Added: 2 years ago
From: Symmathos
Views: 23,736
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (303)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I still think that maya's death on persona 2:innocent sin

  • @danielthepokefreak I think it's more that Aerith's death and (I guess) Tidus' fading are just a given at this point. Top scenes vids should have a disclaimer saying "+Aerith's death+Tidus leaving" so they wouldn't need to show them anymore.

    Another good one is from FFVI, Ceres trying to commit suicide after you've played her last few days in a hut and everything around her has died, so she gives up. Too bad 16-bit doesn't translate well to these videos. Still, heavy.

    (+Team ICO stuff tho).

  • Comment removed

  • gears of war 3 doms death.....that is all

  • come on aeriths death should be 1. that fucking music as the holy materia hits the ground gets me every time

  • I'm not sure if anyone would agree with me (mainly because not as many people were into this game or even knew much about it until SSBM), but the many deaths of characters from Fire Emblem games i think is sad, I also think the death of Arthas Menethil (A.K.A The Lich King of the Scourge) is very sad, and I think FF deaths should stop being put into these videos seperately, there have been a lot of traedies throughout th series, and I've only ever seen 2 of them in these saddest game moment vids

  • 5. Incredibly emotional, even for a kids game.

    4. It's never not sad when you have to kill a believeable character who was a friend to the protagonist.

    3. A sacrifice is always tragic, no matter the situation.

    2. Over-rated but still quite sad non the less.

    1. Meh.

  • I'm sorry but there's just no way Aerith's death is more sad than any of the Metal Gear scenes...

  • My #1 is DEFINATLY John marstons death

  • fox death is really sad that should be 1...

  • My #1 is the "Death of Adam Malkovich" in "Metroid Other M"

  • Fox is the best !

  • "An undying shadow in a world of lights"

    That says number one to me :s

  • one of the most amazing game ending is so sad in infamous 2 when cole and kuo sacrifce their lives to cure everone from the plaig

  • im quite happy te top 2 in this video are the 2 saddest things in the ff series! bravo on a good selection! im gonna re play both final fantasies now!!

  • CoD: MW when all your squad dies was probably the saddest for me, just saying though don't hate.

  • some may say different but the gow 3 seen when dom died was pretty sad.

  • @Madmouad thank you I only disagree with one thing, Aerith's death wasn't sad, I found it made me happy because she was useless, however the ending of Crisis Core did make me cry because it was so much more meaningful.

  • @death17954 aerith wasnt useless at all! the materia that fell out her hair was the very thing that saved the planet against meteor! it ses so later in the game! sorry i just wanted to point that out!

  • @SidDisco I want to point out that you apparently did not playthrough FF 7, if you did, you would know that the Lifestream is what saved the planet, not Aerith's Materia, they thought that her Materia was Holy, but they were wrong, Cloud states this at the end of the game.

  • gears 2?

  • FUCK EVERYONE THAT SAYS HALO AND COD ARE SAD THERE NOT

  • Dude you NAILED it with MGS 3! Kudos - that scene tore me up.

  • Fucking kingdom hearts song...

    getting me all teary eyed... >:'/

  • but it definitely gave the game more depth after she died

  • i laughed when aerith died cause i always hated her ^.^

  • The new saddest moment in gaming history is in Gears Of War 3... SPOILER ALERT--------

    Dom's death :(

  • For me Mgs on psone is stiill the best end

  • oh if i had a quarter for everytime someone used the same cliche things look we only needed one video not like 600 you people need to play a wider span of games. n00bs

  • what about when everybody though Master Chief was dead at the end of Halo 3??

  • whats the song for 5

  • number 2 probably made everyone go O_O WTF! the first time they played the game.

  • Maybe if they remade FFVII I would've felt sad for Aeris, but I really didn't have a reaction watching that one...

  • @Meganimanic you probably didnt play the game when it first came out and that was the best graphics at the time....it was sad as hell when you boosted your Aeris character with the best shit, and then they just took her away like that...the video doesn't show the saddest part either where cloud is holding her body and lowers her into the water..then again I was like 12 when I played it but I still get a lump in my throat thinking about that part

  • How is mw2 sad/ an emotional ending? Gay fanboys who play one game/ or only play FPS's and call themselves gamers and think it takes emotion.

