Added: 1 year ago
From: ashtarchris
Views: 290,641
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,338)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow possibly one of my favourite songs...i feel like such a noob that i only found out about it from a video game though lol but oh well, great song i love it.

  • Luck won't save 13 people tonight

  • One of the violin players is Lucia Micarelli from the show 'Treme'. Wow.

  • The town of Blackwater is still paying for what they have done. They shall never feel peace.

  • Beautiful song.... And yes rdr sent me here and Im proud of it..... RIP to one of the finest fictional men ever lived John Marston RIP.....

  • @Pappi1901 okay dude no offence and it was indeed sad of an ending and an unforgettable one i agree with all of that so don't get me wrong but saying RIP john marston is just way to far. hes a real person from history yes but saying RIP to a video game character is kinda ridicolous no offence ones again.

  • @11Switchblade YEAH.... okay.. whatever you say man... your right..

  • @Pappi1901 shut the hell up bitch nobody was talking to you. and you damn streight

  • @11Switchblade WOW.... you kiss your mother with that mouth....

  • @Pappi1901 i licked your moms Vagina with it

  • lik if u crey alwayz ;_;

  • I think the piano ruined it

  • This is an example of a real music!! Just can't get enough of this song.

  • Girl playing a violin or viola at 0:23 is the the girl from Treme!

  • You know what would be awesome? Hand the lyric sheets for this song out to a church choir and have 'em join in.

  • I abused the replay button

  • Man, I almost cry at the end of the game!

  • @EduWestCoastRap I feel you. I was shocked. And when I finally killed Edgar Ross and had my vengeance, I was still feeling emotional when this song was playing.

  • I love this song so much, I've taken to learn it on Guitar and Piano. It's so beautiful!

  • @ashtarchris Did you guys write this song exclusively for the soundtrack? If so, R* chose well.

  • 13 gays doesnt have a soundcard

  • @YeahOdude stupid homophobe. Learn to speak

  • John Marston, even though you are a fictional character, I will honor you for the rest of my life...

  • Amazing song! Congrats on the awesome job.

  • The best song for the best game!

  • I love how the red bar from the dislikes isn't visible at all.

  • Epic

  • I love this song its simply amazing<3

  • ... *sniffle*

  • I wish my father was like John Marston.

  • Love U ... Rockstar games, Rockstar Team , Who Play Rockstar Games, The Rockstar Fans ... Love U Evry 1 <3

    & Love U John Marston...

  • I'll kill 13 people with deadeye

  • 13 people need slapped! #justsaying

    

  • i cried listening this song the first time i pass the video game : /

  • i cried so hard i pooped

  • The most beautiful song in the world. Simply loved the mood it set in the world of Red Dead Redemption

  • really was struck by the ending of red dead, completed it just a few weeks ago. If only other games could be more like this games. original story and everything <3 John Marston was a pure legend.

  • This is such an amazing song I could listen to it all day it means a lot.

    I haven't even played the game its in but I might just to listen to this more :)

  • I love metal and this song is amazing i keep on listening to it. after the end of the game i was asking myself who is this band and what is the name of the song i heard dead man's gun and i figures tht was it now im like now to find the artist. BEAUTIFUL LIVE :')

  • People don't forget. Nothing gets forgiven. -John Marston

  • How can anyone dislike this song?

  • My favourite song in video game history thank you.

  • Awesome I love rdr

  • Best song ever! Makes me really think about life.

  • John Marston a really men *___* My top follower today ^^

  • 13 person never finish this game .

  • By far the best song on a video game.

  • @mikeking9317 thanks! It was an amazing game to be able to be a part of it. Rockstar Games are geniuses and true artists in an age of sequels and rehashes of old engines.

  • @ashtarchris Just for that comment sir, you have won true gamers respect

  • @ashtarchris wasnt a sequel but yeah

  • @9EricR red dead redemtion was a sequal

  • @isucch more of a spiritual sequel since it doesnt continue the story of the predecessor in any way

  • @isucch if you think its a sequel you clearly havent played red dead revolver, the characters name is red and he doesnt die in the end, same company and same style, but new story and new characters, dont reply if you are a dumb shit pls

  • @9EricR oh well, now i have to live knowing there is such an ignorant piece of shit living with me on this planet.

