now I would say that this is played by someone who obviously knows music, but when I listen to it, I can barely pick up that its How Great Thou Art - so as to say If I were not told that it was How Great Thou Art it would just sound like some random jazz. Also I would label this as sacrilegious as there is more emphasis on the pianist than the message of the hymn.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yep Jazz is great...but... sometimes you have to get a grip on reality and run with the idea "If it's not Broken don't fix it." Only I read the title I wouldn't have a clue what he was murdering!!!
itmefergal maybe you should learn something about music before you criticize something like this. i have been playing the piano for 12 years and i couldn't do anything close to that. he's a truly gifted pianist and took a great song and added a great style to it. no one in their right mind with any knowledge of music whatsoever could call this "murdering a song." great arrangement jhunt keep it up!
The song which was originally Southern Gospel, kind of lost its slow, touching meaning, but overall you did make it your own and that's what made it a good performance. 5***** :)
God doesnt care about the style of music DondaLonda all he cares about is the heart, u could worship God with an out of tune guitar in a shed and he'll still appreciate it, its not about the intstruments, its not about ability or talent God looks at the heart... read John 4:23 - 24
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think this is the worst thing I have ever heard!!! How Great Thou Art is a beautiful hymn, a love song, an anthem to the greatness of our God. This is a mockery of the hymn.
I love piano music, but I will NEVER listen to this again. It sounds awful!!!
Well thats just sad how people think just because it's different that you can't still worship God with it. Who said it has to be the way its ALWAYS BEEN. I believe my God accepts any music that is written for him. This man has a gift and he using it for the glory of God. Let me guess your a Baptist that goes to a traditional church that has no room for anything new or different. Take a music history class and you learn "traditional" music now was frowned upon years back. Open your mind.
ahhh, yes, claytonisglad, I too am a baptist and have been victim to the rigidness of the denomination. We are now allowed to clap in my church, in fact, the youth jump around. But that's a beside. I think it's better to be developing the good music so younger generations can appreciate what already has great words. And, hymns were considered the 'evil modern' music in my mum's day. Funny how things develop. I think this is awesome.
It's called sarcasm. I was questioning the intimation that God can only like one style. I actually believe that God loves music fullstop. He does have angels devoted only to singing praises to him and making music.
It's depending of church denomination or tradition, or rule, or country or people.
In my church, old hymn played with (or i can say with modification) mars, jazz (like this video) or pop - funk R 'n B genre, it's depending when your service, for child service, youth (funk and other) or older people (mars, jazz, or swing - i like swing)
Other hymn modified to other genre, "When The Saints Go Marching In":
This is 'How Great Thou Art'? I don't recognize any part of it (at all) in this video. It's like a completely different song, even for the jazz version of it.
Well, unless it is the performer's own version of it...but if that is the case, then he has a totally different view of the song than the traditional. I'm not saying he performed bad, because it sounded pretty good. I just can't hear any part of "How Great Thou Art" in there. I thought I knew jazz, but maybe I don't know it that well.
Ok, i can tell you; listen carefully the reff of How Great Thou Art @ 0:32, again @ 0:49, 1:36 and 1:51; it's an easy part to find it's How Great Thou Art or not.
Maybe yes, but i think it's dependent how individual taste/feel; i am enjoy this version, i ts very peace, smooth, easy listening when i am driving, or in public transportation.
The sheet music simply had cords and melody. Most everything you hear was improvised. All real jazz musicians play from charts showing the cords and melody.
Very cool. Its my goal to be able to transcribe such hymns into full scale transcriptions for piano...except my style is more classical/romantic. This is definately a piece of inspiration for my goal.
Bravissimo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tatyanapianista 4 days ago
I know no one will read this, but it’s worth a shot.
I’ll post it anyways, just in case.
I'm a pianist (16 years old), and have been for about 7 years. I know there are SO many in this world, but I'd like for you to see me.
I would love nothing more than to have people enjoy my music, and become popular on YouTube.
If anyone who reads this could press the "Thumbs Up" button, other people will see it.
Just a simple button press could make my dream come true. Thank you ♥
letschat6 2 months ago 4
Well, boaring theme, uninspired improvisation. This is no Jazz, it is Bar Jazz - a complete different thing...
FHenningsen42 2 months ago
Very nice!
dboydustin 3 months ago
Brilliant improvisation, you've got a great feeling for it, nice one mate
linclinc5 4 months ago
Amazing
jamiethomasqwerty 4 months ago
Jesus Jazz!!! awright now...this is so cool man, why it makes me just want to praise the Lord. hallelujah!!! great post.
damanfrom808 5 months ago
Muito bom...
Lega!
