Try playing Lee's bass lines (and singing) simultaneously, Lifeson's guitar riffs/arpeggios and solos, and finally Peart's syncopated drum rhythms. None of the above is easy to perform.
The "musicians" in many of the so-called bands of today would be completely and utterly out of their depth i.e. bands like say McFly or U2. Rush's complicated awesome music could well be described as being on a "timeless wavelength"!!
Wow. First off: very well played! I like how you pretty much nailed the feel of the song, even though your tone is so different.
Secondly: I'm guessing you learned by ear? There are a few areas where you're missing detail or play it a bit differently to Geddy, but that's OK. I really (really) like that you doubled with the synth in the break, though.
I see you've also covered "Show Don't Tell"; I think there's a little bit of that in this cover, too. (e.g. 0:40) ;)
damn! simply amazing! i just started playing the bass 15 weeks ago. i'm playing on a 5 string right now but i know it's going to take me years to play on a six string and probably a couple of decades to get to your skill.
Good job, man. This is one of the most epic rock songs of all time. Great Geddy scream and a killer bassline at the same time, classic Rush sound. You capture it nicely. Cool thing about Rush covers is that it's cool to overdo the bass!
I like your volume on the vids. Just enough to stand out and make it clear what you're playing but not enough to cover up the song. Great playing. How does Geddy do that and sing?
Not only do you do a great job you make it look like you needed little practice. Well done. The problem with Geddy I guess has always been that he makes this look so bleeding easy on stage as if he only needs to concentrate on his vocals and timings. This is not a simple by any stretch. Geddy makes it look as if he was born with two sets of brain (looking at him it is arguable agreed) a true multi-tasking musician if there ever was one. And before anyone shoots me down; I am a Rush fan- so
Dude- you need to back the camara up a foot or so to show the whole fretboard. We can only see from about the 5th fret up. Killer chops though. Nicely done.
Man, there is something in your videos that differentiate you from all other bass covers. You not only play outstandingly well, but can get a very clean and smooth tone from your bass which is unbelievably enjoyable. Great work.
Bravo! No many players can do Geddy's finger sound attack with both hands . This guy has done his lessons, soooo smooth and relaxed in his playing. . Simply amazing. Imagine how he'd sound on a Rickenbacker 4001 or Fender. Guess I ll use these videos to fix the corners I ve been cutting for years.
Very nice man. I became a RUSH fan in 1977, when I saw them play as lead up for Ted Nugent at the Santa Monica Civic Auditorium! That was the 2112 tour, and I've seen every tour they've done since. What's really cool is that now I can afford to sit up front! What amazed me most was that Geddy was playing like he does, sings, AND plays foot pedals simultaneously! THAT is incredible!
hey man, I've been watching your stuff for quite a while now. I finally decided to start making my own vids, and Circumstances was one of them. (I'd forgotten you did it to!) I just sent it as a response. Hope you enjoy it half as much as I dig your version.
Extremely well played - how about a few more - like Digital Man or Marathon or maybe something later like Earthshine ?? I wish Geddy would post some stuff on YouTube like Myang does - but perhaps that violates some unwritten publicity rules - can't be seen mingling with all us commoners.....LOL. I'm sure your rendition would do Geddy proud, though.
what i love bout geddy is that he is naturally awesome, no need to show off with solos, every song is so complex itself is a solo,i still love yyz cause its bass line just goes hard the full length and is all over theplace!! rush and you rock!!
I don't get how it's possible... He's probably some superbeing. He has multiple different brains that account for different functions of playing music...
Hey bro great job man...i personally think you may be one of the best bass player on youtube. Is that a warwick bass your playing? Just wondering....it sounds phnominal! Im not sure where your at as far as playing outside of youtube... but you definatley play at a professional level.
by the time it takes to perfect a bass line like that, you would probably be able to play it while sleeping. i'm sure entheogenesis could sing along if he wanted to.
from what i heard this past summer, it was exactly the same. i don't know of any songs where Geddy plays a simplified version. the only song where i have heard him say he had trouble playing bass while singing was Turn the Page. however, if you listen to A Show of Hands, he plays the original line and sings during the live performance.
