Added: 5 years ago
From: yak3001
Views: 2,470,055
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,197)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • THIS SONG THIS VIDEO ITS BEATUFUL I WANT TO CRY EVERY TIME I HEAR IT I JUST WISH IT DIDNT HAPPEN TO HER HER SISTER WAS SOOO YOUNG AND FRAGRIL I AM SOO SORRY FOR ANYONE THAT LOST SOMEONE THAT MMEANT THE WORLD TO THEM THAT THEY LOVED AND CARED FOR THEM

  • so why this song had not the video?

  • I love this song :) helps through alot of things

  • Every time I listen to this song song, someone breaks my heart :'(

    As I sit here typing me and my...love...are breaking up, slowly and painfully she's tearing my heart out, and there isn't anything I can do to stop it :'(

    And yet this song helps...it keeps me calm and stops me from tearing myself apart in anguish.

    Thank you Amy Lee, you have helped more than you shall ever know.

  • god blessed me i thriumph in the dark i over came a lost place i,m not underneath a tragedy as all you whom turned to evanescence i found myself and goth is my selfexpression my life is into her band be proud play it loud if you disagree i don,t care i,m 4 real amy lee rocks.

  • oh GOD! it's hard to read these comment and not tear up! omg i feel so bad 4 all of you! STOP MAKING ME CRY! D'X

  • she should sing this music and ben should came back to the band

  • this song give me chills but in a good way :)

  • Very hard to listen to this song without emotion. I lost two sons and this song is an emotional release for me....

  • i just learned to play this and i cry even when i am the one singing it!

    

  • Very well made video. I understand why she cannot play it live. It chokes me up every time. So sad yet so beautiful.

  • there was Prince...and after Amy lee just a complete artist!!! I love her so much!!!!!

  • i cant choose what is my fav song all of her song r the best

  • this song is just INCRADIBLE!!!!!I have a glowin' tieth...

  • I don't think this song is so much about either wanting to die or to be with her sister (obviously she wants to be with her sister but you know what i mean). I think she writing from the perspective of when she was younger, cause when ur young grief isn't something that really hits you yet. I think its more about denail and then finally at the the end "suddently i know im not sleeping" she finally realizes that her sister isn't comming back and its just her.

  • @maanalove

    Ur not the olnly one

  • Don't try to fix me i'm not broken (y) That's the best part .. And this song makes me cry everytime i hear it ... i think i'm not the only one .. :D

  • wonderful song...love one so much. thanks for stirring video-good job <3

  • Just let me go...yes, I can feel it, her sister. It's here, it's at the corner, everywhere. And stilling inside it, fix the sad hearts. <3

  • thats amazing

    

  • I like this song a lot.

  • I like this song a lot.

  • Comment removed

  • Not trolling (in actually complimenting because it's s great video and song) but I noticed at one part it was a clip from my chemical romances song vampires will never hurt you.. Great choice I love this song too but it's to sad

  • She doesn't perform this live for a reason. You know why? It's about her sister. She'd break down, singing it live. I can hear the feelings in her voice, I can hear her pain.

  • cool

    

  • Verry verry good this song is of best at the edge she

  • she wrote the song for her sister who died at the age of 3

  • This song is one of the best Evanescence's songs (esta es una de las mejores canciones de evanescaence)

  • no fun ;]

  • This song remind me of a friend that went missing. At a playground , years ago :/ I miss her. I would dedicate this song to her and my sister.

  • Uh No this song was written about her sister that died at a young age

  • The part of the dark angel wings is broken with seether

  • my daughter was 13 and had cancer a tumor in her throught and she couldn't breathe this song was written about her she was a young school girl the doctors said she had asthma and she was hardly able to breathe what followed was chemo no smiling and i wanted to wake from this night mare she didn't feel broken and said don't cry there was a lot of no sleeping

  • where does the clip of the girl with black wings come from???? BTW I love this song and the video<3

  • 110 people haven't been told that she's not breathing...

  • i loveyouu amy lee <3

  • o god, this is f.....g beautiful

    amazing voice!!

  • goosebumps from my toes to my neck. so beautifull Crying almost lol

  • i like this song

  • i love u evanesence

  • This song is about how her sister died when Amy was 6 and her sister was 3 she was first told that her sister had passed on while she was in the school yard. I don’t think this is so much that she wants to die but that she wishes she could be with her sister. This song was written completely by Amy Lee when most Evanescence songs are not just written by Amy. She put her soul into the song.

  • mt sobre natural axo mt diferenti

    gosto

  • super video

  • Cette chanson est magnifique ...

  • i love youuu bgad sotk gamd (This song When I hear fly in another world )

  • thats a lot of views for a homemade video.. O.o

  • do they ever sing this live? i mean i cant find any live performance of this song :c

  • @PortelaMetalCrew No she doesn't sing this live, because she wrote it about her dead little sister and it's very emotional for her. (or that's what I've heard)

  • @Pikahopp oh alright, thank you :) its a shame, id love to see her singing this live ._.

