Mariah Carey - Heartbreaker Live @ La Gala de la Hispanida

[AnonymousXtinaSinger]

Omg Mariah I Love You And All But Must You LipSych Every Performance If This Song ? Is It That Vocally Challenging That You Cant Juss Lip The Fs And The Whistle ? What Was Her Excuse? Then Shes Terrible At Lipping At That

[DanKanzas]

@AnonymousXtinaSinger She sings it live at all her tours. She was obviously preserving her voice for the Rainbow Tour she was about to do and I'm sure that was the longest tour she had done at that point in her career. Mariah has said lots of times that its difficult to sing all her songs back to back because of how demanding the vocals on each track are.

[CoreyLongmire]

she sounds amazing.... but this video is 6 years old, I dont think nobody cares if she lipped.

[MyWhistleE7]

I do not have those nodes on the vocal cords and no vocal performance of Mariah Carey but all I can do ..... C7 E7 F7 and C6 of mine sounds like a Leona Lewis:D

[mandelion]

she has vocal nodules and it can get worse. so i think saving her voice is more important. she does live in more "important" shows (like concerts) tho' and she STILL rocks it so go figure.

[pmfa91]

Mariah is so bad at lipping xD !

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

Almost every heartbreaker performance she did was LIPSYNCHED, terrible, is that what makes someone amazing ? lipsynching ? MESS.

[iiAmitx3]

@XTINASDISCIPLE idk is screaming all the notes makes a singer amazing?? i don't think so... at least she's lipping to good vocals.... which your singer can't even lip synch to

[goldbronzetanboy]

she looks so so so cute in this beautiful

[IreneBTV]

I was there :')

[PeterTenglund]

muchu ambrella bella notte (sorry, thats the way you italiens sounds like, ha ha)

[PeterTenglund]

muchu abrella bella notte (sorry, thats the way you italiens sounds like, ha ha)

[MCLambDahling3000]

the heartbreaker song is very bubblegum/ teen poppish. but wait till ya get to the remix!!!

[MariahCareyAngel1]

I love how she used to dress in Raibow era!!

[iepposko]

i think she sings a few words... the rest is prerecorded with a fex differences from the original

[perfecthonor]

she sings so easily... wow. very impressive.

[Rickybondfly]

if this is live i'm the pope.... ;-)

[lukedlang]

certain parts are lipsynced, but who cares, still good

[nowherepink]

¿que pintaba esta yankee en una gala de la Hispanidad?

[owersoon]

@nowherepink Ella y Christina Aguilera representaron ese año a USA en la Gala de la Hispanidad

[nowherepink]

@owersoon tampoco es muy hispana a pesar de su apellido " C.A".. Si eso es lo que entienden por hispanos en USA allá ellos .

[cjanmartin]

even if she lip syncs its still her voice... and mariah's voice is so different..

[rogergarth5]

non è live è un prerecording cmq lei bellissima ed unica.

[wellythonvieira]

Why Mariah writes music that does not itself able to sing live?

She dubbed the whole time! And she believes that no one noticed!

[edsssooonnn]

the jeans !!! i love mariah

[QueerSwede1]

oh dear, not live at all.

[Xulo13]

Mariah Caarey en mi sevilla???? madre mia ojala que vuelva!!

[Mimardemusica]

2 words: Play back. 

[luxxo77]

@Mimardemusica 100% live ;)

[Mimardemusica]

@luxxo77 if you listen well, live versions, never reaches the high notes. I am a singer, and I know when someone does play back.

[niltash]

wow

[EeyoreWhyBother]

She has always been an amazing talent, too bad her need to look like a cheap whore over shadows her voice.

[TheMrMarilyn]

WTF!!!!She's MIMING here!!!!

[RUDYCAREY]

aqui estaba yo y no os imaginais el revuelo que se genero con ella hay que gracia la gente impactada, otros gritando, diciendo eres la mejor!!!! jejeje y ella super simpatica

[tertra114]

she is too pretty in this video, at 0:07 she looks like a doll, her eyes look so big

[randomhajile2]

live play back,

very good

[Grisso90]

i love those damn whistles!! superb

[Ehadurkah]

The only Human with 7 octave range and she show some of it here!

