It's amazing what a bit of backing music and cgi can do. You actually made this episode look and sound almost like it could have been made today! A lot more dramatic i think. Also makes it feel a lot more fast paced then the Chase ever was!
Ah, replace the great, eerie (and arguably the best version) Hartnell era theme with Murray Gold's cheesy, cliched and overblown version with a severe lack of atmosphere...
Hmmm, very good. And recapturing a time when the Daleks looked as they should, metalic, evil, intelligent and sinister...so far removed from their recent hideous incarnation of over-sized garishly coloured upside-down ugly flowerpots! God damn Steven Moffat! 1 minute ago
I love this CGI. I don't like that music though. It's great in the new seasons but it just doesn't fit the old. Thanks though. I thought The Chase was a little under-rated and I'm happy to see you've taken the time to buld it up a bit.
He doesn't 'suck', what he does is good, it's just overused, not quite sure that it fit's with all the scenes in this clip though. Still prefer the Peter Howell title music. Great CGI, especially the last bit in the dalek ship, blended together really well.
This is just brilliant. 'The Chase' was a pretty silly story what with the Dalek sequence at the Empire State Building etc. but I still found it really enjoyable.
NOW IMPROVED 1000000% with the effects you've created here.
I wish the BBC would release this on DVD next with your effects added to it! The shots of the twin suns on Aridius were beautiful; didn't matter it was in black and white. Well done.
I must admit to preferring the original theme music as well. Nothing against the current one, I just like the original so much. Beyond that, outstanding!
that whistling is bloody annoying. It's a wonder she didn't end up wedged in the Time Space Visualizer. Call me old fashioned but I still prefer the old title music. The recon (reimagining) is sweet.
And the render on the new level is brilliant. The nice lighting is seamless with the lower level and the motion of the cgi daleks is impeccable ... twitching, jerking, excellent!
That was one of the most amazing things I have ever seen on YouTube. Thank you. You should get the Beeb to commission you to do the whole treatment to all six episodes. Well done!
you know i found the chase episode on youtube just type in zero one sixp1 and its the origginall episodes and also its ian and barbras last episodes on doctor who
Fricking awesome. The SFX have just the right grainy quality to blend in comfortably and the time tunnel chase adds so much to the story. It's what the Chase always needed. Where can I get a copy with your SFX added?
That bit where Vicki turns off the Visualizer, and we see the screen for a moment, is just begging for an image of Rose mouthing the world "Doctor" ;)
And the Doctor would be wondering, "Who's that blond girl? I don't know here, but she seems to know me. " Would be interesting if Doc #9 would then see her in the apartment store and recognize Rose, and say, "So THAT'S who was looking for me so many years ago! She's a looker....better go help her out." XD
The Chase itself a pretty lame, plotless, episodic story (and I say this as a fan of a lot of the earlier stories), but you've managed to bring a lot more drama into it with these edits - congratulations!
I didn't used to have a particularly high opinion of The Chase, until I started watching Doctor Who in order from the beginning and my view totally changed.
The show had more or less alternated between a future story, then a historical since the start, so when The Chase came along with its Daleks, time machine pursuit, comedy moments, Beatles cameo, Mechanoids and everything else crammed in, it's a unique extravaganza.
It's just a shame the budget couldn't realise it all properly.
The visual are nice - new series footage turned into b/w and Murray's maudlin music shoehorned in and drowns the dialogue (which didn't need music to tell us how to feel) out. Mind you, the music does help replace the cartoon feel with something more serious. Pity it's all reused.
Though the original shots of planet Aridius do look nice...
Absolutely incredible. Paramount recently began updating the Star Trek series with CGI effects and sounds. Could'nt the BBC do the same with the classic Doctor Who?
They have, actually, but only for one serial, as far as I know. The DVD of "The Ark in Space" has a CGI space station, rocket takeoff, and view of Earth. I don't know why that one and none of the others, necessarily.
Yes, I think they had Valerie Singleton make the Dalek Saucer in the original Invasion of Earth and it was probably John Noakes bouncing the string up and down ;p The CGI option for the Saucer makes a huge difference, with its eerie presence overhead.
