@EriksChristine It's on the DVD, "Josh Groban : An Evening in New York" Reprise Records, 2009. I strongly recommend this DVD. While Josh's CD's have always been flawless, his live performance skills have sometimes been considerably weaker. This most recent DVD shows tremendous evolution and a near perfect performance.
Sorry if this is a repeat comment, but does anyone know where this was filmed? When I saw him in Vancouver in 2007, those of us in the front row were allowed to approach the stage like these fans here, just for this song.
im kinda dissapointed he didnt go big on the "but in time" but other than tht rele good. i kno its supposed to be high the first time but the second time ur supposed to go big
@SaVeStHeDaY37mm As much as I love Josh, Music of the Night will always be Michael Crawford's piece. There's a vid of him performing it and he lost his pitch a tad. Felt kinda bad for him cause I think he was performing for the president... The vid's floating around.
Yes, but Ed had a wonderful voice regardless! After puberty his voice could either become greater or plummet to where it sucks. I'm rooting for the better one because he's damn adorable and I loved it when he sang.
i know. i didnt actually cry (im a hard-ass i just cant do it lol) and i was just like oh....this is awful, i dont want lil toby to die! lol but he didnt thankfully. but still i love that song.
If you like josh groban and his song "the prayer"...Type "Coppell Talent Show" and hear two Texas High School All-State singers. The guy SOUNDS like Josh and the girl is amazing.
it was nice - he sat on the edge of the stage for this song - the fans were allowed to come up. He signed a few things and shook hands. Never seen anyone do this before -not while singing the whole time. He is real special.
Oh my God - was this the concert at Bobcats Arena in Charlotte? I was there, and he was INCREDIBLE. I cried during this song - I couldn't help it! He's got to be one of the most beautiful men on this Earth...
lol yea i was on your right...he was so amazing! cant wait till he comes back to toronto...hes coming back for a liek "various artists" thing but i would rather just see him, rather then him for a couple of songs and a whole bunch of other people
ehh. I love josh but I was just in sweeney todd and he did an ok version of the song, it just wasnt how it was meant to be sung by the character. but of course it was a concert and not a performance of the show, so he did it well for his audience.
and he seems soooooo down to earth!!!! I have never seen a singer sign autographs and sit with fans during a concert before!!! i loved it!!...O man i wanted to marry that man that night....it was disgusting how much i loved him hahaha
i love him he great at sing
panadabear722 11 months ago
@EriksChristine It's on the DVD, "Josh Groban : An Evening in New York" Reprise Records, 2009. I strongly recommend this DVD. While Josh's CD's have always been flawless, his live performance skills have sometimes been considerably weaker. This most recent DVD shows tremendous evolution and a near perfect performance.
straightarrow372 1 year ago
Such amazing talent... oh my gosh!
WeHeartCamilla 1 year ago
<3 Joshieee
kyonekothatpwns 1 year ago
Sorry if this is a repeat comment, but does anyone know where this was filmed? When I saw him in Vancouver in 2007, those of us in the front row were allowed to approach the stage like these fans here, just for this song.
NikolitaNiko 2 years ago
It was filmed by me in Toronto on March 5, 2007. i was in the tenth row.
OneJoshFan 2 years ago
Neat! Thanks for the reply. :)
NikolitaNiko 2 years ago
im kinda dissapointed he didnt go big on the "but in time" but other than tht rele good. i kno its supposed to be high the first time but the second time ur supposed to go big
Westjk14 2 years ago
Nice job.
Nat4Brendan 2 years ago
I want him to sing that to me to cheer me up... I love you Josh. When you come here again I coming to see you again. your awesome
crazy4mickey 2 years ago
holy shiznap! he is so good!
Youcantstopthebeat22 3 years ago
Honestly, what CAN'T Josh Groban sing?
