I hate to say this after manconoo and daubreyjaneweirdsley's match (though it ended well!) but I really really couldn't stand The Edge in the movie...
He couldn't even jam properly!! I see their point though in putting him in, but they could of chosen someone better iin my opinion...
Watch British comedian Bill Bailey's take on The Edge's guitar playing it's hysterical and oh so true. The Ege like his singer the pompous Bono is the most overrated guitar player of all time. Strip away the delay and sustain and what do you get, plinky plonk, plonky plink. He shouldn't even be sharing house room with Page or White.
@manconoo "Fantastic"?!!! Only in his and your own rather limited imagination. I think you like The Edge and God!! What a juvenile name, suffer from some form of delusional mediocrity. Guitar playing by a middle aged man for spotty adolescents. Now go to your room!!! Errrhh!! Like "Nuff said". Laughable
@manconoo Temper, temper my cretinous little man. No one asked you to send your rather inane comments to my inbox in the first place. Don't you know your use of the word "cunt" is the last refuge of a moron. What's your problem are you a repressed homosexual? Or aren't you getting any Cuuuuuuuuuuuuuunt?!!!!! I guess you can always fuck Palestinian's. When their tied down of course. What a fool!!!
@daubreyjaneweirdsley Now now! There there...I am sorry for calling you a cunt, I take it you are a woman? I am not gay as it happens and my boyfriend will even tell you that. For the record I hate Zionism and it does not represent me or most decent jews. I want to see the Palestinians get their land back. The Edge is still a great guitar wizard totally different style to White and Page.
@manconoo You sound like a decent and reasonable man so lets agree to differ over The Edge. I wish you well and forgive me if my tone was a little strident.
Meh I'm not a fan of U2 but I appreciate The Edge is good at what he does
Jimmy is the best but I agree, Jack is a close second.
Jimmy and Jack are more creative, geez, I was watching something with Edge in, he was like, oh this song without the effects goes like this, it was really simple. He said it himself.
i love led zeppelin, jack whites alright, U2 is my favorite band, im not saying Edge is the best out of all of them, but im saying in MY OPPINION he is the most creative. You Dumbshits think im saying hes the best. No Wrong. Dumb Fucks.
yeah, take where the streets have no name for example..... Jack White Nor Jimmy Page could ever make that sound. yeah its effects, but you have to know how to use the effects. and he does know how to do that.
yeah, i am. im saying he is more CREATIVE, not better at the guitar. Jimmy page would whoop his ass at guitar with no effects, but when you bring in effects the edge can do some sweet stuff.
I don't think you can come out with such a big statement, when you don't know. It's not true. It's not just because he doesn't play what Jack White and Jimmy Page play, that he can't do it.
Same thing would happen if you took away The Edge's pedals. He wouldn't be used to it and he probably wouldn't play as well. In the end its all about their different styles
All great guitarists :) ♥The Edge♥ It was amazing watching them play together, especially with their different styles. The Edge with his amazing technology, Jimmy Page was his more natural style, and then Jack White and his "alternative" ideas. Yeah, one guitarist may sound better in your opinion, but that doesn't mean their the best at everything. If you were to give all of the Edge's pedals to JImmy, Jimmy would probably not play as well as he normally does.
Just saw this movie tonight and really enjoyed it. My favorite 2 bands of all time combined with a new musician to me- Jack White that I really was impressed with. Go see it if you love music!
If you were just introduced to jack white, you have some catching up to do...he is a living legend!! PLEASE drop everything and listen to the white stripes, raconteurs, dead weather(in any order)....you life depends on it...
do you think any of these guys would have agreed to this movie if they didn't have a lot of respect for each other? why don't you guys shut up and show these artists they same respect they show each other. they're all fantastic musicians in their own right.
are you guys kidding me? yea jimmys great. Edge and white both know that. but that doesnt mean they arent great themselves. Jack is amazing at guitar and so is edge. im not saying jimmy isnt but they all are good at what they do. take it from a guitarist. its not about whos better its about what you can learn from others. believe me when jimmy plays with them he learns something too.
Thank you Roxas, one of the few intellegent people to comment on this, people, yes, Jimmy Page is a legend, but that doesn't mean Jack White and The Edge aren't great, they really are all amazing, anybody who really loves music understands it's not about being the best or the most famous, it's about learning more, bettering yourself for yourself, and making great music
James Patrick Page is one of the sloppiest players ever. He's not the best "technically" by any means... but he's my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE !!! Sure, you got Eddie VH, Steve Vai, etc etc. I'd rather hear one good long note than 100 fast shitty notes. Page live was/is electrifying. Others are just playing by rote. B O R I N G.
