I am so blown away by the talent of Eden and Liz! They can act, they can sing... WOW ! AMAZING! Plus the song fits their friendship onscreen (as BAM) and offscreen... I love their performance here - totally the best! Thank you so much for this clip! I'm in awe of Eden and Liz! I love them! :)
Ironically, they were working on AMC at that time, playing Maggie and Bianca respectively. Today, they are both on CBS's Young and Restless as Chloe Mitchell and Heather Stevens. :) They are working together once more! Love it!
WOW.... i AM VERY IMPRESSED. Elizabeth has an amazing voice. Who would think that someone so tiny would have such a large voice like that. You Go girl. I love ya lots...
they both are amazing actress's and amazing singers who knew soap stars can sing too! I loved them an all my children. Maybe they should Make a CD together
I commend both girls for having the courage to get up in front of all those people and sing their hearts out. I think they did a good job. Its hard to compete with Chenowith cause she's freakin brilliant but I love our BAM girls :)
Ok so i'm a huge fan of wicked and recently of Eden and Elizabeth but they just so totally blew me away!!! I completely love them. This song sooo works for them too! and WOWW!!!!!!! i had no clue Elizabeth could sing much less that good. I just so LOVE them <3
Regardless their voices, this works because of their onscreen pairing on AMC. It fits them....but I too am surprised by Liz' voice....much better than I suspected. Great song, great actresses...great friends! We should all be so lucky to be able to sing this song to a friend.
aww... that was so sweet. I actually think they have outstanding voices. I didn't think Liz could sing like that. lol. Eden's voice is adorable. ^_^ I think the beginning was a bit awkward for Liz just standing there, but if she were to walk in later on and not be present on stage at the beginning, it would have definitely taken part of the sentimental value away. So this was a great setup, for a great cause, and it makes brings me happiness to see them singing to each other like that. ^_^
Is it really fair to complain about their voices as if they were professional singers hired for the roles on Broadway? These are soap stars doing the song for a benefit show to fight AIDS. I think it was a sweet and generous thing to do, and, even if they are obviously not Chenoweth and Menzel, they're not half bad!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
haha ino, right? but she was much younger then. i was a good singer when i was like 6-10, then the cuteness wore off and i guess the talent did too lol
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
idk, but i didn't really like it. i didn't think either were that amazing. Eden was NOT good and Elizabeth was ok. i mean they weren't dreadful but i think all of u guys are giving them to much credit
This is such a beautiful song between two friends, too bad someone in the middle of it says "fans for the dyke", listen closely you can hear it. People need to grow up. Thank you Eden and Elizabeth, you rock.
They BOTH are awesome singers! EDEN has an amazing voice, they both just have very different vocal ranges which I don't believe the person playing the piano got quite right BUT a very difficult song to do. ALSO, yes they were both very emotional because they had just finished All My Children and moving out to LA together to try and start a new life.
Its a beautiful song and it been singed by two amazing actresses with beautiful voices. You can see it touched them to sing this and that they ment what they singed. Thanks so much to the person who filmed this, here in the Nedetherlands we don't here much about them, so thank god for youtube!!
Eden said in an interview that they had just come from filming their final scenes together on All My Children so they were very emotional/crying, you can kind of hear that in their voices, took a little of the power out of Eden, which is totally understandable...
Elizabeth has a bit more vocal prowess than Eden but either way it was still enjoyable to watch. Yay to them for pandering to the BAM fans out there cuz they really do have good mojo together.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this is really not good haha. Its cute and I get the significance but neither of them are fantastic by any means. Props to them for AMC etc etc but ehh hah
And Cheno doesn't sound young? lol Just sayin'. Not saying this one's perfect but it's just a silly comment to make considering. Anyway, Eden (Elphaba) has a naturally higher pitched voice. So that explains that.
Eden's actually singing Glinda's part in this. Glinda has a higher voice like Eden's so it was definitely natural. Kristen Chenoweth's part. Liz is actually singing Elphaba's part. Just an FYI.
