God she is friggin HOT. HAHAHA @ the hate on her. She's friggin sexy and before you go and say she's a slut, why don't you actually make sure you know what the HELL you're talking about. You're just making yourself look stupid. She is a beautiful person inside and out and if you hate her so much, why the fuck are you wasting your time commenting on videos about her? That just goes to show how fucking pathetic you are. I laugh at you haters. Get your fucking facts straight.
@ohhhhkylie I dont know miley cyrus on a personal level. I have met her however, and shes a total bitch. Not to mention that she is represented by Disney and little girls go see her live. OH and also, you have to be pretty fuckin stupid to let someone film you doing drugs and then posting it online for the world to see. She's a fucking moron. So trust me, I have PLENTY to hate on.
@BbyKathlene why don't you try being under the public eye 24/7? no one is perfect. everyone makes mistakes. hah she is far from a bitch. she's nice to all of her fans and you obviously aren't a fan so if she was mean to you, you probably deserved it. Disney has not represented her for about a year now. Plus, she is 19 years old. She shouldn't have to worry about if she's doing things that are good enough for children to watch. if she isn't on Disney, there's no reason to care about that.
hahaha I dont think you know who I work with. Ive been to dinners with the cast of her show and mitchel and emily were very sweet. She, on the other hand, was totally rude to everyone around her. She's nice for publicity and once again I dont know her PERSONALLY but the choices she has made and the way she acted around people in PRIVATE led me to believe she was immature and rude.
@ohhhhkylie and yes, she is 19. Thats still pretty young. See thats the problem with kids and teenagers nowadays, they think being 17 is like being 20 and 19 is like being 25. She has made no attempt to break away from Disney. Once they stop putting miley cyrus/ hannah merch on the market is when stuff like this isnt a big deal. You're forgetting that since she is still somewhat popular on disney, little girls will stil look up to her or go to her shows.
EVERYONE FORGETS THAT MADONNA USE TO DO ALL THESES THINGS BACK IN THE 1980'S AND TEENS WERE CRAZY TO BE HER NOW IS ALL HATERS GONNA CALL HER A WHORE TOO? LM@O HATERS WILL ALWAYS HATE ON BEAUTIFUL WOMEN LOL!!!
@BlueMistRocks It's obviously because Madonna looked good doing it. It came off as natural. With Miley you can tell shes trying way to hard and thats not sexy..... At all.
Don't get me wrong though I'd still hit it in all different types of directions lol
its sad cos shes gt a younger sister...tbh i kinda lost a lot of respect for her..i used to love her and think she was amazing in her HM days and with songs like when i look at you, the climb, best of both worlds, 1 in a million, 7 things etc I know am in my 20s now but i used to watch HM in my late teens and the songs actually touched me and some made me cry. They need to make her stop doing in front of kids.. i need a word with billy ray.cos its just really bad..and embarrassing for her
@chocoholicSISTA263 she sang when i look at you when she was 17.... this concert was on her wonderworld tour when she was 16.. um yea... she is still goin on stage singing songs like the climb just because she isnt the little 12 year old blondie doenst mean she is a bad person now.. she just grew up....
@chocoholicSISTA263 i understand your point.. but most of her fans are not 11 years old anymore and yeah sometimes miley overdoes her sexiness. she really want to be accepted as a serious singer and performer she is just doin things like that to show she isnt the hannah blondie anymore.
oh ok then i understand your point. She should just carry on shaking her ass to gain more fame and recognition to make up for her mediocre singing instead of getting more singing lessons so people stop calling her blonde wig-wearing hannah montana . :-) um makes a lot of sense thanks.
@chocoholicSISTA263 really, wow you can't seem to take the fact that Miley is all grown up now, she is no longer on Disney channel and she doesn't have to act appropriate like she used to anymore.
wtf..?? next we;re gonna see taylor swift sliding down a pole? .i really do miss the innocence of these disney stars but guess you can't chain them to childhood innocence forever
Guys I'm tired of seeing miley and her fuckin sisters faces i have commented on have of all there shit ... that's been uploaded callin them hoes and whores and shit-lickers hah-aha no not that one just thought of it but WHUT I WUD LIKE TO DO IS BUY BACKSTAGE PASS'S TO HER SHOW AND RUIN HER LIFE CALL HER OUT ON STAGE AND BE LIKE DAMN BITCH YOU SUCK DICK YOU MOTHAFUCKIN HOE
where has the good world gone i want it back please!! :{
Wow,that is exciting!!!!I'd like to recommend you an exciting place for casual encounters or NSA relationship etc. If you don't mind, you may check out __Casual-Relationship. co m ___. Hope you like it. Thanks.