    Please just kill yourself and dont worry even if you now reply, I will not read it and just ignore the fact that your THAT stupid to actually do so.

  • @isucch You're letting this immature individual get under your skin. Not only that, but your comment sounds worse than his. I detest his actions as much as you, but I do not condone THE TAKING OF A LIFE to be used as fuel for something as petty as an ONLINE DISAGREEMENT. Get these type of children behind you, which you most likely have already.

  • @9EricR um sorry to say but it is a sequel to revolver lol, one uncle is red, two an online charicter shadowwolf is related to Red.

  • @161johny its speculated that red is his uncle, and red and john are similar characters because its a similar game, its an adaption not a fucking sequel, do you know what a sequel is, just because you think it is doesnt make it one, do some fucking research on their website before you open you mouth you rube

  • @9EricR i rlly dont see why ur getn so pissy lol its a game not real life

  • @9EricR dude your fucking pathetic stop getting so mad. red isnt his uncle and believe me ive done more research on this game than you could ever get in 2 years. and there are many characters that could possibly be red harlow including john for the most part. i believe its john cus of the same scars on his face and yes actually it is a sequel dumb fuck. read about it for a change instead of listening to videos telling you about it. it is no doubt that it is john. that fact of the similer scars..

  • @11Switchblade the scars are in honor of Red from the first game, its on the rockstar website you dumb fucks, and even if red is his uncle the stories dont link, thus not making it a sequel. Its an adaption, same style and same company yes. Look in the dictionary what the word sequel means and then look on rockstar, dont even know why this an issue

  • @9EricR dude its cus ypu gpt np clue what your talking about. you make no valid point and your pretty out voted here just look around you in the comments. and STFU dumb ass. stop acting like you know anything about it. its a sequal trust me. now stop getting so angry everytime somebody replies to your 10 year old ass. you know nothing of red dead.

  • @9EricR the scars are not in honor of anything dumb fuck. its either red harlow or its from a bear. as read in wiki.

  • @11Switchblade wiki? Probably wrote by some retard like you, for the love of christ look on rockstar

  • @9EricR dude do you have any clue what your talking about? i looked at everything known domand.including rockstar. wiki actually gives the full explanation of the whole game. your the only retard here lifeless cunt. you don't know shit.

  • @9EricR the fact of the same scars on his face says it all.

  • @9EricR shut the fuck up and stop ruining a great song and video with your shitty argument.

  • @9EricR I'm getting sick of these arguments on Youtube. I'll get to the people you're bickering with, but your disagreement with them does not invite you to insult them with childish language and bait them into your own immature game. If you don't want them commenting, keep the profanity to yourself.

  • @ashtarchris True man. Very well said. You and Rockstar did both an amazing job! This song is so intense and fits perfectly to the ending of the game!

  • @mikeking9317 By far the best video game.

  • @NearlyNeely True. Great story gameplay ect...

  • this is in my opinion one of the best songs I've listened to in a videogame, and also in general music. it's simply awesome

  • Is it possible to get piano sheets anywhere?

  • This song tore my heart into several pieces just now.... And I loved it. Fabulous song and I'm buying your album.

  • man i cry when i listen to it

  • I get the chills just listening to this

  • I just cried some manly tears...

  • Thank-you Manly Guys for once again showing me awesome music!! :D

  • What's the name of the singer?

  • I almost had to cry again while listening this song. Red Dead Redemption is just such a sad and intense game and this song, this great song is just so beautiful! Thanks Rockstar and thanks Ashtar Command! RDR is THE example when you can say that games are art! Man, I love this game - and this song.

