Hanoverian Monarchy=Good, Jacobite Monarchy=Bad, Rangers Football team=Good, Celtic Football team=Bad, Protestant/Presbyterian Christianity=Good, Catholic Christianity=Bad, N Ireland=Good, Rep Ireland=Bad, Britain, which is overrun with immigrants already=Good,EU with immigrants =Bad - that just about cover it theneil100? You say you don't want to be a puppet, well you're already a muppet. I'm in favour of your dying breath - you're taking up precious air as is!
It always makes me chuckle that people assume this must be a pro-jacobite sng, Its not, its a very anti-jacobite song "Ye Jacobites by name your faults Iwill proclaim". Listen to the
@ColdMattyCross Rabbie Burns wrote this poem. He was jacobite. The 'Your fautes I will proclaim/Your doctrines I maun blame' are reference to the failures of the rebellion (Culloden) and not condemnation of the jacobites. It may not be a song that praises the jacobites but it definitely isn't an anti-jacobite song.
@campbo The original song was vehemently anti-Jacobite. Burns watered it down. Your doctrines I maun blame is pretty clear though. He in blaming their principles not the fact that they failed. Saying that it is only a song. He wrote in character. Sometimes entertainment is just entertainment.
I want Britain out of the EU,if you think that our forefathers sold scotland out to England,it,s nothing on what allah salmond has in store for scotland in the eu,they,ll line their pockets,and bankrupt the country,at the same time alienate us from our english ,welsh and n irish brethren,and ally us with the likes of greece,germany,southern ireland,etc,a puppet country,flooded with immigrants,with no control over our destiny,i will fight to my dying breath against that,all those in favour of in
@theneil100 Thank you! Finally someone who agrees with me! People talk of independence from the rest of the UK; we need independence from the EU! People voting SNP have no idea what a deep pile of shit they're getting us into.
@Steely1888 so I can fuck off to England is that right pal,get yer pal allah Salmond to give us a refferendum,then we,ll let you get a wee peice of land somewhere up the highlands where you can fuck off to.
@theneil100 What you are feeling towards Brussels - The Scots have felt for 300 years - working hard, and having our natural resources taken by the Bloody London Government to prop up the UK! Well FUCK THAT! we have had enough!
he was anti-Jacobite. He often wrote in character or purely for entertainment. Just as other Lowlanders did who wrote many of the Jacobite classics. For instance Sir Walter Scott wrote Bonnie Dundee and James Hogg wrote Donald MacGillevry etc. Likewise there is no conflict between singing all these songs as I do most weekends. Songs are usually just songs! As you suggest there is no need for folk on the net to get so het up!
Seems to me that the views that really count are the views of the Irish people in the here and now! They had an official referendum on the subject and an overwhelming majority in the Republic, plus a significant majority in the north, voted 'yes' to the principle that the North should remain part of the UK as long as the majority there wish it to be so, and that they can leave the UK when they want. The UK govt accepts this too! What's to argue about?
"@Steely1888 Since 2 cent. BC geographers huv seen Ulster as seperate from Ireland, the Romans called Ireland Hibernia and Ulster Ulidia because they saw that the people in Hibernia and Ulidia where different culturally and thats still the case the day, "
@Gingerly43 - your an idiot, read my comments i never brought religion into it, you are seriously sad if cause the romans referred to ulster as a seperate state then thats how it should be? your an idiot and clearly a fanatical supporter of the ulster loyalist sectarian shite. fuck off and dont reply i dont give 2 fucks about your views
"the stuarts are better monarchs" and "the hanovarians are better monarchs", whit as dose ae pish, aw monarchy is shite! whae the fuck in there right mind wid let some cunt proclaim themsel' "king" and by extention better than every cunt else? that hael thing gos against whit is scottish, scotland hus aye stood fur that everycunt nae matter yer creed or colour is equal. The queens shite still stinks like the rest ae oors, so lets get rid and live in a independant scotland free ae imperial rule!
The fact remains that if you pair off Hanoverians vs Stuarts in a mud wrestling match, the Hanoverians win. The Stuarts were small and slight, with really long hair. The Hanoverians had shorter hair, were much fatter and rounder. Quite frankly, the Stuarts don't stand a chance.
he'd make Scotland Presbyterian then once he had a power base in England he ruthlessly, along with his brother James VII, oppressed Presbyterian Scots launching the Killing Times on southern Scotland - whilst James also was king during the Bloody Assizes in England. James was also completely incompetent politically once on the throne
There's nothing like coming upon a wonderful historical song and seeing it offer a home for bigotry. I'm English and I'm ashamed of much of what was done by the English in the past; similarly, it's not all innocence and romantic ideals amongst those the English 'suppressed'. One thing is most definitely in common - all these issues are those of the past and are only brought to the surface by those who are unhappy with peace. Live and let live and let religious and nationalist bigotry die.
If you go away way back you will find that the population of the uk are the children of the twelve tribes of Israel give or take the foreign entrys now and again,bet alot of people didnt realise that,stand by for fireworks!!!
"Ulster" aka the 6 counties - when actuality it contains 9 counties the other 3 being Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan. It's not even "Northern" Ireland as the most northerly point of that Isle is Malin Head in Donegal. Stop boring us with your pathetic revisionist bullshit. O'Neill and O'Donnell fought bravely piss of your landgrabbers you make the Isrealis look reasonable
the jacobite rebellions were not about scotland and england fighting each other they were more complex than that indeed the majority of scots did not support the prince particularly in the lowlands,who saw the movement as backwards we entering the period of momentous cultural,social and industrial change and an absolutist monarchy was becoming an irrelevance in the new commercial scotland. many if not the majority of his highland supporters did not want to cross the border into england .
@forsythbill1 "many if not the majority of his highland supporters did not want to cross the border into england " None of the Scottish commanders (whether Lowlander or Highlander) wanted to invade England and they only did so in the end because a deluded Charles convinced them that the English populace would rise in support.
@Islandretreat What the Jesuits have no part of it. James II strived for a kingdom with the peace to allow religions to develop ad they would. Its about how they treated the Kingdoms, and as monarch as James II why would you want the country run by those who wanted money out of pointeless wars and not those who wanted to trade.........
@ogreoh "Stuarts were better monarchs" Surely debatebale at the least. Pox on both houses I'd say. James VI&I oppressed both Scots and English Borderers; started the Plantation of Ulster and attempted the same thing in parts of the Highlands forcing chiefs to send their boys to be schooled in the Lowlands etc. Charles I was a disaster who made several unsuccesful invasions of Scotland and eventually caused the civil wars that devasted all three of his kingdoms. Charles II promised the Scots
@gaconnochie Oh agree mate, but 20/20 at the time isn't there. As a 17th century British history student I just loathe the way Britain turned out in the 18th century. That by modern standards of freedom that the absolute Monarchs of Catherine and Frederick executed less folks than 'progressive' Britain over the century gives me pause.
@ogreoh I kind of agree with you there. As I said pox on both their houses. Just because someone points out 17thC Stuart flaws it doesn't mean they don't recognise 18thC Hanovarian flaws.
@gaconnochie I suppose so sir, but I'll take an optimistic hope for a more benevolent and equal Jacobite British Isles could have been over the Hannoverian reality, especially with the two centuries of Whiggish history that lauded the state created in the wake of 1689 despite that it marginalized a a great number of the crowns citizens well until the great reforms of the 1830s and beyond....as misplaced as such hope may be
@ogreoh, Striving for religious peace? That's the opposite of the truth. Firstly the Jesuits are a Miitary Order, and King James II was a member of the Order, trained in Rome, the only Jesuit to ever sit on the throne. That fact has been well covered up. It's well known that he was surrounded by Jesuit "confessors" but the truth is he was a Jesuit himself. Webster's 1828 Dictionary defines a Jesuit as a deceiver. King James II was certainly that, to say the least.
