TVXQ - Winter Rose [Eng subs + Romanization]

[TheCassie502]

love this song!!and our 5 boys..;(

[shiwola]

Wish the wish though talk wasn't always be the talk... 5>2 = 5>3.

[MrsSuJuLove]

ahh I love this song so much, it just makes me want to cry..<3

where did you get the pictures at 0:52, 2:42 and 3:49 ?? I love thos pictures<3

Always Keep The Faith..

[jaoyingnik]

just lovely. love their voices!

[moradintintin]

this would sound better with 5 voices :'(

[shiwola]

Soooooooo beautiful and touched,  wish to be 5...

[0611kimlinh]

winter rose merry christmas tvxq55555 i miss they.....

[witchhag23]

aaaawwww thank you for putting them together... I miss them..

[rodaG12]

I'm a Homin fan and I like this fan-made video. Though I can't say I ALWAYS keep the faith, there is a level of acceptance that I keep in my chest when I see them as TVXQ (Duo) and JYJ.

[ouikimchi]

this video is so touching >_< i really like this video! thanks for this wonderful video. im OT5 and i will Always keep the faith ^-^

[dbsklover4eva]

seeing the lyrics along with those photos makes me sad, another christmas without DBSK together :(

[dbsklover4eva]

you know what I really am SERIOUSLY thankful and glad that Dong Bang Shin Ki photo's on your video isn't just the 2 of them

seriously THANKYOU!, its good to know there are some people who still aren't losing hope :)

[uhTVXQ]

很溫馨，可是爲什麽我會流淚呢？！好想你們啊~

JYJ from 東方神起

希望你們能懂...

[goldeneternity]

Great video and compilation for this song! I really liked it and now I have something really pleasant to watch and a way to understand the lyrics while listening to this song. Thanks a bunch! :D

[Katlyn2406]

I like this video (although that it's so sad). I hope that something miracle will happen on Christmas Day.

[libeikaDH]

this made me cry :'(

[dooseobyaoi]

From Yunho to Jaejoong on a lonely winter night 3

[meia002]

i dont understand. they're saying this is tohoshinki's new single...then i saw homin singing it... but this was sung by all 5 of them back in the day... so can someone please explain.... homin is singing it again for christmas? but why say new single.... when they sang it when they were 5....

[HappilyPeculiar7]

@meia002 did they really sing this as 5 cause I never heard it or saw it. I for sure thought only Changmin and Yuno sang this song. Or else they wouldn't be calling it a new single. Like Somebody to love they would just say it was an updated version. If they did then its probably like Maximum since it wasn't ever offically released they just recorded with Homin and ther you go its a new never before sold single.

[meia002]

@HappilyPeculiar7 but... i saw the old video of it... and yunho was so young back then... so you're saying they never sang this as 5 before??? i need to find that video... >.< so confused!

[HappilyPeculiar7]

@meia002 I'm saying maybe its there was a song like Winter Rose they performed on stage. Since they never realsed it as 5. It can be considered a new song years later when its actually recorded and sold.

Artists do it all the time. Perform a song on stage and then years later update it abit and sell it as a new song

Sorry if I confused you.

If they sang this as 5 I want to hear it too

[YukiHimeProduction01]

@meia002 are you mistaking this for an old song >.< This is a new single. I haven't heard that they sang this as 5 before.. probably you mistook this. Maybe the one you are talking about is the "Magic Castle" one. It is also a Christmas song that they released in 2004. They are super young back then :) Young and cute :D

[kazekai224]

Sigh, everywhere I go, theres drama on a kpop page. :D I guess people dont appreciate the people who sing the songs anymore. Such a shame tsk tsk. "YES I DO! STFU!" Really? Then why the F*** do you care about what others think? "Why should I care about what you're saying Kaze?" You don't have to. I just feel the need to school you kids because you're all fighting for almost no reason at all. :)

[sweetangelslc]

Let's all just appreciate their music and not talk about anything else:)

[CassloveDBSKno1]

0h, TVXQ5forLIFE!

Thanks U very much...

Always keep the faith....