The Saucer they now use in the show looks very similar to the craft which featured in The Daleks comic strip in TV Century 21 magazine, circa 1960s.
It's UNIT's theme from the first album. Great piece of music. Considering who it was written for (the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce), it should be put into some Third Doctor stories...
You spend ages looking at crap on YouTube and then something like this comes along and makes it all worth while. I didn't quite go on a couple of choices for music earlier on, but from that shot of Aridius onwards you had me hooked, it was brilliant. And the linking CGI from the Tardis scenes to the Dalek ship interior... also genius. Really enjoyed this one, thanks! =)
I would have like to hear the Original music as well, even though I like Murray Gold's version for the new series, I feel that the original is more in keeping with the monochrome gloom of the Hartnel era.
Cheers! I really am utterly humbled and chuffed at all the really nice positive feedback people have given me. It has made me really keen to work on some more projects.
That was breathtaking - the original footage was worth seeing, and this just enhances the experience. The repair sequence, for instance, had me giggling for the first time over the Doctor telling to stop whistling. Beautifully done. More, please! :)
im mean the theme tune... sorry ... PLEASE TELL ME WHAT TO DO ON DOCTOR HIAKU!!!!!!! please im so stuck! , im the guy with the mispelt emperor adress. PLEASE! :( lol sorry
mr.robber brilliant work! i love it , i really want to see the chase again with those bits in it! P.s still stuck on the yeti men hikau (yes , its me with the mispelt emperor adress!) please give a hint!
A perfect example of improved production value in music and sympathetic effects.Raising quite a moot point as to key clasic episode revamps for a new generation to enjoy. Well done my dear chap.
well, that was good, the landscape was the standout best effect, but personally i equally loved the low-budget effects on the repeats... they are in a league of their own :-)
Dire musical stylings of Murray Gold!!??! Rubbish! That man is a very gifted composer. I just wanted some advice mindrobber if you don't mind. I love what you have done here, especially the TARDIS in the vortex and the alien landscape. I'm trying to recreate the vortex effect myself and I've been trying to do so with a combination of Photoshop and After Effects, so far with limited success. How did you accomplish yours? Any tips?
Thanks for your defense of Mr Gold. :-) The way I created my vortex was to take loads of Hubble images and mix them all up into a montage of clouds and sparkles. It's then mapped onto the inside of a cylinder and the camera within.
Come to think of it, it's actually two cylinders to create some "parallax". The inside one has a transparency map so you can see through to the outer one. I hope that makes some sense!
I love that, that's brilliant; the CGI (I presume) Daleks on the upper part of their time machine look amazing, and fits in really well with the cardboard Dalek that lands in the background of the "real" scene. The music fit perfectly as well :o)
Hehe. Doesn't quite beat my favourite comment which I got for the new effects on Spearhead from Space where I was told that I had "totally ruined" their favourite Doctor Who story "forever"!
Great FX, but I hate Murray Gold's music. The piece you've used for the time tunnel sequence is ok, but 90% of his stuff is either an OTT directionless racket or a 'lay it on thick' emotion heavy sledgehammer. Silence is golden. Somethimes.
As has previously been posted that's really good stuff. Especially the DARDIS chasing the TARDIS down the time tunneel and then the CGI enhancements inside the Dalek ship
The music that was being played while the TARDIS was being chased by the Daleks down the Time Vortex, and the Daleks themselves on the ship, was an excellent choice.
I don't like the new DW theme replacing the classic who theme... as the 60's theme was so eery and great... the effects are ok, but I prefer the classics not being fiddled with. It's like having a classic movie like Casablanca being remade with Britney Spears and a crap actor in it... It just wouldn't be right. But overall it does look okay.
But they didn't cast Ingrid Bergman because she was cheap... Whereas the awful old FX in Who were bad because they had no time or money. There's no doubting the directors would have wanted stuff like the original TARDIS model shots to look less terrible, if they had the resources. :-)
I think the BBC should follow in Trek's footsteps and do a full overhaul of all the FX shots for the existing old Doctor Whos. After watching this I think it'd be awesome to see this entire story with new effects shots - especially that fight scene at the very end. It looked so cheesy with only a handful of miniatures. That's one thing I love about the new series. Thanks to CGI the FX are spectacular.
