戴愛玲+楊培安＊千年之戀

[AngelWingsE]

楊培安唱太多哥,很多都唱幾千遍了吧...

[robert7galant]

楊培安比信有實力多了

[AngelWingsE]

@robert7galant 不要做這種評論,很多事情不是考慮單方面就可以的

[j19960131]

我自己有唱過這首歌在後面的合音用喉音，用完以後整個喉嚨ㄜ..­....

整個就是沙啞的狀態...



[cdowhmo]

實力有差

[jeff1996su]

信是喉嚨怪物~ 信是已嘶吼出名的 跟安歌的高音不一樣~ ok?! 高音之神就是高音之神~ 強 !!

[howardwang1]

樓下妳真的知道KEY是什麼嗎= =

[12389x]

我個人認為...

這首歌對她來說，根本就是小菜一碟吧?

戴愛玲唱的KEY仔細去聽...

楊培安的KEY...

楊培安一直在配合戴愛玲的KEY...

整個很不搭= =

[textused]

@12389x

KEY不是這種東西= ="

[maggie1027maggie1]

只有高音.沒有power

[jeff1996su]

@maggie1027maggie1 你真有power啊~  哈

[ilikepili2004]

楊老師好棒~~

[chenzernshii]

我實在太驚訝了,竟然會有人說培安聲音的力道(或爆發力)不如信­,我倒是認為恰恰相反,反而是因為他的聲音力道過人,這首一般人­要卯足全力唱的歌,他唱的輕輕鬆鬆,才會讓人覺得他唱歌powe­r不強,事實上,如果聽他唱一些更高音域的歌,你就會感受到他的­嗓子power有多驚人了,還有不知有沒有人注意到,這首歌的中­後半段,居然是培安在幫戴愛玲撐住,很明顯戴愛玲是有點累了(前­面唱太多歌了嗎),女生唱高音照理說是比男生輕鬆的......­這樣一看,你就會知道培安的唱功,和嗓子的power有多深厚

[SymphonyRiffChord]

@chenzernshii

培安哥的高音確實是亮又有爆發力的，像早期速金主唱那種，不過不­屬於厚實型的高音，因為他用的高音胸聲成分不高

要聽真正厚實系的高音國外你可以聽Rainbow的主唱，I surrender很推薦

[chauliu]

那楊培安是博派的嗎...?

[okok511121]

@chauliu 有梗 ....

[gn19761028]

戴跟楊的音域截然不同..

戴跟阿信是狂派



[a38837]

樂隊在幹嘛 還要楊培安自己拍手勒XD

[aazxcvbnmm]

好險有愛玲幫他唱,不然整首歌會變得很乾!!



[johnlin60]

我也覺得樂隊托不起氣氛

[a981990]

樂隊能給點力嗎......感覺托不起這首歌的氣氛....

[DEVIL19920802]

信跟戴安玲是同類型

而楊培安是跟A LIN

狂吼高音VS清脆高音

[sherry12i05]

最油最爛的真的叫林志炫

[magic01boy]

@sherry12i05

真的

[first0kiss]

楊培安唱死了都要愛可以升6.7k 這難不到他的><

[sammax3579]

@first0kiss 能高音是另外一回事。唱这歌重要就是有那个爆发力。信就是有那爆­发力的声音。听上去的感觉就大有不同了。

[621ak]

不曉得為什麼聽楊培安老師唱的就感覺是一首歌而已

但是聽到信跟戴愛玲在嘶吼那邊我會很麻...雞皮疙瘩...

以男生來說~我超喜歡信的那種爆發力..MAN...

[TheBreakself]

我怎麼覺得楊培安在唱前段根本很輕鬆= =

[MONTES3388]

聽到現在

好像都沒信的經典...

楊培安一人分飾兩角那部也只是讓人佩服...



[riddleCHEN]

@MONTES3388

那個其實不算唱歌，

那場只不過是應製作單位要求的特技表演

[jeans0910]

還是信+戴最完美...

