Beyonce Love On Top Live VS Lady Gaga You And I Edge Of Glory End Of Time VMAS 2012 VMA

[NInjaEmoPandaDanii]

thats like comparing rick ross to 30 seconds to mars... wtf?

[makeupfromvictoria]

Okayy Lady Gaga is my idol and inspiration...Right here she wasn't singing...I think this was just about the dancing at this time in the performance...They are both crazily talented, just in different ways. They are two of my favorite artist ever! I really can't pick but I just love gaga so much so....LADY GAGA<3

[ked911]

gaga has more talent in her little finger than thunderthighs has in her big butt

[RawrImAPijin]

rihanna.

[bobocutie11]

well i vote 4 Beyonce but you cant do that their best friends so their the same

[bobocutie11]

well i vote 4 beyonce but yu cant do dhat their best friends so their dha same

[chagaspar]

REALLY? You made a comparison between Beyonce and Lady Gaga? C'mon mannnn.... I can't believe this!

[xXxTuga97xXx]

That poor barbie doll head

[xSweetLollipopxD]

BEYONCE THE BEST

BEYONCE BEYOCE!!!!!!!

[tweetiiful]

beyonce duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

[sonricsxalapa]

B

E

Y

O

N

C

E

[blackmigmag]

Beyoncé is a real great artist. Lady gaga is just a great marketing product.

[goldenangel1001]

i love them BOTH!

[clararocks900]

Everyone I know is getting pregnat......,.. Weird..

[Curk00]

Beyonce is sex. 

[softballgurl122]

BEYONCE ALL THE WAY. shes amazing and beautiful. shes just outstanding love her. i love gaga to but gotta say beyonce

[lovelyhunniee]

lady gaga? she was around for what? 4 or so years? i dont care enough to remember....beyonce...we GREW UP watching her. youd be crazy to think lady gaga is better.

[mjbarcelon94]

beyonceeeeeeeeeee



[mjbarcelon94]

beyonceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee



[FoxPreShowLive]

▼ Click My Channel Name For More Incredible Videos For You To See! ◄

[SarahBCampbell]

not sure i was distracted by how absolutely gorgeous Beyonce looks in that dress!

[baliinki]

BEYONCE.BEYONCE.BEYONCE.BEYONC­E.BEYONCE.!!!!

[MrsCathyPotter]

Beyonce is talent.

[MrsCathyPotter]

Beyonce is queen.

[MrsCathyPotter]

Beyonce is Queen.

[poloking979]

Beyonce

[SazM16]

Now that is talent when you can sing live like that, don't know any other female artist except frm mariah carey that can do this, GO ON BEYONCE! x

[Slizzy77]

sorry beyonce , LADY GAGA !!!!

[iiliketoolaugh]

her hairs as bad as her lip syncing..

[emotori1980]

Gaga is gonna win cause she a whore. But I vpte Beyonce she beautiful.

[leahmacneil]

If I were a boy has to be the worst song I've ever heard. Nothing against Beyonce...but fuck...it's awful.

[123456domdon]

lady gaga did not lip sync her song... watch her lips move to the words.... if she did lip sync then she did an absolutely amazing job!!!

[thedozzz1]

Beyonce!!! Isnt that obvious?

[maepotz03]

beyonce

[momonpnone]

prego wins hands down!!!!!!!

[Vediboi888]

gaga is horrible live 

[YourAddictionx15]

BEYONCE

[CorpralCordaro]

gaga. gaga all the way

[0RedTree0]

damn you guys are heartless, i dance and the moves Gaga are doing are quick and tiring. who the heck can sing during that?? Actually, it's very difficult to sing from your diaphragm while doing any kind of dance.

[secretmc2011]

beyoooooooooooooonce!!!!

[Manoronedeaths]

Im just into the weirdness of people so gaga makes me gaga >:)

[RonnieJordan01]

Beyonce :).

[MateusOnly]

Beyoncé dá aula pra Gaga ;-)

[Famfriass]

Beyonce takes her career seriously.

[anitam202]

♥ beyonce

[ARTHURHOFMAN]

Lipsync ánd forced dancing, you would think she would master one if she left another. Overrated. I wish her the best though. She’s trying.

[Djolivas18]

Beyonce

[missteena84]

i love beyonce...

[missteena84]

i like Beyonce most..

[Shirleyorangedream]

LMFAO SHE RUBBED THE BARBIE'S HEAD ON HER VJ

[Sabrina12312]

Beyonce. Is that even a question?

[yourangeltonight]

Beyonce actually sang her song, Gaga had to Lip Sync her song .There is nothing to compare. Beyonce is a true entertainer and there is no one like her because Legends are born and singers are taught to follow.