OMG wow - think the BBC should just hire you to put in new effects on the old episodes as optional DVD extra. Great Job and the music works so well too!!!
That was fantastic. The scenes cut together so well that if you didn't know you would assume it was all original. I loved the time tunnel sequences, and the alien planet vista was particularly beautiful. Superb stuff!
Brilliant stuff! It makes me want to rush out and watch The Chase. I love these 're-imaginings' much more than colourization experiments. If I had one MINOR nitpick/suggestion: degrade the CGI with a few pixels of blurring, to match the tone of the actual episode. It would make it less jarring and more fluid. Loved it though. A lot of hard work went into this and it shows.
Thanks very much. :-) I did put a bit of blur on the CGI but you're right in that I need to put even more to match how bad the original is! I added a bit of camera shake to the Dalek lift shots in the hope they would blend a bit better. Hopefully when the DVD comes out I can recompile it and put my sharp CGI back in!
I actually didn't even realize that the Daleks were CGI at first, that's how good they were! And then, the only thing that gave the game away was the aerial shot down the lift shaft, because I thought that sort of camera direction was "too creative" for early '60s Who. That makes it pretty damn good CGI!
don't stop there!!!, the part where the tardis is being chased by the daleks time machine was hair raising with the unit music, absolutaly fantastic stuff people
are they movie daleks at 3:36
OzzySupreme 11 months ago
The orchestrated music sounds sort out of place in old who, but then I do prefer the early electronica stuff
almanacofsleep 1 year ago
cool! nice timing of the music!
klawzilla 1 year ago
2:37
Two suns?
TATOOINE!
mariomaniac6411 1 year ago
It's amazing what a bit of backing music and cgi can do. You actually made this episode look and sound almost like it could have been made today! A lot more dramatic i think. Also makes it feel a lot more fast paced then the Chase ever was!
aquacandyman3000 1 year ago
Very cool f/x. Wonderful!
ericinwisconsin 1 year ago
u have any effects for the dalek ray, a sort of combination betwen a fire exsiguisher & a laser glow,
nathanalaneller 1 year ago
Ah, replace the great, eerie (and arguably the best version) Hartnell era theme with Murray Gold's cheesy, cliched and overblown version with a severe lack of atmosphere...
Wodanaz 1 year ago
@Wodanaz Yeah, I think replacing the theme was a bad idea
nuclearbugman 1 year ago
Hmmm, very good. And recapturing a time when the Daleks looked as they should, metalic, evil, intelligent and sinister...so far removed from their recent hideous incarnation of over-sized garishly coloured upside-down ugly flowerpots! God damn Steven Moffat! 1 minute ago
Bez1960 1 year ago
Comment removed
Bez1960 1 year ago
I like the old school looking vortex effects. Could do without the Murray Gold music.
Durwood71 1 year ago
Watch my Five Doctors new effects vid.
Redhellmet 1 year ago
so looking forward to this episodes DVD launch!
Attikanoise 1 year ago
I love this CGI. I don't like that music though. It's great in the new seasons but it just doesn't fit the old. Thanks though. I thought The Chase was a little under-rated and I'm happy to see you've taken the time to buld it up a bit.
CHEESOdorito 1 year ago
Bloomin Lovely!
cjcampbell37 2 years ago
Good job.
WelshAdam89 2 years ago
He doesn't 'suck', what he does is good, it's just overused, not quite sure that it fit's with all the scenes in this clip though. Still prefer the Peter Howell title music. Great CGI, especially the last bit in the dalek ship, blended together really well.
thejacalofskaro74 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
murray gold sucks.
seploud 2 years ago
Agreed. Bland Insipid & Over Dramatic shite. But suits the New series if you get what I mean!
therealKINDLE 1 year ago
I thought the Dalek and Mechanoid battle in this story was well done for its time
DavrosMarioSonic 2 years ago 5
This is just brilliant. 'The Chase' was a pretty silly story what with the Dalek sequence at the Empire State Building etc. but I still found it really enjoyable.
NOW IMPROVED 1000000% with the effects you've created here.
