no le funsiona niuna a este wn Perlman es mejor diganme como se puede comparar no toka a la velosidad apropiatda corta muchas partes de la partitura es inposible que se comprar con el mejor violinista de todo los tiempo se desafina demasiado por tokar posiosiones que no coresponden niuna cansion consejo que no siga tokando i aruinando nuestra musica clasica Perlman que siga mejor este tal Vengerov que no siga tokando gracias o kiten este video porfabor gracias :D canvia tu estilo Vengerov chau
perlman gana por mucho, el estilo con que vengerov toco es el estilo ruso y ese estilo suena horrible en una musica de un compositor italiano, vengerov es buenisimo pero no le funciono esta
It's too bad that there's only an excerpt posted of this performance, because technically, it's very sound (with just a few mishaps), and the expression is....well, I've never seen someone have so much fun playing this. Vengerov's enjoyment certainly carried into his sound. I don't think it's fair to judge this against full performances, just because we can't see much of the piece.
I love how the pianist's moving at 0:46 - cute! :)
And yeah, Perlman may be better, but - what an amazing performance. On this level it's arguing about purely personal preferences of style, because from a technical point of view, who's to argue?
Bazzini had imagination .Must find more. Vengerov is so sexy and surely one of my fave living.He,Hahn and Joshua that Russian lady who won Tchai .there are so many great violinists now.but he is special!
He allows the bow to bounce too far off the string reducing the quality of sound. His silly facial expressions detract from the performance. Talented but over-rated violinist.
his pizzicato is the best i have ever heard of any interpretation by a MILE!!! People can mock him as much as they want about his grimaces and everything but he is a genuine musician and an incredible technician, no doubt about it.
@shiveringflower thank you, I've not come across his playing before, ok fair enough, crisper and more precise yes but it doesn't ring as much as vengerov!
The difference between Perlman and Vengorov is the smile, Perlman is playing and smiling at the same time, Vengorov is trying to force a smile but has too much tension on his face, Perlman wins..... but they are both great!!!
I do believe perlman is better, but i just love Vengerov's way of playing music, he's amazing, gotta say i do like him better than Perlman but thats just personal preference
@rwcmarco haha its funny cause neither u or JClayCast have the right to say who is better. They all play it differently whether its vengrov, perlman or garrett so shut up lol u dont know anything and are probably 10 year old kids who dont know anything
@Mirorn4 It's very easy to call it a sport if there's a competition. But I don't judge based on who I like more - I base it on their interpretation (how realistic to composer's ideals) and how well they perform. Sure he's good, in fact he's very good, but Perlman plays, imo, better.
Besides, it's my opinion - just cause I think Perlman performs with much greater skill and accuracy doesn't mean you have to agree with that. :)
Hmph. >_> It must be two different variations, because in all of the other videos, the noticeable note (I'm not taking the trouble to figure out what note it is)) is supposed to be a flat, not a sharp.
Funny about Perlman having said somewhere that he has great fingers for any instrument EXCEPT the violin. At the end here, the left hand pizzicato is played better by Vengerov because his fingers are not so pudgy! As to the rest of it--well, Perlman is Perlman!
i wonder if his body was a bit more still if he would actually get a prettier more solid sound out of his him. it seems like he is moving around so much that the contact point between his bow and instrument suffers sometimes making it weak. but yeah i mean the guy is good...you can't say he isn't.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
he looks like a pervert cum businessman playing the violin...he looks punkish and...i dunno..his taste of fashion doesnt suit music..urgh i dunno how to describe..
His playing is affected by his movements - they are too erratic and wide. The string-plucking is categorized by fine, accentuated melody that resonates each chord - what Vengerov does instead resembles plucking feathers from a duck (very disappointing). He is talented, but only a very dim shadow at the feet of Perlman. Want passion and a true genius playing La Ronde des Lutins? Search youtube search "Perlman" - THAT is GODLY talent.
There aren't too many violinst in my opinion that are better than Maxim Vengerov. He is so young but is already one of the greats. This piece always stuns me every time I see it.
In the nicest possible way, very talented man but thats just noise
bpt2209 3 months ago
I like Perlmans and Vengerov's, Come at me Bro?
2007wesman 3 months ago
Excellent! =) He has dynamic expressions, but Itzhak Perlman is exacter than his execution.
dlsrngns 5 months ago
cel mai tare
blonduuuuu26 8 months ago
He looks like David Byrne.
