Added: 1 year ago
From: GilmourTrueHD
Views: 161,103
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (551)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • In 10 minutes i have a lesson .. Damn i can not listen to the whole song although it is gonna be the 17 time for today ..

  • Amo esta banda ...............

  • David Gilmour was born in some kind of parralel universe or diferrent galaxy.. but he is definetely not from Earth. Fucking genious

  • WOW

    

  • there will never ever, be music like this. Amazing.....Pink Floyd

    

  • I don't know who wrote them but the lyrics are genius

  • @drogonfly88 Although many of the group's later albums would be unified by a central theme with lyrics written mainly by Roger Waters, the Whole Meddle album was a group effort with lyrical contributions from each member.

  • @drogonfly88 Waters did! The one and only...........

  • pinnacle of music

  • Incredible.

  • I have no words... absolutely nothing to say about this... I just prefer listen this song again...

  • I have no words... absolutely nothing to say about this...

  • About as good as it gets :) Thank God for Mr Gilmour/Mason/Waters and Wright as well as the ensemble who performed so fabulously on this track.. Makes the heart soar

  • Watching this whole thing with my new headphones and RainyMood was one of the most spiritual experiences of my life.

  • 17:49

  • i would pay millions to be here

  • one of the best ever!!!!!!

  • The last 5 minutes, are absolutely perfect...

  • pure perfection.that's just it

  • ¡Que pasón que pasonzote!.

  • Gilmour's tone at the beginning and end of this song is about the best clean tone I've ever heard. It almost sounds like he's using a Tube Driver with the utmost minimum gain, or perhaps the Compulator and a very loud Hiwatt.

  • that first ping always sends a chill down my spine

  • rest in peace - rick wright!

  • Great.

  • Oh, Rick... How I miss you.......

  • Once, someone asked me how much my longest orgasm lasted. My answer was: 25 fucking minutes and 11 fucking seconds.

  • MISS YOU MR WRIGHT

  • Que perfección que sonido que calidad PERFECTOO

  • Godfathers of space rock. Dudes are from another universe.

  • Perfection indeed

  • una OBRA MAESTRA

  • I could listen to 21:00 to 24:00 forever

  • @Avantex13 from time to time i would need a reminder to what that part the finishing touches are though

  • @Avantex13 I could listen to 00:00 to 25:11 forever and ever.

  • Thank you for sharing this.

  • This solo and the Comfortably Numb solo is probably my favorites

  • Statements just seem vain at last...

  • is there the mp3 version of this video, ofc full 25 min, cause all downloaders cannot do more than 20 mins i guess..

  • Comment removed

  • i reallllllllllllly hope your coming to edmonton Mr.Gilmour that would be a dream come true

  • The second Guitar part for this piece is bit un-glamorous -Dave Gilmore has all this juicy large sound show case with effects and massive overdriven passages, the other guy has these dry repetitive rhythm pieces..what a rip off :-(

  • This is what music means. Epic!

  • 04:30 to get in the 4th dimension

  • 17:55 = orgasm :)

  • After this i would even subscribe to my dog lol

  • This is not Pink Floyd. Just sayin'

  • so this is what its like to cum your pants.

  • Truely EPIC! Need I say more? I think not.

  • @DEF0963 truly...not truely..dang typo

  • Wow... this " is " perfection . Makes you wonder who Gilmour and Wright listen to ?

  • @507barry Roger Waters ;)

  • @507barry Hah- that's an interesting question. Well, Wright's listening to the celestial choir these days, I guess. I did hear him say in an interview once that he never listened to PF on his own time, but he didn't say who he did listen to.

  • fantastic

  • replay and again, and again anda again...........orgasmic!!!

  • Comment removed

  • This is just MAGIC

  • Byłem 50 metrów od Dave'a & Rick'a :D

  • Para mí esto fue la última entrañable conversación y abrazo afectuoso entre David y Rick !!

    For me, this was the last close conversation and the last lovely hug between David and Rick !!

  • 6 people were blinded by the light effects when clicking the like button

  • All I can say is "WOW"!

  • A partir del 21:00 Presente toda la fineza y magnificencia del Rock Progresivo.

  • after 22:00 is a fuckin' dream... he provokes me goosebumps, sweat, sexual excitation... if I believed in God, I'd thank him for creating David Gilmour and, most of all, for creating music

  • 6 lady gaga fans heard this song .

  • The lights/lasers at the concert is just incredible. This is has more lights than if Zeus, Jupiter, and Thor were to fight. Whoever was actually there, well, they dont know how lucky they are

  • 14:38 EPIC

    

  • OMG! I've lost my brain!

  • Comment removed

  • M00:00RE !! :D

  • l'himalaya de la musique pop des années 70 ! groupe majeur , long live rock !

  • 6 people must die

  • Solo ellos fueron capaces de crear semejante atmósfera. Genios!