I wish the BBC would release this on DVD next with your effects added to it! The shots of the twin suns on Aridius were beautiful; didn't matter it was in black and white. Well done.
pufferfishish 2 years ago 2
The Chase was so painful to watch that it could even be compared to any of the new series! Ok, not that bad.
therealKINDLE 2 years ago
@therealKINDLE
lol!
CHEESOdorito 1 year ago
Every time I see Ian in that shirt I expect him to form a Barbershop Quartet
Rumpio 2 years ago 2
Brilliant. Murray's music has taken the whole series to a new dimension
DJPIMPMASTERJAZZ 2 years ago
I agree,the music to this video is awesome!!
:)
theseus27 2 years ago
really really really lovely
Ianwhodares 2 years ago
Friend, you just made one of the best classic episodes EVEN BETTER!
brunoofthesheikra 2 years ago
I love this a lot
Thwancondu 2 years ago
The real oddity of the cardboard Dalek is how to explain its lack of shoulder panels when compared to the others. ;)
TheCastellan 2 years ago
Maybe he was naughty on a mission and they took them off him as punishment so he could never go outside again.
themindrobber 2 years ago
What would constitute being "naughty" in Dalek mentality?
TheCastellan 2 years ago
Sneaking up behind other Daleks which are guarding the top of a ramp and then shoving them so they whiz all the way down?
themindrobber 2 years ago 6
@themindrobber lol!
TheBenjee9 1 year ago
@themindrobber Perhaps, but in a way that would exacerbate an already bad situation. Exacerbate! EXACERBATE!
KevServo 8 months ago
"HEY GUYS HOW ABOUT YOU GO THROUGH THIS DOOR HERE"
Pcfan11 6 months ago
Cardboard Dalek was probably left over from The Dead Planet when they didn't have shoulder panels
DJPIMPMASTERJAZZ 2 years ago
This sotry gets some slack, though I liked it, was my first Hartnell Dalek story, and only problem were the Aridian costumes.
TheCastellan 2 years ago
I have to say you've done a brilliant job here. Just great! And if you knew me you'd know that was high praise indeed. I'm not easily impressed.
escarpe 2 years ago
Wow - you've made the planet Aridius look simply stunning! It'd be a crime if your work doesn't appear on the DVD.
WalkingPencil 2 years ago
excellent!
really great!
3:36 see those two dalek guards?
they are in fact movie daleks! from dr. who and the daleks!
droidhunter784 2 years ago
Yep, and no one was sure what was up with that since this came out before the movie.
TheCastellan 2 years ago
I'm blown away... This is brilliant!
happinesspatrol 2 years ago
despite people saying this story isn't good, it looks fantastic!
powerhousechipmunk23 2 years ago
Yes, making The Chase look good really is an acheivement
IshmaelSkyes 2 years ago
Cool
bardar27 2 years ago
I must admit to preferring the original theme music as well. Nothing against the current one, I just like the original so much. Beyond that, outstanding!
hombredesilla 2 years ago
that last bit with the dalek ship flows together so well!
ohmydinosare 2 years ago
that whistling is bloody annoying. It's a wonder she didn't end up wedged in the Time Space Visualizer. Call me old fashioned but I still prefer the old title music. The recon (reimagining) is sweet.
android65mar 2 years ago
FANTASTIC!!!
mangasmommy 2 years ago
You read what they said? I wish
themindrobber you going to work on the
bbc. And after that Lucas is going to chose you
as a job owner to make a CGI affects
hilarioph 2 years ago
Naw, Lucas goes over the top with CGI and he's abusing it, now.
MR's doing it good, keeping to the style, just like how the trek guys are doing TOS.
TheCastellan 2 years ago
Brilliant!
happinesspatrol 3 years ago 2
And the render on the new level is brilliant. The nice lighting is seamless with the lower level and the motion of the cgi daleks is impeccable ... twitching, jerking, excellent!
dodgyville 3 years ago 2
The BBC should hire you to do update the original series. You really "get" it.
dodgyville 3 years ago 3
That was one of the most amazing things I have ever seen on YouTube. Thank you. You should get the Beeb to commission you to do the whole treatment to all six episodes. Well done!
rapidotrains 3 years ago
3:10, the music fits perfectly
Trayusstudent1 3 years ago 2
Movie Daleks!!!