JanetEsq 8 months ago
Vengarov haters are delusional anti social nut sacks.
PizzatheHutt78 9 months ago
Music isn't a competition retards
Miguel1724 9 months ago
Nice facial expression!!!! XD
noobchestnut 9 months ago
wow!
demisser 9 months ago
He LOOKS like a Goblin....
deepmagick 10 months ago 6
it is terrible sloppy and he looks like he was shoved a dildo in his ass
bernhardlanger 10 months ago
i like him anway
WaterLikey 10 months ago
no le funsiona niuna a este wn Perlman es mejor diganme como se puede comparar no toka a la velosidad apropiatda corta muchas partes de la partitura es inposible que se comprar con el mejor violinista de todo los tiempo se desafina demasiado por tokar posiosiones que no coresponden niuna cansion consejo que no siga tokando i aruinando nuestra musica clasica Perlman que siga mejor este tal Vengerov que no siga tokando gracias o kiten este video porfabor gracias :D canvia tu estilo Vengerov chau
GEANNINO 11 months ago
Check out the Francescatti video of this... It blows every other recording away.
bobbphysics 11 months ago
hes pretty impressive, but yes I agree perlman would have him for breakfast.
3drican 11 months ago
perlman gana por mucho, el estilo con que vengerov toco es el estilo ruso y ese estilo suena horrible en una musica de un compositor italiano, vengerov es buenisimo pero no le funciono esta
AmadoDom 11 months ago
It's too bad that there's only an excerpt posted of this performance, because technically, it's very sound (with just a few mishaps), and the expression is....well, I've never seen someone have so much fun playing this. Vengerov's enjoyment certainly carried into his sound. I don't think it's fair to judge this against full performances, just because we can't see much of the piece.
hkobb7 11 months ago
perlman plays better by far...
sebabastiseverin 1 year ago
IN MY OPINION, Vengerov's technique never behinds Heifetz's and I think he has better expression further... bravo ~
yurietyler 1 year ago
I love how the pianist's moving at 0:46 - cute! :)
And yeah, Perlman may be better, but - what an amazing performance. On this level it's arguing about purely personal preferences of style, because from a technical point of view, who's to argue?
FrancescoK 1 year ago
hahaha he LOOKS like a little goblin.
saintmichael104 1 year ago
Amazing playing, best left hand pizz ever, makes it look easy as hell, but then spoils it by looking like a freakish clown as usual.
mrwasbesonders 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is he having a stroke at 1:04 ???
SmiPro91 1 year ago
is he having a stroke at 1:04 ?
SmiPro91 1 year ago
Guys, every musician has their own style.they are both very good violinists. it only depends on the listener's preference.
josephlwu1 1 year ago
maxim vengerov very bad..........perlman very good
jorgejlsdc 1 year ago
this is the only one have potential to play like Jascha Heifetz on Paganini Caprice No. 24 but indeed heifetz has a better interpretation of music
calvin22082200 1 year ago
that pizz is just so clean!
philycheesesteak2010 1 year ago
Just got reminded of how bad I suck at violin. Oh well.
firemedic561 1 year ago
Bazzini had imagination .Must find more. Vengerov is so sexy and surely one of my fave living.He,Hahn and Joshua that Russian lady who won Tchai .there are so many great violinists now.but he is special!
lovesGenet 1 year ago
i will not believe that the guy who wrote this is not pagannini
philycheesesteak2010 1 year ago
1:07 WTF
Amarynthine 1 year ago
I know how to play the music but not that good as him.. i have to keep practing though! he's very good..
ladyrecord9 1 year ago
He looks like a goblin :LOLOL!
baldwin180 1 year ago
He allows the bow to bounce too far off the string reducing the quality of sound. His silly facial expressions detract from the performance. Talented but over-rated violinist.
hnk777 1 year ago
i had to close my computer moniter to be able to watch this video without being distracted by his facial expressions.....
but great music!! I like this verson better than perlman's for some reason...
daniel0731ex 1 year ago
his pizzicato is the best i have ever heard of any interpretation by a MILE!!! People can mock him as much as they want about his grimaces and everything but he is a genuine musician and an incredible technician, no doubt about it.
Bachismydiety 1 year ago
@Bachismydiety I love Vengerov, but Vasa Prihoda's left hand pizzicato ( end section) is faster, crisper, and much more distinct.
shiveringflower 1 year ago
@shiveringflower thank you, I've not come across his playing before, ok fair enough, crisper and more precise yes but it doesn't ring as much as vengerov!