  • This album should be in every school in every country, every province, every village in the compulsory subjects list !!!!!!

  • Byłem tam:)

  • @czester179 to jesteś szczęściarzem...

  • genius

  • I'm from Poland and I haven't been there...what a shame ;/

  • i have just been informed that merriam-webster has adopted this performance as the definition of EPIC!

  • PINK FLOYD NO ES DE ESTE MUNDO !!!!

  • If there was a God for music..it would be Pink Floyd!

  • One of the greatest musical orgasms of my life.

  • @introvabile me 2

  • THANK GOD FOR 720P

  • 17:55 <3

  • Absolutely beautiful. I was born in the wrong era.

  • 06:47 - 11:20

    Silence, two genius at work.

  • this song is magic, gave my goosebumps nearly the whole thing

  • Comment removed

  • The echo of a distant time

    Comes willowing across the sand

    And everything is green and submarine...

    Love Guilmour ! and loved this version

  • Pink Floyd brings out emotions, not sure which one...just raw emotions,thanks for posting!

  • Too bad Roger Waters wasn't there :(

  • 6 dislikes. Nice try Bieber fans =)))

  • imposible explicar lo que se siente al ver y escuchar este temazoo... simplemente es como subir al cielo y despues de 25 minutos volver a este mundo ... :D GRANDE PINK FLOYD

  • SOOOOOOO SICKKKKKKKK!

  • Gdansk, I was there. great time, super version of classic Pink Floyd song. the best band ever!!!

  • That guitar is one of the most beautiful things i have ever seen.

  • I really like this version but the Pompeii version will always be the greatest thing I've seen them do live. Could be because of the era in my life where I first happened upon it. It's bittersweet to see Wright in this now. From what I remember, it wasn't very long between when he found he had cancer till he passed away. Watching this, I'm sure he and Dave prob had plans to go on with further projects but he was actually dying unbeknownst to both of them.

  • The best guitar solo ever. Especially since im stoned

  • pink floyd restano i numeri 1 nel mondo..ciao da italy

  • Just perfect.

  • ¿Que habrán sentido los músicos que tocan al lado de Rick y David?. ♥

  • Perfecta♥

  • 21:01 LOVE!!!!

  • one of the best videos i have ever seen on youtube and one of the best i ever will see.

  • The best version of the best song in the FUCKING WORLD!!

  • 00:00 REPLAY BUTTON.

  • there u go AJ, !!!!!!!

  • wikipedia org Australian Pink Floyd Show

  • Was 15 in 1979, was lucky enuff 2 see the wall. Also saw P.F.#3 in 88 & 94 at Arrowhead Stadium. (Kansas City) Absolutely the greatest band to evert exist!!! See australian Floyd if u get the chance, fairly accurate reproduction. Rock on.

  • Best version of Echoes I've listened to!

  • @ClaraPNAraujo i don't know ..... this piece is beyond perfection ... but the one in pompeii .... is GODLIKE

  • @ClaraPNAraujo same

  • @ClaraPNAraujo Echoes Live in Gdansk

  • @ClaraPNAraujo echoes the acoustic version is a great version too.

  • Unlike other bands, they just seem to get better with time... there is no sign of decadence, they just sound better... and already sounded good when they were young.

    Just awesome!!

  • Que banda es unica,es la mejor de todos los tiempo el rock progresivo/clasico..

  • Were is gdansk?

  • @MrAdrien1999

    It is one of the biggest cities in Poland, a place where Solidarity was formed and where the peaceful transformation of communist block started in 1980s.

  • @KKWisniewski1 thanks!

  • GRANDE GILMOUR Y WRIGHT CONCHETUMARE ! DESDE CHILE ♥

  • and I am you and what I see is me

  • R.I.P Richard Wright

  • @KaanPensatore1986 No dude, mine aren't siblings. BUt unlike yours, they are at least from the same species. Now go fuck off and play on the freeway before I have to remind you of what you really are.

  • @KaanPensatore1986. On an even more serious note, let's find out why two people wasted 15 seconds on your conception.

  • @kaveman1021

    Conception-HELL. They kept the afterbirth

  • My favorite song from my favorite Pink Floyd era. Fuck all that paranoid shit from the ego maniacal mind of Roger Waters!

  • @KaanPensatore1986 If you don't like the song, just keep it to yourself. No-one values your opinion.

  • @CrapTurret94

    Do not worry one of these days you get smart enough to learn how to read something from left to right. I do not need google to understand plain English. It is a good thing, That you tube auto corrects..

    So indeed you fail....

  • @Secondlifecreator Based on these comments alone, I know who the intelligent one is (myself), so I don't need to prove this to you. Enjoy your life of ranting on the internet to people who don't care what you have to say.

  • @KaanPensatore1986

    And kids? never seen kids here selling off as whores. Unlike you might know, the like ATM machines like yourself...sucker.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @KaanPensatore1986

    Simple anwser?