The 3 subjects are players of substance,and THAT is what the cover band gallery doesn't get.
What's to remember of Steve Vai's playing over the music of those 3? These guys had vision and original ideas,that is why their music lasts because their music is bigger.
Then don't watch the movie, don't watch the vids on youtube, and don't comment anymore. You're making yourself look really retarded for sticking around and commenting if you don't even like it.
HAHA you are obviously a biased asshole. Just look at your name. Led Zeppelin is definitely the best of the three bands, but all three are great in their own right. U2 was THE most popular band in the 80s. White Stripes are one of a kind, mixing blues and punk. Just go back and listen to your Zeppelin albums in seclusion.
He is the guitar player for "The White Stripes." It wasn't my decision, but the idea is that Page represents (and is arguably the best guitarist from) the 60s-70s, The Edge for the 80s-90s (and even until today), and Jack White represents the youngest generation from the 00s.
Not sure. Although it does have a distributor (Sony Pictures Classics), it's still playing the film festival circuit. It will next be in the Berlinale Special Galas section at the Berlin Film festival.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Page is cool. I like his hat. Born To Be Wild was his best song. Who are the other guys with him ? His guitar technicians ? What is guy with white hair ?
dude either your a fucking retard and think that the guy second from left, who has the long white hair, is not jimmhy page, when in fact it is, or you're joking
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
OK I see now Jimmy Page is old. Edge is not really guitar player. He plays New Romantic dance music. Who is Jack White ? The video on youtube of his playing is just terrible. I like Born To Be Wild. I am not retard - but i have mental issue.
Cool video really, I'm really impatient to see what the film will look like, being a fan of U2, and Led Zeppelin being one of my favorite groups.. Love the White Stripes too ^^
By the way, what does Edge answer, after the presenter says he's got more pedals than you do" ?
Thank you for the nice comments, it's my pleasure. It was so exciting -- more like a rock concert than a movie screening. I'm glad you got to see the film.
Jimmy is such a sweetheart<3
EverTheSame5 8 months ago
This made my day "It's called America."
polishgrl87 9 months ago
These 3 should do a comedy show with guitars. :-D
ArrJayEss 1 year ago
'id take the explorer' lol
sims3ps3NG 1 year ago
How is Jack even possible
brutonello92 1 year ago
Cool i'd would loved to have been there.....
slyvester117 1 year ago
Hehe. "Thanks Edge."
lepigeonmad 1 year ago
"You grew up in this very very..."
"It's called America."
XP I loves you Jack White!!
GRandPavisStalker 1 year ago
I hate to say this after manconoo and daubreyjaneweirdsley's match (though it ended well!) but I really really couldn't stand The Edge in the movie...
He couldn't even jam properly!! I see their point though in putting him in, but they could of chosen someone better iin my opinion...
GRandPavisStalker 1 year ago
lol jacks so funny. id take jimmy's guitar LOL
jingwah 1 year ago
Ya'll Can't say what you want about each man. If they ever play a concert together i'm there!!
themossbackman 1 year ago
Watch British comedian Bill Bailey's take on The Edge's guitar playing it's hysterical and oh so true. The Ege like his singer the pompous Bono is the most overrated guitar player of all time. Strip away the delay and sustain and what do you get, plinky plonk, plonky plink. He shouldn't even be sharing house room with Page or White.
daubreyjaneweirdsley 1 year ago
@daubreyjaneweirdsley Edge loved that sketch by Bill Bailey by the way. The Edge is a fantastic guitar player whether you agree or not. Nuff said.
manconoo 1 year ago
@manconoo "Fantastic"?!!! Only in his and your own rather limited imagination. I think you like The Edge and God!! What a juvenile name, suffer from some form of delusional mediocrity. Guitar playing by a middle aged man for spotty adolescents. Now go to your room!!! Errrhh!! Like "Nuff said". Laughable
daubreyjaneweirdsley 1 year ago
@daubreyjaneweirdsley You don't like U2 - fair enough and you think The Edge is crap. I couldn't give to fucks you stupid cunt.
manconoo 1 year ago
@manconoo Temper, temper my cretinous little man. No one asked you to send your rather inane comments to my inbox in the first place. Don't you know your use of the word "cunt" is the last refuge of a moron. What's your problem are you a repressed homosexual? Or aren't you getting any Cuuuuuuuuuuuuuunt?!!!!! I guess you can always fuck Palestinian's. When their tied down of course. What a fool!!!
daubreyjaneweirdsley 1 year ago
@daubreyjaneweirdsley Now now! There there...I am sorry for calling you a cunt, I take it you are a woman? I am not gay as it happens and my boyfriend will even tell you that. For the record I hate Zionism and it does not represent me or most decent jews. I want to see the Palestinians get their land back. The Edge is still a great guitar wizard totally different style to White and Page.
manconoo 1 year ago
@manconoo You sound like a decent and reasonable man so lets agree to differ over The Edge. I wish you well and forgive me if my tone was a little strident.