SaVeStHeDaY37mm 3 years ago 3
@SaVeStHeDaY37mm
He can't sing anything past 25% tenor ranges... lol
chavaliay1 1 year ago
@SaVeStHeDaY37mm As much as I love Josh, Music of the Night will always be Michael Crawford's piece. There's a vid of him performing it and he lost his pitch a tad. Felt kinda bad for him cause I think he was performing for the president... The vid's floating around.
PhoenixBlackthorn 1 year ago
what key is this in?
strongsad14 3 years ago
ed did that in a studio though and he is doing it live!!! i like this version better!!!
mileymandyfan411 3 years ago
Yes, but Ed had a wonderful voice regardless! After puberty his voice could either become greater or plummet to where it sucks. I'm rooting for the better one because he's damn adorable and I loved it when he sang.
MyChemicalFantasy589 3 years ago 2
wow
Crenmagicman 3 years ago
I LOVE HIM
LiefsteCamilla 3 years ago
ED SANDERS VERSION IS BETTA
LukeBenwardFan94 3 years ago
EVERY version is better
Pianoismyantidrug 3 years ago
Mandy Patinkin sings this song so well.I wish it was on here - he is just great.I don't like this version at all.
Luna810 3 years ago
true, true. and i think that Ed Sanders was 14 when they filmed it, but he's 15 now so yeah. but yeah u have a good point
soccerstar5930 3 years ago
no he was 13 when they filmed it.
hes now 14.
killhannahlover 3 years ago
oh...
soccerstar5930 3 years ago
okay, he has a good voice, no doubt, but Ed Sanders did it better.
soccerstar5930 4 years ago 3
yeah, Ed has a amazing voice.
paramoreclasses101 3 years ago 2
I have to agree. Josh is a grown man. I think this song is much cuter and more sentimental when little kids sing it.
I actually bawled during the movie when Lil' Ed sang it. I had the huges knot in my stomach thinking "God, now she's gotta kill 'em -sniff-!"
beautifullytragic1 3 years ago
i know. i didnt actually cry (im a hard-ass i just cant do it lol) and i was just like oh....this is awful, i dont want lil toby to die! lol but he didnt thankfully. but still i love that song.
soccerstar5930 3 years ago
I liked Ed Sanders version better. This one's too overdone.
djinnmasterkeladry 4 years ago
didn't think I'd like it, but was pleasently surprised. :)
thealexmusical 4 years ago
I love him. His voice is just incredible. I could listen Josh's singing for the rest of my life and never get tired.
drakkis 4 years ago 2
If you like josh groban and his song "the prayer"...Type "Coppell Talent Show" and hear two Texas High School All-State singers. The guy SOUNDS like Josh and the girl is amazing.
BstGuy18 4 years ago
HAPPY BIRTHDAY JOSH!!!!!!!!!! :D
AFVfan1 4 years ago
*squeals* omg josh..singing a sweeny todd song!! omg!! thats orgasmic!
duckie0106 4 years ago
-squeal- I love Josh!! And Sweeney! OMG!!!
HiddenBeauty 4 years ago
Whoa Sweeney Todd and Josh Groban. Interesting combonation, but still pretty good!
Fixalot 4 years ago
wow thats amazing and so incredible. what an amazing man
KatieGroban4ever 4 years ago
wow, I had no idea he'd done this song! Not bad!! I love this song. :D
aeromilagro85 4 years ago
i am so not a fan. no offense, i just don't like his voice. but i love this song.
another1shortdaymore 4 years ago
I'm sorry guys, JG is absolutely brutal
blayreellestad 4 years ago
in one word: breathtaking
bballsk8tergirl 4 years ago
it was nice - he sat on the edge of the stage for this song - the fans were allowed to come up. He signed a few things and shook hands. Never seen anyone do this before -not while singing the whole time. He is real special.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
Nope - it was at the Air Canada Center in Toronto.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
Oh my God - was this the concert at Bobcats Arena in Charlotte? I was there, and he was INCREDIBLE. I cried during this song - I couldn't help it! He's got to be one of the most beautiful men on this Earth...
SqueegeePie 4 years ago
Nope, this was at the Air Canada Center in Toronto.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
Heheh, yeah, I've been perusing the footage - I guess he did this at all the concerts. Regardless, it's beautiful!