@ogreoh "James II strived for a kingdom with the peace to allow religions to develop" Actually James oppressed the Presbyterians in Scotland whilst his brother was on the throne and continued to do so whilst in office. He was eventually persuaded to moderate slightly but the idea that he wanted complete toleration for everyone is bunkum!
@mrdfitz1 - please tell me when "ulster" came into existance as a state? exactly, its not a country, majority of ireland voted yes to independence, a resounding 75% that should of been the end of the matter. So when scotland votes independence if one area is pro union do u think they should be partitioned off? am not even gonna reply to you cause i have already established you are an idiot. my comment gets thumbs up as people agree with me unlike you
@Steely1888 Since 2 cent. BC geographers huv seen Ulster as seperate from Ireland, the Romans called Ireland Hibernia and Ulster Ulidia because they saw that the people in Hibernia and Ulidia where different culturally and thats still the case the day, I dispise the idea of the "United Kingdom" and would like tae see Scotland independant but just because ae that I cannae no notice the people ae Ulster are no the same as the Irish, Ulster shouldnae be Irish or British, Ulster should be free anaw.
@albagubrath90 - away n dont talk shite. Using your pathetic logic scotland wouldnt be a country then, cause the gaels are different from the picts and there were other scottish tribes. You telling me the "ulstermen" today are direct decendents from the ones the Romans were referring to? Anyway nice try but i can see your account is new and your a daft hun having a laugh
@Steely1888 Im no a fuckin hun ya tit, and so what if i am whit the fuck is that goat tae dae wae it, im no saein they're directed discendents either, im saein we huv tae see that they're no the same as the irish and that if they dinnae want tae be part ae ireland the dinnae huv tae be and in future if yae want ae huv a rational discussion dinnae bring religion intae it cause god isnae real and it makes yer argument weak when yae resort tae bigoted comments like callin' somebody a hun.
@albagubrath90 - your a fuckin retard. There are parts of ulster that ARE already part of the republic of ireland, and there are 6 counties under british rule and slightly under half of those counties are irish nationalist u fool, so your gonna completely ignore that for support of the people who were sent their to divide so the british could rule it better? your a fanny, develope a brain cell and look up who Carson was, who threatened orange terror after 75% of ireland voted independence
@albagubrath90 - i wasnt bringing religion into it you tit, fs how thick are you? im talking about the politics of the place and you think of religion? your the bigot then, and your a militant atheist fuck
@Steely1888 Im hardly a militant athiest by sayin god dusnae exist, callin somebody a hun is a bigoted comment because you're only sayin that because yae thought I wus a prodestant, and I ken that three counties of Ulster are aw ready in the republic but as you say not the majority of the remainin counties want tae be in the republic, if the majority did I would more than support them but they dinnae so they souldnae huv tae be.
@albagubrath90 - how the fuck is a "hun" sectarian and makes me bigoted? do you even know what a "hun" is, you clearly dont. a "hun" is what rangers fans get called, not members of presbyterian churches u tool, and huns are loyalist, in strong support of "ulster" (which u are). So dont even talk to me, your an idiot, and you havent got a clue, you know fuck all, go read a book u cant even spell "protestant" shows how much u know - tit
@albagubrath90 - am blocking you now cause i cannot be arsed with your uneducated views and pathetic replies. Majority of Ireland did want to be independent and voted on it and 75% voted YES therefore by democracy they should of been independent but no. Carson threatened orange terror if ireland were to be newly formed independent which is why your beloved "ulster" exists as a sectarian state. The Irish people were robbed of their freedom and have a right to struggle on
@Steely1888 Why bother wasting your breath on uneducated, unpleasant and unrepentantly unionist 'people' that spew out vulgar views on youtube...views that fly in the face of decent people who hold values like fairness, mercy and democracy in low esteem. 'People' who have generation after generation of hatred and twisted ideas bred into them.
@Steely1888 The only time I sometimes get through to certain 'people' is when I hypothesise: "Imagine Scotland gained full independence from the so-called 'union' by majority vote via democratic elections, but a majority of people in say Ayrshire start spouting pro union defiance against the democratically free Scotland and threaten horrific sectarian violence if they are not allowed to remain part of the union...." Well my answer to them would be "Fuck off to England...Scotland is now free"
...I am shocked — but not surprised — to say that many people think that it would be acceptable for a region to split from Scotland and remain in the UK. It's the ultimate in double-standards! In our lifetime, majority vote has unfortunately kept Scotland part of the UK — this is acceptable to these unionists, but they suddenly change their minds at the idea of that same vote making Scotland free and feel it would be ok for a region to go against the majority and divide the country!
@felipescotland77 - your only getting one reply from me so fuck off after this, yes after independence unionist fucks should go live in the remains of the UK. Your that unionist arent you? Unionists in america exiled after the patriots won so unionists in scotland would be no different. How am i uneducated i fucking educated a few people who came out with unionist attacks, anyway nice to see a die hard unionist listening to a Jacobite song
@Steely1888 What are you talking about dude...Im a nationalist who believes in free Scotland! How dare you let your foolish anger boil over and rant at someone (me) who AGREED with your posts and who was lending you support! And how fuken dare you call me a unionist! you need to calm domn and make an attempt to read my posts again without the red mist of anger getting your wires crossed.
Oh and once you realise we are on the same side and once you re-read my posts and realise you interpreted them completely the wrong way around...please then be aware of the history of the song here and that, unfortunately, it is NOT a pro Jacobite song. Please go and read some encyclopedias and learn about the anti-jacobite origins of this song and the slightly more moderate tone its lyrics have taken while it was tweaked over the decades.
@felipescotland77 "it is NOT a pro Jacobite song." Unfortunately some people just don't actually listen to lyrics of songs. Because it has Jacobite in the title many presume it is a Jacobite song. It is clearly ludicrous that anyone could think it is pro-Jacobite as it clearly blames them and their doctrines for the conflict. Sometimes too folk have real trouble in understanding that many of these songs are purely entertainment. Just because Burns wrote one anti-Jacobite song it doesn't mean
@Steely1888 Ken whit Im fed tryin tae reason wae yea, if the majority ae the remainin counties dinnae want tae be part ae the republic they shouldnae huv tae be thats aw Im sayin.