I love DBSK 5, too

[doralost21]

this song is wonderful as well as tvxq <3!!!!!

[NerdyALy11]

Whaaa I miss them so much! But I'm still waiting and I will continue to wait..

[OnlyMusicWins]

Now that I have seen the translation I'm crying. this is such a beautiful song. And really you did a wonderful job on the vid.

I am going to add this cause I feel the need to do so. I'm not a Cassie but I am a Kiss Me and I will be honest, it is hard when groups split. My best friend is a Cassie and she was heart broken when she found out about the split but she now supports them both. I do that with Album and U-Kiss it's the support they receive that counts the most and keeps them performing.

[ArtemisRahl15]

can't stop listening to this song despite the horrible grammar mistakes!!!!!!! ... or is it BECAUSE of the grammar mistakes? i don't know anymore!!!! this song is still AWESOME!!!

[sitishweewee]

Though seperated, I still see them as one group...first kpop group that I love so much..thank you for the vid!..the song is beautiful and so are all of them. What I wish for christmas is for them to be as one again...for real..^^ 

[tytong1]

this is an awesome fanvid! omg. seriously, i teared watching this. thanks for sharing this video. always keep the faith! <3 and! really looking forward to tvxq asia fan party later on! :D :D keke.

[scenechick1516]

I personally don't see why we cannot still think of them as five even if they aren't together as TVXQ... Whether or not Jaejoong, Yoochun, Or Junsu left because of SM or they just wanted to leave or any other reason, it really shouldn't be any of our business. We should just love our boys regardless if they aren't together physically. The hating on either or is not helping Jaejoong, Yoochun, Junsu, Changmin, or Yunho. Just keep supporting our boys as true cassies should.

[foreverneverO7]

@scenechick1516 fans should move on instead of holding on to the past. u all should accept the current TVXQ Duo and If you guys want to support Jyj, do so without using the 'TVXQ' name. Jyj didnt even want to associate themselves with TVXQ. why are you fans so attached to associating the three with TVXQ?

[lachexamour]

@foreverneverO7 you obviously don't know anything. Go troll somewhere else.

[foreverneverO7]

@lachexamour obviously you are the one who know nothing about whats really going on. some delusional fans!

[mvan1108]

awww i know we cant do anything and i'm not complaining or trying to get attention, but i really really miss all 5 of them together. they both are succeeding, but when it was all 5 of them, that was when they were at their best. these sad songs and pictures of all 5 of them just makes you feel so sad and its so incomplete.

[yummiwatch]

DBSK has been 5 for more than 6 years, so to those people who do, don't come here bashing on this. it's really immature and you have no right to do that.

I love the clip and adore the song ^-^

thanks for sharing!!

[cultureofunhate]

whatever really happened, i hope whoever got hurt wud forgive or hv forgiven as time is a great healer..i dun believe in that term "wud never forgive" esp sharing the love one had shared that way. plez, life is too fragile n too short n theres already too much hatred in this world. plezz, let us just strive in the name of humanity..

[reneetbn]

I honestly do not mean to offend anyone with my comment. It's just that sometimes people are tired of fanwars, and people arguing about the same thing over and over. It gets tiring you know. I rather see positive comments.(:

[reneetbn]

I think we should focus on how wonderfully beautiful this song is& not the law suit. I mean gosh I love the meaning & really though the incident has been dealt w/ & what's happen, happened. Pple are entitled to their opinion so try to understand and respect it. If you feel like what you say might start something just pause right there and go rant about it on tumblr, a friend, something! Just not online b/c it will drag on &lead nowhere. So instead of bickering w/ others just enjoy the song/vid(:

[madisoncao]

Always Keep The Faith!!! :))) I believe in them all 5 of them!

[christy8891]

this is a perfect video. Thanks for making it! I miss the 5 of them so! Beautiful graphics and beautiful song = perfect combination.

<3 TVXQ!

[dreamingofyoo]

wahhh.. without even knowing the lyrics it was just a beautiful song when i first heard it.... but wahhh with the lyrics... its soo pretty!! this is officially by far my favorite christmas song... :)

[ErickitA888]

@TVXQ5forLIFE the video is absolutely beautiful. I love it!!!! I don´t know how people can say things like that!! If we love TVXQ most love them as 5 or as HOMIN or JYJ. all of them are talented and unique, and I love them!!!!

