Added: 3 years ago
From: prasha0dracula
Views: 181,903
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (386)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is one of the covers I like better than original

  • I sought metal cover ;] thanks

  • Great song.

  • its good, but i actually think ian kenny;s voice would fit this song alot better! i wish it was on my cd!!

  • Good cover but the original is way better!!!!

  • AWESOME!!!!!!

  • This is absolutely 100% awesome.

  • where can i download this song?

  • This is a great cover, I love this song.

  • Hope like fuck Hoss get's some backing vocals on the new album <3 Kenny's voice is out of this world, but I think a nice balance of the both would just take it to another level (if that's actually possible)...

  • yeah!

  • lovely.

  • @19Hudson82Bull Yeah, because the only ones that matter are the ones Wikipedia has in it's database? Come on...

    

  • Whoever disliked this are kidding themselves... I can't believe this is the first time I had heard it, slightly dissapointed in myself ;)

  • WOW !!!!!!!! This is one of my all time favourite songs with my favourite BAND !!! Amazing, love it, could listen to it over and over and over :) THANKYOU

  • I have Karnivools 3 albums but i really want to grab my hands on this cover where can i buy it from?

  • @jGeZsAs I was wondering the same thing- it's not available on itunes?! Frustrating!

  • @jGeZsAs nobody sells it anymore.

  • I love Australian Men!

  • Awesome cover and beautiful pictures! Very good video! :)

  • 2:25-2:29, that was the sun, but that's ok.

  • Tears the original a brand new arsehole! Fooking awesome.

  • That was awesome.

  • 507 people had an eargasm

  • Why have I not heard this song before?????????? I like it.

  • Mark does an absolute amazing job here but get Kenny singing as well on it and lets hear a new version on the third album!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Amazing, just fucking amazing!!!

  • I loved Tasmin Archer's original, but I'm a Progressive-Metal fan... this is AWESOME!!! Thanks a lot for posting!!!:D

  • fuck mad cover

  • who the fuck disliked?????

    

  • I like his voice better than Kenny's...

  • Absolutely love this song.... not on their albums wish it was!!!

  • This is a great cover, but not better than the original which is in a totally different genre. Tasmin Archer's version & vocals evokes the true emotion of the lyrics, I didn't get that from this version. It is a good rock cover and arrangement of one of the greatest songs of the 90's though.

  • Comment removed

  • Excellent cover! It rocks!

  • Is there a way I can rip this song to my media player? cant find it anywhere else

  • @CooldudeXXL

    Dude.

    Let people have thier musical preferances and chill out.

    Noone gives a shit if you dont like it, take your hate elsewhere.

  • AWESOME!!!!!

  • i probably listened to this for atleast 30 times in 24 hours..amazing song!

  • no comment....

  • vool dont have a different singer!! hahaha your the fool

  • people are dumb as nails, different singer duh, i like it, a different sound for vool' but proves that they are a band of diversity and that they could last without the beloved ian kenny.

  • Autotune? Rofl!

  • yeh great vocalist

  • No fuckin' way! Is this Hosk singing? :O

  • @andiecrowe10 sif! The original rocks, it was one of my favourite songs growing up. Which is why I love this so much.

  • @dragon2712 lol ok... but the cover is wayyyyy better. Karnivool just rocks my soul!!!

  • I've also uploaded this track in High Quality! ;)

    check it out:

    /watch?v=cZLliumYrQ8

  • Ian playing guitar. Hoskings Singing. <3! Not the usual Karnivool, but wow, Hoskings should sing more often :D

  • ...wow...

  • this doesn't sound anything like ian or even that much like vool

  • @08timlfc It's not Ian, it's Mark Hosking, the curly blonde-haired guitarist. Isn't he amazing though? Man, he needs to sing lead more. He sings backup but I mean, come on, this is like uncovering a hidden gem. I can almost say just the way he sings SOUNDS like the moon haha. That sounds weird but I think vooligans will understand it. This is like one of my favorite songs, and its a cover. I feel bad for the black lady who made this, I forgot her name, but hey, good job to her for making IT!!!