Daubrey Jane
daubreyjaneweirdsley 1 year ago
@daubreyjaneweirdsley I think I am falling in love with you. ;-)
manconoo 1 year ago
Meh I'm not a fan of U2 but I appreciate The Edge is good at what he does
Jimmy is the best but I agree, Jack is a close second.
Jimmy and Jack are more creative, geez, I was watching something with Edge in, he was like, oh this song without the effects goes like this, it was really simple. He said it himself.
LillyCandyCane 1 year ago
i love led zeppelin, jack whites alright, U2 is my favorite band, im not saying Edge is the best out of all of them, but im saying in MY OPPINION he is the most creative. You Dumbshits think im saying hes the best. No Wrong. Dumb Fucks.
Tye1st 1 year ago
yes he uses technology and he is reallyy good for that and makes u2 sound very good... still Page is the best by far
LOVELED1 1 year ago 4
i agree.
Tye1st 1 year ago
lmfao it's called America.... great.. :D
JoeElliot1994 1 year ago
Suckiest interviewer ever, good thing the lads and the filmakers saved this Q and A from a total disaster.
TheGoldenSphinx 2 years ago 3
Jack White craziest
Jimmy Page best shredder
The Edge-byfar the creative.
Tye1st 2 years ago
Edge "The Creative" ?! Please, is has been playing the same chords for 25 years...
Jack White and Page are the really creative ones...
TheBernauld 2 years ago 2
you got that right....pagey is the best, but, jack comes a very second close....nothing better than a great guitar player
sjlbooks 1 year ago
So....According to you, The Edge is more creative than Jimmy Page or Jack White?
AAAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHHAWFHSLGFUIDSAGFlewhgf
cannabisabuser 1 year ago 8
yeah, take where the streets have no name for example..... Jack White Nor Jimmy Page could ever make that sound. yeah its effects, but you have to know how to use the effects. and he does know how to do that.
Tye1st 1 year ago
Come on, man, you're talking bullshit, you're saying that The Edge is more creative than Jimmy Page because he uses effects...Listen to yourself...
cannabisabuser 1 year ago
yeah, i am. im saying he is more CREATIVE, not better at the guitar. Jimmy page would whoop his ass at guitar with no effects, but when you bring in effects the edge can do some sweet stuff.
Tye1st 1 year ago
Do you know what creative means? If not, go google it, then come back.
You are either an idiot, or a subtle troll.
cannabisabuser 1 year ago
sorry wrong, where do you think all the riffs from zep came from.....jimmy page
sjlbooks 1 year ago
FRIKKENAWESOME
I don't think you can come out with such a big statement, when you don't know. It's not true. It's not just because he doesn't play what Jack White and Jimmy Page play, that he can't do it.
leochestertrudel 2 years ago
Same thing would happen if you took away The Edge's pedals. He wouldn't be used to it and he probably wouldn't play as well. In the end its all about their different styles
citycatred 2 years ago 2
All great guitarists :) ♥The Edge♥ It was amazing watching them play together, especially with their different styles. The Edge with his amazing technology, Jimmy Page was his more natural style, and then Jack White and his "alternative" ideas. Yeah, one guitarist may sound better in your opinion, but that doesn't mean their the best at everything. If you were to give all of the Edge's pedals to JImmy, Jimmy would probably not play as well as he normally does.
citycatred 2 years ago 3
oh he would he's jimmy page and jack white would as well cause he uses many pedals
no if you took the edges effects away he's be fecked
FRIKKENAWESOME 2 years ago
@FRIKKENAWESOME Cmon they are all frikkenawesome guitar players with their own unique sound - edge included!
manconoo 2 years ago
In the early 70's Led Zeppelin began their concerts with WHOLE LOTTA LOVE and ended their concerts with WHOLE LOTTA LOVE.
LOVE IS THE ROCK IN ROCK STAR
playing from the heart, that's how rock stars play together, they are ONE LOVE, and that's where the music streams from....
we are all looking to be the purest channel for love: "a great guitar sound"
thank you for the music, and the movie... it will turn on many people to the love embedded within...
Be well, happy, and peaceful
Bela Ray
belaraymusic 2 years ago
they couldn't afford more mic's haha
lampshad3126 2 years ago
This was hilarious. "It's called America." Ahaha!