Trayusstudent1 3 years ago
Such a shame so many original episodes were wiped.
Cryptoyourisan 3 years ago 3
you know i found the chase episode on youtube just type in zero one sixp1 and its the origginall episodes and also its ian and barbras last episodes on doctor who
doctorwhofanatic17 3 years ago
Muchos grassy arse!
Cryptoyourisan 3 years ago
There is a chance at the moment that Marco Polo will be recovered in Bankok.
I hope it's there.
Yetaxa 3 years ago
That would be great.
KaFaraqGatri 3 years ago
Indeed, but all the episodes from this story still exist!"
CrazyBobos 2 years ago
You know, I really enjoyed that. Fantastic work.
melkur 3 years ago
people like you should actually get a paid job with lots of old film companys like the bbc.
torchwood10 3 years ago
The Chase is one of the best Dr Who stories ever - here's hoping they get you to do the CGI for the DVD!
ToKillForVideo 3 years ago
Fricking awesome. The SFX have just the right grainy quality to blend in comfortably and the time tunnel chase adds so much to the story. It's what the Chase always needed. Where can I get a copy with your SFX added?
rodhannah 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
y the crappy murry music - its such crap!@
Redhellmet 3 years ago
Do the whole story! Give us all a treat! :D
Galron066 3 years ago 2
That bit where Vicki turns off the Visualizer, and we see the screen for a moment, is just begging for an image of Rose mouthing the world "Doctor" ;)
acerlutra 3 years ago
actually that would be a good plot point
(rose tries to call the doctor but she gets it wrong and calls the second doctor)
dinosaur77777 3 years ago
The First actually.
DalekSupreme52 3 years ago
And the Doctor would be wondering, "Who's that blond girl? I don't know here, but she seems to know me. " Would be interesting if Doc #9 would then see her in the apartment store and recognize Rose, and say, "So THAT'S who was looking for me so many years ago! She's a looker....better go help her out." XD
TheCastellan 2 years ago
u actually did make the carbord dalek look a lot less fake i had to watch it twise to see if i could see the carbord dalek
clevm002 3 years ago
yeah, have they hired you for th€e dvds yet?
alonsyalonso 3 years ago
brilliant job!!!!
skalzey 3 years ago
This is fantastic!
The Chase itself a pretty lame, plotless, episodic story (and I say this as a fan of a lot of the earlier stories), but you've managed to bring a lot more drama into it with these edits - congratulations!
orson12 3 years ago
I didn't used to have a particularly high opinion of The Chase, until I started watching Doctor Who in order from the beginning and my view totally changed.
The show had more or less alternated between a future story, then a historical since the start, so when The Chase came along with its Daleks, time machine pursuit, comedy moments, Beatles cameo, Mechanoids and everything else crammed in, it's a unique extravaganza.
It's just a shame the budget couldn't realise it all properly.
themindrobber 3 years ago
great work,absolutly cracking stuff.
bluenun2100 3 years ago
Nice time vortex. I like it.
DalekHunter1994 3 years ago
they should put this on the DVD
mikedd1234 3 years ago
Uh...excuse me? Everyone knows the original theme from '63 is THE SUPERIOR version......nice effects,though..
wheez123 3 years ago 3
NIce.
EdgarKritik 3 years ago
Tis superb...
i want to see the whole serial this way...
shakeyphil 3 years ago
i have always been a fan of your work but this is outstanding your work on the krotons and this should be on the DVD releases!
joshandjuoo 3 years ago
man, the chase was one of the best episodes of any doctor! my favorite part is the Daleks Vs. Frankensteins monster
srvfan454 4 years ago 4
The music does get in the way of the dialogue, but the rest is great.
LaughingPsycho 4 years ago
The visual are nice - new series footage turned into b/w and Murray's maudlin music shoehorned in and drowns the dialogue (which didn't need music to tell us how to feel) out. Mind you, the music does help replace the cartoon feel with something more serious. Pity it's all reused.
Though the original shots of planet Aridius do look nice...
