I love this video! I don't think we'll ever forget about 2D animation. I loved the part when Hayao Miyazaki appeared and picked up the pencil! He was wearing Haky's clothes and crossed the bridge where it lead to the bathhouse! And No Face was there! I love Miyazaki's work!
I have your fist book, It was used in my school in Dallas, so happy I found your new book as a 2d flash animator and cartoonist I find your book inspiring, I also enjopyed your film, and as animater myself I can apprieciate your your work and know how much you put into it! thank you for sharing this with the world.
I'm glad I bought your book. This movie is really touching and I feel so motivated by watching it. I hope I can get my arts teacher convinced to show this in her lesson, so we can discuss it after the final exams. x3 *feels motivated* As long as we have something to draw with, 2d animiation can't die.
Wow, this is a Greek tragedy. Though i am happy that 2D animation is still being used over sea's, but I still say: That 2D animation shouldn't die in the good old U.S.A!
Hi,Mr Tony White.I'm learning your book right now.I like your book a lot. At the same time,I'm preparing my first short cartoon.I'm totally agreed that painting with a pencil is the most important thing.I prefer to draw more pictures at first.
Glad the book helped. You might be interested to know that I have a new one coming out in September, through Focal Press. Its called "Animator's Notebook". You might also like to know that we're in the last 24 hours of our Kickstarter appeal for a new 2D film trailer - "Bad Penguin" - that will hopefully lead to a movie. (Although time's running out if you want to pledge!) It will be done as an entirely non-profit venture to support traditional animation in the USA. Thanks for the comments! :)
I cried with the video and smiled, it is a great film. Hope you keep doing animated work. I was touched. jeje hayao miyasaki in the final part was great XD Love his work. I´m just beginning into the animation world so you book is a great help for me.
That is so funny! I just literally got done saying " well Hayao Miyazaki still keeps with" and before I even finished the sentence there he was picking up the pencil. That was cute!
Too much Walt Disney-worship, both in and outside the industry, is what landed animation in this situation in the first place. How I wish anyone at all had seen fit to try and provide him and Disney Studios with some proper competition back in the 30s-50s. If Warner Bros had decided- had had the Funding necessary to venture into feature animated films, and had been successful at it, things would be very different now.
Don Bluth put up a good fight, carrying the torch throughout the 90s, but...
@doroterra uh no, he was referencing Hayao Miyazaki's Spirited away. He still uses the traditional style of animation: In example- cells that are hand drawn.
Hi tony. I am a 25 year old aspiring animator. I am currently reading you book Animation from pencil to pixel and it is helping me a great deal. I have only recently decided to become an animator after working as a graphic designer and web designer for a few years and I am loving the mixture of creative processes that it involves.
dear tony, I am currently reading your book.i just bought it yesterday and havent even put it down :) this is such a helpful read. and this film you made is awesome.
thank you also for being so down to earth... i really enjoy that especially.
Tony: I like this video a lot and I appreciate what you have to say, but I think your jab at Ralph Bakshi at 4:45 is a little uncalled for. Not that I consider the bulk of his work to be animated brilliance, but prominent efforts to market animation to a more adult audience were long overdue. A more accurate depiction of the decline of animation quality would have focused on the deluge of limited TV animation from Hanna Barbera, Jay Ward, et al.
I do actually applaud a more mature and imaginative use of animation, especially in the face of the predictable and formulaic approaches of corporate Hollywood. But let us not be fooled. Ralph Bakshi produced mediocrity with this and his other films. Fritz could have been a HUGE breakthrough moment for animation and yet he dropped the ball. Even the fabulous R. Crump (who's work 'Fritz' was based on) hated the film and dissociated himself with it! That's why I chose it. Tony. :^{)}=-
That's a fairly common opinion about the Fritz film but I've never really understood what people think Bakshi 'should have' done, aside from maybe tweaking some of the pacing. In my opinion the film is quite faithful to the source material, therefore it's episodic and a little disjointed. As much as I like Crumb's work, he's widely known to be an egomaniac. I suspect his displeasure with the Fritz film stems from somebody having more success with one of his characters than he did.