  • I Dont understand how people can replase rdr Whit mw3 & bf3 just becose they Newer, its just kill people in those games in rdr jhon thos it fore his famely he even kill him Self fore them

  • What is the name of the girl at 4:44 ? She seems vaguely familiar , but I can't put my finger on it ...

  • WOOOOWWWW

  • This song should have way more views than this, John Marston all the way

  • I cried so much at the end. When I heard this song, I just broke down ='(

  • John marston is a legend

    Rip

  • R.I.P. John Marston! Viva la Revolution!

  • I'd do anything to be able to play this on guitar............

  • red dead redemption <3

  • who in the flying duck is john marston? RIP ubk_families

  • @mag741 if you honestly don't know then im going to find you and beat u with a red dead redemption game case THIS IS ITS THEME SONG!

  • @mag741 John Marston is the protaganist of the game that features this song.

  • @mag741 i hope you a trolling, otherwise it's a video game character that everyone loves :)

  • @rajlle well ubk_families aint no video game character hes my homie.

    rip and this song go out to him

  • this song is just amazing

  • Thankyou for your Music. It has helped me not let go of something I believe in.

  • awesome song! not sure how a stumbled upon this! :)

    i love youtube :D

  • R.I.P John Marston, your sacrifice will never be forgotten. Blessed are the Peacemakers.

  • Thumbs up for Manly Guys Doing Manly things.

  • I'd also definitely buy the album if released in the UK.

    This is easily one of my favorite songs of all time and I'm not one to take to new music easily.

  • best song form a game ever! this song stopped me listenign for lvurfr3nz for months

  • i just wanted to say that i love this song, and have a new found appreciation for Ashtar Command! Thanks

  • I just can't get over how beautiful this game is. The visual and audio mixture is just perfection.

  • This is quite possibly the saddest song I've heard.

  • I can't get enough of this performance. The new album is one of the best I've heard in a long time as well!

  • r.i.p john marston a true legend of the west

  • Please release your album in Europe, it's really hard to keep up with your music, especially since Chris Holmes' album has literally disappeared from the face of the internet ...

  • @TheSofterware send me a direct message and I'll send you a copy

  • @ashtarchris can you send me a copy too I can;t find it any where after 2 hours of searching, all over google, both yesterday and today :(

    really like this genre of music, with them being the star

  • @ashtarchris You'll send it to mee too? Cuz this music is so awesome.

  • @ashtarchris How awesome are you guys.... good stuff

  • @ashtarchris just got some mad respect from me dog

  • @ashtarchris I feel that the lyrics to this song have a highly deep message and they extrapolate much further than just giving a rigid narration of the struggle that the game's antagonist had to experience. Is this feeling justified?

  • Comment removed

  • @morgireland99 That is one hell of a comment well done my friend.

  • You want to play as John Marston again well play undead nightmare its just he cant talk, he's missing an eye, nd his skin is green.

  • What a great tune to end the game, really adds to the whole experience and makes me reminisce of John Marston and his adventures. It's a story I didn't want to end and when he died the finality was intense. What a deep and incredibly captivating masterpiece.

  • Thumbs up if you're listening this in 5000 B.C. with an iStone.

  • check out our new video for mark iv directed by matt ornstein

  • @ashtarchris the credits of a game or movie are supposed to sum up the entire process of creating it. the music in the credits is supposed to sum up the story that was told. only when i heard it did i understand the significance of the story that was told in Red Dead Redemption. That is what is supposed to happen when you experience a piece of art. this art captures the essence of the art that it was put into. with that being said, it is a success.

  • @threadysparrow thank you!

  • RIP john

  • who can dislike this???

  • Pink-shirt singer looks like Seth Macfarlane. :O

  • the red head girl really look like chloe from uncharted 2, right??

  • apart fron the game, this song makes me stay strong and keep my head up all the time. No one gonna hurt me now. Im stronger than ever even thought i felt like a peace of shit before touching the "play" button

  • Jesus, I'm flying!

  • I didn't play much of Read Dead Redemption, but this song makes me want to beat it just to hear this song.