Eww smelly, flat, flabby ass with a gruesome vagina... no guy in his right state of mind would wanna even look at that (well unless your a super old and very very very perverted)
its jus a lildancing ...you boys are loose if that makesyou super horny... i dnt see the big deal itsentertainment ... dam imjushappy she cud dance with wat little ass shedoes have
wow. Such a shame she used to be insecure and now she's on stage shaking her butt and trying to be sexy. But at her age (18) being sexy means everything.
And to think young girls still look up to her. It's sad really. Miley ditched Hannah Montana and her young fans for an older audience. She's trying to grow up too fast when she has a long way to go.
sorry yeh but my neice is 10 and i let her do everything miley does cos for one miley is 17 now, she can these sort of things, if kids want to copy her thats there choice. whats miley meant to do, be stuck in some little girls body and outfits till shes old enough to say she has grandads. sorry yeh but she;s getting older just like britney did nd look no1 ever said anythin bad about her shakin her ass at 17
Whore
cupcake14302 1 day ago
@cupcake14302 you go around calling girls whores? your prob an ugly woman that gets none....girls should be sexy..shut up you prude
bluebuilding 4 hours ago
@bluebuilding, dang but this is Disney.... this is horrible
GovindaP89 2 hours ago
Lol wiggle it, just a little bit.
defcon5iveeee 2 days ago
she cant dance
BlueSnowAngels 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Picture her getting fucked
NEWYORKSFINEST123456 2 days ago
she got ugly
Redneck37379 2 days ago
Do I have to go to jail now?
KennonWryt 2 days ago
hater get a life stop being rude she can care a less and dude she has a bf she not going to cheat on her man and she not going to fuck you
hayliesong 2 days ago
where did she forget the ass ?
garnipidos 3 days ago
say what you want about the dumb bitch but id fuck the shit outta her
scuba136 3 days ago
Pancake flat Booooo!!!!!
jobasigroup 3 days ago
I bet she's got a pussy out of this world!
Mufaso1000 3 days ago
Did I just watch paper move?
WhiteKanye4 4 days ago
Mileys Dad Back Stage: -Epic face palm-
XxKillingRosesxX 4 days ago
What is the name of the song?
MileyCyrusFamous100 5 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Girl of 13 year old who sings really good, visit Samantha Padron in Youtube with the song of Wherever I go !!!
Francispadron 5 days ago
I thought you needed to have a booty to shake one.
jeffno9 6 days ago
what booty? shes flat as hell and suffers the noassatall disease.
TheBellaDemente 1 week ago
not to bad. i'd hit that lol
Pmike2345 1 week ago
Dude she has a nice Ass. Before you go dissing, ask yourself this...how many Ass's like that have you fucked?
NextSelection671 1 week ago
wtf.,,
TaAn1996 1 week ago
wow, hottie
DOUBLEGRINDKING 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you stopped scrolling and started reading this, thanks :)
Guess most of you all are thinking "omg, not a noob spammer, gtfo".. well, I wish I could.
I don't have many subscribers, nor advertisiments on YT. This is the only way of getting heard.
Im 18 Rap / Hip Hop . Listen to my new mix, Gotta Go FT ME " Orsin Wellz " . Give me a chance, pls!
If you don't, please take a sec to like this comment so that others can see it and hopefully help me!=)
Thanks, o . Wellz
gucciiitalentS 1 week ago
fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap fap
CrimsonKing5298 1 week ago
ID BUY THAT FOR A DOLLAR!