@mrdfitz1 - ulster is not even a country so it is not for "ulstermen" your region came into existance due to crazy unionist royalist loyalists forming a terrorist group. You are not native, your either of scottish borderland descent and you live so far south you dont know if your scottish or english so you people came to the conclusion that ye were "british". Scotland and Ireland are celtic countries, emphasis on the COUNTRIES. "ulster" goes against democracy when 75% voted yes on independence
@Maverickthebroken1 - Whats saxons got to do with Scots? saxons are from saxony in germany, and they took over england then later the normans took over england. "saxons" connotates englishmen
@Maverickthebroken1 saxons is more a culture legacy than a genetical group....20% highest in NE england + east anglia...most "brits" descend from first settlers from basque region moving up after ice retreated
@ashbannor Quite so. The original source song Burns based this on is vehemently anti-Jacobite. Burns tones it down making it more anti-war than anti-Jacobite. Though he still blames them for the conflict in it. "You Jacobites by name....your faults I will proclaim....your doctrines I will blame...you shall hear"
Stuff the polotics i'll be 60 this year and and have every type or gig from Pink Floyd to the Royal Philharmonic and have o say the nihjt I saw thr Corries was one of the best gigs i've eer seen Eddie
@urphyma456 Well said, Urphyma456. Whenever my Scottish ears hear the passion that is this song, it's not politics that I'm left thinking about, rather it's a renewed feeling of the beauty of life. The Corries did indeed rock, wish I had seen them play live, too - still there's always YouTube. :-)
Scottish Office and legislation differed from what went on in England. Once the Scottish Office had no mandate, and because they didn't recognise that and took no notice of Scottish opinion, then the whole system didn't work. Decentralisation was inevitable. It was only a matter of how far that decentralisation would go! For a union to work when t is made up of three small countries and one large represented by one parliament then the representatives of the large country need to take heed of
@TheMightOfTheEnglish in terms of votes yes in theory our votes are equal but in reality they are not. This is because uk politicians care little for the Scottish vote, it is less numerous than the english one and they therefore do not try to represent the Scottish people. This then leads to governments being elected with only English interests at heart causing them to take decisions that are detrimental to the Scottish people I won't insult your intelligence by giving examples, there's to many
@danonutube1 Absolutely correct. During the Thatcher years the political scene in Scotland diverged from that in England. Under that Tory administration the Scottish Secretary stopped being Scotland's man in the Cabinet and instead became the Cabinet's man in Scotland. He was there to force Thatcher's policies, backed by the English electorate, on to a Scotland who had given them no mandate. Scotland has always been run differently from England as most of what is now devolved was run by the
@TheMightOfTheEnglish @TheMightOfTheEnglish I agree with your view on Europe I for one would not see Scotland gain it's independence from England only to surrender it to Europe. However this does not in any way destroy my argument as we may get less money from Europe but we would keep our own money. the deficit of Scotland is significantly less than the rest of uk meaning we would be able to support ourselves with insignificant investment borrowing compared with the millions loaned to London
@gaconnochie neither do I it was a typical I'll informed response intended to demonize anything that opposes Britannia by making it a criminal offence oh well roll on the referendum
@johnjohnnyist the law is not always right many laws have been created that good men have risked their lives to break a traitor to Scotland is not someone who disagrees with the monarchy, it is someone who refuses to stand up for the people. The people of scotland deserve the same rights as any other country they deserve and eventually they will demand, nation status
@danonutube1 I don't know why the other poster brought the law into it. There is nothing unlawful or unconstitutional about the Nats holding an independence referendum - or people debating it. The UK govt has conceded that!
@danonutube1 in what way doesnt scotland have the same rights as everyone else ? you are a nation within the united kingdom. my vote isnt worth any more than yours , your free to do anything you want , being part of europe destroys your argument , look at the outside interference has done to this country , its not a level playing field , id be more concerned with staying in europe , than the union if i was you, you may get european money being a small nation, but at what price
@johnjohnnyist What a strange thing to say! there is no presumtion about it, of course that's what a referendum will decide. I was not trying to start a debate I was simply giving an opinion as others were.
@johnjohnnyist There will be much debating from now right up until the referendum. It is a strange thing to suggest it shouldn't be debated prior to the vote. How else are people to decide? The problem is that there hasn't been a lot of debating about it up until now. The unionist parties at Holyrood have simply avoided the issue by dismissing it as an irrelevance.Now because the Nats have a majority they (the unionists) are going to have to debate it.
Aye, Rabbie Burns, But Walt disnae!-old scotish joke, since the SDP got in we now have a chance of a FREE Land....steve god bless Scotland ( and let wales ane ireland gain their independence too!)
@remeclerk I think you've made a wee typo there. The SDP merged with the Liberal Party to become the Liberal Democrats and they got trounced at the election. I take it you mean SNP :-)
Lol @ all the scottish revolution nutjobs in here who don't realise Scotland would be broke in a week if it seperated. It relies on England for almost everything.
don't feed the troll people, just flag all of this ignorant idiot's comments as spam and treat him like the petulant 4 year old that he seems so determined to look like, this argument has gone on for many many months and isn't likely to stop any time soon, don't waste your time playing his childish games
@TheXand19 You loyalist counts need to fuck off out of Scotland and Ireland you only want to stay in the uk so can avoid controversy with the English. You would rather fight yer own people than fight for them, you are both a coward and a traitor to scotland fuk off u cunt
@Ewolf98 - well it was mainly scots lowlanders that fought for the patriots, the highlanders were redcoats fighting the patriots, the scots need to get along man, the generation before that it was highlanders fighting red coats and lowland scots lol. we need to unite and get the loyalists and english oot
@akropiss well we are all closer to the original settler who were pre celtic,,,,,but as a welsh geneticist I agree with your sentiments....dont forget the welsh includes the cornish and strathclyde britons/cumbrians.
Whereever you are from its not important its the CULTURE!! and its been totally pushed back to these islands fringes ignored during the empire days..and still is to an extent
@3tangle3 Why do Celtic & Pre-Celtic strains remain so strong despite multi-cultural Roman, Scandinavian/Germanic conquest & settlement? Celts seem to be a multi-ethnic Cultural Union.
Could different ethnicities be the same peoples overlapping under different cultural guises -- over time?
@USAsoldier1955 It is because the actual genetical input from these later invasions is surprisingly very low......but this depends on the area. Some parts of Western Wales and Western Ireland can have 95-98% of population being majority iberian 'pre celtic' settlers (celtic being an evolved european culture) with several later celtic invasions bringing their own genetic tint to the proceedings :D, and this can very between person to person, the actual difference is small however just potent
Actually, we Euro peoples prefer Canadians over USA twonks. They're less arrognat, less ignorant and dont think they're amazing because they come from the colony's.
On another note, anyone who is racist will never be recognised as a fellow Scotsman.
Aww ye glaikits can get back te arguin our yer ain wee skags ae land an leave Alba oota it.
@USAsoldier1955 you are an embarrassment to Scottish descendants the world over - as well as an equal embarrassment to Americans. I am both - a Scottish descendant living in the USA (my grandfather came here from Scotland). To the Scots posting here: I was raised to love my heritage and to support an independent Scotland - why wouldn't I, an American, have the right to post here. I am also a Republican - meaning that US political affiliation has very little bearing on the subject.
@akropiss balls, the true original British are the Welsh, the English were always a Germanic people going right back to their Anglo Saxon origins. Shut up if you can't even use the right word.
@akropiss balls, the true original British are the Welsh, the English were always a Germanic people going right back to their Anglo Saxon origins. Shut up if you can't even use the right word.
Rossmcl177 I am or my family are not part of what u say. i am from The true Jacobite Atholl highlanders. Which we took no part in any english rules untill ww1/2 So bite yer tongue m8 really pls do. My ancestors fought in 1700s last battle to be |FREE from English rule and to this day we stand by it. Robertson Clan
stop fighting.......english or scottish...the brythons were here before i.e welsh and cornish....but anyway i am not too bothered....what you should be united about is the fucking centralised state and the monarchy leaching all the hard taxpayers money...wtf.....!!!
I'm nearly 60 years old and i'v seen a few live gigs in my time I saw The Corries at the Hexagon Reading in the 80's and have to sy it still ranks as one of the best live gigs i've ever seen
@USAsoldier1955 please keep comments like this out of these videos, it is just likely to spark a huge argument as scotland is very famously divided and your inbox will likely be soon full of replies like f*ck king billy and up the ra
@rmartin232 Please keep comments like YOUR'S out of these videos, it is just likely to spark nuclear war as Scotland....and all humanity....is very famously divided and your inbox will likely be soon full of replies like f*ck the RA, King Billy's On The Wall....NO Surrender, etc.
@USAsoldier1955 SHUT UP you're raving mad and ought to be locked up. you are proof that americans are lazy ignorant self-absorbed self-righteous arseholes. how dare you insult people gratuitously like that??
@USAsoldier1955 Last time I checked, we don't have a bad name; in fact, that's why Americans wear canadian flag pins when they go to Europe. No one wants to hear your ultra-conservative yankee bullshit.
@IIGECKOII Most Europeans eat Canadians....thinking they will be baled-out by the USA! Of course, that's why increasing numbers of Canadians are moving to the USA -- and becoming AMERICAN CITIZENS! :D
@USAsoldier1955 What my fellow citizens do is their choice. As for being eaten by the Europeans... better than you being eaten by the middle east... and south-east asia XD have a nice day
@tearlach45 fuck bonnie prince charlie. singlehandedly destroyed the clan system in scotland. Made out to be a romantic hero but it couldnt be further from the truth. 35,000 to 40,000 people were slaughtered after he buggered off when his uprising imploded.