Bachismydiety 1 year ago
@Bachismydiety The audio only version that is - the filmed version is strangely slow.
shiveringflower 1 year ago
what an incredible pizzicato !!!! my lord ......
bielsachile 1 year ago
esse cara é um merdaaaa o pedorr itzhakk é bem belhorr
jorgejlsdc 1 year ago
The eyebrows.
567092 1 year ago
Ask Perlman who was the greatest,and he'll tell you Heifetz,and I believe Perlman is second!!!!
stuballs42 1 year ago
o Max realmente é muuuto bom !!!! mas toca de modo grosseiro e ridiculo !!!
Fora que tem cara de desenha animado...hehe
rotinb 1 year ago
The difference between Perlman and Vengorov is the smile, Perlman is playing and smiling at the same time, Vengorov is trying to force a smile but has too much tension on his face, Perlman wins..... but they are both great!!!
Zoloft61 1 year ago
sounds like shit compared to perlman.
blueishmonkey1 1 year ago
Horrid...nothing i'd wish to record.
heyaidkwhut 1 year ago
I do believe perlman is better, but i just love Vengerov's way of playing music, he's amazing, gotta say i do like him better than Perlman but thats just personal preference
3rdcr 1 year ago
I like the clarinet version more, as done by Robert Springs
blakrock11 1 year ago
amazing!
MustaffaCuppa 1 year ago
this is AMAZING! :)
francnico 1 year ago
he may not be as good as others but his facial expressions are priceless, hes one of the less serious violinist even though he tries to be serious
vuth94 1 year ago
this song sounds like it would fit real well into a scene from "Tom & Jerry"
StopTheMoti0n 1 year ago
Perlman slaps this chump down any day
rwcmarco 2 years ago 31
perlman is perlman
nathanviol 1 year ago 5
@rwcmarco haha its funny cause neither u or JClayCast have the right to say who is better. They all play it differently whether its vengrov, perlman or garrett so shut up lol u dont know anything and are probably 10 year old kids who dont know anything
redviolin1231 1 year ago
@rwcmarco either way i sure cant do it lol
vloin 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Itzahk Perlman still the best version
vhfuong 2 years ago 3
O-O
lllllllllllllll88 2 years ago
he is the best!!!!
TheAssasin951 2 years ago
naaww, Itzahk Perlman still wins. :)
JClayCast 2 years ago 71
@JClayCast
Don’t be ridiculous, music it’s not sport; you can’t say “someone win”
He’s good enough to play it and he has his own interpretation.
Mirorn4 1 year ago
@Mirorn4 It's very easy to call it a sport if there's a competition. But I don't judge based on who I like more - I base it on their interpretation (how realistic to composer's ideals) and how well they perform. Sure he's good, in fact he's very good, but Perlman plays, imo, better.
Besides, it's my opinion - just cause I think Perlman performs with much greater skill and accuracy doesn't mean you have to agree with that. :)
JClayCast 1 year ago
@JClayCast for sure
123456mth123456 1 year ago
The best at what???
gibsonpaddy 1 year ago
not hate but, tiene algo como incomodo
3000gre 2 years ago
absolute and perfect control of the violin.
246trinitrotoluene 2 years ago 3
jesus christ! that is proper sick at the end!! mental player! LOVE HIM!
theeggtheegg 2 years ago 3
his face is amazing
UneducatedGenius 2 years ago 3
perlman kicks his ass anyday
buddyfio 2 years ago 9
You are wrong.Vengerov's pizzicato owns Perlman's in anyday.
bountyhanz 2 years ago
i absolutely agree with you!
linalein248 2 years ago
not a chance.
craisslayer 2 years ago
Perlman rules!
Wangan22 2 years ago 2
@Wangan22 I think Vengerov better than Perlman...
Violinist0222 2 years ago
@Violinist0222 Agreed, different styles but Vengerov is much more exciting.
craisslayer 2 years ago
agree, vengerov just make me still attentive in the hole song, in all his songs
gero8909 1 year ago
Perfect!!!!!!
sori1004jyIsupportU 2 years ago 2
lol i agree
jdducut83 2 years ago
to good for words
JM7876 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
JM7876 2 years ago
wow man, that's incredible!
bigbraces 2 years ago 3
somehow he reminds me of heifetz, although with considerably more enthusiasm
ErktheEngineer 2 years ago 3
Just heard Yehudi's...just phenominal...
goroundit123 2 years ago 3
awesome!!!
fiftygall 2 years ago 2
0:56.. amazing
nertin123 2 years ago 17
Absolutely.