MegaTrolleater 1 week ago 2
she has no butt to shake
r07363395 1 week ago
Why has someone not looped this...
thenumbersmason 1 week ago
I dig it. just saying.
kvnftzsmmns 2 weeks ago
WHAAAAAAAAAAA!!!! FCKNG LOVE HERR <3!!!!!!! that asss!!!! damnnn..... whaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!! XD
BzafsMrmemolie 2 weeks ago
I wouldn't clean her ass with a pressure washer.
skunkfarm 2 weeks ago
Nice bum
hannahmontana216 2 weeks ago
i just want to cum inside her.
OdddSelenaGomez 2 weeks ago
What booty? I'm confused, she has no ass.
Veiledozify 2 weeks ago 31
Comment removed
insaneworkout1 4 days ago
WHAT ASS??
ozzy7149 2 weeks ago
miley is slut now
Anathema614 2 weeks ago
MY EYES!!
Beauty4queen 2 weeks ago
What an amateur.
XcroNz 2 weeks ago
she is nasty
death123536 3 weeks ago
Mom walked in, had to switch to porn because that was easier to explain.
AcornBurrka 3 weeks ago 92
@AcornBurrka hahahahahaahaahahahah dude haha that was classic! ^_^
sofhuamay 2 weeks ago 2
@AcornBurrka what did you tell her ?
desmondmiles428 1 week ago
@AcornBurrka ahahahahahahaha!!!!!
SuperJiggawhat 1 week ago
pathetic
ivanav098 3 weeks ago
ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
sexiiA13 3 weeks ago
now that's FUGLY.. (=when ugly just isn't enough.)
Niinaloveskenny 3 weeks ago
So fucking hot,I love Miley
haveaniceday45 3 weeks ago
22 people was gays or jealously girls.XD
haveaniceday45 3 weeks ago
is this all girls here ????
ahalo010 3 weeks ago
ready for someone to bury their bone in her backyard.....
defcon5iveeee 4 weeks ago
I thought this was a senior citizens' 100th gathering.
Kurac80 4 weeks ago
She have a grandma ass
Fluttershyisshy 1 month ago
God she is friggin HOT. HAHAHA @ the hate on her. She's friggin sexy and before you go and say she's a slut, why don't you actually make sure you know what the HELL you're talking about. You're just making yourself look stupid. She is a beautiful person inside and out and if you hate her so much, why the fuck are you wasting your time commenting on videos about her? That just goes to show how fucking pathetic you are. I laugh at you haters. Get your fucking facts straight.
ohhhhkylie 1 month ago
@ohhhhkylie We do it because we know that whales like you will post and the rest of us will have something else to laugh at.
cripchris123 3 weeks ago
@ohhhhkylie I dont know miley cyrus on a personal level. I have met her however, and shes a total bitch. Not to mention that she is represented by Disney and little girls go see her live. OH and also, you have to be pretty fuckin stupid to let someone film you doing drugs and then posting it online for the world to see. She's a fucking moron. So trust me, I have PLENTY to hate on.
BbyKathlene 3 weeks ago
@BbyKathlene why don't you try being under the public eye 24/7? no one is perfect. everyone makes mistakes. hah she is far from a bitch. she's nice to all of her fans and you obviously aren't a fan so if she was mean to you, you probably deserved it. Disney has not represented her for about a year now. Plus, she is 19 years old. She shouldn't have to worry about if she's doing things that are good enough for children to watch. if she isn't on Disney, there's no reason to care about that.
ohhhhkylie 3 weeks ago
hahaha I dont think you know who I work with. Ive been to dinners with the cast of her show and mitchel and emily were very sweet. She, on the other hand, was totally rude to everyone around her. She's nice for publicity and once again I dont know her PERSONALLY but the choices she has made and the way she acted around people in PRIVATE led me to believe she was immature and rude.
BbyKathlene 3 weeks ago
@ohhhhkylie and yes, she is 19. Thats still pretty young. See thats the problem with kids and teenagers nowadays, they think being 17 is like being 20 and 19 is like being 25. She has made no attempt to break away from Disney. Once they stop putting miley cyrus/ hannah merch on the market is when stuff like this isnt a big deal. You're forgetting that since she is still somewhat popular on disney, little girls will stil look up to her or go to her shows.