[Grace790710]

i'm crying while watching this MV i really miss them together....AKTF Cassies and pray that they could be as one group again....if you love them it's either HoMin or JYJ let's understand them and be happy for them...please stop bashing let's respect their decision......

[cj13js]

I love this song so much OuO

[cassiopeiaDBSKluv]

Hiks hiks I miss them ToT huuuuaaaaa AKTF

[yamapikiss]

I. MISS. THEM. TOGETHER. PERIOD.

[LoveAbleTVXQ]

so pretty... thanks!!! OTL5 FOREVER! i loe that u used DBSK photo's i still remember those times, i actually feel bad for people who became fan when DBSK broke into 2 groups, but yet. we don't know anything, we don't even know them personally, we know them throughout shows and drama's but who knows how they realy are.

[giantsweater]

@LoveAbleTVXQ Suppose you watch cnn and you found out somebody got hurt, are u gonna say I don't trust the news cuz I wasn't at the scene? People have a brain to tell what's wrong or right. Looking at obvious facts proofs evidences, how can u say u don't trust it as u don't know jyj personally. Then what r u gonna trust in the world? I've been a cassie ever since they're 5. Then u prove me jyj didn't use homin pics for their cosmetics business & CJES boss's not arrested for intimidating KSW.

[LoveAbleTVXQ]

@giantsweater hay i'm innocent, but if you want to say your oppinnion im okay with it, i just mean, IF i knew everything what would change the fact their right now JYJ and homin? nothing realy, so instead of crying, weeping over the fact DBSK is not 5 anymore, i prefer listing to their voices, and the fact i dont hear the news and such, you know how people are is changing others their words against them. i prefer listing to their voices. period.

[newhlmieza]

OK,.... TO ALL VIEWERS WHO LOVE 5...3..OR 2.. JUST IGNORE WHAT giantsweater said..... keke..cuz is like stupid thing reply for who just wanna make fun in here.. its ok if u like 5..3..or 2 ONLY... AS LONG WE KNOW 'LOVE AND RESPECT' MEANING right. ... ;)

[giantsweater]

@newhlmieza Don't mention about 2. Why do u think I came here from the beginning. This video's linked to Korean websites where Cassies hang out. We all know what sorta ridiculous things're happening on youtube, twitter etc but we mostly ignore cuz we understand you guys cannot get right information. All the rumors & wrong information which piss us off is by outside of Korea. Give you one link in Eng not enough but still helpful. Don't say you don't trust what's written cuz it's based on truth.

[newhlmieza]

keke... ure so funny dear...does`nt mean i`m from oversea..i can`t read japanese and korean... oo so u just said on tv,news and magazine....? dear.. one word can create many words from one word.. and did`nt u see... i said just jyj? I SAID 5... 5... !!

oo u wanna make me anger with ure unmatured words?bring it on.. i will never been stupid anger with ure little words.. if i anger.. i will just like u..NO I WILL NOT LIKE THAT... keke.. dear,dear... u just make fun in here with ure words right...

[giantsweater]

@MegaPigBoss How can u prove jyj makes more money than tv2xq? CJES must've offered lots of money when jyj decided to leave SME. But don't u see why cjes offered jyj that much money? CJES didn't have to waste a cent for discovering, training & producing idols. JYJ was already ready to go as they were from TVXQ of SME. JYJ says SM is bad, then is CJES good? CJS boss is the guy who got arrested for threatening Kwon Sang Woo with his gang family to have his contract renewed.