@frettish The clan system was doomed for destruction long before he arrived. After Culloden, Tartan, Bagpipes and Gaelic were all banned by British law because they were all symbols of Catholicism in Scotland. It was the "glorious Protestant" religion that destroyed the clan system.
@USAsoldier1955 - For a Christian Minister, youre language is really inappropriate. "Somalian fanny on the dole ruled by true Scots" ???? Born and raised Roman Catholic the main message I get is that Jesus taught us to treat everyone the same no matter what religion, colour of skin etc. "every Christian nation is at War with the forces of the Antichrist Papacy, the False Prophet Mohammad"?? Do you honestly think the miraculous Jesus would have time for these pathetic views? Allahu Akbar
@USAsoldier1955 you DARE compare scotland to the United States of Asswholes? what brings you to the conclusion that the US of Asswholes are the "true Scotland"? has the "true scotland" vanished from the globe? im disgusted that some little republican faggot like you claims to be scottish. you know nothing of scotland or history. i have just one request: do humanity a favour and drop dead, scum of the world.
@USAsoldier1955 HAHAHAHA im pretty suprised you know how to spell germany. its interesting that republicans tend to call everyone who stands against their ideas a commie. and you call me commie AND nazi in one post? you should really take some histoy lessons if you have something like that in your third world country you call USA... btw: you should just use a language if your capable of finding it on a map. uups - seems like you shouldnt use any language.
@USAsoldier1955 btw: "you are the google translator" now youve really hit me, dont you? how old are you??! twelve? your language is on the level of a premature schoolyardmonkey - oh, i forgot, youre a republican - explains everything
@USAsoldier1955 First of all: Nazis are not welcome in Germany, and people like you who say all germans are Nazis will not survive long if they come to Germany. So, I ask you to please, for Gods sake:
Shut the fuck up because you don't know nothing about anything. Faggot.
Second: If you want Scotland to be loyal to the Brits. why were you american not loyal to the fuckin brits, hm?
@1995Scotsman Ohh just forget it, it's obviously beyond you.
ljotulf 2 weeks ago
cheers:)for my hungarian ears its still:" where did yo come from where did yo go cotton eye joe" :)but lov,luv this music slangevar..
pikacccsu 2 weeks ago
Corries on youtubes home page, amazing! Serch for Braes o Killiekrankie, best song ;)
scotchmist30 1 month ago
@1995Scotsman - You ovbiously haven't understood my comment.
ljotulf 1 month ago
@ljotulf
I understood it pretty clear..
England is the place for you!
1995Scotsman 2 weeks ago
Hanoverian Monarchy=Good, Jacobite Monarchy=Bad, Rangers Football team=Good, Celtic Football team=Bad, Protestant/Presbyterian Christianity=Good, Catholic Christianity=Bad, N Ireland=Good, Rep Ireland=Bad, Britain, which is overrun with immigrants already=Good,EU with immigrants =Bad - that just about cover it theneil100? You say you don't want to be a puppet, well you're already a muppet. I'm in favour of your dying breath - you're taking up precious air as is!
ljotulf 2 months ago
@ljotulf
There's a much larger nation to the south waiting for you.. go!
1995Scotsman 1 month ago
Once you let the tims comment on Scottish songs ,thread fucked!
NickerSkids 2 months ago
It always makes me chuckle that people assume this must be a pro-jacobite sng, Its not, its a very anti-jacobite song "Ye Jacobites by name your faults Iwill proclaim". Listen to the
damn words.
ColdMattyCross 2 months ago
@ColdMattyCross Rabbie Burns wrote this poem. He was jacobite. The 'Your fautes I will proclaim/Your doctrines I maun blame' are reference to the failures of the rebellion (Culloden) and not condemnation of the jacobites. It may not be a song that praises the jacobites but it definitely isn't an anti-jacobite song.
campbo 3 weeks ago
@campbo The original song was vehemently anti-Jacobite. Burns watered it down. Your doctrines I maun blame is pretty clear though. He in blaming their principles not the fact that they failed. Saying that it is only a song. He wrote in character. Sometimes entertainment is just entertainment.
gaconnochie 1 week ago
Classic Corries once again. Linda, when will you be canonised?!? I;m about to search the thatch for my claymore!
Horsemarine100 4 months ago
@Horsemarine100 look again it aint Lind!
rosswatt1979 4 months ago
@Horsemarine100 Sorry, my mistake! The sentiment remains, though!
Horsemarine100 4 months ago
I want Britain out of the EU,if you think that our forefathers sold scotland out to England,it,s nothing on what allah salmond has in store for scotland in the eu,they,ll line their pockets,and bankrupt the country,at the same time alienate us from our english ,welsh and n irish brethren,and ally us with the likes of greece,germany,southern ireland,etc,a puppet country,flooded with immigrants,with no control over our destiny,i will fight to my dying breath against that,all those in favour of in
theneil100 4 months ago 2
@theneil100 Thank you! Finally someone who agrees with me! People talk of independence from the rest of the UK; we need independence from the EU! People voting SNP have no idea what a deep pile of shit they're getting us into.
PureJockPureBrit 4 months ago in playlist scots
@Steely1888 so I can fuck off to England is that right pal,get yer pal allah Salmond to give us a refferendum,then we,ll let you get a wee peice of land somewhere up the highlands where you can fuck off to.
theneil100 4 months ago
@theneil100 What you are feeling towards Brussels - The Scots have felt for 300 years - working hard, and having our natural resources taken by the Bloody London Government to prop up the UK! Well FUCK THAT! we have had enough!
billyconnearly 4 months ago 2
he was anti-Jacobite. He often wrote in character or purely for entertainment. Just as other Lowlanders did who wrote many of the Jacobite classics. For instance Sir Walter Scott wrote Bonnie Dundee and James Hogg wrote Donald MacGillevry etc. Likewise there is no conflict between singing all these songs as I do most weekends. Songs are usually just songs! As you suggest there is no need for folk on the net to get so het up!
gaconnochie 4 months ago
Seems to me that the views that really count are the views of the Irish people in the here and now! They had an official referendum on the subject and an overwhelming majority in the Republic, plus a significant majority in the north, voted 'yes' to the principle that the North should remain part of the UK as long as the majority there wish it to be so, and that they can leave the UK when they want. The UK govt accepts this too! What's to argue about?
gaconnochie 5 months ago
"@Steely1888 Since 2 cent. BC geographers huv seen Ulster as seperate from Ireland, the Romans called Ireland Hibernia and Ulster Ulidia because they saw that the people in Hibernia and Ulidia where different culturally and thats still the case the day, "
Steely are you on Crack?
