people stop fightin about IU voice , haters theres a bunch of them everydayyy everysecond, so dont hate cause she got a great voice & she is more famous then you , got thatttt C: so get a life yuck
be watching this YouTube video. You would be recording your own songs in a studio, professionally composing your own songs, or professionally performing. I suggest all of you to shut the hell up and watch another video if you do not like this one.
I want to clear some issues that some Koreans, who are incompetent in either English or music, so they could not deliver the message correctly.
The replies of some Koreans labeled the three notes as "three octave note." WRONG. This video shows three long, high notes that are difficult to perform.
IU's VOCAL RANGE is three octaves, which is a significant range.
Here is a piece of my opinion. If you are good enough at music to criticize IU, you are mistaken. Because if you are, you wouldn't
@yoonshik95 Professional credentials don't make you a better expert. Don't underestimate the level of talent out there (it is immense). Also, the common man has a sum of wisdom too. He is allowed to criticize, and he could be right too! The comments section is here for a reason: to express. There will always be hating assholes, but there are people who want to express legitimate criticism. You can't just tell people to "shut the hell up" and expect rainbows + unicorns in every comment section.
@spark12no3 Considering my criticisms of the false information in the comments on this video, I don't understand how one could possibly even get the idea that I "expect rainbows + unicorns in every comment section." I feel that I did not say anything without a strong basis on any of my statements because some people, by making ridiculous and false statements on this comment section, have proven their incompetence. I'm criticizing those who said stupid things, not people who haven't said anything
@yoonshik95 I am well aware that you criticized false information, which I thank you for. What I was getting at was that, it sounded as if you were offended by ANY criticism of IU, even legitimate ones. Unfortunately, many extremely biased kpop fans have that attitude, which I absolutely detest. If that's not what you really meant, you may ignore my previous argument. On the side, it seems as if you didn't understand what I mean by "rainbows + unicorns," I meant all positive-happy comments.
@Jake1981Ko 여성이 일반적으로 진성으로 낼 수 있는 음정이 높은 레까지라고 하니 아이유가 낸 높은 파#이 제법 고음에 속하기는 합니다. 물론 보는 관점에 따라 약간 다르기는 하겠지만요...; 본인이 진성으로 높은 솔,라 까지 올라가는 여성이 본다면 그닥 고음은 아니겠지요.
@Jake1981Ko 일단 여자랑 남자는 소리를 낼 수 있는 음역대와 key가 틀리구요. 아이유가 부르는 파#은 이미 보통여자의 진성 범위를 많이 넘어섰다고 보심되구요, 남자 2옥 라= 여자 3옥 레, 아이유가 부른 건 남자가 3옥 도#을 진성으로 불렀다 보심 되여. 그래서 아이유보고 대단하다 그러는거임 ㅎ 보통 여자 노래는 악보에 한옥 낮게 기록하죠 보기 편하게 ㅎ 그럼 좋은하루되세욤
@sirjacklee 남자 여자는 음역대를 놓고 비교대상들이 못됨 ㅡㅡ 여자는 원래부터가 목젖이없고 , 목부분의 근육이 발달하지 않아서 남자에비해 노래부르기 3~4배는 유리합니다. 남자는 목에 힘빼는데만 빨리는 8개월 그것도 보컬트레이닝 받으면서 ,, 늦으면 3년정도걸리죠...그에비해 여성은 음역대가 남성에비해 선천적으로도 높고 ,,
부정적이아니라 요 동영상은 립싱크 입니다 3단 고음 부분시 안무가들이 아이유를 살짝가려주는 느낌도 들고 고음시 표정관리 문제도 있는지 고개도 돌려버리고 아이유는 얼굴반반한 애들 모아놓은 여자 아이돌 그룹 애들보다는 음악성도 있고 기타도 잘치고 노래도 잘하는 편이죠 하지만 아이유는 고음가수가 아닙니다
@teamsush 이 때는 라이브 맞습니다. 3단 고음이 이 무대로 떴으니까요ㅎ 근데 한 2주하고 그만뒀습니다. 라이브할때 이부분만 립싱크를 하거나 코러스 부분을 부르던데요. 뭐 아이유의 커리어를 고려해보면 목관리를 위해 잘 관둔것 같네요. 3단고음 안해도 아이유가 노래잘하는건 다 아는사실인데.
i'm really glad she stopped singing the 3 note part.... it almost ruined her voice... i was really close to ruining my voice by singing that part too much, too... it's really hard on the vocal chords...