[giantsweater]

@MegaPigBoss Then what do u know about jyj? Suppose u were yunho or changmin and you warned jyj not to use ur pics in their cosmetics business but they didn't listen to u, would u still think they r good? It's infringement on likeness. Homin didn't want it at all.SM also has the portrait right of tvxq cuz they gave a birth to tvxq. SM permitted jyj to do the budiness back in 2008 as a person not as a tvxq member. Here's a link that has more. truetvxq.blogspot.com

[KamiBlaze]

I can listen to this over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over

[sujurox21]

fanwars aint ending anytime soon :( Btw this song's beautiful. <333

[giantsweater]

@vee5578 I don't know what happened I left 'U' to u I wanna get rid of it but I can't. Anyways U-KNOW named the fanclub Cassiopeia as it's seen yearround in Korea. It stands for the fans & TVXQ. But who cut off 2 stars outta 5 ?

[giantsweater]

@vee5578 U

[giantsweater]

@MegaPigBoss 윤호를 콕 찝은거보니 죄순이구나~ 나라망신 시키는 죄순이들. 니들 오빠들 망했다고 너무 열등감 쩔지마~^^ 풉

[giantsweater]

@MegaPigBoss Jyj must be better at lying, betraying, cheating & hurting friends than TV2XQ. I wish I could've left comments earlier. You are a this kinda person who like people that have bad personalities, aren't you?ㅋㅋㅋ

[jussmittin]

@giantsweater where do you have these facts of them lying, betraying, and cheating? why cause they had guts to stand up for themselves? what the other person said was wrong, but what you say is even worse. bad personalities???? do you know them? what has shown they have bad personalities just based on their public persona?

[giantsweater]

@jussmittin If u have brain and heart even thou u never met them in person, you can presume what sorta of people they are. One exam, when tvxq was given 3-day vacation years ago, Changmin was spotted at the petroleum accident scene helping people restore the coastal area with his father who's a highschool teacher by volunteers & reporters. And Yunho was spotted at an orphange playing with kids, cleaning the place, helping the teachers there. Yunho was always famous for his charities among TVXQ

[jussmittin]

@giantsweater oh and you must blind honey cause you must not hear of all the charity work jyj has done. and don't say its for show.

[giantsweater]

@jussmittin I was cassie at that time how can I be blind not hearing what jyj did? JYJ chairity work started after they broke up showing off and trying to say we get paid a lot by CJES much more thatn SM. They are childish. They were paid equally when they were 5 but jyj didnt have money to donate before while yunho & changmin always did. You give me the links showing they did some charities when they were tv5xq.

[giantsweater]

@jussmittin HOMIN said on Golden Fishery in March this year that they didn't even know if JYJ's gonna sue SME. If what yunho & changmin said on the show was wrong jyj should've sued Homin for defamation. And Homin parents submitted statements with their signatures to the court about how it all happend back in 2009. JYJ parents couldn't say anything about that. Plus JYJ said they don't know Homin's phone numbers as homin changed first but that was lying evidenced by Homin's remarks after comeback

[giantsweater]

@jussmittin While yunho & changmin were spending their only vacation for other people, what did jyj do? TVXQ had a bunch of stalkers but only jaejoong & yuchun had dirty rumors that we all knew it was not only rumors. Junsu was fine but he was too into gaming and he met that guy from cosmetics company which ignited break-up of TVXQ. I don't blame jyj for leaving SM but they shouldn't have back-stabbed yunho & changmin. JYJ didn't even let Homin know they're gonna sue SME and leave them.

[MegaPigBoss]

@giantsweater haha, bad personalities you say? Well, you see, we will never know until you meet them personally in real life. From what I can see, JYJ left for the better...they are probably making much more money then HoMin right now since SME is very stingy with their money. Besides, if DBSK wanted to go worldwide like JYJ did wouldn't it be kinda ironic? Rising God of the East?? lol.

[giantsweater]

@MegaPigBoss And who says SM is very stingy with money? When SM opened the contract between them to the media everybody said it's not even bad, actually better than any other idol company.One thing they could complain about was the long term.But who signed the contract from the beginning? It was their parents. TVXQ was teens so their parents agreed with SM's overseas long term project and signed the contract. JYJ fans in Korea they don't care about moral thing. But we cassies are not like that.

[MegaPigBoss]

they're not bad but compared to JYJ, their nothing. JYJ FTW!

[jussmittin]

@MegaPigBoss Im JYJ biased too but don't come here and be like that because you will cause fanwars between Homin fans and JYJ fans which people don't need.

