Response hanafi fiqh channel Womens prayer according to Quran and Sunnah

[isaidthisok]

Jazakhallah khair brother for this video. I am fortunate enough to be born a Muslim however having a family following hanafi Madhab and sadly Barelwi forefathers I am upset when I am criticised about aspects like namaz, being a woman. I always found is discriminatory that a women's namaz was treated differently. I have now began praying correctly, but I like to believe my previous prayers&that of the females in my family is also accepted. Inshallah.

[LifewithAllah]

@isaidthisok

I am re editing this video and adding alot more information into it sister. InshaAllah i will be releasing the video by the end of this week and u can learn alot from that video.

[elve2]

I also want to point thet so called brothers calling Hanafi followers "hanafi folks" is quite insulting, muslims are supposed to adrees other muslims as "brothers", and not "folks".

[LifewithAllah]

@elve2

You called us "So called brothers" and in the same sentence u said we should address each other as brothers. Is this Justice my brother? Think over what u said. No one is greater than Rasool Allah pbuh. If u reject the Sunnah due to blind following than re consider ur emaan.

[elve2]

SubhanALLAH nowadays everyone is a Mujtahid. Naudhubillah.

Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) was a Tabi'een,, therefore he was amongst the three generations of the best people.Do you think you know better than him?No you don't, as none of you is a Mujtahid, and none of you are Salaf Salih, whereas he was one of them.

You should pay respect to this great muslim scholar.That's one of the teachings of Islam:respect the teachers and the learned ones.

[LifewithAllah]

@elve2

MashAllah, the only arguement people pass on mostly is "do u know more than imam abu hanifa? are u mujtahid?" i mean... Subhan Allah how we ignore the sunnah due to some 1's greatness...? this is destruction and this is what leads to rejection of Quran and Sunnah just like hanafi fiqh channel have Done. No Deobandi on earth can prove the complete hanafi way of praying from Authentic Chain right upto imam abu hanifa or from Quran and sunnah.

[LifewithAllah]

@elve2

you are saying that none of us is mujtahid.... my brother.. use some common sense for the sake of Allah... I only presented Top Scholarly works of Scholars and not "MY IJTIHAD and. Doing some 1's islaah does not require "deobandi" IJTIHAD. For the sake of Allah dont come up with the lame deobandi arguements again. Imam Abu Hanifa was not a tabee. youtube.com/watch?v=ECr7I_zxG3­w

[LifewithAllah]

@elve2

thirdly, why do u think that by "disagreeing" with hanafi fiqh is disrespect to Imam Abu hanifa? Which Deen teaches you this brother?? Wallahi Billahi none is greater in human beings to Mohammad Sal Allahu aley$hi wasallam and i advise that u dont disrespect Mohammad Sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam by disagreeing with his sunnah and agreeing with the unproven way of Salah attributed to Imam Abu hanifa.

[Habz170productions]

@lifewithAllah

asalam alayikum were can i watch the full video that is played at 6:26

jazakallah khair

[LifewithAllah]

@Habz170productions

walykum Assalaam, the link is given in the description or you can watch it on Khalifahklothing channel, here is the link

youtube.com/watch?v=WKblG-Zoag­k&hd=1

[LifewithAllah]

@konquest1453

Wa Iyyak, Its the same in my country brother.The Hanafi isnt really a hanafi any more.. He is Sufi and One Basic Reason that i know is that these Sufis dont follow the Aqeedah of Imam Abu Hanifa (rah). They just follow Imam Abu Hanifa (rah) in the issues of Masaayil/Fiqh and NOT in Aqeedah. They written this openly in their books and the majority of the innocent people are unaware of this.

[LifewithAllah]

@konquest1453

Ameen, May Allah accept these works and efforts from us and you, ameen. My brothers its very important that we gain knowledge of Quran and Sunnah from top scholars that are aware of the modern day hanafis. im here insha Allah and u can ask for any assistance or question Insha Allah. There is a lot more to come and insha Allah many things left to be responded and im just one person doing this with the assistance of my few friends and the help of Almighty Allah. Watch the playlist.

[SmilingMuslimahs]

MashaAllah amazing video, JazakAllah khair beother and may Allah reard you for your hard work. We needed a video like this.