@TonyWhiteFilms This might be quite far-fetched, but I think Ralph Bakshi is to animation what synthesizers were to the 80's New Wave: For better or worse, it made animation approachable to some. Sure, there are technical, narrative and conceptual flaws on Ralph's artwork, but he's the result of an era that tried to make animation more approachable to people that were not part of a big studio. Granted: Fritz the Cat is an eyesore but, oddly enough, it fed my interest in animation.
@FuhQTube I understand what you're saying but I needed an example of the 'decline' that all could identify with internationally. TV ads are very localized and very transitory. Yes, Bakshi films did (rightly) attempt to reach 'adult' audiences. Its just that he made them so badly that audiences were majorly turned off - as was R. Crumb too! This lack of resultant confidence of course spoiled it for the rest of us who also wanted to make 'adult-targeted' movies but couldn't raise the finance.
love the film i hope that animaticus drawersawrs rise again as i am an aspiring animaticus drawersarus !, also i was wandering what the miyazaki animaticus is saying at the end as i cannot see the subtitles 'case of the youtube screening only thing
As a member of the Animaticus Drawersaurus herd since 1974, I congratulate you, Tony, on producing this brilliant animated short. I am doing what I can to keep a strain of the herd alive.
There's just something about 2D animation that has a 'realism' or 'breath of life' 3D cannot imitate. I hope to help keep the Animaticus herd from becoming extinct. =D
Thank you for making this. It has touched me and everyone I have shown it to.
Speaking of which, I appreciate the higher quality in this video. It usually felt awkward when viewing it on my computer with the CD.
More importantly, I now appreciate the video itself a lot more. Having learned as much as I have, I now understand everything about it, as opposed to when I watched it when I had a fresh eye to animation knowledge.
Awesome...get this into theatres so that you can be in the running for the Academy Award for best animated short! We're pimping this at The Cartoon Geeks. Very well done.
I've tried, with no success. It was even turned down my most animation festivals I've sent it too! I guess its just too in-joke, industry-focused to have a popular appeal. But it served its purpose with the book anyway!
You're the first person to have noted that reference! (Most people glaze over and think I've lost my mind at that point!) It is of course an homage to the wonderful Richard Williams' breakthrough film, "A Christmas Carol"... produced by Chuck Jones and winner of an Academy Award.
I have many fond memories of this version of "A Christmas Carol" from my childhood. This particular scene scared me out of my wits. BTW. Last time I checked, the entire film (in many parts) is here on YouTube.
its nice, but it sounds like its saying that 'true quality animation' is the sole property of Disney. Is it meant to imply that Miyazaki is just picking up what Disney left behind? Becasue Studio Ghibli has always been on equal terms, if not better than Disney.
Yep, just seen it Cartoon Brew as well, loved it, especially the part with Roger Rabbit. One strange thing here - why is the video for Welcome To The Jungle in the similar videos section?
I like the making and quality of this short film very much, but the personification of Good and Evil is highly questionable to me. Every animation technique has its advantages and drawbacks, the trick is knowing when and how to use which.
I love this video! I don't think we'll ever forget about 2D animation. I loved the part when Hayao Miyazaki appeared and picked up the pencil! He was wearing Haky's clothes and crossed the bridge where it lead to the bathhouse! And No Face was there! I love Miyazaki's work!
Gundameister93 4 days ago
I have your fist book, It was used in my school in Dallas, so happy I found your new book as a 2d flash animator and cartoonist I find your book inspiring, I also enjopyed your film, and as animater myself I can apprieciate your your work and know how much you put into it! thank you for sharing this with the world.
theanimatedpencil 1 week ago
I'm glad I bought your book. This movie is really touching and I feel so motivated by watching it. I hope I can get my arts teacher convinced to show this in her lesson, so we can discuss it after the final exams. x3 *feels motivated* As long as we have something to draw with, 2d animiation can't die.
