It is so funny reading these comments. Did she or didn't she sing live?? The truth is she didn't ... but isn't that funny that we can't tell? It just shows you how talented Menzel really is. I was lucky to catch her on the TV when she performed at the PBS Soundstage ... and I was stunned, she sounds exactly like her CD's ... which made me think ... how come people who can't sing like they sound on their Cd's win awards ... yet top notch singer's like Menzel can't??
I don't think she was pregnant when she sang this. She wasn't singing live here, I don't think she was even at the fireworks display, the song was prerecorded.
I don't know when exactly it was recorded, but she debuted it, live, at a concert held in NYC last April or thereabouts. That was the premiere of the whole American River Suite (so not an Idina concert). So most likely she was pregnant when this was recorded.
I love Idina soooooooooo much!!!!!!!!! She sings perfectly in this song!!!!!!! It's the best I've heard her sing ever! She is my hero and I will be a Fanzel forever!
@chubssochubby Thanks. The TV version sucked... back recording all around, they just didn't understand that fireworks tend to be louder than people singing.
I think I'm going to have to pick up her new CD (This song isn't on there though).
i completely forgot about her singing for this. you can guess how surprised / excited i was to be sitting there and randomly hear Idina's wonderful voice :)
WHATS GOING ON HERE? I LOVE IDINA TOO, AND I JUST FOUND OUT ABOUT HER PREGNANCY YESTERDAY, ANNDDD I HAD NO CLUE THEY WERE GUNNA PLAY HER MUSIC!!! i wish i knew, shes so beautiful, and her voice makes the fireworks look good.
There is no way that was her. For one, Idina's about 7 months pregnant right now. And if its where I think you mean, that girl looked more blondish. Besides they'd have shown her and said her name if she'd been there.
Happy Independence Day America from the uk
warjakeboy 8 months ago
does anyone have the lyrics written down. I can't seem to make out what she sings between
"I’ve got a hope for us to share
And as those rivers flow"
and
"We can finally be one nation truly free
Flowing like a river"
fudgyvmp 1 year ago
@fudgyvmp
I think between that is:
I dream of being with you where
jambajuzi 5 months ago
It is so funny reading these comments. Did she or didn't she sing live?? The truth is she didn't ... but isn't that funny that we can't tell? It just shows you how talented Menzel really is. I was lucky to catch her on the TV when she performed at the PBS Soundstage ... and I was stunned, she sounds exactly like her CD's ... which made me think ... how come people who can't sing like they sound on their Cd's win awards ... yet top notch singer's like Menzel can't??
Kylouch 2 years ago 14
And amazing that she sang like that pregnant!!
Soon2beonbroadway 2 years ago
I don't think she was pregnant when she sang this. She wasn't singing live here, I don't think she was even at the fireworks display, the song was prerecorded.
Katwillbehere 2 years ago
I don't know when exactly it was recorded, but she debuted it, live, at a concert held in NYC last April or thereabouts. That was the premiere of the whole American River Suite (so not an Idina concert). So most likely she was pregnant when this was recorded.
LondonNow 2 years ago 3
The orchestra was live, but Idina's voice and the choir was prerecorded.
jasobres 2 years ago
It was at Carnegie Hall when it originally premiered. Idina made her Carnegie Hall Debut this past April
broadwaymike92 2 years ago
i wish they showed her singing it! and thanks phoebe21!
countrychick102 2 years ago 3
me 2! i was dissapointed. but her awesome singing made up for it!
volleyball613 2 years ago
I've been looking for this for sooo long! Idina's awesome!! This song is great! Thanks for posting!
haleygrace1 2 years ago
I love Idina soooooooooo much!!!!!!!!! She sings perfectly in this song!!!!!!! It's the best I've heard her sing ever! She is my hero and I will be a Fanzel forever!
Clarinetist0409 2 years ago
beautiful song! love idina!
elphie4evergreen 2 years ago 2
ROCK ON IDINA for getting the big firework song!!!
Although as this wasn't live I don't really get why they were miming the orchestra...
:-P
MvyMkr 2 years ago 4
Does anyone know where I can get this song's lyrics??
PENEROPECRUZ 2 years ago
Type American River suite lyrics on google...
MvyMkr 2 years ago
thanks phoabe21 :)
moonkeypoop 2 years ago
Just in case you didn't already know this-you can download this song off of newyorkpops' website for free!:)
phoebe21 2 years ago 3
ah i love her voice so much! heck i love her! go Idina!!!
ElphabaForLife 2 years ago 12
frickin amazing!
chenzel03 2 years ago 3
when i herd idina sing this on the 4th, i started crying
she is such a beautiful person && she will be my hero forever. ima fanzel forever(:
broadwaylover4life 2 years ago 2
I love this song! Idina rocks! <3
BroadwayBabe10689 2 years ago
she can still belt it out with a baby in her tumtum. :)
sarahnicoleee917 2 years ago 3
That made me laugh! It's true, she's incredible. This is actually the best I've heard her sing=]
JmB8207 2 years ago 2
She did a beautiful job with this song! Gotta love Idina <3
JmB8207 2 years ago
You can hear the studio version of this song on her myspace now!
chubssochubby 2 years ago
Yea! Thanks!!
phoebe21 2 years ago
@chubssochubby Thanks. The TV version sucked... back recording all around, they just didn't understand that fireworks tend to be louder than people singing.