Gingerly43 5 months ago
@Gingerly43 - your an idiot, read my comments i never brought religion into it, you are seriously sad if cause the romans referred to ulster as a seperate state then thats how it should be? your an idiot and clearly a fanatical supporter of the ulster loyalist sectarian shite. fuck off and dont reply i dont give 2 fucks about your views
Steely1888 5 months ago
"the stuarts are better monarchs" and "the hanovarians are better monarchs", whit as dose ae pish, aw monarchy is shite! whae the fuck in there right mind wid let some cunt proclaim themsel' "king" and by extention better than every cunt else? that hael thing gos against whit is scottish, scotland hus aye stood fur that everycunt nae matter yer creed or colour is equal. The queens shite still stinks like the rest ae oors, so lets get rid and live in a independant scotland free ae imperial rule!
albagubrath90 5 months ago
The fact remains that if you pair off Hanoverians vs Stuarts in a mud wrestling match, the Hanoverians win. The Stuarts were small and slight, with really long hair. The Hanoverians had shorter hair, were much fatter and rounder. Quite frankly, the Stuarts don't stand a chance.
masnip 5 months ago in playlist masnip's Favorited Videos
he'd make Scotland Presbyterian then once he had a power base in England he ruthlessly, along with his brother James VII, oppressed Presbyterian Scots launching the Killing Times on southern Scotland - whilst James also was king during the Bloody Assizes in England. James was also completely incompetent politically once on the throne
gaconnochie 6 months ago
UR aue full a shit the corries ar aue about SCOTLAND an FREEDOM FA the english
randjim 6 months ago
There's nothing like coming upon a wonderful historical song and seeing it offer a home for bigotry. I'm English and I'm ashamed of much of what was done by the English in the past; similarly, it's not all innocence and romantic ideals amongst those the English 'suppressed'. One thing is most definitely in common - all these issues are those of the past and are only brought to the surface by those who are unhappy with peace. Live and let live and let religious and nationalist bigotry die.
nicedave29 6 months ago
If you go away way back you will find that the population of the uk are the children of the twelve tribes of Israel give or take the foreign entrys now and again,bet alot of people didnt realise that,stand by for fireworks!!!
ricardokize 6 months ago
"Ulster" aka the 6 counties - when actuality it contains 9 counties the other 3 being Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan. It's not even "Northern" Ireland as the most northerly point of that Isle is Malin Head in Donegal. Stop boring us with your pathetic revisionist bullshit. O'Neill and O'Donnell fought bravely piss of your landgrabbers you make the Isrealis look reasonable
Grifflaw 6 months ago
@Grifflaw - so did O'Doherty, thats my irish side and they done a famous rebellion :)
Steely1888 6 months ago
the jacobite rebellions were not about scotland and england fighting each other they were more complex than that indeed the majority of scots did not support the prince particularly in the lowlands,who saw the movement as backwards we entering the period of momentous cultural,social and industrial change and an absolutist monarchy was becoming an irrelevance in the new commercial scotland. many if not the majority of his highland supporters did not want to cross the border into england .
forsythbill1 6 months ago
@forsythbill1 "many if not the majority of his highland supporters did not want to cross the border into england " None of the Scottish commanders (whether Lowlander or Highlander) wanted to invade England and they only did so in the end because a deluded Charles convinced them that the English populace would rise in support.
gaconnochie 6 months ago
@gaconnochie, Very true. The Jacobites were deceived by the Jesuits, they were lied to about support south of the border.
Islandretreat 6 months ago
@Islandretreat What the Jesuits have no part of it. James II strived for a kingdom with the peace to allow religions to develop ad they would. Its about how they treated the Kingdoms, and as monarch as James II why would you want the country run by those who wanted money out of pointeless wars and not those who wanted to trade.........
ogreoh 6 months ago
@ogreoh okay that came off too drunk, but still the Stuarts were better monarchs than the hannoverians....
ogreoh 6 months ago
@ogreoh "Stuarts were better monarchs" Surely debatebale at the least. Pox on both houses I'd say. James VI&I oppressed both Scots and English Borderers; started the Plantation of Ulster and attempted the same thing in parts of the Highlands forcing chiefs to send their boys to be schooled in the Lowlands etc. Charles I was a disaster who made several unsuccesful invasions of Scotland and eventually caused the civil wars that devasted all three of his kingdoms. Charles II promised the Scots
gaconnochie 6 months ago
@gaconnochie Oh agree mate, but 20/20 at the time isn't there. As a 17th century British history student I just loathe the way Britain turned out in the 18th century. That by modern standards of freedom that the absolute Monarchs of Catherine and Frederick executed less folks than 'progressive' Britain over the century gives me pause.
ogreoh 4 months ago
@ogreoh I kind of agree with you there. As I said pox on both their houses. Just because someone points out 17thC Stuart flaws it doesn't mean they don't recognise 18thC Hanovarian flaws.
gaconnochie 4 months ago
@gaconnochie I suppose so sir, but I'll take an optimistic hope for a more benevolent and equal Jacobite British Isles could have been over the Hannoverian reality, especially with the two centuries of Whiggish history that lauded the state created in the wake of 1689 despite that it marginalized a a great number of the crowns citizens well until the great reforms of the 1830s and beyond....as misplaced as such hope may be
ogreoh 4 months ago
@ogreoh, Striving for religious peace? That's the opposite of the truth. Firstly the Jesuits are a Miitary Order, and King James II was a member of the Order, trained in Rome, the only Jesuit to ever sit on the throne. That fact has been well covered up. It's well known that he was surrounded by Jesuit "confessors" but the truth is he was a Jesuit himself. Webster's 1828 Dictionary defines a Jesuit as a deceiver. King James II was certainly that, to say the least.
Islandretreat 6 months ago
@ogreoh "James II strived for a kingdom with the peace to allow religions to develop" Actually James oppressed the Presbyterians in Scotland whilst his brother was on the throne and continued to do so whilst in office. He was eventually persuaded to moderate slightly but the idea that he wanted complete toleration for everyone is bunkum!
gaconnochie 6 months ago
@mrdfitz1 - please tell me when "ulster" came into existance as a state? exactly, its not a country, majority of ireland voted yes to independence, a resounding 75% that should of been the end of the matter. So when scotland votes independence if one area is pro union do u think they should be partitioned off? am not even gonna reply to you cause i have already established you are an idiot. my comment gets thumbs up as people agree with me unlike you
Steely1888 6 months ago
@Steely1888 Since 2 cent. BC geographers huv seen Ulster as seperate from Ireland, the Romans called Ireland Hibernia and Ulster Ulidia because they saw that the people in Hibernia and Ulidia where different culturally and thats still the case the day, I dispise the idea of the "United Kingdom" and would like tae see Scotland independant but just because ae that I cannae no notice the people ae Ulster are no the same as the Irish, Ulster shouldnae be Irish or British, Ulster should be free anaw.
albagubrath90 5 months ago
@albagubrath90 - away n dont talk shite. Using your pathetic logic scotland wouldnt be a country then, cause the gaels are different from the picts and there were other scottish tribes. You telling me the "ulstermen" today are direct decendents from the ones the Romans were referring to? Anyway nice try but i can see your account is new and your a daft hun having a laugh
Steely1888 5 months ago
@Steely1888 Im no a fuckin hun ya tit, and so what if i am whit the fuck is that goat tae dae wae it, im no saein they're directed discendents either, im saein we huv tae see that they're no the same as the irish and that if they dinnae want tae be part ae ireland the dinnae huv tae be and in future if yae want ae huv a rational discussion dinnae bring religion intae it cause god isnae real and it makes yer argument weak when yae resort tae bigoted comments like callin' somebody a hun.
albagubrath90 5 months ago
@albagubrath90 - your a fuckin retard. There are parts of ulster that ARE already part of the republic of ireland, and there are 6 counties under british rule and slightly under half of those counties are irish nationalist u fool, so your gonna completely ignore that for support of the people who were sent their to divide so the british could rule it better? your a fanny, develope a brain cell and look up who Carson was, who threatened orange terror after 75% of ireland voted independence
Steely1888 5 months ago
@albagubrath90 - i wasnt bringing religion into it you tit, fs how thick are you? im talking about the politics of the place and you think of religion? your the bigot then, and your a militant atheist fuck
Steely1888 5 months ago
@Steely1888 Im hardly a militant athiest by sayin god dusnae exist, callin somebody a hun is a bigoted comment because you're only sayin that because yae thought I wus a prodestant, and I ken that three counties of Ulster are aw ready in the republic but as you say not the majority of the remainin counties want tae be in the republic, if the majority did I would more than support them but they dinnae so they souldnae huv tae be.
