Added: 4 years ago
From: MenialTasks
Views: 160,409
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (402)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm going to do that on my violin, and post it on YouTube

  • This feels very rushed (outside of the parts that were missed / misplayed), if you would slow down a bit it would sound a LOT better. A good rule of thumb is play slower than you think it should be (because your nervousness will make it faster) :) I am not disliking because I think every person who puts themselves out there is brave and it certainly wasn't miserable... come back with the version I know that you can do and I will like it.

  • fake, if you look at the other videos they use there hands in the begining. he copied it from the vid ''EPIC hes a pirate cover!!!

  • u hav hairy hand

  • well done

  • i don't think people here are too smart which is a shame.... it sounds the way it sounds because what you're hearing is the electronic sounds the microphone has picked up.... what he's playing is actually sound waves.... see the difference?? what we hear and what he hears are different. he actually did a pretty goo job at this; just doesn't have the proper recording equipment you're used to hearing.

  • What you need to do is simple

    you need to relax and have fun with it

    if you enjoy it, it shows

    and right now its not showing

    take your time with it and loosen up

    you're thinking way too much and that makes it extremely plastic and forced

    intonation could use some work but I guess you haven't been playing the violin for very long so that's not your fault

    the most important thing with music is to have fun with it

    Do that, the rest will fall into place

  • I feel extrememy noobish right now... This is amamzing :) I ned to start practicing violin now lol

  • This is really awesome!

  • Now I feel bad to be a noob... :(...lol....:(

  • i think this is good but i have no right to tell you what to do because i'm a violist. :P

  • please could you give the notes please. I really need it!!! o.o

  • Use less pressure when bowing that's why makes the annoying scratchy sound.

  • Super :) un peu vite à mon gout mais sinon super !

  • Super video : ) continue posting good musique be cause on youtube i realy can not find pirate of the carribean on violin apart from you :) a litle farst at the begening but it geets beter ere the midle ... a litle tuning to probeble :

    PS ; sorry for my speling mestaks i'm french ...

  • Amazing !

    You very very talent violiner ;))

    

  • @anitka40 so talent

  • i want 2 start playing violin and i want 2 play this song but i only have 1 question: is the violin tuned normally? (lol im such a newbe lol)

    I think u sound AMAZING by the way ^-^ keep up the good work

  • u did very good but ur going to fast and the bowwing is too hard but u did great for the most part of :)

  • very well ^^ :)

    gz

  • He isn't bad, but i like the version with breaks more. And I must say that this is true that he's not playing very good. Maybe good, but not very good.

  • he must be on the noob

    hes putting too much pressure on the bow

  • he must be noob

  • Nice, maybe aim your cam to view the whole violin so no ones confused about bowing.

  • Yeah, get down to that fiddle mother fuckers

  • Man! Your cool with your violin! But i think need abit tuning...

  • im going to start playing the violin soon

  • nice job. but, arent there supposed to be rests in te song :)

  • waaaaawwwwwwwwwwwwww...... veryy goodddd...

  • Good !

  • Nice job, although you could tune your violin up before you play but, I don't know if that's just the recording screwing up the sound quality. Camcorders can be bitches to violins XD

    Anyway, the stuff you need to work on are dynamics, articulation, timing and resting between phrases. Get a metronome or something and set it to like, allegro or a bit slower. That should fix part of the problem.

    Either way, just practice and you'll get better (ironic, coming from someone who hates practicing :D)

  • @xBeccaluvluvluvux yep, just use the treble clef instead of the bass. (u kno. the top one instead of the bottom and then just skip) i've done it multiple times (started off with harp and then tried piano and now am doing violin and harp and piano.... lot's of instruments....)

    but yah...... u can..........................

  • I don't know about the recording equipment that you used and what it could have done with the sound but you may need a little tuning or the songs just a bit lower then it's just usually is. But It's a diffeent version and i like it!! Good job!

  • hey man,,,in the sheet u gave,,there is many notes played in same time,or what ido in it

  • COOL

  • :) awesome

  • I like the slightly off sound of this recording. Sounds more piratey =)

  • Sound good,

    You have to work on ur timing though.

    Try to practice with a metronome!

  • man , u could make a finger chart for this song . because im starting practicing ,and i dont know how to read a violin partiture , i only want to know the finger positions ,it is the only thing that i need ,cause the partiture are so hard to read i think

  • do you kann make a tutorail yes or no

  • Sounds good overall, but a little too fast paced.

