David Cook performs Silver @ Pearl Street, Northampton, MA 05/23/09

[GeorgiaPat]

I'm glad he's including some of the "Analog Heart" songs. I don't know how I'd feel about the crowd singing, but I guess they just can't help it. I'd probably do the same thing. David's probably flattered, as he should be.

[DCsGlory]

The ultimatum was, "Play Silver or I want my money back." At the end, David said, "So per your ultimatum, you're not getting your money back. I just want everybody to know that."

[ExtraEccles101]

so what was the ultimatum?

[doedaphna]

haha give him more ultimatums like that!

he seems to respond well :)

[Love36214]

OMG. I cannot believe that David is surprised that people know the words to every song that we have been able to get our hands on. We even learn the new ones (hint, hint) super fast. He is an amazing lyricist and we are in awe. That doesn't even take into consideration that VOICE. Just does me in.

[ealo11]

I absolutely love this song and have been hoping he would sing it some time. He once said that it was his favorite song from AH.

[wehoscott]

DC'sGlory is right... David, you really don't know how much we treasure Analog Heart.

[irollwithxvampires]

I was there...

I cried. <3

Thank you for posting this, (so fast, too!) I love getting to re-live last night over and over...

[princesslizann]

Thank you, so very much for posting this.

I love Anaalog Heart and I love Silver. Every song on this record is terrific Infact I think I have listen to it more this week then DCTR.

[jtft1989]

I was there! It was such a surprise and a delight.  Want more Dave!!

[fairytalewitch]

I don't know why I have tears in my eyes! I love Silver, I probably listened to it hundreds if not thousands of times since last summer and it's still my 2nd fav from Analog Heart (1st is The Truth). Thanks so much for capturing this moment and uploading it! :)

[CookieLove1983]

I am so happy. I never thought I would heard him sing Silver!!

[worldtraveler91]

This is............................­.......gah, I can't even! I LOVE YOU, DAVID COOK. OMG. At the concert the night before this show, I brought a sign that said "SILVER" but they didn't have a chance to play it, I'm so glad people kept requestiing!!!!! Thank you soo much for this.

[CookTime9]

Have tears in my eyes. I would just like to second everything that DCsGlory said.  We not only know every word to the much-beloved Analog Heart, we know Balance, Just in Case, and on and on. We love so many things about David and the band, but most of all we love the words.

[mermcc]

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh!  I've been waiting over a year to hear this sung live. David,Vlease please. V Beach would be perfect. LOVE these songs.

[DCsGlory]

David, I don't think you have any idea just how much we treasure Analog Heart. You still had that little smile of pleasure & surprise you get that people "seem to know the lyrics" to your songs. That should give you a hint ... we love them all, we know them all, and we really want to hear you sing them all. We love YOUR music.

(Thanks so much for this beautiful video.)