  • Everything in this song is wonderful. The lyrics, the association with the game, the smoothness of the singers, the melody. Can't get tired of listening it.

  • I'm in love, sorry girl, I want to marry this song!

  • LmaO! Yo. UncleSpank vvv. This is related the way Mummys are related to Zombies. Ashtar is an Alien religion belief system. Soooo........why not Kung fu hookers? Freaky stuff my brother. Not that Im judging.....My parents are Mormon...

  • Why is "Attack of the Kung Fu hookers" related to this?

  • Best Dad ever... John Marston... willing to give anything for his family... O jack why...

  • Ashtar Command is releasing our Debut LP “American Sunshine” on iTunes today please go check it out.

  • @ashtarchris No.1 best song attached to a game ever. This made the game so much better for me, thank you.

  • Прекрасные люди! Прекрасная музыка!

  • This song makes me wanna play RDR so bad.. I think the story in the game is kinda sad tho, almost cried when Marston was ambushed and killed x)

  • at what point does this song feature in the gameplay?

  • @phirseatthi It plays in the final credits if I remember correctly

  • who else bumps this shit while playing red dead redemption

  • awesome song!!

  • oh man i needed that, i haven't cried in a long ass time.

    you guys did a phenomenal job, i wish you the best of luck and success in your future endeavors.

  • A man desperately trying to escape his past, giving his life for his family. Rockstar, you really out did yourselves with RDR! Makes me sad that all we get is another GTA next...

  • @Elfinlocksable i know right.... F*** GTA..... Red Dead is where its's at....... Red dead was the best game I have ever played.  GTA SUCKS compared to this awesome game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This song always makes me think about John and it is very depressing

  • damn! i love this song,the game,rockstar and Ashtar COmmand... if you liked Deadman's Gun you should hear "Holding out for love" ,"China" and "Requiem for love"... Ashtar Command have became my favorite band, they are awesome!

  • my eyes well up each time i hear this song, man i'm a frickin gay, its a fuckin game, But still it gets to me everytime.

  • @MongolianBeerFarts Aint' no shame in showing emotion....stuff makes us cry....showing emotion just makes us human

  • memento John Marston

  • I hope this band to be known worldwide... as the game already is

  • *MANLY TEARS*

  • Might be the saddest song ive ever heard. Just because of this epic game

  • This is a pact: If there is no Red Dead 3, i will quit gaming forever and lose all hope in humanity.

  • @15GamingGuy Yeah with Jack, as the would be next protagonist if they contiued this storline, has endless possibilities of a plot for another game

  • @Rolfchoppa007 They wouldn't use Jack. John's story is already at the very end of the Cowboy Era and so they would have to make the game set at the same time somewhere else or set before Redemption. Dont forget Redemption itself was a sequel to Red Dead Revolver which followed Red Harlow, a completely different character.

  • @15GamingGuy Redemption is definately not a sequal. Sure a sequal of era of time but the correct example of a sequal would be star wars a new hope to star wars the empire strikes back.

  • @Rolfchoppa007 Fine then...A "Spiritual Successor" to Red Dead Revolver. I know that the story isnt a continuation but it is the second in the franchise.

  • I recently learned that the voice actor for Langdon Ricketts had died. I think this is a fitting tribute to a true icon. To both the real him and the fictional John Marston, we will all miss you.

  • From now until eternity, some games will remain. Few can claim to be immortal. Portal is one. Red Dead Redemption is another. It is the only game that brought me to my knees with emotion and if i EVER forget this game, then i should be ashamed of myself.

  • Im crying.

  • RIP John marston....

  • @Jipps1208 You're kind of a douchebag for posting that comment. Just saying.

  • wow... I'm a musician myself and love when that blue moon shows itself and I find a song with just pure soul and passion... Mad props on this guys. This is awesome!

  • I dedicated this song to my young friend who died of cancer. He kept on fighting but he lost, he could not give anymore. Sometimes quitting doesn't mean that you give up, sometimes it means that the battle is no longer worth fighting for.

  • Goosebumps... again!