Stunning that this season with her and her PERFECT voice... Chris Daughtry who gives me chills when he performs, that gray haired freak Leno clone won.
she deserved to win. like seriously i looked up this performance cuz i remembered it years later. taylor hicks hasn't even done anything since hes won. him winning was a joke since he looked old and danced weird. she has a beautiful voice and that performance right there just gave me chills.
Was this her first performance of Over the Rainbow or from the finale? Because the other one is better. Still, every time she looks up during the "Somewhere" part I get chills.
this season is when i gave up on american idol. 3 other people who should of won got beat out by fucking Taylor Hicks. First i pulled for Daughtry, then Elliot, then Katherine but they all lost.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
If you like this check out Leona Lewis from X Factor singing this. I personally like Leona's better, though her arrangement is not as DRAMATIC as Katherine's.
well where the heck is taylor hicks at anyway?! hes not even famous lol jk
katharine kinda sucked here but she has improved so much thats why people say she shouldve won. but even in this video i sitll like her way better than taylor hicks.
I think this is actually what kept her from winning. Yeah, it was amazing, I'm not denying that. BUT, she performed it just one or two weeks before. And the first performance was better (just a little).
It wouldn't been better if she chose a different song that she did earlier in the seaon.
She actually does have perfect pitch. Her earpiece was not working that night. In the longer video of this, she's excited because she couldn't hear anything through her earpiece.
@rachelford2068 Simon said he would win because he sang popular wedding songs, which he did, Catherine was ruined by a music industry that could not write songs for her voice.
Wow, you really need to get your theory terms right before you go around calling people crackheads. She doesn't crack, it's a glich in the video, but intonation means that you have depth to your voice, not a crack or riff, which is something she tries to do that gets on my last nerve. So get some books on music theory, then start talking shit, dumbass.
BTW, DUMFUCK, I DIDN'T call that shit head a CRACKHEAD (not that there's anything wrong with that). I SAID CRACKRHEAD. There's a difference. And you need reading glasses.
And this is in response to the comment you left on my channel. First of all, how am I self righteous if one of the main reasons I replied to your post was because you of you throwing names at people without even knowing what you were talking about? I'm not pompous because I know that I am no less nor any greater then the next person, but it's not my fault your made yourself into a total asshole.
And finally, how can I be jealous of someone who has no common sense, and without any thought of humility. I have studies music theory for many years, and I do know what I'm talking about, but only when someone who choses to speak on something they know nothing of in such a negative manner towards others, do I feel inclined to put them in their place. And yes...I have a butthole, and it works fine, maybe yours is backed and you're a bit constipated...maybe that's why your such an ass.
The more you peddle your drivel, the less impressed I am. "Whatever", I said, (or maybe you don't take that for an answer). I have wasted enough time on you already and don't intend to respond to your immature bullshit. And, BTW, I'm not constipated. On the contrary, I 've shit many turds bigger than you...
I throw names at people? I think you'll find yourself the KING/QUEEN of that (read your own posts, Dorothy). AS i've said, I'vw wasted enough of my time on your (irresponsible) politically correctly charged ass...
No, it's not an ipod. It's a little speaker singers put in their ears so they can hear themselves above the crowd and stay on pitch. Kat's speaker wasn't working in this performance, but she still had perfect pitch.
I know this is really good, but have u heard Carrie Underwood singing Independance Day by Martina Mcbride? It's almost as good as the original, although its not a touching song, still amazing,.
still pissed she didnt win. she should hve won. they should do where r they now && post taylor hicks in a dump. but ii no longer gve a damn shes better && u kno it. so ii hve nothin else 2 say but ii like elliot's new song.. its spiffy. lol
SHE did and can SING BETTER! She is on the charts he isn't! He was just something different and new that appealed to older people and Katherine definatly is beautiful and a better singer so it being a singing contest... SHE SHOULD HAVE WON! But things happen for a reason and i'm glad to see she's doing so AMAZING now!