VSPINKLOVER89 2 years ago
Just saw this movie tonight and really enjoyed it. My favorite 2 bands of all time combined with a new musician to me- Jack White that I really was impressed with. Go see it if you love music!
demgirl83 2 years ago
@demgirl83
If you were just introduced to jack white, you have some catching up to do...he is a living legend!! PLEASE drop everything and listen to the white stripes, raconteurs, dead weather(in any order)....you life depends on it...
jbw004 1 year ago
i wonder how long its been since the edge too off his beanie
mustardbubble 2 years ago 3
All great guitarists man,
Cheezitman12345 2 years ago 2
do you think any of these guys would have agreed to this movie if they didn't have a lot of respect for each other? why don't you guys shut up and show these artists they same respect they show each other. they're all fantastic musicians in their own right.
higerto11 2 years ago 4
it's called america. lol
Lillyfromthedablock 2 years ago
Jack White is certainly worthy of being in this group, although the Edge, not so sure...
But really White is an awesome musician. And of course Jimmy is the best musician there ever was, possibly.
publicssoss 2 years ago
just different styles dude, i mean besides the edge and jimmy both playing rock are there any similarities in their playing styles
anosan 2 years ago 2
Too True
Lukestar1991 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Jack White should only be allowed to shine Jimmy's Les Paul.
leddhed 2 years ago
are you fucking retarded
BLKvids 2 years ago
This movie should be called "Jimmy gives guitar lessons to a couple of chumps."
leddhed 2 years ago
are you guys kidding me? yea jimmys great. Edge and white both know that. but that doesnt mean they arent great themselves. Jack is amazing at guitar and so is edge. im not saying jimmy isnt but they all are good at what they do. take it from a guitarist. its not about whos better its about what you can learn from others. believe me when jimmy plays with them he learns something too.
Roxasblade100 2 years ago 5
Thank you Roxas, one of the few intellegent people to comment on this, people, yes, Jimmy Page is a legend, but that doesn't mean Jack White and The Edge aren't great, they really are all amazing, anybody who really loves music understands it's not about being the best or the most famous, it's about learning more, bettering yourself for yourself, and making great music
JimiGoode 2 years ago 3
edge and jack white!!!!!! my guitar heroes
msmusic4evr 2 years ago 2
magnificent .. .cant wait till this hits theatres
offthelinegt 2 years ago
James Patrick Page is one of the sloppiest players ever. He's not the best "technically" by any means... but he's my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE !!! Sure, you got Eddie VH, Steve Vai, etc etc. I'd rather hear one good long note than 100 fast shitty notes. Page live was/is electrifying. Others are just playing by rote. B O R I N G.
TacomaPaul 2 years ago 3
The 3 subjects are players of substance,and THAT is what the cover band gallery doesn't get.
What's to remember of Steve Vai's playing over the music of those 3? These guys had vision and original ideas,that is why their music lasts because their music is bigger.
spentonmediocrity 2 years ago 3
yea... over the hills and far away is one of the most technical songs there is...
JimmJacob 2 years ago
jealousy?
FlowMephisto 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Jimmy should bitch-slap those other two ho's and play by himself.
leddhed 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jimmy doesn't hold a candle to Jack White
funkyGmohawk 2 years ago
Dude, you need to piss in a cup.
leddhed 2 years ago
I know you don't really believe this.
You are trying to just push buttons.
So I won't comment.
xlerosx 2 years ago
are you retarded?
JimmJacob 2 years ago
If those other two are carrying Jimmy's gear, then he should not bitch-slap them.
leddhed 2 years ago
ignorant fuck, go to bed
offthelinegt 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah, I want to hear Jimmy play ' 7 nation army'...not . The movie should be titled "Jimmy and a couple of hacks".
leddhed 2 years ago
Then don't watch the movie, don't watch the vids on youtube, and don't comment anymore. You're making yourself look really retarded for sticking around and commenting if you don't even like it.
offthelinegt 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
The movie should be called "Jimmy gives guitar lessons to a couple of chumps".
leddhed 2 years ago
no jimmy and jack give lessons to a chump
drewsky80 2 years ago
fag
offthelinegt 2 years ago
You are acting like I was the one who took the Rainbow sticker off of your bumper.
leddhed 2 years ago
HAhaha so true Jimmy and a couple of hacks
can't compare Led Zep with white stripes or U2....
fattirevsbud 2 years ago
Finally, somebody with some sense.
leddhed 2 years ago
because the other guys you were talking to are 13 lol
fattirevsbud 2 years ago
HAHA you are obviously a biased asshole. Just look at your name. Led Zeppelin is definitely the best of the three bands, but all three are great in their own right. U2 was THE most popular band in the 80s. White Stripes are one of a kind, mixing blues and punk. Just go back and listen to your Zeppelin albums in seclusion.
