. I may agree with this policy but disagree on the next.
SGtwelfmunkis 2 months ago
I like the idea of Libertarianism, but I'm not saying it's the best way to run things. If the world as it is is anything to go by, I think the fusion of all these ideas becomes the final product. Also, each individual theory provides the necessary checks to prevent extremism. The objections are there for a reason and building / compromising on those issues will certainly provide the correct answer and best result.
SGtwelfmunkis 2 months ago
I've just started following this series and I thinks it's really great that Harvard puts this kind of stuff up.
I come from an Asian country, and yes we are democratic, but more than that, we live in a highly meritocratic society. Which really explains why you find many Asians working very hard at education. It's very much the culture in this part of our world. Frankly, I thinks it stinks that I have to live my whole life running on the tips of my toes and I'd much rather be somewhere else.
SGtwelfmunkis 2 months ago
The three libertarians are, in order from left to right: an entitled slob, a smarmy wee tick and a frankly terrifying psycho-girl. Hell no, let the family starve!
danmcdaid 2 months ago in playlist Justice with Michael Sandel
@danmcdaid To degrade the speakers is an argumental falacy. I think libertarianism is wrong but its better if you give fair arguments against it
conchamolusco 2 months ago
@conchamolusco You're quite right, I was just being naughty.
I do genuinely find them a bit scary/horrible though.
danmcdaid 2 months ago
@danmcdaid Haha, I really do too
conchamolusco 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pessoal dêem uma olhada nessa banda..... musica muito boa...
Equação Zero - Pássaro solitário
/watch?v=4ZqZJksaSfU
Quem gostar da um joinha ai..... façam os seus comentários, adicionem em favoritos e nos ajudem a divulgar....
obrigado..........
geversonurbano 2 months ago
I don't think students at Universities like Harvard are an more intellegent than any average person. Their biggest talent is being able to concetrate for very long periods of very boring material. Their reading comprehention is really good. I think smarts is also shown in people who can solve problems, like a good mechanic, and computer people. Some of the smartest people are able to think outside the box to solve problems.
mjpitche 2 months ago
@mjpitche maybe because money gets you into harvard more than smarts do ex. tray banks went to this school
englandcolors 2 months ago
Αfter a couple of videos, I still cannot believe that there are Harvard students with so shallow thoughts and such an incapacity to construct pure logical arguments in avoiding basic reasoning mistakes... The basis of the social contract- not even democracy!- is to cede a part of your personnal liberty for the benefits of living together with others, and thus yes people, the collective partially owns us! If you don't like it, you have the right on the free choice not to live in society!
AetiusMerlin 2 months ago
@AetiusMerlin Victoria, I think, has cought the better idea of the case... :)
AetiusMerlin 2 months ago
why is this still on the front page?
TheSherwin2261 2 months ago
+1
lenialyubimov 2 months ago
I only intended to watch like... 2-5 minutes of the video... I ended up watching the whole thing.
WEShamanPower 2 months ago
This isn't teaching, it's right-wing indoctrination under the guise of philosophy.
VLGEMProust 2 months ago
Fact: usually rich people don't earn their money fairly.Bill Gate doesn't.
FeelFree3 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pessoal dêem uma olhada nessa banda..... musica muito boa...
Equação Zero - Pássaro solitário
/watch?v=4ZqZJksaSfU
Quem gostar da um joinha ai..... façam os seus comentários, adicionem em favoritos e nos ajudem a divulgar....
obrigado..........
geversonurbano 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
visit
/watch?v=f1QThKhRGuI
and you can download full
version softwares for FREE
and at full Speed at MEDIAFIRE
links
supergamerz11 2 months ago
lol this school looks asian
Tdotbwoy 2 months ago in playlist Tdotbwoy's favorites
Is it weird that im 15 and ENJOY watching these?
I believe it is
MrSpeartron 2 months ago 2
@MrSpeartron
It's not weird at all. Just means that you're not an idiot.
ChainsawVsGod 2 months ago
@MrSpeartron It is, you're an idiot.
danne696 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GALERA DA UMA OLHADA EM ( APAIXONADA SIM TABACUDA NÃO )
NO YOUTUBE
juliana86319 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pessoal dêem uma olhada nessa banda..... musica muito boa...
Equação Zero - Pássaro solitário
/watch?v=4ZqZJksaSfU
Quem gostar da um joinha ai..... façam os seus comentários, adicionem em favoritos e nos ajudem a divulgar....
obrigado..........
geversonurbano 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I m a beautiful model, recently i find a good site and just wanna make more friends,so if you are interested ,maybe you can hit me up on
-----ŔichFriends.òrg ----Sunrise555 there... thanks !
it's the most effective site in the world to connect with, date and marry successful, beautiful people.-Meanwhile, . It's worthy a try. You do not have to be rich or famous. !
----
sexysingle11 2 months ago
Everyone assumed going to Harvard will solve hunger, unemployment, getting rich and high level of status. It is presumed a ceasar's class of learning. Can this professor analyze a simple street protest called "Wall Street take-over" the practical way?
cass2chk 2 months ago
This remain why I don't go to church..
