Selena Gomez & the Scene - Who Says Live on Good Morning America (6/17/2011)

[zakiitiz]

To everyone who says that she's bad singer:on the one hand you should know that the quality of the sound depends on many things,such as microphone,recording devices,weather,and even on your computer speakers.On the other hand-you shouldn't compare live versions of her songs to the ones you've heard in official CD's,because they use autotune while recording albums,and also singer can try again if she fails in some sound.When you're on stage you're not able to repeat it.

Selena-you're the best! <3

[tianasweettea]

No Selena...just no. God go whatch Miley sing Robot on GMA that's real live singing! This is crap and her backup singers are totally carrying the song!

[Wishingstar5857]

Selena Gomez's hair looks so pretty <3

[xLaxMasxLindax]

okey exelent¡¡¡¡

[xLaxMasxLindax]

aguente selena :-)

[AxSelenaG]

Excelent!!!! I love it! I love her!!! But the audio isn't good!!!! :(

I saw her in live, she wasn't doing playback and she was singing perfect <3

It's only about the audio of the video ;)

Argentina loves Selena <3

[ThePopcorn102]

What do you guys mean she cant sing LIVE!!!! SHE just cant sing at all its not like she just gets good when there recoding it they autotune it

[JustinBieberIlayda]

Oh my Bieber pls help her...

she can't sing live OMG +o(

[ladyatnite]

Selena need to know what song that fits on her tune or voice like naturally that song fits on her tune when she sing it live

[SkittQxc]

Demi Lovato is better.

[ThePopcorn102]

She is so off tune and her voice dont even get me started. im not trying to be mean but she dose not desserve everything she gets for a bunch of auto tune.She seems like a good person tho and nice and sweet so im really not trying to hate

[bitchrauhl]

how can you say that she is the 'BEST' at singing live? you haven't heard real rusic yet, honey. you're probably only 12 or 13. in my opinion. Celine is number one, anyday /watch?v=Ji-GONSfwnE

[Panthelia]

Omg this is awful. Anyone that says otherwise is either deaf or in denial.

[ThePopcorn102]

@amf7410 So we can't hate her voice just because she is sining a song about being herself

P.s you jsut want her to sound good that is why you think she sounds good

[selenajonaslovato94]

Gosh..wish I was there..I want meet her..She talent,beautiful,nice and cute..I love you Selena Gomez.You the best.

[SeL869]

She CAN sing, she's perfect!

[556Lukas]

Selena in brasil UHUUL

[MsLinnybear]

Love you like a love song is a bit harded than who says it's got more hard note's so that y she did better in this song so top hating she sings amazing!!!

[121writer]

Selena doesn't have a great voice......but she actually sounds best singing Who Says....and before any starts saying 'um r u any better' I'd say it depends on the song. She can sing....just not as great as others.

[Funshine100]

Why do people keep bashing on her?

I don't get it, SHE SOUNDS BEAUTIFUL

[MusicGurl38]

You people need to be nicer , no offence .......... I mean come on . I went to her concert in Sacramento JINGLE BALL , and she had a great voice ! She is really pretty,nice,sweet,good singer,and actress,and a sweetheart <3 She never said you guys cant sing , so why are you guys being mean and saying she cant sing ....... GO SELENATORS ! <3 : D

[JollyAlberty]

Woahhh!!! She is wayyyyyyy better in this song!!!! I just listened to her live when she sang Love You Like A love Song, and honostly she's amazing in this song! #SELENAROCKS(;

[YEEitsRosaisela]

Honestly.. she sounds good here! In the other video live 'Love You Like A Love Song' she sounds weak. She can sing, that's my opinion. If she couldn't sing, i don't think she'll have 20+ million fans.

[JollyAlberty]

@YEEitsRosaisela You took the words right outta my mouth.

[insanebitchful]

is she sick or something? she sounds TERRIBLE. well at least she's pretty

[TheNoralii]

I love selena gomez music from excellent artists from Venezuela loves it and I hope one day he meets............

