hey u dont you know ys looted 5 lakshs crores in just 5 years y dont u investigate on jagan binami chanels like ntv tv 5 sakshi and zee 24 hours?cbn isr is the one who developed ap it is proved by srikrishna committe also ,,that is tdp and its party which developed ap
3 Billion humans earn less than $2aday, half the world has no toilet access.50%of the worlds money belongs to 500 humans.There will be poverty as long as workers are not given the control and ownership over their production.As long as Corporate owners Board Members capitalist bosses autocratically manage the distribution of production and profits, workers in all countries will be extorted of how much capital their labor actually produces.Long Live Socialist☭ Revolution!
He speaks the truth and his bluntness hurts.... what are the young (educated) politicians doing? What is the media doing? Responsible news channels should have people like him on the panels rather than the same, biased, ineffective jokers? I appreciate NDTV for having aired the documentary covering the Vidharba farmers... but how come I have not seen ANY debate which included Mr. Sainath? Has he been included in the award winning "we the people" His no nonsense talk gets staight to your heart
I love this guy. I wish we had more like him. Why isn't he there in every youth forum, why doesn't television invite him instead of the stooges who come to comment on every topic? They are afraid I guess.. very afraid. His no nonsense talk would unmask them. :)
I love this guy. I wish we had more like him. Why isn't he there in every youth forum, why doesn't television invite him instead of the stooges who come to comment on every topic? They are afraid I guess.. very afraid. His no nonsense talk would unmask them. :)
Well said Mr. Sainath, media is totally controlled by the establishment in this country... and then people also speaks the language of this mainstream media, now we have reached the stage in which we can't even use any of their news as references. That's what happens in capitalism, capital controls everything let it be the fourth pillar of society..!
Once FDI was permitted in media, foreign media tied up with an Indian partner to run the show nothing INDIAN.It's all for the media stakeholders.INDIANS have forgotten the meaning of INDEPENDENCE.Except for the fact that politicians are of Indian origin (which in itself is not completely true) we are fully dependent on the Western world for everything from printing our own CURRENCY to getting the price for our products & produce to getting employment.None of this can be called INDIAN MEDIA.
India's media is owned by the British and Americans. Murdoch even got a cricket team in India (rajastan royals)...kinda sick don't u think. Indian people have lost their minds in giving the ruling elite and the western powers carte blanch in India. Get out in the street and hang all politicians and their masters so the people of India can get rid of this new slavery - globalism.
@shailendersain people of india are the politicians and market owners. Its only a corrupt society that will tolerate corrupt people at the top. An auto guy dumps the meter and charges you double if your not sure, the shopkeeper charges you twice if your new and everyone is willing to cheat you if your not aware. Where is there not corruption in this country? Poverty breeds corruption out of desperation. The only place there is some sanity is the super markets that charge at a fixed price.
@KarthikSoun Such developments need to come top-down and not bottom-up. I understand that you think that the Indian society is immense corrupted but please understand that the population is only doing so because their 'leaders' aren't giving the right message. And note that elitist & politicians by their followed agenda only get the people they deserve. So now the circle is closed. Hope u understand my grammar. Peace
@shailendersain I agree to a certain extent! I feel the congress party is to cowardly to enforce anything. When i was 22 i thought i knew everything and how to do it but right now after extensively reading and researching i really dont know how an welfare state is going to emerge in India. There seriously is no one in the horizon who thinks like that. With ppl like Mayawathi and lalu we cant hope much either.Its tragic to see all this ignorance and pain in this country.
@KarthikSoun thats b/c your leaders and industrialist are handpicked by AngloAmerican elitist. British Empire never really left, they still pull all the strings. Not only Congress but all other political party's aim is just to uphold the status quo and enrich themselves. Welfare state is dead. I live in The Netherlands and right know they are taring it down with all means.Hospitals got immense waiting lists, workers pensions are not covered, schools are a joke, police is undermanned and so on.
@shailendersain So your not indian? I can see that the west pulls most of the economic strings but how do they hand pick our leaders!! Thats a total misstatement. The netherlands is as close as it comes to haveing an welfare state. I dont agree that netherlands is screwed up thats as much humans can do materially after that its left to us as individuals to choose a path.
@KarthikSoun Im Indian.Check the link I send you.One of the first is the link of the U S's International Visitors Leaderships Programs.All Indian PM's where handpicked decades ago trough this program and carefully brought to their positions. On the list you'll find the todays PM's of pretty much the entire world. I live in Holland and I tell you, the system is collapsing. I'm not gonna have the same benefits of the generation(s) before me while I'm being taxed double to keep this system alive.