TheSunshine20021 2 months ago
when the guy says "gays and lesbians" at 9:25
the no-souled ginger sitting in the front row puts his head down in shame
i wonder why?
qualy55 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SorryNoCommentHere 2 months ago
I thought it was Harvard. Is it an Asian division of Harvard or an Asian school?
mjpitche 2 months ago
@mjpitche asian people are smart.
mrfishsticklover 2 months ago
@mrfishsticklover: absolutely a myth. First and second generation immigrants in Asian families just study much harder than other people. They understand education is a way for better life. Jewish understands that as well.
jimfee42 2 months ago
@mrfishsticklover Maybe, but maybe it's just that education is held in high esteem in their counties and therefore they work harder than their American counter parts, just like Indians. The sad thing is that this is a famous American university yet there are almost no Americans attending. They should only allow people from the US to attend. Other countries have their own uniersities. Let their people study there.
mjpitche 2 months ago
@mjpitche: your suggestion is exactly the same as putting a trade barrier between countries. That's not how the world works. No country can be completely isolated. If you don't want foreign students in US schools, don't allow any immigrant. As a result of that, the aging American will lose their retirement and social security. US just doesn't have enough new born to support the people exiting labor force.
jimfee42 2 months ago
SorryNoCommentHere 2 months ago
The libertarians are so retarded
tyfairhead 2 months ago
yummy educcative o.o :B <3
valentinaknows 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GALERA DA UMA OLHADA EM ( APAIXONADA SIM TABACUDA NÃO )
NO YOUTUBE
juliana86319 2 months ago
вы все гавно
Nutryful 2 months ago
Only the insane have strength enough to prosper. Only those who propser truly judge what is sane. The victorious decide what justice is, which means justice is a concept built on insanity.
K4inan 2 months ago
@K4inan nice one thrasymachus
Metamorphisize 2 months ago
@Metamorphisize Why would you call me thrasymachus
K4inan 2 months ago
Love tutorials on all subjects, good to learn on the go especially on the train!!!
jusdathang 2 months ago
SINCE WEN was dis in CHINA
KurtunityChannel 2 months ago
Hey guys. Just keep those alimony checks coming in. We Feminist's have a business to run.
readyourmind92 2 months ago
/watch?v=HDxG1WSk_40
paulyd38352 2 months ago
No se trata principalmente de distribuir la riqueza, va más allá de ser solidario. Se trata, según creo, de evitar el absolutismo en cuanto a poder de coerción, acumulado en una persona o grupo económico.
walterbonny 2 months ago
Comment removed
deuteightthree 2 months ago in playlist deuteightthree's favorites
This has been flagged as spam show
Dada life- Happy Violence (Vocal dub mix) Exclusive!!!
/watch?v=OIdKq9tFjC4
/watch?v=OIdKq9tFjC4
/watch?v=OIdKq9tFjC4
ELTONPAES 2 months ago
'' Free to choose '' So we are free to choose that this must go off the homepage of youtube?
iJordiii 2 months ago
@iJordiii You're free to choose to either click on the video or to ignore it.
PerfectRock007 2 months ago
How is this going to help anyone get a fucking job? Might as well have all these idiots working at mcdonalds to be a productive part of society,
BeepimajeepBeep 2 months ago
@BeepimajeepBeep That's pretty much where things are going. Best thing to do to make a decent living is get a skill. Tech school will make you a ton more money than college.
mjpitche 2 months ago
wtf the man has a pokemon shirt lmfao 18:50
coolmon99 2 months ago 10
@coolmon99 pokemon lol.
BeepimajeepBeep 2 months ago
@coolmon99 College students can be pokemon fans too! :D
*is in college and LOVES pokemon*
SpencerJonath 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GTA V first trailer
/watch?v=v_NEELIYgHM
Serverownia 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please visit my channel for the unpopular truth about homosexuality.
A person does not need hatred or any kind of phobia in order to acknowledge important differences between heterosexual attraction / behavior / marriage / adoption and homosexual attraction / behavior / marriage / adoption. Even non-religious people know this.
Homosexual activists, with support from the media, have successfuly framed themselves as noble victims; it's an effective way to push a social agenda.
lightandbeautiful 2 months ago
Lol 80% are Asians. We should learn from them.
Anyway, great and interesting speech.
myAKQJ10 3 months ago
37:49 student sleeping on the background! FAIL
ivanovish90 3 months ago 40
@ivanovish90 Wat? it took him 37 minutes!!?? -took me about 3!!!
bigrobnz 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Galera da uma olhada no meu trabalho
/watch?v=ch9QMlwfWUI
Ou
CLIKA NO MEU NOME E SE ESCREVAM
PancadaoSPL 3 months ago
so you pay all these £ pounds to learn that fagats have the right to deform societies under this liberation allegations ... u wasted my time .
omer88f 3 months ago
@omer88f Why the harsh language? It is only a mental exercise. Quite basic even.
orjanst1 2 months ago
@orjanst1 I hope it's so .. as he concluded that they have the right to do it if they didn't harm anyone it wasn't even a matter of discussion or opening perspectives .
omer88f 2 months ago
maybe taxation is equivalent to forced labor but it is the intrinsic intention behind the act that separates them from being the absolute same
XtraXtraodinaire 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Estou fazendo essa dieta indicada por uma amiga já estou na terceira semana e consegui perder 9kg. O site dessa dieta para quem quiser: editoratmb(.)com/emagrecer/
FlaviaCarvalhoBr 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pessoal dêem uma olhada nessa banda..... musica muito boa...
Equação Zero - Pássaro solitário
/watch?v=4ZqZJksaSfU
Quem gostar da um joinha ai..... façam os seus comentários, adicionem em favoritos e nos ajudem a divulgar....
obrigado..........
geversonurbano 3 months ago
That's because we are not just individuals, we form groups. For the group to be happy,it can't just be one happy rich guy (who decide for the others, who has everything he wants) and the other are poor and unhappy.
roxinouchet 3 months ago