VampireCrovax 2 years ago 6
@nertin123 dang that so incredible!
desther621 1 year ago
Prihoda's 1924 recording is much much better than this decidedly average performance.
shiveringflower 2 years ago
vengerov is to awesome that you can know that art of playing he has...^^
jabba987654321 2 years ago
Vengerov is king...Perlmans a bit of robot...
rychehed 2 years ago 2
Amazing song, amazing talent.
But this guys face enrages me.
FearTheNumbers 2 years ago 6
to me it shows how much he's trying and caring about the piece
NonDairyYogurt 2 years ago
Perlman did a lot better, this guy just takes the musicality out of the song.
StaviFilms 2 years ago
I agree
Sylfira 2 years ago
Okay, after seeing Perlman's take on it, this guy does better Pizzicato. :U
Perlman's a master of staccatto though.
IceIsNice286 2 years ago
I LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!!
gero8909 2 years ago
Perlman >
Plus I don't like this guys face. :D
goboenomo 2 years ago
You're right - Perlman's better.
But still, he can play it, and I can't--not yet, anyway. =P
SamTexan91 2 years ago 6
Perlman might be better, but Vengerov has a long way to go... and I like his expressions and the enthusiasm that you can feel in every single note.
VampireCrovax 2 years ago 3
how old is Vegerov...he cant be much older than 40 is he?
iwasadeum 2 years ago
he is 35, born 8/20/74
chazzunusmaven 2 years ago
i dont think perlmans better at all haha
craisslayer 2 years ago
@VampireCrovax And in his face;)
geiger94 1 year ago
People can hate on him, but hes pretty much untouchable. You think he gives a fuck what some mediocre violinists think? Hes rich bitch!!
iGotSpaceLikeNASA 2 years ago
0:16's in the wrong key lol. but good nevertheless, I would like perlman's better.
goodcommentguy 2 years ago
dude its not the wrong key, there was actually a key change on that part of the song
i know what youre thinking of, but yea it was actually correct
YungSunYu 2 years ago
Hmph. >_> It must be two different variations, because in all of the other videos, the noticeable note (I'm not taking the trouble to figure out what note it is)) is supposed to be a flat, not a sharp.
SamTexan91 2 years ago
He truly enjoys it! :)
vtmvs10 2 years ago
I don't like perlman's pizzicato as much as Maxim's :)
slimbullet96 2 years ago
уроды комментируйте те кто что то понимает в скрипичном искусстве, Венгеров лучший на сегодняшний день
classlion 2 years ago
Funny about Perlman having said somewhere that he has great fingers for any instrument EXCEPT the violin. At the end here, the left hand pizzicato is played better by Vengerov because his fingers are not so pudgy! As to the rest of it--well, Perlman is Perlman!
ipmoic 2 years ago
I prefer Perlmans version...
99tollap 2 years ago
pizza- $18.99, car- $20,000, facial expression- priceless
CcCharlesW 2 years ago 2
GAY!
Well played though.
Sibelius2000 2 years ago
It was a little sloppy... and not as long as the original...
cjh37878 2 years ago
NOW THATS WHAT I CALL TALENT!!!
JuggalocodeChile1988 2 years ago
SOU MAIS O PERLMAN !!!!!!
rotinb 2 years ago
he look so please with himself lol
thestfuguy 3 years ago
LOL yep!
protosoulex5 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very nice...
I suggest you upload the same in 'Dynamycdesi'.It is a online talent contests site for people and gives an award to the Best Talent.
sdhanyam 3 years ago
He moves just as much as he needs. Sitting in the audience it is entertaining, but refrain from too much movement or sick movement. ;)
GLXLR 3 years ago
Holy mother of god what is he doing
area51restroom 3 years ago 4
HOLY SHIT!!! 0:57-0:59 i dunno whether its him of rhe violin...
jara123451 3 years ago 9
left-hand-pizzicato, but played a tad too fast to be effective
dancingdingos 3 years ago
musicians shoudl reframe from moving too much, i know its expression, but it also brings upon myriads of problems
jara123451 3 years ago 2
i agree.
protosoulex5 2 years ago
He is GENIUS. Period.
loveplayingviolin 3 years ago
utter clown this vengerov.
bernhardlanger 3 years ago
you are a douchebag
kodutta7 3 years ago
who are you talking to?
