American Idol Top 8 Girls (Top 16 Week) by Sir Mac

[susanpseudo]

Siobhan deserves your #1 spot! She's the best. Check out some of the online, non-AI  interviews- she's great!

[vaea46]

hi can i ask u a stupid question - im just observing, u have a binnie on and a jersey - i was wondering if you were COLD - until i spotted the FAN on Medium speed ?? are u Hot - ?? hehe - im sad that Lilly is gone - Katie. the lil twat should go home

[macthemovieguy]

Medium Speed. You're really observant...

[lemonphantom]

I agree with you mostly..... I didn't really think Didi's performance was anything special and kinda sleepy but I think she's great. It's probably because I'm not familiar with the song she sang...... And also that I think Katie did better than Paige. I know it doesn't matter since they both sucked but I thought Paige's vocals were horrible and off pitch most of the time...

[wldnemesis]

katelyn was worse then Lacey

[layarlan]

I agree with mostly everything you said but if you think back to Katie Steven's "At Last" or group day you might feel a LITTLE bad for her leaving because she really does have a beautiful instrument but hasnt showed it yet!! it is most frustrating when you know they've got the pipes and they are not flaunting them as they should be at this stage...if should be full show off mode now,,,not snooze mode!!!...hope andrew garcia has an awesome rearrangement for us tonight!!!

[dpontarelli007]

lots of background or cam noise audible otherwise, not bad. Siobhan is my fav.