Added: 5 years ago
From: MachineGunSmith
Views: 186,783
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (836)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • FUCKING AWESOME!!!!!!!!

  • HITS HARDER THAN CHRIS BROWN

  • fuckin' amazing man ..

  • Impressive.

  • SWEET MOSES THIS ROCKS!

  • lmao, I found this video after I commented on Aenima asking you to play this song.

    Good job.

  • you r just gr8!

  • this is awesome!

  • =O  wow.

  • dude, wat r u using for ur lighting, i need 1 of those

  • I used to play this song pretty similarly to the way you do. Now, though, I'm fairly sure the into section is done with the right hand outlining the hits on various toms and the left filling in eighth-note-ghost-notes between each hit (with a fill down the toms at the end of each phrase). It sounds more correct to me when I play it that way, anyway. Rest of the song sounds spot on, though.

  • Hey man that's awesome keep up the good work.

  • i gave it 5/5 cause even though it might not have been 100% right, it still sounded badass and at the end of the day isnt that what really matters?

  • hey were in iraq or something?

  • I think the guy did a good job

    soo...stop pointing out peoples mistakes

  • So, can you play this "correctly"?

  • I agree

  • dude. It takes a drummer to be able to come up with his own stuff! If everyone copied everyone else there would be no variety in song. Let Danny carey get it right. Let this guy do his own interperatation

  • he says in his profile that he doesnt play songs just like they are he makes his own thing to them.

  • don't think he was trying to play it exactly the same to begin with.

  • I know, didn't feel like typing at the time. Just listen to the song, its pretty easy to figure out the actual pattern.

  • I need a drummer...

  • what the fuck are you bitching about? this dude was great and youre critizing him but you love that other little faggot? youre a moron machinegunsmith whoops that others guys ass

  • Good job man. Well done

  • your high hat completely destroys the feel in the verse.

  • i disagree completely :/

  • so do i. that is incredable

  • The high hat is the best part dude

  • for this song do you switch your snare to a tom?

  • greeeeeeeeeat..

  • i like the high hat better in your version man great job

  • Bad ass, man.

  • My drums teachers teacher taught Danny Carey, and my teacher said that he met Danny Carey. Awesome Cover MGS!!!

  • i like the speed of the verse played on the highhat, im not a drummer im a bassist but i can honestly say that this impressed me. very hard song. i would know i heard it live =]

  • what frogprince said.

  • that... was a fucking masterpiece man. you rock!

  • you're fucking great man

    that songs amazingly tough!

    keep it going

  • wow!!!! im blown away!!!

    u fukn rock mann!!!

  • Very very cool, awesome job, are you in a band??

  • i really want to see some more videos from u, seriously u rock (cross fingers)

  • is this what you wanted!?! is this what you had in mind!>?! cuz this is what ur gettin!!

  • I can't fuckin believe some of these asshole comments criticizing this guys style, finesse and the asshole who said "not how Danny plays it but it alright i guess".

    Being able to play this at all is fuckin ridiculous and amazing and ragin on this guy for not having the same style instead of complementing him is messed up.

    Fuckin amazing work brazo man.

  • this is the best drum cover i have ever seen

  • you are truly machinegun

  • not how Danny plays it but it alright i guess

  • That's the idea .. what for do we want a clon of Danny?. Nice job MG .. keep 'em coming

  • This song is one of the greatest drumming performances I have EVER heard, by anyone.

  • hahah hes possessed! good work

  • Although he can keep up with the song, he doesn't have the style or finesse of Danny. This guy looks like he playing in a death metal band. Danny never looks (or sounds) like this. And that's what makes Dan amazing.

  • im watching this high and my god its great.

    nice job

  • thts kool man

    insane

  • good lord incredible!

  • Hey MachineGun ! Excellent interpretation of an excellent Tool song ! You are a pleasure to hear and watch playing ! I watch this video time to time since several months and I still love it ! Good luck with your drumming business !

  • wow...amazing job dude!

  • this is awesome and does sound good but i mean common people, hes just copying a danny carey riff, im not saying i could play it or anything, im just saying some of you say this guy has a better version and shit. who cares, he didnt right this amazing song on drums....who else but danny carey could right drum riffs this good. no one, that is why danny carey is the best drummer, hands down.

  • i have to agree danny carey is the MAN!!

  • No mames, estas bien cabron!!!! great stuff dude.

  • i cant help but feeling if i was at a Tool gig and Danny was injured somehow and you filled in , i would in no way be dissapointed. Your technique , energy and sound is fucken surgical dude. Nice one brother.

  • MachineGunSmith = GodLike

  • YOU ARE GOD LIKE AT THE DRUMS!!!!!

  • to me you version is more agressive than the original. there is an anger in your version but it can be described more as a slap in the face than a ritious anger towards something thats wrong.

  • sounds really different!

  • Ur my idol man

  • FILTHY!!!!!!! WOW FROM A HUGE TOOL FAN

  • hey machine could u play people = shit by slipknot please that would be sweet

  • Nice td20!!

  • The last minute is the best

  • close but definetly not the same feel

  • MachineGunSmith = GodLike

  • definatly sick man

  • dude! you are sick!

    really good!