@shailendersain Was i supposed to go through all those links? What do you think i am a robot? A couple of zeitgest videos dont mean anything, zeitgest is full of conspiracy theories but thats not to say they are completely wrong but half truth is still false. If the future PMs are handpicked then why dont you tell me who will be next? The system is not collapsing a lot of people stands to gain a lot so they wont let it to collapse. Your just sounding paranoid.
we need leaders who have risen from grass root level, who can raise the gauntlet against the ones who are in politics to appease the corporates. clearly media around the world has a large role to enable people through disseminating content without bias and with comprehension. but if economics doesn't support, ranting like this won't lead them to.
If the performance of India for 5 decades + this 5 yrs are of any reference to go by, NDA govt was indeed a golden period of cleaning the mess created by congress.
@martiantourist fuck off you ignorant idiot, NDA directly messed up education by putting brainwashing hindutva stuff and blatant historical lies in fucking school textbooks. It created the worst market for poor people and farmers, it suppressed free flow of information and ran forced advertisements glorifying itself on TV. Learn a few things before you spew some shit out of your sewer-mouth
@martiantourist I agree with you ... but the context of this video is to check the Media .. Plzz look at the high point - "70% of teh population dont make up to have anything relevant for teh news"
I think P. Sainath is making all great relevant points. I do not think that he is pessimistic, he is uttering the truth and many of the people cannot digest truth. He is not a hypocrite, I think most of us are hypocrites!! And the Indian media is a big bitch, just like the US media. Face it guys. India shining is an illusion. It doesn't matter whether a country is shining or not until all its people live in harmony with each other as truly helpful, social human beings.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this faggot is expecting too much. By reporting the interiors of india, does not mean the poverty will be reduced. People like this faggot and other communist leaders talk in lenghts about poverty, but when some international company tries to set up its company in rural areas-what these faggots do? oppose it !!If there is no poor people, because of economic growth, communists would become jobless like this faggot on the screen !!
You do have avalid point that people like Arundhati Roy will become jobless if there is progress. But people like Sainath do a good job on reporting urban distress and ensuring fruits of growth are equitably shared. you may want to read works of Jean Dreze who has written excellent material supporting sainath. Dreze has done that work with Amartya Sen- one of the greatest economist of our times. as per your criticism of communists- u r right. these commnuists lick the feet of chinese
To kashsoldier: I do not think you understand what is trying to say at all. You get 0/10 marks- and a F grade. Please clear your basics and post back sensibly.
rubbish. he is not advocating communism. read the book - globalization and its discontents - by nobel laureate in econ. saintah is merely trying to wake up people who are on india shining bandwagon.
This is a Pessimistic creature nd is Quite Disgusting.
I have red alot of his artricles in The Hindu. He even visited my college, MCC and this one drives A Car , stays in AC Rooms and liesurely criticizes what he enjoys.
i suspect u havent gotten his point. he is not against capitalism. he is just trying to say that we must not forget the poor. he is just trying to say that india is shining only for the few - like u and me . but it is not for the rural poor. he is not saying taht if u stop driving car and ac , the poor will automatically become rich. he is trying to reveal dark underbely of poverty. i suspect u must have mistaken him for other pseudosecularist in ' the hindu'. btw some or videos are great. peace
good point. communism is falied ideology which will make everyone poor. no questions. it is likely that sainath is a closet communist. but he does have apoint when he says that we must be cognizant of real issues. i suggest u read '' globalization and its discontents' by nobel prize winning economist Joseph Stiglitz. finally, its good to be optimistics. we must all be optimistic, but clearly not blind to relaity taht stares us in teh face. the reality alas is very harsh
Actually a Chinese leader in the communist party said this in the 1970s. "Communism does not mean everyone should be equally poor." The deal with Chinese communism was that at this point well in the 1950s the average chinese person had a high life expectancy. Anyway back to the point. Chinese tend to have the stereotype that they will sell you anything. ITs always been like that. Even when communism took over. Communism by gov't but capitalism for the economy is how they work.
you do know capitalism is a failed idea. Pure capitalism that is. That's why it doesn't exist, and the US has the markets that closer reflect pure capitalism but even the US doesn't have it because they know it will hurt the society.