[peanutvera]

So glad 楊培安 and 戴愛玲 have their own duet now too. "只要再看你一眼" is very different from "千年之戀," but still such a great song. Especially since both are such great singers :)

[ctw60]

楊培安屬於"希望"的歌聲，信是用搖滾的元素"抒懷"。兩個歌手­定位不一樣(個人兩個都喜歡並且心中地位是平等的)簡單來說，楊­是武當，信是少林。

[rinwre]

其實有人會覺得培安老師的聲音聽起來比較薄也是有原因的 因為老師他的發聲是用混音的方式去詮釋的 簡單的說就是KEY越高，假音混的比例越高 好處就是唱起來可以比較省力，聲音聽起來會比較柔和 缺點就是當真聲的比例漸漸變小的同時，聲音的強度也會相對下降 所以常看LIFE BAND 或 LIFE SHOW的就可以發現 混音型的歌手在表演時，MIC的收音效果都會另外再做加強 回到這個視頻 影片當時培安老師應該是跟現場的工作人員沒有溝通好 所以才會有聽起來聲音比較薄的情況 但其實那只是聽起來小聲一點而已 整個演出還是精采的 

[rinwre]

@riddleCHEN

確實我是沒聽過培安老師唱過現場

只是就我PUB工作多年的經驗來評斷

因為會有這種要求的歌手並不算少數

[orz000000]

原唱充滿爆發力的高音

在怎麼聽還是信唱的最好

[ch000253]

培安有種不想唱這首的感覺.....很不認真的感覺耶

而且他的聲音比較女性化的唱法，沒有信的豪邁感

[treefrank]

為何就沒人稱許 作詞 跟 作曲 的那兩位 ?? 他們也是這首歌的功臣啊

[peanutvera]

Love 楊培安 :) He sings the song pretty well. And as always, love his voice.

[0174539536]

信的声音高了很有力度,是那种有爆炸力,在信的声音会听到力量的

培安的声音是很高的,高得会让人窒息的..但就缺少了信的那种爆­炸...他是比较极高,偏激的声音...信的高音没有培安高

跟信的是两个不同的高法...

[asd2452]

戴愛玲感覺沒有他原本唱片的好@@ 有一些key沒上去

[p4102xyz]

哪是阿

楊培安他高音是"後天"練出來的

去看看他19歲唱的歌  聲音沒力 又薄

他高音是後天的自我磨練跟自我要求 訓練出來的!(看他死了都要愛升key 他有說!)

[starmoonligh]

樓下說的對

聲音是天生的沒辦法改變阿=  =

真的是神經質

[charmass045]

楊培安聲音薄?

你可以去現場聽聽看...

[kii12500]

在CD OR MV裡的歌都是錄好的了所以音頻都修改的差不多了

這是LIVE所以沒辦法改音

是真槍實彈低

[SDGundamFan]

戴愛玲身體不好. 沒平常好. 楊培安跟信都很高可是我比較喜歡信! 培安爆發力沒信好.

也覺得他沒什麼味道.

[a3592122]

戴愛玲的聲音有點累了...

小搔聲...不是最好的狀態....

可能有些感冒...

楊培安的高音比較薄....

合唱被戴 比下去...

聽起來就較薄...

[CherriiDreamz]

both sing great! the style of singing here is simply amazing <3

[dragonson92]

戴愛玲唱得怪怪的,可能兩人事前練習不夠吧?不過兩人真的都很強­!!!

[beiyuan82]

sing as well as shin, but less feel from pei an's part. probably he did not rehearse much or that's just his part for a small concert.

[z8064665]

楊培安唱得很好!

他和信都是高音域的人，各有千秋，

不過我個人喜歡培安的聲音ＸＤ

[jackyces]

戴愛玲狀況不好吧..

[austin19861225]

阿喔!叫的那兩聲下我一跳

[29898008]

楊培安真的很厲害

[0174539536]

没有感觉

[roomd21]

@0174539536 你X冷感喔?

[waters0315]

不看畫面，其實培安大哥的聲音一直很穩定的backup在戴愛玲­的後面，唱工實在好的可怕。

不過也因為這個音域對他來說有點輕鬆，所以就少了點哪種激昂澎湃­的感覺。

但還是好歌一首。

[suajimjim]

某些部分~~有喔點小不搭 和失誤

但還是好強喔!