Actually, that was what I meant - I just messed up up my comment. I think with typing Eden, it made me type Elphaba instead. Whoops. But note that I did point out the high pitched voice thing [about Glinda].
For those of you stating that Eden needs to grow up, it's not really her fault. Any of you who have watched AMC before, knows she has a younger sounding voice. This shouldn't be news to you. Most of the time how a person speaks, will be a reflection on how they sing. Not all, but some.
I don't know . . . Eden sounds REALLY nasal, like she's still a little kid. I'm going to agree with pretty much everyone here and say that Liz did sound better on her own, but it's a beautiful song and they are sweet together, so I guess in a way I did like it.
I wish they would acknowledge each other, at least. The song is about Elphie & Glinda's friendship, and basically their last goodbye. They barely even look at each other until midway through, and the end.
it wasnt suppose to be spectacular because of the singing, it was meant to be special because they were both leaving all my children "together". it is mainly for BAM fans and broaway cares. i still think they did a great job. no, it wasnt kristin and idina singing (the original elphie and galinda) but they still sound good.
Ok, ppl its called audio being recorded on a cell phone. I dont personaly like Eden's voice because she always goes into a voice that she thinks the part has. But they are both vocal trained. Its just the bad audio on the recording that makes it sound crappy! you can record the best of singers on a cell phone and they will sound crappy!
I mean, you'd be hella nervous, and I'm sure a little bit of that's coming out with them, too. Lots of people have amazing voices, but live, under pressure, they turn out crap.
Amber Benson singing 'Creature of the Night'. Compare that to Buffy OMWF, and you've got a drastic change.
oi. look, i'm not classically trained or nothin but even i can tell eden got a bunch of notes wrong. elizabeth is better, but some notes in their were funky too.
they weren't actually cast as Glinda and Elphaba were they? I thought Glinda was extremely flat and a bit off on her enunciation and sometimes off key (although that may have been by design). Elphaba was not much better. They both have the potential to be great if they would take some lessons.
yeah their underlying voice certainly has a lot of potential. I've since heard them sing other songs which were fantastic, and I think this one is one they should stay away from IMO.
Wow. I was expecting this to be bad, but it was passable. Definitely could be trained into something good.
mavryck5 1 month ago
Elizabeth and Eden were Rivals in Y&R
alyssa6477 3 months ago
@alyssa6477 That is so wierd i wonder if they got there roles mixed up wih BAM atleast once lol
midnightbluestar13 2 months ago
@midnightbluestar13 Well i dont know. but i shouldnt say they are "rivals" in Y&R... them two dont agree because one took ones bf
alyssa6477 2 months ago
Love this and them!
brenmip 4 months ago
Oh, well, this is a dream come true :)
musicaldramaqueen 7 months ago
i think they both did a great job at singing.... they both have amazing talent....
Minx2011forever 8 months ago
I am so blown away by the talent of Eden and Liz! They can act, they can sing... WOW ! AMAZING! Plus the song fits their friendship onscreen (as BAM) and offscreen... I love their performance here - totally the best! Thank you so much for this clip! I'm in awe of Eden and Liz! I love them! :)
mags214 9 months ago 3
i like it~ for teenagers they're pretty dang good
TheTHESPIANS101 9 months ago
i like it~
TheTHESPIANS101 9 months ago
This is sweet!! I like ... no I love it! And I think they sing VERY well. :-)))
kakaduty 9 months ago
make me wanna see the rehearsal vid of this they said they were crying during rehearsal...
jgpBT 1 year ago 3
Ironically, they were working on AMC at that time, playing Maggie and Bianca respectively. Today, they are both on CBS's Young and Restless as Chloe Mitchell and Heather Stevens. :) They are working together once more! Love it!
