Thomas and the Magic Railroad Review P1

[MrILikeBaboons]

This movie would have been so much better if they had included P.T. Boomer.

[legonatter105]

do u know were i can find the full movie to watch cuz i think the movie is great

[legonatter105]

i cant beleive the thomas we have now its all digital, wtf its not soposed to be digital

[optimegatrongodzilla]

i know that WWE uses this song, but what's it called?

[TsoLan1]

I don't know why but I laughed out loud at 6:08 when you introduced Patch as "another useless character"

[Multiheatfan3]

I like it at 2:51

[13LLR]

James and Percy sound like robots.

[thomasfan93]

@TheThomastank1 Oh

[MrConductorFan1406]

From 2:11 to 2:22, where'd you find that pic?

[thomasfan93]

Was this your first Toon Critic Review?

[turtlesandthomas]

well, this is better than anything thomas they make today .

[ThomasPercyandToby2]

@turtlesandthomas *laughs* Yeah, right. At least the series these days has different versions for different countries while British fans had to suffer a British icon being fully targeted to an American audience.

I have nothing against Americans, but Thomas was British and it should have always stayed that way.

[optimegatrongodzilla]

@turtlesandthomas yeah, why did they suddenly go to cgi? and crappy cgi at that?! even so, i still want to see the more recent thomas movies. i loved thomas when i was little and i watched both thomas the tank engine and shining time station on nick jr. i also loved theodore tugboat.

[MrComedy01]

James, Gordon and Henry disliked this video XD

[captainofthetitanic]

wasnt sodor in europe and shining time in the US?

[leothelion19]

@captainofthetitanic sodor was a island so I dunno

[JamesandSpike]

@captainofthetitanic bingo. 

[meatballguy1]

8:58 Pretend that the ball is his head and then you'll know why he got to do this movie.

[spiderlost9]

how come edward isn't in this movie?

[dominoesandtin]

Peter Fonda, Lightnen UP!!!!!

[axeinthehead14]

i couldnt agree more. i loved it when i was little cant believe it now. love the whole "ill be raping your memories now."

[SilverHyozanryu]

did you ever watch the British dub of the show ? Im not saying this cause im British but I think its alot better than the American Dub

[TheUnknownAvenger]

@SilverHyozanryu I may be American, but I prefer the British version. It's a whole lot better in my opinion compared to the American.

[racecarboy9425]

at first i didn't care about all the bad stuff when i was 5 but now i see all this crappy stuff and my first thing i have a problem with is gordon i mean what the fuck did they do to his voice george carlin should have done his voice

[paguy42]

I want to punch you in te face. This is one of my favorite movies of all time. Yes the human actors aren't good, and yes the cinametography is bad, but it is a children's movie! They don't care about good actors and special effects! The message is still amazing

[thomastransformer]

the only thing that didnt really work out for this movie is that it was a lil more focused on the people and lil less on the trains. other than that it was a good movie

[TheThomasandedward]

uuuhh do you likr cgi or the real moldes

[games4356]

@cooljoemaz Thanks. :)

[milkygoodness]

To me, and many others I would guess, the worst thing about this movie is its wasted potential. It could have been wonderful if they'd kept to their original ideas.

[meatballguy1]

8:55 Hardy har har.

[games4356]

did this movie come out in 2000?

[UnknownThomasFan30]

The thing of it is, is how many times does a movie like this get so fucked up by removing practically all good quality to this movie? none. Edward, Goeorge, Duck, Oliver, Diesel, and others and P.T Boomer are absent. Plus, Lily's narration, and how it all worked and everything makes the movie great! But they messed it up.

[Thomasmemoryscentral]

@UnknownThomasFan30 Another thing I recently discovered is why the British voice actors got removed. Thinking back to how Thomas has US and UK Dubs, why not leave the UK voicers like Angelis in a British dub and the US voicers like Roman in an American dub? At least the English would be satisfied that Michael and John Bellis got their lines in.

[SonicBonjoviFan]

shamefully i was one of the kiddies who gave into the merchandising of this film ^_^'

[thecrazyevilleaf]

WTF y is an adult reviewing this? No one cares!!!!!

[thomasfan1993]

@thecrazyevilleaf Umm. He's not an adult, he's a teenager I:(

[jellywillreturn]

Few people can review in the style of the Nostalgia Critic and succeed. You have my respect.

[jm0364]

Say what you like I still like this movie when I was a kid and still do so "mmph !!!" >:(

[ZeroGal5]

Thomas was major part of me and my brother's life. like you we both watched it on t.v. every morning. it sounds dumb, but i was ashamed to have red hair when i was little and was made fun of. James gave me alot of self pride and i was soon proud to have red hair like James' paint, so he's always been my fav, even to this day! i was very happy when the movie first came out, but James does sound like a child. i like his current CGI (UK) voice. i wish the original Magic Rail Road would be released.

[supergodzilla12]

i might review this myself. it SUCKS. awesome review, even though i never like thomas.

[andersinnevada]

the only thing I didnt like about the movie was percy and james voices. they sounded like girls. well james sounded ok but I just dont like percys voice.Also wheres edward hes a main character too!

[FlameAmigo619]

I said I WANTED to. But I never did.

[TenCents01]

Dude if you actually read the details left out on SiF, you would be amazed how much more sense the story made. It was more about Shining Time for the most part, but it was not riddled with as many plotholes.

[FlameAmigo619]

I understand, but i never got around to that.

[thebladezmanII]

Indeed, one trace of that is even clear in the preview you used for it (PT Boomer falling off the viaduct with D10

[MrDarkcatify]

@FlameAmigo619 Thanks for review it because i hate this fuckin movie!!

[meatballguy1]

@FlameAmigo619 What actually made you want to do TATMR?

[UnknownThomasFan30]

@TenCents01 Thats no excuse though, they released it like that, he should review the way it was released.

[darthwinsor]

am i the only one who saw d10s driver fall off when he fell off the viaduct?

[bambloop]

@darthwinsor it wasent dieasel 10s driver its pt bommer

[Snotrod191]

its not that bad

[tejojo]

I also wonder why Alec Baldwin went from zero to hero.

[freddykrugerfan]

i wonder y he did this movie

[FlameAmigo619]

Money, money, money.

[freddykrugerfan]

surly tho when he read the script he thought it was bad

[thebladezmanII]

Theyve gawta have more Monay!

[Captstar2]

He was the US narrator at the time and so he was cast as director.

[freddykrugerfan]

but again i point out it had a bad script

[Captstar2]

The original was better from what I heard until they butchered it.

[freddykrugerfan]

the directer should release a directers addition of the film