Why do losers who are in high school choir(kids who usually wish they can hang out with the popular kids, at least in my high school) always come into these types of videos and criticize professional singers? Weather you like it or not IU is a professional singer for a reason unlike some cryers who are still nobody in high school choir team. Just because you're in choir or have been taking voice classes, suddenly these losers become professional critics, lmao
Sorry if that offended some of you guys who ARE actually in choir, but I meant those rotten apples who suddenly thinks they have the merit to criticize when they're not in position to do so. It's one thing to criticize constructively but just being an ass is annoying you know? =)
i just agree with u on the 'losers who are in high school choir(kids who usually wish they can hang out with the popular kids, at least in my high school)" and lol'ed
at first when i heard 3 octave i was like WTF DAMN. but then i watched this and i remembered that koreans call notes octaves sometimes so i was like aww. but i was still like WTF DAMN because i still wasn't expecting that hahaha.
Everybody needs to give singers a break especially talking about a live performance. Don't judge a person's voice from one video. Live performances are always different. You don't know if one day the singer had a little stuffy nose or they didn't hydrate well enough and their throat is dry. Everybody has a bad day and everyone a good day.
I love her, and she is a good singer, but the only reason why she could go that high is because her voice is high. Her voice wouldn't be able to go as low as some other people. Some people have even higher voice then that..... want my voice to be igh, but it turns out it never iss..
ok, it is not a 3 octave, I was shocked after I heard it, hehehe.. it's not even that high, she has a very cute voice that's why she can reach it, I cna't explain it that much, but that's how it is, it depends on a persons voice, if you have a bold voice then definitely you can't reach it but if you have a voice like IU then yo can reach it...
@game3341 Her name is IU, a Korean singer. She became very famous in the kpop industry after singing this song called Good Day, and singing that really long 3 octave note. Its mainly that long 3 octave note that caught peoples attention.
Pitchy, pitchy, and pitchy. She sounded a lot better during her "Missing Child" promotions. All the non-singing she was doing for "Boo" and "Marshmallow" has ruined her.
노래 잘만 하는데 다들 왜이러지? 아이돌 올킬이랬지 누가 세상에서 가장 잘 부른다고 했나? 사실 아이돌 중 아이유 따라올 사람 없을텐데.. 누구랑 비교하면서 얘는 걔네들에 비하면 고음이 아니다.. 노래 못 하는 거다라고 하면 본인한테 무슨 이득이 있는 것도 아니고.. Just because her high notes aren't as high as another singer's doesn't mean her notes AREN'T high.
@TheKingdomofErnor it doesnt have to do with the echo, shes slightly flat either way if you compare it with the original song. i think iu is talented too, and im not hating on her. im just saying that she can be out of tune too and shes not perfect all the time.
@loveparadex well the attack is called screech just as the attack watergun isnt called watergun attack , durp. and muriah carey only learns 3 moves, sing ( usualy fails ) supersonic ( to confuse people into thinking she can sing ) and sand attack ( making people think they see a hottie when they see a peace of shit with a microphone )
@OjFarm 님하 페는 육체가 아닌가요 그럼 정신적? 저 바이올로지 a+ 맞았거든요 ^^ 음악은 a 맞고 ^^
그리고 목소리 갈라진다 하지 않고 out of tune이랬거든요 ^^
이런 논쟁 고 싶지않습니다, 개인차이니깐. 남이 IU 좋아하시는건 상관없으니 전 keyshia cole이나 들으렵니다 2007년곡들이 2010년 아이유곡보다 좋은듯~ 개인적 의견이니 상관 마시길 가창력 떠나서 노래도 더 좋은거 같에요 맨처음 부터 저도 이런 곡 듣는거 아니였는데 실례헸습니다
goosebumps!!!
raekijung 2 weeks ago
Love Lee Ji Eun
WooyoungIUno1couple 1 month ago
wow
zpiwwmu1 1 month ago
라이브 맞구만 뭔 말들이 많아
kin8219 2 months ago 2
아 댓글 수준들 하고는 참...
여기 죄다 고딩들만 모아다 놧나?
고음 운운하는 애들이 고딩이거나 고딩수준이지 니들이 혼자 3분이상 율동과 함께 노래부르고 마지막에 10초정도 끌면서 3단으로 올릴수나 있을거라고나 생각하냐? 그냥 깨끗하게 올린3단고음 듣고 싶으면 아이유 게릴라데이트에서 부른3단고음이나 처들어라
jys62533 3 months ago
@jys62533 율동 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아 개폭소 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
hso91 2 months ago
Comment removed
spark12no3 4 months ago
Comment removed
spark12no3 4 months ago
아미마디~이~히~
kisun2u 4 months ago
people stop fightin about IU voice , haters theres a bunch of them everydayyy everysecond, so dont hate cause she got a great voice & she is more famous then you , got thatttt C: so get a life yuck
katialovex 5 months ago
be watching this YouTube video. You would be recording your own songs in a studio, professionally composing your own songs, or professionally performing. I suggest all of you to shut the hell up and watch another video if you do not like this one.
yoonshik95 6 months ago
I want to clear some issues that some Koreans, who are incompetent in either English or music, so they could not deliver the message correctly.