[MegaPigBoss]

@jussmittin lol you're a funny guy. As much as i'm JYJ biased, it's the truth. JYJ is in fact a much better singer then HoMin. Especially Yunho. I never said they sucked or anything so i don't need you to lecture me kk.

[jussmittin]

@MegaPigBoss I'm glad you find me funny. you said they're nothing compared to JYJ so that is a put down, don't come here and try to contradict yourself. If you don't want a lecture, learn to watch what you write cause some fans are hardcore and they will say meaner and harsher things then i would ever say. future reference.

[MegaPigBoss]

@jussmittin yeah i think i know....but i think fans like you would only have the guts to respond to something like that. If fans want to argue with me, i'll take it. Besides, who gives? I'll say whatever I want man, don't try to boss me around lol.

[newhlmieza]

whether is wrong or not... is not us to decide it...

after all there is no jyj if tvxq/tohoshinki/dbsk did`nt come first right.. ;)

we actually never know the true story..only hear from source to source..never know is true or not.. so how come we judge them without knowing? and ye.. JJ has been mention words AKTF.. from where?

and ye... this video is amazing.. and is not wrong after all... this owner never said bad about them right.. so is that wrong too...? i love and proud of 5 !!! AKTF...

[giantsweater]

@newhlmieza You don't even know what AKTF means. Mickey said that on his homepage to ask fans to support JYJ not Yunho&Changmin. Mickey yuchun is the one who cut off 2 stars outta 5 stars on his twitter. Don't know why overseas fans use AKTF for 5 TVXQ when Mickey didn't even mean so.

[newhlmieza]

@giantsweater my dear, i`ve been for cassie`s when there is no for 'words' k-pop and hally wave..

even i`m not from korea-dbsk or bigeast-tohoshinki... does`t mean i did`nt know about that.and ye,u should respect other opinion dear... don`t create some problem in here.. if u did`nt like it.. just ignore.. ure words is like unmatured.be a adult fan..support who u want. but respect other ar the same time.. be like 5 if u like them cuz they respect each other..untill now,i never hear bad words..

[giantsweater]

@newhlmieza It's not about respecting other opinion. It's about JUSTICE. Where do u get information about TVXQ or JYJ ? Overseas fans don't have enough data in Eng, they often get brainwashed or don't get opportunities to compare the data offered by 2 fandoms. We say everthing with evidences such as according to what yunho said on TV or news or magazine interviews or the papers they offered to the media. But I've never met any jyj fan who give anwers with proofs. Just everthing is I GUESS.

[marielovesJYJ]

to be objectively saying, this song is nice :)

I like the melody and I mean it

reminiscing the past is not wrong but to not moving on is,

why do we have to live under hatred when we can smiley supporting to what they had chosen..

[HuMbLeElePHanT]

HEY PEEPS JUS LISTEN

[snow6ft]

WOW what an amazing video. Together or apart I love them all! Thank you for uploading!

[aikoedis07]

grrr!!! I LOVE THEM!!!!>_<

[iamtonidiaz]

tears won't stop... this song is beautiful <3333 pls stop the squabbling ppl, and just appreciate the song for what it is... and be proud that changmin and yunho sang this with such emotion and heart. we're here because of the music, ne? and @TVXQforLIFE - thank you for uploading this. i literally cried a river. and not complaining about it. hehe. ^^

[iamtonidiaz]

p.s. i mean @TVXQ5forLIFE, hehe.. left out the 5 accidentally.

[smnudalo]

I don't understand why people are so uptight if other fans are trying to hold on to DB5K. Why do you they have to waste time bashing on us??? We respect the boys' decision on splitting up, but does it hurt to have a little more faith?

To those who are fans of HoMin only and JYJ only, 1 question... will there be HOMIN or JYJ without the original TVXQ5 ??? we don't know the real reason behind their situation, so don't pretend that you know everything.

[TVXQ5forLIFE]

@smnudalo I know right... No one knows the whole real truth expected for these 5 people: Yoochun, Jaejoong, Changmin, Junsu, Yunho.

