They got 30 seconds in and the second horn blew it with bad intonation. Why didn't they just redo it? On second thought, that horn player should just be fired because he can't hear that he is out of tune at 1:13 either. Or maybe he showed up to the session late and didn't warm up his horn. This is why buying recordings of orchestras annoys me. I can imagine it better than they can play it. Saddening. :(
@DerangedRanger1 As far as I could check by listening, the horns play right. Debussy's score includes simultaneous Major 2nd interval for horns at 30". At 1'13, the horn could be better tuned, but the pitch is right. Remembering that horns are rather harmonically than equal tempered.
@didgig From the time I spent in orchestras, something I noticed that many don't seem to understand is that there is more to intonation than simply playing the right pitch. If you you don't play as a unit it will not sound in tune. For example, not attacking precisely, or more commonly, not listening across or studying scores enough to know who you are playing with so that you can match timbres. I would have made them do this again with more attentive ears.
La Nature est vide de regard ; la musique, vide d'arbres. Seule la communion du Souvenir et de sa Représentation sublimée, par la recréation poétique résultant de Wordsworth, sécrète le mystère de l'Amour cosmique qui relie le coeur entreposé dans le bocal de la furieuse modernité à la campagne ensoleillée. Autrefois, peut-être, qui sait ?, la campagne, ensoleillée, ruisselait de délicatesses chatoyantes.
Merci, Claude, d'avoir donné la vie. La première fois, souviens-toi, il pleuvait ce jour-là ; c'était au siècle dernier et j'ai pleuré ; et depuis, le sanglot n'a pas cessé. Comment pourrais-je jamais connaître un tel bonheur ?
thanks very much. But high quality movie for read notes etc means a very large amount of memory... I'm planning to put this material in another place with a better quality. I'll let know!
LOVE this! :)
MyPlaymobileClaymay 1 year ago
They got 30 seconds in and the second horn blew it with bad intonation. Why didn't they just redo it? On second thought, that horn player should just be fired because he can't hear that he is out of tune at 1:13 either. Or maybe he showed up to the session late and didn't warm up his horn. This is why buying recordings of orchestras annoys me. I can imagine it better than they can play it. Saddening. :(
DerangedRanger1 1 year ago
@DerangedRanger1 As far as I could check by listening, the horns play right. Debussy's score includes simultaneous Major 2nd interval for horns at 30". At 1'13, the horn could be better tuned, but the pitch is right. Remembering that horns are rather harmonically than equal tempered.
didgig 1 year ago 5
@didgig From the time I spent in orchestras, something I noticed that many don't seem to understand is that there is more to intonation than simply playing the right pitch. If you you don't play as a unit it will not sound in tune. For example, not attacking precisely, or more commonly, not listening across or studying scores enough to know who you are playing with so that you can match timbres. I would have made them do this again with more attentive ears.
DerangedRanger1 1 year ago
@DerangedRanger1 Ouch, that WAS out of tune, lol!
linguistmuz 2 months ago
25 de abril de 2010, MASP, 16 h, com a Camerata Aberta, em versão de câmara (David Walter). Imperdível!
basso69 1 year ago
It's all about 3:56-4:30. The cello and horns in this part are so moving.
98jaym 1 year ago
La Nature est vide de regard ; la musique, vide d'arbres. Seule la communion du Souvenir et de sa Représentation sublimée, par la recréation poétique résultant de Wordsworth, sécrète le mystère de l'Amour cosmique qui relie le coeur entreposé dans le bocal de la furieuse modernité à la campagne ensoleillée. Autrefois, peut-être, qui sait ?, la campagne, ensoleillée, ruisselait de délicatesses chatoyantes.
TempodiPiano 2 years ago
Merci, Claude, d'avoir donné la vie. La première fois, souviens-toi, il pleuvait ce jour-là ; c'était au siècle dernier et j'ai pleuré ; et depuis, le sanglot n'a pas cessé. Comment pourrais-je jamais connaître un tel bonheur ?
TempodiPiano 2 years ago
Comment removed
TempodiPiano 2 years ago
I LOVE 5:45 !!!
pelleas08 2 years ago 6
me too...from 5:45 to 6:30 is like a musical orgasm!
bbwannab 2 years ago 5
me three.
wesleyan97 2 years ago
@bbwannab One of the greatest 3/4ths of a minute as any i've heard in music.
darmani212 8 months ago
@pelleas08 If you love this part, you might also like Yann Tiersen's music from the film Amélie. It's very much alike ;)
JaniceMaya 1 year ago
very nice work! wish it was on high quality to show more clearly the notes... hopfully I have the score somewhere...
galliard1981 3 years ago
thanks very much. But high quality movie for read notes etc means a very large amount of memory... I'm planning to put this material in another place with a better quality. I'll let know!
didgig 3 years ago
@galliard1981
I've got the score :)
JaniceMaya 1 year ago