PINK FLOYD Your Possible Past

[zepecat]

best cover of this song in youtube so far.

[bassweld]

I agree with KristinS below and I think, the best cover of this song on here. Great!

[KJeezy08]

I second that comment, but man dont be discouraged! you sound a lot of Waters himself. Good acoustics btw.

[angie4josh]

*Cringes* man this sucks I need to redo this.

[Stephenwp]

I really liked your performance. I just wish the camera wasn't so close so that I could watch your hands and see how you played it.

[KristinSuzanne]

Dynamic! Emotive, Poingant and Perfectly on Pitch!!! Even on the higher registers...ya nailed it all! while playing beautifully!

Tough to do it all and u make it look easy...Just we could see your face :(

Anyway...you're extremely talented. Wish you were in any of my lineups!

Rock on Dude ~K

[Arturdg1bk]

Wow! You sound like a Waters! Great cover anyway :)

[floyd123]

excellent!!! sound a little like waters Keep it up A+++++

[angie4josh]

@floyd123 a bit thinner and whiny but i guess its ok. lol

thanks!

[expatpedro]

Hey fella, for me this was brilliant, guitar n vocals......a classic song

[chrisdarroch]

Sorry.......I meant to say that it sounds a lot like Waters. I just didn't want to stress that in case that was deemed the main issue in my commentary.

To clarify a little the points I made below. I think that music is only karaoke if one tries to 'cover' in this way. One has to make something new of it; that is; if one's desire is to excel musically.

[angie4josh]

i see what you are saying.

but.

nobody does covers like i do them.

and futhermore i give not one shit for doing it differently. a cover is a cover.

thanks :)

[chrisdarroch]

Ok dude, if that's the way you see it; then well done for sounding like Waters; although it gets lost at spots like 1:20.

I really might not like it if too many people agreed with or understood the subtler or more extended points I make as, to me, this would mean that I am not as cool a thinker as I wish to believe I am, thanks :)

[angie4josh]

im sure you said somthing very broad and thought provokeing, let me take a moment to reflect........

...hmmm. i didn't find anything. oh well.

[chrisdarroch]

YOU, probably couldn't of course, that is probably the underlying point. That is why you are doing what you are doing.

Trying to get kudos and praise for how good you are at mimicking other people's music. Cool that!

Keep on with the covering. Can't make your own shit then copy other peoples and let the praise roll in.

Perhaps life as a real creative may never be one of your possible pasts.

[angie4josh]

i guess you have not seen my original songs then.

[MrBenoo08]

theres billions of covers on youtube. there not performed for fame or fortune, but as tribute.

so if you want to take your hearless figure and complain about somebody elces attempts to enlighten peoples lives. fuck off you ungrateful fuck,

nice work angie4gosh mate :)!

[angie4josh]

Many thanks MrBenoo08, how have you been anyway?

[MrBenoo08]

Verry well ! going to do a music A-level in september , ill probly be doing alot of roger covers, so ill be sure to send you them ;)

[chrisdarroch]

Sounds like Waters in spots however............dude, musically this is like masturbation....it is good and sometimes you can persuade yourself that it was fulfilling but man there is something lost about it.

Musiclal Mimicry is always done. But like sex; the resultant children should only be like you. To be competitive you have to add something new to it; not simply copy it.

[71bee383]

very nice! I also think you did a great Waters impression.

EXCELLENT tune from an EXCELLENT underrated album.

[the1whoSeesAll]

Man, I thought I was listening to Waters at first. You did an exellent cover of this. It's really an amazing song. I'm disappointed at how underated it is. How did you learn it?

[angie4josh]

lol thanks for the comment, but im realy just a wannabe like everyone else,

um i just picked up the music by ear so there are surely gaps and wrong chords everywhere.

[Lintflas]

No excuses, dude! :) Your voice is just great and this cover-version is one of the best Floyd covers, I've ever listened to. Maybe you should work a little bit on the chords, but they were really ok!

[jamshakvids]

Damn bro, that was really nice. I rarely sit through a whole song on YT. Wish I could have seen you do that live.

[angie4josh]

lol i guess it was ok for 6 AM lol

soon ill be posting my cover of "Each Small Candle", and this one i recorded on cubase, it is compleatly different from the original, exept i tryed very hard to match Roger Waters vocals in it.

thanks for the comment, and i LOVE the mashup you did with NIN and Pink Floyd that was the shit!

[final58fant58]

he ll yea man you sound better More like Roger nice cover!

[183Vitold]

Miraculously performance - I like this piec.

Hi is complicated in playing, you did it very well .Voice similar to Waters .Forgive me my weak English.

Five points - ***** Piec punktow(PL)

[angie4josh]

AWESOME! thank you!

[MrBenoo08]

Wow, youve jsut blew me away, Best cover ive heard for a long time, your voice is perfectly suited for roger/pink songs

You rock !

[angie4josh]

lol i know its a bit squeeky, but it was like 6:am lol thanks for watching.

[angie4josh]

lol