  • @klearlykahmerican the original artist's name is tasmin archer. and YES... amazing cover! loove hosking...

  • @lilaznkami Tasmin Archer should be happy with this version.

  • Does anyone know where I can download this version?

  • as soon as the first word was sung i loved it.

  • dont fuck with Andie. She will cut you!!!!!

  • @JdoGGer1122 haha. Epic.

  • @EDCvideos dude.. your a damn fool. Its Vool. Why do you think that it isnt Karnivool??? Enlighten me please.

  • @andiecrowe10 Yes, I was wrong, I heard the vocals and couldn't believe that was karnivool, Apperson told that mark was lead vocals in this song

    sorry about it

  • messed up the lyrics in the beginning

  • @EDCvideos Yes it is! God, look it up in their wiki for one. They did a cover, and the only reason it sounds different is because Ian isnt singing. He is playing guitar.

  • @Apperson62490 how is singing, Apperson?

  • @Apperson62490 Ah, I saw it, it's Mark

  • WORD ITS KARNIVOOL!!!!

  • This is totally Karnivool. Just listen to the harmonies at the end. Its just not Ian singing, Its Mark. Karnivool covered this song when Ian went to go record for Birds ot tokyo. The facts are all there. Check it out for yourself.

  • @andiecrowe10 It's scary to think that they have the greatest male vocalist of our time, in Ian, and somebody Like Hoss backing him up. Truly frightening.

  • @kingStuLad Greatest male vocalist of our time uses autotune, apparently

  • Comment removed

  • The song kicks ass and the video is well done.

  • it doesnt really sound like him

  • @F9ER its coz another band member is singing

  • @vampgm any other songs he sings in?

  • would have been cool if they played this live, but I'll forgive them -- lol

  • Best cover EVER

  • cant download this song any where on the net it sucks

  • have they ever done this in live shows?

  • NOT Karnivool...lol!

  • @Suomioz78 It is !!! "The song was also covered by Australian progressive rock band Karnivool and was released as the B-side to their single "Themata" in 2005" and its Mark Hosking the guitarist singing.

  • Comment removed

  • It is Karnivool, it's just not Ian who is singing, it's mark and he's got a pretty nice voice himself....I think you can hear Ian at the end doing some backing vocals but I'm not sure. These guys are just great. I'm a girl and I'm a big Karnivool fan

  • @metalloulou isnt it Hoss singing? ah k i was confused for a sec. theyre all really talented

  • GREAT PICTURES BTW :-)

  • this is god damn fucking epic... the vocal only intro is so god damn fucking awesome..... love this <3

  • this isn't Ian Kenny singing. doesn't sound like a cover that Karnivool would do.

  • @Pieman09thepivotguy You clearly aren't a Karnivool fan. I can easily tell that it is in fact Karnivool because of the instrumentation, particularly the bass activity and guitar tone.

  • @fromeveryside well clearly i wasn't listening to this properly, i've never heard this cover before or even the original song. and to me it didn't sound like ian kenny singing. i am in fact a big karnivool fan, i just don't have their first album.

  • @Pieman09thepivotguy He didn't say it was Ian, he said it was because of the type of instrumentation he recognized the band. To me it doesn't sound like you're that big of a fan if you dont got their first album. It's like claiming you're the biggest metallica fan and never heard "Enter Sandman" or "Master of Puppets" and say, "errr this does'nt sound like a song Metallica would do"

  • @ThyMate wow, just wow. this happens with everything i talk about. i have persona, themata, and sound awake. the very first album i am having trouble finding. just calm down, it's not that big a deal.

  • @Pieman09thepivotguy kick his ass

  • @Pieman09thepivotguy Wow you claim to know everything about Karnivool. "The song was also covered by Australian progressive rock band Karnivool and was released as the B-side to their single "Themata" in 2005" and its Mark Hosking the guitarist singing.