I think I'm going to have to pick up her new CD (This song isn't on there though).
MCWHAMMER 2 years ago
I hope they release this song with Idina singing it sometime soon :-)
Gabriella189 2 years ago
dang she has the best voice
12bballplayer 2 years ago
wowow. her voice is just always and ever purely ahmaaaazing ! <3
sheebeenhere 2 years ago
her voice is sooooo amazing. i want this as my cellphone ringtone! =]
Tyses 2 years ago
i did :) although the firework popping takes away a bit its still nice lol
blockhead29 2 years ago
Right? Is there any way to remove that annoying background popping?:)
phoebe21 2 years ago
i wish. i love this song :)
blockhead29 2 years ago
if there is a regular mp3 version anywhere i would download it and make a ringtone out of it! its amazing!
Tyses 2 years ago
amazing!
tatortotproductions 2 years ago
i completely forgot about her singing for this. you can guess how surprised / excited i was to be sitting there and randomly hear Idina's wonderful voice :)
blockhead29 2 years ago
Does anyone know where I can download this version of "American River" by Idina Menzel for my iPod? I would appreciate it. Thanks! God Bless America!
mpuhak50 2 years ago
I know this is pre recorded but still ts absolutley amazing!!!! WOW!!!!
wickediswicked5 2 years ago
Fanks for posting.
smeloise 2 years ago
WHATS GOING ON HERE? I LOVE IDINA TOO, AND I JUST FOUND OUT ABOUT HER PREGNANCY YESTERDAY, ANNDDD I HAD NO CLUE THEY WERE GUNNA PLAY HER MUSIC!!! i wish i knew, shes so beautiful, and her voice makes the fireworks look good.
katieeatsrainbows 2 years ago
your so right about her voice making the fireworks look good!!
greenboro7240 2 years ago
Wow.... this is incredible!!!! I love Idina!!!
Clarinetist0409 2 years ago 2
cant beleive her baby is due in september! love u idina wish u all the best :)
fanzelandtwilighter 2 years ago 3
ah really!? when did you find that out?
d3annax012 2 years ago
well shes 7 months pregnant so in 2 months baby comes lol
fanzelandtwilighter 2 years ago
haha opps totally forgot sorry that was stupid
d3annax012 2 years ago
I don't know why exactly.
but I'm SURE this is a recording...
it just doesn't sound live at all.
Her voice is too...detached from everything.
I don't know how to explain it but she's not singing live here.
BroadwayBaby008 2 years ago
It was Idina, but it was pre-recorded. Same with Audra's piece.
LondonNow 2 years ago
well ya... it's really loud.... if it was live... nobody would hear her... with all the fireworks and shit.
Maureen96Idina 2 years ago
well the microphone volume goes pretty high but yeah.
BroadwayBaby008 2 years ago
I want this song sooo badly!!!
SurfingGirl777 2 years ago
she was there, at the end of the tv broadcast you see her leaving the stage.
goducks007 2 years ago
There is no way that was her. For one, Idina's about 7 months pregnant right now. And if its where I think you mean, that girl looked more blondish. Besides they'd have shown her and said her name if she'd been there.
idinaismymuse 2 years ago
when TheaterMania announced that Idina and Audra would be singing it said they were prerecorded. so Yes you are right.
bethanyb5 2 years ago
Agree!
phoebe21 2 years ago
what a beautiful voice!
unabletosoldier 2 years ago
She should be around 7 months pregnant. The vocals were amazing but it would have been nice to see her
nikki33010 2 years ago 2
where is she? and am I right in thinking that she performed this nearly 7 months pregnant!
Gabriella189 2 years ago
She wasn't actually there. It was just prerecorded vocals.
idinaismymuse 2 years ago
love idina's voice and america so nice video
elphie4evergreen 2 years ago
great! I love her!
<3
melonflower 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
IDINAMENZELSTYRER 2 years ago
Now those are what I call fireworks!
gilmores2 2 years ago 3
i was blasting this when i heard her start to sing
then at the end im like YEAH DEE!!!! hahah
xoTossTossxo 2 years ago
Idina<3
punkysk8er522 2 years ago 3
Idina sounds great, as does Audra.
nanotechcre8or 2 years ago 2
This is incredible! She sounds amazing!
idinasfavefanzel 2 years ago 9
GORGEOUS!
honeygirl931 2 years ago 2
ah, she sounds amazing!
puppypersonLOTR 2 years ago 3
she sounds awesome!!
ReadyForFame 2 years ago 3
AMAZING!!
love it....
catylaloca 2 years ago