SiriWesen 5 months ago
Wow, this is a Greek tragedy. Though i am happy that 2D animation is still being used over sea's, but I still say: That 2D animation shouldn't die in the good old U.S.A!
Scoonertuna 5 months ago
Hi,Mr Tony White.I'm learning your book right now.I like your book a lot. At the same time,I'm preparing my first short cartoon.I'm totally agreed that painting with a pencil is the most important thing.I prefer to draw more pictures at first.
xinandmagiclife 5 months ago
Glad the book helped. You might be interested to know that I have a new one coming out in September, through Focal Press. Its called "Animator's Notebook". You might also like to know that we're in the last 24 hours of our Kickstarter appeal for a new 2D film trailer - "Bad Penguin" - that will hopefully lead to a movie. (Although time's running out if you want to pledge!) It will be done as an entirely non-profit venture to support traditional animation in the USA. Thanks for the comments! :)
TonyWhiteAnimation 7 months ago
Your book has really helped me to understand true animation
Jzz87 7 months ago
this is just amazing. What are you doing nowadays Tony??
Jzz87 8 months ago
I cried with the video and smiled, it is a great film. Hope you keep doing animated work. I was touched. jeje hayao miyasaki in the final part was great XD Love his work. I´m just beginning into the animation world so you book is a great help for me.
2Nicamos 1 year ago
amazing!
i hope 2D never dies
Lidve1337 1 year ago
That is so funny! I just literally got done saying " well Hayao Miyazaki still keeps with" and before I even finished the sentence there he was picking up the pencil. That was cute!
Sh3ikha 1 year ago
Too much Walt Disney-worship, both in and outside the industry, is what landed animation in this situation in the first place. How I wish anyone at all had seen fit to try and provide him and Disney Studios with some proper competition back in the 30s-50s. If Warner Bros had decided- had had the Funding necessary to venture into feature animated films, and had been successful at it, things would be very different now.
Don Bluth put up a good fight, carrying the torch throughout the 90s, but...
greybrother0001 1 year ago
@doroterra uh no, he was referencing Hayao Miyazaki's Spirited away. He still uses the traditional style of animation: In example- cells that are hand drawn.
DreamSerumProd 1 year ago
Great work, Tony. I've already bought the DVD, which I'll be checking out in due time.
falariem 1 year ago
Hi tony. I am a 25 year old aspiring animator. I am currently reading you book Animation from pencil to pixel and it is helping me a great deal. I have only recently decided to become an animator after working as a graphic designer and web designer for a few years and I am loving the mixture of creative processes that it involves.
ToonBunker 1 year ago
dear tony, I am currently reading your book.i just bought it yesterday and havent even put it down :) this is such a helpful read. and this film you made is awesome.
thank you also for being so down to earth... i really enjoy that especially.
youresotoughhh 1 year ago
Miyazaki ending was the way to do it though he did just recently did his last film
TheUnderscoreH 1 year ago 2
What does that chines guy say at the end?
ceitiosaurus 1 year ago
Haha no the end is Miyazaki and the movie spirited away
emigre312 1 year ago
Nope, that's him as No Face from Spirited away. :/
wolfah 1 year ago
Tony: I like this video a lot and I appreciate what you have to say, but I think your jab at Ralph Bakshi at 4:45 is a little uncalled for. Not that I consider the bulk of his work to be animated brilliance, but prominent efforts to market animation to a more adult audience were long overdue. A more accurate depiction of the decline of animation quality would have focused on the deluge of limited TV animation from Hanna Barbera, Jay Ward, et al.