BbyKathlene 3 weeks ago
Ive seen more curves on a brick wall.
tazzz174 1 month ago
shes got little butty but she still growing up so il like to see that
eRedEagle 1 month ago
Her ass isn't that great but she has some nice legs. I'd bang her before Taylor Swift.
ESchneider513 1 month ago
EVERYONE FORGETS THAT MADONNA USE TO DO ALL THESES THINGS BACK IN THE 1980'S AND TEENS WERE CRAZY TO BE HER NOW IS ALL HATERS GONNA CALL HER A WHORE TOO? LM@O HATERS WILL ALWAYS HATE ON BEAUTIFUL WOMEN LOL!!!
BlueMistRocks 2 months ago
Comment removed
HereosandVillains 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BlueMistRocks It's obviously because Madonna looked good doing it. It came off as natural. With Miley you can tell shes trying way to hard and thats not sexy..... At all.
Don't get me wrong though I'd still hit it in all different types of directions lol
HereosandVillains 1 month ago
its sad cos shes gt a younger sister...tbh i kinda lost a lot of respect for her..i used to love her and think she was amazing in her HM days and with songs like when i look at you, the climb, best of both worlds, 1 in a million, 7 things etc I know am in my 20s now but i used to watch HM in my late teens and the songs actually touched me and some made me cry. They need to make her stop doing in front of kids.. i need a word with billy ray.cos its just really bad..and embarrassing for her
chocoholicSISTA263 2 months ago
@chocoholicSISTA263 she sang when i look at you when she was 17.... this concert was on her wonderworld tour when she was 16.. um yea... she is still goin on stage singing songs like the climb just because she isnt the little 12 year old blondie doenst mean she is a bad person now.. she just grew up....
MissFischstaebchen 2 months ago
@MissFischstaebchen yeh bt why shake ur ass like that when performing for kids??? can you answer me that??
chocoholicSISTA263 2 months ago
@chocoholicSISTA263 i understand your point.. but most of her fans are not 11 years old anymore and yeah sometimes miley overdoes her sexiness. she really want to be accepted as a serious singer and performer she is just doin things like that to show she isnt the hannah blondie anymore.
MissFischstaebchen 2 months ago
Comment removed
chocoholicSISTA263 2 months ago
Comment removed
chocoholicSISTA263 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh ok then i understand your point. She should just carry on shaking her ass to gain more fame and recognition to make up for her mediocre singing instead of getting more singing lessons so people stop calling her blonde wig-wearing hannah montana . :-) um makes a lot of sense thanks.
chocoholicSISTA263 2 months ago
@chocoholicSISTA263 really, wow you can't seem to take the fact that Miley is all grown up now, she is no longer on Disney channel and she doesn't have to act appropriate like she used to anymore.
itguySimbaLake 1 month ago
@itguySimbaLake lol is it bothering you???
chocoholicSISTA263 1 month ago
Comment removed
ROCKSTARxoxxo 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@itguySimbaLake Being "all grown up" doesn't mean you should behave inappropriately.
ROCKSTARxoxxo 1 month ago
wtf..?? next we;re gonna see taylor swift sliding down a pole? .i really do miss the innocence of these disney stars but guess you can't chain them to childhood innocence forever
chocoholicSISTA263 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Guys I'm tired of seeing miley and her fuckin sisters faces i have commented on have of all there shit ... that's been uploaded callin them hoes and whores and shit-lickers hah-aha no not that one just thought of it but WHUT I WUD LIKE TO DO IS BUY BACKSTAGE PASS'S TO HER SHOW AND RUIN HER LIFE CALL HER OUT ON STAGE AND BE LIKE DAMN BITCH YOU SUCK DICK YOU MOTHAFUCKIN HOE
where has the good world gone i want it back please!! :{
RoughWhiteJokers 2 months ago
Nice ass
ghostfacekid101 2 months ago
@ghostfacekid101 Perv
Fucas101 2 months ago
@Fucas101 I wasn't serious
ghostfacekid101 2 months ago
Wow,that is exciting!!!!I'd like to recommend you an exciting place for casual encounters or NSA relationship etc. If you don't mind, you may check out __Casual-Relationship. co m ___. Hope you like it. Thanks.
young6166 2 months ago
id hit it.
pogonip8532853 2 months ago
wow she has no ass
MissAmanDuhMad 2 months ago
billy ray must be proud
420YLEM 2 months ago
@tonebone8 omg i lmaod so hrd hahaha
punchie710 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
looks, like a camel's ass
tonebone8 2 months ago 30
@tonebone8 lol
bille77 1 week ago
i like it
changeofaddress1 2 months ago
Omg...
eden3dvir 3 months ago
That's a weird bottom. It looks like a frog's ass.