  • you are not always in the same rhythm you have to work on it and the the tones were not always perfect ...but all in all its oke ;)

  • sounds good to meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • slow down one beat your going fast

  • omg...work on the pitching ;/

  • people only hate this video cause you don't have the two other tracks recorded under this, so it doesn't sound like other videos. Don't worry about it.

  • it was really good but you got the first note in the third measure wrong it sponds to close to the first note in the measure

  • Very nice!

  • Comment removed

  • You're putting to much pressure on the bow, ease up on it and it will sound beautiful.

  • less presure on the bow, and dont skip the quarter note rests then itll be good

  • really good work and the violin? like amati's sound ;D

  • itll be better if you tuned it

  • Ouch

  • can you pls make a video who you take your fingers on the line that i can seenhow i can play it (sry for my english i come from germany)

  • make it stop was my first thought.. ...

    But sick skillz

  • The violin isn't supposed to be fingered right handed, usually the left hang fingers the notes and the left hand bows,

  • @Mrspeddy3 wtf instrument are you playing?

  • @Mrspeddy3 you're an idiot.

  • @alleyhanai I was tired!!! I know that was a really stuidp comment! I just got home from soccer and I didn't sleep the night before cause I was studying!

  • ur violin is seriously out of tune dude.good playing but,gave me a headache=(

  • The song it's self is great, your only small problem, just a teeny weeny thing :P TUNING. otherwise not too shabby

  • There are a lot of comments about how this sounds. A lot of it has to do with the recording equipment used. The sound isn't bad. Yeah, tuning could use a LITTLE work. But overall pretty good.

    It's good to be able to post music on here to have other MUSICIANS give CONSTRUCTIVE CRITISIMS. But unfortunately, people like papilow202 can also post on here....

  • bei 0:35 der 3. Finger auf der e Seite muss hoch gespielt werden (a und nicht as)

    Das Handgelenkt noch etwas gerader und starrer, dann tust du dir auch leichter die Töne richtig zu greifen ;)

    Ansonsten, mit noch bissl Übung, wird das dann schon :)

  • more flowingly...the rest is fine ^^

  • haaaaaaaaaaa my ears

  • UH not against you, but sounds awful

  • Dude that it pretty good better tham me but can you try to practice a lil more but you sound great!

  • i play the violin too..and we play the song in the orchestra..and so i knwo thats i dufficult..thats really good!

  • nice... ;)

  • Terrible. I'm sorry, but intonation and timing is just off. Nice try, though.

  • blow me away

  • wow O_O

  • it sounded ok to me

  • Niice sounds good :D!

  • Thou playest fine thy violin.

    Thou shalt make more video's for thine folk.

  • now i know violin doesnt have any frets..cause im just play the guitar.. :)your violin sound weird...

  • bad sorry!

  • Work on your timing, and the durage of the notes... :)

  • Are you shifting in this piece I can't really tell. Sorry.

  • Shut up newbies in violin!!

    He is playing very good but he doesn't make any breaks... If you don't like it you don't have to make a bad comment  !1.1

  • @25Kfaaa The rests are part of the rhythm but it's up to the person in this situation if they want to pause. :/ Though personally, I think it would sound better if the rests were respected. Really good in the end though. :D

  • its good !

  • te chinuie talentul

  • why violin sounds so annoying

  • aaahh....

    my ears.!!

  • work on your beat and it will sound good

  • beautiful!!!!! of at some parts but still beautiful!! great job!! i can play that on piano guitar and flute!!

  • @masha5maria1965 yeah well it's easier on piano. the other two I don't know but violin is really hard

  • great :D

  • work on the rhythm... it needs to be more jaunty (if that makes sense :P )

  • SOMEBODY STOP MAKING ME LAUGH!! HAHAHAHAHA

    Your welcome =)

  • oh you made nice

  • @XxLisa97 I accidentally my ears.

  • work on intonation

  • Timing

  • your violin sounds a little out of tune i think is either your E String or your D String but good job : ]

  • little slow and yea little off tune but good playing

  • sounds funny maybe tune it but still nice song

  • dude if u were graded on youtube this vid would get a B-

  • good you must work but you are not bad.

  • wat een takke herrie

  • wonderful!

  • saweet

  • very good i liked it.

  • nicely dote mate

  • non fo le fair sa au violon bien jouer c super

  • lol best comment. jajajajaja ell o ell.

  • funny i forgot about this vid pero clicking on your comment MADE me remember hahaha ;)

  • I wouldn't criticize him for lack of emotion, this song is difficult. Unless you have serious talent, this song takes months to play perfectly.