FuhQTube 2 years ago
I do actually applaud a more mature and imaginative use of animation, especially in the face of the predictable and formulaic approaches of corporate Hollywood. But let us not be fooled. Ralph Bakshi produced mediocrity with this and his other films. Fritz could have been a HUGE breakthrough moment for animation and yet he dropped the ball. Even the fabulous R. Crump (who's work 'Fritz' was based on) hated the film and dissociated himself with it! That's why I chose it. Tony. :^{)}=-
TonyWhiteFilms 2 years ago
That's a fairly common opinion about the Fritz film but I've never really understood what people think Bakshi 'should have' done, aside from maybe tweaking some of the pacing. In my opinion the film is quite faithful to the source material, therefore it's episodic and a little disjointed. As much as I like Crumb's work, he's widely known to be an egomaniac. I suspect his displeasure with the Fritz film stems from somebody having more success with one of his characters than he did.
FuhQTube 2 years ago
@TonyWhiteFilms This might be quite far-fetched, but I think Ralph Bakshi is to animation what synthesizers were to the 80's New Wave: For better or worse, it made animation approachable to some. Sure, there are technical, narrative and conceptual flaws on Ralph's artwork, but he's the result of an era that tried to make animation more approachable to people that were not part of a big studio. Granted: Fritz the Cat is an eyesore but, oddly enough, it fed my interest in animation.
koshkatoverdrive 1 year ago
@FuhQTube I understand what you're saying but I needed an example of the 'decline' that all could identify with internationally. TV ads are very localized and very transitory. Yes, Bakshi films did (rightly) attempt to reach 'adult' audiences. Its just that he made them so badly that audiences were majorly turned off - as was R. Crumb too! This lack of resultant confidence of course spoiled it for the rest of us who also wanted to make 'adult-targeted' movies but couldn't raise the finance.
TonyWhiteAnimation 1 year ago
Its awsome!
And your book helped me a lot :)
Streusel95 2 years ago
Wonderful representation about animation. Animation is new and still young. I strongly believe that we are not extinct at all but hibernating.
heimsboy 2 years ago
love the film i hope that animaticus drawersawrs rise again as i am an aspiring animaticus drawersarus !, also i was wandering what the miyazaki animaticus is saying at the end as i cannot see the subtitles 'case of the youtube screening only thing
MatthiusMonkey 2 years ago
Maybe he is saying "This Pencil is cream, creamy pencil! I like creamy pencils, they make me happy." ?? Maybe???
Animaticus Drawersarus, loving that name.
Gredika 2 years ago
I am reading your book , it is of great inspiration for me thank you for sharing your knowledge and experience.
Keor66 2 years ago
Awesome reading your book. I love all the references in your animation.
RocketCarProductions 2 years ago
oh cool!! i totally use this book in my Animation class!!
natticus54 2 years ago
This is SOO SAD BUT TRUE.... Thats why I do 3D, and not draw anymore.
3DDesignz 2 years ago
this is AMAZING
pencil is being succeeded from gens to gens...
lamegozilla 2 years ago
8:09 Aww!
PCWWalser91 2 years ago
Comment removed
PCWWalser91 3 years ago
As a member of the Animaticus Drawersaurus herd since 1974, I congratulate you, Tony, on producing this brilliant animated short. I am doing what I can to keep a strain of the herd alive.
Gian (John) Celestri
JohnTheAnimatorGuy 3 years ago
Um... You say you got help from Roy E. Disney and that he provided his voice but i can't hear his distinct voice anywhere?
Nick4700 3 years ago
Try listening to the voice of the ghost and the chuckle at the end. I would be sued if I lied. I also resent your insinuation that I did so!
Tony. >:^{(}=-
TonyWhiteFilms 3 years ago 2
Just a question i was wondering sorry if i sounded doubtful love this video good job and congratulations on your career.
Nick4700 3 years ago
There's just something about 2D animation that has a 'realism' or 'breath of life' 3D cannot imitate. I hope to help keep the Animaticus herd from becoming extinct. =D
Thank you for making this. It has touched me and everyone I have shown it to.
reverseblade 3 years ago
That was wonderful.