SamuelCardoso180511 8 months ago
now I would say that this is played by someone who obviously knows music, but when I listen to it, I can barely pick up that its How Great Thou Art - so as to say If I were not told that it was How Great Thou Art it would just sound like some random jazz. Also I would label this as sacrilegious as there is more emphasis on the pianist than the message of the hymn.
tommygunsegs 8 months ago
this is a perfect improvisation, I can wait until the day that I can do the same, I want to play some hymns at church-style Jazz.
heitorsd 10 months ago
nawww... I dpn't think so
rdoister 11 months ago
now THAT!!! was playing with soul!
spooner1957 1 year ago
yeah!i love it!!!!!!
camarillovicky 1 year ago
whoever disliked this video probably sucked or dont kno how to play
Nate3104 1 year ago
This is an amazing improvisation ! I wish I could learn jazz piano :)
kentseiyoung 1 year ago 2
an i love you the mucic
0pilin9 1 year ago
es la mejor mucica que escuche
0pilin9 1 year ago
meh.
dave1y2000 1 year ago
This is certainly so heartwarming...playing stride piano in tribute for his grandma! indeed,a very talented pianist! To God be the glory...
lalan1958 1 year ago
~sweet
rosetone50 1 year ago
Fake
juicestain117 1 year ago
@juicestain117
Jealous.
Ragtime44Films 1 year ago
Very-well done.
ryancangri 1 year ago
Wonderful Job!!!
MUSICROX83 2 years ago
Love it!! Love jazz and gospel music..You nailed them both!!!
idamay1 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yep Jazz is great...but... sometimes you have to get a grip on reality and run with the idea "If it's not Broken don't fix it." Only I read the title I wouldn't have a clue what he was murdering!!!
itsmefergal 2 years ago
itmefergal maybe you should learn something about music before you criticize something like this. i have been playing the piano for 12 years and i couldn't do anything close to that. he's a truly gifted pianist and took a great song and added a great style to it. no one in their right mind with any knowledge of music whatsoever could call this "murdering a song." great arrangement jhunt keep it up!
rifleman50cal 2 years ago 12
@rifleman50cal Okay maybe he didn't murder it, but he certainly made hash out of it. Some people like hash.
lightrays 1 year ago
@rifleman50cal thats his opinion and your's is yours.... no amount of experiance makes your opinions right...
xlhotlx 7 months ago
YES! This is HOT! He is killing this old hymn (in a good way).
professorlip 2 years ago
The song which was originally Southern Gospel, kind of lost its slow, touching meaning, but overall you did make it your own and that's what made it a good performance. 5***** :)
SouthernGospelPiano8 2 years ago
Comment removed
crazyghetto978818 2 years ago
can you gicve me the notes from this song?
nhangia 2 years ago 4
Sorry, this was all improvised. No music other than the basic cords and melody.
jhunt7111 2 years ago 2
@nhangia there's no sheet on jazz my friend...
gugunayie 1 year ago
Great groove, and nails the style, but in his own way. Cool!
joeholtsnotes 2 years ago
In WHAT way incredible?
Z1Z12 2 years ago 4
nice steinway and good playin ;-)
brownyluvsu 2 years ago
yea this isnt really jazz but i love it so much, just a much better way of playing a simple song :D
DrRevClarke 2 years ago
How do you mean its not realy Jazz!?
You cant listen to this same song and tell me it doesnt sound Jazzy!
Are we watchin the same video!? XD
shanevan1 2 years ago
It's not actually jazz. It's something between jazz and raggtime, and it sounds really awsome
rolesare 2 years ago 4
stride?
nickplee 2 years ago
yes...actually...I couldn't remeber the name for that style:P
rolesare 2 years ago
You smoke weed man.
michel6 2 years ago
Great! I hear bits of Brubeck, and it doesn't get any finer than that.
doothless 2 years ago
What a tasteful rendition!
robertBeach1961 3 years ago
Right on! Loved the composition and the spirit behind it. Keep rockin' brother!
bobdogg23 3 years ago
God bless you ! This is the most amazing How Great Thou Art I ever hear!!
sunwaypyramid 3 years ago
HOHOHO~~ a great jazz song
oh wait that's a hymn? which part of it?
it sounds more like a music you hear in bars where you have alcohol and girls
SwriIpooI 3 years ago
Open your heart. As long as he play with his heart to worship the Lord. What's wrong with that?
michaelatm2603 3 years ago
why does this have to be a religious debate? Can't you jsut appreciate music? Personally, I don't like it that much.
jazzlover06 3 years ago
++++1
steve is a musical genius.
jmanthirtyseven 3 years ago
Boy, you betta play that thang!
NotYourTypicalNegro 3 years ago
thats some great playin
RobinLaliberte 3 years ago
God doesnt care about the style of music DondaLonda all he cares about is the heart, u could worship God with an out of tune guitar in a shed and he'll still appreciate it, its not about the intstruments, its not about ability or talent God looks at the heart... read John 4:23 - 24
God bless x
JCUK08 3 years ago
i know. i was being sarcastic. i thought it was pretty obvious. especially since i'd just talked about how things have changed from era to era.
