Dude your a fucking idiot, obviously it isn't going to sound exactly the same, it's a fucking cover for one, and it isn't all wrong, you obviously have no concept of how hard portnoy's stuff is to play, or else you wouldn't of made such a stupid comment.
give this guy a break! It's a no brainer to just memorize every single tom and cymbal hit that MP makes and recreate it perfectly. Challenging, yes, but a no brainer.
It takes a whole new level to take a song like this and feel so comfortable with it that you are capable of making it your own by incorporationg your own style into it and playing smoothly regardless. And that's exactly what this guy does. Great job!
Hey Bob I dont care what anyone says about this video. you do alot better than anyone else ive seen try this. Thats cause no one else has ever tryed it that I can find!!! hahaha See ya soon bob. Love jammin with ya!
you seem to be a great drummer but idk that prog metal is for you.. you dont seem to have the chops for the progressive fills and you didnt recreate mp's parts very well
OMG if you want to get MP recreated plaing GO HEAR MP this is not MP this is COOOVER and that is what exacly means cover, you know to criticize, but do you know to play it so comfortable ?
I like your style and ur a good drummer but i really liked the fill wen it dropped down to the bass and drums for the 2nd time in the real song the best
too funny. I don't totally disagree, and if I was capable you know I would, but I'm not. Just an older guy having some fun. I thought only Rush fans were so persnickity about their "drum parts". Chill out junior know-it-all.....
Yeah I guess, I mean the whole thing is to be different from everyone else. Individuality, you know? Because when I play drums, I want people to be able to tell if it's me or Mike Portnoy or Neil Peart and so on so forth...
Well you shouldn't play it exactly how it is. Give it your own taste and emotion. Of course play the opening beats perfectly, but when you see a good opening, improvise!
wow, you're a lot better than me, i'm 17 but dude, gotta put the snare in on that fill at 2:40, contrating toms and snare sounds real nice right there. amazing though
I saw Portnoy doing the studio version of this song. You play it a different way, considering your set is... different. Actually, i prefer yours; for this song at least. Your drums are perfectly set, you do less useless moves like Portnoy does, you rock.
good shit, bro!
xpsycho4rentx 2 years ago
I dont get why people think you suck on here! they are just jelous that they cant do it any better than you can. They must be so jelous LMAO!!!!
LPFREAKYFREAK 2 years ago
ALLL WRONG
have another listen to the song you fuck
rickygibson3 2 years ago
Dude your a fucking idiot, obviously it isn't going to sound exactly the same, it's a fucking cover for one, and it isn't all wrong, you obviously have no concept of how hard portnoy's stuff is to play, or else you wouldn't of made such a stupid comment.
DistortionXtreme 2 years ago
mike portnoys material is meant to be played with modern grip on the drum sticks, not traditional...
yeah, you could probably pull it off if you really put in the effort, its just all in position to play the way he plays man.
jtonessimo 2 years ago
holy shit this guys the truth
KYamada416 3 years ago
give this guy a break! It's a no brainer to just memorize every single tom and cymbal hit that MP makes and recreate it perfectly. Challenging, yes, but a no brainer.
It takes a whole new level to take a song like this and feel so comfortable with it that you are capable of making it your own by incorporationg your own style into it and playing smoothly regardless. And that's exactly what this guy does. Great job!
RICbass78 3 years ago 2
Hey Bob I dont care what anyone says about this video. you do alot better than anyone else ive seen try this. Thats cause no one else has ever tryed it that I can find!!! hahaha See ya soon bob. Love jammin with ya!
LPFREAKYFREAK 3 years ago
eres bueno con las manos pero faltan tambien los pies mas practica con los pies doble bombo
55662353 3 years ago
you played another song ' didn't likeit!!
santosadriano 3 years ago
You have to listen more to the song..
drummerhenrik 3 years ago
pluss i could hear MPs drums more than yours which covered your mistakes
FOMFAH2 3 years ago
So, we are waiting for your video.. if you can do better.
ferlotte 3 years ago 3
you seem to be a great drummer but idk that prog metal is for you.. you dont seem to have the chops for the progressive fills and you didnt recreate mp's parts very well
FOMFAH2 3 years ago
OMG if you want to get MP recreated plaing GO HEAR MP this is not MP this is COOOVER and that is what exacly means cover, you know to criticize, but do you know to play it so comfortable ?