  • What about Sara's death in Lament of Innocence ? :(  That moment is sad...

  • Good list although the Gray Fox choice was wrong since there are other more touching moments in many games.

  • I can list a few other games that aren't on these lists; FF7 Crisis Core, Lufia 2, & Xenosaga 3.

  • Only fucking anime japanese porn games lol and metal gay solid. It is clearly YOUR opinion

  • heres my reaction to the 1st part of this video:

    Me: JUMP BITCH!!

  • To all the people who complain that I didn't put in MW2 or Red Dead Redemption's sad moments, please compare the date this video was submitted to the release dates of those games.

    I've read all the comments and you guys have given me some great feedback. I'm planning on making another video like this, but I'll be using some of your suggestions.

  • @Symmathos could u describe wat the each moment was in the description

  • @Symmathos how is mw a sad game

  • this sucks no war games

  • I agree with number one i cried when i had to kill my aeons :'( x

  • wheres assassins creed?

  • the saddest is Red Dead Redemption by far, not the very end but the last part with john...

  • I know Aeris' death was sad but i jus think everyone is pressured to include because everyone has it a top saddest vg moments...

  • @AnbuBlackOps6 It was a historical thing, It was the first 3d graphic video game to make people around the globe remorse for her fictional character. I remember having this long talk with my friends like someone actually died, and if you talked to anyone who played the game their whole mood would change if you brought that up..Ive never seen anything like it, even till this day.

  • @Nardz024 Heh, this will probably make people yell pussy but idgaf. I still remember my reaction the first time I saw that scene. Since I had no idea what was gonna I was pumped for a boss fight but I wasn't expecting anything like that considering I used Aeris a ton and got so used to her in party. When I saw her get killed I remember kind of watching like thinking maybe she's just going to get revived.. nope. Then that first moment you see the materia hit the floor, my skin started crawling.

  • @Nardz024 After the music started playing I kinda realized she wasn't coming back, then watching Cloud hold her while Seph taunted his feeling I remember tearing up a bit.. and as soon as I saw the boss fight it turned to pure anger.. I remember fucking Jenova up, the whole fight was like a cloud of tears and anger because her theme was in the background. The rest of the time after the fight I was pretty much crying thinking.. THIS IS SO FUCKED UP. SEPH IS GOING TO GET A SWORD SHOVED UP HIS ASS!

  • @HumorousLOL Your on the same exact level that im on, I had no idea that was going to happen either, its good to see someone else who experienced the game the same way I did, ill admit also man I cried too...actually reading what you wrote brought back the same emotion that day like 10 years ago when I fought Jenova..its funny cause literally, I had to step away from the computer and i cried for about 5 minutes...my Girlfriend was like OMG whats wrong.

  • @HumorousLOL .I then LOLD wile crying and told her its all good, I then finished up and came back to this message to say what just happened..Its crazy what a damn video game can do to somebody..Im not the type of dude to cry either, lol..absolutely mad man.

  • @Nardz024 That was probably the first game that brought that type of emotion out of me, ever. The only other game that was able to do that around that time was Silent Hill on PSX, of course that emotion was extreme fear. When a company succeeds in bringing out emotion you normally reserve for real life situations, you know they made a quality product.

  • @HumorousLOL Dude...I had a serious problem with her death. :[ That JENOVA fight was apocalyptic. I'm surprised Sephy didn't cut his losses after he saw the emotion I put into killing her.

  • @RiotDragonX Soon as that sword went through Aeris, shit went down lol

  • Comment removed

  • the ending of fallout 3 was pretty sad

  • wow they need to make an update on sad games halo reach should def be in the top 5

  • none of these are sad mother 3 when claus died was sad

  • @cheeseisbad1991 that was the first game that make me cry more than any other game... i couldnt fight claus at all... i cant imagine how lucas would of felt...

  • @cheeseisbad1991 That was so sad that it couldn't be added.