This has been flagged as spam show
hey u dont you know ys looted 5 lakshs crores in just 5 years y dont u investigate on jagan binami chanels like ntv tv 5 sakshi and zee 24 hours?cbn isr is the one who developed ap it is proved by srikrishna committe also ,,that is tdp and its party which developed ap
rajkumar1111ify 1 week ago
indian poverty is very pathetic and wht common public can do, it is very pathetic,,
1966singh 2 months ago
india is exploding because of wrong policies,,india is going bankrupt,and60 crore is going to die because they have not educated,,
1966singh 2 months ago
3 Billion humans earn less than $2aday, half the world has no toilet access.50%of the worlds money belongs to 500 humans.There will be poverty as long as workers are not given the control and ownership over their production.As long as Corporate owners Board Members capitalist bosses autocratically manage the distribution of production and profits, workers in all countries will be extorted of how much capital their labor actually produces.Long Live Socialist☭ Revolution!
noprofitmaximierung 3 months ago
THEIR ARE VERY FEW GOOD JOURNALIST IN SOUTH ASIA ONE BEING NAZAM SETHI FROM PAKISTAN AND P SAINATH FROM INDIA.
REST ARE BOLLYWOOD ITEM NUMBERS.
visi365 7 months ago
were is accountabality and ethics look what happen to murdoch and its cronies shut for ever and ndtv and barkha dutt are still alive.
INDIA IS DEMOCRACY IN NAME ONLY NOT LIKE WEST.
visi365 7 months ago
He speaks the truth and his bluntness hurts.... what are the young (educated) politicians doing? What is the media doing? Responsible news channels should have people like him on the panels rather than the same, biased, ineffective jokers? I appreciate NDTV for having aired the documentary covering the Vidharba farmers... but how come I have not seen ANY debate which included Mr. Sainath? Has he been included in the award winning "we the people" His no nonsense talk gets staight to your heart
ushvenk 7 months ago
I love this guy. I wish we had more like him. Why isn't he there in every youth forum, why doesn't television invite him instead of the stooges who come to comment on every topic? They are afraid I guess.. very afraid. His no nonsense talk would unmask them. :)
ushapan 7 months ago
I love this guy. I wish we had more like him. Why isn't he there in every youth forum, why doesn't television invite him instead of the stooges who come to comment on every topic? They are afraid I guess.. very afraid. His no nonsense talk would unmask them. :)
ushapan 7 months ago
It's BS.
India didn't reject BJP+ or it's IS campaign. It got 200+ seats, despite 5 decades of un-defeatable Dynasty rule.
It was a hung verdict, in favour of NDA for god sakes
mukkodan 10 months ago
Well said Mr. Sainath, media is totally controlled by the establishment in this country... and then people also speaks the language of this mainstream media, now we have reached the stage in which we can't even use any of their news as references. That's what happens in capitalism, capital controls everything let it be the fourth pillar of society..!
paritoshvagabond 10 months ago
ndtv and ibn is a joke hand of congress party mouth piece
visi365 1 year ago 2
@visi365 its with with all the channel...some or the other are buying the news for them self...u r right I have seeing such baised news...
danger963 1 year ago
@visi365 Fantastically said. Its high that they start 'reporting' rather than taking sides.
dipti2379 8 months ago
worth watching....totally blunt!!
kshitijgupta1 1 year ago
Only great institutions like The Hindu and P Sainath can uphold dignity in journalism and cover poverty
Napoleon476 1 year ago
Only great institutions like The Hindu and P Sainath can uphold dignity in journalism
Napoleon476 1 year ago
India is not India anymore guys. Wheres the original language? Screw the Media.
It's all English!
makemap 1 year ago
Great one. More Indians should watch this.
thirunagar 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@thirunagar No, I think everyone should watch this.
khanriza 1 year ago
Once FDI was permitted in media, foreign media tied up with an Indian partner to run the show nothing INDIAN.It's all for the media stakeholders.INDIANS have forgotten the meaning of INDEPENDENCE.Except for the fact that politicians are of Indian origin (which in itself is not completely true) we are fully dependent on the Western world for everything from printing our own CURRENCY to getting the price for our products & produce to getting employment.None of this can be called INDIAN MEDIA.
kpganesh 1 year ago
We'd be the fourth largest anything in the world... ☑
rahidelvi 1 year ago
India's media is owned by the British and Americans. Murdoch even got a cricket team in India (rajastan royals)...kinda sick don't u think. Indian people have lost their minds in giving the ruling elite and the western powers carte blanch in India. Get out in the street and hang all politicians and their masters so the people of India can get rid of this new slavery - globalism.
shailendersain 2 years ago 5
@shailendersain people of india are the politicians and market owners. Its only a corrupt society that will tolerate corrupt people at the top. An auto guy dumps the meter and charges you double if your not sure, the shopkeeper charges you twice if your new and everyone is willing to cheat you if your not aware. Where is there not corruption in this country? Poverty breeds corruption out of desperation. The only place there is some sanity is the super markets that charge at a fixed price.