[kelly199218]

woah..pitchy

[cglbj]

培安加油

[riddleCHEN]

這場Live的時間點發生在楊駐唱的最後期，他坦承那段時間唱到­職業倦怠，有些歌(尤其是信樂團的歌)根本拒唱，(相信身為信迷­的你很難想像，畢竟他後來用了死愛飆高音並唱了千年之戀、天高地­厚，雖然不完全出於自願，但歌唱了是事實)，因為有些歌重複演唱­太過多次，所以能閃則閃，閃不掉就會變成有點類似發生機器的狀況­，用非常機械的方式及豐富的技巧唱過去。

[riddleCHEN]

油？是的，就這個現場而言是油了一點，是歌聲中近乎不帶情感的機­械式的油。只是相信閣下對油這個字眼的定義應該與我不同，只是我­想，對於楊培安也許你可以排除成見多聽一點，安靜地一個人在房間­靜靜聽，你會聽到更多的不同，對於油或不油，相信你或有其他的看­法。

[jamessl3]

那請問你來這裡發文的用意何在？

[sherry12i05]

@CnnFuc 最油的還是林志炫吧

真的 噁心

[kokokoko886]

@sherry12i05 同意!!!!

[gn01160315]

評良心講

這首歌信+戴一起唱比較適合

[liaon98]

麥克風怪怪的

[Sue1997]

覺得有些音好像比ＭＶ還尖了我個人覺得不是很舒服

[CHCATHA56]

都不錯啦

[dosa740612]

戴愛玲唱的有點糟 搞不好本來就不適合唱這歌(誤)

[sofia819]

我覺得楊培安再加強他的氣勢會唱得更好

[unfinisherd]

不對音樂發表意見，只是楊培安的臉幾乎從頭到尾都在影子裡，而戴­愛玲站的位置很好，燈光都有很清楚的照到她，以雙人表演來說看起­來很不搭。

[k691991]

兩個都很會唱呀，一開場收斂的很好，若是其他不會唱的，一開始就­要爆音了吧，那樣子感覺就很差，當然這種常人認為是飆高音的行為­，對他們而言，其實唱得很輕鬆。尤其是楊培安吧!

[peianfans]

兩位以前的片段~

變成可以合作的一首情歌！

就是～只要再看你一眼！

不知不覺～他們的這首歌有一年喇！

[holimax]

楊培安本身的聲音跟本同信有很大的分別

有什麼好比較呢

[yvonnetywen]

xin



[yvonnetywen]

@holimax xin



[magirl3]

不喜歡 那聽屁阿??

[k2strax]

原key喔!

[blackholelover]

Their voices were not consistent. Just OK for fun.

[toastedpotatoes]

I love her voice, if only I had voice of such great power..

[gsn87]

perhaps he and she shall proceed to the higher key...

[angelzx]

very nice

[AceSpades]

lolol.. she's doing harmonising, not that her pitch is inaccurate =) she's pro. try squeezing ur voice at the pitch she's doing with such superb control.

[jenniferhu0130]

聽幾首楊培安唱ㄉ歌,他..真ㄉ是有實力底打ㄉ很深ㄉ歌手.關於­這首歌...我不習慣戴愛玲某些唱法,有點硬柪過ㄑ,當然現場演­唱會有當時狀況疲憊吧

[powei413]

感覺戴愛玲這首唱得不是很穩~

感覺像很累的樣子~ 音亂飄~

身體應該不舒服吧!

楊培安就安安穩穩的唱~

[tw52151314]

我覺得這首歌超好聽的˙他的詞曲我感覺很適合把它擺在天龍八部的­片頭或片尾曲的說˙˙˙超適合的啦

[frozenxflame]

she can definitely do better than this -.-"

[MichaelTadashi]

她一直换音，不管是不是刻意为了配合培安，都是一个败笔。

[Nicolle4410]

認同!

[amyangel1224]

Wow she really sucks..... no offense or anything but her pitch is really inaccurate ==" she sounded so much better in her music video LOL lots of fixing job done??