[LifewithAllah]

@SmilingMuslimahs

wa iyyak. You can also read the article from our website. I have given the link in the description of this video. Insha Allah u will see more Proper responses with proof insha Allah.

[seekyourdestiny]

I can't imagine the time you must have taken to go through the books, especially when they're not even available online. Allah bless you endlessly akhi, for the sincere and noble efforts to distinguish Islam from innovation.

I don't even know how to access these books. That's such a big hindrance, hanafi folks give references of books which aren't even easily accessible.

They hardly ever quote Bukhari or Muslim. If they quote the other 4 books, they'd never mention the strength of the Hadith.

[LifewithAllah]

@seekyourdestiny

Akhi the biggest issue and probably the only issue is that the scholars have done tremendous work in urdu and they have responded with mouth shutting answers but all is in urdu. We have to translate all these works one by one and i have asked many scholars to please put their efforts in the english language as well. Insha Allah u will see more responses in proper videos of scholars of the Ahlul hadeeth scholars. Insha Allah.

[malchoudhury786]

whoever tried to mess up hanafee way of salah,is not hanafee ,ex hanafaee or salafee.

secondly, Molana abdurraheem saheb has already replied to ur objections and misunderstandings.the only thing u shudve done is that,erase all garbage u put up and leave the beautiful nasheed on .:)))ur becoming influenced by fake ahle hadith?all 4 schools hv been accepted by ummah.u are not better than them in any way.so stop causing fitnah.u pray how u know and leave others alone.

[LifewithAllah]

@malchoudhury786

first of all shame on u giving a fatwa despite being a layman. Secondly, your molana's desperate attempts to discriminate between men and women's salaah has beeen answered thoroughly in this very same video. All your molana now has to do is reply properly or any hanafi should attempt to atleast respond to one or 2 points from the video that i made. Alhamdulillah until the day of judgement none of u will be able to respond to these scholarly answers from the Ahlul hadeeth,.

[LifewithAllah]

@malchoudhury786

4 school of thoughts are accepted but deobandi germs which came into existance with the power of the English man after 1850 is not accepted. and the school of thoughts are 5 and not 4. This is accepted by Deobandis as well. So stop causing fitnah and dont lie deliberastely as Allah;s curse is on the liars.

[warriorb0y]

Subhan Allah...Akhi You did an excellent job...JazaakAllah...I wish someone can respond to this stupid video created by Hanafi Fiqh...

watch?v=J2gQmV7ch1E

They have disabled comments so no one except their hanafis can post comments...

[seekyourdestiny]

@warriorb0y That was such a LAME video akhi! :D

My family and I had a good laugh at it. Haha, you see, the amount of brainpower used to make this video can only be expected from the hanafi folks (coz the argument is exTREMEly ludicrous and laughable), and the intellectual capacity required to blindly trust this video and take it to be an absolute refutation to salafis, can also only be expected from the hanafi folks :p

The average hanafi would NEVER question what their preachers say...

Sad :/

[CCSF1999]

One of the Shuroot of Salat is that our awra be covered. Rasulullah Salla Allahu Alayhi wa Sallam wore his thawb midway on his shin. A woman cannot do this. If she bared her leg up to her shin, then her Salat would be BaTil (wrong). So it is totally relevant how you dress in Salat.

[LifewithAllah]

@CCSF1999

So where did we say the dress is not relevant?

[CCSF1999]

@LifewithAllah Jizak Allah Khayr.

[LifewithAllah]

@CCSF1999

:) wa iyyak. Dress is really a vry important part, specially alot of men dont have their pant or lower garments above the ankles, The Dress Code is one of the most neglected Sunnahs these days acc to me. many men and women have forgotten the importance of dress in Islam but i hope Allah makes things easy for them. Ameen

[janjua1492]

@LifewithAllah May ALLAH reward you for your beautiful work.We are proud to have people like you who are helping people to understand the sahi Deen.