  • Nice, I like your version of the song. It's too bad you don't have two pairs of high-hats to play that part when Maynard is singing "I hope you're choking." That part sounds great in stereo (and I would imagine it sounds great live too).

  • its not the exact beat but honestly id like to meet the person who can play danny carey down to the exact note... its sick none the less

    what mic system do you use? the sound qualitys great

  • ''I know my drum-pattern is NOT the same as Danny Carey. This is just my own reflection the song''. And i bet he could play it as it rlly is. I think this version is kinda better then Danny's..MGS<3

  • fucking sick :o

  • if only the world had more drummers like you

  • owned, you're amazing man, don't listen to him.

  • I think I like your version even better than DC's! awsome job man can't wait to get my drum set!

  • bravo MAJSTOREEEEE!!!!!!!!

  • Wow! impresive, awesome cover!

  • machinegunsmith,i have been a tool fan for a little shy of twelve years..and in all that time i have never and i repeat NEVER heard anyone cover a tool song as beautiully as you do...if i were i record rep i would make sure you make it big!!!...please dont ever stop what you do!

    with much,much respect Zack

  • FUCK YOU ARE GOOD!

  • Keep rocking!

    This Tool song was very entertaining and dig your style. It's like a 'tribal' feel to it. Kicks ass!

  • man, love your site, could you do "mudvayne -fall into sleep" or "sepultura territory". cos i learn from your vids

  • awesome broski

  • Dude, you rock!

  • I don't even like Tool or this type of music but this guy is very talented. There is no reason to hate on him just because you can't do what he does.

    Keep on rockin, man! Fuck the Haters

  • You're ok. I know it's your "interpretation" but it's a lot more complicated then you have depicted it to be. Your version can be compared to a straight line of monotonous beats. Simplified and stripped it of all value.

  • Ok I never comment back to other drummers like this, but seriously after watching your "The Grudge" video...You must of been talking about your self with that comment...it describes you Perfectly.

  • omg smith u are so correct..this guy comes out and in his mind downgrades your drumming when infact..truthfuly honestly Nicotag looks like a robot..a sucky one at that...sorry Nicotag but u show no emotion..and plain and simple maginegunsmith would blow u out of the water

  • It's funny when I see other drummers like you or fat ass "matter311" leave shitty comments on YouTube about other drummers such as MGS. If your not DC himself, your opinion shows your insecurities when your own style can't back up your statements. At lease MGS has as an odd time signature & a "feel" of the song. You should really get own geometrical references right before trying to criticize others, when you should be criticizing yourself.

  • how is nicotag goin 2 talk when his is fuckin garbage compared 2 MGS machinegunsmith is alot more talented and skilled than nicotag

  • fuckin kick ass!

  • wow! u rock !

  • Your snare sounds really mid range.. it needs tightened.. but yeah.. great job man.. i would love to play with u man.

  • yea haill friend \m/

  • yea fuck hahahahahahahha great!!!!haill haill haill!!!!!

  • your the shit. I wish i could drum like you. In my band our drummer is good. You should teach him some stuff. Your awesome. Dude.........

  • holy shit,i favorited this within like 15 seconds of watching it.you are a god on the drums.keep rocking dude you are fucking amazing

  • wow! nice man! gj. however if you listen to the song more carefully , you will see that it is far more complicated. anyway, i hope you soon record a new one, a right one!

  • take what you wanyted and GOOOWAH!!

    Fucking awesome man

  • no doubt the best drummer on YouTube.

  • Dude.. Holy Shit. That's totally badass. Keep up the good work!

  • Thats Awesome

    I love your style

    btw

    TOOL RULES!!!

  • awesome

  • dddaaaaaaaammmmmmnnnnnnn......­.

  • your videos are great

    great TooL covers..... if you take suggestions you should try Right in Two by TooL

    i just wondered if you get dizzy

  • dude i swear. you are one of kind. u should do some of your songs or somtin.

  • dude...1

  • hey man the mans of disturbed watch your video man you really awesome !!!!

  • awesome job. you kick ass. more tool songs would be great

  • could you do scream aim fire for bullet for my valentine i think that would be a good song for you. you would prolly nail it.

  • one of my favorite drummers of all time

  • Great stuff. I really enjoy your playing. Thanks for all the posts. By the way, have you taken a look at Martin Periard? He's also a drummer who posts here in Youtube. Between the two of you guys, I'm a happy man. Take care.

  • Keep playing more Tool songs! Great work.

  • Your version is interesting, sort of sounds like war drums. This video is pretty sick, amazing work.

  • nonononon, no es así

  • This would look way sicker if you had long hair, like Wayne from Wayne's World. Picturing that makes it pretty awesome, but this is still pretty sick.

  • Nice. That's pretty funny.

  • you are one of best drummers I have ever heard. You should be famous. I not bad myself, but you could blow me out of the water. You style is unique just like mine. I will post some drumming of mine soon and you can comment. Later

  • anyone who can play TOOL is a fuckin God!

  • you're so fucking amazing MAN!!!! :D 10+

  • fukcing hell mate you can play the drums, quality

  • you rock!!!