  • I wish yuna woulda never said "i love you" to tidus, i knew it was true but her saying it right as he fades made me cry...

  • these are ALL crapy video games >:O

  • @pwnerzatzhaloz3 HEY! Not MGS...

  • sometimes kingdom hearts would put tears in my eyes same thing with metal gear =( they are awesome games!

  • Well, the ending of final fantasy X was really sad, that's true, but there was only one part in a game which nearly made me cry. Day 356 from Kingdom Hearts 358/2 days (if I do remember right)

  • Saddest one is ffx as included on this Vid.... No human can disagree

  • What about Naomi's Death in MGS4 or Sniper Wolf in MGS1?

  • In my opinion, the ending of Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Explorers of Time/Darkness would be number one.

    But hey, this is your list and your opinions, not mine.

  • saddest in video game is when your system breaks while you are playing on it.

    rrod for example.

  • While I'm happy that MGS got represented, I don't think Fox's death was the saddest. I think that would go to the death of Sniper Wolf. Much, much more sadder.

  • there shouldve been chopper's death from ace combat 5. i actually cried during that scene...i bet every1 who has played that game has cried in that scene

  • @shortdevil2 Check out my video on top 20 games. I mention it there.

  • nobody understands that Sora and Kairi were seeing eachother but they were in different worlds so they couldnt actually be together

  • cod= lool mgs= <3

  • when xion dies in kingdom hearts 356 days .

  • In the Kingdom Hearts one, I felt like saying "THE GAP IS THE SAME SIZE AS THE GAPS IN THE FLIPPING TRAIN STATION! JUST JUMP". It didn't make me sad. It Just Upset me :(

  • I appreciate a lot that you put fox death in this video :'(

  • OMG this vid made me wanna play MGS3! And lol, FFX ending is IMO truly the saddest : / But atleast Tidus got to Jetch :)

  • YOU'RE FUCKING KIDDING ME WHAT ABOUT SILENT HILL...DEAR GOD THE WATER ENDING OF 2...LISA'S DEATH...ANGELA'S DEATH...LEAVE ENDING OF 2...THE BAD AND BAD + ENDING OF 1...EILEEN'S DEATH ENDNG...those are just a few things that were ten times sadder than anything Hideo Kojima could dream up...and the ending of KH wasn't frackin sad...they weren't perma split...and aerith's death made me laugh...

  • @Arella17 I disagree, but u r right with SH its very sad. But HK is a master at emotion and thats weird that u laughed. The KH ending wasnt really sad it was more emotional

  • @Arella17 Your opinion. I stated in another video like this that other's opinions are not the list maker's.

  • ok seriously y isnt tht none of these had deaths like Roach and Ghost or Master Chief? its retarded

  • it took me about 15 minutes in MGS3 to kill The Boss ='(

  • Reading through these comments, clearly few here have played Mother 3.

    If you combine the sadness of all of these events together, it wouldn't even add up to half of what Mother 3 brings to the player. It is not simply sadder, but deeper in every social/political and philosophical way possible. Every moment in that game has an intellectual meaning behind it to make it much more than "an innocent girl being killed" or what have you.

    These are sad, but nothing like Mother 3...

  • why did arieo have to die D:

    and why did the guy in number one have to sacafice himself

  • why did arieo have to die D:

  • Please US games fail at making emotional bonds with characters, therefore the scenes are not sad and actually quite pathetic. Take ICO or SOTC or FF for example, those games actually make you care what happens to the characters. Not this GAYLO or COD bullshit.

  • @Charliem1994

    I beg to differ, partially. You're half right, you're using bad examples. Very Few FF games actually make you care for their characters. FFX deserved to make this list, but not so high. FFVII did not, as the devellopment was almost non existant, the characters were far too shallow to make you give a crap and it was badly handled.

    If you want a genuinely sad scene, try searching for "A dream Interrupted" in Valkyria Chronicles, and if you can, the scene after it.