Yeah. She is amazing. She didn't make it to the top because she is beautiful but because she could sing. Who's all over the TV now..?? It sure isn't Taylor. She might not have won officially, but she and Chris are deffinitely winning on the charts today.
No, that ugly troll had trademark hair and took on a generation she was too old for. Fortunately she's doing better than the troll in the real world today.
Anywho, I've only heard Kyla sing once before this song which was "Sana'y Maulit Muli" and she does have better range than Katherine, MUCH better range and like most Pinay singers, she has a beautiful tone but I think Katherine's tone is better, but Kyla has better range like many Pinay singers, because the Filipinos rock at singing!
if you are or have read this comment then you are cursed for life. You will have a terrible life and never get married (if you are already married you will get divorced). Only way to undo this curse is if you comment 5 videos with this exact message.
she sings that song sooo beautiful!!! It's so smoothe! She should have won....between her and taylor her hands down...Chris was my favorite but Taylor over her WHY????
I like this song just the way it is, the fact that every female singer out there today tries to top all others by "making it their own" ruins the song. I understand for AI you should show your personality. This song is a classic. It was written years ago but is still beautiful today. Something you could listen to over and over again without getting a headache. especially when Kat sings it. NO. She shouldn't have changed a classic. She is amazing.
when she came in second my heart sank. what a voice what a face...she got me to watch the show every week. shes simply amazing. good luck in the future kats...tu est la meiheur chanteuse des etat unis presentement. rick
i must say....she completely sucked on jimmy kimmel...she needed back up vocals..and still sucked..dont know why but she wouldnt have made it this year with the song she sang
leona from x factors version is wayy better.. look it up and u wont be disapointed.. simon cowell said she was the best contestant/singer he ever had outta all his shows includin american idol
my did she need an ear piece monitor when it was accoustic? anybody familiar with the set up? I would think that there would be ample monitor speakers around the stage perimeter. why was there a need for an earpiece?
The earpiece has to do with the size of the arena and the fact that her voice is being broadcast through the speakers... The reverb and the echo that happens would make her hear herself and the music at different times.
er, that didn't quite answer my question, but thanks anyway. i do understand the concept of monitor speakers needed by performers to hear themselves, my question is really why she needed it when she was singing acapella (not accoustic as per my earlier post). and then she took it out only when the band started to play...
oh, sorry... I didn't understand what you were saying. I really don't know then. My only guess could be that perhaps either something went wrong with it or that she was using it to make sure she was in the correct key for when the music kicked in.
Leona lewis xfactor uk is so much better, i like this girl but the tones of leona lewis blow this away, not as much vebrato, less theatre like, but thias girl is amazing, good luck to her!!!
The reason she lost is because of the "Ace Syndrome". Ace sang his best song "Father Figure" early and the same with Katherine, whereas Taylor was consistant throughout AI.
shes so pretty
JMU1023 6 months ago
LOVE the acapella opening and the subtle arrangement that truly allowed her to show off her natural voice.
mariahfan444 1 year ago
When I hear this version my skin crawls. Ewwww.
If you want to hear it done well, listen to Eva Cassidy sing it. The woman had soul; McPhee had stars in her eyes.
Hottea1960 1 year ago
I love her voice...It's very classic!
violinplayer101 1 year ago
Stunning that this season with her and her PERFECT voice... Chris Daughtry who gives me chills when he performs, that gray haired freak Leno clone won.
Where is HE now anyway?
Boobalopbop 1 year ago 3
i have chills... seriously, she is so amazing
VocalsRmyThing 1 year ago
In the Netherlands no one knows her. I think that is such a waste..
LisavanHarmelen 1 year ago
@LisavanHarmelen no ofense or anything but why does that matter?
xochelsayyxo 1 year ago
@xochelsayyxo because she's great.
