Added: 5 years ago
From: mest0505
Views: 12,610
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (23)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the bayside version was murder to listen to. Bad Astronaut all the way

  • wow nice sheepburn, you just started the exact thing that you tried to "prevent" lol nice one

  • i love this song and i love the smoking popes.

  • you don't know a girl named megan...

  • what?

  • such a sweet guitar solo.

  • Nobody sings this song better than Josh Caterer. I better not see anyone else starting up that "I prefer Bayside's cover" crap.

  • Excuse me, people are entitled to their opinions too...

    I like the acoustic version of Bayside's a lot... though I do think this is pretty awesome... the acoustic version makes it... rather... 100x more depressing though...

  • def, the version i listen to depends wat type of mood im in at the moment

  • My sentiments exactly. If they do, it shows they prefer mediocrity (Bayside singer's tone has that dime-a-dozen, whiney tone. Nothing unique). There's a jackass kid here on youtube singing Megan that sounds like Bayside. Case in point.

  • What? How can you say Anthony's voice isn't unique??? The crap emo that is played on the radio (a formally good source of music turned worthless) all sounds the same. Take fall out boy and panic at the disco....can you honestly distinguish the two bands?? I can't, along with the 800 other emo pop culture bands out there right now. I personally love baysides acoustic version. Anthony is an awesome guitarist, and a damn good singer.

  • Since you asked: Yes, whiney tone & not a good singer from what I've heard. All these newer bands have the same depth & are very bland. Those other two bands you mentioned: Shit. This Emo music caters to all you youngsters who like that MTV, Warped Tour garbage. Bayside obviously saw something very great in the Popes which is why they covered their song. We've got nothing to discuss. Obviously you & today's youth like it so knock yourself out listening to that stuff.

  • @p4horror are you retarded? if you've listened to bayside you would know anthony's voice is far from whiney.

  • wow man, have you never listened to bayside before? anthony doesnt have a voice like everyone else. He mite be one of the movst talented vocalist of our time

  • I perfer Bob Nanna's(TheCityOnFilm" version of this song. Search the city on film on myspace and listen to it, it's really good.

  • this song is great but i like it better with acoustic with both anthonysmoking popes singer singing

  • Great song from a band I flew to Chicago to see when it was deemed a one-time only reunion show. Only Josh can sing their song just right. Just Josh (no bayside crap) Thanks for posting this.

  • Looooooooove this song

  • this song is fucking awesome.

  • haha, thanks, i was suppose to post more but i got lazy.

  • if you have pretty pathetic, you should definitely post it.

  • haha, too bad my camera ran out of film. i wish i recorded that song. oh well so many people post that song up anyway.

  • Good audio on this on, compared to others on YouTube.

  • thanks, most of the speakers were behind me so i was just picking up the caterers' amps.

  • romantic

  • yes very romantic. i was soo happy i was lucky enough to get up front.

  • hi! smoking popes is one of my my fave! they sound like the smiths, probably the best romantic band in the world! hey mest tnx 4 the letter! take care!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more