albagubrath90 5 months ago
@albagubrath90 - how the fuck is a "hun" sectarian and makes me bigoted? do you even know what a "hun" is, you clearly dont. a "hun" is what rangers fans get called, not members of presbyterian churches u tool, and huns are loyalist, in strong support of "ulster" (which u are). So dont even talk to me, your an idiot, and you havent got a clue, you know fuck all, go read a book u cant even spell "protestant" shows how much u know - tit
Steely1888 5 months ago
@albagubrath90 - am blocking you now cause i cannot be arsed with your uneducated views and pathetic replies. Majority of Ireland did want to be independent and voted on it and 75% voted YES therefore by democracy they should of been independent but no. Carson threatened orange terror if ireland were to be newly formed independent which is why your beloved "ulster" exists as a sectarian state. The Irish people were robbed of their freedom and have a right to struggle on
Steely1888 5 months ago
@Steely1888 Why bother wasting your breath on uneducated, unpleasant and unrepentantly unionist 'people' that spew out vulgar views on youtube...views that fly in the face of decent people who hold values like fairness, mercy and democracy in low esteem. 'People' who have generation after generation of hatred and twisted ideas bred into them.
felipescotland77 5 months ago
@Steely1888 The only time I sometimes get through to certain 'people' is when I hypothesise: "Imagine Scotland gained full independence from the so-called 'union' by majority vote via democratic elections, but a majority of people in say Ayrshire start spouting pro union defiance against the democratically free Scotland and threaten horrific sectarian violence if they are not allowed to remain part of the union...." Well my answer to them would be "Fuck off to England...Scotland is now free"
felipescotland77 5 months ago
...I am shocked — but not surprised — to say that many people think that it would be acceptable for a region to split from Scotland and remain in the UK. It's the ultimate in double-standards! In our lifetime, majority vote has unfortunately kept Scotland part of the UK — this is acceptable to these unionists, but they suddenly change their minds at the idea of that same vote making Scotland free and feel it would be ok for a region to go against the majority and divide the country!
felipescotland77 5 months ago
@felipescotland77 - your only getting one reply from me so fuck off after this, yes after independence unionist fucks should go live in the remains of the UK. Your that unionist arent you? Unionists in america exiled after the patriots won so unionists in scotland would be no different. How am i uneducated i fucking educated a few people who came out with unionist attacks, anyway nice to see a die hard unionist listening to a Jacobite song
Steely1888 5 months ago
@Steely1888 What are you talking about dude...Im a nationalist who believes in free Scotland! How dare you let your foolish anger boil over and rant at someone (me) who AGREED with your posts and who was lending you support! And how fuken dare you call me a unionist! you need to calm domn and make an attempt to read my posts again without the red mist of anger getting your wires crossed.
felipescotland77 5 months ago
Oh and once you realise we are on the same side and once you re-read my posts and realise you interpreted them completely the wrong way around...please then be aware of the history of the song here and that, unfortunately, it is NOT a pro Jacobite song. Please go and read some encyclopedias and learn about the anti-jacobite origins of this song and the slightly more moderate tone its lyrics have taken while it was tweaked over the decades.
felipescotland77 5 months ago
@felipescotland77 "it is NOT a pro Jacobite song." Unfortunately some people just don't actually listen to lyrics of songs. Because it has Jacobite in the title many presume it is a Jacobite song. It is clearly ludicrous that anyone could think it is pro-Jacobite as it clearly blames them and their doctrines for the conflict. Sometimes too folk have real trouble in understanding that many of these songs are purely entertainment. Just because Burns wrote one anti-Jacobite song it doesn't mean
gaconnochie 4 months ago
@albagubrath90 - anyway nice try taiginator
Steely1888 5 months ago
@Steely1888 Ken whit Im fed tryin tae reason wae yea, if the majority ae the remainin counties dinnae want tae be part ae the republic they shouldnae huv tae be thats aw Im sayin.
albagubrath90 5 months ago
@mrdfitz1 - ulster is not even a country so it is not for "ulstermen" your region came into existance due to crazy unionist royalist loyalists forming a terrorist group. You are not native, your either of scottish borderland descent and you live so far south you dont know if your scottish or english so you people came to the conclusion that ye were "british". Scotland and Ireland are celtic countries, emphasis on the COUNTRIES. "ulster" goes against democracy when 75% voted yes on independence
Steely1888 6 months ago
Saxons ftw xD but UP THE SCOTS!
Maverickthebroken1 7 months ago
@Maverickthebroken1 - Whats saxons got to do with Scots? saxons are from saxony in germany, and they took over england then later the normans took over england. "saxons" connotates englishmen
Steely1888 6 months ago
@Maverickthebroken1 saxons is more a culture legacy than a genetical group....20% highest in NE england + east anglia...most "brits" descend from first settlers from basque region moving up after ice retreated
3tangle3 6 months ago
I am sorry to inform you all that this song is about non combat - why its wrong to fight.
ashbannor 7 months ago
@ashbannor Quite so. The original source song Burns based this on is vehemently anti-Jacobite. Burns tones it down making it more anti-war than anti-Jacobite. Though he still blames them for the conflict in it. "You Jacobites by name....your faults I will proclaim....your doctrines I will blame...you shall hear"
gaconnochie 7 months ago
I am sorry to inform you all that this song is about non combat - why its wrong to fight.
ashbannor 7 months ago
It's beautifull.-man would like to go out and kick anybody in face - super!
Easy guys. I'm peacefull boy, but this song is very energious and combat. I love to ride listening this and "Caide sin do'n te sin" by Boreash
Irioncal 7 months ago
FUCK yer 12th of July...the Jacobites live on!
Bobajamin 7 months ago
Stuff the polotics i'll be 60 this year and and have every type or gig from Pink Floyd to the Royal Philharmonic and have o say the nihjt I saw thr Corries was one of the best gigs i've eer seen Eddie
urphyma456 8 months ago 2
@urphyma456 Well said, Urphyma456. Whenever my Scottish ears hear the passion that is this song, it's not politics that I'm left thinking about, rather it's a renewed feeling of the beauty of life. The Corries did indeed rock, wish I had seen them play live, too - still there's always YouTube. :-)
DrewWlliams 8 months ago
the sensibilities of the minority nations. In Scotland's case they didn't!
gaconnochie 9 months ago
Scottish Office and legislation differed from what went on in England. Once the Scottish Office had no mandate, and because they didn't recognise that and took no notice of Scottish opinion, then the whole system didn't work. Decentralisation was inevitable. It was only a matter of how far that decentralisation would go! For a union to work when t is made up of three small countries and one large represented by one parliament then the representatives of the large country need to take heed of
gaconnochie 9 months ago
@TheMightOfTheEnglish in terms of votes yes in theory our votes are equal but in reality they are not. This is because uk politicians care little for the Scottish vote, it is less numerous than the english one and they therefore do not try to represent the Scottish people. This then leads to governments being elected with only English interests at heart causing them to take decisions that are detrimental to the Scottish people I won't insult your intelligence by giving examples, there's to many
danonutube1 9 months ago
@danonutube1 Absolutely correct. During the Thatcher years the political scene in Scotland diverged from that in England. Under that Tory administration the Scottish Secretary stopped being Scotland's man in the Cabinet and instead became the Cabinet's man in Scotland. He was there to force Thatcher's policies, backed by the English electorate, on to a Scotland who had given them no mandate. Scotland has always been run differently from England as most of what is now devolved was run by the
gaconnochie 9 months ago
@TheMightOfTheEnglish @TheMightOfTheEnglish I agree with your view on Europe I for one would not see Scotland gain it's independence from England only to surrender it to Europe. However this does not in any way destroy my argument as we may get less money from Europe but we would keep our own money. the deficit of Scotland is significantly less than the rest of uk meaning we would be able to support ourselves with insignificant investment borrowing compared with the millions loaned to London
danonutube1 9 months ago
Comment removed
danonutube1 9 months ago
@gaconnochie neither do I it was a typical I'll informed response intended to demonize anything that opposes Britannia by making it a criminal offence oh well roll on the referendum
danonutube1 9 months ago
Comment removed
danonutube1 9 months ago
@johnjohnnyist the law is not always right many laws have been created that good men have risked their lives to break a traitor to Scotland is not someone who disagrees with the monarchy, it is someone who refuses to stand up for the people. The people of scotland deserve the same rights as any other country they deserve and eventually they will demand, nation status
danonutube1 9 months ago
@danonutube1 I don't know why the other poster brought the law into it. There is nothing unlawful or unconstitutional about the Nats holding an independence referendum - or people debating it. The UK govt has conceded that!
gaconnochie 9 months ago
@danonutube1 in what way doesnt scotland have the same rights as everyone else ? you are a nation within the united kingdom. my vote isnt worth any more than yours , your free to do anything you want , being part of europe destroys your argument , look at the outside interference has done to this country , its not a level playing field , id be more concerned with staying in europe , than the union if i was you, you may get european money being a small nation, but at what price
TheMightOfTheEnglish 9 months ago
"Scotland in the UK4Ever"
I wouldn't be so sure about that, Watch this space.