[LifewithAllah]

@janjua1492

Ameen, may Allah reward you too. Ameen.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

Brother i will also give u references regarding to this issue. Insha Allah. jazak Allah khair for the id. i will send a few references to you tonight insha Allah.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

send me ur email id, i will send 4 or 5 references. i wish you knew little urdu but anyways... send me your email id. I will email it to you insha Allah. I dont intend making these references common atleast for now. so please co operate with me and send me ur id.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

so the answering thing isnt really a daleel but yes i do advise you to respect every 1, my own family is deobandi and im the only ahlul hadeeth. I respect them but i dont consider them to be on the pure path which rasool Allah sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam commanded us to be on i.e Stricly adhering to Quran and Sunnah. Deobandis also reject that Allah is above the throne. My family believes in this but Deobandi scholars reject this.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

And brother its not about who answers well, even Dr Tahir ul Qadri answers well on many questions.. but in reality if u ask any learned scholar.. he will say he is a kaafir bcz he lies on Islam, he lies on the Quran and lies of the prophet mohammad Sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam, and after all this he claims to be Shaykh ul Islam.. His lovers follow him.. Ghulam Ahmed Qadyaani before becoming a murtad... he was used by hanafis to respond to ahlul hadeeth which he couldnt.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

Im not declaring that all of them have the kufr and shirk aqeedah... Sometimes the scholars them selves are unaware. But wallahi... you try and take these scanned references to them... Even if u dont know urdu, just show it to them.. and come back and tell us what they responded back. Remember that u have to tell them to answer instead of abusing coz thats what we get when we question these things...

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

My beloved brother, if i tell you that "I am as Allah is",

If i say that "Fatimah Radhi Allaahu anha.. THE PURE daughter of Mohammad Sal Allahu Aleyhi wasallam hugged me in my dream"

If i do Tahreef (changing) in the Quran in order to Prove Taqleed.

If i say that Prophet Mohammad pbuh was looking at the private parts of a Bitch and a Donkey during Salaah...

Na Auzubillah..

what will u say? Akhi they dont show these things to the Layman.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

Dear brother, i want to provide you the scan pages so you may check it up with any urdu speaking brother. But if u dont want it then its ok. matrudee and Asharee are not kuffaar, rather The Asharis erred in their interpretation of some of the Divine attributes of Allah. I will email you some references later on tonight Insha Allah. I hope they benefit you, email me your email id please.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

brother should i email u the references with scan pages? Its not the time right not to make these things public. I am going for hajj soon insha Allah and when i return, then i will make more proper responses to alot of claims made by the Deobandis. Right now its not the time, nor do i intend making these public until compelled. I can however email u the references with Scans if u wish.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

There are classical hanafis who follow the hanafi school of thought and who follow Qur'an and Hadeeth and Asool of Imam Abu Haneefa and Imam Tahawi, He is our brother and He is has a pure aqeedah for sure Insha Allah Unless he makes a mistake. But trust me that there is plenty of things in the deoband scholarly books which i have to translate on my own and present it to you with scanned images so you can cross check the references.

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

They only take his name but when you compare the aqeedah and manhaj of Imam Abu Haneefah (rah) with the Aqeedah and manhaj of the Deobandis, u will see so many differences. Muhammad Yusuf Ludhyanvi says that the Imam of Deobandis and barelvis in matter of Aqeedah are Abu Al Hasan Ash'ari and Imam Abu Mansoor Matreedi. In matters of tasawwuf and Sulook, both Deobandis and Barelvis do "baith"(urdu word) on Silsila of Chishitiyya, Naqshbandiyyah, Qaadriyyah and Suhrwardiyyah...

[LifewithAllah]

@Shadi1007

Walykum Assalaam dear brother, brother note what i said before, its the Deobandi scholars who had this aqeedah of kufr and shirk. The Layman is not responsible and does not of these things at all because he is not told these things. The Poor Layman is only made to follow what he hears and what the people do instead of opening up the proper books of the deoband scholars and reading what they actually said. And trust me... the deobandis are far away from Imam Abu hanifa (rah).

[LifewithAllah]

@WeBorn2DieAnyTime

No, All hanafis are not deobandis, there are some groups in it and almost each of them has given the fatwa of Kufr on the opposing hanafis. There are Arabs that are Sufis and hence they may be Deobandis but there are pure hanafis in the arab world that dont raise the level of Imam Abu hanifa (rah) to the level of the prophet sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam or Allah. Deobandis are mainly from India and Pakistan.