I LOVE all of the Rush vids your have made. You are great bassist and musician. You have obviously mastered your instrument and you make music with it. Unlike some "players" who just wank on their instruments and play as fast as possible without dynamic contrasts or sense of phrase, you sir are musically interesting. I am especially impressed with your phrasing and articulation. I would love to see a video of you cover the bass part for By-Tor and the Snowdog!!! 5/5
nice guitar man
forgedby2112 2 months ago
That tone is perfect!
PurpleFalcon7 5 months ago
...SICK...
souljour2000 5 months ago
Geddy is the best.
davidlm6974 6 months ago
to think geddy plays and sings this...
spoon149 6 months ago 7
@spoon149 dont forget he's doin the synthesizers too
forgedby2112 2 months ago
escapa0020, someone else posted that on another topic. It's lame that if you like rush so much that you have to copy a compliment.
BeowulfVids 6 months ago
Hypnotic.
Absolutely beautiful.
easyas314 7 months ago
Well done. Beautiful playing
wooglin1968 7 months ago
Holy Shit! How does Geddy sing and play this at the same time?
TairyGreen89 7 months ago 4
excellent playing and so effortless- nicely done
alheeley 7 months ago
Good job kinfolk
LAMB0Fg0d420 8 months ago
RIGHT LET'S STOP MESSING ABOUT!!
Try playing Lee's bass lines (and singing) simultaneously, Lifeson's guitar riffs/arpeggios and solos, and finally Peart's syncopated drum rhythms. None of the above is easy to perform.
The "musicians" in many of the so-called bands of today would be completely and utterly out of their depth i.e. bands like say McFly or U2. Rush's complicated awesome music could well be described as being on a "timeless wavelength"!!
Does anyone else agree?
ecapa0020 1 year ago 14
@ecapa0020 No I don't agree. You didn't mention playing bass pedals with their feet on top of all that. ;)
electricchaos 1 month ago in playlist More videos from entheogenesis
6 People lost to him in chopsticks.
prognosis2112 1 year ago
wow respect!!GREAT JOB.
incrediblewild 1 year ago
6 people were assraped by a dick the size of Geddy's awesomeness
TOSportsFan1990 1 year ago 2
Great really! Well until now , I never realized how complex the bass was in this song, but of course its Rush and its Geddy. Cool
gonzgeorge 1 year ago
Wow. First off: very well played! I like how you pretty much nailed the feel of the song, even though your tone is so different.
Secondly: I'm guessing you learned by ear? There are a few areas where you're missing detail or play it a bit differently to Geddy, but that's OK. I really (really) like that you doubled with the synth in the break, though.
I see you've also covered "Show Don't Tell"; I think there's a little bit of that in this cover, too. (e.g. 0:40) ;)
Great Stuff!
identiticrisis 1 year ago
how the fuck does geddy lee play that while singing?
silveroon009 1 year ago 4
@silveroon009 Because hes GEDDY LEE!! THATS HOW!! :P
Shadows622 1 year ago
6 people missed the like button
zanarian11 1 year ago
@zanarian11 and those 6 people who missed the like button are now in chuck norris's to-do list
cameronj279 1 year ago
damn! simply amazing! i just started playing the bass 15 weeks ago. i'm playing on a 5 string right now but i know it's going to take me years to play on a six string and probably a couple of decades to get to your skill.
xOmumblesOx 1 year ago
THAT LITTLE LICK AT 3:14 ALWAYS GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS !
WELL DONE SIR
greg77hot 1 year ago
Yeah good job...definitely different with the six and the tone being active is different, but you do an amazing job on the riffing..very articulate
rushnroulette1 1 year ago
Who the fuck are the six people who don't like this?
frrrrrunkis 1 year ago 2
@frrrrrunkis probably Jason Bieber lovers
xOmumblesOx 1 year ago
@frrrrrunkis They're Lady CaCa/JustinE Beaver fans.
sbrushfan 1 year ago
Lovely great music, and you must be the best bass player I know tbh.