The replies of some Koreans labeled the three notes as "three octave note." WRONG. This video shows three long, high notes that are difficult to perform.
IU's VOCAL RANGE is three octaves, which is a significant range.
Here is a piece of my opinion. If you are good enough at music to criticize IU, you are mistaken. Because if you are, you wouldn't
yoonshik95 6 months ago 5
@yoonshik95 Professional credentials don't make you a better expert. Don't underestimate the level of talent out there (it is immense). Also, the common man has a sum of wisdom too. He is allowed to criticize, and he could be right too! The comments section is here for a reason: to express. There will always be hating assholes, but there are people who want to express legitimate criticism. You can't just tell people to "shut the hell up" and expect rainbows + unicorns in every comment section.
spark12no3 4 months ago
@spark12no3 Considering my criticisms of the false information in the comments on this video, I don't understand how one could possibly even get the idea that I "expect rainbows + unicorns in every comment section." I feel that I did not say anything without a strong basis on any of my statements because some people, by making ridiculous and false statements on this comment section, have proven their incompetence. I'm criticizing those who said stupid things, not people who haven't said anything
yoonshik95 4 months ago
@yoonshik95 I am well aware that you criticized false information, which I thank you for. What I was getting at was that, it sounded as if you were offended by ANY criticism of IU, even legitimate ones. Unfortunately, many extremely biased kpop fans have that attitude, which I absolutely detest. If that's not what you really meant, you may ignore my previous argument. On the side, it seems as if you didn't understand what I mean by "rainbows + unicorns," I meant all positive-happy comments.
spark12no3 4 months ago
@spark12no3 Fair enough :D nice talking to you
yoonshik95 4 months ago
참고로 아이유가 부른 저 부분은 소찬휘 tears 보다 겨우 반키 낮은 키이고, 보통 사람들이 목소리 가늘게 해서 올라가면 자기가 올라갔다고 생각하지만 정말 제대로된 진성으로 부르는 것과는 분명한 차이가 있죠
sirjacklee 7 months ago
@sirjacklee 진성으로 저렇게 못부릅니다 두성입니다
wsdrrs 5 months ago
@Jake1981Ko 여성이 일반적으로 진성으로 낼 수 있는 음정이 높은 레까지라고 하니 아이유가 낸 높은 파#이 제법 고음에 속하기는 합니다. 물론 보는 관점에 따라 약간 다르기는 하겠지만요...; 본인이 진성으로 높은 솔,라 까지 올라가는 여성이 본다면 그닥 고음은 아니겠지요.
chorbits 7 months ago
라이브 아닌가요? 고음이니깐 표정관리가 안 되는거 아닌가요?
MiniPanda4 7 months ago
대박 ㅋ
jennfsho 7 months ago
난 아이유팬도 아니고 관심도 없지만 뭐라 하는 인간들 이해가 안감 딱보면 라이븐거 모르나? 처음 몇초는 AR이 들리는데 갈수록 부르는게 더 커지는 거 몰라? 그리구 뭐 고개를 돌린다니 댄서가 가린다니 하는데 그거랑 부르는게 뭔상관임 부르는게 들리면 된거지 그리구 얘가 립싱크면 왜 3단고음 잘하다가 몇일안가서 안하고 코러스부르는거겠어 아이유가 약간 복식으로 안하고 목으로부르는게 있어서 계속 3단고음하다가 지목망가질까봐 걍 코러스부르는거 아니야 또 아이유한테 뭐라할꺼면 전세계인들 다보는 유튜브에서 나대지말고 네이버나가서 욕해 그리구 님들이 한번 불러보고 립싱크라해
gpfspsk 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PERFECT
Ciabatlolkevinr 8 months ago
이렇다 저렇다 하는 분들..일단 당신들중 지금 노래방가서 노래부르고 동영상찍어 올려서 욕보다 칭찬 더 받을 수 있는 분만 평가하세요. ^^
cheshireOwO 9 months ago
MR 제거 들어보면 당연히 라이브맞다는걸 알수있는데...ㅋ
jiminiz1 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
근데 이거 별명이 왜 3단고음이예요?고음이 아닌데?
Jake1981Ko 9 months ago
근데 이거 별명이 왜 3단고음이예요?고음이 아닌데?