[TKOuellet]

@yourangeltonight GaGa does not lip sync, have you even heard You and I or Edge of Glory? she has raw talent, shes a profesional piano player, dancer, singer, she's had more hits in a year than beyonce has ever, I love Beyonce, and I absolutely love GaGa, and I'm not going to compare them, but Lady GaGa has talent, whether you refuse to admit it or not, she's not famous for her outfits. If you saw her performance at the VMAs you can tell she actually sings, and she's absolutely phenominal.

[VannaT08]

@yourangeltonight Lady Gaga does NOT lip sync, pffft. Beyonce sings, but so does Gaga. Both great artists, but Gaga is unique. LITTLE MONSTERS LIKE THIS!

[BearsAndUmbrellas]

I love both... oh so much. but i will always love gaga the most. The person who made this video doesnt realize how these two gals and adele are the only people with real talent now-a-days. Put kesha up there then we'd have an obvious loser.

[xoxCindellaaaCullen]

beyonce! hands down!

[renesmecullen212]

lady gaga!

[kidd2xclusive]

Beyonce relies on her god given talent, her VOICE! I love Gaga but come on, a Queen doesn't need gimmicks. Gaga loves Bey, & Bey loves Gaga, please don't get it twisted.

[dzonikarter]

i am white boy from europe but black girls are the most beautiful girls on planet.no one can not compare with cute black girl.big loooove for black girls

[Kramz1231]

@makemoneyhere Oh that must be why Beyonce couldn't wait to work with Gaga. Class couldn't just wait to work with "trash."

[dzonikarter]

i am white boy from europe but black girls are the most beautiful girls on planet.no one can not compare with cute black girl.big loooove for black girls

[QueenSnookie2]

beyonce can sing soo well, to be able to hit those notes and still get higher... AMAZING!

[butterflypixietrix]

Lady Gaga is better because she knows how to be a performer and the crowd is jumping and going wild to see her perform!!

[butterflypixietrix]

Lady Gaga is better because she knows how to be a performer and the crowd is jumping and going wild to see her perform!!

[ThrillamuhNillazBacK]

this video doesn't make for a good comparison. They are both great performers, but each of have their unique way of going about it. There are better live performances that will help you choose who is better at Live Performances

[pinkyale89]

Woooow Beyonce voyce! Great! I love her ^_^ She's my idol!

[nicelad72]

Sorry about length of previous post, someone superglued the talking stick to my fingers.

[nicelad72]

And breathe. As you have got me here under false pretences, (next stop genuine Love on Top video), I will add my 2 bob's worth (British slang for give my opinion). Question is about best performer, these artists are 2 very different performers, who both excel in their art. I love Beyonce primarily for her amazing voice, her pitch control and clarity are amazing. Her dancing, bloody hell, the comments on this thread amaze me, examples; Single Ladies official video & Run the World live at Billboa

[pluggingM]

LADY GAGAAAA PERFORMER & BEST LYRICS!

beyonce singer & beauty

[PinaColada4645]

I don't understand why people need to find the need to compare. They are both great performers and special in their own way.

[nicelad72]

Just a thought. How about, now this is a wild, out of the blue idea, how about labelling the video with the correct track names. Some people might suggest you used both artists latest release titles to get more hits. Some people may think that, I couldn't.....Or could I. Hmmm

[lobbazalee]

Gaga does not even compare to Beyonce. That is like comparing Britney Spears and Beyonce.

[mskeyla100]

wow beyonce performance gave me chills....

[amyxhunni]

There both such good artists. But beyonce has the better voice and lady gaga is a better performer/entertainer. I prefer lady gagas songs and style.

[finfin233]

beyonce won for  sure lady gaga get some people to make you sing beter

[Raoulirshan]

Duhh Beyonce!

[narutorox77]

Beyonce :D

[Marquisrose15]

Beyonce

[kaykayboopa]

Beyonce to the fullest!

[lwd22]

freaking fucking fake Madonna... xD

[MrCatwoman5]

l like Beyonce more then gaga

[MrCatwoman5]

l like Beyonce more then gaga

[MrCatwoman5]

l like beyonce more then gaga

[mrzcookielover]

BEYONCE all da way

[kent80082006]

she sounded a bit like rihanna here

[jathomas0910]

i would love to see them perform telephone together

[auraxliveyourlife]

Beyonce.

[courtneygirly95]

Beyonce is the coolest and prettiest!! Freakin love her dress!!!

[courtneygirly95]

Beyonce is the coolest and prettiest!! Freakin love her dress!!!