  • @FonMasterIon i didnt mean all FF games but yes i have seen VC part and it was so sad ..... i just forgot to mention it :)

  • @Charliem1994 what about gears of war, it was really sad when tai and maria died

  • @BloodyAbyss1216 nah Americans cant use emotion properly. Not to mention GOWs voice acting sucked which made the scenes funny

  • @Charliem1994

    yea on the COD scene i was like "DAMN! thats a nice gun!"

  • FINALLY! Someone who agrees that Kingdom Hearts ending is sad xD My dad walked in on my crying at the end, laughed, and walked out.. *sigh* They just don't understand.. And Final Fantasy X? Easily the saddest moment in game history.. I can't even watch this video without crying, haha.

  • The kingdom heart's ending is not sad..It's more..Emotionnal. You cry. Of the..Too much emotion. The boss death is REALLY REALLY sad. A so charismatic woman..I make twenty minutes tu shoot her.. And now, i still regret to have doing this.Gray fox had a beautiful death..His last words are always in the heart of the players. Tidus goes..Damn. He was my little favorite with auron.

  • The music in the #8 was just great... made it so much sadder.

  • The end of Kingdom Hearts and the end of Halo 3 were the closest i've ever gotten to crying over a game

  • any one who thinks that ghost and roach dying is sadder than the endding to ff10 needs to get there head checked

  • the 5th is fuckin gay

  • @StuS153 You are watching a video of the top 5 saddest video game moments and you are considering the ending of kingdom hearts to be gay?

    That proves how little you know about video games.

    Can you tell me your definition of a sad video gaming moment?

  • Death of Big Boss is really sad =[

  • dragon age is sad if u choose to sacrifice urself

  • hell yeah there only one snake

  • 8:08 OWNED!

  • Vandal Hearts 2 and star ocean 2 are the saddest games ive played

  • Ghetto

  • @halo3guy50 i think that the Cod rts ending was sadder

  • @lethalninja492 obviously....

  • Carlos's death - Saints row 2.

  • that's only Japanese video game history

  • I don't want to be hated but KH and FF are overrated. They are games that have confusing story lines. I mean WTF Donald and Goofy in an anime game? Walt Disney would go robocop and destroy Square Enix.

  • @MrOmgtheykilledkenny Overrated they may be, but dayyyyyum is FFX golden ;)

  • FFX will and always deserve it's place at #1. And I think most FF Fans will agree with me on this.

  • @MegaEternalLife agreed :)

  • @MegaEternalLife

    Nah Zack's death and the scream of cloud s the one

  • ive seen like 4 sad videos and im very suprised heavy rain has not been in one

  • i don't care if everybody hates me for this comment but I think that all things Final Fantasy suck balls

  • @cladjak15 dood i agree with you those are the stupidest games ever .i dont understand how people enjoy them

  • KH1 and 2 both had sad moments and I loved the games for them I will always remember them

  • yey again, another shitty list.....

  • fallout 3 should be there wen his father dies that's sad!

  • My number 1 vote is a combination.

    The end of FFX and the sad-ending of FFX-2.

  • Almost every moment in Kingdom Hearts should be on this list o.o

  • @lollypop292 so true

  • @Rooster0903 I love kingdom Hearts ^^

  • @lollypop292 kingdom hearts is not a game that many has heard of ,but god dammit kingdom hearts is one of the few games that should have the title masterpeice

    (PS: I cried the first time I saw the ending)

  • @Rooster0903 It's like all I ever talk about xD

  • @lollypop292 i agree how many kindom hearts are there i played that game i forgot which one

  • @lollypop292 there are some happy moments in kh but there are a lot of sad ones :P

  • @lollypop292 What the hell are you talking about?! Kingdom hearts isn't sad at all!

  • @skitty427 xD heartless

  • @lollypop292 Oh, reeeaaal funny. I'm being serious! The only sad part ever in kingdom hearts is axel's death, and that isn't even that sad because I don't really like axel.... (fangirls, try to resist the urge to shoot me, but yeah, the only thing I like about axel is his voice actor..)