1scot4scotland 9 months ago
Check out Shannon version, for me the best in the universe ;p
prym29 9 months ago
For all you folks posting your opinion (which I respect) that Scotland will not become independent I say simply watch this space.
rabnuds 9 months ago
@rabnuds I don't think any of us should debate whether scotland will become independent - that's presumably what the referendum would decide
johnjohnnyist 9 months ago
@johnjohnnyist What a strange thing to say! there is no presumtion about it, of course that's what a referendum will decide. I was not trying to start a debate I was simply giving an opinion as others were.
rabnuds 9 months ago
@johnjohnnyist There will be much debating from now right up until the referendum. It is a strange thing to suggest it shouldn't be debated prior to the vote. How else are people to decide? The problem is that there hasn't been a lot of debating about it up until now. The unionist parties at Holyrood have simply avoided the issue by dismissing it as an irrelevance.Now because the Nats have a majority they (the unionists) are going to have to debate it.
gaconnochie 9 months ago
Aye, Rabbie Burns, But Walt disnae!-old scotish joke, since the SDP got in we now have a chance of a FREE Land....steve god bless Scotland ( and let wales ane ireland gain their independence too!)
remeclerk 10 months ago in playlist all
@remeclerk I think you've made a wee typo there. The SDP merged with the Liberal Party to become the Liberal Democrats and they got trounced at the election. I take it you mean SNP :-)
gaconnochie 10 months ago
@gaconnochie LOL your right, but then again ive been away for so long I forget whose who!...Steve
remeclerk 10 months ago
@remeclerk surely it's quite difficult to get mixed up between the SDP abd the SNP?
Soz just found that difficult to believe
johnjohnnyist 9 months ago
@johnjohnnyist well when you get to my age.....its just a load of letters!-LOL, anyhow I still advocate a free scotland!!!!! Steve
remeclerk 9 months ago
Lol @ all the scottish revolution nutjobs in here who don't realise Scotland would be broke in a week if it seperated. It relies on England for almost everything.
Eiraha 10 months ago 2
don't feed the troll people, just flag all of this ignorant idiot's comments as spam and treat him like the petulant 4 year old that he seems so determined to look like, this argument has gone on for many many months and isn't likely to stop any time soon, don't waste your time playing his childish games
hXc232 10 months ago
@TheXand19 You loyalist counts need to fuck off out of Scotland and Ireland you only want to stay in the uk so can avoid controversy with the English. You would rather fight yer own people than fight for them, you are both a coward and a traitor to scotland fuk off u cunt
danonutube1 10 months ago
@danonutube1 Actually in the eyes of the law you're the traitor and without the rule of law what is there?
Scotland and Ulster uniionists together!
johnjohnnyist 9 months ago
@Ewolf98 - well it was mainly scots lowlanders that fought for the patriots, the highlanders were redcoats fighting the patriots, the scots need to get along man, the generation before that it was highlanders fighting red coats and lowland scots lol. we need to unite and get the loyalists and english oot
Steely1888 11 months ago
@Steely1888 what do you mean English get out,there aint no English in uk ,its full of blacks Paki,s poles,Russians and about everything else,
retardedjoe12 11 months ago
Up the Jacobites and the fight for freedom
danonutube1 11 months ago 14
@USAsoldier: 50% of you american are german :-)
DieterB62 1 year ago
"Like any other Virtue, Tolerance is only defined by God....and is always INTOLERANT of EVIL."
You recognize that?
And you, as a Marine, are gonna tell me that you would not be evil if you killed a man waving a white flag, just because that's your orders?
Who gives your orders, your fucking Generals or God?
Would God want you to kill innocent People, to kill 17 years old boys?
Where is God in a world in wich Soldiers killing civilians are honoured by Kings and Queens?
stikkbomb 1 year ago
@akropiss well we are all closer to the original settler who were pre celtic,,,,,but as a welsh geneticist I agree with your sentiments....dont forget the welsh includes the cornish and strathclyde britons/cumbrians.
Whereever you are from its not important its the CULTURE!! and its been totally pushed back to these islands fringes ignored during the empire days..and still is to an extent
3tangle3 1 year ago
@3tangle3 Why do Celtic & Pre-Celtic strains remain so strong despite multi-cultural Roman, Scandinavian/Germanic conquest & settlement? Celts seem to be a multi-ethnic Cultural Union.
Could different ethnicities be the same peoples overlapping under different cultural guises -- over time?
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 It is because the actual genetical input from these later invasions is surprisingly very low......but this depends on the area. Some parts of Western Wales and Western Ireland can have 95-98% of population being majority iberian 'pre celtic' settlers (celtic being an evolved european culture) with several later celtic invasions bringing their own genetic tint to the proceedings :D, and this can very between person to person, the actual difference is small however just potent
3tangle3 1 year ago
2 people are clearly not jacobite XD
Angus333McBride 1 year ago
can anyone explain what the song is really about
no just BPC
armaghlore 1 year ago
smell ma boaby lol
BAMitsMURRAY 1 year ago
Actually, we Euro peoples prefer Canadians over USA twonks. They're less arrognat, less ignorant and dont think they're amazing because they come from the colony's.
On another note, anyone who is racist will never be recognised as a fellow Scotsman.
Aww ye glaikits can get back te arguin our yer ain wee skags ae land an leave Alba oota it.
RoFethos 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@RoFethos Aye ye wee fag, an tak yer woggie stik an ram it up yer paki bum! America is now the TRUE SCOTLAND....more Scots HERE! ;D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 USA has neer been the true Scotland and will never be. USA sucks, Scotland rules.
williamdargie06 1 year ago
@williamdargie06 = Somalian fanny on the dole ruled by true Scots....in the USA! :D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 Warning: don't feed the troll.
TrollsNeedATroll 11 months ago
@USAsoldier1955 you are an embarrassment to Scottish descendants the world over - as well as an equal embarrassment to Americans. I am both - a Scottish descendant living in the USA (my grandfather came here from Scotland). To the Scots posting here: I was raised to love my heritage and to support an independent Scotland - why wouldn't I, an American, have the right to post here. I am also a Republican - meaning that US political affiliation has very little bearing on the subject.