  • @PortelaMetalCrew She said that This song and her other song like you,

    are pretty emotional to her, for it brings back memories of her dead sister ,Bonney i think.

    She also said its pretty personal.

  • This song puts me in a another place, lets me forget

  • shes so beautiful!!!<3

  • My friend said this song describes me perfectly... I said she's wrong because of one line: I AM broken, but I still don't want anyone to fix me.....

  • @iluvzexion ........

  • I love it, this songs helps me to forget about everything what happened today :)

  • The beautiful thing a bout Amy is every album she comes out with theres always a song for her younger sister......

  • when i feel sad ... i listen to this U_U

  • Nice (= 

  • i can see Tarja Turunen in some moments!

  • Hello Youtube,

    I just want to say that Amy Lee has been my inspiration and the one person who managed to pull me through my difficult life. The pain and loss in this song is something I know well Now, I want to be just like Amy and touch others in the way she did to me by being an artist as well. Could you please help me out by visiting my Channel (MontyKayaProductions) and watch / subscribe? And could you guys please thumbs up this comment so others can see?

    Thank you so much.

    Monty Kaya :)

  • Videos from Nightwish! ^^

  • Nice music and video...

  • Normally I don't like music videos with random people in it but this was really good and went along very well with the song :)

  • She has an amaze n voice and she has dis GYPSY look about her, now dats SEXY :-). Keep make n great musiz Evanescence.

  • listening to this with my three year old sister lying asleep in my arms, i feel rather depressed

  • She has the most amazing voice I have ever heard...

  • Sic Radical! ^^

  • This song is dedicated to her younger sister who died from unidentified illness.

  • scenes from nightwish's nemo video

  • j'aime trop bon

  • This video is great

  • I would like to dedicate this song to my fallen brothers in arms. Its the first christmas ive been home for a while.this song some how lets me cope.though so many guardian angels fell i was able to come home to my family. Dad i miss u. It was my greatest honor to pay my respect to u at the wall in my uniform this memorial day. I promise i will teach my sons the same values u gave to me.dad i truly miss u. This song is great

  • What movie are some of these scenes from?

  • Eu adorava ouvir esta musica cantada por ela ao vivo. Devia ser lindo|

  • RIP her little sis.

  • Listen to this, pause it, then go to 'Rainy Mood' then close your eyes.....

  • This is my favorite Evanescence song. I adore it. It's sad, but it's real. I know how she felt..

  • What is Tarja Turunen have to do with this video??Srsly what is Sleeping Sun doing in this video?

  • best song after going down and bring me to life ♥♥ love evanescence and amy♥

  • GOOSEBUMPS!!

  • 'has no-one told you shes not breathing?'

    this song is dedicated to her sister who died when amy was a little girl. she didn't understand what was happening :(

  • adoro esta cancion...amy eres de lo mejor¡¡ the admiro¡

  • Amy Lee sometimes sounds like Cher

  • simplemente me encanta....caen lagrimas cada vez qe la escuxo...

  • It makes me cry, beautiful song...

  • I think that this song is the best evanescence's song ever

  • @VeryPrettyFlower Most emotional to be sure

  • @VeryPrettyFlower me too =) I Knew this beautiful song through the book Fallen ^^

  • :D

  • wonderfull...no words...just hello and music

  • i used to listen to this song a lot during a particularly dark time of my life, and it mesmerises me to listen to, because of all the memories it brings back :/ beautiful song though

  • A 15 year old girl holds hands with her 1 year old son. People call her a slut, no one knows she was raped at 13. People call another guy fat. No one knows he has a serious disease causing him to be over weight. People call an old man ugly. No one knew he had a serious injury on his face while fighting for our country in the war. People call a woman bald, but they don't know she has cancer. Re-post this if you are against bullying and stereotyping. I bet 95% of you wont do it.

  • Remember when you could watch a video without commercial?

    Remember when music videos were uploaded by user and not VEVO

    Remember when all the info was to the right of the video?

    Remember you could rate a video 1-5 stars?

    Remember the famous yellow subscribe button?

    Remember when the users controlled the site and not corporations?

    WE MISS THE OLD YOUTUBE!

    Post this in every video and lets start a youtube revolution!

    Thumbs up to keep at the top of the page

  • se isso é evanescence porque tem cenas dos vídeos do Nightwish?

    me poupe

  • its about Amy's sister dying while Amy was at school...

  • This video is dedicated to her sister Bonnie, which died at the age of three. She died of a mysterious illness, Amy lee was in her school playground when she found out.

    I love you Amy Lee.-3 beautiful song dedicated to her.

  • truly beautiful.. thankyou for sharing..xx

  • Brasil :D .

    Evanescence é a melhor banda

  • wow this song very beautiful

  • eu amo d+ o evanescence

  • Why in the world She's Not breathing.. O_O

  • @TheMysicko this song is about her little sister who passed away when Amy was in kindergarten.