  • @skitty427 mhmm sure.... as those other 26 thumbs ups

  • @lollypop292 Ehh, whatever. I don't care how many people disagree with me, I still think that kingdom hearts isn't sad at all. I just like the game because I get to kick ass with badly developed anime protagonists, and I like the organization. (Yes, I will admit, I am a fangirl of one of them....)

  • @skitty427 then thats your opinion :)

  • shooting boss was an accident for me. it was just sitting there and i pulled the fire button cause i didnt know what to do. next thing i know some dbag is on the helicopter flipping revolvers around.

  • okay as this was made in 10th april they wouldnt have known about red dead redemtion but when john dies i cried you spend so long helping him getting his family back and then just a major sad moment

  • Why is Ghost and Roach dying sad? If anything, they were too fucking stupid to see it coming...

  • Somebody loves their PS3 a little bit too much

  • The saddest i came across in my opinion *the ones i came across* is in world in conflict when bannon stays behind to die in the nuke i was like "dammit bannon why dont you let me leave my troops behind so you dont die!!!"

  • All of you arguing that somehow an ending to modern warfare was sadder than any of these obviously hasn't played these games. These games had a thing called "character development" that made you really care for the characters, and gave you a true emotional response instead of the "oh no ghost died i r sad and angry ololol"

  • why the hell do people think final fantasy is sad the end of cod 4 was more sad than any of these

  • @sporepid "why the hell do people think final fantasy is sad the end of cod 4 was more sad than any of these "

    You are so god damned ignorant, that I just threw up on my keyboard in disbelief at humanity... almost... stupid fuck.

  • i remeber trying to shoot the dam stinger

  • I'd hate to be another "OMG YOU DIDNT INCLUDE THIS!!!"

    but chances are you haven't played it, and chances are you would love it, so I'll give a shout-out to mother 3... its JP only, but with an outstanding fan translation it makes for the saddest video-game ever made, as it is a game that doesn't include a "sad scene" but it in itself quite a tragedy.

  • To everyone who says that roach and ghost should have been in the list. Look at the video date.

  • 5. and 1. were stupid as fuck. Where's Roach And Ghosts death from MW2? Or Carlos and Aishas death from SR2? T_T RIP

  • @xXelmarcoCFCXx mw2 wasnt made yet so your the one who's stupid as fuck

  • roach and ghost

  • @dude1010103 So true though for most people it would just be the ghost part

  • my saddest moment was in Lost Odyssey when Lirum died T_T

  • or when shadow died in sonic adventure 2 battle

  • one of the saddest for me was seeing roman die in gta 4 or kate whichever yo chose

  • after playing kingdom hearts and seeing the ending i was soo sad :( i was like noo sora, come back :'(

  • whers Dom and Maria

  • moment 4 never got me sad even through i know what it means, i just was glad i killed her but if i was him i would feel the same

  • Comment removed

  • fallout 3 good ending

  • 2 wasnt sad

  • i loved the game butt why didnt she get on the could and love this song kingdom haerts to many thing lately XD

  • missing one

  • the saddest moments that i liked was number 2,5, and the saddest 1

  • im sorry but i laugh everytime i see that kingdom heart one its like sora:'kairi no!'*music burst* sora:'wtf'

  • moment 5 wasnt sad it pissed me off

  • @apls291 THAT WAS THE SADDEST THING EVER TRY LOSING A LOVED ONE AND GET BACK TO IT

  • @OrigamiWiZKiD ever watched your brother die in front of your eyes

    then stfu #5 wasd gay plus u find her in the second game

  • @apls291 agreed when i beat the game i was like wtf nothing was accomplished

  • where is mah bioshock good ending

  • U forgot bioshock 2 good ending

  • @kickedyamum yeah that was sad :(

  • The 2 saddest moments i´ve ever seen on video games are these 2:

    1. Splinter cell conviction: when Sam kills his best friend and then he knows that his friend (lambert) was potecting sarah (sam´s daughter).

    2.Cod mw2: When sheperd betrays roach and ghost and kill and burn them.

  • mgs1, THE best shooting game before MW2, yes i would rate mgs1 higher then CoD4 + CoD5. it is just such an epic game

  • oh f@$% kingdom hearts that made me laugh