Really nice videos!
Metaldrummer100 1 year ago
Good job, man. This is one of the most epic rock songs of all time. Great Geddy scream and a killer bassline at the same time, classic Rush sound. You capture it nicely. Cool thing about Rush covers is that it's cool to overdo the bass!
RCAvhstape 1 year ago
Damn i like this cover!
Jak3Mac 1 year ago
dude your amazing how long have you been playing
MrTomsanders 1 year ago
awebo
JIMVOMIT 1 year ago
I like your volume on the vids. Just enough to stand out and make it clear what you're playing but not enough to cover up the song. Great playing. How does Geddy do that and sing?
udreksuh 1 year ago
very good! just like geddy!
betyerass 1 year ago
BEAST!
/love
Jak3Mac 1 year ago
nice dude , good song to play too ; )
SnareExtraordinair 1 year ago
amazing, now just be able to sing it...
GeddyRulez 1 year ago
kick ass complex playin with years of practice!!!
killcraz 2 years ago
great stuff Sean :-) smooth .
Garyquango 2 years ago
Flawless, my friend. You are a top notch bassist.
Andytheminstrel 2 years ago
Fantastic!!!!!Great job!!!
Doommaster69 2 years ago
awesome job dude, wish i could get you in my band
ironwolg 2 years ago
I have the same screensaver on my computer haha.
Underscore2112 2 years ago
beautifully done brother! A pleasure to watch.
merlinmcmagic 2 years ago
You just plug into cubase and record with no EQ or sound retouching? Your bass have a really good sound, what mics are you using?
chicalleje 2 years ago
very well bro, just tune the bass
apioman1 2 years ago
fukin sick dude
lookatme9778 2 years ago
Holy shit! This is soooo hard and you are sooo good! Indeed the best bassline cover ive seen
FireAssasin 2 years ago
If you can play this - you can play anything!
Really, this is what I call awesome bass playin´!
I´m a great Rush-Fan, and Geddy´s Basslines are like cherries on top of an huge ice-cream pot!
Rules!
MoDangerFlint 2 years ago
Not only do you do a great job you make it look like you needed little practice. Well done. The problem with Geddy I guess has always been that he makes this look so bleeding easy on stage as if he only needs to concentrate on his vocals and timings. This is not a simple by any stretch. Geddy makes it look as if he was born with two sets of brain (looking at him it is arguable agreed) a true multi-tasking musician if there ever was one. And before anyone shoots me down; I am a Rush fan- so
aslambukhatir 2 years ago 8
This is just amazing. Nice playing man!
Geddy is amazing at writing the sickest bass lines ever.
HomesliceDrummer 2 years ago
Nice little touch adapting part of the keyboard solo for the bass.
Very classy indeed.
wsg2112 2 years ago
Man, just perfect!
jonasrenato 2 years ago
Thanks man, now I have to change my pants! LOL...awesome!
frrrrrunkis 2 years ago
amazing, dude!!!!
watchyourst3p 2 years ago
Phenomenal. Wish I had time to practice like this guy, although somehow I doubt I could ever be as good; he's obviously got some crazy talent...
ChromeSoup 2 years ago
2:34 jaw dropping how perfect that pull off hammer on was
DeltaGaryGordon 2 years ago
On level of difficulty/impressiveness, what would you say is higher?
Cupid's Dead by Extreme
or this?
JoeMomma2455 2 years ago
Dude- you need to back the camara up a foot or so to show the whole fretboard. We can only see from about the 5th fret up. Killer chops though. Nicely done.
OddManFoSho 2 years ago
Damn, that's so smooth. I always loved Geddy's bass lines. You do a great job.
pepper123 2 years ago
crap, you are good. i'm addicted to your basslines now. i love that riff at 0:39. you did that just perfect.