Jake1981Ko 9 months ago
Comment removed
Choi516 9 months ago
@Jake1981Ko 3옥타브 미 - 3옥타브 파 - 3옥타프 파# 뭐 진성이니까 조금 낮게 들릴수도 있죠
Choi516 9 months ago
Comment removed
sirjacklee 7 months ago
@Jake1981Ko 일단 여자랑 남자는 소리를 낼 수 있는 음역대와 key가 틀리구요. 아이유가 부르는 파#은 이미 보통여자의 진성 범위를 많이 넘어섰다고 보심되구요, 남자 2옥 라= 여자 3옥 레, 아이유가 부른 건 남자가 3옥 도#을 진성으로 불렀다 보심 되여. 그래서 아이유보고 대단하다 그러는거임 ㅎ 보통 여자 노래는 악보에 한옥 낮게 기록하죠 보기 편하게 ㅎ 그럼 좋은하루되세욤
sirjacklee 7 months ago 26
@sirjacklee 남자 여자는 음역대를 놓고 비교대상들이 못됨 ㅡㅡ 여자는 원래부터가 목젖이없고 , 목부분의 근육이 발달하지 않아서 남자에비해 노래부르기 3~4배는 유리합니다. 남자는 목에 힘빼는데만 빨리는 8개월 그것도 보컬트레이닝 받으면서 ,, 늦으면 3년정도걸리죠...그에비해 여성은 음역대가 남성에비해 선천적으로도 높고 ,,
미성에다가 목에 근육발달도 없으니 ,, 여자가 훨씬유리할수밖에 ..
cksghchl 7 months ago
@cksghchl 님 말씀이 다 맞습니당.ㅎ 밑에 글을 쓰신분이 남성분이신것 같은데 어느정도의 음역대인지 잘 모르시고 오해를 하시는것 같아서 어느정도인지를 가늠해 볼수 있도록 그 대상을 남자의 음역대로 설명해본거라고 생각해주시면 되욤. =)
sirjacklee 7 months ago
@sirjacklee 참 뭔말인지 ㅋㅋㅋ
kimjb95 4 months ago
3단고음 맨 마지막 음정이 살짝 낮으니깐 라이브 맞음.
jin12345678 9 months ago
내가 봐도 라이브 맞는거 같다만.. 여기서 말 함부로 헀다간 ,, 아이유 빠들한테 매장당할듯
cksghchl 9 months ago
Comment removed
zzangcorea 9 months ago
라이브 맞는데요. 못 믿으시는 분들은 이걸로 만든 mr제거 라이브 들어보시길
ChoeJinHyang 9 months ago
딱봐도 라이브구먼 ㅡㅡ
아이유가 라이브랑 AR이랑 차이가 거의 안날정도로 부른다고 예전에 떳던데
거미가 인정한 가수임...라이브 맞습니다 저거
아이유가 립싱크한거 본적이없는데
KoreanLegendSinger 10 months ago
부정적이아니라 요 동영상은 립싱크 입니다 3단 고음 부분시 안무가들이 아이유를 살짝가려주는 느낌도 들고 고음시 표정관리 문제도 있는지 고개도 돌려버리고 아이유는 얼굴반반한 애들 모아놓은 여자 아이돌 그룹 애들보다는 음악성도 있고 기타도 잘치고 노래도 잘하는 편이죠 하지만 아이유는 고음가수가 아닙니다
allfighter2010 10 months ago
@allfighter2010 원래 음원이랑 조금 다른데요?? 라이브 맞습니다 ^_^;
SoHeefrom91 10 months ago
이건 립싱크지 라이브가 아니죠. 이 노래를 라이브로 부르는걸 못본거 같은데...
teamsush 10 months ago
@teamsush 이 때는 라이브 맞습니다. 3단 고음이 이 무대로 떴으니까요ㅎ 근데 한 2주하고 그만뒀습니다. 라이브할때 이부분만 립싱크를 하거나 코러스 부분을 부르던데요. 뭐 아이유의 커리어를 고려해보면 목관리를 위해 잘 관둔것 같네요. 3단고음 안해도 아이유가 노래잘하는건 다 아는사실인데.
ReallyTkfkd 10 months ago
i'm really glad she stopped singing the 3 note part.... it almost ruined her voice... i was really close to ruining my voice by singing that part too much, too... it's really hard on the vocal chords...
yurikmusic 11 months ago
Why do losers who are in high school choir(kids who usually wish they can hang out with the popular kids, at least in my high school) always come into these types of videos and criticize professional singers? Weather you like it or not IU is a professional singer for a reason unlike some cryers who are still nobody in high school choir team. Just because you're in choir or have been taking voice classes, suddenly these losers become professional critics, lmao
drsnowmon 11 months ago
@drsnowmon
lmao so true
except i am in school choir too. But I agree with you.
AllstarHunE 11 months ago
@AllstarHunE
Sorry if that offended some of you guys who ARE actually in choir, but I meant those rotten apples who suddenly thinks they have the merit to criticize when they're not in position to do so. It's one thing to criticize constructively but just being an ass is annoying you know? =)
drsnowmon 11 months ago
@drsnowmon
i just agree with u on the 'losers who are in high school choir(kids who usually wish they can hang out with the popular kids, at least in my high school)" and lol'ed
AllstarHunE 11 months ago
at first when i heard 3 octave i was like WTF DAMN. but then i watched this and i remembered that koreans call notes octaves sometimes so i was like aww. but i was still like WTF DAMN because i still wasn't expecting that hahaha.