protosoulex5 2 years ago
omfg how did he pull that pizzicato off it looks like hes not even touching the string
qwerpoiuy666 3 years ago
I KNOW!
utooboob17 3 years ago
his using his nails.
xiaoxiayu 3 years ago
remix
vyolynoalex93 3 years ago
i wonder if his body was a bit more still if he would actually get a prettier more solid sound out of his him. it seems like he is moving around so much that the contact point between his bow and instrument suffers sometimes making it weak. but yeah i mean the guy is good...you can't say he isn't.
violinRL 3 years ago
Maybe so, but I think his body movement is what his playing so emotional. He really knows how to connect his emotion to the audience.
basstremor 3 years ago
his facial expressions are utterly amusing.
Kaoskadosk 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he looks like a pervert cum businessman playing the violin...he looks punkish and...i dunno..his taste of fashion doesnt suit music..urgh i dunno how to describe..
kingarthurau 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing, but he looks like an ass hole
kooshy123456 3 years ago
he looks like someone just shuvd a dildo up his arse
jepdez 3 years ago
lmao
kooshy123456 3 years ago
lol
manboyii 3 years ago
His playing is affected by his movements - they are too erratic and wide. The string-plucking is categorized by fine, accentuated melody that resonates each chord - what Vengerov does instead resembles plucking feathers from a duck (very disappointing). He is talented, but only a very dim shadow at the feet of Perlman. Want passion and a true genius playing La Ronde des Lutins? Search youtube search "Perlman" - THAT is GODLY talent.
apcobolisback 3 years ago
i don't know
have you seen his music video for this>???
yellotheemcee 3 years ago
yes...
that IS the difference between a studied Russian-Jeweeisch and an Born Talent hungarian
jipsy....but BOTH are great !!!
wallhalla64 3 years ago
Eh.... mediocre at best. And heavily abbreviated.
Milky111wtf 3 years ago
i doooooooooooont like him!
violin2429 3 years ago
I can buy all his CDs but never a video, to see him is stressful.
Probando37 3 years ago 2
HE'S AMAZING!
astoria30001 3 years ago
omg he looks like that mega million commerical thing guy ahaha.
SKang023 3 years ago
vengerov is pos.
dfxr808 3 years ago
he is good but i hate his faces he makes
Tonys714 3 years ago
he IS the dancing goblin... lol. although marvelous
Cameron08812 3 years ago
best performance of this piece imo.. such feeling
Somniaxe 3 years ago
awesome!!!
mintywinter 3 years ago
la version de Itzhak Perlman es mil veces mejor q la de Vengerov
SUPERPAGANINI 3 years ago
the bow bouncing was so cool xD
Lolzerd 3 years ago
hes not that young hes like 30 lol i no its young for a violinist but still lolz i really like this piece tho
yellotheemcee 3 years ago
There aren't too many violinst in my opinion that are better than Maxim Vengerov. He is so young but is already one of the greats. This piece always stuns me every time I see it.
violinplayer94 3 years ago 2
Very Creative !
Violinist0222 3 years ago
He's very motional!! I give 5 stars
Vitafivehundred 3 years ago
this man can play!!! oh man, i can only do that in my dreams,lol. this has really inspired me to catch up on my violin playing.
monicav3 3 years ago
That's the idea! Never give up! "You've to train really hard!", as Vengerov says.
VampireCrovax 3 years ago
This is so amazing, and he's still so young. I just hope he doesn't burn out. Otherwise I can't wait to see what he will be like when he gets older.
hlaakso 4 years ago
this dude is truely amazing
hollowblood 4 years ago
maldicion!!!........Cómo es que existe un violinista tan chingón como Maxim Vengerov???.....excellent violin player!
titobacha 4 years ago
This is, by the way, the song played in an episode of futurama between the robot devil and fry.
Critter145 4 years ago
Maxim rules!! (H)
VampireCrovax 4 years ago
This man has crazy faces! He's so funny! lol
rozz011 4 years ago
Perlman plays much better!
duartepapel 4 years ago
That´s just your point of view. In my opinion, there´s no one like Vengerov.
I mean, Perlman is one of the greatest violinist of the world, but.. how old is he? does he play with his soul, as much as Vengerov does?
I´d like to read your words..
VampireCrovax 4 years ago
Maxim Vengerov: <b>así se toca el violín</b>
chopinalpiano 4 years ago 6
Tal cual, gracias por hacermelo conocer. ;)
VampireCrovax 4 years ago