3D Modeling Reel

[asstegos21]

Great Work !

[marscaleb]

I looks like some utterly amazing CGI work from twelve years ago.

The materials could have been done better for something made in 2008.

(Still better than what I can do though.)

Great work on the modelling.

[atlaswingpasaway]

im guessing this is anime style 3D made by a western modeller.

[KenseyQuarantine]

I can assume it was much better on preview.

[veetya92]

omg that face. looks like me

[zippythewildone]

I can tell you used a drawing for the model reference.

And you need to work on your drawing skills. It sounds harsh but its the nicest way I can put it. The body propotions are all off and the face looks odd. It's better to model from a photo reference and then stylize the proportions afterwards.

[Heckatoncheries]

face looks like a man body looks great though

[72dew]

the face looks 40

[JoelakaDamian]

She walks weird...

And the face is also weird...

[invertedstyles]

4 minutes is too much 1:50 minute is pushing it, cut this down. Your bumpmap is insane and out of control.... At ID software we wont watch your entire reel if it doesn't grab our attention in the first 8 seconds. Keep working and good luck in the future!!!

[CariagaXIII]

people stop being judgmental this video is 3 years old so this reel could be better now that softwares are more improved

[ElectrofilmsENT]

@CariagaXIII It's about the thought process and skill. Software is just a tool. A disproportionally modeled face won't be fixed by the latest and greatest software.

[CariagaXIII]

@ElectrofilmsENT yeah its a tool but there are tools that work dedicated on a specific job faster than using only one software like 3ds max for modeling wherein you can actually model topology better in zbrush or bryce for landscapes

[ElectrofilmsENT]

@CariagaXIII That is absolutely true, but I think people are speaking on the reel's visual merit alone. In this case, if 3Ds Max was used, it probably wasn't the best piece of software to be used for this particular project. Zbrush was available at the time also. But, if you're modeling skills aren't up to par, zbrush, maya, or houdini wont help you very much.

[CariagaXIII]

@ElectrofilmsENT i guess so

[ElectrofilmsENT]

@CariagaXIII Either way, we can all agree the artist spent a lot of time on this piece and it definitely shows!

[CariagaXIII]

@ElectrofilmsENT yeah so its gonna be like 25% of the software and 75% talent,skills, and experience well thats what i think of it

[2hafstylezk]

@CariagaXIII sht iz blowin mine makin anime hair iz fuckin hard.. least 2 me atm

[TheKazmosis]

I LOVE that you have Dreamtheater as you music, but for a 4 minute reel, you should have 4-5 characters. Also change the bg to a 5% gray or its too hard to see.

[VLProduction1002]

Firstly, its way way way too long

Secondly you use too much time on the character

But fine work indeed

[TadaAnime]

haha looks like kaito(vocaloid)

[T2Master01]

@YuseiAkiza as a manga style character turned 3d you dont think the face is right?

I think the face is well done.

[PrinceOF9Imagination]

male face LOL

[GFOgravedigger]

@PrinceOF9Imagination

Are you better? Then let us se it.

[Deathrideroriginal]

oh the body is for a more beatiful girl :S

[allainluciano]

guys,sorry for being noob. lol,.. what SOFTWARE did he use to Make this?? nice graphics

[DTMidian]

Comparitively, bodies are much easier to model than faces. I think you did the best you could at the time and if that's true then job well done. I'm sure by now, 2 years later, you're much better.

[SqueakyFart]

MAN LADY!

[NeroDeamon]

except the face and hair ...... the body is amazing....thats what u call professional work :D!!! nicely done.......

[theworldofozven]

FAKE BOOBS!!! I don't see them bouncing when she's walking.

[cinexstudios]

not bad, however the helicopters surfaces need tweaking, looks like a tiny model and not the real thing.. just my 2 cents :)

[IronmanRyanBoyce]

Great job! This looks pro!

[theworldofozven]

@IronmanRyanBoyce EWW. ARE YOU BLIND?? or maybe you're just as noob as this guy was.

[IronmanRyanBoyce]

Yeah, okay...

[NEOCAPTORX]

muy buen modelando, lo unico que no me gusto mucho es la forma de la cara y la nariz esta muy triangular y plana. la animacion del caminado se ve extraña, parece que le pesan las bubbies XD.

Pero en general esta excelente man y espero que no te desanimes con mis comentarios. Saludos

[111111DAVE]

turn down your normal map on the helicopter it is a bit to strong and on the female character which looks amazing you dont give the viewer time to see the wires and wires are so important!

[PreyingMantisMan]

yes, Pull Me Under by Dream Theater!

[tremor50]

question... what software did you use?

[SQuirtyTurtle]

Just a suggestion: Don't use white backgrounds when you showcase, I could barely see what was goin' on...

[nokogiriz]

レベルは凄い・・けど顔が・・

顔がちょっと残念です；；他は最高です＾＾

[claimore22]

awsome job you did ! for both of them :). 3D aint easy