DondaLonda 3 years ago
Dont pay attention to any of the above coments. Excellent job! Esspecially love your runs!!
okera123 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think this is the worst thing I have ever heard!!! How Great Thou Art is a beautiful hymn, a love song, an anthem to the greatness of our God. This is a mockery of the hymn.
I love piano music, but I will NEVER listen to this again. It sounds awful!!!
dcy62 3 years ago
Well thats just sad how people think just because it's different that you can't still worship God with it. Who said it has to be the way its ALWAYS BEEN. I believe my God accepts any music that is written for him. This man has a gift and he using it for the glory of God. Let me guess your a Baptist that goes to a traditional church that has no room for anything new or different. Take a music history class and you learn "traditional" music now was frowned upon years back. Open your mind.
claytonisglad 3 years ago
ahhh, yes, claytonisglad, I too am a baptist and have been victim to the rigidness of the denomination. We are now allowed to clap in my church, in fact, the youth jump around. But that's a beside. I think it's better to be developing the good music so younger generations can appreciate what already has great words. And, hymns were considered the 'evil modern' music in my mum's day. Funny how things develop. I think this is awesome.
DondaLonda 3 years ago
apparently God only likes one style of music?
DondaLonda 3 years ago
Wrong! God looks at the heart. Whatever you do, the heart counts.
michaelatm2603 3 years ago
It's called sarcasm. I was questioning the intimation that God can only like one style. I actually believe that God loves music fullstop. He does have angels devoted only to singing praises to him and making music.
DondaLonda 3 years ago
I think it could be jazzed up without making hash out of it.
lightrays 3 years ago
right... but, you wouldn't expect something like this to be played on a fundamental church, wouldn't you?
yet, it's still a nice version...
F7dim 3 years ago
It's depending of church denomination or tradition, or rule, or country or people.
In my church, old hymn played with (or i can say with modification) mars, jazz (like this video) or pop - funk R 'n B genre, it's depending when your service, for child service, youth (funk and other) or older people (mars, jazz, or swing - i like swing)
Other hymn modified to other genre, "When The Saints Go Marching In":
watch?v=ErUrPXt31vo
watch?v=D0TkqycQ6GA
watch?v=Oph-v6pS3qs
stiktrik 3 years ago
I find it a bit far out for a solemn song like how "How Great Thou Art" to be played like that... It loses it's solemn feel...
F7dim 3 years ago
It's Jazz mode: ON, not play like hymn, but jazz.
stiktrik 3 years ago
Now that's style, mate...
losttwin 3 years ago
This is 'How Great Thou Art'? I don't recognize any part of it (at all) in this video. It's like a completely different song, even for the jazz version of it.
chrisgast 3 years ago
It's there...listen closely. It's definately a Jazz version.
stripesutube7 3 years ago
Its How Great Thou Art, or you can't find the different style?
stiktrik 3 years ago
Well, unless it is the performer's own version of it...but if that is the case, then he has a totally different view of the song than the traditional. I'm not saying he performed bad, because it sounded pretty good. I just can't hear any part of "How Great Thou Art" in there. I thought I knew jazz, but maybe I don't know it that well.
chrisgast 3 years ago
Ok, i can tell you; listen carefully the reff of How Great Thou Art @ 0:32, again @ 0:49, 1:36 and 1:51; it's an easy part to find it's How Great Thou Art or not.
stiktrik 3 years ago
I'm sorry. I still don't hear it. Great piano playing, though.
chrisgast 3 years ago
go to a black church in detroit and you will hear this stuff live and the way it was supposed to be played
twsstar 3 years ago 2
Sorry, but the medium (jazz) and the lofty tones of "How Great Thou Art" just can't be married. It trivializes the song. My opinionated opinion. :-)
juup212 3 years ago 2
Maybe yes, but i think it's dependent how individual taste/feel; i am enjoy this version, i ts very peace, smooth, easy listening when i am driving, or in public transportation.
stiktrik 3 years ago
Playing jazz mucis from sheet music?? BOO!
sautezFort 3 years ago
music**
haha I can't spell. yay
sautezFort 3 years ago
The sheet music simply had cords and melody. Most everything you hear was improvised. All real jazz musicians play from charts showing the cords and melody.
jhunt7111 3 years ago 15
@jhunt7111 not if they have them memorized ;)
SFuNk24 1 year ago
@jhunt7111 I'm not a jazz piano player, but all my piano playing is improvised, but I do look at chords for reference
idoltyler06 6 months ago
anybody know who wrote this arrangement, or anybody have a chord sheet?
CitationVPilot 3 years ago
his mom is my teacher
kmanblazzer 3 years ago
wow!
thats very nice!
really i apreciate the work of this man!
SirArmengol 3 years ago
Very cool. Its my goal to be able to transcribe such hymns into full scale transcriptions for piano...except my style is more classical/romantic. This is definately a piece of inspiration for my goal.
Very clever.
goodridgewinners 4 years ago