I don't understand why people don't like the wall. It was such a good album imo. I know that David Gilmour didn't like it, same with the other members. But, i don't know, i just thought it had a good meaning to it. And just in case someone wants to tell me that i have no idea what I'm talking about, I'm pretty sure i do lol I'm not stupid.
P.S. fatchants, you should be a little nicer to robotorb. If someone doesn't share the same opinion with you, that doesn't make their's stupid. Grow up.
It is bizarre but Music From the Body id actually a very interesting album, mixing Roger Waters songs with eccentric string quartet pieces. Themes of future Floyd songs are sprinkled within. The songs are like apocalyptic lullabies.
This is rather stupid, to show the graphics from The Wall, which was the disco album produced by "the surrogate band", and not a heart-felt expression of Pink Floyd..
over this music, which was deeply soulful and from an entirely, starkly contrasting era
at least be appropriate, this would be better with just the still of the album cover,
not the art of coke-fried, post-psychedelic Pink Floyd, which they admit
@fatchants = rather stupid? are you very well familiar with the lyrical, conceptual and thematic work of Roger Waters, within Pink Floyd or as a solo artist? if so, I think you'd realize that this track was in fact the first that would plant the seed, touching on themes that would later to explode in full on Floyd's 1979 "the Wall" release.
("Free Four" is another track track, following this one, that touches on the subject of his father's death and the matter of time... then we get "Dark Side")
@robotorb the theme has nothing to do with aesthetics, which is wht my comment was addressing only, very obviously, in plain English man. Your reply is totally irrelevant.
People who are familiar with the deeply beautiful things Pink Floyd did and ..the Things that inspired them.. find the coke-era *surrogate-band* the cold tasteless crap around it..extremely offensive
anything to do with The Wall is ..not just sacrilege to this piece of music but it's opposite in theme..you're wrong man..
lol dude you're kind of silly to ask me such things. I know of countless references to Milton's _Paradise Lost_, which became the backbone for basically everything they did until they threw in the towel with _The Wall_ and made it a scathing joke on unwitting fans.. what am I not getting? lol we've been making "art about loved ones dying" since we've been in caves, did you know _that_? and we should..throw in "death-art" from a bad album that's nothing to do with this song's theme or era..why?
@robotorb if you're an intelligent person, try to wrap your mind around this: The Wall was an album about *this very thing* being done to Pink Floyd. That's all th album is about. the title "Live At Pompeii" was even about this dynamic, their being misunderstood..they were serious acidheads not druggies..the death of the 60s, or Pompeii.. was "the theme" also, when you look deeper than an obsession predictable for everyday people..maybe not Mr. Waters. As Syd would say, Have You Got it yet?
you have no idea what you're talking about man, it's so sad. this is press fodder, not deep heavy shit like what Pink Floyd were into. "ooh my dad died and I'm angry about war now", Billy Joel is capable of writing a song about that. so is my little sister. you have to at least explore strong psychedelic compounds to understand the lyrical references. it's not grade school social studies man.. you believe what you read that they told the magazines? lol are you a "sheep"? Use your brain :)
@MrTaximusic Floyd were smarter than most people who listen to them, they read a lot of *books* as well as looked at the Pictures
'The Wall' was a seething joke to make fools of people who would buy that album, it was a self-fulfilling "we're selling out" declaration. It was a PLAY, and unlike everything before it (except perhaps WYWH, but that's a whole other Long Serious Discussion), 'The Wall' wasn't something that came from the heart, at all, it was sarcastically _typical rock drama_.
@fatchants yes i agree the wall was not there best but look inside the book of roger he did write some good stuff what about the pros and cons mt do you like that
I don't understand why people don't like the wall. It was such a good album imo. I know that David Gilmour didn't like it, same with the other members. But, i don't know, i just thought it had a good meaning to it. And just in case someone wants to tell me that i have no idea what I'm talking about, I'm pretty sure i do lol I'm not stupid.
P.S. fatchants, you should be a little nicer to robotorb. If someone doesn't share the same opinion with you, that doesn't make their's stupid. Grow up.
bayray222 2 months ago
Comment removed
bayray222 2 months ago
It is bizarre but Music From the Body id actually a very interesting album, mixing Roger Waters songs with eccentric string quartet pieces. Themes of future Floyd songs are sprinkled within. The songs are like apocalyptic lullabies.
madahad9 3 months ago
Everybody shut the fuck up and enjoy the song.