  • @askmyname727 dude your a fag, i don't know who you are but you obviously get offended very easily. stop trying to make me the bad guy. did i ever say i knew everything about karnivool? no. i don't know that much about them at all actually. thanks for the info. and by the way, i was never able to get the single for Themata because the cd wasn't in any stores near where i live so how should i know anything about the songs they released with it? why bother making such a big deal out of this?

  • @Pieman09thepivotguy Well don't say its not KARNIVOOL when you don't know. That's all.

  • @askmyname727 well i didn't know cause it was the first time i'd heard the song. and i didn't recognise who was singing.

  • HOOOOOOLY SH*T!!!!!

    \m/ mmmmm mmmmm mmmmm!

  • @tsimpoukopoios

    Because the majority of the Australian public doesn't know what's good for them (or their ears)

  • who is on vocals cos it definatly aint ian kenny

  • @nixmixs Its Mark Hosking mate, usually does on guitar backing vocals but perfect for this song I reckon... sounds awesome!

  • This isnt IAN KENNNNYYY!!!!!!!!!

  • @dalejjxen no shit. lol.

  • EXELENTE CANCION

  • Awesome song, this band rocks!

  • @3tittiefreak thanx for the information

    @BaZerKo1985 for me karnivool are karnivool when Ian sings... if the rythm guitar or the band play with someone else a cover doesn't mean that karnivool are playing... it's only a featuring... this is my opinion... coglione

  • Comment removed

  • @fabiosantachiara you should hit yourself alot. 

  • @fabiosantachiara hah you kind of seem like an idiot now.

  • It's not often a cover version makes me like a song I loved even more.

  • @fabiosantachiara You're right, this isn't ian kennys voice. But youre wrong, it is Karnivool. Ian doesn't sing this, the rhythm guitarist does.

  • first time i've heard this, fucking sick

  • If anyone is aware of any side projects of any Karnivool members but especially Hoss, please let me know (I know about BoT with Ian).  I can't bring myself to believe that this is the only instance of Hoss singing lead vocals. It's just too darned good.

  • Hos's voice is amazing in this.

  • Loving Mark Hoskings voice! Awesome :D

  • @dano555666 you sir are a dickhead

  • @jarbymetal666 Yeah it is, just not Ian Kenny singing... Its Mark Hosking, one of their guitarists

  • Mark Hoskings voice good enough to be the front man of alot of high key bands, let alone Ian Kennys! Good stuff boys!!!

  • how can i get this? ive looked everywhere

  • @jclp81its on the american release of Themata, the Jap and euro release (the one we got here in Australia) doesn't have it. :(

  • Well done, one of the best covers ever! It's much better than the original song!

  • seriously, better than the original. And I love the pics you have to go with the song. Thank you.

  • @ankachick yes!

  • the thing here is that ian's voice sounds different from all the other songs of karnivool... strange...

  • @MrKounellos this isnt ian kenny singing. its guitarist Mark Hoskings

  • @aorton10 wtf?! ;p tnx for the info dude... still cannot believe it... he has almost the same range with ian.. incredible!

  • its confirmed, im in love.

  • shit hot. another fukn awesome aussie band

  • The original song is better (yes, I know that I am OOOOOLD^^) but this is a really good cover.

  • Hi, i'm 19. Even if this is a very good cover, i still prefer the original one :) <3

  • Thanks for uploading this.

  • karnivool need to do this live more often

  • @Mullineux1 this needs to be on youtube live! love it

  • Fuck this band is cool !

  • i want them to play this live, with ian on guitar and hoss just singing, cos i know ian can play guitar. itd be an awesome swap, crowd would love it :D

  • I remember this song (original) from when I was a kid. Fantastic song and very impressive cover version!

  • i know ian kenny is an amazing singer but i doubt he could do a better job. fantastic singing. If kenny ever pisses off to birds of tokyo theres always an option here. Great cover

  • i takes off at 1:43

  • I never get tired of hearing this. It's one of the best covers ever done. Can anyone please tell me where I can buy a copy of this? I know that it's the b side of the single "themata", but I can't find any legit sellers.