KarthikSoun 1 year ago
@KarthikSoun Such developments need to come top-down and not bottom-up. I understand that you think that the Indian society is immense corrupted but please understand that the population is only doing so because their 'leaders' aren't giving the right message. And note that elitist & politicians by their followed agenda only get the people they deserve. So now the circle is closed. Hope u understand my grammar. Peace
shailendersain 1 year ago
@shailendersain I agree to a certain extent! I feel the congress party is to cowardly to enforce anything. When i was 22 i thought i knew everything and how to do it but right now after extensively reading and researching i really dont know how an welfare state is going to emerge in India. There seriously is no one in the horizon who thinks like that. With ppl like Mayawathi and lalu we cant hope much either.Its tragic to see all this ignorance and pain in this country.
KarthikSoun 1 year ago
@KarthikSoun thats b/c your leaders and industrialist are handpicked by AngloAmerican elitist. British Empire never really left, they still pull all the strings. Not only Congress but all other political party's aim is just to uphold the status quo and enrich themselves. Welfare state is dead. I live in The Netherlands and right know they are taring it down with all means.Hospitals got immense waiting lists, workers pensions are not covered, schools are a joke, police is undermanned and so on.
shailendersain 1 year ago
@shailendersain So your not indian? I can see that the west pulls most of the economic strings but how do they hand pick our leaders!! Thats a total misstatement. The netherlands is as close as it comes to haveing an welfare state. I dont agree that netherlands is screwed up thats as much humans can do materially after that its left to us as individuals to choose a path.
KarthikSoun 1 year ago
@KarthikSoun Im Indian.Check the link I send you.One of the first is the link of the U S's International Visitors Leaderships Programs.All Indian PM's where handpicked decades ago trough this program and carefully brought to their positions. On the list you'll find the todays PM's of pretty much the entire world. I live in Holland and I tell you, the system is collapsing. I'm not gonna have the same benefits of the generation(s) before me while I'm being taxed double to keep this system alive.
shailendersain 1 year ago
@shailendersain Was i supposed to go through all those links? What do you think i am a robot? A couple of zeitgest videos dont mean anything, zeitgest is full of conspiracy theories but thats not to say they are completely wrong but half truth is still false. If the future PMs are handpicked then why dont you tell me who will be next? The system is not collapsing a lot of people stands to gain a lot so they wont let it to collapse. Your just sounding paranoid.
KarthikSoun 1 year ago
@shailendersain Moreover europe does tax a lot thats there system of ensuring wealth distribution. What you take from the society cant be all yours.
KarthikSoun 1 year ago
This man gets my respect
ednan9 2 years ago
Comment removed
KHANONEONE 2 years ago
Nice work. keep it up. dvdf
EdgardoJustice 2 years ago
Brilliant interview.
roopesh1977 2 years ago 6
we need leaders who have risen from grass root level, who can raise the gauntlet against the ones who are in politics to appease the corporates. clearly media around the world has a large role to enable people through disseminating content without bias and with comprehension. but if economics doesn't support, ranting like this won't lead them to.
abhiglad 2 years ago
If the performance of India for 5 decades + this 5 yrs are of any reference to go by, NDA govt was indeed a golden period of cleaning the mess created by congress.
martiantourist 3 years ago 3
Depends upon "golden period" for who? May be top two percent of India.
pktubes 3 years ago 13
NDA's was a golden period for the poor and hapless gujarati muslims indeed !