[Cristina123868]

she cant sing, she is better as a actress, MILEY CYRUS AND DEMI LOVATO R REAL SINGERS

[BiebersLermaniac]

@Cristina123868 i'm not hating. But Miley Cyrus isn't that great live either.

[prinsarcessah1997]

maybe she was having a bad day...

[rous327]

Thumbs up for Selena's chorists.

[iluvbroadway15]

@rous327 they do everything and never get the attention deserved

[jaiydee]

Is she tone deaf? =P

[celi910]

bad singing day.....? 0.o

[727danie]

hay algo que rescato de selena gómez, es una de las pocas artistas nuevas que se sube al escenario y canta!!! FELICITACIONES Y DEDICADO A LOS QUE HACEN PLAYBACK!!!!

[MllesPuppemd]

PLEASE! She has two albums (2, right?) if she could really sing she would do it a lot better. SHE SUCKS at singing!

[EmilyElizabethY]

Even if she didn't do perfect vocally, she still has a great confidence on stage, and confidence is half the battle! :)

[gracielou1311]

2:10-2:13 there was tune off... listen carefully... and I THINK it's Selena.. :p No way it would be back up singers they were singing in another key, so Selena... ts ts ts... :p

[prettiestgirlinutube]

this is more talking than singing tbh.

[TessyClaireBear]

Well I guess her songs are aimed at 10 year olds who can't really tell the difference. At least this song's about nice enough stuff.

[bitashan90]

have you seen Demi Lovato singing live? SHE ROCKS. really

[Epicpineapple100]

meh..at least shes pretty... 0_o

[Lizzybown]

She seems like such a sweet and nice person, she is very cute, she have great songs, she's an great actress and she's a good role model. But singing live...?

[SelMelDemiX]

@Lizzybown But Singing live is amazing i love selena gomez

[selenajonaslovato94]

@Lizzybown I agree with you before you say but singing live..But for me she singing live is very good.

[Lizzybown]

@selenajonaslovato94 Okay :) Well I don't think she's terrible at singing live, I know she can be better than this. I like when she sings acoustic, but not on stage. But she's still awesome! ^^,

[selenajonaslovato94]

@Lizzybown I don't care what hater selenator say it..what I can say it..Selena is the best singing live..and I love what she doing for her fans...

Yea..She still awesome,beautiful and cute singer..

[sheislovinyou]

@carmelitagiselle eh.. we are not sayin we are professional singers.. it's just our opinion . i honestly think she can't sing.. but i like how she acts..

[Dystt]

Actually its the quality of the sound on this video thats making her sound bad.

[ReivRagi]

не знаю как вам, а по мне так очень даже ничего.

[conejito878]

ounou una  perra

[meiliarox]

I REALLY AM NOT A FAN, but singing live is really hard, and I've seen her sing live well so I feel bad for her. Her voice doesn't sound bad, it sounds really hoarse like shes been overworked

[avrilrock5]

im not a huge selena Gomez fan, but still i can say that she sings ok, maybe she isnt the best singer in the world but she isnt the worst singer either, she sings without playback and thats great, and still she doesnt sing totally out of tune! I doesnt have a problem listning to her live couse she sing

[luv2perform210]

Okay, everyone always says how she sucks live. At least she is singing live. I think she is doing great! All you people who are insulting her, do you have fans worldwide? do you have platinum albums, a hit tv show, and hit movies? No! So just leave her alone and let her live her life!

[MatildeTepest]

selena gomez es genial y WHO SAYS

[fernandohun]

@carmelitagiselle Yes but all those *rude* people are not trying to sing and make money off it . She is an actor why did she start singing?

[terri97able1]

she sounds good shut up who ever talks about her beachs

[amf7410]

I find it ironic that people are saying that she has a bad voice on a song that is all about being yourself... that includes whether you can sing or not lol.

BTW, she can sing :D

[Mardealou]

@amf7410 So what you're saying is, that it's okay to earn millions of dollars for singing, wether you can or not?

[abby12x]

@amf7410 Umm she can't sing. I could sing better than her. Yes, the song is about being yourself, but she still can't sing. She sucks.