[WeBorn2DieAnyTime]

@LifewithAllah Jazaka Allah kheiran for the answer :)

[LifewithAllah]

@WeBorn2DieAnyTime

Walylkum Assalaam,

Dear brother im a former Deobandi and i can tell you with full guarantee that the Deobandis ONLY CLAIM that they follow Imam Abu Hanifa (rah) where as in reality they Dont. These People are Sufis and the Books of their Scholars contain Aqeedah of Pure Shirk and Kufr. The Layman Deoband has been kept away from these things and we are told that Deobandis are muqallids of Imam Abu hanifa (rah) but thats certainly not the case.

[aasimazam]

@LifewithAllah one thing that you have twisted in your hatred for Deobandis, is the fact that many salfi overlook. We follow the HANAFI madhab, not Imam Abu Hanifa. There is a difference which is why a Hanbali book of Fiqh was quoted. You know that useless argument you constantly put forward, about leaving the saying of Imam Abu Hanifa in favour of a Sahih Hadith? Well this is what is meant by that. The scholars have perfected the Hanafi madhab and sometimes we don't follow certain fatwas of IAH

[LifewithAllah]

@aasimazam

Ok, So will u take ur words back if i show you proof from Hanafi Scholars that the Evidence for the Muqallid is the "Sayings of the Imaam" and not Quran and Sunnah...You say you dont follow Imam Abu Hanifa rah and i know this... You people only take his name and dont follow him in aqeedah or manhaj and hence this is your deceit. Even Mumtaz ul haq himself says we are the Muqallids of One of the greeatest Imams of this Ummah... and now u r saying ur dont follow Imam abu hanifa rah

[LifewithAllah]

@aasimazam

Secondly, it is not my hatred for debandis, its ur hatred that u think that this video is "my hatred" for deobandis, u ppl dont have a clue or Proof with what u r talking about and now all u have is hate, abuses, Ghuloo of Imam Abu hanifa (rah) and other things. You really have no clue what u r talking about brother.. hanafi madhab is perfected??? bro I dont intend making a video on hanafi fiqh books and what it contains which clearly contradict Quran and Sunnah.. Jazak Allah khair.

[WeBorn2DieAnyTime]

As Salaam aleykum warahmatullahi wabarakaatuh

Masha Allah

Jazaka Allah kheiran for sharing

wa salaam aleykum warahmatullahi wabarakaatuh

[jesusdagr8]

from the very mouth of Prophet(s) you are going to hell coz netiher you are sheikhul hadith, nor mufti nor any aalim what authority you have,to speak on deen. Rasoolullah(s) said'he whoever gives fatwa(answer) without knowledge though it might be right but he has to shoulder this burden of the sin' that he spoke of deen without any knowledge,thats you must know complete Quran, ahadees of all kinds, former verdicts, differences and much more....plus you must possess hikmah to resolve the issues

[LifewithAllah]

@jesusdagr8

Ok so you have applied the fatwa on me that i will go to hell. Subhaan Allah.. i had the same questions when i was becoming ahlul hadeeth but unfortunately u lack manners to put forward ur concern and i did not lack manners back then. All this work which u see IS NOT MINE.. this is all TOP SCHOLARLY work presented to you from Urdu into english. I understand what uve heard from deobundis bcz im a former deobundi my self. So i hope i removed this misconception of urs.

[jesusdagr8]

Part1- these ayas that you brought forward like ahlul quran as they do the same with quran to prove their standpoints....have these ayaas been taken from salf-saliheen in their exegesis while doing detailed commentory on Quran. These ayats were those revealed upon the prophet(s), coz hypocrites were there to do their job. Allah commanded them to follow Allah and if anyone has any dispute then ask ahlul zikr, ahlul amr, if still anything remains there then leave it to Allah war rasool..

[LifewithAllah]

@jesusdagr8

Now You are calling me Ahlul Quran who are basically kaafir so Prophet mohammad pbuh said “If a man declares his brother to be a kaafir, it will apply to one of them.” According to another report: “Either it is as he said, otherwise it will come back to him.” This is the fatwa of Mohammad Sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam and not mine. Secondly, i will consider this as a mistake from u and your ignorance out of emotions.. The vErse of Surah Nisa does not Say "Leave it to Allah war Rasool"

[LifewithAllah]

@jesusdagr8

The verse says "....if you differ in anything amongst yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger (SAW), if you believe in Allah and in the Last Day. That is better and more suitable for final determination"

It does not say LEAVE IT TO ALLAH WAR RASOOL pbuh, it says GO BACK TO ALLAH AND HIS RASOOL pbuh. Allah has given the Solution to our differences and Subhaan Allah i think uve learned this tahreef from Mahmood Al Hassan Deobandi who also did clear tahreef in the Quran..