TheRush250r 2 years ago
your bass sounds great i want it
idk590127 2 years ago
great job now you have to sing too
lol
761178 2 years ago
I love the tone of that bass!
Rangerpwner 2 years ago
that looks hard to play
shartne 2 years ago
it is ive tried and gave up. imagine what its like for geddy lee singing while playing this
malignantbassist 2 years ago
Man, there is something in your videos that differentiate you from all other bass covers. You not only play outstandingly well, but can get a very clean and smooth tone from your bass which is unbelievably enjoyable. Great work.
leasm 2 years ago 36
do you record all your vids at once? your pants had the same hole in the yyz vid lol
golfis4triangles4 2 years ago 4
Great!
4zinger 2 years ago
Bravo! No many players can do Geddy's finger sound attack with both hands . This guy has done his lessons, soooo smooth and relaxed in his playing. . Simply amazing. Imagine how he'd sound on a Rickenbacker 4001 or Fender. Guess I ll use these videos to fix the corners I ve been cutting for years.
penzman 2 years ago 4
Woah :D
Louisbass0017 2 years ago
4 of 5 man, awesome :)
tehnrdholeguy 2 years ago
4/5?!
7/5!
RushPwnsX 2 years ago
You six-string guys are always fretbord acrobats. Incredible.
djlucy1 3 years ago 33
@djlucy1 Just remember! Geddy did this one over a 4-string one, so if he can do it, so can you! (and me! heh)
kiyoshi11 1 year ago
@djlucy1 I'm scared to move up from 5 to 6 simply because I'm not that flexible with my hands yet
Maxiamaru 8 months ago
Very nice man. I became a RUSH fan in 1977, when I saw them play as lead up for Ted Nugent at the Santa Monica Civic Auditorium! That was the 2112 tour, and I've seen every tour they've done since. What's really cool is that now I can afford to sit up front! What amazed me most was that Geddy was playing like he does, sings, AND plays foot pedals simultaneously! THAT is incredible!
BigZub 3 years ago 7
My hat is off to you sir. I can only learn, thank you :)
BlueMeanieSulk 3 years ago 4
all your stuff is great dude.
bchoopster234 3 years ago
I think my favorite rush bass line... and you really rock... I like to watch your stuff... beautifully played note after note... congrats!
fabin69 3 years ago
I have 2 questions; How does Geddy do it with just 4 strings (vs your 6) and sing too? Is he human?
eggo63 3 years ago
well first of all hes in the same band as neil pert and alex lifeson, and second, no. lol Geddy is amazing!!!! by far my fav. bassist
KongWubba867 3 years ago
i think this guy is only using four of the six srings anyway. love his tone.
mjdillaha 3 years ago
He manages to combine the higher notes with this song,,, It's not so hard.
coosomo 3 years ago
good job
ironfistvideos 3 years ago
Nicely done grasshopper.
raneybird 3 years ago
Awesome!
Geddy Lee can sing at the same time
GOD LEE
JavateamAndre 3 years ago
awesome, one of my fav. rush tunes/bass lines
tewest99 3 years ago
coolest bridge EVER
rainbowmonkey27 3 years ago
hey man, I've been watching your stuff for quite a while now. I finally decided to start making my own vids, and Circumstances was one of them. (I'd forgotten you did it to!) I just sent it as a response. Hope you enjoy it half as much as I dig your version.
Spector2112 3 years ago
Phenomenal. I absolutely love your videos. Keep posting!
robison100 3 years ago
Comment removed
Louisbass0017 3 years ago
Went to your channel. Where is your version of this song?
netwolf 3 years ago
Comment removed
Louisbass0017 3 years ago
well how are people supposed to see them if you delete them? :P
superbus69 3 years ago
Comment removed
Louisbass0017 3 years ago
vov dude u've got serious skill. Nicely done
wagsbass 3 years ago
this is the image (or video) of perfection.
fanofthemusic1090 3 years ago
Dude, That rules. You rule! But now play it while singing and playing taurus pedels and keys. Killer job though.
briprior71 3 years ago
I know, huh. How does Geddy do it while singing. No matter what, the bass player in the video does an excellent job. I wonder if Geddy has seen this.
oceandojo 3 years ago
Just started playing bass. Not sure I'll ever get that good :( Freakin' awesome, man.