[BiebersLermaniac]

@abby12x gtfo then.

[avialavigne123]

@amf7410 your right she is amezing!!!!!!

[margotpeeters]

@amf7410 People say that because it's true, and when you're a professional singer, you must be able to sing well... :p

[selenagomezrocks012]

if you think you can sing better then her then prove it and post a video.SHE CAN SING!

[selenagomezrocks012]

if you think you can sing better then her then prove it and post a video

[TheAyoubaster]

@carmelitagiselle Yes i love her but i don't think she can sing live cuz i can sing better than herr !! but still love her

[sweetchick411]

@carmelitagiselle its life, people judge, get over it

[PhReShx10]

Selenas high tempo pop voice is not the best. She should just stick to acoustic. She's so much better there.

[kikibubu1997]

I really love she but in live she's really bad sometimes ! It's not already but hear im sorry but its really BAD.

[tommiboy13]

She's getting better... she just prolly wasn't always a singer ;] but she'll get there eventually

[Ady964]

Selena can sing. Only her vocal cords collapsed.Soon it will be definitely in order.

[virgo1999181]

she's not that bad.....she just needs more practice.at least she's singing live

[virgo1999181]

okay...so most of us don't have a good voice but we really love to sing.just because we don't have a good voice that means we should not sing?

[NiLeyRaY92]

@virgo1999181 of course she can sing if she loves it, but she shouldn't do it in public because her voice is not ready yet to sing live... at least for now she should focus more on actic and keep on taking singing lessons and in the future she can come back as a singer...

[LouisaLovesKorea]

@NiLeyRaY92 i agree with you..first of all she has a great voice..but she hasnt given everything yet..i think her voice is better than this and she needs practise..and she is only 19 so she has time/years to improve her voice..!

[MusicRox1250]

ok people stop hating if your so good then maybe u should prove that u should b world famous!!!

[Anaid97XD]

@LiizzyyRosee ... okay , but i also love to sing (but i can't) and i'm Not doing it in public!

it's ok if she sings at home or maby in ´the internet. and she really can't sing! .... just saying

[niamel9]

She is Beautiful, but she did many out peach you know .. :S

[THEKID3951]

OMG...PLZ IF YOU DONT HAVE ANYTHING TO GOOD TO SAY ABOUT SELENA, THEN MIGHT AS WELL DONT SAY ANYTHING....MAYBE YOUR A DIMOND IN THE ROUGH...

[fredlovers09]

I don't think she's that bad, to be honest.

[shakeitupchicagocece]

I love selena don't get me wrong...but i think the onl yreason why her music career is so succsessful is most her fans can't sing for their life so them compared toselena she sounds like a godess and thats why they say shes amazing...:S

[SelGomezfangren]

@shakeitupchicagocece you're also a fan and i bet you sing worse 

[shakeitupchicagocece]

@SelGomezfangren If i were worse why would i have 63 + awards from talent shows just from my singing? and why would i be the lead chorus solo? and why would i be invited to sing at most of my cities events/festivals -.- get ur facts straight before u accuse lol

[SelGomezfangren]

@shakeitupchicagocece okay whatever and by the way if you were "so talented " prove it



[shakeitupchicagocece]

@SelGomezfangren That sounds retarted. I don't need to prove my talent to a stranger. some ppl r born with talent unlike selena gomez i can sing very well without trying. its called GIFT hun witch i dought selena or u have in music :)

[SelGomezfangren]

@shakeitupchicagocece  and your not retarded bitch.

[shakeitupchicagocece]

@SelGomezfangren Im actually not retarted..... Sorry that someone hates ur stupid 'idol' why don't u go finda real life instead of accusing ppl cuz they don't like ur 'hero'...-.-

[SelGomezfangren]

@shakeitupchicagocece i do have a real lifen ***** okay and she is much more better than you ****** ***

[shakeitupchicagocece]

@SelGomezfangren Umm what r those stars suppose to represent? just say swears fucking bitch !! and how do you know shes better then me?? U honestly r going to claim you're 'idol' is better then a person u never met in real life?? wow big mouth but lame comebacks. Why don't u and ur 'inspiration' go fuck urself !! and obviously u don't if u get mad because someone doesn't like a talentless bitch u look up to -.-

[ItsDestinyyYoo]

@LiizzyyRosee But the people that love to sing aren't famous . She is. And why? Shes not that good either .