LisavanHarmelen 1 year ago
@xochelsayyxo because she's great. I think everyone should know her
LisavanHarmelen 1 year ago
she deserved to win. like seriously i looked up this performance cuz i remembered it years later. taylor hicks hasn't even done anything since hes won. him winning was a joke since he looked old and danced weird. she has a beautiful voice and that performance right there just gave me chills.
lahnajayx 1 year ago
Was this her first performance of Over the Rainbow or from the finale? Because the other one is better. Still, every time she looks up during the "Somewhere" part I get chills.
jraehol 1 year ago
She should've won! I rank her 3rd all-time behind CarrIe Underwood and Kelly Clarkson for all time best Idol performer
dsscam 2 years ago 2
The Kewl thing about American Idol is that they pretty much don't care who Wins the title ... they all are Good by Top 5 or 4 or 3...
You Can tell just by watching sales.
Check out last years years x factor thats why Simon is starting a new show.
degbers007 2 years ago
i love this girl
Rocafile 2 years ago
i have serious goosebumps hearing her sing this/
XXJoeBroLuvrXX 2 years ago 4
this season is when i gave up on american idol. 3 other people who should of won got beat out by fucking Taylor Hicks. First i pulled for Daughtry, then Elliot, then Katherine but they all lost.
rougejaw 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If you like this check out Leona Lewis from X Factor singing this. I personally like Leona's better, though her arrangement is not as DRAMATIC as Katherine's.
AsuScholar 2 years ago
amazing¡¡¡ :D
hereiam19 2 years ago 3
she should have won
she sounds so amazing, such a beautiful voice
stemmlerd1 2 years ago 29
well where the heck is taylor hicks at anyway?! hes not even famous lol jk
katharine kinda sucked here but she has improved so much thats why people say she shouldve won. but even in this video i sitll like her way better than taylor hicks.
Anae420 2 years ago
the most dramatic finale ever but too bad she didn't win...
blackice1022 2 years ago 5
yeah...nice pipes !!
frankzy89 2 years ago 3
SEE A NICOLE PILLMAN !!!
musikperu 2 years ago
holy shit america taylor fucking hicks won and not her or daughtery fuck
randybarnhart123 2 years ago 5
I think this is actually what kept her from winning. Yeah, it was amazing, I'm not denying that. BUT, she performed it just one or two weeks before. And the first performance was better (just a little).
It wouldn't been better if she chose a different song that she did earlier in the seaon.
dirulovely 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
good voice but she got way to artistic around that shit, messed up the whole song! ;(
TheMartein 3 years ago
Oh, for a second I thought she had perfect pitch........until she took out the earpiece. No biggie though, I don't either.
dirulovely 3 years ago
She actually does have perfect pitch. Her earpiece was not working that night. In the longer video of this, she's excited because she couldn't hear anything through her earpiece.
nothlithawk777 3 years ago
she is the best freakin singer EVER!!
way better than that grey hair guy she shouldve totally won!!!!
andyhilliard 3 years ago 8
Very Is thi video
JeetDL 3 years ago
i love when katherine sang that song in the final american idol, makes mi cry, so sweet
carlabena 3 years ago 3
i like her voice. but i like lea salonga's version of this song better
asianreview 3 years ago
She has a beautiful voice but it is really breathy which gives it a dirty dirty technique. But she is amazing :)
classicalgal14 3 years ago 3
she should of won ----she is way better than taylor his---what has he even done since this show
rachelford2068 3 years ago 21
@rachelford2068
he did absalutly nothing
supergirls2121 1 year ago
@rachelford2068
he did absalutly nothing
and its hicks btw
supergirls2121 1 year ago
@rachelford2068 Simon said he would win because he sang popular wedding songs, which he did, Catherine was ruined by a music industry that could not write songs for her voice.
SlayerofFiction 1 year ago
she has a beautifull voice
amazing voice for her age
but.. i dont know.. she bored me a little bit
i dont know, its just my opinion
3NickelDoors 3 years ago 3
She's so gorgeous!
ktaurus 3 years ago 9
Such a pretty song can ignite itself into a race/crack/dope/I'm better than you/ war. That's sad, folks...