[nicevidbro]

She had 5 octaves, not . Get a clue.

[jmatt4life]

She nails this live version. It varies from the album cut just enough and she makes it her own. AWESOME!!! (-=

[mrxoxo02]

okay ill explain mariah can sing "BALLAD" and "HIGH NOTES" but not "POP AND RNB SONGS" or sometimes she can sing it but not just good like her BALLAD POWER. GET IT? 'SHE CAN SING HIGH BUT NOT LOW"

[jesparza562]

u think mariah cant sing low. she is an alto . check out her tribute to stevie wonder. she has low notes no other artist , besides toni braxton , can hit.

[TeeJay1625]

@jesparza562 I wouldn't say an alto, maybe a mezzo. she was known at the beginning for being pop singer with a soprano belt, which is crazy since most belters and woman in pop are mezzo sopranos or altos. crazy stuff!

[AnnieThelen14]

she is coloratura soprano

[sentfromupabove]

@AnnieThelen14 no LMAO

[cmandmc1991]

you should listen to her live vocal range G#2-G#7 which is really low to really high. You probaly don't know mariah that well do you

[jmatt4life]

I love it!!!! I had never seen this video. Thank you for posting it. I do not know of anyone who can vocalize like she does. This song is ultimately tricky with the vocals. I LOVE IT! AWESOME!!! sAm (-=

[jmatt4life]

Y concordo con elzakooox. ESPECTACULAR!!!  Vocalizacion tremenda! (-=

[benjaminjanet]

i miss the old mariah to :(. she has ambitious and energetic, this ones kind of lazy , still good and hot! but memoirs imperfect angel is teribbble!

[rismax]

Oh miss Mariah. I miss this you. There is just something not right about the present Mariah. But I can't even hate. Get it gurl!

[elzakooox]

expectacular sin palabras la mejor voz del mundo y del planeta!!!!! la voz mas aguda del mundo!!

[LADYDIVAA]

mariah wat 2 do about these haters that go videp to video hating on u your so good they say u lipsynch i guess if it was left up to these white people u neva sang a note...

[nicevidbro]

Haters? Please shut up. This is not live, its a pre-recorded.

[ashrafd1]

Wil, Its all up to the producer... Mariah's now a days inspired people... whatever! She got the voice...She's still number one,,,whenever, wherever ...

[ashrafd1]

The URL contained a malformed video ID.

[ashrafd1]

yes I am a fan of MC,,, I know the real sounds of Heartbreaker and its dfrent from this..therefore I conclude this is not lip sync ,,,

[sweetangelfire]

This is not lipsync...she do adlibs

[wattagurl]

if you're really a fan of Mariah Carey, you would know that this is not her "live" voice. You know how Mariah sings live, right? But that's ok, I still love Mariah! :-)

[sweetangelfire]

this is live..they do mix with non and pre record voice...but its a live

[MariahHeartbreaker]

hi...anybody knows where can i watch the another performer in this show of mariah?? she sang heartbreaker and against all odds...please tell me thanks

[daxureMusic]

/watch?v=xDMqzYDi81M

[justeinnek]

omg!! nice

[arielzo]

so sweet =] i luv this song too !

[lukituchi]

Who says this is live is deaf ... honestly :))

[SJEEZUS]

its not lipped

[nanodun011]

It is lip-synched. You can tell when she moves too far away from the mike, and the pitch and volume is still the same. She is an amazing performer, though, and I LOVE this song.

[sweetangelfire]

Again this is live...she extended some voice like humming...and some part are not thats what they called mixing....to the live and pre record voice... look at 0:28/29 thats live...that extended thing 0:52/54 is also live..ure just listneing to the background so u think its NOT live..but its live...

[sweetangelfire]

Again if ure a fan..u should know how she can trick and do magic the way she perform at stage and her director randy jackson....think about...and she got a good mixer...for pre record and live and non live

[ashrafd1]

That's what U think... Yes MC sings a lip sync, sometimes when the producer can't afford her voice, they can only afford Lip sync but not now...

[ashrafd1]

But this one is 100.1 % LIVE! are U obsessed?

