Christy Moore's cover is a new take on Merchant's version. It's great to see one of Natalie's songs covered by a person of other country. This cover stands on its own as a great song.
What chord is he playing with his thumb and wee finger does anyone know? If anyone knows the actual chords of the whole song too could they let me know. thx
Not sure of the chords of this but they shouldn't be too hard to find on Google. He's playing G with his wee finger....he always plays it like that, not sure why.
Just listened to the Natalie Merchant version and I still think Christy Moore performs it better. He's more passionate, and it seems to have more meaning to him when he sings it! The guitar also sounds far better in Christy's version. After all him and Declan are both a genius on the guitar, :-)
I have been a big Natalie Merchant fan (my understanding is that she wrote this), but this Christy Moore version makes the Natalie Merchant versions pale in comparison. Others mileage may vary! Even live, this just rolls off of his lips and guitar!
who knew music can have such emotion, Christy Moore seems to express emotion better than any other live acoustic artist and really just crushes all the crappy chart stuff these days
it's a great song, well performed also. still pondering what it's about; emigrants or suicidebombers (the album 'motherland' was dedicated to 9/11 victims). i think the latter. But the Irish accent makes it a bit off this world, almost a farewell. Tricky. Any opinions?
Nicely sung by Christy but... No one can sing this better than Natalie, they can do versions of, but Natalie's voice is a part of the song, it is intertwined with the words and melody.
Here's a test for you, who's singing the song when you hear it in your head?
@beroconnell: Glad you're going somewhere good now, shame some people can't just listen without judging, maybe they should look at themselves in the mirror before opening their mouth.
I left Ireland In 1988 to come to Canada.....because I was torn apart by a land that never respected what I had to offer. Seems to me the cruel world of Irish Politics has again infected those that have the same to offer has i did. Its sad but as we all know corruption is a wonderful thing among those when the good life seems to be obliterated from there normal way of life. For those of you who come to where I am " Welcome to Canada" you will enjoy and never look back
Oh this song .. Been away for 19 years from my Motherland and this is so moving, brings tears to my eyes at the best of times! Top - thanks for posting!
This is one of the best version's of this song i've heard so far and it's really meaninful, This means a lot to me, And i occasionally listen to it when i have problems - Why? Because it seems to take the worries away - Christy is a good Singer, Well done to him. Seem's nicer when a male is singing it. ^^
For one who listens to heavy metal such as myself there is always that one exception; that one beautiful song that sings with the soul. The song that just vibrates with you and give you sense of calm and that wonderful feeling when you put a blanket on and your all warm and safe. This song is it...
my opinion of merchant is she's a great lyricist, and she's a good musician, i personally just dislike her voice/singing style, and i like moore's cover better.
I can imagine Christy really cares about some of the previous posts. No, really. He's probably wounded. So, assuming I'm being sarcastic, some of the nay-sayers jumped on, to spout their venom on youtube... why exactly? Goddamn losers. Its a good song, leave it at that.
A lot of very strange comments on here..The very idea that Christy "should be" doing this or that, is ludicrous, Why pigeeon hole anyone in that way... I too prefer Natalie's version but with so much crap out there clogging the airwaves I am happy to hear this version drifting on the wind..
Wow people back off everyone quit the hating, These guys had asked Natalie Merchant permission for her song. Ms. Merchant was honored that they want to include one of her songs on their album, she a big fan of these guys. This info is posted on her official website, in older post. read about it.
@enyrb Where did I say it was the best? In fact I specifically said it maybe wasnt as good as Natalie's. Your attitude amazes me, just cos its Irish? what a chilsidh thing to say.
@enyrb What?! Thats bullshit, why shouldnt people try it? I think Christy does a great job, maybe not as good as Natalie but good all the same. You were obviously interested in listening to other versions if you clicked in here in the first place so give the stupid comments a rest.
It has much feeling before!!! I like the version of Natalie as well. I think she is one of the "feeling in song" in person! But I like Christy´s live version and the backing work of Declan is fantastic.
Thanks to fellow Celtic supporter for putting this up. A beautiful song and one that everybody can relate to. Christy yer the man the man wit the plan. Slan go foille Cath1888
did u listen to it then...? lol...think wee have a green eyed monster on this page....Mmm.....lol...natalie merchant recorded it aug/sept 2001 and if u take ur brain back to that time??
this song must have touched christy moore so much that felt the need to cover this painfull but true song, giving Natalie her due credit. debs
One of the best songs that has ever been written (by Natalie Merchant). Listen to the chorus! Christy and Declan have given this song so much feeling!!!
