For those who hate, those who defend with curse words, for those with opinions, and for those without. Steven Wilson and Aviv, religious or not, gay or strait. These types of songs are written because of all of you. Just so you all know.
Steven Wilson and Aviv geffen sound so great singing together, man i live in kettering ohio, the came to cleveland ohio but it was a 6 hour trip, little much for me to try and do, not enough money. However I’m beginning to question if I was right to just skip it.
Steven Wilson is the only non-jewish in this groupe all the musician and the co-singer (Aviv geffen) are jews from Israel. you guys make no sense with your hate against jews, you just envy their success and influence in this world. Jews are so successfull people thank to their unique education from generation to the next and not because god help them.
About antisemitism - whenever is person is that stupid it's just so sad, some people should just get a fucking life just to prevent the pain from others.
Mate, there is no real distinction of what is required and what is not, it has no place in such things like music.....just accept the way he decides to show himself, and enjoy the music! :-)
Seems to me that Steven is very Spiritual, Religion is man's creation. Believing In God and/or being a follower of Christ does not make you religous, it is a spiritual connection with your Creator. Just my opinion!
i'm Palestinian but why the fuck should i care what shit they believe in!? good music has no religion, its a religion on its own besides have you ever heard em insult other people or beliefs? if you hate this band just vote down and fuck off no1 cares what your immature incomplete mind thinks
hard to believe that some dumbass was hating on aviv... for being jewish nonetheless... wtf. maybe one day the world will be free from mindless assholes.
I'm so sorry for those people who do not know peace, love, music.........for those who care about race,nationality,religious and all these fucking things which exist only for these idiots.........we are all human.....and we are all the same because we all have hearts emotions and we all can enjoy life......this is a great music and the only thing is to enjoy it..............
The more I listen to Steve Wilson and see what he does with other artists, the more he reminds me of Todd Rundgren back in the day when Todd played all sorts of styles and produced albums for many artists. I also think Aviv's voice contrasts very nicely with Steve's. It adds a really nice touch.
I had the luck to listen to Aviv Geffen live a couple of days ago :)his voice is really amazing..and it fits the songs he sings.He's a unique artist .
Really, what a shame. But let's face it: Blackfield is for people with good taste of music. So, unfortunately... it's not for everyone in the world...
omg fuck off you antisemitic pieces of shit, who cares about their race or creed or sexual orientation, great music knows no race or religion, pull the dick out of your ass and listen to the music.
I agree with you, however do you not think the "pull the dick out of your ass" part made you sound a bit hypocritical, since you claimed that nobody cares about sexual orientation?
It had nothing to do with sexual orientation, but more to do about them being so reluctant to like the music just because of Aviv's ethnicity/religion. It was not intended to gay bash, it's more synonymous with "stop bitching."
@dlkrdlkr There is an interview somewhere where he said that he read Dawkins' "God Delusion," and said that he agreed with pretty much everything he wrote.
@dlkrdlkr It seems to me that you think less of Wilson for not being religious ("it's not cool to be an atheist"). If that is how you feel, then you are intolerant. And also you may as well insult me because I too am an atheist. I never said anything negative about Jews. Jewish people are cool in my book. I even enjoy volunteering at my JCC.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
why and i am asking again , why , KEEP THAT JEW FAGGOT ??? he aint nothing but a no talent , Steven could do all the instruments plus vocals alone .....shit sucks
just for the record, steven wilson is the only non israeli, non jewish in this band. check out their names at the end of the live dvd show in ny if you dont belive
Blackfield is such a GREAT BAND and Steven is a God at creating music...there are few guys that can be so prolific at making these kind of songs, sad, but beautiful
Steven doesnt have anything to do with this song, it's Aviv's he wrote the entire thing, so before anyone disses Aviv on being a jew etc., I'm an Israeli and this is the kind of musical excellency that comes from our country
I saw them yesterday night in a small club in Munich and i gotta say it was awesome. It's a shame that Aviv is not that well know here. Both Steven and Aviv are fullblooded musicians, it can't get any better. I loved the atmosphere and the whole band was fantastic, i think i need to buy the DVD.
ok i really like blackfield....i love steven wilson and pt. But avivs voice live really gets to me. I hate how it cracks up at the end of every line.....ive tried so hard to like it (his live voice) but i just cant. Am i the only one or are other people bothered by it? SW on the other hand sings so awesome live.