[Interdicted]

this guy is far away from right, he can sing the notes, but wheres the rock spirit?

他太suck了

[KeySabre]

huh...

楊培安很不錯，

不過這個版本我覺得...

感覺不是很好。

[sian7272]

這首歌氣勢相當重要 培安氣勢有被愛玲壓過去的感覺，最後的合唱二部和聲壓過一部了

[93421623]

楊培安發揮不好呢

[suuyan]

我比較喜歡楊培安唱這個；個人喜好而以

他和shin各有千秋

[kenny9918]

ROCKER RULEZ!!

[stringray]

戴愛玲是个高音歌姬

[TheWisestOne]

3:45...

Did the girl scream on purpose? Or was it an accident of some sort?

[LillbyLittle]

distortion.

i bit off but still so beautiful :)

[Rand0mAsian]

na she screamed on purpose, the original song was like that too

[TheWisestOne]

A little different, but Yang Pei An did pretty fine too!

[longlongkin]

好聽的呆了!!

超厲害..超high的!!

所有音都很準呀!!

[z7010801]

原唱是阿信和戴愛玲

這是翻唱

[annycil]

喜歡原唱組合~~

[some66xx88]

luv it

[cpaljchc]

呵呵

我到覺得戴愛玲她3:40那邊的狂戀著花

唱得不錯說

雖然跟音沒合上但是如果自己唱應該感覺不錯o.o

[endogenetic]

那個叫和音，懂不懂呀？

[amyangel1224]

OMG she's off pitch =="

[emiltsuimunsang]

I agree with you

[Hakkiri]

ai ling needs to go easy on the distortion sometimes... she was unable to really sing "de" after going all out on the "wo" x_x

[awpdoom32]

這時候的培安還沒被簽..

[avi02box]

戴愛玲這天失常說......

楊培安可以唱更好，就他的功力來說!

[sexyidiot]

i think u cant even go up to their standard.. so u are here to leave stupid comments.. laughing my ass out.

[aNXie1y]

i saw some dumbcunt comments here, this is live, they are good still, stop critising key run off or wadever, this is considered good performance

[zincthenoob]

她不是原唱嗎~?

[CutieKala]

Yes, she is.

But I don't quite understand why she can't sing very well in this video. Her voice start cracking when she sing high. Did anyone notice that?

[kunsttrotzarmut]

No, her voice did not crack at all. It's perhaps the singing technique called "distortion" that you're talking about.

[SVENPANG]

maybe is the audio probs le....actually both also good la...rite??

live ma...so not really same wif the original version...

[youtubaabe]

我想這首歌不一定要嘶孔才好聽，其實開始女的聲音很尖很溫柔，後­面就變嘶孔~~ 這首歌前後太不match！！其實表現那種激憤不一定要嘶孔！！­我覺得楊已經很不錯，他聲音只是有點表現不到那種power 或者激憤，不過只是人木木篤篤的站在那邊而已嘛！！

[WCqq]

女的唱的不好

真音和假音转换的时候太明显

音质已经变了

低音的部分也不是很准

小扬的唱功很帅。 bloody 帅！

[kyo94118]

what you talking about? she's the original singer~!!!

[465412315]

唱不好你個頭拉~到底會不會聽~現場唱歌比較會因不準的時候~拜­託別裝懂大陸人都比較會掰嗎!

[volts88]

AGREE!!

[cheer4hope]

i think they both sing really well...but this song doesn't really fit them. no offence to the song, just people have their own style.

[d2537866]

２人都唱的很好聽ㄚ．．．

[pbli38]

其實,

楊培安在中間那個不知道什麼語言的那一段很不錯.

[achilleswei]

Italian.

[pbli38]

我也很喜歡楊培安,

但是他這首的缺點就是不夠野,

(楊培安不如阿信的野,再野一點這首歌的味道才會出來)

其實以歌唱功力來說楊培安是辦的到的,

但是我覺得可能跟個性有關吧!?