HypnoToad72 4 years ago
Absolutely incredible. Paramount recently began updating the Star Trek series with CGI effects and sounds. Could'nt the BBC do the same with the classic Doctor Who?
masbeer 4 years ago
They have, actually, but only for one serial, as far as I know. The DVD of "The Ark in Space" has a CGI space station, rocket takeoff, and view of Earth. I don't know why that one and none of the others, necessarily.
vargaboy 4 years ago
they did it with earthshock and revelation of the daleks too
mikedd1234 4 years ago
Worth checking out The Dalek Invasion of Earth.
themindrobber 4 years ago
Yes, I think they had Valerie Singleton make the Dalek Saucer in the original Invasion of Earth and it was probably John Noakes bouncing the string up and down ;p The CGI option for the Saucer makes a huge difference, with its eerie presence overhead.
The Saucer they now use in the show looks very similar to the craft which featured in The Daleks comic strip in TV Century 21 magazine, circa 1960s.
flippinecc 3 years ago
In a word, fantastic. From which episode is the creepy, tense music c. 3:30 taken?
vargaboy 4 years ago
It's UNIT's theme from the first album. Great piece of music. Considering who it was written for (the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce), it should be put into some Third Doctor stories...
BlackMoonLilith 4 years ago
This is the best DW remix on the Internet. Fantastic job!
ProteusQ71 4 years ago
Excellent! Makes one drool at the possibilities.
mikey8052 4 years ago
Breathtaking.
georgi80a 4 years ago
Awesome! Need to see more, i'd love to see a special edition of this story!
fugazi32 4 years ago
Tremendous. Is there more?
SCross440 4 years ago
this is genius
redsnowstudio 4 years ago
Well done! I really like this!
Thwancondu 4 years ago
3:10 isnt that the music from the unit scene in the xmas invasion?
windjackel 4 years ago
Love the drama of the 2 ships passing through the vortex with that music. They should start adding the new music when rereleasing the DVD's!
bubbachix 4 years ago
The original titlesequence from '63, combined with Murray Gold's theme for the new series? That in itself was stunning
slavemale2 4 years ago
truly excellent stuff it would be great if they added cgi effects like this to this story when it comes out on dvd
shittowel 4 years ago
Oh, wow. That's fantastic - now go and do the rest of the story! :p
elevendayempire 4 years ago
You spend ages looking at crap on YouTube and then something like this comes along and makes it all worth while. I didn't quite go on a couple of choices for music earlier on, but from that shot of Aridius onwards you had me hooked, it was brilliant. And the linking CGI from the Tardis scenes to the Dalek ship interior... also genius. Really enjoyed this one, thanks! =)
GrowlyCubNZ 4 years ago
Very cool!!!!!!!
www501stlegioncouk 4 years ago
Coolio!
HumanDalek 4 years ago
I would have like to hear the Original music as well, even though I like Murray Gold's version for the new series, I feel that the original is more in keeping with the monochrome gloom of the Hartnel era.
woodgatejack 4 years ago
Very nice.
LaughingPsycho 4 years ago
The original 3rd doctor music was better
Scarperguy 4 years ago
You mean the 1st Doctor...
themindrobber 4 years ago
Excellent work! One of my favorite Hartnell stories. I especially like the time tunnel.
TubularMonkey 4 years ago
That was pretty cool, was the footage of the planet with two suns from Pitch Black?
woodgatejack 4 years ago
No, it's all my own work.
themindrobber 4 years ago
Holy s---! My apologies, damn that's good work!
woodgatejack 4 years ago
Cheers! I really am utterly humbled and chuffed at all the really nice positive feedback people have given me. It has made me really keen to work on some more projects.
themindrobber 4 years ago
That was breathtaking - the original footage was worth seeing, and this just enhances the experience. The repair sequence, for instance, had me giggling for the first time over the Doctor telling to stop whistling. Beautifully done. More, please! :)
tweedygirl 4 years ago
wicked!
cyberleaderjim 4 years ago
and sorry for writing logo
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
if i may make just one thigy , i dont think the new series logo goes with the old enter sequence , but anyway its fantastic!