SqueegeePie 4 years ago
I love this song, and Josh Groban's voice is amazing. I don't really care that it was bland acting, JG isn't an actor and this was a concert.
aliauthor 4 years ago
You do know its bland because he isnt acting the part, hes signing the song from his classical training background.
DIsneylandfreak07 4 years ago
This is a concert, not a musical theater presentation.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
No shit. Im saying its bland cause hes not acting out the song, ,just singing it.
DIsneylandfreak07 4 years ago
wow, how pretty. Very pretty voice. excuse me as I fall asleep.
ZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...
LordMoe9 4 years ago
ahhhhhhhhhhhh... Josh Groban is the Toby to my Mrs. Lovett lol.
harmoniouskazoo 4 years ago 2
I was so there. I thought this was a great a version of this song. <3
Dorianslover 4 years ago 2
Lots of other versions of that song on here - go watch them.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
My GOD he's so bland.
buddyboy80 4 years ago 3
ed sanders in the new film is so much better than this one. I like josh groban but not this song
cappuccinokid06 4 years ago 2
haha good stuff
6tinkerbelle9 4 years ago
lol yea i was on your right...he was so amazing! cant wait till he comes back to toronto...hes coming back for a liek "various artists" thing but i would rather just see him, rather then him for a couple of songs and a whole bunch of other people
6tinkerbelle9 4 years ago
(I had to get my ticket lol) I was in section 323 row 3
6tinkerbelle9 4 years ago
helena bonham carter does alot better in my eyes
OhdudeWTF 4 years ago
She barely even sings in this song. How can you say that she sings better than Josh Groban?
yumichan89 4 years ago
ehh. I love josh but I was just in sweeney todd and he did an ok version of the song, it just wasnt how it was meant to be sung by the character. but of course it was a concert and not a performance of the show, so he did it well for his audience.
Pianoman011 4 years ago
OMG I love Josh's voice....seriously he needs to sing Johanna
SweetFlava789 4 years ago
great voice most definitely...I just don't like this song on him...
TheActressChick 4 years ago
i'd rather hear him sing johanna...
iseestarsinyou 4 years ago
he is amazing, but did he ever actually do sweeney todd? he might upstage evryone if he did.
Hoppusisgod 4 years ago
He's too old to play Toby and too young to play Sweeney. He might do Anthony ok, though. He could knock "Johanna" out of the park.
corvus13 4 years ago
and he seems soooooo down to earth!!!! I have never seen a singer sign autographs and sit with fans during a concert before!!! i loved it!!...O man i wanted to marry that man that night....it was disgusting how much i loved him hahaha
6tinkerbelle9 4 years ago
you were there?
uogb 4 years ago
yesss but i was in the 300's...amazing concert :D
6tinkerbelle9 4 years ago
Great video, great quality. I love this song!
NCGrobanFan 4 years ago
yeah, it's the emotion that he puts in to his songs.
NCGrobanFan 4 years ago
he is amazing!the biggest talent this world will ever know!me a grobanite?you bet!love this sexy man
grobanluvva 4 years ago
I am crying. Thank-you!
lultimanotte315 4 years ago
Wonderful!Lucky you!I would so like to see him life once!
r8p6 4 years ago
OMJ!!!! this is so lovely, thanks for posting :*
Melodia222 4 years ago
flawless. he looks so happy while he's singing...
ncmiles400 4 years ago
He sits on the edge of the stage and invites fans to come stand around him when he sings. It is an amazing and wonderful thing to experience.
madrefiera 4 years ago
I was ten rows back, but my little camera had a very good zoom on it - 10x. He was sitting ion the edge of the stage for that one song.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
when? where?
mhand00 4 years ago
Toronto Canada-- March 5 I am a bit slow getting stuff up and running.
OneJoshFan 4 years ago
Its really great. You must have been very close and it lookd like he is standing at the same level as the audience.
mhand00 4 years ago