[smnudalo]

@TVXQ5forLIFE There's no harm if they decide to hate JYJ. We don't care. It's just that they must respect us the same as we respect them. And btw, you're video is awesome! Love the pictures!!! :)

[wishheart707]

i love the video dear....although i had a hard time watching it...it makes me cry..

i'm so proud to be their fan

i really love this song a lot..

our yun and min did a great job!

and i'd bet my life...and my love for them that

yun and min...and even jae, chun and su

wont see this as disrespecting any of them

they wouldnt mind..

so there's no need to worry about it.

[TVXQ5forLIFE]

I know some people are having bad feelings about me using pictures of 5. You can say that I'm not respecting Yunho and Changmin. But once again, I made this video to reminisce about the other 3 members so if you don't like to see JYJ then don't watch rather than watch and hate it. If this is going to cause a war between Cassies then you guys must be really immature. Just accept it that I made this a TVXQ5 video. And if you noticed, my username is TVXQ5forLIFE. Please don't fight just because I

[giantsweater]

@TVXQ5forLIFE Do u think this is funny? U have no idea how jyj plus their family hurt yunho n changmin. You are insulting my idol using the pic that has jyj in it. Winter rose is my Duo's hard work. If you ever wanna insist on being a fan of my duo, first you have to try to figure out what really happened between them. JYJ is evil to my Duo. Before you ask Cassies not to watch this 5- video, you don't use my Duo's song n pic. I have right to say this to ur face as I'm the offical Cassie for 2.

[smnudalo]

@giantsweater woo~ you have all the nerves to say "YOUR DUO"? excuse me, but do you OWN them? Are you paying them? Are you feeding them? I respect your decision of hating JYJ for leaving HoMin but dear, all the datas you've seen, are u positively sure there all true? You wake up! Look at this world we are living in! All people LIE to get what they want. All LIES! Now, if u can't respect others, u sure as hell don't deserve to be respected. And FYI, 10 years of friendship is NOT EASY TO BREAK UP.

[giantsweater]

@smnudalo Another stupid comment by who doesn't know what's goin on. I've never heard that 10-year old good friends enjoy " back-stabbing ". You have no right to call TVXQ ' my duo ' cuz you are not a fan. What kinda Cassies don't know what really happened till now? If u think jyj fans are cassies, DO NOT DARE!!! Friendship deosn't break easily, of course I agree with u on that. But I hope u can say the same thing to ur own friends even after you get betrayed by that friends you trusted.

[smnudalo]

@giantsweater Oh now your accusing me of being "STUPID" you don't even know me. And please, DO explain to me and to every overseas fan what really is going on. Since you KNOW IT ALL, then go ahead. You can even PM me, and oh! give me YunHo's number alsookay?? LOL! XDD what I'm trying to say is you should give RESPECT to other people. PLEASE! Not plainly because of TVXQ's situation, but as a person who says what he/she thinks. & I didn't call HoMin "MY DUO" because he's "OURS!". :P

[giantsweater]

@smnudalo Who regards you as a fan among Cassies? You are a typical jyj fan who supports people like jyj. You can do whatever u want with jyj but get off tvxq. There's no true yunho & changmin fans who can support jyj at the same time after knowing they got hurt bad by jyj as it's insane. It's contradiction. About Cell numbesr, you know nothing that's why u commented like that. When TVXQ came back in Jan they had interviews we found out their numbers aint changed. What Jaejoong said on twitter?

[smnudalo]

@giantsweater it's just like a child who ran away from home. Whatever happens to him, may he be dead or change name or whatever, he is still the son of his parents. Just like JYJ from TVXQ & HoMin from TVXQ. I tell u,. I AM NOT on JYJ side nor on HoMin side but I'm on TVXQ5 side. And the number was supposed to be a joke. Since u think u KNOW IT ALL, I thought u might know Yunho's no.too. :P Now... I am still waiting for your explanation on my inbox. Where is it??