ipfcsnobs 2 years ago
@martiantourist fuck off you ignorant idiot, NDA directly messed up education by putting brainwashing hindutva stuff and blatant historical lies in fucking school textbooks. It created the worst market for poor people and farmers, it suppressed free flow of information and ran forced advertisements glorifying itself on TV. Learn a few things before you spew some shit out of your sewer-mouth
prabhatpalpal 7 months ago
@martiantourist I agree with you ... but the context of this video is to check the Media .. Plzz look at the high point - "70% of teh population dont make up to have anything relevant for teh news"
jayant250888 6 months ago
I think P. Sainath is making all great relevant points. I do not think that he is pessimistic, he is uttering the truth and many of the people cannot digest truth. He is not a hypocrite, I think most of us are hypocrites!! And the Indian media is a big bitch, just like the US media. Face it guys. India shining is an illusion. It doesn't matter whether a country is shining or not until all its people live in harmony with each other as truly helpful, social human beings.
swamink1 3 years ago 45
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this faggot is expecting too much. By reporting the interiors of india, does not mean the poverty will be reduced. People like this faggot and other communist leaders talk in lenghts about poverty, but when some international company tries to set up its company in rural areas-what these faggots do? oppose it !!If there is no poor people, because of economic growth, communists would become jobless like this faggot on the screen !!
kashsoldier 3 years ago
You do have avalid point that people like Arundhati Roy will become jobless if there is progress. But people like Sainath do a good job on reporting urban distress and ensuring fruits of growth are equitably shared. you may want to read works of Jean Dreze who has written excellent material supporting sainath. Dreze has done that work with Amartya Sen- one of the greatest economist of our times. as per your criticism of communists- u r right. these commnuists lick the feet of chinese
muktamona 3 years ago
Try to understand the point he is trying to make.
Please read book "The Rise of Disaster Capitalism" by Naomi Klein.
luvpeaceandjustice 3 years ago 4
To kashsoldier: I do not think you understand what is trying to say at all. You get 0/10 marks- and a F grade. Please clear your basics and post back sensibly.
swamink1 3 years ago 21
@kashsoldier
i totally agree with you....you have understood the truth my firend...you will get peace.
ujjwalsaha1980 1 year ago
marxist r d ones who manupulated with indian history go n check urself...jnu n all ncert fucking all r hand in glove..need of hour unbiased media ...
sandysss791 3 years ago
He is a communist.
i.e., He is a lobbying for a failed ideology
Rajofyourheart 3 years ago
rubbish. he is not advocating communism. read the book - globalization and its discontents - by nobel laureate in econ. saintah is merely trying to wake up people who are on india shining bandwagon.
muktamona 3 years ago
Bull Shit.
This is a Pessimistic creature nd is Quite Disgusting.
I have red alot of his artricles in The Hindu. He even visited my college, MCC and this one drives A Car , stays in AC Rooms and liesurely criticizes what he enjoys.
He is a complete Hypocrite.
Rajofyourheart 3 years ago
i suspect u havent gotten his point. he is not against capitalism. he is just trying to say that we must not forget the poor. he is just trying to say that india is shining only for the few - like u and me . but it is not for the rural poor. he is not saying taht if u stop driving car and ac , the poor will automatically become rich. he is trying to reveal dark underbely of poverty. i suspect u must have mistaken him for other pseudosecularist in ' the hindu'. btw some or videos are great. peace
muktamona 3 years ago
But, He is a Red Card Holder.
Rajofyourheart 3 years ago
What bullshit? What is quite disgusting? Which part, which point do you have objection?
roopesh1977 2 years ago
those who are optimistic atleast don't want people to be poor like the communists !!
kashsoldier 3 years ago
good point. communism is falied ideology which will make everyone poor. no questions. it is likely that sainath is a closet communist. but he does have apoint when he says that we must be cognizant of real issues. i suggest u read '' globalization and its discontents' by nobel prize winning economist Joseph Stiglitz. finally, its good to be optimistics. we must all be optimistic, but clearly not blind to relaity taht stares us in teh face. the reality alas is very harsh
muktamona 3 years ago
Actually a Chinese leader in the communist party said this in the 1970s. "Communism does not mean everyone should be equally poor." The deal with Chinese communism was that at this point well in the 1950s the average chinese person had a high life expectancy. Anyway back to the point. Chinese tend to have the stereotype that they will sell you anything. ITs always been like that. Even when communism took over. Communism by gov't but capitalism for the economy is how they work.
lordblazer 3 years ago
you do know capitalism is a failed idea. Pure capitalism that is. That's why it doesn't exist, and the US has the markets that closer reflect pure capitalism but even the US doesn't have it because they know it will hurt the society.
lordblazer 3 years ago
he is awesome
bha1210 3 years ago 3
This man is my hero...i wish he was my uncleji.
jumpnjza2 3 years ago 2