ZwienerZ 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They should call this movie "Jimmy gives guitar lessons to a couple of chumps".
leddhed 2 years ago
Yeah he does , but does he ever wear underwear?
And I wish Edge would take that fucking stocking cap off!
sisterdiggins 2 years ago
he's probably bald
bernardobrj 2 years ago
Jack White, you have such style!
lucydawg12 2 years ago 4
im only going for jimmy paGE
dannyaudio 2 years ago 3
please watch 'the hardest button to button' live at blackpool lights and change your mind
(not tryin to put jack white at the same level than page...)
bernardobrj 2 years ago 2
Jack White is a very good songwriter! guitarist ,he`s mediore
PAULOcbi 2 years ago
YEE THE EXPLORER
emgrocks92 2 years ago
Jack White is so funny!!
Avixz 2 years ago 15
when does this film come out? anyone know????
jakeyboy261992 2 years ago
Yes, it will be released on August 14 starting in LA and NY.
larry4111 2 years ago
cheers man =p ur a badass
jakeyboy261992 2 years ago
"Edge has more pedals!"
XD
I wanna see that movie!!
I like Led Zeppelin and The White Stripes,but I LOVE U2!!!!!!Especially The Edge!! :D
elevation95 2 years ago 4
"I'm older than him,"
I share ur love 4 Edge!!
I live in T.O. and my friend was in a movie, called ONLY, @ TIFF. I wish I had seen EDGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
chachiacha 2 years ago 3
White..."Thanks Edge." LOL
leftynk 2 years ago 8
White..."It's called America" Lol
mromsennis 2 years ago 25
are you simple?!
ballzdeeper69 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
who is jack white ?
dockaiser 3 years ago
He is the guitar player for "The White Stripes." It wasn't my decision, but the idea is that Page represents (and is arguably the best guitarist from) the 60s-70s, The Edge for the 80s-90s (and even until today), and Jack White represents the youngest generation from the 00s.
larry4111 3 years ago
when is the bloody documentary gonna come out, I wanna watch it?
letshakehands 3 years ago 3
Not sure. Although it does have a distributor (Sony Pictures Classics), it's still playing the film festival circuit. It will next be in the Berlinale Special Galas section at the Berlin Film festival.
larry4111 3 years ago
page beats both, sad but true. i love u2 anyways
caguamamon 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Page is cool. I like his hat. Born To Be Wild was his best song. Who are the other guys with him ? His guitar technicians ? What is guy with white hair ?
avazbone 3 years ago
From left to right are Jack White (in big hat), Jimmy Page, The Edge, producers Thomas Tull and Lesley Chilcott, and director Davis Guggenheim.
larry4111 3 years ago
dude either your a fucking retard and think that the guy second from left, who has the long white hair, is not jimmhy page, when in fact it is, or you're joking
nbeast8900 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OK I see now Jimmy Page is old. Edge is not really guitar player. He plays New Romantic dance music. Who is Jack White ? The video on youtube of his playing is just terrible. I like Born To Be Wild. I am not retard - but i have mental issue.
avazbone 2 years ago
Yeah, He is...:)
Gabbushkaa 3 years ago
Indeed. Jack White and his main influence Jimmy Page are legends. It must have been so sweet for Jack to stand next to his guitar idol.
I really enjoyed this video.
Bercia15 3 years ago 2
Thank you! He seemed pretty flustered up there. He was almost embarrassed to talk with his idols around him.
larry4111 3 years ago
What legends.
Isn't Jack the sweetest? :D
SugarlessCancerous 3 years ago 2
no... me!
axlrocksyuju 3 years ago
wow
lagman50 3 years ago
thanks for helping create a good rock culture in the world
garrotevengador 3 years ago
Cool video really, I'm really impatient to see what the film will look like, being a fan of U2, and Led Zeppelin being one of my favorite groups.. Love the White Stripes too ^^
By the way, what does Edge answer, after the presenter says he's got more pedals than you do" ?
meriadec89 3 years ago
Thanks! Edge says, "I'm older than he is."
larry4111 3 years ago
Thanks too
meriadec89 3 years ago
Thank you, thank you, thank you, for uploading!
I was at the venue but I couldn't get in ... later I had a chance to see the film, it's nice to see the Q&A.
marigoro 3 years ago
Thank you for the nice comments, it's my pleasure. It was so exciting -- more like a rock concert than a movie screening. I'm glad you got to see the film.
larry4111 3 years ago