AlbieGray 1 year ago
I love it Elizabeth Hendrickson, She has a beautiful voice, I'm a fan of her and Eden Riegel
xLuiKangx007 1 year ago 2
WOW.... i AM VERY IMPRESSED. Elizabeth has an amazing voice. Who would think that someone so tiny would have such a large voice like that. You Go girl. I love ya lots...
kissmyfnass 1 year ago 3
this was a wonderful night. Lizzie and Eden gave sweet and sad a real goodbye for the fans.
greggesimmons 1 year ago
they both are amazing actress's and amazing singers who knew soap stars can sing too! I loved them an all my children. Maybe they should Make a CD together
LSGIRL86 1 year ago
I commend both girls for having the courage to get up in front of all those people and sing their hearts out. I think they did a good job. Its hard to compete with Chenowith cause she's freakin brilliant but I love our BAM girls :)
LexaUO26 1 year ago
Elizabeth Hendrickson sings more better than Eden Riegel.
Eden Riegel sings too flat.
JustinBouvier 1 year ago
Ok so i'm a huge fan of wicked and recently of Eden and Elizabeth but they just so totally blew me away!!! I completely love them. This song sooo works for them too! and WOWW!!!!!!! i had no clue Elizabeth could sing much less that good. I just so LOVE them <3
chestariley9 2 years ago 6
elizabeth 3:05 - 3:12
O_O WOW that was good....didn't expect that outta her!
EMCdance 2 years ago 3
Regardless their voices, this works because of their onscreen pairing on AMC. It fits them....but I too am surprised by Liz' voice....much better than I suspected. Great song, great actresses...great friends! We should all be so lucky to be able to sing this song to a friend.
amc25yrfn 2 years ago 7
They really singin to eachother...thats beautiful
sancharram1 2 years ago 12
It's not the same with Elizabeth in green makeup and a witches hat... and Eden in a blonde wig and poofy dress
transboyforpride 2 years ago
It wasn't dreadful. Something about them, I liked.
SoMuchBetterThnBecky 2 years ago
aww... that was so sweet. I actually think they have outstanding voices. I didn't think Liz could sing like that. lol. Eden's voice is adorable. ^_^ I think the beginning was a bit awkward for Liz just standing there, but if she were to walk in later on and not be present on stage at the beginning, it would have definitely taken part of the sentimental value away. So this was a great setup, for a great cause, and it makes brings me happiness to see them singing to each other like that. ^_^
SPASHLEYCARDAVIES 2 years ago 6
they did okay for not being singers.
Sonianv 2 years ago
Is it really fair to complain about their voices as if they were professional singers hired for the roles on Broadway? These are soap stars doing the song for a benefit show to fight AIDS. I think it was a sweet and generous thing to do, and, even if they are obviously not Chenoweth and Menzel, they're not half bad!
spawnycat 2 years ago 36
@spawnycat
There are ranges of sounds the trained professional cannot make and they are not altogether unaesthetic.
sikyatavo 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they are TERRIBLE!!!!!!!!!
awwyoulovemee 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Who's the girl who sings first? She's quite amature for an ABC Broadway event. Has she taken singin lessons before?
Actually this whole performance is quite amature
presencegirl 2 years ago
It's nice when Eden sings the higher part. The naselyness kinda leaves her voice. They both are amazing singers.
Othellolover 2 years ago
i never thought eden was that great of a singer. im sure alot of you disagree, but anyone on my side??? shes an amazing actress though.
TaylortheTuckerGirl 2 years ago 2
yeah I don't really like her voice that much either..
sloanadrianna 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
actually, she kinda gives me hope that if someone THAT bad can make it on broadway, I can too. bahaha.
musicmajor78 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
haha ino, right? but she was much younger then. i was a good singer when i was like 6-10, then the cuteness wore off and i guess the talent did too lol
TaylortheTuckerGirl 2 years ago
love them..... adore them.... i wish i had a BFF like eden or liz..or both.. i'm greedy.. lol
farahzawawi93 2 years ago
they are like in Disney..beautiful..
flyshock 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
idk, but i didn't really like it. i didn't think either were that amazing. Eden was NOT good and Elizabeth was ok. i mean they weren't dreadful but i think all of u guys are giving them to much credit
Anniethecoolone 2 years ago
They SO SHOULD have hired Eden as Mac over at Y&R. I would loved to see Eden&Elizabeth go head to head over Billy.