ArgentinianTraceur 11 months ago
한글로 된 댓글들은 왜 하나같이 부정적입니까? 노래만 잘하는구만 그것가지고 쥐어짠다, 못한다, 그게 대수냐... 여기 있는 사람들 이정도 올라갈수있습니까? ㅋㅋㅋ 못하면 말을말던가.
youngiiexD 11 months ago
Everybody needs to give singers a break especially talking about a live performance. Don't judge a person's voice from one video. Live performances are always different. You don't know if one day the singer had a little stuffy nose or they didn't hydrate well enough and their throat is dry. Everybody has a bad day and everyone a good day.
inocelda1 1 year ago
I love her, and she is a good singer, but the only reason why she could go that high is because her voice is high. Her voice wouldn't be able to go as low as some other people. Some people have even higher voice then that..... want my voice to be igh, but it turns out it never iss..
cherrytops64 1 year ago
ok, it is not a 3 octave, I was shocked after I heard it, hehehe.. it's not even that high, she has a very cute voice that's why she can reach it, I cna't explain it that much, but that's how it is, it depends on a persons voice, if you have a bold voice then definitely you can't reach it but if you have a voice like IU then yo can reach it...
gelai8134 1 year ago
@mariliap2 Yes she stood out by doing tat and so does Jonghyun from SHINee :p
JustHurryUpNow 1 year ago
HAHAHAHAHA stop saying that!!! is obiously that he sang 3 octaves... check it with a piano!!! ¬¬ f*ck you haters!!! :D
Azufandub 1 year ago
It is your misunderstanding it just 3-grade high voice. I don't know how can I explain, but actually, it is not 3 octave note.
wsdrrs 1 year ago
@wsdrrs it's 3 octave note. Exactly highF#
kok4753 11 months ago
@kok4753 octave is 8 notes.
wsdrrs 11 months ago
@kok4753 a octave is 8 notes.
wsdrrs 11 months ago
@kok4753 아 한국분이셨구나 . 옥타브느 8개의 주요음. 즉 도래미파솔라시도 를 한 옥타브라고 하는걸로 알고있습니다만,
wsdrrs 11 months ago
i dont kno why in english it gets 'translated' to 3 octave note but even in the title, Koreans call it 3단 고음 (3 step/note high note, in a way)
so stop arguing about it not begin a 3 octave or whatever. just a misunderstanding
hjlee6192 1 year ago 13
OMG i tried this and my neck is sore it makes no voice of mine
sweetchoco0525 1 year ago
부...부왘!!
yearppp 1 year ago
me n my sis always lipsing tht part loool.
xxKazManiaxx 1 year ago
i love the 'aigoo' part. :D haha.
and wow she sings like it's too high. :D
rusheil012 1 year ago 55
Comment removed
IsTommyMad 7 months ago
ㅋㅋㅋ내공은또뭐임ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
뭐아이유안티는아니지만모가좋은진모르겠네ㅋ
노랜잘하는데노래가안좋고
몸매좋고얼굴은이쁜데머리랑옷은안예쁘고...
ㅋㅋㅋ
걍 드림하이나잘봐야지ㅋ
드림하이 화이팅!
evakim97 1 year ago
원 내공??
luke50597 1 year ago
shes famous cause she can freaking sing and on top shes adorable. so no more haters man
12iLoVeYa12 1 year ago
내공냠냠
SamJahDaeMyun 1 year ago
i dun get y shes on everything these days...........
imnoobish 1 year ago
who is she .......................
game3341 1 year ago
@game3341 Her name is IU, a Korean singer. She became very famous in the kpop industry after singing this song called Good Day, and singing that really long 3 octave note. Its mainly that long 3 octave note that caught peoples attention.
Boomchakalaka07 1 year ago
@Boomchakalaka07 lol, "3 octave note", rofl
Blue is a 3 spectrum color.
TheKingdomofErnor 1 year ago
@TheKingdomofErnor Huh? Where did I mention the colour spectrum lol? O_o
Boomchakalaka07 1 year ago
@Boomchakalaka07 ... I was making a simile. There's no such thing as a "3 octave note" just like there's no such thing as a "3 spectrum color".