MrDarkShadow64 11 months ago
@MrDarkShadow64 = Phony Scotsman Lying Embarrassment To His Family & The Republican Party
USAsoldier1955 11 months ago
Happy New Year from Hooks N Crooks!
wilsonj1954 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@akropiss
@akropiss balls, the true original British are the Welsh, the English were always a Germanic people going right back to their Anglo Saxon origins. Shut up if you can't even use the right word.
adouglasmhor 1 year ago
@akropiss balls, the true original British are the Welsh, the English were always a Germanic people going right back to their Anglo Saxon origins. Shut up if you can't even use the right word.
adouglasmhor 1 year ago
lern2readhistory about scotland and the jackobites
honorablegod 1 year ago
Rossmcl177 I am or my family are not part of what u say. i am from The true Jacobite Atholl highlanders. Which we took no part in any english rules untill ww1/2 So bite yer tongue m8 really pls do. My ancestors fought in 1700s last battle to be |FREE from English rule and to this day we stand by it. Robertson Clan
Grouter12 1 year ago
stop fighting.......english or scottish...the brythons were here before i.e welsh and cornish....but anyway i am not too bothered....what you should be united about is the fucking centralised state and the monarchy leaching all the hard taxpayers money...wtf.....!!!
3tangle3 1 year ago
English republican and proud.
1982CFD 1 year ago
This tune's a belter.
1982CFD 1 year ago
scottish and PROUD!!!!!!!!!!!!
theliontails1 1 year ago
I'm nearly 60 years old and i'v seen a few live gigs in my time I saw The Corries at the Hexagon Reading in the 80's and have to sy it still ranks as one of the best live gigs i've ever seen
urphyma 1 year ago
@urphyma Lucky you !
kyuuzoryuusuke 1 year ago
+ God Bless King Billy, & the Loyal Orange Cause!
LOYAL Scotland in the UK Forever! :)
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 please keep comments like this out of these videos, it is just likely to spark a huge argument as scotland is very famously divided and your inbox will likely be soon full of replies like f*ck king billy and up the ra
rmartin232 1 year ago
@rmartin232 Please keep comments like YOUR'S out of these videos, it is just likely to spark nuclear war as Scotland....and all humanity....is very famously divided and your inbox will likely be soon full of replies like f*ck the RA, King Billy's On The Wall....NO Surrender, etc.
My what delightfully turgid prose! ;)
LOYAL SCOTLAND in the UK4Ever! :)
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
Comment removed
rmartin232 1 year ago
Comment removed
rmartin232 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 SHUT UP you're raving mad and ought to be locked up. you are proof that americans are lazy ignorant self-absorbed self-righteous arseholes. how dare you insult people gratuitously like that??
RobyM89 1 year ago
@RobyM89 Wee poooor Paki Lassssie! OFLOL! UK4Ever....God Save the Queen & LOYAL SCOTLAND! :D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 Racist ignorant fuck. You give Americans a bad name.
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII Racist ignorant Fag, you give Canadians a bad name....as if they didn't already have one! :D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 Last time I checked, we don't have a bad name; in fact, that's why Americans wear canadian flag pins when they go to Europe. No one wants to hear your ultra-conservative yankee bullshit.
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII Most Europeans eat Canadians....thinking they will be baled-out by the USA! Of course, that's why increasing numbers of Canadians are moving to the USA -- and becoming AMERICAN CITIZENS! :D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 What my fellow citizens do is their choice. As for being eaten by the Europeans... better than you being eaten by the middle east... and south-east asia XD have a nice day
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII Well, that's a rather RETARDED answer, EH?
Of course, the Middle-East, South-East, China, North Korea, et all are EATING EACH OTHER....after CANADIAN LEFTOVERS! :D
LOYAL SCOTLAND IN THE UK4EVER!
+ GOD SAVE THE QUEEN....of Scotland & Canada! ;)
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 Tres bien.
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII Merci
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 merci? pourquoi?
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII Pour le ;)
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 cretin
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII = paki idiot
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 To which I reiterate my initial comment, you are a racist ignorant fuck.
IIGECKOII 1 year ago
@IIGECKOII Aye, taking to yer ain fanny agin, lassie! LOL! :D
Loyal Scotland in the UK4Ever!
+ GSTQ!
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 Fuck the Queen. God Save Bonnie Prince Charlie.
tearlach45 1 year ago
@tearlach45 fuck bonnie prince charlie. singlehandedly destroyed the clan system in scotland. Made out to be a romantic hero but it couldnt be further from the truth. 35,000 to 40,000 people were slaughtered after he buggered off when his uprising imploded.
thanks carluccio.
frettish 1 year ago
@frettish The clan system was doomed for destruction long before he arrived. After Culloden, Tartan, Bagpipes and Gaelic were all banned by British law because they were all symbols of Catholicism in Scotland. It was the "glorious Protestant" religion that destroyed the clan system.
tearlach45 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 - For a Christian Minister, youre language is really inappropriate. "Somalian fanny on the dole ruled by true Scots" ???? Born and raised Roman Catholic the main message I get is that Jesus taught us to treat everyone the same no matter what religion, colour of skin etc. "every Christian nation is at War with the forces of the Antichrist Papacy, the False Prophet Mohammad"?? Do you honestly think the miraculous Jesus would have time for these pathetic views? Allahu Akbar
tearlach45 1 year ago
@tearlach45 = Phony Papist Racist Anti-Christian Bigot Mohammedan Pathetic Raghead HateMonkey
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 you DARE compare scotland to the United States of Asswholes? what brings you to the conclusion that the US of Asswholes are the "true Scotland"? has the "true scotland" vanished from the globe? im disgusted that some little republican faggot like you claims to be scottish. you know nothing of scotland or history. i have just one request: do humanity a favour and drop dead, scum of the world.
LordOfCastleBlack 1 year ago
@LordOfCastleBlack =wee Paki republican scum of the world asshole fanny lassie OFLOL! :D
Loyal Scotland in the UK4Ever!
FGAU!
GSTQ!
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 seems like your brain has been washed a few times too often :P btw: in germany we have a word for people like you: we call them nazis
LordOfCastleBlack 1 year ago
@LordOfCastleBlack Aye, ye wee German laddie, yer pate is nicht ra in yer crotch an' up yer arse! :D
BTW: On planet Earth we have a word for people like you, we call them Commie fags! :D
PS -- We only kicked your Nazi arse in WWI & WWII because of the incredible innovative & industrial STUPIDITY of the German nation! :D
Jah, Du ist shistkauff, mein freude! Seig Heil! :D
Loyal Scotland in the UK4Ever! :)
+ FGAU! :)
+ GSTQ! :)
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 HAHAHAHA im pretty suprised you know how to spell germany. its interesting that republicans tend to call everyone who stands against their ideas a commie. and you call me commie AND nazi in one post? you should really take some histoy lessons if you have something like that in your third world country you call USA... btw: you should just use a language if your capable of finding it on a map. uups - seems like you shouldnt use any language.
LordOfCastleBlack 1 year ago
@LordOfCastleBlack = scheisskopf
My sincere apologies for the typo in my last post! :D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 woooow - you found the google translator - bravo.
LordOfCastleBlack 1 year ago
@LordOfCastleBlack You ARE the GOOGLE TRANSLATOR....God Help us! ;)
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 god has nothing to do with this, wanna-be scotsman.
LordOfCastleBlack 1 year ago
@LordOfCastleBlack Blames God For His Wee Failed Wanker Wannabe American
;D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 btw: "you are the google translator" now youve really hit me, dont you? how old are you??! twelve? your language is on the level of a premature schoolyardmonkey - oh, i forgot, youre a republican - explains everything
LordOfCastleBlack 1 year ago
@LordOfCastleBlack = 11 year old immature schoolyard monkey wee German Nazi republican
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago
@USAsoldier1955 First of all: Nazis are not welcome in Germany, and people like you who say all germans are Nazis will not survive long if they come to Germany. So, I ask you to please, for Gods sake:
Shut the fuck up because you don't know nothing about anything. Faggot.
Second: If you want Scotland to be loyal to the Brits. why were you american not loyal to the fuckin brits, hm?
stikkbomb 1 year ago
@stikkbomb = wee german fag laddie failing to wank
PS - We Americans ARE British, that's why we had the Revolution -- ye clod! READ! :D
USAsoldier1955 1 year ago