Toro6559 6 months ago 2
@Toro6559 lol yeah close your eyes first. like with everything Floyd. :)
fatchants 5 months ago
never heard this before, hard to imagine it's 40 years old. It's ageless
HappyAitch 7 months ago
why the wall ? great songl
munghi 7 months ago
This is rather stupid, to show the graphics from The Wall, which was the disco album produced by "the surrogate band", and not a heart-felt expression of Pink Floyd..
over this music, which was deeply soulful and from an entirely, starkly contrasting era
at least be appropriate, this would be better with just the still of the album cover,
not the art of coke-fried, post-psychedelic Pink Floyd, which they admit
is such and made a huge joke of..
..go ask The Magic Eye
fatchants 11 months ago
@fatchants = rather stupid? are you very well familiar with the lyrical, conceptual and thematic work of Roger Waters, within Pink Floyd or as a solo artist? if so, I think you'd realize that this track was in fact the first that would plant the seed, touching on themes that would later to explode in full on Floyd's 1979 "the Wall" release.
("Free Four" is another track track, following this one, that touches on the subject of his father's death and the matter of time... then we get "Dark Side")
robotorb 6 months ago
Comment removed
fatchants 6 months ago
@robotorb the theme has nothing to do with aesthetics, which is wht my comment was addressing only, very obviously, in plain English man. Your reply is totally irrelevant.
People who are familiar with the deeply beautiful things Pink Floyd did and ..the Things that inspired them.. find the coke-era *surrogate-band* the cold tasteless crap around it..extremely offensive
anything to do with The Wall is ..not just sacrilege to this piece of music but it's opposite in theme..you're wrong man..
fatchants 6 months ago
lol dude you're kind of silly to ask me such things. I know of countless references to Milton's _Paradise Lost_, which became the backbone for basically everything they did until they threw in the towel with _The Wall_ and made it a scathing joke on unwitting fans.. what am I not getting? lol we've been making "art about loved ones dying" since we've been in caves, did you know _that_? and we should..throw in "death-art" from a bad album that's nothing to do with this song's theme or era..why?
fatchants 6 months ago
@robotorb if you're an intelligent person, try to wrap your mind around this: The Wall was an album about *this very thing* being done to Pink Floyd. That's all th album is about. the title "Live At Pompeii" was even about this dynamic, their being misunderstood..they were serious acidheads not druggies..the death of the 60s, or Pompeii.. was "the theme" also, when you look deeper than an obsession predictable for everyday people..maybe not Mr. Waters. As Syd would say, Have You Got it yet?
fatchants 6 months ago
you have no idea what you're talking about man, it's so sad. this is press fodder, not deep heavy shit like what Pink Floyd were into. "ooh my dad died and I'm angry about war now", Billy Joel is capable of writing a song about that. so is my little sister. you have to at least explore strong psychedelic compounds to understand the lyrical references. it's not grade school social studies man.. you believe what you read that they told the magazines? lol are you a "sheep"? Use your brain :)
fatchants 6 months ago
@fatchants = at this point, I have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. good luck!
robotorb 6 months ago
@fatchants have a moment of clarity mt and a large cigar
MrTaximusic 5 months ago
@MrTaximusic Floyd were smarter than most people who listen to them, they read a lot of *books* as well as looked at the Pictures
'The Wall' was a seething joke to make fools of people who would buy that album, it was a self-fulfilling "we're selling out" declaration. It was a PLAY, and unlike everything before it (except perhaps WYWH, but that's a whole other Long Serious Discussion), 'The Wall' wasn't something that came from the heart, at all, it was sarcastically _typical rock drama_.
fatchants 5 months ago
@fatchants yes i agree the wall was not there best but look inside the book of roger he did write some good stuff what about the pros and cons mt do you like that
MrTaximusic 5 months ago
Comment removed
fatchants 11 months ago
I have the recording.
eldorado61guy 1 year ago
me encanta el estilo de Waters, bonita cancion no la habia escuchado antes.
alcoholangelo 1 year ago
Wonderful, beautiful song. I close my eyes and I'm a little boy on a beach again.
:)
hopebgood 1 year ago
That classical-style guitar and Roger's voice was the dollop of cream over those lyrics. Beauty simplistically. 5*****
flowerlove79 2 years ago 3
Fantastic.......
Holidays and happy days at home
MrRogerwaters 2 years ago 8
@MrRogerwaters fucking hey! That's the line that always sticks out for me! Good times eh?! Call me a twat, but I'm happy for us.....
hopebgood 1 year ago
AWESOME!
igguasu 2 years ago 2
Nice work my friend Roger the greatest good work
deansusky 2 years ago
A lost gem from "Music From The Body"
paulbur42 3 years ago 10