Evilwhiteguy 3 years ago
well played man.
staysictonkpils 3 years ago
You sure got Geddy Lee covered. mind blowing
loosenutlambert 3 years ago
good lord that b line is busy....never noticed how intricate it was on hemispheres.
kipdikenedyhobgood 3 years ago
Wtf man? What more is there really to say?...
Your "chops" stand alone! As sturdy & fluid as can be! Btw, Great show in Det. supporting DT, back in early spring here! Solid sound!
Cheers for posting mate!
EndlesslyRocking 3 years ago
yeah man you ROCK!
codibick 3 years ago
Nice, nice, nice!!!
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago
You are very skillful
o0lafi610o 3 years ago
great video
what bass is that?
nidius123 3 years ago
look on his profile
Ferronator 3 years ago
You dominate every song you post.
SaxMachine124 3 years ago 3
NICE BASS NICE PLAYING NICE SOUND
M666M666 3 years ago
Playing this bass line is impressive in itself, much less singing at the same time
lafleursucks 3 years ago 5
AWESOME
JavateamAndre 3 years ago
I love this bassline. And you play it like a badass. Awesome.
catchyossarian 3 years ago 3
Incredible! I love this song! This made my favorite list with ease.
mandalay71 3 years ago
nice! The tone is perfect
bassism1 3 years ago
Great job on my fav song from my fav album! Super!
si9mund 3 years ago
awesome
RichDiaz99 3 years ago
people wonder how geddy can play this and sing at the same time. heres my answer hes a robot
yearealsmrt 3 years ago
You have your timing down perfect!
I can do the same along with the Professor.
Just great......
Pipeloader 3 years ago
your a god dude...gave me fukkin goosebumps man
dinglenutzz 3 years ago
Hoew the fuck Geddy plays that and sings at the same time Ill never know
lafleursucks 3 years ago 3
Fucking Perfect!!!!
torturekiller2006 3 years ago
grande bassista grande band potenza e melodia!!!!!!
claudio211274 3 years ago
keep up the good work!
TornadoWarrior1 3 years ago
excepcional player.
5* to you.
keep good job!
amoximed 3 years ago
Extremely well played - how about a few more - like Digital Man or Marathon or maybe something later like Earthshine ?? I wish Geddy would post some stuff on YouTube like Myang does - but perhaps that violates some unwritten publicity rules - can't be seen mingling with all us commoners.....LOL. I'm sure your rendition would do Geddy proud, though.
villastrangiato 3 years ago
Who died and made you Geddy Lee??
jlamb666 3 years ago 2
what i love bout geddy is that he is naturally awesome, no need to show off with solos, every song is so complex itself is a solo,i still love yyz cause its bass line just goes hard the full length and is all over theplace!! rush and you rock!!
nadkath2 3 years ago 4
nice
thrashpamplona 3 years ago
How I like this song, I might make a cover myself one day!
mrfred24 3 years ago
wow
ajcard920 3 years ago
This guy teaches me how to play bass
arbitermatt 3 years ago 2
Yeah, i practice with him hahaha
Lordchipa 3 years ago
Nice, nice, nice!!!
WRITERCAB 3 years ago
After Geddy Lee , You are the best bassman that I seen !!!
michaudsimon 3 years ago
LOL "bassman"
Demonicwolfworm 3 years ago
you know what's fucked?
he can do this and sing at the same time
Demonicwolfworm 3 years ago 4
what's more fucked is he can do this, sing and play synth pedals
RyanCush 3 years ago
Yeah that too!
I don't get how it's possible... He's probably some superbeing. He has multiple different brains that account for different functions of playing music...
Demonicwolfworm 3 years ago
One can only hope.
RyanCoosh 3 years ago
haha this guy gives me guitar lessons :D
danney69 3 years ago
Lucky.