I Love This Song So Meaningful Me Peronally love It Because It Reminds Me Of Me Dad Singing It To Get Me To Sleep x Amaazinn Love You Dad x Brilliant Christy Well Done !!
I think this should be played in every abortion clinic. "..don't miss this waste land, this terrible place when you leave... Mother(land) cradle me, close my eyes, lullaby me to sleep, keep me safe, lie with me, stay beside me. Don't Go!"
Christy Moore, his voice is so awesome, like a warm irish whiskey.
I love to hear him sing this song, He is a legend.
Cathye3 3 months ago
@Cathye3 I am very agree !
guitarquejamais 5 days ago
Christy Moore's cover is a new take on Merchant's version. It's great to see one of Natalie's songs covered by a person of other country. This cover stands on its own as a great song.
epituchano 5 months ago
this is like a lullabie for us young irish lads gone away,and everytime we listen 2 this song,it draws a tear,but ina goodway!thanks christy
john665915 5 months ago 3
CHRISTY, a true living legend!!!
mawrchmandog 6 months ago
What chord is he playing with his thumb and wee finger does anyone know? If anyone knows the actual chords of the whole song too could they let me know. thx
SnowyNUFC 6 months ago
@SnowyNUFC
Not sure of the chords of this but they shouldn't be too hard to find on Google. He's playing G with his wee finger....he always plays it like that, not sure why.
dec8808 5 months ago
makes ya teary hah
paulbarrett1998 6 months ago
those 2 thicks who dis liked this must be degenerate english cunts
deannugent91 6 months ago
i love when my dad sings me this..has me teary :')
CherryLadiezz 6 months ago
Just listened to the Natalie Merchant version and I still think Christy Moore performs it better. He's more passionate, and it seems to have more meaning to him when he sings it! The guitar also sounds far better in Christy's version. After all him and Declan are both a genius on the guitar, :-)
MrKevyboy1 7 months ago
Comment removed
MrKevyboy1 7 months ago
Comment removed
xsowhatdontcare 8 months ago
whats the meaning of this song
creamius88 8 months ago
Pure silk, the man, his country, the passion, maybe one day I shall be in his audience
meggahappy 8 months ago
One of my favorite songs, and Christie gives us a great cover!
I moved across the country a few months ago and listening to this always makes me miss home...
Veovis523 9 months ago
I have been a big Natalie Merchant fan (my understanding is that she wrote this), but this Christy Moore version makes the Natalie Merchant versions pale in comparison. Others mileage may vary! Even live, this just rolls off of his lips and guitar!
jeffkohutgmailcom 9 months ago
The only artist that each time i see him, just gets better Queens hall embra 13/04/2011, fantastic!
Isllwyn 9 months ago
I want my own Christy Moore so he can sing me to sleep every night =]
PeaceNdLovee 1 year ago 7
PURE talent!! Id say its the first album i actually paid to download of itunes its that gud
Toxiccheese1990 1 year ago
who knew music can have such emotion, Christy Moore seems to express emotion better than any other live acoustic artist and really just crushes all the crappy chart stuff these days
Toxiccheese1990 1 year ago 2
it's a great song, well performed also. still pondering what it's about; emigrants or suicidebombers (the album 'motherland' was dedicated to 9/11 victims). i think the latter. But the Irish accent makes it a bit off this world, almost a farewell. Tricky. Any opinions?
bookshots 1 year ago
vintage christy,gifted.
mrjesabi 1 year ago
omg beautiful , what lyrics, what heart, wow
artistickone 1 year ago
go on ya cunt ya
squinn95 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
he is so handsom and single but he is a father naneedj.info
harshanamanju 1 year ago
Absolutely stunning.
7gustavo7 1 year ago
Nicely sung by Christy but... No one can sing this better than Natalie, they can do versions of, but Natalie's voice is a part of the song, it is intertwined with the words and melody.
Here's a test for you, who's singing the song when you hear it in your head?
@beroconnell: Glad you're going somewhere good now, shame some people can't just listen without judging, maybe they should look at themselves in the mirror before opening their mouth.