KEVLY 3 years ago 3
ahe's amazing!
fashionista10182882 4 years ago
SHE IS SO GREAT!! i cant beleve she ddnt win.
oOmanniOo 4 years ago 2
I know! And what has Taylor Hicks even done since?
ktaurus 3 years ago 9
The crack is the frekin video ! SHES AN AMAZing singer i cant believe you said she sucks at singing...you MUST be deaf
qg6ff 4 years ago
Her voice doesn't crack, Crackrhead, That's called an intonation. DUH...
KEVLY 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
1:44-1:50 her voices cracks. she sucks at singing but her songs are good.
kiwi14919 4 years ago
Get it together, Crackrhead. See above...
KEVLY 4 years ago
Wow, you really need to get your theory terms right before you go around calling people crackheads. She doesn't crack, it's a glich in the video, but intonation means that you have depth to your voice, not a crack or riff, which is something she tries to do that gets on my last nerve. So get some books on music theory, then start talking shit, dumbass.
brod923 4 years ago
Puh-leese, Bitch. Lighten up...
KEVLY 4 years ago
BTW, DUMFUCK, I DIDN'T call that shit head a CRACKHEAD (not that there's anything wrong with that). I SAID CRACKRHEAD. There's a difference. And you need reading glasses.
KEVLY 4 years ago
Well damn, even more reason to call you a dumbass. Take your racist predjudice and go jump off a bridge!
brod923 4 years ago
whatever...
KEVLY 4 years ago
And this is in response to the comment you left on my channel. First of all, how am I self righteous if one of the main reasons I replied to your post was because you of you throwing names at people without even knowing what you were talking about? I'm not pompous because I know that I am no less nor any greater then the next person, but it's not my fault your made yourself into a total asshole.
brod923 4 years ago
And finally, how can I be jealous of someone who has no common sense, and without any thought of humility. I have studies music theory for many years, and I do know what I'm talking about, but only when someone who choses to speak on something they know nothing of in such a negative manner towards others, do I feel inclined to put them in their place. And yes...I have a butthole, and it works fine, maybe yours is backed and you're a bit constipated...maybe that's why your such an ass.
brod923 4 years ago
The more you peddle your drivel, the less impressed I am. "Whatever", I said, (or maybe you don't take that for an answer). I have wasted enough time on you already and don't intend to respond to your immature bullshit. And, BTW, I'm not constipated. On the contrary, I 've shit many turds bigger than you...
KEVLY 4 years ago
That's funny you say that, cuz I'm 6'5", so you must have a very widely strecthed asshole! My condolences!
brod923 4 years ago
I throw names at people? I think you'll find yourself the KING/QUEEN of that (read your own posts, Dorothy). AS i've said, I'vw wasted enough of my time on your (irresponsible) politically correctly charged ass...
KEVLY 4 years ago
yeah, brod923 was right..u have no right to call people crackrhead! she says something wrong, so? get her right, but dont call her that.. not fair!
jessicacrack87 4 years ago
whatever. I've wasted enough time on you...
KEVLY 4 years ago
She has such a remarkable voice!!
WhiteManiacs 4 years ago
B E A U T I F U L
<333 ***********
MusicAdd4ever 4 years ago
in simon's words, the best performance of the season. in my words, damn excellent!
femmefataleminx 4 years ago
wait, for the accapella part at the beginning, was she wearing an iPod to keep on tune?!?!?
cutie11sexy11ally 4 years ago
sure is
aza123neo 4 years ago
No, it's not an ipod. It's a little speaker singers put in their ears so they can hear themselves above the crowd and stay on pitch. Kat's speaker wasn't working in this performance, but she still had perfect pitch.
nothlithawk777 4 years ago
Lovely voice. But I like Australias Jessica Mauboy and Ricki Lee Coulter better.
abbotits 4 years ago
I know this is really good, but have u heard Carrie Underwood singing Independance Day by Martina Mcbride? It's almost as good as the original, although its not a touching song, still amazing,.
pagan9999 4 years ago
must be hard to have that spotlight just on u and sing a song like that! good though...no GREat!
qg6ff 4 years ago
yeah and with no music at the begging. lol.