[Whiteloverish]

Beyonce rocks :P

[fransiscaification]

beyonce...for sure!!!

[MegaGirlGaGa]

Lady GaGa and Beyonce are the best! But i like GaGa just a little more. But Beyonce comes a very, very, very, very, very close second!

[MegaGirlGaGa]

Lady GaGa and Beyonce are the best! But i like GaGa just a little more. But Beyonce comes a very, very, very, very, very, very close second!

[MegaGirlGaGa]

Lady GaGa and Beyonce are the best! But i like GaGa just a little more. But Beyonce comes a very, very, very, very, very, very, very close second!

[moonshendog]

how orange are the dancers?

[krakibhaider]

Beyonce with no doubt.

[miihantah1]

BEYONCE.period.

[tanealove15]

BEYONCE!!! Gaga is aight but beyonce is mre ma style

[Mikkishayeshayeb]

Beyonce is amazing. (: I love her music soo much

[Cosholic]

beyonce is the queen

[UnCommonCollin]

you kinda short handed both of them ! this isnt right cuaz while dancing beyonce sounds different ! and gaga sounds different w/ just her piano too ! get one with bothe of them PERFORMING then i would be proper !

[MovieCreators101]

gaga!!!!!!!!!one million times gaga!thumbs up if u agree! :]

[KatMichelle1]

those dancing people need to me, im trying to watch beyonce. ?

[effeng]

i go for beyonce' totally yhe best performer....

[mevemichaud]

I love gaga but the perfomance that i love the most was beyonce

[Abadmane]

Gaga is a better entertainer, but Beyonce voice is amazing and can perform way better than Gaga! Wish it was two more similar Videos of Beyonce n Gaga. Beyonce is not performing n that video N Gaga is not singing! One where Beyonce is actaully performing instead of standing in one spot!

[XiMontageKingiX]

Beyonce all the way!!!.... GAGA sounded as if she was on drugs, maybe she is.

Gaga is lip syncing. she tries to distract people from the fact that she is doing that by saying things like i like ur jacket and throwing dolls out to the audience! Bad Gaga!

[XiMontageKingiX]

Beyonce all the way!!!.... GAGA sounded as if she was on drugs, maybe she is.

Gaga is lip syncing.

[thatoo9]

Beyonce is talented. She just have to sing and also her beauty is freaken awesome...she is my no 1 lady

[flynn395]

its called the video music awards, not the video dance awards, if someone is good at dancing but sucks at making music they shouldnt be famous artists. thats why music sucks so much today. Good day sir.

[huant43]

Lady Gaga just rubbed the doll's head on her pussy!!!!! LOL

[nekomoeYam]

What's up with the Dancer...She's Like ORANGE all over. =_='a

[AngelGaga13]

Beyonce was just standing and singing while Gaga was dancing and singing. Gaga's song didn't involve a lot of vocal talent while Beyonce's did. They pitched Gaga's voice and it made her sound weird.Put a performance of Gaga in the piano and THEN we can judge. In my opinion,they both have AMAZING vocal talent but nobody can entertain,shock,stand out or put on a show like Lady Gaga. I mean,her performance of Paparazzi in the 2009 VMAs was pure talent and theater!

[alexxus12345]

Beyonce is way better than Lady Gaga !

[HappyHappyChannel]

Heres your answer. IF they were both singing and dancing on stage. WHich one would you rather look at?

[jonasforever95]

Both have a beautiful voice. Beyonce's was obviously amazing, but Gaga was dancing so she couldn't sing. That's like impossible to sing good if you're dancing so much. Pluss, you gotta have variety at an awards show.

[MissLauriex]

I feel Lady Gaga tries to hard to try and portray the shock factor. Madonna was the original trend setter, Gaga's a poor imitation. Beyonce is just ..amazing. End of

[loversyoustoo]

ha lady gaga  how are you i like your song a lot

[romance828]

why not pick a song where beyonce is singing & dancing...but hands down Beyonce...there is no competition or comparison

[giovannaeme]

I love you Gaga, i love you Beyonce !♥

[Mr75797]

is that gaga or the chipettes? lol.

[Mr75797]

is that gaga or the chipettes? lol.

[Mr75797]

is that gaga or the chipettes? lol.

[siwa1994polska]

Beyonce .... Beyonce .... And again Beyonce ;)

[MyHeartEscapes]

I'd vote for Beyonce.

Lady Gaga is an alright singer but she's just... disgusting to me. Like, her personality.

[LanieD82]

i always suspected beyonce couldn't sing .

she's a one trick pony - can wail in one pitch and key and that's about all she's got. explains why the music is so one dimentional and bassless

[xangief05]

Beyonce is simply gorgeous...no matter what she does (sing/dance/act/etc.)