  • I can't believe how amazing that was! I always fear that someone might try to cover this song on the drums. My fear is that they will screw it up. You didn't do the intro exactly like DC but you made it your own. That was truly awesome.

  • i dont care if that was off a bit , that fucking kick ass. good job!!!!!!!!!

  • doubles kick are kick ass.

  • yeah! he can be a good drummer and can play fast. but he is playing wrong. the intro is smilar but completely wrong and after adam jones starts to play he misses the ritm and goes fast!.

  • "I know my drum-pattern is NOT the same as Danny Carey. This is just my own reflection the song."

    you're a dumbass.

  • The excuse in the video description would be valid if the beat he was playing wasn't so easy to play.  The beat is dumbed down. It's definitely interesting, but if I had to guess, this guy's "reflection" comes more from an inability to play Danny's stuff than creative license. Flame away, but that's where I stand.

  • Excuse? It's the fucking truth! There's only one DC & that's the way it will always be.

  • Exactly.

  • I actually enjoy to hear other musicians such as MGS abilities to create something unique & originate work of art to an invention of music. If you want to hear an exact copy, listen to the original song. Most people feel the same & if not, you don't have an open mind about music.

  • My mind is very open to music, but I'm a drummer, and this is not right. He's not on time in the bridge, the intro is all eighth notes on the bass drum with no dynamic range or accent where it's supposed to be. I'm all about interpreting songs in new and original ways, hell, I'm even for BSing a song if it sounds good, but this doesn't.

  • Ooooooh I get it now....Dude your just a want-a be drummer. You clearly can't back up your comments with playing like that! Come on!!! Your the one with no timing dynamics or originality. You have NO clue what your talking about & you have alot to learn before posting bullshit like this. Doesn't sound good???? Take a look at MGS views, over 6,000 subscribers, famous bands have recognized him and over 1,000 people FAVORITED this video alone!

  • FUCK YEAH

  • Bro thats fucking awesome, thats the best ive ever seen the intro done. (next to danny of course)

  • dude you rule =) and dam you do the tripelits fast lol

  • awesome man .. rock on

  • Holy shit .... you're amazing at this and such an awesome song too .... kickass, well done.

  • dude, you rock so hard. that is just awesome drum skillz.

  • i love to watch this, thanks

  • i can play this song on drums perfectly....but i havent figured out how to upload videos yet...

  • Is easy.

    Next to the search line to the right!

    UPLOAD!

    I think you not it perfect...

    Something I think.

  • wtf... dude you kick ass!!!

  • dude that was sick

  • awesome bro. Fucking awesome...

    Hey guys, no one is like another... No one is like Danny....

  • i like danny careys version better but i like what you did here great job

  • very nice

    not exact to the song but still sweet.

    tools drummer is fuckin amazing so i doubt anybody on youtube can cover his stuff perfectly.

    that other video in ur "about this video" is good... too bad he didnt do the whole song.

    neways ive watched alot ur videos dude

    u kick some ass

  • He states that he knows the song is not exact--only is own interpretation. There are people on Youtube who can cover Carey's stuff perfectly, or at least as close as is decipherable.

  • you are INSANE man..u fucking rock

  • This is one of the best drum songs ever written. That was awesome. Wow...

  • The drum beats are so different, there almost, hard to judge when he's going to do a beat, each ones different, I like it

  • Dude you are one of the best drummers i have ever seen i never post comments but dam dude you rocked it

  • omfg this is inhuman!

  • FUCKKK hes good!

  • wouw... You kick ass!!! =D

  • you are my hero...

  • im a big tool fan.. love the drummin dude

  • I like how you changed the high-hit part from the original. I personally think it fits the song better.

  • holy fuck well done mate, some good shit there. i seen a few of ur other percussions but that 1 really showed ur talent. keep it up, love to see you on stage..

  • FFUCKING..HELL

  • hey man, i think everyone here would love to hear Forty Six & Two, from Tool. Especially the drum solo. being a drummer, it would be really tight to hear you do a great cover on the song.

  • Wow awesome, i want to see some devil driver =]

  • what is ur band's name bc im buying every album, oh and btw, if u went solo drumer and just recorded all these youtube videos i would still buy them

  • I don't think I've ever left a comment on YouTube before... either way, I can't resist leaving a comment on this... damn impressive. That is fuckin' tight.

  • Danny should be proud of your work man. Tool forever number one!

  • I watchedy our other videos and was like 'ok, cool' but for this you deserve respect to the max! You should play more Tool man, it's good for you and good for us to watch. Lateralus or Rosetta Stoned for example =D

    Cheers you're good =)

  • i have to say. you make the intro drum pattern a lot harder that it needs to be! good job

  • Effin Heavy!!

  • idilooooooo

  • Wow, I can not remember the last time that I was that impressed. That was unbelievable! I prefer your version as well. Great frigin' job!

  • dude i prefer your version of the song than the original!

    nice work!!

  • hey, it's wicked awesome but.. c'mon...better than TOOL?! impossible.

  • agreed.

  • nice freakin' work, sounds damn good.