@coirpeach1: Hope you survive and get your rights
darkan99el 1 year ago
ta ocras ar na paiste ta siad ag lorg an eolas
blackbog69 1 year ago
Very good
DublinaThe 1 year ago
Comment removed
DublinaThe 1 year ago
Comment removed
DublinaThe 1 year ago
bero connel no 1 cares bou yer life story ffs, just a song dont cry
1916padraigPearse 1 year ago
I left Ireland In 1988 to come to Canada.....because I was torn apart by a land that never respected what I had to offer. Seems to me the cruel world of Irish Politics has again infected those that have the same to offer has i did. Its sad but as we all know corruption is a wonderful thing among those when the good life seems to be obliterated from there normal way of life. For those of you who come to where I am " Welcome to Canada" you will enjoy and never look back
beroconnell 1 year ago
@beroconnell why u telling us ur life story, dont cry for fuck sake its only a song
1916padraigPearse 1 year ago
@beroconnell Ill stay and fight for my rights
coirpeach1 1 year ago
Oh this song .. Been away for 19 years from my Motherland and this is so moving, brings tears to my eyes at the best of times! Top - thanks for posting!
aoife2209 1 year ago
This is one of the best version's of this song i've heard so far and it's really meaninful, This means a lot to me, And i occasionally listen to it when i have problems - Why? Because it seems to take the worries away - Christy is a good Singer, Well done to him. Seem's nicer when a male is singing it. ^^
Xhollie101X 1 year ago
Does any one know what the guy´s name is who is playing with Christy? This a very beautiful version. Perfection. I luv him.
mymsil 1 year ago 3
@mymsil Declan Sinnott
55911061 1 year ago 2
@55911061 Thanks!!
mymsil 1 year ago
Comment removed
jimbob885 1 year ago
love you Christy xxxx
123sweetpea1 1 year ago
Simple yet profound, i like it :)
signa111 1 year ago
best version
asparecus 1 year ago 2
wow!!! beautiful beautiful voice!!! always expresses every word with such emotion!!
goosebumps for me!! Christy we love you!!
clarrisina 1 year ago
beutiful,vintage christy.
mrjesabi 1 year ago
For one who listens to heavy metal such as myself there is always that one exception; that one beautiful song that sings with the soul. The song that just vibrates with you and give you sense of calm and that wonderful feeling when you put a blanket on and your all warm and safe. This song is it...
arcaneaddict 1 year ago 6
best version of all
scuttx1 1 year ago
my opinion of merchant is she's a great lyricist, and she's a good musician, i personally just dislike her voice/singing style, and i like moore's cover better.
gourdguru 1 year ago
This is beautifull
Mavlik 1 year ago
For the record...I love this.
lorenrt303 1 year ago 2
I can imagine Christy really cares about some of the previous posts. No, really. He's probably wounded. So, assuming I'm being sarcastic, some of the nay-sayers jumped on, to spout their venom on youtube... why exactly? Goddamn losers. Its a good song, leave it at that.
darkklaxxon1 1 year ago
go on the christy,never away from the hills of donegal when i miss home,over in oz,thank christy,makes me feel at home for a couple of mins,
john665915 1 year ago
A lot of very strange comments on here..The very idea that Christy "should be" doing this or that, is ludicrous, Why pigeeon hole anyone in that way... I too prefer Natalie's version but with so much crap out there clogging the airwaves I am happy to hear this version drifting on the wind..
gudlisner501 2 years ago 32
@gudlisner501
I completely agree.
bosspug 1 year ago
most of u what the fuck it's a beautiful song and he sings it better than any of u could so what the fuck u talkin about
waznip 2 years ago 3
Wow people back off everyone quit the hating, These guys had asked Natalie Merchant permission for her song. Ms. Merchant was honored that they want to include one of her songs on their album, she a big fan of these guys. This info is posted on her official website, in older post. read about it.
dtoolis 2 years ago
@enyrb Where did I say it was the best? In fact I specifically said it maybe wasnt as good as Natalie's. Your attitude amazes me, just cos its Irish? what a chilsidh thing to say.
AranGalactico 2 years ago
@enyrb What?! Thats bullshit, why shouldnt people try it? I think Christy does a great job, maybe not as good as Natalie but good all the same. You were obviously interested in listening to other versions if you clicked in here in the first place so give the stupid comments a rest.
AranGalactico 2 years ago
go fuck yourself ya langer, no one asked you
trevorfitzcorcaigh 2 years ago
i think your wrong
neillyport 2 years ago
great song, dvd and book, gets better with age, on this site by mistake, lost a couple of hours in nostalgia, great
sandersmorgan 2 years ago
the best song ever, and mucho better Christy's version, Love it
CatalinaPolkReyes 2 years ago
2 legends their
trevorfitzcorcaigh 2 years ago
Declan Sinnott is a legend! fuckin amazin
thesliotars 2 years ago 4
christy is allways a good choice for me when i need a healthy dose of music.
simyan2008 2 years ago 5
seen christie twice live fantastic
JCnephin 2 years ago
great version but NATALIE IS NATALIE!