[mrwaqy]

@LifewithAllah Translation: Narrated by Yazid bin Abi Habib (ra) that the Prophet (Peace be upon him) passed by two women while they were performing prayer. He said: When you make prostration “KEEP YOUR BODY ATTACHED TO THE GROUND BECAUSE WOMEN ARE NOT LIKE MEN IN THIS CASE” [Sunnan al Bayhaqi al-Kubra (3/74)]

In I’laal al Sunnan (3/26) it is said that narrators of this hadith are relied upon and not rejected

[LifewithAllah]

@mrwaqy

Already responded brother, so many people start commenting without even watching the video or reading the response. Plz watch and then comment so both of us can benefit.

[LifewithAllah]

@jesusdagr8

But i wont blame u for tahreef, i will consider it your mistake and your buhtaans and fatwas on me... May Allah guide you or may Allah deal with you, Ameen. Your hate for the Sunnah is very evident brother.. Fear Allah.

[TheMedicine677]

funny reply from a mind narrow thought

end of discusion

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677

May Allah guide you and prevent u from lying next time. Ameen.

[TheMedicine677]

@LifewithAllah u accuse me with lies?

i leave this to Allah

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677

Definetely and watch the video i gave you, it is possible that Allah opens up your pathways.

[TheMedicine677]

@LifewithAllah my comments were result of watching that video

and hold your tongue o poor being who thinks is right and all others are wrong

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677

If your comments were as a result of watching that video then definetely you are a liar and i have no space for liars in my channel. Thank u for commenting. May Allah guide you and open ur heart to Blindly follow Mohammad Sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam instead of scholars of Deobund who came into existance after 1850

[TheMedicine677]

ahlu hadith ohhh and where were you before 250 years ago?

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677

wallahi so strange :) You people are only brain washed to absurdity. Watch this video and statements of the earliest scholars of Islam:

/watch?v=yVITrEo-OEg

Watch it and comment. Its for ur own benefit and open ur mind. Jazak Allah khair.

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677 And about 200 years ago it was the cult of Deobund that came into existance, not Ahlul hadeeth. the term ahlul hadeeth initiated as early as 2nd century to discriminate the people of haqq from the people of shirk, bidah and deviance. These thing u will never hear from your scholars and when we refute such non sense, u ppl say that we dont respect scholars. They are not scholars... they are liars and trust me... Deobundi or barelvi cannot do without lies.

[TheMedicine677]

we who?

[TheMedicine677]

All i can tell you is to open your mind and not to defame scholars

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677

Whch scholars have i defamed?? Subhaan Allah you people are brain washed that Ahlul hadeeth defame scholars. We dont defame any scholar except that we refute the scholars of Shirk and Bidah.

[LifewithAllah]

@LifewithAllah

Ahlul hadeeth

[LifewithAllah]

9 dislikes without any reason from the opposers of Sunnah. Allahu Akbar.. And you label your selves Muslims? :)

[TheMedicine677]

u say former deobundi lol it is deobandi not deobundi  how could u be a deobandi when u do not even know to spell the name

[LifewithAllah]

@TheMedicine677

I think you dont need to tell me its spelling because i know that alot of people spell it as Deoband and im amongst the few who spell it as Deobund. And its ridiculous for you to say on the basis of your spelling that how can i be a former deobundi. :) I repented from the Shirk and misguidance of Deobund a few years back. Alhamdulillah and now i follow the Manhaj and Aqeedah of the Taif Al Mansoorah.

[harisnsiddiqui]

Subhan'Allah, All i have to say is May Allah give us all guidance. Their is enough division in the Ummah, perhaps you could have put this effort into further uniting the Ummah than dividing it. Im not going to waste my time and argue with you but please for the sake of Allah, invest your time in to doing some thing that will unite not divide the Ummah.

On a second note, No reputable scholar of any Madhab would bash or discourage reading the teaches of another scholar or a different Madhab.

[LifewithAllah]

@harisnsiddiqui

Brother, on what basis are you saying that I or my am dividing the Ummah? I expect a reply insha Allah.