FFJC7 4 years ago
still pissed she didnt win. she should hve won. they should do where r they now && post taylor hicks in a dump. but ii no longer gve a damn shes better && u kno it. so ii hve nothin else 2 say but ii like elliot's new song.. its spiffy. lol
trixh8me 4 years ago
AMAZING!!!!!
pibekatalan10 4 years ago
You could close your eyes and imagine Judy Garland singing the song this way... truly a piece of AI magic
ihaveachild1 4 years ago
I sang a rendition of this song, and I'd love if everyone took a look at it and left me comments!
diffcontroversy 4 years ago
SHE did and can SING BETTER! She is on the charts he isn't! He was just something different and new that appealed to older people and Katherine definatly is beautiful and a better singer so it being a singing contest... SHE SHOULD HAVE WON! But things happen for a reason and i'm glad to see she's doing so AMAZING now!
xsublimeguy16x 4 years ago
I know Right. Taylor won, but now it seems like Katherine should have won, and Taylor seems forgotten.
IloveSPIDERZ 4 years ago
I LOVE YOU KATHERINE MCPHEE.
shoforix 4 years ago
sure she looked nice. but this is a singing contest, not a beauty contest people.
juju414 4 years ago
Yeah. She is amazing. She didn't make it to the top because she is beautiful but because she could sing. Who's all over the TV now..?? It sure isn't Taylor. She might not have won officially, but she and Chris are deffinitely winning on the charts today.
blondiiqotbraiin 4 years ago 2
Which is what it ultimately comes down to. They can sell records.
blondiiqotbraiin 4 years ago 2
she was soooo beautiful!!! unlike the ugly troll who won that season
billybob2729 4 years ago
i agree also
cstewar2 4 years ago
....yeah well that "ugly troll" could sing better and is now making millions so :P
Imforeverone88 4 years ago
No, that ugly troll had trademark hair and took on a generation she was too old for. Fortunately she's doing better than the troll in the real world today.
blondiiqotbraiin 4 years ago
So is Katharine. She got millions alone for Sexy Hair products endorsement alone.
And sing better? You mean GRUNT.
lcswoosh 4 years ago 3
i like her...
i think i finally get what people mean when they say someone can look 'cute'....
and indeed,she sang well. indeed.
AdventusOriri 4 years ago
kyla is way better than her...check this out "kyla "over the rainbow
xylonica18 4 years ago
I take it you're Filipino ^^
Anywho, I've only heard Kyla sing once before this song which was "Sana'y Maulit Muli" and she does have better range than Katherine, MUCH better range and like most Pinay singers, she has a beautiful tone but I think Katherine's tone is better, but Kyla has better range like many Pinay singers, because the Filipinos rock at singing!
abangel16 4 years ago
Regine Valesquz and thats about it.....
pr0n3 4 years ago
kyla is way better than her...check this out "kyla over the rainbow:
xylonica18 4 years ago
beautiful & talented
jsong630 4 years ago
Absolute perfection.
ShaneH 4 years ago
She should have made this her last performance. It was a lot better than My Destiny.
phillyvocalist 4 years ago 2
chills chills
she should of WON
krystle823 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if you are or have read this comment then you are cursed for life. You will have a terrible life and never get married (if you are already married you will get divorced). Only way to undo this curse is if you comment 5 videos with this exact message.
**BEWARE**
acescount 5 years ago
LOL, u are sad haha
phillyvocalist 4 years ago
this gave me chills. taylor hicks shouldve never won. katharine shouldve won. taylor cant sing he is a dumbass and flips out all the time.
Maddyha 5 years ago
That was great. i think that that was her best performance !!