EmmieClassic 2 years ago
EmmieClassic.... I AGREE!!!!! That would have been amazing!
haleysauntie 2 years ago
This is such a beautiful song between two friends, too bad someone in the middle of it says "fans for the dyke", listen closely you can hear it. People need to grow up. Thank you Eden and Elizabeth, you rock.
hergirl10 2 years ago 2
where do u hear someone saying that?
ecm177 2 years ago
@ 2:22
P3CHARMED92 2 years ago
It said, "battery's gonna die".
bhwhile12 2 years ago 2
at the beginning, elizabeth is on the left (she's in the black dress!)
nicolemcdoom 3 years ago
Who's Who?
Mitzi3039 3 years ago
They BOTH are awesome singers! EDEN has an amazing voice, they both just have very different vocal ranges which I don't believe the person playing the piano got quite right BUT a very difficult song to do. ALSO, yes they were both very emotional because they had just finished All My Children and moving out to LA together to try and start a new life.
ninh63 3 years ago
this is true... i love lizzy and eden... they are amazing together
JKAT91 2 years ago
Poor Eden..she sounds like crap compared to Elizabeth.
Velcroshoesrgood 3 years ago
Its a beautiful song and it been singed by two amazing actresses with beautiful voices. You can see it touched them to sing this and that they ment what they singed. Thanks so much to the person who filmed this, here in the Nedetherlands we don't here much about them, so thank god for youtube!!
DutchCountryAngel 3 years ago
Eden said in an interview that they had just come from filming their final scenes together on All My Children so they were very emotional/crying, you can kind of hear that in their voices, took a little of the power out of Eden, which is totally understandable...
punkkat 3 years ago
Elizabeth has a bit more vocal prowess than Eden but either way it was still enjoyable to watch. Yay to them for pandering to the BAM fans out there cuz they really do have good mojo together.
Tweyelite 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dont Have A Fit.They Aint That Good.
IckleZoeThehe 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
omg eden cant sing.
Gottagetoutnow 3 years ago
eden sings great on stage.rashanda
godnlenora 3 years ago 2
she sounds like she sucked helium...
livfstdieprettyy 3 years ago
why are they singing?
snoringelephants 3 years ago
That was awesome. The only thing that could have made it better is if they did a song from RENT.
aquarius129 3 years ago
Liz totally rocked Elphaba's part. She's a great singer! Loved this!
SunshineAlesa 3 years ago
this is so amazing.They are very great singers.
hhbgffhfbgf 3 years ago
amazing! I had no idea they could sing!
amarinesgirl709 3 years ago 4
Loved it!!! The song's theme is perfect for them since they are such close friends. Beautiful song and talented women...perfect!
kportillo 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is really not good haha. Its cute and I get the significance but neither of them are fantastic by any means. Props to them for AMC etc etc but ehh hah
heartbhoys 3 years ago
He they both sounds good, in Eden´s case everyone knew she sings before, but i didn´t know that Liz sings so good!
Kennedy78 3 years ago 6
I Thought it was amazing" Yes" These two are ery close friends and it shows; That's beautiful.
ronniethecrazyone 3 years ago 2
i think the Elphaba is way much better!
jdthemindfreak 3 years ago
wow i'd never seen this! it actually made me cry for bianca and mags...wish they were back on amc, anyway at least we all have imaginary bitches!!!
=)
mylittlebambam 3 years ago 6
Oh My goodness:) So beautiful:)
I am so glad I saw this:)
WOW:)
peaCe
hagalicious 3 years ago
the person who sings glinda's part sounds like a little girl, she doesn't get it
musical0theater 3 years ago
And Cheno doesn't sound young? lol Just sayin'. Not saying this one's perfect but it's just a silly comment to make considering. Anyway, Eden (Elphaba) has a naturally higher pitched voice. So that explains that.
overthemoo 3 years ago 2
Eden's actually singing Glinda's part in this. Glinda has a higher voice like Eden's so it was definitely natural. Kristen Chenoweth's part. Liz is actually singing Elphaba's part. Just an FYI.