And i know about your second note, Alhamdulillah.

[jahariabdullah2011]

Does it really matter how they get on here.....even if they was weak the number of similar ahadith wud raise The satus to HASAN....we can do this all night....stick to The ahlus sunnah

[LifewithAllah]

@jahariabdullah2011

You leave ur facebook and email id behind and ask for discussion, now when i added u, u r not coming and u say reply to me on email. And u ur self continued copy pasting weak ahadeeth here. And You have Absolutely 'ZERO' knowledge of the science of hadeeth and u want to discuss with me? brother,,.just come on facebook. Im waiting. U r not allowed to comment further. Jazak Allah khair.

[jahariabdullah2011]

Ataa (RA) says, “A woman should pull herself together when she bows down into ruk'u: she should bring up her arms to her stomach and pull herself together as much as possible. When she prostrates she should bring up her arms close to her and press her bosom and stomach against her thighs: she should pull herself together as much as possible.” [Musannaf Abdur Razzaq]

[jahariabdullah2011]

Ibn Abbas (RA) was asked about the Salah of a woman and he (RA) answered. “She should gather and join herself”. [Ibn Abi Shaybah]

[jahariabdullah2011]

I ask u to reply via email so we can discuss the issue...are you aware of The sciences of hadith? And the ijma of the ummah.....

[LifewithAllah]

@jahariabdullah2011

Subhan Allah, you are copy pasting weak ahadeeth here and u want me to reply to you via email?? Either u have lost ur senses or am i a fool. I have added u on facebook. Come there. If u post any frther comments here, i will block u from here.Jazak Allah khair for ur copy pastes.

[LifewithAllah]

@jahariabdullah2011

And you are asking me about science of hadeeth? Its quite evident that u r not aware of it because you are posting absolute weak ahadeeth and rejectingt the authentic ahadeeth as if its nothing. Come on facebook. im waiting for u there.

[jahariabdullah2011]

Ali (radiyallaahu anhu) said: "When a woman makes sajdah (prostrates) , she should practise ihtifaaz and keep her thighs close together” (Musannaf Ibni Abi Shayba, vol 2, pg 504, #2793, Al-Majlis al-Ilmi)

[LifewithAllah]

@jahariabdullah2011

Dear brother, may Allah grant you jannah.Ameen. That hadeeth is very weak and i have already responded to it. Watch the video.

[jahariabdullah2011]

As salaamu alaikum your video is very misguiding you failed to mention the statement of bayhaqi on the priciples of the women's salah which is concealment MAY ALLAH FORGIVE YOU OF THE FITNAH YOU ARE TRYING TO CAUSE.....IF YOU WANT TO DISCUSS DALEEL....IM ON FACEBOOK-ABDUL AZIZ AND MY EMAIL IS abultalib35@yahoo.com

[LifewithAllah]

@jahariabdullah2011

And it is evident that you have not even watched the video properly and you are declaring my video as misguiding because its going against your madhab., Subhaan Allah my video only contains pure sahi ahadeeth and rejects weak ahadeeth and u call it misguidance?? May Allah forgive u for this behaviour and may Allah open ur heart.

[LifewithAllah]

brother, Make sure u behave properly next time and watch the video before commenting. My channel is not for people who give labels OR people that comment without watching the video. If u dont have the patience to discuss then keep your lips sealed. The statement that "womens salah is concealed" does that mean womens salah is different than men? No! And i appeal u to follow quran and sunnah.. the solution to our disagreement is Quran and Sunnah so quote one sahi hadeeth in ur support.

[1987kahil]

Jazakallah brothers for making this video. Me and my group of friends have also left the bralwi and deoband teachings. It makes so much sense to me. May Allah guide us all to the true path

[LifewithAllah]

@thegoldstar5

wa iyyak. please share it on your facebook,youtube and else where.

[asadbaloch1]

JazakAllah Khair Brother you are doing really good work, and keep it up, i have lelft hanafi deoband for similar reasons! May Allah Reward you with good!

[LifewithAllah]

@asadbaloch1

Jazak Allah khair for ur comment. Ive had so many friends who were deobundi or barelvi before and now Ahlul hadeeth Alhamdulillah. Please share this video on your facebook and else where.