Her voice is fantastic....Listen to the version with the blinded guys...amazing..
simogoogoo 2 years ago
Love this song! Didn't know he did it!
GraemeMDBSc 2 years ago
This a brillant version of motherland I think it is better than Natalie Merchants version well done Christie.
Rachel
ionaray 2 years ago
best version of this song i have heard
neillyport 2 years ago 42
@neillyport Try Natalie Merchant's version....
mafkeez86 1 year ago
@neillyport Ummmm..... Have you heard the original???
SpriggDiggler 9 months ago
Stunning song, and singer
StarrDussteh 2 years ago
It has much feeling before!!! I like the version of Natalie as well. I think she is one of the "feeling in song" in person! But I like Christy´s live version and the backing work of Declan is fantastic.
irishlike1 2 years ago
One of my all time favorites by nathalie but well done Christy,you captured the soul of the song, which takes real talent.
lordkorner 2 years ago
Anyone know what tuning christy uses?
kevinfaulkner00 2 years ago
smashing song
howdofolks 2 years ago 3
hope next product from christy as soon as possible
maursun 2 years ago
christy headbutted me years ago
gerryeire050 2 years ago 5
lol u serious?!
cellardoor70 2 years ago
awesome.
32GaugeSlug 2 years ago
Thanks to fellow Celtic supporter for putting this up. A beautiful song and one that everybody can relate to. Christy yer the man the man wit the plan. Slan go foille Cath1888
shamrock1916 2 years ago 4
Beautiful.
bannedmil 3 years ago 2
Because You adored Natalie Years ago when she was in 10,000 maniacs, makes you right?? Wrong.
My thoughts are bang on in not "rambing" m8. enyrb are you one of the 10,000 maniacs??
lol....
DeborahCam 3 years ago
did u listen to it then...? lol...think wee have a green eyed monster on this page....Mmm.....lol...natalie merchant recorded it aug/sept 2001 and if u take ur brain back to that time??
this song must have touched christy moore so much that felt the need to cover this painfull but true song, giving Natalie her due credit. debs
DeborahCam 3 years ago
tard
brc028 3 years ago
idiot
joghyjobie 3 years ago
Declan is da man. Beautiful Spanish guitar too
StyerAUG 3 years ago 4
One of the best songs that has ever been written (by Natalie Merchant). Listen to the chorus! Christy and Declan have given this song so much feeling!!!
irishlike1 3 years ago
I Love This Song So Meaningful Me Peronally love It Because It Reminds Me Of Me Dad Singing It To Get Me To Sleep x Amaazinn Love You Dad x Brilliant Christy Well Done !!
kimzy1888 3 years ago 2
I think this should be played in every abortion clinic. "..don't miss this waste land, this terrible place when you leave... Mother(land) cradle me, close my eyes, lullaby me to sleep, keep me safe, lie with me, stay beside me. Don't Go!"
8BILLL 3 years ago
Amazing song, wonderfull singer. We happened to hear this song on the radio (Traditional hour on Clare FM) while we were in Ireland.
This song really touches you!
DrywFiltiarn 3 years ago
god.. sooo beautifuuuuul...
many thank for sharing and
5***** :)
KatiBerlinben 3 years ago
anyone know if theres any way to download this song coz its amazing
DrRocky356 3 years ago
Download tubecatcher and use it to extract the song from the vid. Enjoy.Or try Limewire but make sure you have a goog antivirus installed.
Sakura640 3 years ago
It's on his "Burning Times" CD.
GaryB007 3 years ago
Brilliant
geniennis 3 years ago
Thanks I enjoyed that
ann01011 3 years ago
Right up there with the best of Christy, if not the best..cant stop listening to this, brilliant.
Dubaimark 3 years ago
"Faceless, nameless, innocent, blameless and free"
Beautiful...
DizzyKnux 3 years ago
soooooo beautiful. great. just great.
dubbeldammertje 3 years ago
took me ages to find this couldnt remmber the name tis didley deeeeeeeee
cheypie18 3 years ago
Beautiful cover of some of Natalie Merchant's finest lyrics!
Thanks for posting this!
LexaLovesNatalie 4 years ago 2
Lovely voice, he communicates the passion behind the lyrics and still keeps it honest. Very nice!
dogwomanhere 4 years ago 2
awesome
desglynn 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this, Christy Moore is a legend. I appreciate it.
McNubbins1 4 years ago
motherland keep me save
m3lyan 4 years ago
Gratz on posting it. Put on Irish ways and Irish laws if you have it matey :D
shitcreekpaddlestore 4 years ago