[Lizzybown]

2.59 I hate to say it, but it's terrible...

[Lizzybown]

I don't understand. When Christina Grimmie come to Selenas tour she learn how to get the high notes so fast. And are now a very professional singer. So I guess Selena has the same coach, but she sings... I don't get it, shouldn't Christina open up for Selena then? I think Christina Grimmie diserves better!

[SelPrincess]

@beiberismyobsession She HAS a coach already...

[mikutennis]

i love selena and this a song. but she can't sing a song.

[SaiKoSeSu]

@LiizzyyRosee You are right. People should be able to do what they love. However, if you are not on a professional level then you shouldn't be making money off of it. Imagine of the Disney animators were not "the best" at what they do. Their movies would look like crap, and they would still expect to make money off of them!

[Douliimm]

HER VOICE IS GOOD

[shashaa97]

@LiizzyyRosee YOU are soooo right!

[DEADangelmike98]

<3 <3



[bisforbambi]

I like her as a person, and she's not a terrible singer all, but her voice is just to weak to be a professional singer. And when she says "beautiful me" at like 1:58, it's sooooooooo pitchy :S

[roxandra13]

@carmelitagiselle i honestly dont hate selena, i think she is an amazing actress, but her voice is not good...

[TheSelenafen]

omg really stop haters some people love her and will be her fans forever if you don't like her songs and voice why you are watching thease video i think you haven't gotn othing to do ...

[danx3004]

the black and fat girl at 2:58

[destinytje1]

don't wanna be anybody else.....ofcourse not U R FUCKING FAMOUS !!

[Jeugdjournaal2]

Sel have a very good voice :)

[leylaas13]

She's just an average girl that likes to sing , but that's definitely not a performance good enough for central park. NO HATE! :)

[laika123laila]

1:28 ahahaha the kid

selena <3

[huladancer96]

at least she tried...

[Walshuri]

So sorry to say this , but on stage , she sounds like she's beeing murdered.

[edithsauerlach]

@Walshuri xD

[Imonai04]

She sound so much better here than at "Love you like a love song" from earlier

[tianneandelisashow]

hahah the crowd looks SO EXCITED to see her x) lmfao. she needs to stick to acting not singing. ill admit she does sound pretty okay with this song (:

[dunulupo2]

if she was that bad !! how would she make albums and be that famous and have all those fans who like her singing ??

[JDrockergirl]

@dunulupo2 um, autotune, loser.

[Kentuckygirl216]

@dunulupo2 Its called auto tune



[dunulupo2]

this sounds so good !!I dont know why u all hate on her like that !!! she sounds great !!! thats live it has t be like that !!! but she ounds great <3 u selena !

[MultiBobiii]

Selena Gomez The best and i am the biggest fan in Hungary

i love selena gomez and my favourite singer <3

[juliyanaStarz34]

Her voice is good in vid cause been edit ..on live is the real and its bad

[MrTims23]

Selena isnt to bad. Most artists are just crap live. She just needs to get a little louder :P

[winxclubfan1000]

haha watch that eyebrow at 3:14

[xLoveLGx]

@winxclubfan1000 hahahahaha

[13mydogrox]

Normally her live performances aren't too great (no offense, still luv her!) but this time she sounds much better! :)

[QueenOfNails1]

I Love the Song and Selenas long Hair´s and she ^^

[ilovetoby98]

She sings amazing live i dont get it why people are saying that she sounds weak cuz she doesn't she sounds amazing!

[pmw29206]

I don't get what everyone is talking about. She's singing fine.