I'm talking about the guitare sound, not the performance (which is great). He didn't mess up the song, I'm just saying it would've been much better with the sole overdrive solo.
For those who hate, those who defend with curse words, for those with opinions, and for those without. Steven Wilson and Aviv, religious or not, gay or strait. These types of songs are written because of all of you. Just so you all know.
DeathReserve 1 month ago
just.. marvelous
einnatar 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Aviv is an atheist by the way. Only because he's from Israel doesn't mean that he automaticly is a jew.
SuperYaEn 3 months ago
Steven Wilson and Aviv geffen sound so great singing together, man i live in kettering ohio, the came to cleveland ohio but it was a 6 hour trip, little much for me to try and do, not enough money. However I’m beginning to question if I was right to just skip it.
o0LanternLight0o 7 months ago 5
Play this song in honor of Steven Wilson, because he lost his father today. Thanks for all your amazing music.
BrianKnop 8 months ago 10
I was the happiest man in the world before listening to that... Now I feel strangely sad, and I don't know why...
I'll never listen to Blackfield while being sad, this would be terrible.
Fikmonskov 8 months ago 2
Steven Wilson is the only non-jewish in this groupe all the musician and the co-singer (Aviv geffen) are jews from Israel. you guys make no sense with your hate against jews, you just envy their success and influence in this world. Jews are so successfull people thank to their unique education from generation to the next and not because god help them.
Shalshelan 9 months ago
@Shalshelan +1 took the words from me
AllHailThaKing 9 months ago
About antisemitism - whenever is person is that stupid it's just so sad, some people should just get a fucking life just to prevent the pain from others.
rlevanony 9 months ago
2 awesome musicians !!!
... GODLIKE
pupskaka 9 months ago
i've seen them in munich yesterday. the drummer looks like a fish making bubbles when playing - but he's playing awesome :D
chuckl3s 9 months ago
Mate, there is no real distinction of what is required and what is not, it has no place in such things like music.....just accept the way he decides to show himself, and enjoy the music! :-)
TraySoundAlchemist 10 months ago 2
the guy has glitters on his eyelashes :/
NomanBassDemon 10 months ago
@NomanBassDemon So what? Does it compromise his ability to make us feel great emotions?
TraySoundAlchemist 10 months ago
@TraySoundAlchemist it doesn't. he's very talented, hence IMO using cosmetics is not required. it just looks weird
NomanBassDemon 10 months ago
@NomanBassDemon And KISS wore makeup and looked like mimes? Your point?
BeefcakeMoney 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and why aren't these guys famous?
thefoosa72 10 months ago
Seems to me that Steven is very Spiritual, Religion is man's creation. Believing In God and/or being a follower of Christ does not make you religous, it is a spiritual connection with your Creator. Just my opinion!
goofygirly2010 10 months ago
Just enjoy the music and STFU dammit!
TheCoreQueen 10 months ago
Comment removed
AllHailThaKing 11 months ago
i'm Palestinian but why the fuck should i care what shit they believe in!? good music has no religion, its a religion on its own besides have you ever heard em insult other people or beliefs? if you hate this band just vote down and fuck off no1 cares what your immature incomplete mind thinks
samfraihat1 11 months ago 9
hard to believe that some dumbass was hating on aviv... for being jewish nonetheless... wtf. maybe one day the world will be free from mindless assholes.
paralyzing89 1 year ago 3
its in your head ZOMBIE ZOMBIE ZOMBAYAYAYY!!!! haha
great song though
bobpower 1 year ago
Love x1000000000000000000000000000000000000000
laetitiaandmike 1 year ago
I'm so sorry for those people who do not know peace, love, music.........for those who care about race,nationality,religious and all these fucking things which exist only for these idiots.........we are all human.....and we are all the same because we all have hearts emotions and we all can enjoy life......this is a great music and the only thing is to enjoy it..............
TheArashakbari 1 year ago
i love this song :) but why does arviv paint his eyes thats a little gay
miniqwang 1 year ago
@miniqwang He is actually a gay,he is with Steven lol
MissMetalchick 10 months ago
i love this band but whats up with the sheep blehs!
killercreek450 1 year ago 5
@killercreek450 well...aviv is good but he is like : While I'm melting in the (Raii-i-i--i-i-i-i-i-n) see? O_o
But he is still good xD
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
Aviv sings of the unjustice in his country Israel among other things. Blackfield - one of my favorite bands.