[asadbaloch1]

@asadbaloch1 Yes Brother the Haqq is clear, the city i used to live in b4 had only one ahle hadith mosque and most ppl there were deobandi and bralvi b4 then they changed, n built that mosque!

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

And your example is an Absolute assumption with no proof.. I dont intend debating based on assumptions. and As far the 4 imaams are concerned... Read their lives.. thats all i can say. Problem with our hanafi brothers is that they limit themselves to ONLY the 4 imaams and forget the other great scholars and imaams and they show the picture that these Imaams were error less... Wallahi we love these Imaams.. but they are not greater than our prophet pbuh or the Sahaba,

[fatzila01]

ruling is wrong because his useing a shahih ahadith.

And please don't take me wrong when I said about shahih ahadith I av no doubts about them they are shahih but that does not mean we throw the Dhaeef ahadith away nd say the ruling given by the greatest ulamas of the ummah four imams ruling are incorect. They had vast amounth of knowledge.

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

Even the sahaba made errors... So how can you claim they were NOT incorrect? On Some issues they were incorrect and they knew the hadeeth knowledge is spreading.. Hence all four of them Agreed that Whenever our fatwa goes against Allah and his rasool pbuh..Reject our sayings and follow Allah and his rasool pbuh. We find sahaba making similar errors too... and whenever they were reminded of Quran and Sunnah on a certain issue.. they would accept it without say "BUT" "IF" etc...

[fatzila01]

I did not say u called him a lier but what I said is by saying all Dhaeef ahadith are fabricated or lie is wrong.

2nd u talk about where does that narration change. Brother it's common sence imam abu hanifa made the ruling well b4 the ahadiths were collected by another imam. Thats wen the narration chain ended. So the ahadith we say Dhaeef nd used in his rulings does not mean it's in correct bcos when the ruling was made the ahadith had not have any problem on the narration chain. Con...

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

Brother really wallahi.. as a brother i advise you.. Study the hadeeth basics. I will no longer discuss with you because you dont have the basics right from the begining. You said that it is wrong to call dhaeef hadeeth as fabricated...Dear brother.. A form of dhaeef hadeeth includes fabricated ahadeeth. You dont have your basics cleared about hadeeth, please study it.. I invite you for the sake of Allah to study the basics of hadeeth from Unbiased sources.

[LifewithAllah]

its so disgusting to see some opposers of Sunnah to dislike the video only because the Sunnah goes against their madhab. This is really sad... may Allah guide them.

[LifewithAllah]

@choudry1231

mei bhai hoon :)

[choudry1231]

@LifewithAllah Oh sorry akhi thats a great video keep it up .

[fatzila01]

Astagfirullah Dhaeef ahadith is not a lie how can u say that. May Allah guide u aamen. Ur saying our prophets saying as lies astagfirullah it might have weaker in narration but they are not lies

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

May Allah deal with you for your Buhtaan on me that i said prophet pbuh lied. Go and study the basics of Hadeeth And May Allah's curse be on those who attribute lies to prophet mohammad pbuh also those that say the prophet was a liar.may Allah destroy them, Ameen. Go and learn the basics of hadeeth and then come back. If u comment now, i will block now. Jazak Allah khair.

[fatzila01]

For example there was 3 narrator when imam made the ruling and they had no problem but when the ahadith was collected there were 5 narrator nd the 4th narrator had problem so does that make his ruling incorrect ?? No it does not. I'm not saying nothing bad yt ur telling me to stop commenting hmm wonder y ? But yh I hope I made it clear.

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

You are giving examples which are totallty based on assumptions brother. You are saying, that for example there were 3 narrators but when hadeeth was collected it became 5.. 4 th had problem etc... Bottom line... How did he give a fatwa when the chain wasnt even Complete?? Its a basic and Common rule that if a narrator is not known in the chain of narration i.e "Majhool" then the hadeeth is dhaeef.

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

on one hand mumtaz ul haq makes claims that "What kind of imam would it be that doesnt know hadeeth". And now you are giving opposite examples that imam abu hanifa rah gave rulings on ahadeeth which actually had 5 narrators in reality but he only knew 3 of them and gave fatwa on that hadeeth... This is proof from ur self that he was weak in hadeeth.