[P0Pfox]

Ive probably commented on thousands of videos now trying to promote myself, its hard, but ill carry on till i reach my dream. For thousands to see my videos and enjoy listening to my voice, help other see this with a THUMBS UP!!. Im 16 and have uploaded my first cover of this song. please check it out and subscribe or comment with feedback postive or negative. Thanks so much for the support!! PEACE AND LOVE

[myteddylovemy]

i love selena

to bad she can't sing live

[TamuchitaRockStar]

Me gusta Sel como canta pero en vivo no canta taaaan bien como en los videos, algunas veces pienso que le arreglan la voz en los videos, pero me alegro q ella en los conciertos cante con su voz y no haga playback como otras estrellas, que le mienten a sus fans, pero ella no!!!!!! Muyyy sincera Sellyy!

[Missqinachan]

not bad

[helvetekoket]

@LiizzyyRosee I would say ok, but you guys take Miley Cyrus down. Just because Selena can't sing dont talk crap about Cyrus! She's the best

[LiizzyyRosee]

@helvetekoket wtf are you talking about ? I don't talk crap on Miley Cyrus . ?

[TheSoftballlover28]

all the haters u go stand up the in front of EVERYONE and sing this song. plz listen 2 the lyrics of the song then hate on selena

[cherrymiki1]

She tries to avoid the high notes that she does in her music videos, im so dissapointed :(

[bubbleboo778]

haha she's horrible

just my opinion



[Lissbby]

teens love her. So it doesn't matter if she can or can't sing :)

[mignonette20]

@sarahtaylorkim i agree...

[bieberzfan1]

Even thouugh shes not good liiive, i thouught she wouuld naail who says liive buut i was wrong :\

[thegleekinthepink]

this was the best i've seen so far actually

[brendaababbyy]

okay she not the best. but shes doing her best

[TheChaimaa196]

why people says she is not good i was me too but now no im not a ahater

because miley fan who says she is not good look miley i s a bitch and i m a big fan for her and i love miley an selena too

[dionnesayshi]

I think she did amazing?

[SivirBattleMistress]

Jb is gay girls Selena rock on forevur

[MrJoshy33]

this was good it was perfect but is good let her do what she loves i love to sing but im not good at it but idk cuz im doing something i love

[cikibaba]

this was mediocre singing... but i've seen worse so as far as im concerned she did good :)

[braedenalan]

Seriously get off her dick. She isn't that bad. She just doesn't have a strong voice.

Oh and this was on my birthday! (:

[nemo220901]

LOOK AT 2:55

LOL

[LiizzyyRosee]

@nemo220901 What about it ?

[nemo220901]

@LiizzyyRosee did u not see it

[LiizzyyRosee]

@nemo220901 I did but still . Someone having fun and enjoying themselves .

[nemo220901]

@LiizzyyRosee yeh sopose sorry

[jajafine]

I never liked her singing live, but even I have to admit that shes getting better

[sapphireheart9x]

her voice is week.

[xnadiaaaaaaa]

She's not very good live, but at least she doesn't playback.

[sophiiigirl1]

ohh yes she can sing

[LilMissSassyShayy]

You know you suck when your just your background singers are better than you and when they're only background singers and your the lead singer in a famous band.

[briaredhots1]

<3 selena gomez she is the best

[kartheano1]

i love her voice...i like her voice when she singing live!

[purplelover2461]

i love her but once i went 2 one of her concerts i said it was a rip off :/ no effence!

[FashionnWorldd]

her background singers are older and just standing there. So their gonna sound a little better. If you dont like it, dont comment. Simple as. Love you Selenaaaa <3

[ibtr97]

i do not think she is nervous i just think her voice is not that strong but i think that will change in some time

[LyaDeluxe]

=(

Who says ?

[RunLuigiRun333]

Idk what wrong with yall haters, This sounds super good!! Yall are just being hating bastards & bitches

[TheEverEssence]

@RunLuigiRun333 An opinion expressed truthfully is not 'hating'. The comment section is here so we can share our opinion. You'd better be kidding because there is no way you can hear a strong, developed singer. No, she doesn't have a completely awful voice because they can work with it but there comes a point where ok singing becomes pitchy, off key, and not so good.

[julianeskep]

She can't sing =/

read this.once you started there is no turning back. a little 10 yea