Anguis79 1 year ago
The more I listen to Steve Wilson and see what he does with other artists, the more he reminds me of Todd Rundgren back in the day when Todd played all sorts of styles and produced albums for many artists. I also think Aviv's voice contrasts very nicely with Steve's. It adds a really nice touch.
TheBlackycat 1 year ago 2
I had the luck to listen to Aviv Geffen live a couple of days ago :)his voice is really amazing..and it fits the songs he sings.He's a unique artist .
MARINAnaf93 1 year ago
Blackfield would be nowhere without Steven Wilson.
thefoosa72 1 year ago 5
@thefoosa72 That's not true. Aviv is an Israeli, MEGASTAR.
edthehead83 1 year ago
BLACKFIELD rules !!!
andyczapl 1 year ago
so pop-like. I prefer the darker side of Steven Wilson in PT
gsrgod 1 year ago
BlackField is perfect.....
ScorpionFl0wer 1 year ago 2
wow in two years this has only gotten 20 thousand views? what a shame.
crazycuddlyjesus 2 years ago 13
Really, what a shame. But let's face it: Blackfield is for people with good taste of music. So, unfortunately... it's not for everyone in the world...
jairomaster 1 year ago 3
@jairomaster lol! :P
BrotherGilburt 1 year ago
lol goat. I love this song though
metalkuronodud 2 years ago
love this fuckin song. their first album was spectacular.
rthavi2 2 years ago 3
BABICZ FOR THE WIN
walkerunner 2 years ago 6
Those guitars sound superb :P
I don't have one, but I've seen videos of J. Wesley performing live with those guitars (There's a live performance of Lazarus, i think).
BTW, Geffen and Wilson are awesome.
AkilesJose 2 years ago
sounds like the dude from placebo lol
bobtherelevator 2 years ago
Blackfield is a collaboratory musical group between Porcupine Tree founder and lead singer Steven Wilson and rock singer Aviv Geffen
Mepamper 2 years ago
who knows what he has taken...his voice is shaking!
Vasouliza 2 years ago
That's his style.
djbethell 2 years ago
@Vasouliza His voice is ALWAYS this way.
In an early interview (pre Blackfield) he said something like "I sing like shit - but I sing my own songs better than anyone else"
reviewsnest 1 year ago 7
i think avivs voice is good for the song.
also, if steven sang the begginning itd remind me ofthe third part of anesthetize
kornkrop1 2 years ago
Jewish or not, Steven Wilson has a better voice and i wish he sang more of this song
brh231 2 years ago 2
@brh231 Avivs voice fits this perfect for what he's singing. Stevens backingvocals makes it a perfect blend.
NostalgicProcrast 1 year ago 2
omg fuck off you antisemitic pieces of shit, who cares about their race or creed or sexual orientation, great music knows no race or religion, pull the dick out of your ass and listen to the music.
SacredSerenity 2 years ago 91
"... great music knows no race or religion, pull the dick out of your ass and listen to the music. ..."
RESPECT TO YOU !!!!
harmony0404 2 years ago 3
I agree with you, however do you not think the "pull the dick out of your ass" part made you sound a bit hypocritical, since you claimed that nobody cares about sexual orientation?
JezenThomas 2 years ago
It had nothing to do with sexual orientation, but more to do about them being so reluctant to like the music just because of Aviv's ethnicity/religion. It was not intended to gay bash, it's more synonymous with "stop bitching."
SacredSerenity 2 years ago
@SacredSerenity well put!
PuReNiRvANA1 1 year ago
@SacredSerenity
Ok, I just looked at all the coments. Where are the anitsemitic ones??
Anguis79 1 year ago
Stupid people... You care if one is Jew or not... Just listen to the music... Idiots
rathymus 2 years ago 119
@rathymus Exactly!!!~ but just a question is wilson jewish too?
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
@dlkrdlkr Wilson is an atheist.
edthehead83 1 year ago
@edthehead83 WTF LOL...seriously dude...
how did u knw??