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
Not sure what you're referring to? There's no new series logo here....
themindrobber 4 years ago
im mean the theme tune... sorry ... PLEASE TELL ME WHAT TO DO ON DOCTOR HIAKU!!!!!!! please im so stuck! , im the guy with the mispelt emperor adress. PLEASE! :( lol sorry
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
It's not much of a challenge if you get given all the answers...
themindrobber 4 years ago
yeah i guess, sorry, but a clue or a hint isn't the answer... is it something to do with the five doctors?
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
mr.robber brilliant work! i love it , i really want to see the chase again with those bits in it! P.s still stuck on the yeti men hikau (yes , its me with the mispelt emperor adress!) please give a hint!
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
Bloody well done!
Alexus1138 4 years ago
That worked pretty well, the transition of the Dalek from the upper deck to the lower and then onto the existing footage was particularly well done.
Ryushinku 4 years ago
all of the chase survived
stopmotiondalek 4 years ago
A perfect example of improved production value in music and sympathetic effects.Raising quite a moot point as to key clasic episode revamps for a new generation to enjoy. Well done my dear chap.
PANORAMA1815 4 years ago
well, that was good, the landscape was the standout best effect, but personally i equally loved the low-budget effects on the repeats... they are in a league of their own :-)
whoatethetardis 4 years ago
Your fx need to be an option on the video release. Freaking awesome!
ProteusQ71 4 years ago
Dire musical stylings of Murray Gold!!??! Rubbish! That man is a very gifted composer. I just wanted some advice mindrobber if you don't mind. I love what you have done here, especially the TARDIS in the vortex and the alien landscape. I'm trying to recreate the vortex effect myself and I've been trying to do so with a combination of Photoshop and After Effects, so far with limited success. How did you accomplish yours? Any tips?
AlbertonBeastmaster 4 years ago
Thanks for your defense of Mr Gold. :-) The way I created my vortex was to take loads of Hubble images and mix them all up into a montage of clouds and sparkles. It's then mapped onto the inside of a cylinder and the camera within.
themindrobber 4 years ago
Come to think of it, it's actually two cylinders to create some "parallax". The inside one has a transparency map so you can see through to the outer one. I hope that makes some sense!
themindrobber 4 years ago
brilliant mate
dalekjr 4 years ago
Total genius, mate!
3rdDoctor 4 years ago
I love that, that's brilliant; the CGI (I presume) Daleks on the upper part of their time machine look amazing, and fits in really well with the cardboard Dalek that lands in the background of the "real" scene. The music fit perfectly as well :o)
TheBlokeFromUNCLE 4 years ago
I am outraged! How dare you put the dire 'musical' stylings of Mr Gold to Classic WHO!
OUTRAGEOUS!
TheChromiumDragon 4 years ago
Hehe. Doesn't quite beat my favourite comment which I got for the new effects on Spearhead from Space where I was told that I had "totally ruined" their favourite Doctor Who story "forever"!
themindrobber 4 years ago
Fantastic!
jamiemcrimmon 4 years ago
every time I watch this (& it's been a few times now I can tell ya) it just seems to get better, Top marks
Montyboy63 4 years ago
What cardboard Dalek?
borgduck 4 years ago
Murray's music swamps the titles and is too brash for the creepy title sequence. The rest is nice
Frankymo1e 4 years ago
Great visuals, but some of the music is way too loud or just wrong.
ynkl7abg 4 years ago
ive been on your site, your work is suberb i love it.could you try this sort of thing for genesis of the daleks
torchwood10 4 years ago
thats bloody brilliant. the new graphics should be on DVD!!!
JohnHutch 4 years ago
Cool.
KyronMallett2 4 years ago
excellent work.. love the extra effects!
