Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (54)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I dont agree with anyone that said Orange Caramel - Magic Girl is copied from this song, they just the same type of song, like rap, techno, pop, etc (don't know what this type called tho). And the soundtrack is really different ...

  • I was like "I don't hear how this is like Orange Caram--" then the chorus came on. Good God....

  • I hope I'm not to only one disturbed by the crowd of middle-aged men cheering and gazing at these young girls......

  • Never thought I'd hear that a K-pop copied a song from a J-pop group!

  • @kohakohasupafan well there is a korean cover of love revolution 21 too XD -which sucks, but ok-

  • @xxHartBrokenxx yeah but they had permission so its not like it was copied. and i kinda liked the rap :)

  • mai is the girl that does the voice of hikaru from kirarin revolution, isnt it?

  • @KayleighSmyth Yes n__n she has some songs with koharu C:

  • a k-pop group called orange caramel ripped this song off! look up "orange caramel magic  girl" the melody is the same and everything

  • I love how the wotas say "Maimai!!" and "Nakky!!" out loud. Here in the Philippines, all you hear are fangirls screaming at the top of their lungs like there's no tomorrow...

  • This song is a song released on March 12, 2008.

    How do their copied?

  • Lol not reading through all the comments because its just people talkin to each other about OC?(Idk what orange caramel is. but whatever.) Thats not what we're on here for NOW are we? NAKKY & MAIMAI are an awesome duet and this rocks and they sound cute doing the "ouu~lalala"

    This are the types of comments there should be haha!! ^_^

  • Hmm ...

    I think Orange Caramel fan is willing to tell it.

    "O.C are better singer of these children. "

    But I think if your singer better than it was, these kids. Why do they need to replicate with each song.

    f you think that cool.

    Don't cool on the computer screen.

    I never hated this band.

    But I hate the fans of this band. (Exception the good fan ^^)

    Lol........

  • 小舞好可愛>V<

  • Sure, not the entire song is similar, and the writers of "Magic Girl" might not have realised the similarites between it and "Hare no Platinum Doori" at first, but even Radiohead had the guts to credit Albert Hammond and Mike Hazlewood for similiarities between Radiohead's song "Creep", and The Hollies' "The Air That I Breathe" after discovering similarities between their songs. Just because the similarities are minor and/or unintentional doesn't mean that Tsunku shouldn't be credited.

  • @jfatsnorlax thats what i thought!! they sounded so similar i had a double take and played them at the same time and they matched up perfectly!

  • @jfatsnorlax Just because the composers of "Magic Girl" by made a song that sounds like "晴れのプラチナ通り"(which it doesn't btw) by coincidence then why the hell do they need to credit the composers of this song? It doesn't make sense, it's like you make something that by coincidence, resembles something else and just because they resemble each other you have to give the orginal creator credit even though the both ideas are orginal?

  • stop comparing them with OC!!!!! FOR God`s sake, dont bring the fanwars in jpop videos, they are usually peaceful!!!!!!!!

  • Wow it kinda does sound like orange caramels song but orange caramel is better only becuz the dance is a workout and nana raina and lizzy are suer cute in the mv and afterschool is my fave girl band

  • @ntxhiavmim biased too much? lol I like After School but saying that them are better here is rude and you are comparing adults women with kids LOL plus, you dont make look better the other after school fans

  • this is freaking brainwashing.

    i swear i came back to this vid 3 times today just to see them perform! xD

    but srsly can you imagine..

    you're 12 years old doing a live performance for fans and the ENTIRE audience is a bunch of old men ?! O_O"

    the japanese are hard core ;)

  • Orange Caramel-Magic Girl

    Its Better♥

  • i feel sorry for them i mean just imagine you are a kid and and seeing your fans are all grown ups. in other case "(insert P word here)"

  • @sentaioubleach was thinking the same! :/

  • @iApplefreakk thank god i'm only 18 makes it all better for me then (i'm not a P dammit!)

  • this is an amazing performance. Mai is so cute <3 (pun not intended)

  • WOW! this was the song that the Orange Caramel girls COPIED!

    SHOOT! this is waaaaaaaaaaay better than the O.C. girls :]]

    people of the universe~ 晴れのプラチナ通り is the FiRST one, not the magic girl.

  • @MsShoKura

    THAT Coreans biatch who havent talent are copying HELLOPROJECT,by their style,song (c-ute : hare platinium doori) and dresses.

    WHUT THE HELL ? cant they be theirselves,or did they must copy the others ?

    Il y a 2 secondes · J’aime

  • LOL.....orange caramel's magic girl

  • Mai !!!!

    XD

  • SUCH A CUTE SONG!!!

    This song is so good.

    I know have to listen to more of there songs. xD

  • who said this song is similar with orange caramel Magic Girl? it's different!!

  • @MrEveell there's only a tiny similarity, i think, with their choruses

  • @MrEveell it's not diffrent..just some ways but it is similar

  • Both girls are amazing! Some of the members don't get enough screen time which is a shame, because they're all wonderfully talented :)

  • i im in love wit h both disco queens of my heart delight

  • adoro a saki

    s genial¡¡¡

    :3

  • a mi me gustan las doooooooooos pero mas mai mai XD!! i lve you mai mai,eres genial sigue asi y desfalcaras a todas las de project XD

  • Love the outfit

  • I love Mai.

  • Me too^^

  • mai is love<3

  • sakiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

  • 私はあなたを愛する!!

  • they're saying "Maimai" and and "Nakky"

  • mai is so cute and pretty that she is even getting her own pb on october!

  • umm... was this during summer or around october and stuff?

  • Those two make awesome duets! =D

    Disco Queen was also great! ^3^

    They sound sooo good together!! x3

  • how old is she??

  • If you're talking about Mai then she's 13.

  • which ones mai the one in pigtails

  • yes.

  • Mai has got such an amazing voice for her young age!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more