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

I asked u to stop commenting because you first provided a Anti hadeeth Only Quranite Pervezi hadeeth rejecting Arguement. For that i asked u to go back and study the basics and then come back. Now u r doing buhtaan on me that i said the prophet lied. Astaghfirullah.. May Allah deal with you if u dont take ur words back. May Allah destroy those that lie deliberately against the prophet pbuh. Ameen.

[fatzila01]

@lifewithallah

I know what shahih ahadith is nd I take them as shahih Im not denying it. But my point was u talk about shahih ahadith wer did u get that from. Not that I don't except them. Other point was wen imam Abu hanifa made this ruling the Hadith was shahih bcos der was no problem in narration chain. It might have gone weaker when the ahdith was collected later on

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

ok So you are claiming when Imam abu hanifa made this ruling, the hadeeth was sahi back then? Which ruling are u talking about? Which hadeeth are u talking about? And yes thats what we are telling you..if imaam abu hanifa erred in giving an opinion based on weak hadeeth... And we now know that is a pure dhaeef hadeeth or fabricated hadeeth, then leave that opinion and follow sahi hadeeth. We know all this already brother.

[fatzila01]

Ok u refer to shahih ahadith can u tell me where in the sunnah or quran it talks about shahih ahadith??

Another point talking about weak narration chain when imam Abu hanifa wrote made this rulings it was not weak it might b that the narration got weaken after his ruling. So please brothers stop making this kind of conflict video nd dnt just take shahih ahadith nd forget about all the thousands of ahadith that we say weak

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

Astaghfirullah.... This is a Rock bottom arguement and totally based on Jahaalat. You dont know what Sahi Hadeeth is and u want to discuss Islam with us...? Brother Dont Comment further here.. Go ask hanafi scholars about sahi hadeeth first and then come back. Imam Abu Hanifa said when a hadeeth is found to be Sahi, then that is my Madhab. So ask the hanafi scholars where is sahi hadeeth in Quran and Sunnah.

[AminAmin22]

@LifewithAllah "Dhaeef Hadeeth which is as good as a lie to Propht Mohammad pbuh? "

SubhanAllah - you want to teach the brother about Ahadith then you call Da'eef hadith "as good as a lie" - learn what Da'eef hadith means

Also...are "Sahih hadith" only in Bukhari and Muslim? There are no other books or compilations with one or two Sahih hadith?

Also please show me the hadith or ayah (as you say) that women should not raise their voice when a mistake is made

[LifewithAllah]

@AminAmin22

Brother Answer my question if u know the categorisation of dhaeef hadeeth. do u consider Dhaeef hadeeth to the sayings of the prophet? if not, then what is it?

one of the propoganda of hanafi is that Ahlul hadeeth only believe in hadeeth of Bukhari and Muslim. thats an absolutely lie. Sahi Ahadeeth are not Only in Bukhari or Muslim, there are other great books. And the Criteria of all the Muslims is that the hadeeth should be authentic in order to be accepted.

[LifewithAllah]

@AminAmin22

BUT having said that, there is almost an Ijma on Sahi Al Bukhari and top hanafi scholars regard sahi al bukhari as doubtless and the most authentic book after the Quran. If a hadeeth appears in Bukhari and Muslim, it is called muttafiqun aleyh and this is the Most Strongest hadeeth. As far as your question on women is concerned, check the link i have provided in the description. see if u can find ur concerned matter. Jazak Allah khair.

[LifewithAllah]

@fatzila01

And You said that the hadeeth got weakened after Imam Abu Hanifa made the ruling, ok Alhamdulillah.. so follow Sahi hadeeth as he said. Why do u follow a confirmed Dhaeef Hadeeth which is as good as a lie to Propht Mohammad pbuh? now Please... Dont comment here. First u go and learn about Sahi hadeeth from scholars. This is my advise to you because when u dont know what sahi hadeeth is... then why r u discussing matters related to Sunnah..?

[asalamualaikum1]

intension seems sincere, whats unfortunate is the 'condisending undertone' minus the same it could be a productive video, still as ulamah it would be advisable to hilight such errors in privacy, differences should be less publicised and amicably resolved.

and Allah (swt) knows best brother.

[LifewithAllah]

@asalamualaikum1

jazak Allah khair for the advise dear brother, May Allah reward you with jannat ul firdaws, Ameen.