ProfessorWhat 4 years ago
Outstanding work. Many, many thanks!
greendalek 4 years ago
Great FX, but I hate Murray Gold's music. The piece you've used for the time tunnel sequence is ok, but 90% of his stuff is either an OTT directionless racket or a 'lay it on thick' emotion heavy sledgehammer. Silence is golden. Somethimes.
redfoozle 4 years ago
BRAVO! I think the time-tunnel sequence was superb. Hell, its all good. Great work on getting the music and the footage to gel so well.
devillo 4 years ago
As has previously been posted that's really good stuff. Especially the DARDIS chasing the TARDIS down the time tunneel and then the CGI enhancements inside the Dalek ship
TheCoOrdinator 4 years ago
very , very , clever :)
pureocd 4 years ago
amazing you shuld work for the BBC
mikedd1234 4 years ago
The music that was being played while the TARDIS was being chased by the Daleks down the Time Vortex, and the Daleks themselves on the ship, was an excellent choice.
eaglestriker147 4 years ago
I don't like the new DW theme replacing the classic who theme... as the 60's theme was so eery and great... the effects are ok, but I prefer the classics not being fiddled with. It's like having a classic movie like Casablanca being remade with Britney Spears and a crap actor in it... It just wouldn't be right. But overall it does look okay.
PinkPunkGirl80 4 years ago
But they didn't cast Ingrid Bergman because she was cheap... Whereas the awful old FX in Who were bad because they had no time or money. There's no doubting the directors would have wanted stuff like the original TARDIS model shots to look less terrible, if they had the resources. :-)
themindrobber 4 years ago
this is superb! i love it! would u post the original version cos iv never seen the original footage!
tis is the sorta stuff ud get on the dvd extras!
tardiselliot 4 years ago
That was jaw-droppingly awesome. The best CGI / Special Edition attempt I have seen on Youtube by a mile. Thanks!
nickgowman 5 years ago
I think the BBC should follow in Trek's footsteps and do a full overhaul of all the FX shots for the existing old Doctor Whos. After watching this I think it'd be awesome to see this entire story with new effects shots - especially that fight scene at the very end. It looked so cheesy with only a handful of miniatures. That's one thing I love about the new series. Thanks to CGI the FX are spectacular.
jwg372 5 years ago
Great stuff, especially like the Time Tunnel chase scene..
tomspy77 5 years ago
Awesome! That last sequence especially!!
Birdieupon 5 years ago
OMG wow - think the BBC should just hire you to put in new effects on the old episodes as optional DVD extra. Great Job and the music works so well too!!!
roboman1984 5 years ago
thoroughly enjoyable!
cyberleaderjim 5 years ago
BAD ASS! More, please, if you will. That was superb!
kenjr79 5 years ago
That was fantastic. The scenes cut together so well that if you didn't know you would assume it was all original. I loved the time tunnel sequences, and the alien planet vista was particularly beautiful. Superb stuff!
doctormark68 5 years ago
That was terrific. The effects are great and I love the way you've added the music too.
Mulett 5 years ago
That was great. Now I really want the Chase on DVD. Any knowledge of when it's coming out? Or is it missing?
DarthWengle 5 years ago
No, its not on DVD yet. And it's honestly not worth waiting for!
themindrobber 5 years ago
Brilliant stuff! It makes me want to rush out and watch The Chase. I love these 're-imaginings' much more than colourization experiments. If I had one MINOR nitpick/suggestion: degrade the CGI with a few pixels of blurring, to match the tone of the actual episode. It would make it less jarring and more fluid. Loved it though. A lot of hard work went into this and it shows.
metebelis3 5 years ago
Thanks very much. :-) I did put a bit of blur on the CGI but you're right in that I need to put even more to match how bad the original is! I added a bit of camera shake to the Dalek lift shots in the hope they would blend a bit better. Hopefully when the DVD comes out I can recompile it and put my sharp CGI back in!
themindrobber 5 years ago
I actually didn't even realize that the Daleks were CGI at first, that's how good they were! And then, the only thing that gave the game away was the aerial shot down the lift shaft, because I thought that sort of camera direction was "too creative" for early '60s Who. That makes it pretty damn good CGI!
metebelis3 5 years ago
Hehe, that's exactly what someone else said to me! They'd have never managed the overhead lift shot in Doctor Who!
themindrobber 5 years ago
don't stop there!!!, the part where the tardis is being chased by the daleks time machine was hair raising with the unit music, absolutaly fantastic stuff people
more more more
walsallmatt 5 years ago
Wow, what a splendid job.
pravusprime 5 years ago
more, more, do more it is the best
doctorwhoross 5 years ago