[theTeabag]

this is not live. The whispery parts are equally loud no matter how far her head is from the mic.

[sweetangelfire]

but sometimes its a mix...remember when she sing live it cost a million like 1.5M or 1M dollars...like when she sing happy bday to mohammad ali and when she open somewhere in turkey and she got 100K+ diamond butterfly ring..and so on...and I agree she lipsync if someone cant afford her voice live

[ashrafd1]

amazing performance... No doubt...

[MariahHeartbreaker]

i love this performer...is in seville, spain 12th octuber 1999 hehe when she finished this "show" she went to tenerife with her ex-boyfriend Luis Miguel.....TENERIFEEEE....MY ISLAND....Thanks Mariah for coming....I love you

[funster15]

this is whats called a RUN performance.. Its when she goes in the studio and sings it once through and uses it for a live performances...mic is off..and she sings it in speaking voice so it don't look too lipped.. very common now.

[anyhowpresss]

lipped :X but i still love mariah!

[danmillerscotland]

at least the woman recorded another version for the live audience. believe me, if she lipped... it would mean that her singing it actually live would've harmed her voice or her voice was having a bad day. She pulled it off pretty well, be grateful she didn't pull out of the appearance altogether. She obviously took time out of her busy schedule to be there.

[CharlesLMariah]

this is not lipped, u can tell how she sometimes goes low than high like on the cd, So Stop Hating on my hero, I love her, She has worked so hard for her career, SO Back off

[nicevidbro]

Ugh....Im so fed up of you people saying "hater"

Stop that nonsense. The fact that someone does any criticism about someone does not mean that person is "hating". Hating is insulting without a reason. Saying that she is lipping is telling the truth. Now stop being a crazy fanatic lunatic and face the fact that she is not superhuman.

[MoetDior]

ok well stop being so damn critical! how's that!? She doesn't lip much because unlike most of these artists today have no true talent. What does it matter 99.9% she sings every song live, plus her voice is delicate in order to keep it safe she may have to lip sometimes hitting notes like that can take a toll on your voice! so BLEH!

[nicevidbro]

No. She used to sing 99,9% live. These last years shes been lipping a lot, switching from live to backtrack in her harder parts.

[dizzale19]

i am a huge mariah fan and have every1 of her cds but i no as a fan..when she lips it she covers her face when going to the high parts of her performances...She lipped it ....sry but its tru love ya lambs!!

[funster15]

its amazing for a pre recording.

[Jirina74]

Amazing

[ssaturn]

this was pre recorded and she lipped to the track. this isnt live. you fans need to open your ears

[Bongoprettygurl]

WOW those high notes are amazing

[emolucky]

My God... She can't leave me breathless|

[lugfontaine]

????

[hodgrix]

fucking fake tits. she really needs to loose some weight and fast cuz shes on the verge of obesity

[Ginuwinejay]

It's not the studio version but it is pre-recorded. But SO WHAT?! We ALL KNOW THAT SHE CAN SING IT LIVE IF SHE WANTS to. Think about it. If Mariah were to sing HER SONGS live every performance then her career would be a very very short one. She has to save her voice so that she can keep giving it to us. We should be thanking her not criticizing her!

[emmoichoi]

totally agree with you, who can still stay on top after 19 years in Music Biz beside her and madonna

[chef1088]

Celine Dion hasn't stopped working in 28 YEARS!! she's still on top!

[danmillerscotland]

Celine only really sells on her tours now. Its Mariah that is continuing to break records.

[franceska13]

perfect

[redboyj15]

She sounds amazing in this performance...every note came effortlessly...

[lukituchi]

Yea that's how they came if you lip

[RiPcOrDz83]

@redboyj15 That Is Because It's Not Live!!...

[tulip2111]

@redboyj15 its prerecorded

[ChesterLover]

@redboyj15 effortless because there was no effort... she's obviously lip singing

[bixxius]

@ChesterLover exactly

[iiAmitx3]

@ChesterLover only in 1:11 "it's a shame" part was lipped but "to be so euphoric and weak" part was live though. 1:31-1:55 lipped too and 2:09-2:12 (the whistles were live) so not everything was lipped.

[jamie12969]

Goodness !