[giantsweater]

@smnudalo Cell No.thing is not even funny. That's only a simple exam. Why do they lie about things like that when they know their fans are gonna bash on Homin harder after reading jyj interviews saying we'd like to talk to homin but they changed their #s.When Homin made a comeback, finally they said something to the media, we know jyj says things but we aint gonna refute 1 by 1, one thing for sure thou, we didn't change #s, they never contacted us.On that day jaejoong on twitter I re-texted u.

[smnudalo]

@giantsweater That is why some of us prefer to stay in the past. It became very complicated and we don't even know who to believe in. You can say HoMin is telling the truth. Others say JYJ is telling the truth. Whoever is telling the truth, only God knows who. And to avoid fanwars(like so) we decided to stay in between. But some mistake us to be JYJ fans or HoMin fans, but we really don't mean any harm to both sides. Just like this video & the intention of the owner. Please stop bashing on us..

[giantsweater]

@smnudalo Oh my gosh..If yunho changed his number, do u know how many mutual friends jaejoong has with yunho? Why didn't try to get new number? But It turned out bullshit what jyj said in interviews in 2010. Yunho said my number is the same all my friends know about, I didn't get any msgs from jyj, I guess they r the one who changed their number first. From the beginning jyj shouldn't have interviewed with media like that, if they really wanted to talk to Homin, there were lots of mutual friends

[smnudalo]

Learn to share dear. The boys are not just "YOURS" okay?

[giantsweater]

@smnudalo I do share TVXQ with Cassies but not a person like you who doesn't care about TVXQ. Only thing u care about is it looked better, it was funnier, I liked more when they're 5 somethin like that. But you don't wanna know how yunho & chamin must have felf sad when jyj only had a concert at Tokyo dome where it's so meaningful to them last year. Plus how sm artists couln't work with Avex last year etc. You guys only wanna be entertained by tvxq but ignore what they went through.

[smnudalo]

@giantsweater Both sides are blinded by what they believe in. HoMin lovers-JYJ haters & vice versa. I see your enemies would probably be those who are plainly on JYJ's side. But I am on both sides. So u can't accuse me of not caring cuz I have been in pain just as every fan went through & I tried ignoring but I can't. And then I thought the only safe way is to stay in the past & keep the faith. I'm trying to understand both sides here. I'm not your enemy. I chose the safe path. So deal w/ it.

[YukiHimeProduction01]

@giantsweater Excuse me? You are teaching us how to become a fan? Teaching us to learn what happened to them, when you yourself , don't even know the real story. What you know, it's only from an outside source. Do not teach us who to love and who to hate. Before saying something ill to OUR boys, shouldn't you know them more first. I bet you only know who Yunho and Changmin are.

[vee5578]

@giantsweater The funny thing is that international fans can be better fans than these "official" cassies, who have forgotten where the term Cassiopeia originated from, that international fans can love all of them with an open mind and support all of them by buying their albums even now rather than going around and spreading hateful words online. Who knows who hurt who? At best, we can speculate that they all hurt each other. Evil? Do you even know what the word really means?

[daviddesrosiersrulz]

@vee5578 i love you.

[giantsweater]

Why do u use the pic of 5? Don't u think it's too rude??? As u know this song winter rose by Duo TVXQ has nothing to do with JYJ. I am a Korean Cassie and we really hate these overseas fans who don't understand how JYJ hurt Yunho n Changmin. If you are Korean I guess you already know what really happened cuz the data's all over, u shouldn't lie to yourself. We won't forgive them and TVXQ is for U-Know & Max so plz wake up!!!!!!!!!

[MedusasLover168]

<3

[bachadmirer]

This song is sung by TVXQ, Uknow & Max. Period.

[TVXQ5forLIFE]

@bachadmirer Yes, this song is sang by Yunho and Changmin. No one ever said that was wrong but is reminiscing 5 members together wrong?

[bachadmirer]

@TVXQ5forLIFE I've never seen a fan tell JYJ's song reminds of Uknow & Max. Isn't it odd?

[TVXQ5forLIFE]

@bachadmirer I don't know. I definetely would do the same if JYJ released a song recently. I did a video on JYJ In heaven too.