StarsManny 3 months ago
even if she don't gotta booty, i'd tear that ass up just to say i did.
thanatho123 3 months ago
where's her butt?
meagannnaliseee 3 months ago
Yum. Lol
Mandaah420Meatbootz 3 months ago
She's no Nicki Minaj
bieberbaby1992 3 months ago
yeah alright bitch
Neginaxx 3 months ago
*vomits
SatannicaHelvete 3 months ago
Nice ass =)
SENEZTRAL 3 months ago
do poeple ever think about what they are doing? put your panties back on
aliesamorrow 3 months ago
she is so stupied!
OSBcrew 3 months ago
WHAT ASS???
indomitusEvehementis 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SHE HAS NO ASS!
21mmlove 3 months ago
When you thought Disney couldn't get any better
bahamutzero00 3 months ago
you are so gay
12345678936178 3 months ago
slut
Aytakin16 3 months ago
@Aytakin16 your mom is a slut
3bozidar3grubjesic3 3 months ago
@3bozidar3grubjesic3 how d0 you know my mom you bastErd ?
Aytakin16 3 months ago
@Aytakin16 how do you know miley is a slut? hhhmmm
3bozidar3grubjesic3 3 months ago
@3bozidar3grubjesic3 evEn a blind person can unDerstand
Aytakin16 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She's so funny when she tries to be sexy or when she tries to dance lol she's pathetic...
ToinyBoyZz 3 months ago 42
@ToinyBoyZz That's why she was put in Disney instead of Playboy.
dYnom88t77000 1 month ago
The poor kids...
LilPippyMunchKin 3 months ago
She is like ki$ha dirty hair but ke$ha isnt as rude
JUSTINBIEBERDOLL 3 months ago
Infront of kids?!! She's not a good role model i will tell you that...!
katelyngreerisback 4 months ago 6
......... What 'booty'??
xXPurpleLoliTranceXx 4 months ago
Eww smelly, flat, flabby ass with a gruesome vagina... no guy in his right state of mind would wanna even look at that (well unless your a super old and very very very perverted)
SuperSterlingJ 4 months ago
Wat a freaking tramp does she not know that there was little girls that went to that concert
Lponce350 4 months ago
shes a bitch
ivanav098 4 months ago
HAHAHAHA THE COMMENTS XD
ElectrikkPaperClipxx 5 months ago
@Countrybabes2011 yeah you are ;)
jarrodboyd16 5 months ago
on a disney tour??!!
kitkat2251 5 months ago
wait till selena gomez starts doing this guys will be masterbating at the computer, im a girl and i think selena gomez is hot. lol. and im not a lez.
CountryBabes2011 5 months ago
i want to get behint her on my knees and just worship that amazing ass
spartan2590 5 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
what booty? lmao she got nothing there. its like flat screen
cutesstgirll 6 months ago 64
@cutesstgirll I think this girl is jealous
Duffa04 2 months ago
i would fuck the living shit out that slut
thehollowpillow 6 months ago 2
Miley has talent , she knows how to dance lol
Rubisalomon 7 months ago
its jus a lildancing ...you boys are loose if that makesyou super horny... i dnt see the big deal itsentertainment ... dam imjushappy she cud dance with wat little ass shedoes have
mzdelz12 7 months ago
fgmdsgdslyfdefagefydtwfgwuarewgrefdhjgdslkfyawi i had to wipe my cum off the keeboard
onlinetag 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can't wait for her porn.
