I find it rather fascinating - but also a bit intimidated - when I see someone really young playing something this advanced. It reminds me of one of my Grade 2 classmates...she could play Grade 10 (Canadian RCM) at the time.
Some of the sustained notes weren't actually held all that long, but considering Hannah's age (and therefore, the size of her hands), that's understandable. A valient effort, nonetheless - I certainly couldn't play like that when I was 8!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't hear the three voices quite distinctly, and they don't 'sing', hence the previous comment of being 'not musical' . Some notes were not played; maybe because of her small hands some compromise had to be made. It eventually sounded like a two-part invention. But still very impressive for an 8-year old.
marktgm - Based on your commments, I'd say you weren't "impressed," liar.
Look, she has a teacher and doesn't need your negative comments. She's not playing to suit YOUR taste, get it? Nor is she paying you for your negativity. So please..
brings me to tears...it just moves me so much to see that a child has more talent in her fingers than i posess in my entire body. love love love this little girl.
ive been watching all videos of pianoist kids on this youtube and your the best ive sene yet. Hannah looks like she really feels the music and that is TALENT that was born in you xxx I LOVE U
Thumbs up if you where searching for hannah plays
addeyyry 3 weeks ago
She is really a little dancer on a piano and play bach ha ha ha lol....
tytocuto 11 months ago
GOD! I'M 16 AND I HAVE JUST FINISHED THIS PIECE!!! CONGRATULATIONS HANNAH!!!
unitedofficelu 1 year ago
@unitedofficelu Congratulations to you, really, because YOU have the correct age, not only some month!!! ;-)
AlanLeonheart 1 year ago
@AlanLeonheart thank you! :)
unitedofficelu 1 year ago
@unitedofficelu :-)
AlanLeonheart 1 year ago
Invention?
KevinBeethoven 1 year ago
such a fun piece to play. I like it more on the guitar trio but really good!
offkillerz 1 year ago
Bravo!you are a very good piano player Hannah.That was my favorite D major invention iv'e ever heard.
MrStephenwang 2 years ago
Comment removed
MrStephenwang 2 years ago
why you have to move all of your body when you are playing
iiuud 2 years ago
Probably because she enjoys the music? Why does Glenn Gould hum and wave his hand around while he plays?
danielkirk1 2 years ago
I dont think shes forced, you can tell she has expression in the music that cannot be forced :)
dauiske79 2 years ago 3
I have to learn this...but I'm 22:-)
mucchina87 2 years ago 10
If you get possible to play this piece like her,you are advanced level.
hashirimedes 2 years ago 4
hashirimedes, thaks for your encouragement:)
I've been practicing this for two months and now I can play it quite well. my teacher is very satisfied with me:)
mucchina87 2 years ago 4
Congratulation!
I also am practising this nice piece.
Hannah's video is one of my video-teachers.
hashirimedes 2 years ago 10
despite the age. everybody loves bach :) so wonderful
kedonsiemen 3 years ago 4
i like your hands and how you saty playing piano..i think you play with emotions, Bravo good girl.
valeerioo45 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she's kind of good i guess...what ever. i could probably kick her ass in a fight though.
SaiyanPrince339 3 years ago
Bravo !!
koubache 3 years ago
I find it rather fascinating - but also a bit intimidated - when I see someone really young playing something this advanced. It reminds me of one of my Grade 2 classmates...she could play Grade 10 (Canadian RCM) at the time.
Some of the sustained notes weren't actually held all that long, but considering Hannah's age (and therefore, the size of her hands), that's understandable. A valient effort, nonetheless - I certainly couldn't play like that when I was 8!!!
KitakLaw 3 years ago
聲音太乾也呆板,且一些3.4拍的音太短,姿勢動作太大造成音色及重心不穩,收尾不夠漂亮
kenwei93 3 years ago
Lemme translate for the western guys 'n girls: »She just plays incredible apart from her age.« ;-)))
freddyfamous 2 years ago 5
fantastic!
bmw0912 3 years ago
Very expressive =D
neoguy9090 3 years ago
Nice :)
I'm 13 and just perfecting this now.
I would say that it's a little jumpy in some parts, but I guess that's small hands for you!
Keep up the good work!
JoanneWx 3 years ago 4
amazing for an 8 year old
vivian333999 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can play it better.
ralkramralkram 4 years ago
Ok, play it right now, and show us, we'll be laughing if you can't!
I thought it was great, it's so beautiful that young people can learn these great things.
Bravo!
Ch1t0s3H1b1yA 3 years ago
>> ralkramralkram
She's only 8.
R u comparing ur skill to 8 yr-old girl's???
She's toooo good at her age.
ikachanusa 3 years ago
bravo h
unalegeli 4 years ago 3
I really like the Bach inventions. I thought you did a nice job.
jewell11 4 years ago
Nice job little one !!
prariethunder 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its not to suit his tastes, its not being played as the music was written. its a blasphemy against god
shorttyler 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't hear the three voices quite distinctly, and they don't 'sing', hence the previous comment of being 'not musical' . Some notes were not played; maybe because of her small hands some compromise had to be made. It eventually sounded like a two-part invention. But still very impressive for an 8-year old.
marktqm 4 years ago
marktgm - Based on your commments, I'd say you weren't "impressed," liar.
Look, she has a teacher and doesn't need your negative comments. She's not playing to suit YOUR taste, get it? Nor is she paying you for your negativity. So please..
go away.
PianoCriticsKiller 4 years ago
If you dont want to have some bad comments or critics on u'r music, simple don't place it on youtube.
Btw. Well played, but try to let hear the three voices clearer.
iAmRogier 4 years ago 6
oooooooooooooo
hugoDark678 4 years ago
Perfecting an already perfect technique. Her last thing to improve is speed.
Rendereason 4 years ago
I will see her performances over and over.
Rendereason 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she's cute. but not musical.
blydia 4 years ago
Not musical! what are you talking about? She is an absolutly amazing pianist(SP)
sailorcosmos113 4 years ago
IDOLA!
viiviia 4 years ago
WOW
lovelylisaa 4 years ago
its is really good. you fabulous
thepianolover4ever 4 years ago
Lovely.
sydneylocks 4 years ago 2
Too good, very nice, !
AnthonyB777 4 years ago
she has the art is the playing..not just technique..she plays in poetry..i want her to become famous. someone book her on jay leno or letterman.
Servaly 4 years ago
woww! you're amazing, keep practicing and by the time you're a teenager you'll be sooo pro!!
I'm 14 and I just learned that piece this year
so wow you're really impressive, keep it up! :)
nicnad 4 years ago
Very nice :)
krulz133 4 years ago
brings me to tears...it just moves me so much to see that a child has more talent in her fingers than i posess in my entire body. love love love this little girl.
Brookie678 4 years ago
ive been watching all videos of pianoist kids on this youtube and your the best ive sene yet. Hannah looks like she really feels the music and that is TALENT that was born in you xxx I LOVE U
leeshapopadom 4 years ago
Superb.
geniusoflvb 4 years ago
genius
Janeska182 4 years ago
wonderful!
sumboy 4 years ago
WOW
wmi10 4 years ago
beautiful - at this age too - does she glance at the music even once?
danstash 4 years ago
i actually now wish i had learned how to play the piano.
Hannah your a wonderfull pianist
doitseemslikeicare 4 years ago
bravo
nizarh 4 years ago
Wonderful, Hannah!
pianogirl98 4 years ago