TheKingdomofErnor 1 year ago
아이유가 지연이랑수지랑현아누님들보다 잘나가자나 실력은 두말할거없고
goen1114 1 year ago
Pitchy, pitchy, and pitchy. She sounded a lot better during her "Missing Child" promotions. All the non-singing she was doing for "Boo" and "Marshmallow" has ruined her.
aznvietguy0103 1 year ago
@k875500 딱보니까 고딩인가본데 바이올로지 에이플받고 음악 에이받은 니가 저 노래 불러보고 그다음에 얘기하자
mikmas82 1 year ago
댓글수준 돋네 ... 한글로된 리플들은 어째 다들 부정적이냐 ㅡㅡ
biglee13m 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
요즘것들은 고음높으면 다 가창력있는줄아네.. 사람들 수준이
낮으니까 한국음악도 수준이 떨어지는거야
그리고 고음에도 퀄리티란게 있다 ㅋㅋㅋ
DFOPwns 1 year ago
전.. 3단고음듣기 거북하던데.. 암튼 아이유 완전 슈퍼루키임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 예쁘고 가창력쩔고
yoseobful 1 year ago
노래 잘만 하는데 다들 왜이러지? 아이돌 올킬이랬지 누가 세상에서 가장 잘 부른다고 했나? 사실 아이돌 중 아이유 따라올 사람 없을텐데.. 누구랑 비교하면서 얘는 걔네들에 비하면 고음이 아니다.. 노래 못 하는 거다라고 하면 본인한테 무슨 이득이 있는 것도 아니고.. Just because her high notes aren't as high as another singer's doesn't mean her notes AREN'T high.
itsRAINingg 1 year ago
can someone explain me
nojomen2 1 year ago
뭐 노래는 잘하죠... 하지만 이걸 고음이라고 하기는... Mariah Carey 의 Emotion 들으시면 고음이 뭔지 알게되죠... 아이유 팬이지만 이것만으로 이슈가 되는 건... 쫌 아닌듯.
Kscorpio88K 1 year ago
@Kscorpio88K 그건 그렇지만 Carey 는 아이유 보다 2배 이상 나이가 더 많은데 그동안에 경력 차이가 있는데 이둘을 비교하는건 쫌.....
SephCat74 1 year ago
최고다. 더이상 바랄게 없음.
hpkim779 1 year ago
난 노래 그런거 모르고 그냥 저정도로 길게 끄는거면 잘하는거 아닌가? 근데 왜이렇게 댓글에서 난리인지 이해가 안 감 ㅋ
cucutin1 1 year ago
Comment removed
sunnypark02 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
잇츠더 보짓물 보지보지 에브리썸 보지~
kok4753 1 year ago
3단 부스터는 좋긴한데.. 마지막 3단때 약간 플랫인거 같지 않음?
ktaehee 1 year ago
@ktaehee
예 정확히는 모르지만 F 플랫인거 같아요, 3 단은 아니고 2.5단 이랄까?
drsnowmon 1 year ago
@drsnowmon 최고음은 F플랫이 맞고 E부터 반음씩 올라가니깐 3단 맞죠
kok4753 11 months ago
솔직히 아이유 가창력 인정은 하는데... 이런걸 노래에 넣는건 좀...
3단 부스터건 뭐건 맞는 노래에 맞는 음단을 선택하는게 좋은 노래의 기본인데
이건 그냥 아무곳이나 어려운거 껴넣어서 자기 이미지 살릴려고 하는거 밖에 안보이네요... 3단 올리는건 아이유가 뛰어나서 그런거지만 노래 듣는 사람 입장에서는 조금 듣기가 영...
dubidam7478 1 year ago
fucking lol
iHakoneHero 1 year ago
Good vocals, hate the song. And I prefer how she look when she was little chubbier?
TheRezolve 1 year ago
The 5 people who disliked this failed.
AlanWarpZone 1 year ago
uh, sorry to burst some bubbles but shes out of tune. haha
juhaynee 1 year ago
@juhaynee I totally agree with you! Her song does not deserve these kindda applause
k875500 1 year ago
@juhaynee
and u're tone deaf ..
nombo12 1 year ago
@nombo12 uh, and you dont know anything about music. shes obviously out of tune at 0:14. im just stating the truth, sorry if you cant handle it.
juhaynee 1 year ago
@juhaynee
its not easy to sing that part in one breath plus she has to sing that everyday in diff music shows+practice ..
she shud take care of her vocal cord or it will be ruin in the future ..
everybody's not perfect ..
nombo12 1 year ago
@juhaynee you're incorrect, there's just an echo when she changes pitch and it makes it sound out of tune
TheKingdomofErnor 1 year ago
@TheKingdomofErnor it doesnt have to do with the echo, shes slightly flat either way if you compare it with the original song. i think iu is talented too, and im not hating on her. im just saying that she can be out of tune too and shes not perfect all the time.
juhaynee 1 year ago
@juhaynee I don't like her music or her. I just think you're incorrect.