  • its ok

  • it was too rushed and lacked emotion. you have the skill, you play well already. just play with your heart and feel the song. try to play it with the memory it brings back.

  • what the hell r u talking about? she did great.

  • i didn't say the contrary but it doesnt sound heartfelt. its hard to explain. there is an awesome tv series called long vacation. its japanese. watch it, you'll understand my point

  • same for your mother

  • I like it :D

  • I learned to play this one by ear; how ever I would still like to come across sheet musc

  • you should have raised the tempo up a tad bit but other than that you performed it well :)!

  • Bravissimo!

  • the begining was fast which i liked but in the middle it started slowing down but nice job! keep it up

  • it's great, i like it..

    i want to start to play the vioin too, i'm very fascinated =)

    great

  • Please! PLEASE!!! Give me the score! I can´t find it! T-T

  • 1-0

    Billy Mays wins.

  • If I cant do it, I wont complain!

    Good Very Good!

    I Enjoyed it alot!

  • very nice............and your hands are realy beautiful.

    frgv me

  • Yo quiero la partitura!!!!!

    espero me la puedas pasar

  • lamento desilusionarte, pero yo las he buscado tmbn y esas partituras tienen copyright derechos de autor y todo el rollo. Hay que pagar para tenerlas.

  • your D string is a little bit flat

  • Awesome !! keep it up

  • boring wive!

  • Alittle slow, not bad. Should have just put a pic over it. Dont rly want 2 c ur hand

  • Very Nice

  • to fast bud nice ;)

  • it was very slow

  • hey how long do you play does it take too long to play like this?by the way you are awesome

  • Awesome!

  • i absolutely love this! i like you made it your own in a way

  • i think you make this sound GREAT!

    and thank you soooooooooo much for the link!!!! i play violin too and cant wait to start working on this!

  • from what I've read, the violin seems to bother people the most. I rather like the sound of it. And if it really is such a bad sounding violin, i think you make it all work.

  • if you have the right song and you can do it good that it sounds great it is just a matter of time when you can do it and when you can its beautiful

  • it's too fast! it's nice though.

  • its a little too slow what are you talking about

  • Either get rosin, ease up a bit, or change the strings. It's a bit too scratchy. But otherwise, pretty good. Nice vibrato by the way

  • thats good i love it!! i wish to play that on the violin but i dont have the notes :( btw ur d string is a little flat :)

  • You play very nicely actually, its the blunt sound thats bothering from the violin.

  • Better change dat violin

    You play quite well

  • Mostly I would hate someone playing "He's a pirate" on the violin, but you make it sound FANTASTIC!!!

  • You rush in your playing - work on that. Otherwise, great.

  • I prefer playing it on the piano tbh.

    I just think it sounds better.

    But good luck with your playing.

  • wow

    the worst violin i ever heard

    but ur playing is good

  • bad violin made it sound cheap :( ok playing

  • they were meant to be played with harmonies i think. with other violens. thats when they sound good if all the violenists are playing well

  • how do you play a piano sheet? please help

  • very awesome =D good play ;)

  • WOW!!! You play really really great!!!!

    Congratulations and thanks a lot for sharing the sheet music!!!!!!!!!

    Hugs ♥

  • could you make a video that we see your note hand abit better, because I don't get the notes in my head. ^_^ *PLEASSSSSEEEEE*

  • Awesome!!!!

  • wtf its piano sheet

  • i want to play diz so much!!

  • That is Friggin amazing =O

    You are wonderful =O specially at this piece =)

    Congrats on having such a good talent (Y)

  • AHH i go goosebumps! Lol very very good! I love it!

  • i get them everytime i hear this song!

  • damn you are really good. now i need to learn how to play that. keep up the good work and do your best.

  • OMG you're awesome and your my daily hero for bringing me the notes :D

  • hey du ahts es drauf du bist wirklich gut kannst du mir ein kleine gefallen tuhn bitte ihc brauch die noten wenn du kannst könntes du mir die mla bitte geben ist wirklich wichtig =) bye udn amch weiter so

  • Danke fuer die Noten!!!

  • war ganz okay, ich hätte nur an manchen stellen eine pause gemacht.

  • waow!!

  • wow se oie gnial n violin

    atte:

    Ða$h!ta

  • good !

  • *claps*good job, but ur fingers creep me out...just sayin ^-^

  • creepin me out to, lol

  • Same here... ; )