GrenadaGators 5 years ago
she sunged that song. My favorite, and she did that. She has a beautiful voice.
poistu 5 years ago
she sings that song sooo beautiful!!! It's so smoothe! She should have won....between her and taylor her hands down...Chris was my favorite but Taylor over her WHY????
kandimlr 5 years ago
listen here colours101 she can sing her ass off dont cut cuz ur ass aint nobody and dont HATE
datfranchizeboy2006 5 years ago
She didn't even try make this song her own, she totally copied Jane Monheit. She didn't even personalize it one bit, no wonder why she didn't win.
colours101 5 years ago
I like this song just the way it is, the fact that every female singer out there today tries to top all others by "making it their own" ruins the song. I understand for AI you should show your personality. This song is a classic. It was written years ago but is still beautiful today. Something you could listen to over and over again without getting a headache. especially when Kat sings it. NO. She shouldn't have changed a classic. She is amazing.
blondiiqotbraiin 4 years ago
the ear piece was so she could get the starting pitch for the song
lilbluedoe 5 years ago
when she came in second my heart sank. what a voice what a face...she got me to watch the show every week. shes simply amazing. good luck in the future kats...tu est la meiheur chanteuse des etat unis presentement. rick
rickdumesnil 5 years ago
i must say....she completely sucked on jimmy kimmel...she needed back up vocals..and still sucked..dont know why but she wouldnt have made it this year with the song she sang
OGPDIMEBAG420 5 years ago
watch leonas version it craps all over this
SukmyPikachu 5 years ago
You are right- Leona's version is crap compared to this!
psycheeros3704 4 years ago
i agree
janellle579 4 years ago
leona from x factors version is wayy better.. look it up and u wont be disapointed.. simon cowell said she was the best contestant/singer he ever had outta all his shows includin american idol
dizziewizzie89 5 years ago
Im soooooo mad she didnt win DMANIT taylor hicks sucks ASS!
Losersarelovely 5 years ago
my did she need an ear piece monitor when it was accoustic? anybody familiar with the set up? I would think that there would be ample monitor speakers around the stage perimeter. why was there a need for an earpiece?
MeAkouTube 5 years ago
The earpiece has to do with the size of the arena and the fact that her voice is being broadcast through the speakers... The reverb and the echo that happens would make her hear herself and the music at different times.
pildo2000 5 years ago
er, that didn't quite answer my question, but thanks anyway. i do understand the concept of monitor speakers needed by performers to hear themselves, my question is really why she needed it when she was singing acapella (not accoustic as per my earlier post). and then she took it out only when the band started to play...
MeAkouTube 5 years ago
oh, sorry... I didn't understand what you were saying. I really don't know then. My only guess could be that perhaps either something went wrong with it or that she was using it to make sure she was in the correct key for when the music kicked in.
pildo2000 5 years ago
she should have won
winstonthefan 5 years ago
she´s so cute!
mdyolanda 5 years ago
I crapped my pants hearing how good she was.
coolnesshannah 5 years ago
She is an Angel !!
BBNC68 5 years ago
That had to be the best performance from any American Idol. Some songs didnt fit her well,
but this one fit her like a glove, she nailed it.
Amazing talent...
1quickm 5 years ago
Leona lewis xfactor uk is so much better, i like this girl but the tones of leona lewis blow this away, not as much vebrato, less theatre like, but thias girl is amazing, good luck to her!!!
hartbreakkid85 5 years ago
I totally prefer katharine.
hazeleste 5 years ago
good luck? ...you realize the show ended. she got 2nd.
awesoME7321 5 years ago
I've heard Leona Lewis. Paris is a much better singer, and Paris was only 16 at the time of Idol last year.
Zuul030 5 years ago
she is soo pretty... Her voice is amazing....
thoruhonda 5 years ago
I can't believe she didn't win.
sunkissed29 5 years ago
The reason she lost is because of the "Ace Syndrome". Ace sang his best song "Father Figure" early and the same with Katherine, whereas Taylor was consistant throughout AI.
Zuul030 5 years ago
It's good how the music doesn't play at the start and the emotion on her face is beautiful!!!
Ruukuu 5 years ago