[mccfan39]

That Was Awesome!

[Munita81]

mariah es la mejor!!!

[biggang19]

what the heck is happening to the audience ¬¬ they didnt even stand for her..

inche raza.. que publico tan aburrido.. nisiquiera se puso de pie.. yo me hubiera vuelto loco..

[Kainosielu]

Maybe because she lipsyncs? I'm not sure, but sounds like that.

[biggang19]

i know.. but i love her though!! xD

[DanielAvilaAGT]

she didn't in this performance, this one is live! its a little different than the studio one

[cga1978]

She's so beautiful here. Mariah why cant you go back to be like this again. Fuck all that HIP HOP bull shit, it just isnt you. :(

[szilardzsargo]

i agree she was much better before

[CaptCoochKicker]

god.. that voice. so fine... god!!!

[Grillorigrillo]

che gran patata

[MariahHeartbreaker]

I love this performer beacuase after this show, mariah came to Tenerife ( my home) to holidays with her exboyfriend Luis Miguel.

Any body have Against All Odds Live in this show?? I have it but in VHS...

Visit my channel everybody...

Bye bye

Mariah God Bless You!!

[llrocks]

Mariah in Spain, wow! I remember this performance. I was like 7 years old.

Pre-recorded vocals, lip-sync, but, IT'S HER VOICE! By the way, love the tank top.

[MelissaxProductionz]

cool :)

i love the tank top too,lol

[madonnolo10]

che graaan voceee!! io l'adoro!!

[Vaan95]

hai ragionissimo! eheh

[babeegurlLISAann]

daaaaaaaaaang

at 213 it looks like the easiest thing in the world hittin them high ass notes...

damn mariah...

ur my inspiration!!!

i'll always love u mimi

♥

[tillygg]

Well, she lip-synced them, which makes it MUCH easier.

[BritneyDSpears]

this isnt lip-syncing you fucking idiot.

[tillygg]

Yes, this performance was pre-recorded. It'as not the album version, but she re-recorded "Heartbreaker" and used it for all performances of the song. Check out the other performances if you don't believe me.

[BritneyDSpears]

Like I said it was still sang live.

[luciia123]

shes definatly not lip synching here

[singingdancing91]

she is... watch other lives of her perfomin this song... it sounds the same... im a fan of mariah, but i have to admit this is lipped... she sings it live on her tours only

[seductivelydangerous]

so what is lipsynch?

dubbed?

mimed?

[INVALIDxXxUSERNAME]

LISTEN TO HOW CLEAR HER VOCALS ARE!

[sexyboi2000]

mariah has no curves

[radguy18]

a true diva

[eviljessie10]

I HATE THIS SONG, but I LOVE MIMI!!!

[brasileno1140]

La quiero mucho soy anamorado de su voz!

LOVE YOU MC

I LOVE YOU MIMI!

THE BEST SING

[emailmanziman]

only the high part she was lip sync. other than that she sing live... this is how technical expert did to support their stars...

[DanielAvilaAGT]

why is iy always "she only lipped the HIGH PART!!!, thats rediculous, cuz why would she do that???? either its her voice, look at celine...she always sounds like the cd version and ppl don't say shi%, WTF, leave mariah alone and put ashley simpson to penalty!

[mailgirlsandiego]

she is SO totally lip syncing on this one. When she "really" sings, she holds her hand over her ear alot.And her eyes are usually closed so she can concentrate more on her vocals..sorry to "break all your hearts" here.

[nykidd1015]

Yea it doesnt really matter that she lipsynchs becuase she always does 100 percent live shows at her tours for her fans thats what really counts. If she sang live all the time she would have no voice left.

[BritneyDSpears]

even though most of this performance was live. regardless if she lipped it at this moment in time it was still recorded live without studio equipment.

[radguy18]

love her high notes!!

[allybeehot123]

i do agree here there was a kick up after this show as she atmitted mimeing on stage .x

[jhossy730]

mariah could never lip sync, her voice is amazing, natural she doesn't need to be fake like other fake singers!!!

[hornyleo1980]

Morons.. that's the only word to describe u people.