I so admire her!!!! D' best!

[gshawtymane]

evey move bey does is so amazing

[Diiineoo]

she sounds so different, i think shes useing her head tones

[1945elim]

beyonce is so much better!!!! love her

[1945elim]

beyonce !!!!

[1945elim]

beyonce ofcourse!

[UMSABCD1234]

Beyonce is really the only person I know can sing so amazingly LIVE, eveyone else has tew has a studio, beyonce and Trey songz that is sing well LIVE

[NMESSIAH2008]

gAgA IS STILL THE BEST HANDS DOWN.. EVEN IF YOU THINK SHE WIERD THE BEST OR YOU DONT CARE.. EITHER WAY YOU NO ABOUT HER.. ITS IN THE NUMBERS.. SHE HAS THE MOST FAN BASE.. SHE FUCKING AWESOME!!!!! YOU COULD OF PICKED A BETTER SONG TOO..

[xStandeR]

Gaga :D

[pixiedixie500]

Gaga !!!! I don't think beyonce can dance like that!!!!

[edukart123]

Lady Gaga

[justin229564]

Love.it. VMA rocks.Rocking video.Im so speechless Outstnding...Happy tears



[justin229564]

Love.it. VMA rocks....Rocking video.Im so speechless Outstnding...Happy tears

[justin229564]

Love..it..))) VMA rocks....Rocking video...Im so speechless :'( Outstnding...Happy tears



[Giovanicaramelo]

Can you tell the difference? Beyonce is the new queen. It is much better. And sing live. Singing is not a chatterbox.

Gaga can not sing live. It just sing in the studio.

Look what the critique says, Beyonce is the new queen.

[coco7bb]

beyoncè forever u.u

[ginte97]

beyonce!!! she singing sooo good

[MissJootje1]

Beyonce!!

[nrdixon10]

Beyonce hands down..



[oh3sillykids]

i love them both for different reasons

[bejaminkush]

Beyonce!

[albertquimpogaran29]

GaGa

[1maddierose]

Beyonce :) shes amazing and lady gaga looks kina fake..... if ya no wat i mean......

[shinee766]

of course beyonce is the best

[HeavyHittasMMG]

Is that a serious question??? Lady gaga performance isnt even in the same catogory wow was they serious! BEYONCE!!! Duh

[BeyonceStans4]

Beyonce > Adele > Lady Gaga

[laughte3r]

i love beyonce. she is a complete package and she is a lady, with real talent. gaga is a joke, cant compare her to beyonce

[gabysnell]

beyonce

[FoxPreShowLive]

▼ Click My Channel Name For More Epic Videos That Will Amaze You! ◄

[TheXobritt720]

they're both excellent, successful performers, and serve as inspiration to girls everywhere. love you Gaga and Beyonce.

[NerfandaJ]

Beyonce ;)

[makemoneyhere1]

Beyonce has class, Gaga doesn't even know what it is. Nuff said.

[402CRACKERjack]

@makemoneyhere1 fuck you

[susy246]

lady gaga for sure



[trrrrixiegirl2]

@susy246 Ew. Lady Gaga is freaking weird.

[susy246]

lady gaga for sure

[ilovetippysm]

beyonce CAN sing soo well live <3

[qwerty20099002]

Beyonce !! As she doesn't need to resort to attention seeking gimmicks to b more successful

[TheRawr80]

Not fair.

1. Gaga's performed is pitched.

2. She's dancing, pick a song where she isn't dancing.



[msgetritetime]

Beautiful Legs

[WaMusical]

Hey guys! Check out my cover of You and I here! Much love!

[KoriJoelle]

omg whose the dancing carrot!!

[sagchina]

Beyonce looks so manly.

[sam12670]

i love them both but in my opinion BEYONCE IS THE BEST THERE IS, THERE WAS AND THERE EVER WILL BE!!!! I also agree that she is gonna be an amazing mum!!!! :)

[sam12670]

I love them both but in my opinion BEYONCE IS THE BEST THERE IS THERE WAS AND THERE EVER WILL BE. I also agree that she is gonna be an amazing mum!!! :)

[steffharr]

beyonce all day..........gaga cant sink for fuck sake

[tangelagrass]

Lady Gaga of course!!

[dla97]

beyonce wins i love gaga but her voice isnt very special

[dla97]

beyonce is wins i love gaga but her voice isnt very special

if youre doing a competition between vocals, dont you think it was a bad idea to use a fast upbeat pop song like telephone when shes dancing for gaga

an acoustic performance would have been better