    Because there more skilled then you, that is why you sit behind you keyboard trying to be a real musical wonder. While the made with this, crappy composition over MILLIONS of dollars, I mean wth the know ? There just amateurs that make per gig more then any modern can make.

    The were asked to tour as a PF formation again, the declinded *offer was 150million usd*

    I mean wtf the know right? ...idiot that u are...

    End of this lesson...

  • Comment removed

  • @KaanPensatore1986 Is your life really so empty that you spend time looking up Youtube videos of bands you don't like, so you can complain about them and get attention? That's really sad.

  • Comment removed

  • This song is a masterpiece:) i don't understand why people can't understand what real music is. Pink Floyd are legends, They worked hard,but lucky rich kids parents pay a fortune to make their kids stars, of course many of them do not deserve it all. Talent is different from those who worked their life of than Bieber that gets things served in his hands. "Pink Floyd" changed music by making their own style and will always be many bands and musicians biggest influence.

  • @KaanPensatore1986 I'd prefer to know why someone would waste 2 minutes of their lives writing some of the massive crap out there now. See, unlike you, some people actually enjoy this kind of thing. Need proof? Look at hundreds of millions of albums Floyd sold. Nuff said. You don't like it, don't listen to it.

  • @KaanPensatore1986 Then What the Fuck are you doing here !! Go and listen to Justin Bieber and other gays in pop music,and let us,fans of the real music, to enjoy this epic song !!! Long live PINK FLOYD !! R.I.P Richard and Syd !!!

  • would you people SHUT UP and enjoy the music..take your mouth spewin to another website and leave utube to the grateful ones......

  • @jimihendrix225 Sorry mate, I just can't handle idiots who have no clue that come to bag out the music & the people... I have to say something to them... Enjoy & cheers.

  • @KaanPensatore1986 Man I was just kidding !! And if you think that you are bigger fan of Pink Floyd just because you don't know meaning of the word ''joke'',than you are stupid !!! ''Fuck all that ...'' and fuck fans like you are !!

  • Es epica, grandiosa, simplemente excelsa.

  • @KaanPensatore1986 So what you are really saying is... "your mother doesn't know which sailor got her pregnant when the fleet docked." Anyway, I am happy the government have computers for people like you in the sheltered workshops...

  • @KaanPensatore1986 Mate, I feel sorry for your father. I bet he is troubled by regret, now & will be to the day he dies. Knowing that he should have just had a wank that day you were conceived...

  • Awesome song, but live at pompeii version will still be my favourite, almost listen to it on daily basics

    @KaanPensatore1986 kiddo, you are obviously desperately craving for attention to post retarded comment such as this one, you're such a terrible troll wannabe. Try subtleness next time, it might work...

  • The biggest wish in my life is to see Mr.David Gilmour live !! And after that I would like to get laid, because I am 16 :)

  • @edinslash126 Great expectations for your life man.

  • @edinslash126 keep the faith!! sex is good, but David Gilmour is awesome

  • @XzevastianX Well I said first of all to see Mr.David Gilmour,and then sex and other stuff !! :) and it is nice to see someone who understands my jokes !!

  • @edinslash126 totaly agree

    

  • @superstratman13

    And hearing them on my 4 15 inch cerwin vegas & Onkyo(125W. per channel receiver is good also!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @edinslash126 laid by gilmuour? hes much older.

  • this song is so epic...23minutes of special music!

  • 5 people like Rebecca Black.

  • I don't know why everyone says "David did this" and "Roger that"...NEWS FLASH they are all great. When Syd Barrett "left" David had a huge responsibility of taking over and he did it. Richard Played Amazing in the keyboards and singing. Without Nick's drums they would be lost. And Waters deep lyrics are the ones that made Pink Floyd unique. Give credit to each and one of the members because them combined made the most amazing music to have ever exited!!!

  • R.I.P. Richard Wright !!

  • who care's about the funky part? this guitar solo is EPIC!

  • smokin' jam

  • The 5 dislikes where from the people who's computer broke because it couldn't handle the epicness of Pink Floyd.

  • Jimmy Page said "There will be Led Zeppelin until Jimmy Page, Robert Plant, John Paul Jones, John Bonham will be alive" and the same thing worths for Pink Floyd.. now that Richard is dead, there won't be Pink Floyd any more, it would have no sense to replace him.. think at Queen + Paul Rodgers.. nothing to matter with the original Freddie Mercury.. then maybe I'm wrong..

  • @TheAlberock I agree with you. Roger Waters' backing band is excellent, is own son Harry is an amazing keyboardists, but Waters does the Floyd material, it's not quite right, it's the sense of everything....the timing even the way the notes are played. I was reasured again with the Live 8 performance, which was basically just the four of them. It's like they have some kind of telepathy with each other, that's just magic.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • OMG!

    How could you click on this video then hit the "Dislike" button???

  • this song is an experience!!!