KayJcq92 7 months ago
she has NOOOO ass at all lmao. shes so cute trying to be sexy....not really tho.
sherrybabie64 7 months ago
Sooooo sexyyyy
Amd292 8 months ago
ur perverted
LaughableOneLOL 8 months ago
Yo guys,she is gifted with a hot ass and you just expect her to hide it?!I LOV HER NICE AZZ!!!!!btw im 13.
TheObzfan 8 months ago
Damn
nickd11996 9 months ago
future porn star!
ashley9641 9 months ago 2
@ashley9641 I certainly hope so :D
immortalfool1 8 months ago
replay?
Dreadios 9 months ago
and they say "dancin' expresses yo feelingz" lol
balletgirl21100 10 months ago 3
hahahaha yah her sex feeling the girl feeling hot that night @balletgirl21100
sanjna2010 2 months ago
yummy
MrDaddy146 10 months ago
jenluv1996 she is a whore
bigwee123 10 months ago
jenluv1996 she is a whore slut
bigwee123 10 months ago
I don't care if you call me annoying for writing this, but lol, she is on DISNEY CHANNEL! And who watches disney chnnel? Little kids do.
PeopleCanBeStupid1 10 months ago
All of u guys just stop hating on eachother and if u think she's a whore why watch her videos:/? Your all making yourself look like idiots!
jenluv1996 10 months ago
jkjkjkk
Ornelas371 11 months ago
ah hell yeah now thaz hot;)
Ornelas371 11 months ago
wow!
cheeselovernation 11 months ago
That just made my day haha
Jrok181 11 months ago
wow. Such a shame she used to be insecure and now she's on stage shaking her butt and trying to be sexy. But at her age (18) being sexy means everything.
MegannandLizzfanz 11 months ago
you dumb ass slut bitch you think you all that bitch that is not dancing you dance like a pooor person bitch
MsLove106 11 months ago 2
@MsLove106 thats wut im sayin!
xoLIVE2LAUGHxo 11 months ago
damn i can't wait till she does a sex tape
TheBigjohnny84 11 months ago
I wonder Wat is Justin beiber gonna do after he saw this video haha
k0nGy3 1 year ago
SLUT!!!!!!!!
ShouldveSaidNo15 1 year ago
i want her ass so bad
cereno73 1 year ago
Ate a roll of quarters once... Shit was so cash. haahahaha
11akguy 1 year ago
she got those moves from watching porn
*sigh the poor little kids watching this -__-;
xOHHBABEx 1 year ago
wooooooow she isnt disny any more but she is fucking whore now!
MrWiaam12 1 year ago
Aha You Would Be Recording Her Ass! Lmao
SusyBabiee 1 year ago
And to think young girls still look up to her. It's sad really. Miley ditched Hannah Montana and her young fans for an older audience. She's trying to grow up too fast when she has a long way to go.
bagofcupcakes 1 year ago
mileyz, wat r u doin'?
balletgirl21100 1 year ago
damn i would love to get down behind that, shove my face in and let me tongue go at it!
mikemayer85 1 year ago 41
@mikemayer85 you are disgusting
nileylove61551 1 year ago
@mikemayer85
DAMN RIGHT!
MrHav1k 10 months ago
@mikemayer85 O.O
cutesstgirll 6 months ago
Okay, if she had on some longer pants it would be better... But I know damn well people saw that her ass was hanging out.
LadiieKia 1 year ago
sorry yeh but my neice is 10 and i let her do everything miley does cos for one miley is 17 now, she can these sort of things, if kids want to copy her thats there choice. whats miley meant to do, be stuck in some little girls body and outfits till shes old enough to say she has grandads. sorry yeh but she;s getting older just like britney did nd look no1 ever said anythin bad about her shakin her ass at 17
NathieBritneyWannaBe 1 year ago
tasty!!!!!
linemanup 1 year ago
lol, she is a failing slut.
tiggerey12 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Looks like someone wants it up the ass.
DragonHorse151 1 year ago
Whoa!!! 21,329 views!!!! That's a lot of perverts.
marykandasholsen 1 year ago
what a slut, I love it! hahaha
linf543 1 year ago 25
hmmm...drop it like it's hot...i'd definitely slide it in there...fo sho yo...
101philosopha101 1 year ago
I bet she got on booty pop
ThereYouGoGirl 1 year ago