Castnkill 3 years ago
I would give my up my left nut to have this guy give me guitar lessons :P
fear00donut 3 years ago
Nice man! I saw you and Redemption opening for Dream Theater in August :D
musicdude93 4 years ago
nice job !!! =) i must practice more on my bass playing.
kossukala 4 years ago
This rocks man. My 18 month old little baby LOVES the sound. My little RUSH Fan. Thanks for the tunes!
knicksyankees 4 years ago 2
Hey bro great job man...i personally think you may be one of the best bass player on youtube. Is that a warwick bass your playing? Just wondering....it sounds phnominal! Im not sure where your at as far as playing outside of youtube... but you definatley play at a professional level.
slysterone123 4 years ago
Bad ass.
But Geddy is still the man.
bfntn 4 years ago
Fabulous!! Shame I can't see your fingers though.
floouk 4 years ago
Wow! & Wow!
mikens1 4 years ago
and geddy sings meanwhile... how can you do that ???
ppdevoto 4 years ago
by the time it takes to perfect a bass line like that, you would probably be able to play it while sleeping. i'm sure entheogenesis could sing along if he wanted to.
ComedyKilla 4 years ago
im just guessin but does he play a slightly simplified bassline live? most people who sing and play instruments do
tomlewis1 4 years ago
from what i heard this past summer, it was exactly the same. i don't know of any songs where Geddy plays a simplified version. the only song where i have heard him say he had trouble playing bass while singing was Turn the Page. however, if you listen to A Show of Hands, he plays the original line and sings during the live performance.
ComedyKilla 4 years ago
thats why hes the best!
tomlewis1 4 years ago
plus ca change, plus ce la meme chose my friend...
amberts 4 years ago
I've talked to you before but I have to reiterate that you have the most amazing tone I've ever heard.
SplinterSplunge 4 years ago 2
Now that you mention it, it is very nice. Not too bassy, not too toney or chorusey, it's just right.
2112Gauge 4 years ago 3
good job.
Flunder 4 years ago
Sick
xyz321123 4 years ago
thanks for posting
brian2315 4 years ago
this is the closest i've seen it played perfectly aside from myself. very good bro.
one of the harder basslines by rush.
darthbogan2 4 years ago
geddy does the same while singing! whoa!
voidstuff 4 years ago
No shit?!
MuppetJunior 4 years ago
You told right but Geddy is ONE like no one else!
lucauomo 4 years ago
you can thank the rush forum for all you hits, but great job anyways :)
rushringleader 4 years ago
D'oh!
I thought I could play! Good job man!
jayjco 4 years ago
I LOVE all of the Rush vids your have made. You are great bassist and musician. You have obviously mastered your instrument and you make music with it. Unlike some "players" who just wank on their instruments and play as fast as possible without dynamic contrasts or sense of phrase, you sir are musically interesting. I am especially impressed with your phrasing and articulation. I would love to see a video of you cover the bass part for By-Tor and the Snowdog!!! 5/5
BobbyLiebling 4 years ago 2
FABULOUS!!!!!! INCREDIBLE!!!!
apg72 4 years ago
It's scary that you can play it as good as Geddy, and it's even scarier thet you play it better that Geddy! Good Job!
TinyPigeon 4 years ago
yes he may, but can he sing and play those bass parts.
woloschuk123 4 years ago
f****g awesome dude!!!these basslines are very difficult and you play it with a lot of precision!!!!very very good dude!!!
airraidsiren82 4 years ago
how long have you been playing?
metalgopher 4 years ago
(wierd bass) but awsome bass line rock on!!!!!!!!
woloschuk123 4 years ago
Wierd? why? its a normal 6 stringer..
xiz90 4 years ago
Oh i just never seen a 6 string, bass sorry.
woloschuk123 4 years ago
Awesome. I'd like to hear "La Villa Strangiato"
rays2112 4 years ago
my god
prager87 4 years ago
This song is Awesome!
Rush forever
JavateamAndre 4 years ago 4