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
@dlkrdlkr There is an interview somewhere where he said that he read Dawkins' "God Delusion," and said that he agreed with pretty much everything he wrote.
edthehead83 1 year ago
@edthehead83 oh ok thx dude but i think it's not cool to be an athiest xD he looks jewish though xD
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
@dlkrdlkr Well then I guess that makes you intolerant. He looks like a person to me.
edthehead83 1 year ago
@edthehead83 umm jewish ppl aren't animals lol :D
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
@dlkrdlkr It seems to me that you think less of Wilson for not being religious ("it's not cool to be an atheist"). If that is how you feel, then you are intolerant. And also you may as well insult me because I too am an atheist. I never said anything negative about Jews. Jewish people are cool in my book. I even enjoy volunteering at my JCC.
edthehead83 1 year ago
@edthehead83 LMAO first of all idc cuz I AM NOT JEWISH!!!
plus what book i thought athiests dun believe in gods and stuff, i am not insulting anyone here dude :D
dlkrdlkr 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that dumb ass jew can't even pronounce the word 'with' and 'devil' ....what a joke , what a joke , you're right dumb heab
oxytrebor 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why and i am asking again , why , KEEP THAT JEW FAGGOT ??? he aint nothing but a no talent , Steven could do all the instruments plus vocals alone .....shit sucks
oxytrebor 2 years ago
just for the record, steven wilson is the only non israeli, non jewish in this band. check out their names at the end of the live dvd show in ny if you dont belive
asafshay1980 2 years ago
Blackfield is such a GREAT BAND and Steven is a God at creating music...there are few guys that can be so prolific at making these kind of songs, sad, but beautiful
Deadwing1107 3 years ago 3
Steven doesnt have anything to do with this song, it's Aviv's he wrote the entire thing, so before anyone disses Aviv on being a jew etc., I'm an Israeli and this is the kind of musical excellency that comes from our country
Zusik12900 2 years ago
אביב גפן וסטיבן וילסון הענקים!
השיר הזה עושה לי כל כך צמרמורת שזה מדהים, אין יותר מרגש מהשיר הזה, ועם כל ההרמוניה בפזמון בכלל מתחילים לבכות!
jonaj222 3 years ago 4
I saw them yesterday night in a small club in Munich and i gotta say it was awesome. It's a shame that Aviv is not that well know here. Both Steven and Aviv are fullblooded musicians, it can't get any better. I loved the atmosphere and the whole band was fantastic, i think i need to buy the DVD.
nanmilla 3 years ago
ok i really like blackfield....i love steven wilson and pt. But avivs voice live really gets to me. I hate how it cracks up at the end of every line.....ive tried so hard to like it (his live voice) but i just cant. Am i the only one or are other people bothered by it? SW on the other hand sings so awesome live.
qwertyass215 3 years ago 4
I completely agree
Slunk32 3 years ago
same here
Sabotaje 2 years ago
Absolutely right!!! I agreee....
nmartialis 2 years ago
Im a huge pt fan and the first time I heard Blackfield, i was not too impressed, but it really grows on you. incredible music..
HDL2112 3 years ago
This Is 1 Of My Favourite Blackfield Songs!
I Do Prefer Blackfield II Album Though Hehe
<3 xxx
EvilSammie 3 years ago
I like the Broken voice of avive in this number, buts its just a fact, Steven Wilson owns him hard! and Porcupine rocks ;)
JelteRocks 3 years ago 5
It's actually kind of grown on me a bit. I mean, he's got nothing on Steven, but he's ok.
angryparrot 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I really hate that paki's voice...don't know his name but fuck.
Drumtome 3 years ago
His name's Aviv something or other I think.
jmrocker 3 years ago
Aviv Geffen
otacon12 3 years ago
paki? fuck you he's Israeli
Zusik12900 2 years ago
Well, aviv didn't f*ck the vocals up for once :P
But too bad steven did f*ck up the climax with such an appropriate guitar sound in the ending solo.
Great vid thoug :D
yumeN0dengon 3 years ago
what are you talking about? Steve Wilson did not fuck up once. You are CRAZY!! Ha.
munday20 3 years ago
How about you read what I actually typed ?
I'm talking about the guitare sound, not the performance (which is great). He didn't mess up the song, I'm just saying it would've been much better with the sole overdrive solo.
But then again that's just my opinion.
yumeN0dengon 3 years ago