SunshineAlesa 3 years ago
Actually, that was what I meant - I just messed up up my comment. I think with typing Eden, it made me type Elphaba instead. Whoops. But note that I did point out the high pitched voice thing [about Glinda].
overthemoo 3 years ago
They must be like best friends
haroldwashington07 3 years ago 2
Eden and Liz are extremely close!
SubtextRules 3 years ago 6
For those of you stating that Eden needs to grow up, it's not really her fault. Any of you who have watched AMC before, knows she has a younger sounding voice. This shouldn't be news to you. Most of the time how a person speaks, will be a reflection on how they sing. Not all, but some.
DJYMA 3 years ago 7
eden started in broadway and then moved to tv
MSgirl25 3 years ago
I have the DVD for this charity event, both have great singing voices!
8Pyewacket8 3 years ago
The hug was so cute i liked it
luckygirlGH 3 years ago
the 2nd girl is WAY better!
lizziecolsen 3 years ago
Eden's voice matches Glinda better but does she have any vibrato? I cant hear it.
monkeydancer411 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Eden needs to learn how to GROW UP
broadwayluvr55 3 years ago
Love the little hug at the end x sooo sweet x
XJaDeY02X 4 years ago 11
I don't know . . . Eden sounds REALLY nasal, like she's still a little kid. I'm going to agree with pretty much everyone here and say that Liz did sound better on her own, but it's a beautiful song and they are sweet together, so I guess in a way I did like it.
aks477578 4 years ago
I wish they would acknowledge each other, at least. The song is about Elphie & Glinda's friendship, and basically their last goodbye. They barely even look at each other until midway through, and the end.
But overall, I thought it was pretty good.
iNFAMOUSZLOSER 4 years ago
eden has sang before on broadway for those who did'nt know... i thought she was awesome in this...keep on going eliazbeth and eden
sammccallgirl4life 4 years ago 4
it wasnt suppose to be spectacular because of the singing, it was meant to be special because they were both leaving all my children "together". it is mainly for BAM fans and broaway cares. i still think they did a great job. no, it wasnt kristin and idina singing (the original elphie and galinda) but they still sound good.
heatherahrs 4 years ago 21
Ok, ppl its called audio being recorded on a cell phone. I dont personaly like Eden's voice because she always goes into a voice that she thinks the part has. But they are both vocal trained. Its just the bad audio on the recording that makes it sound crappy! you can record the best of singers on a cell phone and they will sound crappy!
rkburkart 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They are both crappy, but this was good because of BAM.
angelofmusic27 4 years ago
i think liz is better than eden
dc2317616 4 years ago
It's not the best, but it is what it is.
I mean, you'd be hella nervous, and I'm sure a little bit of that's coming out with them, too. Lots of people have amazing voices, but live, under pressure, they turn out crap.
Amber Benson singing 'Creature of the Night'. Compare that to Buffy OMWF, and you've got a drastic change.
Evergreen87 4 years ago
Dude. I love Wicked. So much.
And this song.
And All My Children.
Thank God for Charity.
Evergreen87 4 years ago 2
the glinda isn't bad, but elphaba..
jkbs123 4 years ago
She was fine in Les Mis but that was years ago, the voice hasn't changed, matured.
agnesmoorhead 4 years ago
i think they did amazing considering that they don't normally have any sort of musical anything involved with their work.
slavetomyworld 4 years ago
Ok, so they are not classically trained or whatever, but I still think they did brilliantly.
shamrockle 4 years ago
i mean as in eden or whatever she was obviously not properly trained
KitKat454 4 years ago
she is very um how you say it....BAD
KitKat454 4 years ago
dont let your dipthongs show :]
good though.
sayruhhx34 4 years ago
oi. look, i'm not classically trained or nothin but even i can tell eden got a bunch of notes wrong. elizabeth is better, but some notes in their were funky too.