[kwonseunglii]

@TVXQ5forLIFE there is a lot of song from jyj that reminds of yunho n max

[orioluvjae]

@bachadmirer Well, if u haven't heard from anyone, I'll tell u now. Every song they sing, no matter JYJ or Homin, it reminds me of the TVXQ5 days. In Heaven, especially, and fallen leaves, reminds me of Homin. I know that Homin sings this song and I appriciate them working so hard as a duo, but what's but wrong about reminiscing 5 members??? If u can't appreciate what others have done, then just leave and don't spread hatred around.

[freespiritxj]

@bachadmirer To be honest. I do have a song of JYJ that makes me think of Uknow & Max. Have you heard the song of W, a japanese song that JYJ released? If you listened, you might feel that way. But, I don't know since, each and everyone of us is different in how they view a song.

[aditigrg]

@bachadmirer

i have...if u go listen to JYJ's W and look at the lyrics...its obvious who they r singing tht song to...and its very touching....

[bakaManniina]

It used to be hard for me to watch Yunho and Changmin perform and stuff,but somehow after I read from an interview how happy they are right now, I suddenly learned to let go. I realised that what matters the most is that they're happy. Suddenly it doesn't hurt anymore to watch Yunho and Changmin as tvxq when I realized that it's the 5 people I love, it's not the name of their group. I'm willing to wait with a smile on my face until the day they will meet again :) plus this song is very sweet :)

[saminbishonen]

@bakaManniina i have the same feeling too! at first it really hurts when seeing just the two of them singing rising sun and mirotic on stage, because they are no longer together. I still miss them now, but seeing all five of them working so hard, i think myself - as a little fan - should enjoy their hard work. I will wait for them to come back but before then, I will support JYJ + Homin at the same time. That's what I can do now, just us how hard they are showing us their best!! :D

[bakaManniina]

@saminbishonen yes, that's how I felt..somehow it felt so difficult because it's dbsk. the place where they all used to be in :D and yeah..I think I will still be missing them forever but now I can be missing them with a smile on my face because I know they are doing good right now :)

[saminbishonen]

@bakaManniina Yeah that's right! Let's us all keep the faith. :) and it's only 2 weeks before their 8th anniversairy! I will still celebrate it for all the five of them! :D

[noctemish]

picture of 5? WTF...

[94redheart]

perfect. warm and sweet. DBSK fighting!

[kjjdbss]

where did u find ur pics?

[TVXQ5forLIFE]

@kjjdbss simply purely google :D The pictures in Duet In Heaven are also all from google and I only use HD pics :D

[guayniteru9]

it seems that the song is made for them!! is a beautiful letter i guess is yunho or changmin wrote it?... any way min and yunho voices sound sooooo!!! warm and beautiful!! i´m in love !! <3<3<3<3<3 DB5K!!

[guayniteru9]

awww!! gosh i love it so much !!!! thanx really thanx... i was so touched an the minute 3:48 - 3:50 .... wooo i love it !!

[ExpiredxMilk]

2+0+1+2=5

[77777smiley]

thank u for the video! really luv it!! hope xmas brings the 5 back together. 素敵なビデオをありがとうございました！

[canebog]

yunho's voices make me in love with him

[NaruTiAmo]

It made me cry.. Awesome

[Dione3275]

How sweet and more heart-wrenching this song will be if all 5 members gather to sing it. Melts everyone's hearts.

[naratian4eva]

DB5K DB5K DB5K DB5K DB5K

TVXQ5 TVXQ5 TVXQ5 TVXQ5 TVXQ5

Toho5inki Toho5inki Toho5inki Toho5inki Toho5inki

Jaejoong Yunho Yoochun Junsu Changmin

We miss you soo much~

[Zsuzsi22]

maybe 2012 , keep praying! ;-)

[immalymah]

Ouhh My God..!! I miss them as DB5K.. thnks and it is the nice one.. :D like it..~

[xoxoMADinLovexoxo]

next christmas better be like this !

[xoxoMADinLovexoxo]

*cries*

[ph67n]

loved all the old pictures of them..a Christmas wish that they will be together in the near future, thank you

[ang3lT3uki3]

thank you so much! I've looking for this! BIG <3 to you! Cassie forever!