Buy some glasses to look closer if u think she is lip syncing

[bobby4500]

poor

lip syncing

[babyface1650]

She is not lip syncing people just listen to the song then this performance they sound really different.

[dannyradar]

noo wait

its 1:05-1:10

[gloomyoutlook]

err, she's SINGING the verses, obviously there's a backing track :S

She's singing over the song.

[dannyradar]

no because if there was a backtrack, then they wouldnt turn off the microphone just for the 10 seconds inbetween verses.

the microphone picked up NOTHING but the "background singers"

plus anyways after that she continues to sing with her mouth close and far away from the mic, but the volume in which its "picking up" doesnt change.

[gloomyoutlook]

hmm, nevermind. you're right really, it's not the same as the album version, but it's pre-recorded because she's singing exactly the same song on other programs. (y)

sides, she hardly ever sings live on TV outside the US.

[dannyradar]

haha yaa

im the king at finding lip syncing performances

..they cant fool meee!

lol

(:

[5Gregallz5]

i meant how is she fat? i know people say camera puts 10lbs on people but they don't on mariah, she's never been fat, i no she's tall but she ain't fat. i love her the way she is

[XxACIDxkissXOxX]

How is she fat?? She's 5'9 so she's pretty tall and can carry her weight extremely well.She is a gorgeous woman with a gorgeous woman...

[misslindsey0236]

you guys know shes lip syncing....

[gloomyoutlook]

it's sooooooo live.

[dannyradar]

umm noooo, shes right

mariah is def lip syncing

..start watching at around 1:10

(:

[handbagz2007]

innit i hate skinny people they luk like there mama dint feed em lol! men like sumthing that they can hold on not snap

[hottsandy]

what is up wid people n being skinny?mariah dus not luk fat here n even if she dus so what being skinny is not sexy!

[orvgg]

She looks really out of shape. I love her but I wish she wasn't quite so fat.

[5Gregallz5]

how does she look out of shape, camera puts

10lbs on people and she's never ever in the history of mariah carey shes never been fat

[orvgg]

You've got to be kidding. Mariah Carey is a well knwon fatso. I love her and her music, but I am realistic and can knowledge that she is a fattie.

[tinkerbellfreak]

she is not fat. omg what is wrong with you.

[cowgirlxx]

I dont think she looks out of shape by any means but I do think that her outfit isnt the most flattering to her shape and thats why people are making these comments

[vimeto21]

am i the only straight guy in this thing. she looks freaking hot. i would freaking break her in half if i get my hands on her.

[cowgirlxx]

im not dissing my mariah i completely agreeing with you

[metalica188]

she looks good here she should try to keep her clothes on more often

[angelotujuh]

this is live... i really idolize her... she's the best! ever!

[KieranGeeYttongs1]

=p~ !

[NelsonY]

Live singing, just like how all her fans love it! Reminds me of high school with this album...

[datebi]

la mejor voz del mundo sin duda

[wrigleyx]

aouuuuuuuuuaaaaaaaou hhhiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii MMmmmmmmmmmmmm nnnnnnnnnnaaaa.....No, i hate R'N'B

[angeladomino]

I love this verson of the song...i luv mariah.....

[maicapadilla]

bellisima y q voz con ese cuerpo serrano vaya preciosidad jiiiiii besitos para sus fans

[Mupenzi]

Help me people, do you know anyone else in this world that hits these high notes like she does?

[FlyFree77]

yes...theres Georgia Brown and Adam Lopez...they both have videos on YouTube

[loicel]

Cuando fue esto? que nunca lo vi por RCTV?

[maicapadilla]

fue en la Gala de la Hispanidad de 1999, creo q en la antigua cadena tele cinco y yo lo vi en su momento y me encanto, pero no como ahora q soy super fan de Mimi jiii

[bloodyarizona]

wow!!! she looks awefully gorgeous in this particular vid O________O'

[sarahjh6]

This is defo not live. Shes pre recorded it. But she still sounds good. And looks amazing in what shes wearing.

[whosdiskid]

i always wanted to kno, wheneva she hits those beautiful high notes, y does she cover the ear, so she dont hurt her ears?

she does that so she can hear the note and keep it on key. she blocks out the outside noise and listens to the high note.