Animation isn't dead. You just proved that.
conoba 3 years ago 2
This is so awesome Tony! Can't believe this got so rejected at festivals... Also the whole problem with execs now is so true!
The80swasStraight 3 years ago
Who Framed Roger Rabbit was created without the aid of computers. One hundred percent hand drawn goodness!
ColBarnaby 3 years ago
he is talking about the shadows
psicoyote 3 years ago
Indeed. Roger says, in his goofy voice, "Look! Real shadows!"
PCWWalser91 3 years ago
Speaking of which, I appreciate the higher quality in this video. It usually felt awkward when viewing it on my computer with the CD.
More importantly, I now appreciate the video itself a lot more. Having learned as much as I have, I now understand everything about it, as opposed to when I watched it when I had a fresh eye to animation knowledge.
PCWWalser91 3 years ago
I love U
(and your book)
have a look at my great animations
and tellvme what U think about it.
Maybe we can produce a movie in teamwork.
all my love to you and your films.
knutl123 3 years ago
love it
and i read your book LOL
knutl123 3 years ago
Awesome...get this into theatres so that you can be in the running for the Academy Award for best animated short! We're pimping this at The Cartoon Geeks. Very well done.
MsGeek703 3 years ago
I've tried, with no success. It was even turned down my most animation festivals I've sent it too! I guess its just too in-joke, industry-focused to have a popular appeal. But it served its purpose with the book anyway!
Best wishes,
Tony. :^{)}=-
TonyWhiteFilms 3 years ago 2
Beautiful! I especially loved the "Richard Williams/Chuck Jones" inspired Marleys' Ghost at 5:07.
33Keith33 3 years ago
Hi Keith.
You're the first person to have noted that reference! (Most people glaze over and think I've lost my mind at that point!) It is of course an homage to the wonderful Richard Williams' breakthrough film, "A Christmas Carol"... produced by Chuck Jones and winner of an Academy Award.
Thanks for the comment!
And thanks to everyone for their comments too!
Tony. :^{)}=-
TonyWhiteAnimation 3 years ago
I have many fond memories of this version of "A Christmas Carol" from my childhood. This particular scene scared me out of my wits. BTW. Last time I checked, the entire film (in many parts) is here on YouTube.
33Keith33 3 years ago
Wonderfully drawn and animated with beautiful music. Definately Disney biased, but still brilliant.
patronise 3 years ago
amazing!! thanks a lot, from a young animator in bsas, argentina.
vlasvlasvlas 3 years ago
thank you for this
Random54 3 years ago
beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
knutl123 3 years ago
its nice, but it sounds like its saying that 'true quality animation' is the sole property of Disney. Is it meant to imply that Miyazaki is just picking up what Disney left behind? Becasue Studio Ghibli has always been on equal terms, if not better than Disney.
someonemagical 3 years ago
Very nice. I loved every second of it. Thank you for producing this!
zeekslider 3 years ago
A lovely piece, thanks
mikecupcake 3 years ago
Just Great! Loved the Miyasaki cameo at the end. The true spirit of Disney still lives... in Ghibli.
Kirb 3 years ago 2
Yep, just seen it Cartoon Brew as well, loved it, especially the part with Roger Rabbit. One strange thing here - why is the video for Welcome To The Jungle in the similar videos section?
RyanWithTwoHeads 3 years ago
I like the making and quality of this short film very much, but the personification of Good and Evil is highly questionable to me. Every animation technique has its advantages and drawbacks, the trick is knowing when and how to use which.
fabianfucci 3 years ago
Awesome awesome awesome!
Springymajig 3 years ago
It's the truth isn't it?
RZetlin 3 years ago
This was actually brilliant. Loved it. It may not reach a mainstream audience, but those who understand it will love it.
NobleApple 3 years ago
Omnia mutantur, nihil interit.
rawfulralph 3 years ago
I just saw this on Cartoon Brew. It was wonderful. Thanks for making it.
Taydar 3 years ago