klickBG 2 years ago
nice job man.you missed a lot of doble bass parts but i could not do it better,very nice.
dingui666666 3 years ago
This is what I call a professional cover;) Nice work
wertyguitar 3 years ago
Magyarok is szeretik:)
NatteGuilty 3 years ago
awsome!!!
gulas001paprika 3 years ago
Fuck....man....ma ke kazzo fai
Luiginoy 3 years ago
in effetti non sono gli stessi tempi dispari con la grancassa k porta il nostro Mike....boh. ci vuole cmq orekkio
UselessLars93 3 years ago
rofl.. I meant to reply to another comment.. I think you did a great job. Keep it up! :D
syxxness 3 years ago
Amazing mate :)
ComfortablyNumbed 3 years ago
sweeet...nice playing main
madchops82 3 years ago
shit youre fucking awesome!!!! and the sound is goooooood thx this helped me a lot to understand the song!!!
FADINGDEADSTAR 3 years ago
freaking awesome ! bien joué !
NAThan9871 3 years ago
I like your style and ur a good drummer but i really liked the fill wen it dropped down to the bass and drums for the 2nd time in the real song the best
lightningweasel 3 years ago
very good job yomell, those extra snare fills were excelent, keep on rocking
reyrod 3 years ago
too funny. I don't totally disagree, and if I was capable you know I would, but I'm not. Just an older guy having some fun. I thought only Rush fans were so persnickity about their "drum parts". Chill out junior know-it-all.....
yomell 3 years ago
Yeah I guess, I mean the whole thing is to be different from everyone else. Individuality, you know? Because when I play drums, I want people to be able to tell if it's me or Mike Portnoy or Neil Peart and so on so forth...
AlabamaManWhore 3 years ago
Well you shouldn't play it exactly how it is. Give it your own taste and emotion. Of course play the opening beats perfectly, but when you see a good opening, improvise!
AlabamaManWhore 3 years ago
Woah, I didn't old people listened to Dream Theater!
YOU RULE!
AlabamaManWhore 3 years ago
you are a wanker
you cannot play this song for your life
fullfadeway9 3 years ago
you changed the whole song of MP!!! that's sin!!! what is wrong with you man!?
pikachu14 4 years ago
nice play along to the song...
... cool drummer.
adrumlegend 4 years ago
wow, you're a lot better than me, i'm 17 but dude, gotta put the snare in on that fill at 2:40, contrating toms and snare sounds real nice right there. amazing though
marchtenors4life 4 years ago
you rock, no question about it
Wonbadude 4 years ago
damn thats cool man. its rare to find good drummers online lol keep it up
stich96 4 years ago
That's not true, there are plenty of good guys, even here on Youtube
onikinhas 4 years ago
first time ive seen DT played with traditional grip.
cool.
AndJustice4All68 4 years ago 2
You guys are all way too kind. I'm just trying to have a little fun... Thanks for the positive input (so far)!
yomell 4 years ago
WOOHOOO i would like to play the song with you man! :D
Turboviiper 4 years ago
I saw Portnoy doing the studio version of this song. You play it a different way, considering your set is... different. Actually, i prefer yours; for this song at least. Your drums are perfectly set, you do less useless moves like Portnoy does, you rock.
Great job.
400Aesa 4 years ago
hey mate, great exibition... I just wanna be like you :D.. bye
LeGaCyBriGhtDruMmer 4 years ago
you are one awesome middle aged white dude.. i wanna be just like the same middle aged white guy you are whenn i grow up
UTubeSucks26 4 years ago 3
lmao my thoughts exactly
hungryhungryhippo77 4 years ago
yes yore so good bravo man bravo!
kamurandeliormanli 4 years ago
RADICAL!!!!!!!
UTubeSucks26 4 years ago
U da man
fhdjskal 4 years ago
bravo!!
valerio88 4 years ago
although i prefer portnoys playing, good job! cool to think you don't stick to the original
philbeastall 4 years ago 2
Nice!! You changed some shit around but I liked it, especially around 2:00, very jazzy man, sick!!
yyzny21688 4 years ago
Very impressive dude, you nailed it.
mattroberts 4 years ago
that kicks ass
good job dude
utah7965 4 years ago