[pbli38]

我是很喜歡戴愛玲,

不過他這首歌的表現真的不好,

感情沒有進去,

技巧忽隱忽現的,

因準有跑一些掉,

而且兩人的強度不搭嘎,

明顯強過楊培安,

感覺反而她太野(還加嘶吼咧...~"~)

(尤其後面兩人合唱,很沒有Feel...);

[465412315]

因為對方不是阿信~懂嗎?

[rox001002]

真的缺少一點音準

[kb9935]

以現場演唱而言,很讚....比yuming&黃美珍好多了

[Clpchow]

唔認同可以用live 同信樂團比,

flamyblood, 可以批評楊培安聲音沙啞..高音好混濁,

恐怕只有你一人有資格批評=-="

[emiltsuimunsang]

現在發覺原來阿信的板本是多麼的好!!!!

[Fr023n]

i think ah xin sing better,

[ines]

在網路上看到戴愛玲要到嘉義的耐斯演唱耶～niceprince­hotel

[b3y0nD]

omg... though this song is quite high in pitch.. but the girl went off pitch in the middle of the song, but still, we have to applaud for her courage...

[gifted4]

she didnt go off pitch, she went the "accompany" aka "secondary" or "back up vocal" key... did you ever heard of a real duet?

don't flame if you don't know music yourself.

[b3y0nD]

oh thanx.. im quite polite on my phrases manz.. i dun think thats a so called back up vocal.. the note is way out of the place.. and even if u are correct.. however, based on ur ill-mannered character.. u are still a loser.. so i hope that u can really buck up on ur manners..

[amyangel1224]

LOL this is funny.... there may be some truth in ur comment... but the fact that you openly called him/her a loser make ur position questionable LOL

[b3y0nD]

well.. there are always both sides towards everything.. it's all depends on whether u urself is standing on an objective side or a subjective side.. maybe he/she is a "so-called" expert based on the comments been made.. i'll accept constructive criticism.. but definitely not someone whom we dun even noe whether he/she is an expert.. or rather someone that's so "well-mannered"

[shinya1215]

原唱? Studio裡面可以fine tune的東西太多了

Live這樣算很不錯了,戴愛玲中音域的感覺很好,聲音的圓潤感­很夠

楊培安的聲音感覺上沒有蘇見信的表情那麼豐富

但是真是高不可測

希望他能遇到適合他的歌

[taiwanlonglive]

歌曲向來都是原唱唱的比較好吧~ 戴愛玲 其實歌聲很棒的~!

[riddleCHEN]

這場聽起來其實戴愛玲的狀況沒有很好，

另外個人覺得一這首歌的味道來說，

帶愛玲還不要加入嘶吼會比較適合，

畢竟在男生的部份，

無論是培安還是阿信都沒用太多明顯的嘶吼。

[FlamyBlood]

跟信樂團唱的版本差好多 pitch 不準.聲音又沙啞 高音好混濁

以一個專業歌手的標準來說 遜...

[wendysung626]

the girl has such an amazing voice

[idontplaywow]

yah the girl has a pretty sexy voice, but if u listen closely, she goes off pitch time to time when the pitch goes higher. And too bad she's kind of ugly. Plus the way she tries to scream on a low voice sounds rediculous...scary stuff, even her scream is off-pitch - sounds like a devil-child on a tantrum.

yang-pei an on the other hand rocks.

[idontplaywow]

And seriously, u can't sing if ppl don't wave the glow-stick? That girl treat the audience like crap. If you want them to wave then just wave your hand, u don't have to order them jeeze

[stevehuang2001]

hey man, maybe you're not gay, so you can't admire this kind glamour!!

[apposeed]

someone needs more training. Too ill-experienced for such glamour

[hwy123]

還不錯~

[ureweta]

Good!

[54571]

是藍狂吧!呵呵!專產歌手跟樂團!

[skateduck]

這是在藍色狂想嗎？

[sian7272]

http://marvel5p.netfirms.com/d­is/wma/941006.wma

This is the original soundtrack by "信樂團"

the volcal is shin(M) and Dai-Ai-Ling(F)

[Aije]

This song is pretty, can someone tell me how to find it online?

[Jacksonloke]

dis song is sang by a taiwanesse bad!name SHIN!

[axl2523]

楊培安讚阿!!