  • One of the best covers of any song, ever.. hands down.... Such a great band. wish they came of to UK more often, managed to see em at 3 dates this year though! and even met them so thats awsome. When you look at some of their gigs in australia they are HUGE over there.. and play to no more than 400 over here? its crazy, but better for us haha. great band, great cover, Hoss has an awsome voice, they should do this live!

  • Great Video. I liked it so much,I saved it to my favourrrrites.

  • I for one think Karnivool have to play this song live. I would, for use of a better phrase "lose my shit" if they pulled this one live. Such an amazing cover that only they (albeit Hoss and Goddard) could pull off.

  • Sleeping Satellite", which has guitarist Mark Hosking on vocals, from karnivool!!!!

  • Best Cover of this song! Hoss is on vocals and guitar and Drew Goddard did bass and drums for this song. Look it up.

  • this isn't kenny i believe

  • Awesome cover.

  • my fave song after a few wines.  but who's on vocals. Is it Kenny or not? I loved this this first time i heard tasmin archer. amazing stuff. pity i'm too old to go to gigs anymore. 45 in the shade is way too tragic for that. rock on!

  • your never ever too old for gigs music see's no age limit appreciation for good music is respected !!!! keep living and loving the music .....

  • @lucidavidity yeah theyre doing SXSW. be sure to buy the lads a beer if you see them, theyre awesome nice guys ;)

    (like most Perth people!)

  • @forfuckssakewhatis really they are playing southby? hole shit, they are going to fuck up a lot of people.that is so cool, if i can go i will by them the bar!!!!!!!!

  • which texas show will you be at? I'll be playing with them

  • i dont get it, this sounds nothing like ian kenny

  • This isn't Ian. I believe the bassist did the singing for this song.

  • I think it was actually Hoss....the guitar player.

  • Wooooooo this is incredible =o

  • This is a great cover.

  • I'd give anything to see these guys live. FRICK i love this cover!

  • Wow! This is awesome.. Cant believe I hadnt heard it before today.. Karnivool <333

  • hell yea

  • It isn't Ian... I was talking to Mark Hosking at the Espy last night and he said it was him singing on this track..

  • I actually loved Tasmin's song when I was a kid. Found it really haunting. Needless to say, hearing this was like having an ear orgasm...the only disappointing thing is I'm yet to hear it live.

  • bahahha, thats not harsh. thats just funny! and true!

  • Karnivool should play this at the gold coast big day out

  • great cover, and guys if you dont think its karnivool, listen to the harmonies at the end of the song, its Ian Kenny

  • I interviewed them and he admitted it wasn't him singing on this track at all.

  • seriously?

  • Yeah, he said Hoss 'went forward in time and had perfected his singing and then came back in time to sing on that track'. Ian was busy with other projects and couldn't make the recording sessions and they were bored. I'll upload the interview at some point.

  • sounded just like him at the end, but okay if you say so. how'd you get the chance to interview them?

  • I asked them loads of questions and they laughed about this but were adamant that Ian did not provide any vocals on this track.

    They toured the UK and I am president of the University of the West of England Live Music Society and interviewed them for our online magazine. :-)

  • Please do...it would be cool to hear.

  • I wish Hoss would sing more

  • im sure that was gotye singin the first bit yeh?

  • nah it's Mark Hosking

  • does not even sound like ian kenny......

  • awesome cover... 5*

  • yeahhhhhhhhhhhh¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ great

  • Awesome band!!!

  • This is one of the best covers EVER! Karnivool can't do anything wrong.

    Even their back up singer can sing better than 95% of lead singers.

  • RAYOWMAYANCE

    Good though.

  • Hey Mark you should pump this song people love it.

  • thisd is karni just not with the thunderbird that is ian seriosly has deos anyone think he looks like a high thunderbird when he dances and make shure you see