  • @kersey402 :( Amy's so strong she's truly an inspiration to all of us... Even the angels worship her :)

  • She as the best I love this beautiful BE YOUR SELF never be some one he want you to be be a light be sun don't dream don't become a you don't know

  • I love this I feel like this is my heart when my ex killed me to go with some girl he did not even know and all that left was this girl I don't even know be your self never be some one your not

  • Beautiful

  • Jajaj!!! o sea si sta chida la rola por la muerte de el hermano de Amy, y los sentimientos que implica, ademas de su obsesion por la muerte!! aunque si el video esta revuelto con clips de NightWish, tambien identifique el de Nemo !! como en el minuto 54 al 57 mas o menos!!! ajajja pero ps no quedo tan maleta que digamos, hasta vote por "Me gusta"

  • hello..........

  • this is my fave depression music

  • love it

    

  • que hace una imagen del video de Nightwish en el segundo 0:29. que chafas

  • @pelonpunk no se pero la cancion esta bonita

  • I read somewhere that Amy won't sing this song live because this song was written for her sister who died at 3 years of age. She didn't wanna perform it live in case she had a breakdown. :-(

  • @TheSimba97 i was just at her concert, she sang this song, it was beautiful and heart wrenching , eere and wonderfull

  • QUE CANCION

  • Song to my best :)

  • Linda Musica.

  • I like this song so much i cant stop listening to it XD

  • I always down-vote comments that tells me to repost or thumbs-up. I came here for music, not to be told to post spam.

  • @caitolent YES! I always do the same

  • Beautiful Music......

    Damn Evanescence Is Amazing!

    ~+love.bein,13+~

  • @EvanscenceBigFan ..the band is not amazing its only amy lee. Seriously!

  • crystallookami we need people like you in this world.We listen the song,we cry and we don't understand what is the reason for this kind of behaviors .Thank you.

  • beautiful song!!!!!

  • SUPER!!!!!

    

  • A voz dela é muito linda , parabéns.

  • I nearly fell asleep to this song last night! I love it so much. And it really has a valuable message. I'm so sorry for Amy-lee for losing her little sister :(

  • one of my prefer like that it's so real and beautiful...☮

  • Ce qui rend les hommes sociables est leur incapacité à supporter la solitude et donc, eux-mêmes.

    Arthur Schopenhauer

  • I really like your video, I know you posted this years ago but better late than never, right? Only thing I would suggest is not to use videos from two different bands. Just makes it confusing and even more issues with copyright stuff. Other than that it great. And I agree with everyone, this is an amazing song. It renders me speechless everytime I listen to it. I remember back when it came out, and all that I was going through. Such strong emotions..again, no more words.

  • To tak smutna piosenka że chce mi się płakać jak to słyszę :C

  • Her voice is so haunting... It makes the lyrics just that much more potent. No one can sing this better than Amy.

  • I think I've seen it before? But I can't remember the name of the song.

  • which music video did you use???

  • i just caught my self repeating this song 4 times now

  • EXCELLENT! :D

  • Beautiful

  • The people who dislike these type of songs are the ones that have chairs made out of money and laughing at people because they are poorer than them. They think these songs are jokes.

  • well....98 people have no heart! I'm crying my eyes out!!

  • bm

    

  • total perfection <3

  • hahahahha pegaram partes do video do nemo, nightwish ^^ fico boom

  • eu adoroooo...... Evanescence é muiitooo bom!!

    melhor banda.. e a Amy Lee canta muiiitooo .. adoro a voz dela!

  • I love so much evanescence is very .. veryy wonderful is the best of world.

  • uma linda voz, sem duvida uma diva do hock

    nodes2011

  • Amy Lee AMO A SUA VOZ!

  • 98 people were crying and hit the wrong button

  • @xXuberflutesXx ..no i must correct you. sry my english is very bad because im from germany an 14 years old.

    105 people. .... its a soo amazing song.!

  • q ha sido d amy lee????? alguien sabe????

  • @cutemolee no se si todavia esta cantando pero un amiga miya me ensenyo una consion de ella y supe que su hermana peqeña se murio. disculpa que no escribo tan bien mi enpañol xD

  • @cutemolee el nuevo album sale el 11 de octubre pero casi todo el grupo es diferente aparte por ella claro.

  • so sad so deeply so beautiful

  • how could 98 people not like this

  • So musica perfeita !

  • poso agapw evanencesce...amy lee se latreuw!

  • O.o que Buen temaa que Lindo!!!

    

  • is this the oficial video ??

    

  • Oh... that's so sad. I had no idea this song was for her sister.

    It's really creepy but I'm writing a book on Wattpad and the sister in that dies and this is the song I chose...

    I have major goosebumps xx

    Beautiful song <3

  • eu amooo vc amy lee to te esperando vc no rock in rio valeuu *-*

  • A 15 year old girl holds hands with her 1 year old son. People call her a slut, no one knows she was raped at 13. People call another guy fat. No one knows he has a serious disease causing him to be over weight. People call an old man ugly. No one knew he had a serious injury on his face while fighting for our country in the war. People call a woman bald, but they don't know she has cancer. Re-post thi