TheKingdomofErnor 1 year ago
another Joyce Sims is born, splendid
defector1968 1 year ago
self-explanatory
SyndicateR1 1 year ago
아이유짜응~ 아이유앓이중 ㅠ
yoonbp01 1 year ago
시발...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
hksxskyline 1 year ago
fobs vv
randeDANDE 1 year ago
holy.... lol
deanilk 1 year ago
우와 소름 쫙 돋았다 ㅎㄷㄷ
cucutin1 1 year ago
ㅅㅂ 얼굴도 존내 예뻐 ㅡㅡ 카라팬으로써 그 날 비교 당하길래 기분 너빠서 안보다가 오늘 처음 봤는데 와 진짜 반했어 ㅜㅜ 난 원래 카라나 소시같은 누나를 좋아하는 편인데 어쩌다 나보다 한살 어린애란테 훅갔너 ㅠㅠ
WingedCity01 1 year ago
정말 놀라워요!!!!
아이유 격하게 아껴~
umtaegue 1 year ago
ZOMG IU!!!
namunamuchan 1 year ago
i love the dance
luvdongho 1 year ago
Good stuff, one of the few "k-pop" singers who actually sings.
searchlight31 1 year ago
Ohh I'm a fan of her songs :D
she's soo amazing yaaa~~
SunszHine 1 year ago
@loveparadex well the attack is called screech just as the attack watergun isnt called watergun attack , durp. and muriah carey only learns 3 moves, sing ( usualy fails ) supersonic ( to confuse people into thinking she can sing ) and sand attack ( making people think they see a hottie when they see a peace of shit with a microphone )
xenexe 1 year ago
아이유치해 3단고음이 머야...노랜좋네..^^
seventhsheeple 1 year ago
screaming is not the same as singing, woman.
boxoflols 1 year ago
@boxoflols That's singing.
ninjadude9 1 year ago
@boxoflols
can you go that high ?
just to make it simple her voice crackd she admitted it herself
newmoonshewolf09 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@newmoonshewolf09 보면서 완전 CD 튼듯한 보이스라 깝놀 첨봤을때부터 잘될줄알았어 ㅋㅋ 팬하길 잘했다 ㅋㅋ
GamingWarStrike 1 year ago
@boxoflols i agree
xenexe 1 year ago
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ듣기좋은소린아닌듯
chlwkrrk 1 year ago 3
@chlwkrrk ㅋㅋㅋ 찬성
k875500 1 year ago
@loveparadex im sorry i dont know screech attack, i know growl but thats for attack not defense
xenexe 1 year ago
안티도 아니고 팬도 아닌 입장에서, 이런걸 가지고 가창력이라느니 언플쩌는게 한심하다. 그냥 막 안되는걸 쥐어짜서 내지르는건데...ㅡ.ㅡ 나만 이런건가
solveaproblem 1 year ago
@solveaproblem 고음은 쥐어짠다고 쉽게 나오는거 아님. 거기다가 저렇게 오랫동안 고음하면서 점점 올라가는건 짠다고 되는거 더더욱 아님 어느정도 실력이 되니까 되는거라고 생각함
ktrwcm2010 1 year ago
@ktrwcm2010 님이 오히려 더 모르시는거같네요. 노래는 해보셨는지...;
저게 고음을 쥐어짜는겁니까? 고음을 쥐어짜면은 저렇게 한 음을 길게 뽑지못합니다, 왠만한 여유와 상당한 성량이 필요하죠
님 이 최대로 부를수잇는 고음을 저렇게 길게 한번 짜보세요, 님 성량이 그게 가능하나.
솔직히 아이유 팬도아니고 안티도아닌데 이런 노래의 노자도모르는 무식한발언을보면 조금 화가나네요.
OjFarm 1 year ago
@OjFarm ㅡㅡ?? 전 쥐어짠다고 한적 없는데여? ㅋㅋㅋ 황당하네 코멘트좀 제대로 읽고 댓글 다사지...
solveaproblem 님 댓글보시면 '그냥 막 안되는걸 쥐어짜서 내지르는건데...' 라고 말해서 쉴드쳐준건데 무슨 개드립?? Youtube에 Y 자도 모르는 무식한 사람한테 무식하다고 불리니까 조금 화가나네요.