oh lord we just got to 3:05, that was hideous.
nothing comes close to idina and kristin.
alyalyalySON 4 years ago
ugh.... is she really on broadway? god... are they desperate?
ytfarmer90 4 years ago
If ABC and Broadway cared they wouldn't but this shit on film
Javaisreve 4 years ago
what event is this?
atxfosse 4 years ago
eden i think doesn't really have a mature voice and it's so hard to tell what age she is
xobroadwaybabe111ox 4 years ago
I think eden was meant to look pretty and act well. She's not cut out for Broadway, but that's okay because she's a daytime actress so...there.
beautifullytragic1 4 years ago
wat a song, wat a CANADA!!!!1
OCanadaPERFECT 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they are both pretty shit...
EmmettForrest 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
glinda is really bad sorry
alirocks101 4 years ago
This is rele AMAZING!!! i rele loved elphie!
basketbllchica 4 years ago
That's not the Broadway singers. They are on soaps!
Mollykat5054 4 years ago
Elizabeth is ok.. not amazing but Eden sucks! I still can't wrap my mind around why ppl think she sounds good. she is awful!
DreamingChaseR 4 years ago
Liz sings a lot better in another song she sings alone on a soap talk show. I was like, is that the same person as on here?
Eden does get ripped for her voice. Idk...I think she is a better actor than singer.
CoolChica12 4 years ago
Liz did sing better alone.
spash4life 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crap, why is elphaba not green, and what is with ur voice? I honestly don't mean 2 offend anyone but it's my opinion and no one can change that
nellino1 4 years ago
Awesome! They're gr8 and have amazing voices.
uys1 4 years ago
they're pretty good
penguin55436 4 years ago 2
you go girls! liz and eden blow me away with this song
JazzyJewlie 4 years ago 3
i love when eden riegel sings gimme gimme
paranoidmya452 4 years ago
she did a great job on gimme gimme!
dbarbay 2 years ago
did you go see this? i am so jealous!!! Who was the better singer xxx
i3abyi3lueeyes 4 years ago
I saw this vid and I was like oh my god, it's bianca!! I had no idea she could sing
Hilary345 4 years ago
They were BAM on All My Children, Bianca and Maggie were a lesbian couple. I think they did good, but Eden didn't do as good as Eden.
Trippedoutfairyx 4 years ago
they weren't actually cast as Glinda and Elphaba were they? I thought Glinda was extremely flat and a bit off on her enunciation and sometimes off key (although that may have been by design). Elphaba was not much better. They both have the potential to be great if they would take some lessons.
adam64897 4 years ago
...No. Eden and Elizabeth were on All My Children. They have good voices...
Trippedoutfairyx 4 years ago
yeah their underlying voice certainly has a lot of potential. I've since heard them sing other songs which were fantastic, and I think this one is one they should stay away from IMO.
adam64897 4 years ago
that was amazing! well done
cjknmusic 4 years ago
this is perfect, to me
raguinha13 4 years ago
Wtf you playin at u canny sing u assholes u r...
Shizzle Brap!!!
flosspot22 4 years ago
is this middle school graduation?
buenosdiers 4 years ago
no its All my children broadway show with eden reigel and elizabeth hendrickson who play bianca and maggie
shatara3 4 years ago
how old are they..
phoneoperator 4 years ago
their 28 and 27
shatara3 4 years ago
The girl who's in that soap, she has a horrible whiny voice. argh
JOSHhollowayfan1 4 years ago
That was a bit pants.
Me & My friend Mil do it better than that.
x
EmoEmmie 4 years ago
February 8th 2005
aluragirl16 4 years ago
when was this pleas answer
tdihopy 4 years ago
out of tune in some times, but overall it wasn't too painful
Roperious 4 years ago
they're so cute!!
jhickson001 4 years ago
thanks for clipping
terrifictb 4 years ago
Beautiful. I love them :)
whimsy82 4 years ago
come back.for good.
KOELCHAK 4 years ago