ktrwcm2010 1 year ago
@ktrwcm2010 님댓글이 바로위에있어서 잘못클릭햇는데
실수도 못하나요? 이해력좀 떨어지시는분이네요... 아 이분 잘못클릭하셨구나 생각도못하시나 ;
OjFarm 1 year ago
@OjFarm ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그런생각 했고 실수했으면 지우고 다시 쓰던가 하지 진짜 심각하게 받아드리네 ㅋㅋㅋ
아 여유가 좀 떨어지시는분이네요 님 ^^
그럼 즐거운 유투빙
ktrwcm2010 1 year ago
@OjFarm 음이 길고 짧은건 육체적, 개인적 차이일 뿐 입니다. 성량이 좋다고 노래를 잘 불르는건 아니에요, 목소리도 갈라지고 음도 에매한데요^^
k875500 1 year ago
@OjFarm @OjFarm 음이 길고 짧은건 육체적, 개인적 차이일 뿐 입니다. 성량이 좋다고 노래를 잘 불르는건 아니에요, 목소리도 갈라지고 음도 에매한데요^^
k875500 1 year ago
@k875500 ㅡㅡ ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; 음이 길고 짧은게 육체적이아니라 폐의 용량의따른 성량입니다
목소리가 갈라져서? 그러면 나얼, 윤민수, 김명기는 노래 할줄 모르는인간들이겠네요... 고음지르실때 목소리 갈라지는데 ^^;
OjFarm 1 year ago
Comment removed
k875500 1 year ago
Comment removed
k875500 1 year ago
@OjFarm 님하 페는 육체가 아닌가요 그럼 정신적? 저 바이올로지 a+ 맞았거든요 ^^ 음악은 a 맞고 ^^
그리고 목소리 갈라진다 하지 않고 out of tune이랬거든요 ^^
이런 논쟁 고 싶지않습니다, 개인차이니깐. 남이 IU 좋아하시는건 상관없으니 전 keyshia cole이나 들으렵니다 2007년곡들이 2010년 아이유곡보다 좋은듯~ 개인적 의견이니 상관 마시길 가창력 떠나서 노래도 더 좋은거 같에요 맨처음 부터 저도 이런 곡 듣는거 아니였는데 실례헸습니다
k875500 1 year ago
@k875500
바이올로지 해서 바이올린 생각한 1인
sunnypark02 1 year ago
@ktrwcm2010 고딩이 키배하느라 수고한다. 얼른 공부해서 바이오 A+ 또 맞아오렴. 그리고 천조국의 톱타이어 케이샤콜과 조꼬만 반도에 여고생을 비교하는.. 아, 아니다, 개인적 생각이랬지.
scyoon95 1 year ago
@scyoon95 상큐
k875500 1 year ago
@scyoon95 리플 잘못 다셨습니다
ktrwcm2010 1 year ago
@ktrwcm2010 아이고 스팸죄송ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 제 병크군눀ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
scyoon95 1 year ago
@solveaproblem 저도 찬성이에요!!!!
k875500 1 year ago
말이 필요없네요 소름이 돋는 가창력....
iljimae75 1 year ago
오 지금 봤는데 진짜 쩐다 아이유 대박인데 라이브에서 그런 기술을 쓰다니 진짜 대단하다
lkjhsdf8162 1 year ago
발전가능성이 높은 가수라고 생각합니다.^^
smauto2002 1 year ago
also 0:04
AIGOOOOOOOOOOO!!! ^___________^
Lampheader 1 year ago
@LilyAnneVaj OMG!!! ME TOO!!! LOL... I really hold my breath...lol
anghianning 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wtf is she a god damn cat?
wow that... was horrible was that a fucking screech attack, i can feel my defense falling as i listen to it
xenexe 1 year ago
@xenexe yeah save your shit for mariah carey's shitty screech rendition of the national anthem, this screech shit is nothing compared to that
also pokemon lol
Lampheader 1 year ago
@Lampheader oh dude mariah carey is just horrible, shes like a level 50 pokemon
that uses super sonic or some shit
xenexe 1 year ago
Dayummm, that girls' got some vocals.
SunsetGlow21 1 year ago 3
다비치 짱 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
strikebandit 1 year ago
잘하네.....
baddudland 1 year ago
CD 음질 그대로
sexyguy15 1 year ago
Comment removed
kkjw2 1 year ago
Everybody is on their butt .. IU is already a legend into kpop .. people are just starting to see it right now =)
And with years .. she's going to be more & more amazing .. we can say she can be here in 30+ years too .. ^^
BESTofASIAN 1 year ago
well. I don't think so.. She just have better lung capacity not really concerned with strong Voice.
Lostkorea 1 year ago
최고 진짜 대박!!! 아이유 짱! 어제 뮤뱅 보면서 완전 CD 튼듯한 보이스라 깝놀
TheKDU11 1 year ago 30
헐..
kittenishh 1 year ago
라이브란게 믿겨지지가 않아.....
ujy336 1 year ago
DAM! can someone say talent?
KTbeat 1 year ago
엉엉 ㅠㅠ 아이유느님 날 가져요~~ ㅠㅠ
haniKee 1 year ago
씨스타의 효린이만 빼고 올킬
yarnim 1 year ago
아이유♥ 첨봤을때부터 잘될줄알았어 ㅋㅋ 팬하길 잘했다 ㅋㅋ
Misanthrope08 1 year ago 21
아이유 언니는 가창력이 너무너무 짱이에요!!
b3rryblue 1 year ago
autotuned a lil but still brilliant
westharry 1 year ago
대박....
globee74 1 year ago
와~아이유 쩐다!! 다른 여자아이돌중에 저렇게 노래 부를수 있는 사람들 나와봐!! you win...
koreandy0513 1 year ago